KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Extradited From Dubai to Face a No-Jury Court: the Kinahan Case and What France Would Do With a File Like This

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Extradited From Dubai to Face a No-Jury Court: the Kinahan Case and What France Would Do With a File Like This

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 5 October 2026, Daniel Kinahan appeared by video link from Portlaoise Prison before Dublin’s Special Criminal Court, remanded in continuing custody to appear in person the following week, with a Belfast solicitor now instructed to represent him. It was his second court appearance since his extradition from the United Arab Emirates on 9 August last, when the Irish government sent its own jet to Dubai to collect him. He faces a single charge: directing the activities of a criminal organisation between October 2015 and April 2017. Law enforcement agencies on both sides of the Atlantic describe him as a leading figure in the Kinahan Organised Crime Group; in 2022 the United States put a $5 million price on information about him, his father and his brother, and the US Treasury imposed sanctions on the network.

For an international reader, the spectacle — armed police at the court doors, journalists tracking the government jet online, a bomb-proof van purchased in advance — is only the surface. The legal questions underneath travel far beyond Ireland: how does a European state extract a suspect from the Gulf, what stops the requesting state from adding charges once the plane has landed, how does a trial without a jury survive human-rights scrutiny, and what happens to an empire of money built in Dubai? Those are exactly the questions a French criminal lawyer answers every week in Paris, because France runs one of the busiest extradition practices in Europe and has its own bilateral extradition convention with the Emirates. This analysis reads the Kinahan file as if it had landed on a Paris desk: what France would check before surrendering, what would protect the defence after surrender, and where the money trail would lead. Nothing here prejudges the Dublin trial. Mr Kinahan is presumed innocent, the charge is contested, and only the Irish courts will decide his guilt.

I. If France Had to Decide the Surrender: Extradition Between Paris and the Gulf

Start with the diplomatic achievement, because it determines everything else. Ireland could not have extracted anyone from Dubai without a treaty, and for years it had none: the Irish government put a major diplomatic effort into negotiating an extradition treaty with the UAE, which was signed in 2024, and Kinahan is only the second person brought back under it, after the alleged senior lieutenant Sean McGovern. France knows this sequence well, because it lived the same one. A bilateral extradition convention links France and the United Arab Emirates, and on 16 December 2025 the Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled on precisely that instrument, in a case where a man arrested in the Emirates on 17 September 2024 on a French investigating judge’s warrant was surrendered to France in August 2025. The treaty route works — slowly, technically, and under constant judicial control.

A. The Paris Machinery: Refusal Grounds, the Investigation Chamber and the Prime Minister’s Decree

Suppose the file ran in the other direction and France received the request. French extradition law opens with a list of absolute bars, and the first of them would have decided a Kinahan-type file at once. L’extradition n’est pas accordée : 1° Lorsque la personne réclamée a la nationalité française, cette dernière étant appréciée à l’époque de l’infraction pour laquelle l’extradition est requise. France never surrenders its own nationals outside the European Arrest Warrant system. Had the wanted man been French, Paris would have refused outright and offered prosecution at home instead — the classic civil-law aut dedere aut judicare compromise. Kinahan is an Irish national sought by Ireland, so the nationality bar did not apply in Dublin’s request to Abu Dhabi; but every defence lawyer in Paris checks nationality first, because it ends the file in one paragraph when it applies, and the assessment date matters: nationality is judged as of the time of the offence, which is why a recent naturalisation can change everything, as this firm’s analysis of French citizenship blocking extradition explains in a Canadian fraud case.

The same article lists the other French bars — political offence, offences committed on French soil, prior final French judgment, limitation — and each would have been tested against the file. A charge of directing a criminal organisation between 2015 and 2017 is plainly non-political, the alleged conduct sits abroad, and no French judgment covers it, so a Paris investigation chamber would have moved past the refusal grounds to the procedure itself. That procedure is adversarial and fast. Si, lors de sa comparution, la personne réclamée déclare ne pas consentir à être extradée, la chambre de l’instruction donne son avis motivé sur la demande d’extradition. In practice the wanted person is brought before the prosecutor general, states whether he consents, and if he refuses — as Kinahan-type defendants invariably do — the investigation chamber of the court of appeal holds a hearing, usually within days, and delivers a reasoned opinion within a month unless further inquiries are ordered. An unfavourable opinion ends the matter: the government cannot override it. A favourable opinion opens the political phase, because Dans les cas autres que celui prévu à l’article 696-17 , l’extradition est autorisée par décret du Premier ministre pris sur le rapport du ministre de la justice. That decree can then be challenged before the Conseil d’Etat within one month, and the person must be collected within one month of notification to the requesting state, failing which he walks free for that cause.

French judges use this machinery assertively, including against close neighbours. On 28 March 2023 the Criminal Chamber rejected the Paris prosecutor general’s appeal against an investigation chamber ruling that had refused to surrender a man to Italy aux fins d’exécution d’une peine de réclusion criminelle à perpétuité prononcée par arrêt de la cour d’assises d’appel de Milan du 28 novembre 1985, for terrorist-subversion facts dating back to 1980. The lesson for a Gulf file is symmetrical: even a decades-old life sentence from a fellow EU democracy does not pass automatically; the chamber verifies limitation, the reality of the penalty, and Convention rights before any jet takes off. Conversely, France obtains surrender too. On 11 October 2022 the Criminal Chamber upheld a favourable opinion for extradition to the United States of a Luxembourg national sur la base d’un mandat d’arrêt délivré le 24 septembre 2020, par une juge d’une cour de district de New York, for wire-fraud and money-laundering conspiracy spanning 2014 to 2019 — and the chamber had first ordered the Luxembourg authorities consulted on the surrender of their own national and asked Washington to clarify how sentences would be served. That is the standard a Dubai file would face in Paris: double criminality verified offence by offence, the home state of a foreign national consulted, and the requesting state’s prison regime examined before the opinion is signed.

The France-Emirates channel itself has now been tested at the highest level. In the December 2025 ruling, the Court of Cassation reviewed the detention of a man interpellé le 17 septembre 2024 sur le fondement de la demande d’extradition formée par les autorités françaises pour l’exécution du mandat d’arrêt décerné le 10 juin 2024 par le juge d’instruction, surrendered over a year later. The defence argued that without the Emirates’ extradition decision in the French file, nobody could verify that surrender respected the specialty principle. The Court answered with Gulf pragmatism: the Emirates had informed Paris through Interpol channels that extradition had been granted and handover could be organised, the central authority’s note explained que ce processus est habituel s’agissant des Emirats Arabes Unis et qu’il n’est pas contraire à la convention bilatérale précitée qui n’exige de décision motivée qu’en cas de refus d’extradition, même partiel, and therefore, absent any notified refusal, l’extradition a été accordée pour l’ensemble des faits visés par le mandat d’arrêt. For practitioners, the message is blunt: the Emirates grant extradition without a reasoned public decision, Interpol messages carry the news, and the French judge will accept that — but will then hold the requesting state to every fact named in the warrant, and nothing beyond. Which is exactly where the defence’s strongest weapon lies.

B. The Specialty Shield: Why a Single Charge Is a Defence Asset

Read the Dublin charge sheet again: one offence, directing a criminal organisation, October 2015 to April 2017. After a transcontinental manhunt, a $5 million American bounty, Treasury sanctions and years of headlines about a global cartel, the prosecution has chosen a single count. That restraint is not modesty; it is extradition law. Sous réserve des exceptions prévues à l’article 696-34, l’extradition n’est accordée qu’à la condition que la personne extradée ne sera ni poursuivie, ni condamnée pour une infraction autre que celle ayant motivé l’extradition et antérieure à la remise. The specialty principle means the surrendered person can be tried only for the facts that justified surrender. Any additional charge needs either the defendant’s express waiver or a fresh consent from the surrendering state. Ireland’s 2024 treaty with the UAE will contain the same lock, as every modern extradition treaty does — and the December 2025 French ruling shows judges enforcing it fact by fact.

French practice turns specialty into daily defence work. On 10 June 2026 the Criminal Chamber ruled on a man arrested in Morocco in March 2025 and remis aux autorités françaises, le 20 novembre suivant, en exécution de son extradition accordée par les autorités marocaines, qu’il a acceptée. Il n’a pas renoncé au principe de spécialité ni acquiescé à l’arrêt de condamnation. Because he had accepted extradition but refused to waive specialty, every subsequent French prosecution had to fit inside the surrender perimeter — and the Court policed that boundary on appeal. The strategic moral for any Gulf surrender is identical: never waive specialty at the handover stage, because the waiver is irrevocable and the perimeter it defines will govern the entire trial. Consent to be surrendered quickly, if speed serves liberty interests, but keep the specialty shield intact.

The European Arrest Warrant variant of the same fight reached the Court on 15 April 2026, and it shows how extensions are properly obtained. French investigators holding a man surrendered by Spain asked him during questioning whether he would waive specialty for additional facts; he refused. The judge then sought Madrid’s agreement to extend the surrender, obtained it, and only then laid the additional charge — a sequence the Criminal Chamber approved when it rejected the defence nullity claim against the extension procedure. The mechanism the Court applied sits in black letter: En l’absence de renonciation au bénéfice du principe de spécialité, lorsque la personne recherchée a déjà été remise à la France pour un fait quelconque autre que celui pour lequel elle est de nouveau recherchée, the prosecutor must route a formal extension request through the executing state. Transposed to Dublin, this means the single 2015–2017 directing charge is a cage as well as a sword: if Irish prosecutors later wished to add money-laundering counts, later predicate crimes, or facts outside the charged window, they would need either Kinahan’s waiver or a return trip to Abu Dhabi for consent. Defence teams in Paris treat that cage as their most valuable asset — they map every indictment line against the surrender perimeter, challenge anything that spills over, and force the prosecution to seek extension decisions that can themselves be litigated.

There is a final, quieter specialty trap that the Franco-Emirati ruling exposes. Because the Emirates grant surrender without a reasoned decision, the French court presumed surrender covered all facts in the French warrant. A defence lawyer reading that precedent in reverse sees the opportunity: where the surrendering state’s consent is vague, argue it narrow; where the requesting state’s warrant is broad, argue the consent cannot have covered conduct the requested state never examined. In the Kinahan configuration, the single sharp Irish charge avoids that fight entirely — which suggests experienced extradition counsel shaped it. A sprawling indictment would have invited years of specialty litigation; one count of directing, tightly dated, sails through.

II. If France Had to Try the Case: a No-Jury Court and a Directing Charge

Suppose surrender granted and specialty respected. The next shock for a French observer is the trial venue: the Special Criminal Court, three judges, no jury. Kinahan’s 5 October appearance by video link, his remand to Portlaoise Prison, the three-times-spoken confirmation of identity — all of it unfolded before a court most French lawyers know only from textbooks. Yet the questions it raises — can a democracy try organised-crime leaders without jurors, and what does directing an organisation actually require? — have precise French answers.

A. Tried Without a Jury: the Special Criminal Court Through French Eyes

Ireland’s Special Criminal Court exists because ordinary juries were thought vulnerable to intimidation in paramilitary and organised-crime cases; it tries scheduled offences without a jury, with three judges delivering a reasoned verdict. A French lawyer hearing this description thinks immediately of two domestic analogues and one European control. The analogues: the cour d’assises spéciale, composed solely of professional judges, which tries terrorism and drug-trafficking cases without a popular jury; and the criminal courts that try organised-crime cases where jury intimidation is feared. France itself therefore accepts that jury trial is not absolute — but it surrounds the exception with guarantees: public hearings, reasoned judgments, full appeal rights, and above all review under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, whose fair-trial requirements bind Dublin exactly as they bind Paris.

The European control is where French extradition judges earn their reputation, and the March 2023 Italian case shows how. The Paris investigation chamber had refused surrender partly on rights grounds — decades had passed since the 1980 facts, the sentence was life imprisonment imposed in 1985 — and the Criminal Chamber let that refusal stand, rejecting the prosecutor general’s appeal. French courts do not rubber-stamp requests from states whose procedures they trust; they verify limitation periods, sentence enforceability and Convention compatibility, and they say no when the file fails. Applied to a no-jury trial, a Paris chamber would ask the questions Strasbourg asks: is the special jurisdiction established by law, is the verdict reasoned, is there access to a higher tribunal, and does the defence have full adversarial rights? Ireland’s Special Criminal Court answers yes to each — reasoned judgments, appeal to the Court of Appeal, full defence rights — which is why extradition challenges against it have historically failed. But the examination would be real, not ceremonial, and any fair-trial defect in the requesting state’s procedure — incommunicado detention, evidence obtained by coercion, a shifting charge sheet — would surface there first.

Compare the tempo. Kinahan spent his first hearing confirming he could see and hear by video link, thanking the court, and being remanded for a week; the 13-minute first appearance in August was choreography, not substance. French procedure is equally theatrical at the start — the investigation chamber hearing, the prosecutor’s submissions, the reasoned opinion — and equally slow where it matters: specialty mapping, nullity motions, detention appeals. The difference that would unsettle a French defence lawyer in Dublin is not the absence of jurors but the concentration of the case in a single professional panel from remand to verdict. In Paris, the investigation chamber that authorises surrender never tries the merits; the trial court sees the file fresh. In Dublin, the Special Criminal Court manages remand and will ultimately try the charge, albeit in a different composition. That concentration is lawful and Convention-compliant, but it rewards exactly the defence strategy Paris teaches: build the record early, contest detention conditions and disclosure from the first appearance, and never assume a remand hearing is routine.

B. Directing a Criminal Organisation in French Terms — and Chasing the Dubai Money

The single Irish charge — directing the activities of a criminal organisation — has a close French cousin, and the comparison favours the defence more than headlines suggest. Constitue une association de malfaiteurs tout groupement formé ou entente établie en vue de la préparation, caractérisée par un ou plusieurs faits matériels, d’un ou plusieurs crimes ou d’un ou plusieurs délits punis d’au moins cinq ans d’emprisonnement. French criminal conspiracy requires a group formed with a view to preparation, evidenced by one or more material acts, targeting crimes or serious offences — and the penalty escalates where the planned offence carries life imprisonment or aggravated punishment for organised commission. Directing, in both systems, sits at the top of the ladder: it requires proof not merely of membership but of command — decisions taken, roles assigned, profits directed. That is structurally the hardest charge to prove against a man who spent years in Dubai while others acted in Dublin, and the dated window, October 2015 to April 2017, confines the prosecution to what its evidence showed then, not what investigators learned since. The the ICIJ reconstruction of the high-security surrender and the the BBC account of the return operation both describe an organisation of South American, Eastern European, Pakistani and Afghan supply links — a sprawling network whose command structure the prosecution must now attribute, act by act, to one defendant.

Then there is the money. The American file runs parallel to the Irish one: the $5 million reward and the 2022 Treasury sanctions designations against the network, announced in the US Treasury press release, froze the organisation’s dollar footprint and forced its logistics through ever narrower channels. A French lawyer reading this sees the next battlefield, because sanctions and asset freezes generate their own litigation in Paris. Funds frozen in France under EU restrictive measures can be challenged before the EU courts, as this firm’s sanctions practice regularly explains, and criminal courts separately confiscate and repatriate proceeds through mutual legal assistance. Had Kinahan-type assets sat in Paris — property, accounts, boxing-promotion revenues — three procedures would have converged on them: the EU freeze and its delisting challenge, the French criminal seizure and confiscation, and the foreign mutual-assistance request. Each has different judges, different limitation periods and different evidentiary standards, and defence work consists of playing them against each other: a freeze without a criminal conviction is vulnerable in Luxembourg, while a confiscation without identified proceeds is vulnerable in Paris. The Dubai exile strategy — living where extradition treaties were absent until 2024 — protected the person for years; it never protected the money once sanctions and banking compliance caught up.

That is also why the 2024 Ireland-UAE treaty matters beyond one defendant. The Gulf’s transition from informal refuge to treaty partner mirrors France’s own experience: the December 2025 ruling proves the Franco-Emirati convention now delivers surrenders, Interpol red notices bridge the waiting period — a mechanism dissected in this firm’s analysis of Interpol red notices and French extradition — and specialty then freezes the charge sheet at the handover moment. Fugitives who priced Dubai as a permanent safe haven must reprice it as a jurisdiction with functioning surrender procedures, reasoned or not. The Kinahan jet was the advertisement; the Franco-Emirati case law is the fine print.

Conclusion

The Kinahan file, read from Paris, is a masterclass in modern transnational criminal justice: a 2024 treaty unlocks a Gulf refuge, a government jet closes the distance in hours, a single tightly dated charge respects the specialty lock, a no-jury court offers professional judges instead of an intimidated jury, and parallel American sanctions squeeze the finances while the trial prepares. Each step has a French mirror — the investigation chamber’s reasoned opinion, the Prime Minister’s decree, the specialty shield of article 696-6, the professional-judge panels for organised crime, the sanctions challenges in Luxembourg — and each mirror shows the same lesson. Extradition is no longer the end of the story but its first chapter: surrender fixes the perimeter, specialty polices it, and the trial is won or lost inside boundaries drawn years before the verdict. Mr Kinahan remains presumed innocent of the single charge he faces, and the Special Criminal Court alone will decide whether directing is proved. But whatever Dublin decides, the method now stands exposed for every file that follows: sign the treaty, fly the jet, charge narrowly, and freeze the money first.

📄 Official circular