On 31 August 2026 Vanuatu filed an application at the International Court of Justice seeking proceedings against France over sovereignty of Matthew and Hunter Islands and over the maritime boundary off New Caledonia, and the Court announced the filing in Press Release No. 2026/22 of 1 September 2026. The case cannot move unless Paris consents, and two analyses on this site have already covered that jurisdictional suspense and the sovereignty dispute in depth: our 12 September analysis of who owns the islands and who gets the exclusive economic zone and our 21 September analysis of the sea boundary, the resources and the advisory-opinion fallback if Paris says no. This piece answers the question neither of them asks: while diplomats and judges talk, what do French courts already punish in these waters, and how do fishermen, shipowners, charterers, employers and investors protect themselves? The answer matters because French criminal, fisheries, immigration and property law applies in the claimed zone today, French judges enforce it with robust tools recalled below, and the evidence that will matter in any future boundary litigation is being created on every voyage right now.
I. Can French courts punish acts committed in waters claimed by Vanuatu?
Yes, in a wide range of situations, and the legal bases are both territorial and personal. France claims Matthew and Hunter and the surrounding exclusive economic zone, it patrols the area from New Caledonia, and its courts prosecute offences connected to the zone under rules the Court of Cassation clarified as recently as 16 June 2026. A Vanuatu claim before the World Court changes none of that for the time being: no judge in The Hague is seized, no provisional measures order restrains enforcement, and French authorities continue to apply French law as it stands. Understanding exactly how far that enforcement reaches is the first step for anyone operating between Vanuatu and New Caledonia.
A. French flag, French law: what the Court of Cassation ruled on 16 June 2026
The leading recent illustration comes from a maritime safety prosecution that reached the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation, in case No. 24-86.030 (ECLI:FR:CCASS:2026:CR00828). The defendant operated a French-flagged vessel controlled in a French port and prosecuted for safety, crewing and pollution-prevention offences; the court of appeal had acquitted him on the ground that the place of the offences might lie outside any exclusive economic zone, since the domestic delimitation decrees had not been validated by international law. The Court of Cassation quashed that reasoning and restated two principles of direct relevance to disputed waters. First, criminal judges decide the hard administrative questions themselves: “les juridictions pénales sont compétentes pour interpréter les actes administratifs, réglementaires ou individuels et pour en apprécier la légalité lorsque, de cet examen, dépend la solution du procès pénal qui leur est soumis.” Zone limits, decree validity and conformity with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea are therefore examined by the criminal judge rather than dodged, but they are examined on top of the prosecution, not as an automatic escape from it. Second, and more strikingly for operators near Matthew and Hunter: “la loi pénale française est applicable aux infractions commises à bord des navires battant pavillon français, ou à l’encontre de tels navires ou des personnes se trouvant à bord, en quelque lieu qu’ils se trouvent.” Aboard a French-flagged vessel, French criminal law follows the flag everywhere, including in waters whose sovereignty is disputed or whose delimitation is contested. The same ruling recalled the domestic backbone of the French economic zone, namely “les décrets n° 78-146 et 78-149 du 3 février 1978 pris en application de la loi n° 76-655 du 16 juillet 1976, relatifs à la zone économique exclusive au large des côtes du territoire de la République”, the texts on which French patrols, inspections and seizures in the Pacific rest. For a French shipowner, charterer or fishing operator, the message is double-edged but clear. French safety, crewing, pollution-prevention and fisheries rules bind the vessel regardless of who ultimately owns the islets, and a legal challenge to the validity of the French zone, the very argument the acquitted defendant raised, will be heard by the criminal judge without suspending flag-state jurisdiction. Keep safety certificates, crew qualifications, crew lists and fishing authorisations in perfect order, document every control, and litigate zone validity separately, never as a substitute for compliance. The territoriality rule completes the picture. Article 113-2 of the Criminal Code states that “La loi pénale française est applicable aux infractions commises sur le territoire de la République. L’infraction est réputée commise sur le territoire de la République dès lors qu’un de ses faits constitutifs a eu lieu sur ce territoire.” Any constituent act on French-claimed territory, embarkation at Noumea, landing of catch, transhipment in the zone, refuelling or repairs at a French port, anchors French jurisdiction over the whole operation, even if other segments took place in disputed or Vanuatu-claimed waters. Prosecutors in Noumea use this anchor routinely, and defence lawyers must therefore map every act of the alleged offence geographically before discussing jurisdiction.
B. French nationals and French victims abroad: the long arm of Articles 113-6 to 113-8
Beyond territory and flag, French criminal law follows French nationals and protects French victims wherever they are, a second net that covers conduct around Matthew and Hunter even when every physical act occurred outside French-claimed space. Article 113-6 and Article 113-7 of the Criminal Code extend French law to crimes committed by French nationals abroad, the first providing that “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime commis par un Français hors du territoire de la République”, the second covering offences of which French nationals are victims. A French skipper, diver, scientist or employee who commits a serious offence on the Vanuatu side of a future boundary, or a foreign operator who harms French crew, passengers or property in the disputed zone, may therefore still answer before French courts. Article 113-8 adds a procedural lock that practitioners must never overlook: “Dans les cas prévus aux articles 113-6 et 113-7 , la poursuite des délits ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du ministère public. Elle doit être précédée d’une plainte de la victime ou de ses ayants droit ou d’une dénonciation officielle par l’autorité du pays où le fait a été commis.” For misdemeanours committed abroad, prosecution requires the public prosecutor’s initiative plus either a victim’s complaint or an official denunciation by the foreign State, which gives defence counsel two precise checkpoints and gives victims and companies a clear procedural lever: file a detailed complaint with the French prosecutor and, where possible, seek an official denunciation from the local authorities. These provisions also explain why the eventual international outcome, whatever it is, will not wipe the slate clean retroactively for individuals. Criminal liability already incurred under flag, territorial or personality jurisdiction survives a boundary shift, subject to the usual rules on retroactivity and amnesty, and any negotiated settlement transferring territory would need an Act of Parliament under Article 53 of the Constitution, which also requires the consent of the populations concerned, while a ratified delimitation treaty would take primacy over statutes under Article 55. In short, the law applicable on the day of the act governs, and that law today is French law in the claimed zone.
II. Crew, migrants and money: trafficking, smuggling and compensation around the disputed islands
The Pacific is not only a fisheries zone. It is also a corridor for irregular migration and a workplace for vulnerable migrant crews, and French law punishes both the exploiter and the smuggler with provisions whose exact wording every adviser to Pacific operators should know. At the same time, operators who suffer seizures, interruptions or injuries need to know how French law compensates them. This second part maps the human risks and the financial remedies, with the texts that decide them.
A. Trafficking and smuggling: prison for facilitators, shelter for humanitarians
Labour exploitation aboard vessels and on remote sites falls squarely within French trafficking law. Article 225-4-1 of the Criminal Code defines trafficking in human beings as “le fait de recruter une personne, de la transporter, de la transférer, de l’héberger ou de l’accueillir à des fins d’exploitation dans l’une des circonstances suivantes”, including acts committed “en échange ou par l’octroi d’une rémunération ou de tout autre avantage ou d’une promesse de rémunération ou d’avantage”. Recruitment, transport, transfer, harbouring or reception for exploitation, by threat, abuse of authority, abuse of vulnerability or for payment, is the core pattern of crew exploitation, and French courts read it broadly. On 26 November 2024, the criminal chamber (case No. 23-85.798, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2024:CR01431) rejected the appeal of two defendants convicted of trafficking in human beings, concealed labour and employment of a foreign worker without a work permit, who had been sentenced to two years’ imprisonment with probation, confirming that domestic servitude and labour exploitation fall within the trafficking definition and that labour-code offences stack on top of it. For Pacific employers, crewing agencies, charterers and site operators using migrant labour, the lesson is blunt: underpayment combined with confiscated documents, isolation, threats or debt bondage is prosecuted as trafficking, not as a mere administrative irregularity, and the combination of charges multiplies both prison exposure and civil damages. Alongside trafficking stands the smuggling offence that targets the organisers of irregular movement toward French territory. Article L. 823-1 of the Code on the Entry and Residence of Foreigners provides that “est puni de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 30 000 euros d’amende le fait, pour toute personne, de faciliter ou de tenter de faciliter, par aide directe ou indirecte, l’entrée, la circulation ou le séjour irréguliers d’un étranger en France.” Paid passage, organised routing, logistical support or document fraud for irregular entry toward New Caledonia or through French-claimed waters therefore exposes organisers to five years’ imprisonment and a 30,000 euro fine, whether or not the World Court ever hears Vanuatu’s case. The humanitarian exception is narrowly drawn and must be read literally: Article L. 823-9 shelters “toute personne physique ou morale lorsque l’acte reproché n’a donné lieu à aucune contrepartie directe ou indirecte et a consisté à fournir des conseils ou accompagnements juridiques, linguistiques ou sociaux, ou toute autre aide apportée dans un but exclusivement humanitaire.” Genuinely disinterested legal, linguistic or social assistance remains protected, but any direct or indirect consideration removes the shelter, and assistance with entry itself, as opposed to circulation or residence, stays outside the family exemptions. Shipmasters who rescue persons in distress at sea comply with a duty under maritime law and should log the rescue meticulously; anyone tempted to convert a rescue into paid onward transport should understand that French prosecutors draw a hard line between the two.
B. Seized vessel, lost campaign, injured crew: claiming compensation and securing operations
Enforcement bites financially long before any criminal verdict: vessel seizure, catch confiscation, campaign interruption, detention costs, injured crew. French law offers two compensatory routes that operators in the disputed zone should build into their strategy from day one. The criminal route runs through the civil action. Article 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure opens it widely: “L’action civile en réparation du dommage causé par un crime, un délit ou une contravention appartient à tous ceux qui ont personnellement souffert du dommage directement causé par l’infraction.” A fishing company whose vessel is seized, a charterer whose campaign is interrupted by an enforcement action, or a crew member injured during an interdiction can join the criminal proceedings as a civil party and seek full reparation there, which is often faster and better documented than a standalone lawsuit. Failing a criminal route, the general law of tort applies. Article 1240 of the Civil Code supplies the action: “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer.” Fault, damage and causation remain to be proved under ordinary rules, but the provision covers collisions, negligent interdictions, wrongful interference with licensed operations and defective equipment supplied for the campaign. The status of the islets themselves is fixed by public-property law. Article L. 2111-1 of the General Code on the Property of Public Persons provides that “le domaine public d’une personne publique mentionnée à l’article L. 1 est constitué des biens lui appartenant qui sont soit affectés à l’usage direct du public, soit affectés à un service public pourvu qu’en ce cas ils fassent l’objet d’un aménagement indispensable à l’exécution des missions de ce service public.” Occupation, mooring, scientific installation or commercial activity on the islets without authorisation is therefore vulnerable to removal and penalties under current French law, whatever the eventual international outcome, and any project involving a physical presence should secure written authorisation from the competent French authority in New Caledonia before deploying. The operational checklist for the zone writes itself from these rules. Verify flag, licences and catch documentation before entering the area and keep originals ready for inspection by French or Vanuatu patrols. Insure expressly for seizure, regulatory detention and campaign interruption, since standard hull policies often exclude them. Preserve satellite tracks, logbooks, inspection reports and correspondence that prove the location of each act, because that evidence decides both French jurisdiction today and any future boundary litigation tomorrow. Take advice before any statement to enforcement officers, since admissions on location, flag or authorisation feed directly into the jurisdictional analysis French judges perform under the 16 June 2026 case law. Insert clauses allocating boundary-change risk, licence invalidation and enforcement costs into joint ventures, fishing-access contracts and seabed-exploration agreements, since no court in Paris can guarantee the permanence of a line that The Hague may one day redraw. And monitor the diplomatic sequence, a French consent, a refusal, a revived negotiation or a move toward an advisory opinion, because each step re-prices the legal risk of staying in the overlapping claim, as explained in our 21 September analysis of the fallback if Paris says no.
Operators sometimes ask whether Matthew and Hunter is an isolated file. It is not, and the comparison that concentrates minds in Paris is Mayotte. In the Indian Ocean, the Comoros claims the French department of Mayotte, which voted to remain French and whose population French law treats as fully French citizens, while the African Union and the Comoros invoke decolonisation resolutions. France administers, patrols and prosecutes there exactly as it does around New Caledonia, and no international court has displaced that administration. The parallel matters for three practical reasons. First, Paris reads every concession in one theatre as a signal in the other, which hardens its incentive to refuse consent to Vanuatu’s invitation or to consent only on tightly defined terms. Second, enforcement practice is transferable: the maritime-control methods, seizure routines and prosecution templates used around Mayotte against irregular migration from the Comoros are the same ones deployed in the Pacific, so advisers who know the Mayotte case law already know the Pacific playbook. Third, insurers, lenders and joint-venture partners price political risk across all French overseas theatres at once, which means a hardening of the Vanuatu file can move financing terms for projects nowhere near the disputed islets. A related domestic backdrop is New Caledonia itself, where the July 2025 agreement sketching a State of New Caledonia within France keeps the institutional future open and where any maritime concession would reverberate politically. None of this changes the law applicable on the water today, but all of it belongs in a board-level risk memo. A final word on the moment of control itself, because it is where cases are won or lost. During a French maritime inspection, the crew must produce identity papers, vessel documents, fishing authorisations and logbooks, and everything said or handed over feeds the official report that the prosecutor will read. Masters should designate in advance who speaks to the boarding team, note the exact time and GPS position of the interception, photograph the scene, request a copy of every seizure inventory, and call their lawyer and insurer before signing anything beyond the bare acknowledgment of presence. Foreign crew members enjoy consular notification rights and the assistance of an interpreter, and any statement taken without respecting defence rights can be challenged later before the criminal judge who, as the 16 June 2026 ruling confirms, examines the legality of the whole enforcement chain. Companies should run drills for this scenario the way they drill for fire: the cost of one unprepared boarding exceeds years of compliance budgets. Insurers must be notified within the policy deadline, usually counted in days from the seizure, with the inventory, the position log and the authorisation file attached; late or thin notification is the most common ground for coverage refusal. Lenders holding mortgages over vessels should receive the same packet simultaneously, since enforcement costs and confiscation risk rank ahead of their security in practice.
Conclusion
Vanuatu’s invitation to The Hague may or may not become a case; that decision belongs to Paris and is analysed in our companion pieces. What belongs to French courts is already decided: in the waters France claims around Matthew and Hunter, French criminal law follows the flag, the territory and the national, it punishes trafficking and smuggling severely while sheltering genuine humanitarian aid, and it compensates victims through the civil action and the general law of tort. The 16 June 2026 flag-state ruling, the personality provisions of Articles 113-6 to 113-8, the trafficking and smuggling arsenal and the compensation routes mapped above form a complete enforcement picture that no diplomatic development suspends. For operators, the strategy is therefore two-track: preserve licences, evidence and contract protections for the worst case at sea, and monitor the diplomatic sequence for the best case in The Hague. Files are won in both places at once, and the Pacific rewards those who prepare for each forum while the other deliberates.