KOHEN AVOCATS · PARIS, FRANCE
Tomasz Kosowski Sentencing: What Happens After a Florida Death Sentence?

Hassan Kohen is a Paris-based lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar (Avocat au Barreau de Paris). Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Sources: U.S. court opinions and official U.S. government publications, read for this article

Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Tomasz Kosowski Sentencing: What Happens After a Florida Death Sentence?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

ABC News and the Associated Press reported that a Florida judge sentenced Tomasz Kosowski to death on November 20, 2026. The Circuit Court of the Sixth Judicial Circuit in and for Pinellas County, Florida, had entered a first-degree murder verdict in State v. Kosowski, No. 23-02935-CF, on September 23, 2026, according to the verdict filed with the Pinellas County clerk. The filed verdict and the reported sentence are different records from different stages of the case. The written sentencing order is the document to check for the court’s findings on punishment.

Under Florida Statutes § 921.141(5), a judgment of conviction and death sentence are subject to automatic review by the Supreme Court of Florida. The practical next step is to check when the written order and judgment are entered and whether the appellate docket shows a notice of appeal or a new case number. A sentencing hearing alone supplies no execution date. For relatives of a homicide victim, the immediate question is who will provide notice as the case moves from the trial court into review. The discussion below explains the Florida procedure in comparable cases and makes no further findings about this case.

I. What does a Florida death sentence decide?

A. The verdict and the sentencing order answer different questions

Start with the document that matches the question. A Florida verdict answers which offense the trier of fact found proved. The written judgment records the conviction the trial court enters. The sentence fixes the punishment. In a Florida capital case, the order explaining that punishment addresses the findings that support it. Looking at those documents in order helps a reader tell which matters the court has resolved and which are now open to review.

Florida Statutes § 782.04 classifies first-degree murder as a capital felony and identifies the elements of the different ways the offense can be proved. Under Florida Statutes § 775.082(1), a person convicted of a capital felony receives life imprisonment without the possibility of parole unless the separate capital sentencing proceeding produces findings that support a death sentence and the court imposes it. The first-degree verdict thus answers the conviction question. The findings about punishment belong to the separate sentencing stage.

That separation matters whenever a docket contains more than one jury waiver. Under Florida Statutes § 921.141(1)–(3), a defendant who waived the trial jury may still have a jury empaneled for the sentencing proceeding unless the defendant waives that jury as well. Read the text of each waiver and the record of the court accepting it. A document that covers the trial also may cover sentencing, but that depends on what it says and what the court accepted. A docket label alone gives too little information to tell.

Where there is a Florida penalty jury, it must unanimously find at least one statutory aggravating factor beyond a reasonable doubt before death becomes an available recommendation. The question of how many jurors recommend death is separate. Under the same Florida statute, at least eight jurors must favor death for the jury to recommend it. A life recommendation binds the Florida trial court. A death recommendation leaves the court with a choice between death and life without the possibility of parole, subject to the findings and consideration described in the statute.

Where the Florida penalty jury was waived, § 921.141(3)(b) directs the trial judge to consider all aggravating and mitigating circumstances. The judge may impose death only if the judge finds at least one statutory aggravating factor proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The eight-vote rule concerns a jury recommendation. In a judge-only sentencing proceeding, the documents to look for are the penalty-phase waiver, the evidence and arguments presented to the judge, and the findings in the written order.

When reading a Florida sentencing docket, preserve the distinction between a prosecutor’s request, a defense filing, and the court’s findings. A prosecutor’s memorandum might identify the evidence the state thinks proves an aggravating factor. A defense memorandum might identify a mitigating circumstance, challenge the state’s reading of the evidence, or dispute the weight a fact should carry. Neither filing tells the reader whether the court agreed. The court’s order can accept a fact, reject it, or find it established but assign it limited weight. Those are different outcomes with different implications for an appeal.

The Florida statute also distinguishes the existence of an aggravating factor from the decision to impose death. The aggravating factors are listed in § 921.141(6). The written order required by subsection (4) must address the factors the court found, the mitigating circumstances reasonably established by the evidence, whether the aggravation is sufficient to warrant death, and whether it outweighs the mitigation. For a practical first reading, take those as four separate questions. Identify the statute the judge relied on, the evidence supporting each finding, the mitigation credited by the judge, and the explanation for the final weighing.

B. Which record will tell you why the judge selected the sentence?

Look for the signed written order that sets out the trial court’s sentencing reasons, together with the judgment and sentence. An oral announcement can communicate the result quickly. A transcript records what the judge and parties actually said, while the written order is where Florida law requires the court to set out the findings that support the sentence. Obtain the complete order if it is publicly available and keep the docket entry that identifies when it was filed. If the record seems incomplete, distinguish a delayed public upload from a document that has yet to be entered.

The distinction is useful if the order and the transcript use different language. A judge might summarize several findings aloud, then discuss the supporting testimony separately in the written order. A transcript can also show that the defense disputed a finding or that the court ruled on an objection before imposing sentence. A reader assessing what may be at issue on appeal should note both passages and identify their sources. A news quotation, an oral finding, and a full written explanation carry different information.

In Figueroa-Sanabria v. State, No. SC2024-0768 (Fla. November 19, 2026), the Supreme Court of Florida affirmed two death sentences imposed after resentencing. The court rejected challenges to the defendant’s competence and the validity of his penalty-phase jury waiver. It examined the exchanges among the judge, the defendant, and counsel and concluded that the record showed the defendant understood what he was giving up. When a Florida penalty-phase jury waiver is at issue, read the hearing transcript alongside the form to see what the judge explained and how the defendant responded.

One useful way to read the sentencing record is to write down the trial court’s finding before opening the arguments about it. For example, if the court credits evidence of a defendant’s mental condition but gives it limited weight, the inquiry is narrower than whether any evidence of that condition exists. Read what the order says about the condition, what the expert actually addressed, and how the court explained the weight. Apply the same method to the question of a jury waiver. A form may record the decision, while the transcript can show which phase the discussion concerned, whether counsel expressed a different view, and what the judge said about the choices still available.

The same approach helps with a disputed aggravating factor. A proposed finding may refer to several exhibits that establish different parts of the state’s argument. Identify which parts the written order actually adopted, and then check whether the issue on review concerns the evidence, the legal definition of the factor, or the effect of the finding on the ultimate sentence. Those questions call for different parts of the record. The reader can make that distinction even before the opposing briefs are available.

The history in Figueroa-Sanabria illustrates why the word resentencing requires reading the earlier disposition. The court’s November 19 opinion recounts how a prior appeal left the convictions in place but sent the case back for a new penalty phase because the defendant had been deprived of counsel in that phase. The later opinion resolves challenges to the new sentences. A reader who sees both entries should distinguish the original trial, the first appeal, the new penalty proceeding, and review of the resulting sentence. Each entry answers a different question.

The Florida statute also treats victim impact evidence as a distinct subject. Under § 921.141(8), after the prosecution introduces evidence of at least one statutory aggravating factor, it may introduce victim impact evidence designed to show the person’s uniqueness and the loss their death caused to the community. The provision excludes characterizations and opinions about the crime, the defendant, or the appropriate sentence from that category of evidence. For relatives, the practical question is whether a proposed statement is being offered as statutory sentencing evidence or through a separate opportunity to be heard. The purpose and the court’s instructions should guide how it is prepared.

To follow a Florida case at this stage, keep the clerk’s case number with the separate dates for verdict, sentencing hearing, written order, and any notice of appeal. If you are reading on behalf of a family, note the next scheduled proceeding from the docket or a notice issued in the case. A sentencing hearing may be easy to find in coverage, but the date and text of a filing are what allow readers to verify that they are looking at the correct proceeding.

II. What happens after sentencing for the defendant and the victim’s family?

A. Follow the Florida Supreme Court’s review of the judgment and sentence

Article V, § 3(b)(1) of the Florida Constitution directs the Supreme Court of Florida to hear appeals from final trial court judgments imposing death. Section 921.141(5) provides for automatic review of the conviction and sentence and gives that review priority. The court’s jurisdiction guide explains which appeals the court must hear under the state constitution. For a reader accustomed to seeing criminal appeals go to a district court of appeal, the forum is an important difference in a Florida capital case.

Automatic review is a feature of the Florida judgment and sentence. A reader tracking the case should still find the actual notice and the appellate case number to establish the procedural status. A report that someone may appeal tells the reader less than the notice of appeal, the appellate docket, and the court’s scheduling orders. The public record may initially show a filing in the circuit court before the appellate case appears under its separate number. Use the trial court case number to verify that the appellate entry relates to the same judgment.

A direct appeal takes up issues arising from the proceedings in the trial court. Florida Statutes § 924.06 identifies judgments and orders from which a defendant may appeal, and Florida Statutes § 924.051 sets out Florida’s preservation and prejudicial-error rules, including the distinction for fundamental error. In practice, an issue discussed on appeal may turn on what the record shows about an objection, what the court decided, and whether the claimed error affected the proceedings. The written briefs identify the issues each side asks the court to resolve. An issue described in a brief remains that party’s position until the court decides it.

Some questions concern the conviction itself. Others concern only the penalty, such as an objection to the use of particular evidence or to the role assigned to that evidence. In Guzman v. State, No. SC2024-1191 (Fla. November 5, 2026), the Supreme Court of Florida affirmed a death sentence after a later penalty phase. It found the challenge to the instructions on victim impact evidence unpreserved and also concluded that the repeated instruction gave the jury adequate guidance. When reading an appeal about victim impact evidence, check what objection was raised, whether the trial court ruled, and what instruction the jury actually received.

A later Florida postconviction case is a different proceeding. The issues in a direct appeal generally arise from the trial record. A collateral motion asks for relief under a separate procedure, as the sequence of rulings in Overton below illustrates. A reader following a Florida case should check the order under review to distinguish an initial appeal of the conviction and sentence from an appeal of a later ruling on collateral relief.

That distinction makes docket labels far more useful. An appellate entry describing a postconviction order may appear alongside older opinions affirming a conviction and sentence. The case name alone may remain substantially the same. The order listed in the notice, the docket number, and the issue described by the court tell the reader which proceeding is active. In a new capital case, the first place to look for review of the conviction and sentence is the direct appeal docket once it exists.

For the defendant, the immediate practical questions are which lawyer is responsible for appellate work, which orders are in the appellate record, and where the court will issue its briefing schedule. The record may need to be checked for the trial evidence, the sentencing transcript, written findings, and rulings on issues the parties raised. That information is more useful than trying to predict how the reviewing court will rule based on an account of the hearing. The next public milestone may be an appellate docket entry or an order setting a schedule, depending on what has already been filed.

B. What can relatives request, and when does an execution date enter the record?

Florida’s victim-rights provisions give families a separate way to follow the case. Article I, § 16 of the Florida Constitution provides for reasonable, accurate, and timely notice, upon request, of public proceedings involving the criminal conduct, including trial, plea, sentencing, adjudication, and matters concerning release or escape. It also recognizes the right to be heard in listed public proceedings and to receive information about the conviction, sentence, incarceration, and postconviction processes on the terms stated in that section. The constitutional definition includes a victim’s lawful representative and the next of kin of a homicide victim, subject to the provision’s limits.

Florida Statutes § 960.001 describes notification duties for justice-system agencies, including notification procedures and the use of a victim notification card. A relative who wants updates can check with the agency handling victim notification that it has the correct case number and a current way to reach them. Ask who will provide notice when the case is in appellate review and what information the family needs to give that office. Keeping the notice request and any confirmation makes it easier to follow up if a hearing is moved or responsibility for notification changes.

When a notice arrives, record what it actually announces. A date for a trial court hearing, an appellate oral argument, and a ruling issued without oral argument are different events. If a family member wants to be heard, confirm which proceeding the notice concerns and how that court receives participation or written views. The constitutional right to be heard in specified proceedings and the capital statute’s limit on what qualifies as victim impact evidence address different questions. A victim services contact can help identify which procedure the court is using for a particular proceeding.

An execution date ordinarily appears much later in the record. Under Florida Statutes § 922.052, an execution requires a warrant from the governor directing that the sentence be carried out at a designated time. The statute separately sets out a certification process concerning review of the case and provisions on issuance of the warrant after executive clemency procedures have concluded. The document that fixes the date is the warrant. The conviction, the judge’s sentencing announcement, and even notice of a court hearing each belong to different points in the process.

In Overton v. State, No. SC2026-1724 (Fla. November 13, 2026), the Supreme Court of Florida affirmed the summary denial of a third successive postconviction motion and denied the defendant’s request for a stay after the governor had issued a warrant. The court rejected the postconviction challenge that repackaged attacks on the trial evidence without identifying new evidence. When reading a Florida docket years after sentencing, match any stated execution date to the governor’s warrant and any request to halt it to the court’s separate ruling on a stay.

For a relative receiving notices from different offices, it helps to mark each notice with the proceeding and the document named in it. That makes it possible to recognize, for example, that an appellate opinion concerns only a later motion even though its opening pages recap the original conviction. If a notice refers to a document the family cannot find, ask for its docket entry and identify the court or agency that issued it. A change in which office handles notifications can occur without any change in the court’s ruling.

The difference between a stay request and a stay order matters whenever a date is already in the record. A motion asks a court to suspend some action. The order resolving that motion tells the reader what the court actually did. The same distinction applies to other court filings. For families following a case, recording the title and date of the operative document avoids reporting a request, proposed schedule, or provisional setting as a completed court action.

A useful way to keep track is to maintain two records. One contains court documents and dates, such as the conviction, sentence, notice of appeal, briefs, and appellate orders. The other contains the family’s notice requests and the agency’s responses. The first helps explain the status of the legal proceedings. The second establishes how the family expects to learn of new developments. A gap in one record can be followed up without assuming that the other is complete. If an update comes by phone or through a news report, the corresponding document or official notice is the best way to identify precisely what has changed.

Conclusion

Following a Florida death sentence begins with the written judgment and the order explaining the punishment. Read the findings on aggravation and mitigation, then use the notice of appeal and the Supreme Court of Florida docket to track review of the conviction and sentence. Later petitions, motions, and warrants each have their own purpose, and the operative document tells you which stage the case has reached. Victims’ relatives can follow the same public milestones while confirming that the appropriate agency has their request for notice and current contact information.

📄 Official circular