KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU Free Cabin Baggage: What the European Parliament Voted and How to Claim in France for Fees, Delays and Lost Luggage

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU Free Cabin Baggage: What the European Parliament Voted and How to Claim in France for Fees, Delays and Lost Luggage

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You booked a cheap flight to Paris, and the ticket that looked like a bargain doubled in price the moment you added a cabin bag. If you fly from London, Dublin, New York, Toronto or Sydney to France, that scene is familiar: one personal item squeezed under the seat for free, and anything with wheels billed as an extra, sometimes at the gate under time pressure. In 2026 the European Parliament decided to put an end to that practice. Its members backed a clear rule: every air passenger in Europe should be allowed to bring one personal item and one small piece of cabin baggage on board at no additional cost. The story made headlines across the English-speaking press because it touches millions of travellers, and it raises a very practical question for anyone landing in France: what can you claim today, and what changes tomorrow? This article answers both. It explains exactly what the Parliament voted, why the new rule is not yet the law that governs your next flight, and how French courts already handle the disputes you actually face at the airport: a cabin-bag fee charged at the gate, a suitcase that arrives three days late in Paris, or luggage that never arrives at all.

I. What the European Parliament actually voted on free cabin baggage

A. One personal item plus one 7 kg cabin bag free: the exact measure everyone is talking about

The starting point is an official text, not a rumour. On 21 January 2026 the European Parliament published a press release announcing that it had adopted its position on the revision of EU air passenger rights, by 632 votes to 15 with nine abstentions, and one of the headline bullet points reads as follows: passengers should be allowed one personal item plus one small piece of hand luggage for free. The detailed version of the demand is equally precise: Parliament wants passengers to have the right to carry with them onto the airplane, at no additional cost, one personal item (such as a handbag, backpack or laptop) and one small piece of hand luggage with maximum dimensions of 100 cm (combined length, width and height) and seven kilograms. In other words, the small trolley case that low-cost carriers currently sell as a paid extra would become part of the ticket itself, with harmonised size and weight ceilings so that the rule means the same thing in Paris, Dublin and Madrid.

The same text goes further than luggage. Members of the Parliament want to keep the traveller’s right to compensation once a flight is delayed by more than three hours, they refuse the Council’s push to move that threshold to four or six hours depending on distance, as described in the same press release, and they propose compensation bands of between 300 and 600 euros according to flight distance. They also ask for pre-filled claim forms to be sent by the airline within 48 hours of a disruption, for an end to fees charged for correcting a spelling mistake in a passenger’s name, and for the right to keep a paper boarding pass. Travellers with reduced mobility, pregnant women and adults accompanying young children would get priority boarding and adjacent seating at no extra charge. For a British family flying Ryanair-style to Disneyland Paris, or an American student landing at Roissy with a backpack and a cabin case, the package would remove almost every small charge that currently inflates the final bill after the headline fare.

Why does this matter so much for cross-border travellers to France? Because the hand-luggage fee is the single most common airport dispute that never reaches a courtroom. Gate agents apply the airline’s own baggage policy, the passenger pays under protest to avoid missing the flight, and the file dies there for lack of proof. A European rule with fixed dimensions and a fixed weight would transform that balance of power: either the bag fits the European template and travels free, or it does not. Until that day, however, the passenger who wants the fee back must fight under the law as it stands, and that is where French procedure comes in, as developed below.

B. A negotiating position, not yet the law: what governs your flight to France today

The essential reservation is this: what the Parliament adopted is its negotiating position for discussions with the Council of member states, not a regulation that applies to the flight you take next week. The Parliament itself presents the text as a position adopted in first reading, and the Council has publicly pushed in the opposite direction on several points, including weaker delay thresholds and smaller compensation bands. As long as the two institutions have not agreed on a final text, and as long as that text has not entered into force, no passenger can walk up to a gate at Heathrow or JFK and demand a free 7 kg cabin bag by waving a press release. Any article that tells you otherwise is misleading you, and any claim drafted on that basis alone will be rejected.

What applies today to a flight to or from France is therefore the existing stack of rules. For delays, cancellations and denied boarding, it is Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, whose articles 5 and 7 organise the standardised compensation mechanism that the Parliament wants to preserve and the Council wants to dilute. For the carrier’s liability toward passengers and their baggage, French domestic law points every file toward two sources. Where the airline holds an operating licence issued under Regulation (EC) No 1008/2008, article L6421-3 of the Transport Code provides that its liability, as regards the carriage of passengers and their baggage, is subject to Regulation (EC) No 889/2002 and to the stipulations of the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air signed at Montreal on 28 May 1999. The statutory sentence is worth reading in full: the liability of the air carrier holding an operating licence issued in application of Regulation (EC) No 1008/2008 of 24 September 2008 establishing common rules for the operation of air services in the Community is subject, as regards the air transport of passengers and their baggage, to the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 889/2002 of 13 May 2002 amending Regulation (EC) No 2027/97 on air carrier liability in the event of accidents and to the stipulations of the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air signed at Montreal on 28 May 1999. For carriers outside that framework, article L6421-4 of the Transport Code sends the case directly to the same Convention: the liability of the air carrier not covered by article L.6421-3 is governed by the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules for International Carriage by Air signed at Montreal on 28 May 1999, under the conditions defined in section 2 of chapter II of the present title. In practice, almost every dispute about a bag lost between London and Paris, or between New York and Nice, ends up judged under the Montreal Convention, applied by a French court.

That distinction between the law of tomorrow and the law of today has a direct consequence for litigation strategy. A fee paid at the gate in 2026 cannot be reclaimed on the basis of the Parliament’s vote; it must be challenged under the contract of carriage, the airline’s published conditions, and the general French law of obligations. A suitcase destroyed or delayed in 2026 is governed by the Montreal Convention as received in French law, with its capped liability, its exclusivity, and its strict time limits. And a three-hour delay on the tarmac at Charles de Gaulle is still, today, a claim under Regulation 261/2004 as interpreted by the Court of Justice and the Cour de cassation, not under the future regulation. Readers who arrived here because their flight to Paris was cancelled during the recent protest disruptions will find the cancellation side of the subject treated in our companion analysis for British travellers on cancelled flights and Eurostar disruption rights; the present article deals with what happens to your luggage and your wallet at the gate and at the carousel.

II. Your bag is lost, damaged or delayed, or you were charged a fee: how to claim in France

A. Checked baggage under the Montreal Convention before the French courts: loss, damage, delay and the two-year guillotine

Start with the simplest proof in the whole file, because passengers routinely throw it away: the baggage tag. Article L6421-1 of the Transport Code states that the contract for the carriage of passengers is evidenced by the issue of a ticket, individual or collective, and that the contract for the carriage of baggage is evidenced by the issue of an identification slip for each item of registered baggage. The original French sentence reads: Le contrat de transport des passagers est constaté par la délivrance d’un billet, individuel ou collectif. Le contrat de transport des bagages est constaté par la délivrance d’une fiche d’identification pour chaque bagage enregistré. Keep the little sticker the airline puts on the back of your boarding pass or sends to your phone: it is the written proof that a specific bag entered the carrier’s custody on a specific flight. Without it, everything that follows becomes a fight about facts instead of a fight about law.

Once custody is established, the Montreal Convention, through articles L6421-3 and L6421-4 cited above, gives the passenger three distinct actions depending on what happened at the Paris carousel. If the bag is destroyed, lost or damaged while in the carrier’s charge, the airline answers for the harm on a strict basis, up to a capped amount expressed in Special Drawing Rights, unless it proves a narrow statutory defence. If the bag arrives late, the carrier answers for the damage caused by the delay, which in real life means the replacement clothes, toiletries and essentials a stranded visitor had to buy in Paris before the suitcase caught up. If the bag contains valuables above the ordinary cap, the only reliable protection is declared at check-in: the passenger may make a special declaration of interest in delivery and pay a surcharge, which raises the ceiling to the declared amount. Business travellers landing for a meeting at La Défense with presentation equipment, photographers with lenses, or musicians with instruments should treat that declaration as routine rather than exotic.

Two features of the Convention then decide most French cases before they are even argued. The first is exclusivity: for damage covered by the Convention, the action can only be brought under the Convention’s conditions, whatever the claimant and whatever the legal label. Article L6421-4 says so in plain terms for non-EU carriers, and the courts apply the same exclusivity logic across the board, which means a French claim for a lost suitcase cannot be re-dressed as an ordinary civil negligence action to escape the Convention’s caps and defences. The second feature is the guillotine of article 35 of the Convention, which extinguishes the action after two years. The Cour de cassation recalled this rule expressly when it explained, in a 2019 judgment, that the two-year prescription fixed by article 29 of the Warsaw Convention and article 35 of the Montreal Convention cannot be extended to actions brought under Regulation 261/2004, which sit outside the Conventions altogether. The sentence, in the Court’s own words, is that the two-year prescription fixed at article 29 of the Warsaw Convention and article 35 of the Montreal Convention could not be regarded as applying to actions brought in particular under those texts. So mark the calendar from the date of arrival: a baggage claim under the Convention that sleeps for two years dies, with no French grace period to save it.

The 2019 decision just quoted deserves a closer look, because it also settles the most frequent confusion in airport files. In Cass. 1st civil chamber, 10 October 2019, No 18-20.491, a passenger whose Mulhouse-Paris feeder flight ran late, causing a 24-hour delay to Pointe-à-Pitre, sued Air France both under articles 5 and 7 of Regulation 261/2004 and for failure to hand over the information notice. The Court approved the tribunal’s analysis that the compensation measure provided for in articles 5 and 7 of Regulation No 261/2004 lies outside the scope of the Warsaw and Montreal Conventions, and that the time limit within which actions seeking payment of the indemnity provided for in articles 5 and 7 of Regulation No 261/2004 must be brought is determined by the national law of each Member State. In the Court’s words: the compensation measure provided for in articles 5 and 7 of Regulation No 261/2004 lies outside the scope of the Warsaw and Montreal Conventions, and the time limit for bringing the actions for payment of the indemnity provided for in articles 5 and 7 must be determined by the national law of each Member State. Concretely, a delayed bag and a delayed flight are two different lawsuits with two different clocks: the Montreal two-year guillotine for the bag, and the national time limit for the standardised flight compensation. In France, the backdrop for that national limit is the general five-year prescription for personal actions, since article 2224 of the Civil Code provides that personal or movable actions are prescribed five years from the day the holder of a right knew or should have known the facts enabling its exercise. In French: Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer. File within months in any event rather than testing how a court articulates the two regimes; the passenger who waits loses leverage with the airline long before any prescription expires.

One more French particularity helps package-holiday travellers, who are numerous among British and Irish visitors to France. Where the flight was sold as part of a package, article L211-16 of the Tourism Code makes the retailer strictly liable for the performance of the services in the contract, whether performed by itself or by other travel service providers, without prejudice to its right of recourse against them: the professional who sells a tourist package mentioned in 1 of I of article L.211-1 is automatically liable for the performance of the services provided for in that contract, whether those services are performed by itself or by other travel service providers, without prejudice to its right of recourse against them. If a London tour operator’s partner airline loses your bags on the way to a ski resort in the Alps, you may therefore turn first against the operator who sold the package, in French, before a French court, instead of chasing the airline’s customer service alone.

B. Cabin-bag fees, proof and procedure: the practical file that actually wins in a French court

Turn now to the dispute the Parliament’s vote is really about: the fee charged at the gate for a cabin bag. Under current law, that fee lives or dies on the contract. The airline’s general conditions of carriage set a baggage allowance; the passenger accepts those conditions when booking; and article 1231-1 of the Civil Code provides the sanction for breach on either side, since the debtor is ordered, where appropriate, to pay damages either for non-performance of the obligation or for delay in performance, unless it proves that performance was prevented by force majeure. In French: Le débiteur est condamné, s’il y a lieu, au paiement de dommages et intérêts soit à raison de l’inexécution de l’obligation, soit à raison du retard dans l’exécution, s’il ne justifie pas que l’exécution a été empêchée par la force majeure. If the airline’s own published allowance covered your bag and the gate agent charged you anyway, the airline has not performed the contract and the fee, plus the proven knock-on loss, comes back. If the allowance plainly excluded your bag and you clicked through it at booking, a French judge will have little sympathy, and the future European rule will not rewrite the past contract.

That is why evidence taken at the airport decides these cases, and the Cour de cassation has said exactly how demanding French judges may be. In Cass. 1st civil chamber, 14 February 2018, No 16-23.205, a family claiming 600 euros per passenger for a five-hour Miami-Paris delay produced their electronic booking, a compensation request sent to the airline, and a non-nominative delay certificate signed by the carrier. The lower court threw the claim out, and the Cour de cassation approved, holding that it follows from article 3(2)(a) of Regulation No 261/2004 that the scheme laid down by that Regulation applies on condition that passengers hold a confirmed reservation for the flight concerned and present themselves, except in the case of cancellation covered by article 5, for check-in. In the Court’s words: it follows from article 3, paragraph 2, subparagraph (a), of Regulation No 261/2004 that the scheme laid down by that Regulation applies on condition that passengers have a confirmed reservation for the flight concerned and present themselves, except in the case of cancellation referred to in article 5, for check-in. The Court added, endorsing the lower judges, that the local court, which had established the absence of proof by them of the compensation obligation whose performance they claimed, had, without reversing the burden of proof or requiring impossible proof, rightly rejected the compensation claim. The general rule behind that outcome sits in article 1353 of the Civil Code: he who claims performance of an obligation must prove it. In French: Celui qui réclame l’exécution d’une obligation doit la prouver. Réciproquement, celui qui se prétend libéré doit justifier le paiement ou le fait qui a produit l’extinction de son obligation.

Translate that into an airport routine for any foreign traveller landing in France. Photograph the bag inside the airline’s measuring frame at the gate, keep the boarding pass showing the booking reference, keep the receipt for the fee with the time and flight number, and ask the agent for the written reason for the charge. For checked baggage, file the irregularity report at the airport desk before leaving the terminal, keep the baggage tag, photograph the damaged shell, keep every receipt for replacement essentials with dates, and then confirm everything in writing to the airline without delay, keeping proof of sending. The passenger who arrives before the Paris proximity judge with a dated, photographed, receipt-backed file is the heir of the rule in article 1353; the passenger who arrives with a story and no paper is the family in the 2018 judgment.

Where do you sue, and in what language of procedure? A foreign passenger whose journey ended at Charles de Gaulle or Orly may bring the case before the French courts, and for modest amounts the local-track judge near the airport or the Paris judicial court handles these serial disputes every week. The claim form should identify the flight, the reservation, the baggage tag number, the fee or the loss with receipts, and the legal basis: the Montreal Convention via the Transport Code for checked baggage, the contract and article 1231-1 for the gate fee, Regulation 261/2004 for the delay compensation where it applies. Write the airline a formal demand first, by a traceable channel, with a clear deadline and the full bundle attached; a significant share of baggage files settle at that stage once the carrier sees a file that is ready for court. If the airline answers with a voucher, check whether accepting it waives the balance of the claim before clicking, because customer-service interfaces are designed to close files cheaply. And keep the two clocks from part A firmly apart in your letter: the Montreal two-year guillotine for the bag, the national time limit for the flight compensation, and immediate written notice in both cases.

Finally, a word on the Parliament’s proposed pre-filled claim forms, which would require airlines to send passengers experiencing a disruption a pre-filled compensation and reimbursement form within 48 hours. That mechanism does not exist yet, so build your own version today: one page per incident, with the flight details pre-filled by you, the receipts attached, and the legal basis stated. When the reform eventually enters into force, the passengers who already document this way will be the first to benefit; the others will discover that even the most passenger-friendly regulation only helps those who can prove they were on the plane, with the bag, on the day.

Conclusion

The European Parliament’s 2026 vote for a free personal item plus a 7 kg cabin bag is a genuine political signal, adopted by an overwhelming majority, and it tells you where European air travel is heading: the suitcase in the overhead locker as part of the ticket, not as an optional extra. But it is not the law of your next flight to France. Until the Council and the Parliament agree on a final text, your rights at a Paris gate and at a Paris carousel rest on the existing instruments: the Montreal Convention, received into French law by articles L6421-3 and L6421-4 of the Transport Code, for everything that happens to checked baggage, with its strict liability, its caps and its two-year guillotine; the contract of carriage and article 1231-1 of the Civil Code for the gate fee you were charged; Regulation 261/2004, outside the Conventions and governed for time limits by national law, for the delayed or cancelled flight itself. The two Cour de cassation judgments examined here draw the litigation map with unusual clarity: prove the booking, the check-in and the custody of the bag, because article 1353 puts that burden on you, and keep the Convention claim and the Regulation claim on their separate tracks and their separate clocks. Photograph, keep the tag, complain in writing immediately, and demand in writing with the full bundle before suing in the French court of the place of arrival. Do that, and the future European cabin-bag rule, when it finally lands, will find you already travelling with the habits of a passenger who wins.

📄 Official circular