KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can France Prosecute Iranian Security Officers After the Tehran Attack on French Embassy Staff?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Hassan Kohen, criminal defence lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can France Prosecute Iranian Security Officers After the Tehran Attack on French Embassy Staff?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

France’s diplomatic response to the Tehran incident has created a sharper legal question than the expulsion itself. In its official statement, France said that two employees of the Iranian Embassy in France had been declared persona non grata under Article 9 of the 1961 Vienna Convention after an attack by Iranian security services against two employees of the French Embassy in Iran on 19 July 2026. The statement is a formal position of the French Government, not a criminal judgment; the identity of the alleged officers, the precise acts committed and the available evidence still have to be established. The practical question is whether France can open a criminal case against those alleged security officers even though the conduct took place in Tehran. The short answer is that French jurisdiction may exist, especially if the victims were French nationals and the alleged offences meet the statutory thresholds. That does not give French investigators power to arrest people in Iran, does not guarantee access to witnesses or records there and does not automatically overcome functional immunity claimed for official acts. The analysis below concerns the alleged Iranian security officers, not the Iranian embassy employees expelled from Paris. That distinction matters: diplomatic status in France, state-official status in Iran, French victim nationality, the legal classification of the conduct and the location of the suspect lead to different procedural consequences.

I. Can France prosecute Iranian security officers for an attack committed in Tehran?

A. French jurisdiction begins with the nationality of the victims and the legal classification of the conduct

The first question is jurisdiction, not immunity. French criminal law can apply to conduct that happened entirely outside France when Parliament has created a connecting factor. The clearest possible connection in this story is the nationality of the victims. Article 113-7 of the Code pénal, in the version returned as in force by Légifrance, states: “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime, ainsi qu’à tout délit puni d’emprisonnement, commis par un Français ou par un étranger hors du territoire de la République lorsque la victime est de nationalité française au moment de l’infraction.” The official text of Article 113-7 of the French Criminal Code therefore supplies two conditions that must be tested rather than assumed: the victim must have been French when the event occurred, and the offence must be a crime or an offence punishable by imprisonment.

Being employed by a French embassy strongly explains why diplomatic protection is engaged, but employment by the French State is not itself a substitute for proof of nationality. A file should identify each victim, record the nationality held on 19 July 2026 and preserve the employment or accreditation documents showing the person’s diplomatic or protected status. If the victims are French nationals, the French prosecutor does not need the alleged Iranian officer to be French in order to examine the case under Article 113-7. The provision is deliberately framed around an offence committed abroad against a French victim. It is a jurisdictional gateway; it does not decide whether violence, unlawful detention, threats, coercion or another offence can be proved.

Article 113-6 of the Criminal Code supplies a different gateway when the suspect is French. Its opening sentence provides: “La loi pénale française est applicable à tout crime commis par un Français hors du territoire de la République.” The Légifrance text of Article 113-6 also contains conditions for offences committed abroad by French nationals. That provision is unlikely to be the principal route on the facts publicly described, because the alleged perpetrators are described by France as Iranian security services. It remains important in a cross-border file because identities can change as evidence develops: an individual officer, intermediary or co-perpetrator may have more than one nationality, may have lived in France or may have acted through a French-based participant.

The conduct must then be classified without allowing the diplomatic context to replace ordinary criminal analysis. A four-hour detention, physical violence, threats, forced questioning, seizure of communications equipment and attempts to obtain information could lead to different offences depending on the evidence, the victim’s injuries, the purpose of the conduct and the involvement of each suspect. A diplomatic incident does not automatically become torture, terrorism or a crime against humanity. Conversely, describing conduct as a security operation does not make violence lawful. The prosecutor or investigating judge would need a legally precise accusation, a date, a place, an identified victim and evidence connecting each alleged officer to the acts charged.

Article 113-9 of the Criminal Code supplies another limit. It states that, in the cases covered by Articles 113-6 and 113-7, no prosecution may be brought against a person who proves that the person has already been finally judged abroad for the same facts and, after conviction, that the sentence was served or is time-barred. The official Article 113-9 text does not create an Iranian veto over a French investigation. It addresses a final foreign judgment for the same facts and the consequences of that judgment. A politically announced inquiry, an internal security review or an administrative dismissal in Iran would not automatically satisfy the statutory conditions.

The Cour de cassation has insisted that the court’s competence must be dealt with before the immunity objection. In its Assize Plenary judgment of 25 July 2025, no. 24-84.071, the Court wrote: “La question de la compétence de la juridiction est préalable à celle de l’immunité.” The official decision no. 24-84.071 concerned a different factual setting, including alleged complicity abroad, so it is not a ruling on the Tehran incident. Its sequence is nevertheless valuable: a French judge first identifies the legal basis for hearing the case, then examines whether a rule of immunity prevents the exercise of jurisdiction against the specific person and for the specific conduct.

That order prevents two opposite mistakes. France cannot say “there is immunity” before identifying whose immunity is invoked, under which instrument and for what act. But a victim also cannot say “the victims are French” and assume that an arrest or trial is immediately possible. Jurisdiction and enforceability are separate. A French prosecutor can receive a complaint, preserve evidence, identify suspects, seek judicial measures available in France and ask the Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs to clarify status. None of those steps authorises French officers to enter Iran, compel an Iranian witness to appear in Paris or execute a French search warrant in Tehran.

The competent French authorities would also have to keep the official account and the evidential account separate. France’s statement on the expulsion of two Iranian embassy employees attributes the attack to Iranian security services and describes the diplomatic response. Contemporary reporting by Le Monde recorded competing accounts about the detention and alleged violence. A French proceeding would have to test both the French victims’ account and any contrary account through testimony, medical evidence, documents and digital material. A diplomatic statement can justify an investigation; it cannot replace proof at trial.

For victims, the most valuable early act is usually disciplined preservation. Medical records should identify the date, symptoms, treatment and any photographs or scans. Each witness should write a dated account while memory is fresh, distinguishing what was personally seen from what was later reported. Employment records, diplomatic accreditation, travel records, phone logs and messages can establish the location and status of the victims. If a device was taken or inspected, the fact, time, person involved and later condition of the device should be recorded. The objective is not to publish an accusation. It is to give French authorities a usable chronology that can support jurisdiction, identify suspects and guide requests for evidence abroad.

B. The special extraterritorial provisions help only when their treaty conditions are actually met

Article 113-7 is not the only possible basis. Article 689-1 of the Code de procédure pénale provides a treaty-based route for certain offences committed abroad. The official text says: “En application des conventions internationales visées aux articles suivants, peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises, si elle se trouve en France, toute personne qui s’est rendue coupable hors du territoire de la République de l’une des infractions énumérées par ces articles.” The Légifrance version of Article 689-1 is currently applicable to the facts considered here, while the legal database flags a planned change on 1 January 2029. It is therefore essential to check the law in force on the date of the alleged conduct and not to cite the provision as a timeless rule.

Article 689-1 does not create general universal jurisdiction for every overseas assault. It operates through the conventions and offences listed in the following provisions, and it requires the person to be found in France. Article 689-3, which implements the European Convention on the Suppression of Terrorism and related arrangements, is much narrower than a headline using the words “international crime”. Its text identifies offences committed against a person entitled to international protection, “y compris les agents diplomatiques”. The official Article 689-3 provision must be read with the convention, the exact offence and the conditions for its application. The presence of a diplomatic victim is relevant; it is not enough by itself to satisfy every element of the provision.

Article 689-2, concerning torture under the United Nations Convention against Torture, illustrates the same discipline. The official text of Article 689-2 applies to a person guilty of torture as defined by Article 1 of that convention, if the other conditions of Article 689-1 are met. A violent interrogation may be extremely serious without automatically satisfying the international definition of torture. The distinction matters because a French court must identify the facts, the mental element, the involvement of a public official and the purpose of the conduct. Calling an incident “torture” in a political statement is not the same as proving each legal element.

The public facts also do not establish that the alleged officers are the same people as the two Iranian embassy employees declared persona non grata in France. That distinction should remain explicit. The French statement describes an attack by Iranian security services in Iran and a retaliatory diplomatic measure against two employees of the Iranian Embassy in France. There may be institutional or operational links, but the public announcement does not identify an individual perpetrator or establish that either expelled employee was physically present in Tehran. An analysis that collapses those categories risks accusing the wrong people and confusing diplomatic retaliation with criminal attribution.

If a complaint is filed in France, the immediate objective should be framed in procedural terms: preserve the victims’ accounts, obtain medical and employment evidence, identify the suspected unit or officers, secure digital material and determine whether a treaty-based investigation is available. A complainant may also ask the French authorities to obtain the Ministry’s records concerning the victims’ accreditation and the diplomatic protest. Those requests do not prejudge the outcome. They allow the judicial file to answer the questions that the public statement leaves open: who acted, what exactly happened, under whose instructions, and what evidence exists outside Iran.

The cross-border evidence problem is substantial. Iran may hold video footage, access logs, detention records, internal instructions or the identities of the officers involved. French investigators may seek cooperation through diplomatic channels or any applicable mutual legal assistance framework, but a request is not a guarantee of production. The absence of Iranian cooperation should not be confused with the absence of French jurisdiction. It does, however, affect the realistic prospect of an indictment and trial. The file should therefore preserve evidence available in France before asking a foreign authority for material that may never arrive.

The question of an arrest warrant also needs careful wording. A French judge may, in an appropriate case and after the statutory conditions are met, issue a measure directed at a suspect. That measure has practical value if the suspect travels to France or another state prepared to cooperate. It does not give France a power to execute the measure in Iran. A request for an international alert, extradition or police cooperation would create additional legal and political steps, not a shortcut around territorial sovereignty. This is why a serious article about the Tehran incident must begin with jurisdiction and evidence rather than promising an immediate arrest.

The Court of cassation’s reasoning in no. 24-84.071 is useful again because it separates competence from the merits of an immunity objection. The Court stated: “L’immunité pénale de juridiction procède de l’égalité souveraine des États.” It also explained that immunity operates before national courts, subject to the applicable international rules. The decision’s official text should be read as a framework for classification, not as a finding that every foreign security officer is immune. It supports a method: establish the French jurisdictional basis, identify the person, define the act and then test the claimed immunity.

The earlier cabinet analysis on France–Iran diplomatic expulsions and persona non grata addresses what the diplomatic measure can and cannot do. The present article takes the narrower missing angle: whether France can build a criminal case against the alleged security personnel who acted in Tehran. The two subjects are connected, but they are not interchangeable. One concerns the status of people present in France; the other concerns extraterritorial jurisdiction, attribution and the possible immunity of foreign state agents.

On the present public record, the legally responsible conclusion is therefore conditional. France may have a credible basis to open or continue a criminal investigation if the victims are French nationals, the conduct meets the requirements of Article 113-7 or a specific treaty provision and the evidence can identify the perpetrators. Whether the case can proceed to prosecution, obtain an arrest measure or reach trial will depend on evidence, the suspect’s location, the exact charge, foreign cooperation and immunity. The legal question is live; the outcome is not predetermined by the expulsion.

II. Do diplomatic or state-official immunities block a French case against the alleged Iranian officers?

A. A security officer in Iran is not automatically a diplomat accredited in France

The word “official” is not a complete answer to an immunity objection. Diplomatic immunity, personal immunity of certain senior state representatives and functional immunity for official acts are related but different doctrines. Their sources, beneficiaries and duration are not the same. The French decree publishing the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, together with the French law authorising ratification, provides the treaty framework for an agent of a diplomatic mission in the receiving State. It does not turn every employee of a foreign security service into an accredited diplomat in every country.

Article 29 of the Vienna Convention protects the person of an accredited diplomatic agent in the receiving State. The Assize Plenary of the Cour de cassation reproduced the rule in its judgment no. 24-84.393: “Par ailleurs, l’article 29 de la Convention de Vienne du 18 avril 1961 sur les relations diplomatiques prévoit que la personne de l’agent diplomatique est inviolable et que celui-ci ne peut être soumis à aucune forme d’arrestation ou de détention.” The official judgment no. 24-84.393 concerned the immunity of a head of State and is not a ruling on the alleged Iranian officers. Its citation of Article 29 demonstrates why accreditation and the receiving State matter.

If an Iranian security officer acted in Tehran, the immediate receiving State for any diplomatic status in that operation would be Iran, not France. A person working for an Iranian intelligence or security body might be a state official without being a member of the Iranian diplomatic mission in Paris. The French courts would need a formal answer from the Ministry or other reliable records if the person later claimed diplomatic status. They would also need to know whether the claimed status existed at the time of the conduct, whether the person was accredited to France and whether the conduct was connected to the mission’s protected activities.

Article 31 of the Vienna Convention protects an accredited diplomatic agent from the criminal jurisdiction of the receiving State, subject to the treaty’s limited civil and administrative exceptions. Article 32 makes waiver a matter for the sending State and requires an express waiver. Article 41 requires persons enjoying privileges and immunities to respect the laws and regulations of the receiving State and not interfere in its internal affairs. These provisions must be read together: the duty to respect local law does not erase the procedural immunity, and the immunity does not make the underlying conduct lawful. The treaty text is available through the official Légifrance publication of the Vienna Convention.

Nor does a passport settle the issue. In its criminal judgment no. 17-80.228 of 11 October 2017, the Cour de cassation approved reasoning that a claimant who was not exercising public powers could not rely on immunity and noted that “un passeport diplomatique n’étant pas susceptible de conférer une telle immunité ;”. The official decision no. 17-80.228 is a practical warning for a Tehran file. A document may be relevant evidence of a person’s claimed status, but diplomatic immunity depends on the legal status recognised by the relevant State and the act being challenged, not on the cover of the passport alone.

Personal immunity is narrower still. In no. 24-84.393, the Cour de cassation stated that “L’immunité personnelle, distincte de l’immunité fonctionnelle, est reconnue aux seuls chef d’État, chef du gouvernement et ministre des affaires étrangères, en exercice.” An ordinary security officer does not fall within that category merely because the officer works for a ministry, intelligence service or armed body. The official decision also cautions against reading the proposition as a general licence to prosecute senior foreign officials: the identity and office of the person must be proved, and other international rules may apply.

Functional immunity raises the harder question. In no. 24-84.071, the Cour de cassation described it in these terms: “L’immunité de juridiction fonctionnelle, distincte de l’immunité personnelle, est reconnue aux agents de l’État agissant dans l’exercice de leurs fonctions. Elle n’est pas limitée dans le temps et subsiste après la fin des fonctions.” The official decision no. 24-84.071 says that this principle is subject to international conventions, including the rules on diplomatic and consular relations. That passage explains why a claim that an officer was “following orders” cannot simply be ignored, while also showing why the claim must be tested against the nature of the act and the applicable convention.

Functional immunity is not a factual presumption that follows every official label. The court must determine whether the individual acted as an organ or agent of the State, whether the conduct was performed in an official capacity and whether the alleged act is the kind of sovereign act to which the rule applies. A personal assault during an official operation may still be described by the foreign State as an official act; that does not end the legal analysis. The French judge must also consider whether a special treaty, a rule of customary international law or the character of the alleged offence changes the result.

The same judgment states that, subject to international conventions, functional immunity cannot be invoked for prosecutions for genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes. That exception should not be used carelessly here. The publicly reported facts are grave, but they do not by themselves establish one of those international crimes. The safer analysis is to examine ordinary French offences and treaty-based jurisdiction first, then ask whether functional immunity applies to the specific state conduct. A dramatic label may attract attention; a precise charge is what determines the court’s power.

The French judiciary would also need to separate the alleged security officers from the two Iranian embassy employees expelled in France. If one expelled employee later became a suspect, the receiving-State rules on diplomatic accreditation could matter. If the alleged perpetrator is an Iranian security officer who never held diplomatic status in France, Article 29 and Article 31 do not automatically apply. If the officer is later appointed to the embassy, the date and purpose of the appointment would still matter. The Cour de cassation has repeatedly treated status, function and chronology as questions requiring proof rather than political assumption.

B. Expulsion, waiver and the end of functions create different procedural paths

France’s declaration of persona non grata is a diplomatic response under Article 9 of the Vienna Convention. It can require the sending State to recall an employee, end the person’s functions or accept that France will no longer recognise the person as a member of the mission. It is not an indictment, an arrest warrant or a waiver of immunity. The official statement does not announce that the expelled employees are the alleged perpetrators of the Tehran attack. It describes a response to the conduct attributed to Iranian security services. The difference protects both the integrity of the criminal process and the accuracy of the public record.

A diplomatic request for waiver can run in parallel with a French complaint. Under Article 32 of the Vienna Convention, the waiver belongs to the sending State and must be express. France may ask Iran to waive immunity for a particular person and proceeding, but Iran’s refusal would not prove that the person committed the offence. It would instead leave the French authorities to assess whether the claimed immunity exists, what it covers and whether another route remains available. A waiver of jurisdiction should also be distinguished from a waiver of execution: permission to litigate does not automatically authorise seizure of protected state or mission property.

If the alleged officer has no diplomatic immunity in France and later enters French territory, the practical position changes. The French authorities could assess the person under the ordinary rules applicable to a suspect within France, subject to the procedural safeguards, evidence and judicial authorisation required by French law. A French jurisdictional basis under Article 113-7 would still need to be established, and a treaty route under Article 689-1 would still require its statutory conditions. The officer’s arrival would remove one obstacle—physical access to the person—but would not prove identity, participation or the absence of functional immunity.

If the person is an accredited diplomat and remains protected, the situation is different. Article 29’s inviolability may prevent arrest or detention in France, while Article 31 may prevent the exercise of criminal jurisdiction as the receiving State. The proper response is not self-help or an attempt to force entry into diplomatic premises. It is a formal status request, a diplomatic demand for waiver, preservation of evidence and, where appropriate, a request that the sending State investigate or recall the person. The cabinet’s general guide on diplomatic immunity in France covers the broader distinction between an official complaint, immunity and enforcement; this article applies it to suspected acts committed by security personnel in Iran.

The end of a diplomatic function can change personal immunity without erasing every protection for official acts. In its criminal judgment no. 03-83.452 of 12 April 2005, the Cour de cassation approved the following formulation: “le bénéfice de l’immunité diplomatique, qui cesse de plein droit à la fin des fonctions, peut être seulement prorogé pendant un délai raisonnable qui aura été accordé à l’agent pour quitter le pays ;”. The official decision no. 03-83.452 therefore makes the date of the end of functions and the reasonable departure period central. It does not provide an automatic answer for an Iranian security officer who was never a diplomat accredited in France.

After the reasonable departure period, a former diplomatic agent may lose personal immunity for private acts, while functional immunity for official acts may remain. The distinction is especially important in this story because an alleged security operation may be characterised by Iran as an exercise of State authority. A French court would have to identify the act before deciding whether the former status still matters. It would also have to avoid retroactive reasoning: a later appointment to an embassy cannot automatically convert an earlier private act into an official diplomatic act, and a later expulsion cannot retroactively prove a criminal offence.

Article 113-9 also matters if Iran conducts its own proceedings. French investigators should ask whether the foreign process concerns the same person, the same conduct and a final judgment, rather than treating any public announcement as conclusive. Conversely, a French case would need to respect any final foreign judgment that satisfies the statutory conditions. This is one reason why the file should use precise dates and a factual matrix for each suspect. “The Iran incident” is not sufficiently precise for a double-jeopardy analysis: the alleged detention, physical assault, threats and any later retaliation may be separate acts involving different people.

Evidence preservation remains possible even while immunity is disputed. A French authority can record a complaint, preserve documents, obtain statements from persons located in France and ask for a formal status response. A victim can organise a secure chronology, retain original files, document the chain of custody and identify the official sources that describe the incident. The case should avoid publishing names based on speculation or using social-media material without verifying provenance. A wrong identification can create a defamation or privacy dispute and damage the credibility of a legitimate complaint.

The most realistic procedural sequence has four stages. First, establish the victims’ nationality, diplomatic status, injuries and exact location. Second, identify the suspected officers and distinguish direct perpetrators, commanders, facilitators and persons who merely signed an administrative order. Third, select the jurisdictional route—Article 113-7, a treaty provision such as Article 689-3 where all conditions are met, or another specific statutory basis. Fourth, test immunity and enforceability separately, including the suspect’s current location and the prospect of foreign cooperation. Each stage can produce useful progress even if the final trial cannot take place immediately.

That sequence also explains what the French Government’s expulsion achieved and what it did not. It created a visible diplomatic cost for Iran and expressed France’s position that the safety of its embassy staff had been violated. It did not identify the perpetrators for a French court, obtain access to Iranian evidence or create a waiver of state-official immunity. A criminal case, if pursued, must therefore be built through evidence and legally defined requests. The public importance of the incident makes accuracy more important, not less.

For a victim or a family member, the first written submission should ask for concrete acts rather than a political declaration. It can request registration of the complaint, preservation of medical and digital evidence, a status inquiry through the foreign ministry, identification of the competent French authority and an assessment of the applicable extraterritorial provision. It should attach the official statement but label it as an attributed government account. It should also identify uncertainties: unknown officer names, disputed sequence, missing Iranian records and the precise legal classification still to be determined.

The answer to the headline question is consequently neither an automatic “yes” nor an immunity-based “no”. France can investigate and may be able to prosecute alleged Iranian security officers if the victims’ nationality, the offence and the statutory jurisdictional basis are proved. A French court must then address the person’s status and any functional immunity claim. If the suspect remains in Iran, enforcement depends on cooperation or travel. If the suspect holds a protected diplomatic status in France, the Vienna Convention may block coercive measures until waiver or the end of the relevant protection. The legal route is open enough to justify a carefully built file, but not broad enough to justify an unsupported accusation.

Conclusion

The Tehran incident raises a real French criminal-jurisdiction question because France says that two employees of its embassy were attacked by Iranian security services. If those victims were French nationals, Article 113-7 of the Criminal Code may connect the overseas conduct to French courts, provided the offence is a crime or an imprisonable offence. Article 689-1 and Article 689-3 may add treaty-based routes only if their conditions are met; they do not create a general power to prosecute every overseas attack. Articles 113-6 and 113-9 supply different rules for French suspects and final foreign judgments. The jurisdictional file must therefore be built from nationality, charge, identity and evidence.

Immunity is the next question, not the first. An alleged security officer in Tehran is not automatically an Iranian diplomat accredited in Paris. A diplomatic passport is not enough, personal immunity belongs to a narrow group of senior officials, and functional immunity requires a separate analysis of official status and conduct. The Cour de cassation’s decisions nos. 24-84.071, 24-84.393, 03-83.452 and 17-80.228 supply the controlling distinctions and the official sources linked above. Persona non grata is a diplomatic measure, not a criminal conviction or a waiver. France can preserve evidence, request cooperation and assess prosecution while keeping the public account separate from what a court can prove.

On the facts publicly available on 22 August 2026, the most responsible answer is that France may be able to open and develop a case, but prosecution, arrest and trial remain contingent. The decisive work is to identify the actual officers, preserve evidence in France, establish the victims’ nationality and protected status, select the precise offence and confront any immunity claim through the correct diplomatic and judicial channels. That is the practical line between a credible cross-border criminal file and a headline that promises powers French courts do not possess.

📄 Official circular