France has not legalised surrogacy. It has, however, drawn a sharper line between the invalidity of a surrogacy agreement in France and the status of a child whose parentage has already been established abroad. On 3 July 2026, the Cour de cassation’s Plenary Assembly ruled in two Canadian cases that the French ban cannot, by itself, justify refusing every effect to a foreign judgment naming the intended parents as the child’s legal parents. The court’s message is both protective and demanding: a foreign ruling may be recognised as a ruling on parentage, but only after a real review of its international regularity and of the safeguards surrounding the parental project.
That distinction matters for families returning to France, French nationals whose children were born abroad, and foreign parents who need a French civil-status document, residence document or nationality procedure. It also changes the way counsel should prepare a file. A birth certificate, a foreign judgment and proof of consent do not perform the same legal function. Nor does recognition of parentage automatically settle every consequence of nationality, parental authority or civil-status registration. The practical question is no longer whether the word “surrogacy” ends the case. It is whether the foreign decision is sufficiently reasoned, internationally regular and protective of the child and the people involved.
I. Can France recognise a foreign surrogacy judgment?
A. What does French law say about surrogacy abroad?
The starting point remains the prohibition in the French Civil Code. Article 16-7 provides, in the official wording, “Toute convention portant sur la procréation ou la gestation pour le compte d’autrui est nulle” — every agreement concerning procreation or gestation for another is void. The text is available in the current version of Article 16-7 of the French Civil Code. Article 16-9 adds that “Les dispositions du présent chapitre sont d’ordre public”, meaning that the rules in this chapter have mandatory public-policy status; the provision is reproduced in Article 16-9 of the French Civil Code. Those provisions govern the validity of a surrogacy arrangement under French law. They do not answer, without further analysis, whether a foreign judgment concerning a child’s established parentage may produce effects in France.
That is the essential conflict-of-laws distinction. A court asked to enforce a foreign judgment is not being asked to approve a surrogacy agreement for performance in France. It is being asked whether a decision already made by a foreign court can be recognised within the French legal order. Article 509 of the Code of Civil Procedure states that foreign judgments and acts received by foreign officers are enforceable in France “de la manière et dans les cas prévus par la loi” — in the manner and cases provided by law. The official text is at Article 509 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The provision opens the door to exequatur; it does not grant it automatically.
There is a second distinction between a foreign court judgment and a foreign civil-status act. Article 47 of the Civil Code gives evidentiary force to a foreign civil-status act made in the forms used in that country, unless other material establishes, after useful checks, that it is irregular, falsified or inconsistent with reality as assessed under French law. The complete rule is set out in Article 47 of the Civil Code. A request to transcribe a birth act therefore has a different object from an action seeking exequatur of a parentage judgment. Treating those procedures as interchangeable is a common source of delay and an avoidable source of bad evidence.
The earlier case law shows why the issue became so sensitive. In the 2011 decision in Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 6 April 2011, no. 10-19.053, the court took a restrictive view of foreign arrangements connected with surrogacy. The reasoning reflected the domestic nullity of the agreement and the conception of French international public policy then applied to the resulting civil-status consequences. That position could not remain isolated from the European human-rights jurisprudence concerning the child’s private life and identity.
The Plenary Assembly changed the direction in Cour de cassation, 3 July 2015, no. 14-21.323. The court held that a foreign birth act could not be rejected merely because a surrogacy process was suspected, where the act was not irregular or falsified and the declared facts corresponded to reality. The 2015 ruling did not make the foreign arrangement valid in France. It insisted that the civil-status question had to be answered through the statutory conditions governing the foreign act and through the child’s protected interests.
The 2019 Plenary Assembly decision in Cour de cassation, 4 October 2019, no. 10-19.053 made the human-rights dimension explicit. The fact that a child’s birth abroad originated in a surrogacy agreement prohibited by Articles 16-7 and 16-9 could not, by itself, block transcription for the biological father or recognition of the relationship with the intended mother when doing so would disproportionately harm the child’s right to private life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. This was a rule about the child’s identity, not a declaration that French law permits surrogacy contracts.
The 2026 judgments build on that distinction but apply it to a different procedural object: the foreign judicial decision establishing parentage. That is why the correct question is not “Is surrogacy legal in France?” It remains prohibited. The correct questions are whether the foreign court had an internationally acceptable connection to the dispute, whether the decision respected procedural and substantive public policy, whether the evidence protects the persons involved, and what legal effect the decision is being asked to produce in France.
B. What did the Cour de cassation decide on 3 July 2026?
The two judgments concern Canadian decisions involving children born following surrogacy abroad. The first is Cour de cassation, Plenary Assembly, 3 July 2026, no. 24-50.028, ECLI FR:CCASS:2026:PL00692. The second is Cour de cassation, Plenary Assembly, 3 July 2026, no. 24-50.029, ECLI FR:CCASS:2026:PL00691. The court’s official 3 July 2026 communication on foreign surrogacy judgments summarises the governing balance: the French prohibition alone cannot refuse every effect to a foreign judgment declaring the intended parents to be the child’s legal parents, but recognition depends on guarantees shown by the foreign decision and the record.
The phrase that matters in the 24-50.029 ruling is that the foreign decision’s conformity with French international public policy “ne saurait être appréciée au seul regard” of the domestic prohibition. The court treats two principles as part of the international public-policy analysis: the essential French rule against surrogacy agreements and the child’s Article 8 right to respect for private life. That is not a simple hierarchy in which one principle defeats the other. It is a requirement to reconcile them in the particular enforcement application.
The court therefore rejects a blanket refusal. It does not order French courts to disregard the domestic ban, and it does not say that every foreign birth order or parentage judgment must be enforced. It says that the judge must examine the foreign decision in the form in which it exists. The foreign court’s reasoning, its findings about the individuals, the consent process and the legal consequences of the arrangement become central evidence. A decision that gives only names and an outcome, without explaining who participated in the parental project or how rights were transferred, may still fail the French review.
That requirement was already visible in Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 2 October 2024, no. 22-20.883, ECLI FR:CCASS:2024:C100507. In that case, the court stated that a foreign decision lacking reasons can conflict with French procedural international public policy when the applicant supplies no equivalent documents. For a surrogacy-related parentage judgment, the judge must be able to identify the capacity of the persons who participated in the parental project and verify that the parties, especially the surrogate, consented to the agreement, its terms and its effect on parental rights. The practical consequence is clear: a missing explanation is not cured by simply asserting that the foreign country accepted the arrangement.
The 2024 case also explains why the new 2026 rule is not a sudden permission slip. It is a controlled recognition mechanism. A French judge does not retry the medical or family dispute on the merits. The judge tests the foreign decision’s international legitimacy, procedural fairness, compatibility with fundamental rights and freedom from fraud. But the judge must perform that test with enough information to identify vulnerability, consent and the child’s interests. The protection is therefore two-sided: it prevents a refusal based solely on the label “surrogacy”, while preventing automatic recognition based solely on the label “foreign judgment”.
The second 2024 landmark, Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, 14 November 2024, no. 23-50.016, confirmed a further point. French international public policy does not prohibit recognition of foreign parentage merely because the intended parent has no biological link with the child. Once the foreign judgment establishing parentage is granted exequatur, “la filiation est reconnue en tant que telle” — parentage is recognised as parentage — and it produces the effects attached to that status under the law applicable to each effect. The court did not convert the result into an adoption.
That distinction is decisive. Recognition as parentage can affect the way a child’s legal identity is recorded and how parental status is treated under the applicable law. It does not mean that a French court has created a new adoption or rewritten the foreign judgment. In the 2026 cases, the Plenary Assembly preserves the legal character chosen by the foreign court while applying French conflict-of-laws safeguards. The result is more predictable for children, but it makes the quality of the original judgment and the exequatur file more important, not less.
II. How do you obtain recognition of foreign parentage in France?
A. Which documents does the French exequatur judge need?
The first practical task is to identify the object of the application. If the foreign document is a reasoned judgment that establishes parentage, the file should be built as an exequatur application. If the issue is a foreign birth certificate, the legal route may be transcription or recognition of the civil-status act under Article 47. If the foreign court has issued an order that does not establish parentage but only authorises a later adoption or transfer of custody, the file may fall under a different category. The label used by a foreign authority is not enough; the operative part and the reasons must be read together.
For an exequatur application after surrogacy abroad, the original or certified foreign judgment should be produced in full, not just the first page or an extract of its operative part. The French court needs to see the parties, the court’s jurisdictional basis, the procedural history, the evidence considered, the findings about the child, the surrogate and the intended parent or parents, and the legal result. A finality certificate or equivalent proof should show whether ordinary appeals remain possible. Documents proving service, participation or representation can matter where the status of a person was altered by the foreign decision.
The record should make the parental project intelligible. That does not mean exposing unnecessary private information. It means giving the court reliable evidence about the roles of the intended parent or parents, the surrogate, any egg or sperm donor whose status is relevant, and the person or persons named as legal parents in the foreign judgment. The court’s 2024 standard requires the judge to identify those roles. A dossier that leaves a surrogate’s legal position unexplained is structurally vulnerable even when the foreign judgment is formally final.
Consent must be documented with equal care. The relevant question is not only whether a signature appears on a contract. The file should show what the surrogate understood, when consent was given, whether it covered the modalities of the arrangement, and whether it covered the consequences for parental rights. The French court’s official summary of the 2 October 2024 case focuses on consent to the agreement and to its effects on the child’s filiation. The foreign decision should therefore explain those matters, or the applicant should produce equivalent documents that allow the French judge to verify them.
The evidence may include the applicable foreign legislation, the contractual documents relied upon by the foreign court, informed-consent records, orders made before or after birth, statements concerning the transfer or waiver of parental rights, and the foreign court’s findings about coercion, vulnerability or exploitation. These materials must be translated accurately. Depending on the country of origin and the document, apostille or legalisation requirements may apply. The point is not to build a larger file for its own sake. The point is to close the evidentiary gaps that the 2024 jurisprudence identifies as capable of defeating recognition.
The child’s situation should also be presented in a focused way. The best interests of the child are not a slogan that replaces the legal test. They are part of the reason the French judge must assess the consequences of a refusal under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights and the child-protection principles invoked by the Cour de cassation. Evidence of the child’s identity, residence, continuity of care, existing civil-status documents, family life and practical exposure to an unresolved parentage status can help the court understand the concrete stakes. It should be connected to the relief sought rather than inserted as a general emotional narrative.
The applicant should also establish the foreign court’s connection with the case. The judgment should explain the child’s birth or residence, the nationality or residence of the intended parents, the place where the parental project was carried out, and the jurisdictional rule used by the foreign court. A foreign order from a court with no meaningful connection to the family may attract a jurisdictional objection even if its conclusion is sympathetic. The exequatur judge is not reviewing a merely private contract; the judgment must have been rendered by an authority whose intervention can be recognised in France.
A complete file should finally separate the documents needed for recognition from the documents needed for later effects. The judgment, finality, service, reasons, identity and consent materials concern the exequatur question. A birth certificate, French nationality evidence, a request for civil-status transcription, a travel document or a residence application may concern a later administrative or civil-status question. Combining every request in one undifferentiated bundle makes it harder to see which legal test each document satisfies. A short index mapping each exhibit to a proposition in the judgment is often more valuable than a volume of unstructured records.
This approach is consistent with the sequence of the case law. The 2015 decision in no. 14-21.323 concentrated on whether the foreign civil-status act was irregular, falsified or inconsistent with reality. The 2019 decision in no. 10-19.053 concentrated on the child’s private life and the disproportionate consequences of a refusal. The 2024 decisions in nos. 22-20.883 and 23-50.016 concentrated on the reasons, consent, the identities of the participants and the effects of exequatur. The 2026 Plenary Assembly decisions consolidate those strands for foreign parentage judgments. The file must therefore answer all of them without confusing their procedural purposes.
B. What happens to civil status, nationality and parental rights?
Exequatur is not the end of every procedure. It is the recognition of a foreign judicial decision in France. Once a foreign parentage judgment is granted exequatur, the Cour de cassation says the parentage established by that judgment is recognised as such, rather than being recharacterised as adoption. That principle is especially important where the foreign decision names an intended parent who has no biological link with the child. The 14 November 2024 judgment in no. 23-50.016 expressly rejects the idea that lack of biology alone prevents exequatur.
The next step may involve French civil-status records. A successful exequatur can support recognition of the child’s parentage and, depending on the form and content of the foreign decision and the applicable administrative route, can support a request concerning French registers. It does not erase the conditions of Article 47, and it does not guarantee that every document will be transcribed without a separate review. The 2015 and 2019 authorities remain relevant where the requested act is a birth record rather than a judgment. Lawyers should state precisely whether they seek recognition of a judgment, transcription of an act, correction of an entry or delivery of a document.
Nationality is a separate legal question. Article 18 of the Civil Code states, “Est français l’enfant dont l’un des parents au moins est français” — a child is French when at least one parent is French. The current text is available at Article 18 of the Civil Code. But the establishment of parentage and the proof of French nationality must still be presented through the relevant procedure. Article 20-1 provides that a child’s parentage affects nationality only if it is established during minority; the provision is available in Article 20-1 of the Civil Code. Article 30 places the burden of proof on the person whose nationality is at issue in the relevant proceedings; Article 30 of the Civil Code should be reviewed when nationality is part of the requested outcome.
This is why a family can win recognition of parentage and still need a separate nationality or civil-status application. The foreign judgment may establish who the legal parent is, but the administration may need proof of nationality, the date on which parentage was established, the child’s identity and the authenticity and translation of the documents. The legal effects of parentage may also be governed by different applicable laws. The 2024 court’s formula that recognised parentage produces its effects according to the law applicable to each effect is a warning against treating exequatur as a universal administrative certificate.
The same care is required for the maternal link. Article 311-25 of the Civil Code states that, as regards the mother, parentage is established by designating her in the child’s birth record; the text is available at Article 311-25 of the Civil Code. That domestic rule cannot simply be used to erase the legal structure of a foreign judgment. If the foreign court has established parentage through the legal mechanisms of its own system, the French court must determine how that judgment is recognised and what effects follow. The answer may differ from the result of a purely domestic birth registration and must be tied to the foreign decision actually presented.
Parental authority, succession, name, social-security rights, residence documentation and travel documents may each require a further step or a review under the law applicable to that issue. Recognition of parentage is a strong foundation, but it is not a promise that every authority will accept an incomplete copy of the judgment. The family should obtain a consistent set of certified records and keep the French recognition decision with the foreign judgment and its translations. Where a child crosses several borders, the risk is often documentary inconsistency: one country records a parent as an intended parent, another as an adoptive parent, and a third relies on the birth certificate alone. The French ruling’s insistence on recognition “as such” helps prevent that distortion, but only if the foreign judgment’s legal character is preserved in the file.
The judgment also does not validate the underlying surrogacy arrangement for future performance in France. Article 16-7 remains in force. A person cannot rely on the 2026 decisions as permission to arrange a surrogacy contract in France or as a guarantee that a foreign judgment obtained without procedural safeguards will be accepted. The line drawn by the Plenary Assembly protects the child’s legal identity and addresses the effects of an existing foreign decision. It does not remove the domestic prohibition or make the French court a licensing authority for reproductive arrangements.
For international families, the most useful practical sequence is therefore: classify the foreign document; obtain the full reasoned judgment and proof of finality; establish the foreign court’s connection and procedure; document every person’s role and consent; translate and authenticate the exhibits; choose exequatur, transcription or another route according to the relief sought; and then file the separate civil-status or nationality applications supported by the recognition result. If the judgment is silent on the points the Cour de cassation identifies, the applicant should look for equivalent evidence before filing. If no reliable evidence exists, the risk is not that French law automatically rejects surrogacy; the risk is that the court cannot perform the safeguards the 2024 and 2026 cases require.
Conclusion
The 3 July 2026 Plenary Assembly rulings do not legalise surrogacy in France. They establish something more precise and more useful for cross-border families: the French prohibition cannot, by itself, defeat a foreign judgment that establishes parentage after surrogacy. Recognition depends on a genuine exequatur review, including international jurisdiction, procedural regularity, reasoning, consent, the roles of the participants and the child’s private-life interests. When those safeguards are demonstrated, the parentage is recognised as parentage, not silently converted into adoption.
The practical lesson is to prepare the foreign judgment as evidence, not merely as a headline. Families should separate the recognition question from later civil-status and nationality questions, and every request should be matched to the document and legal test that supports it.