KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Marriage Annulment in France for Expats: Forced Consent, Fatal Error, Bigamy — and What Survives for Children and Property

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Marriage Annulment in France for Expats: Forced Consent, Fatal Error, Bigamy — and What Survives for Children and Property

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You married in Lomé, in Tananarive, in Las Vegas, or at the mairie of the 11th arrondissement in Paris, and today you have discovered something that makes you doubt the marriage itself: a spouse who is still married to someone else, a consent given under family pressure, a past deliberately hidden until after the wedding. Divorce ends a marriage for the future. Annulment (nullité du mariage) does something more radical: it declares that, in the eyes of French law, the marriage never validly existed, and it erases its effects retroactively. That erasure is powerful, but it is fenced in by strict deadlines, a closed list of grounds, and one major safety net — the mariage putatif (putative marriage), which protects the spouse who married in good faith and always protects the children. This guide explains, entirely in English and with every French term translated at first use, which marriages a French court can erase, who is allowed to sue and within which time limit, where a binational couple files, and what survives the judgment for children, money, and property. Every decisive rule is quoted word for word from the Civil Code, from Regulation Brussels II ter, or from France’s supreme civil court, the Court of Cassation (Court of Cassation), with a link you can open and verify yourself.

I. Which Marriages a French Court Can Erase: Two Nullities, Two Clocks, and Who May Sue

French law divides defective marriages into two families, and the distinction controls everything: who can bring the case, and how long they have. Relative nullity (nullité relative) protects a private interest — the freedom of the spouse whose consent was defective — so only that spouse (and in some cases the public prosecutor) can sue, and the clock is short. Absolute nullity (nullité absolue) protects public order — the fundamental prohibitions on which marriage rests — so almost anyone with an interest, plus the ministère public (public prosecutor’s office), can sue, and the clock runs for thirty years. Identifying the right family first is therefore the whole strategy: plead the wrong one and the case dies on admissibility before the court ever examines the facts.

A. “I Did Not Freely Agree, or I Was Lied To”: Relative Nullity and Its Five-Year Clock

The foundation is a single sentence that has stood since 1804. Article 146 of the Civil Code provides: “Il n’y a pas de mariage, lorsqu’il n’y a point de consentement.” (There is no marriage where there is no consent.) Everything in relative nullity flows from that principle. Article 180 of the Civil Code gives it its modern shape: “Le mariage qui a été contracté sans le consentement libre des deux époux, ou de l’un d’eux, ne peut être attaqué que par les époux, ou par celui des deux dont le consentement n’a pas été libre, ou par le ministère public. L’exercice d’une contrainte sur les époux ou l’un d’eux, y compris par crainte révérencielle envers un ascendant, constitue un cas de nullité du mariage. S’il y a eu erreur dans la personne, ou sur des qualités essentielles de la personne, l’autre époux peut demander la nullité du mariage.” (A marriage entered into without the free consent of both spouses, or of one of them, may be challenged only by the spouses, or by the one of the two whose consent was not free, or by the public prosecutor. The exercise of constraint upon the spouses or one of them, including through reverential fear toward an ascendant, constitutes a ground for nullity of the marriage. Where there was a mistake as to the person, or as to essential qualities of the person, the other spouse may seek nullity of the marriage.) Three practical lessons sit inside that paragraph. First, pressure counts even when it wears a family face: crainte révérencielle (reverential fear — the moral pressure exerted by a parent or elder) is expressly a ground for nullity, which matters enormously for spouses pushed into a marriage by their family. Second, a lie can annul, but only a lie about an essential quality of the person — courts have accepted, depending on the file, concealment of a prior divorce, of a criminal past, of a serious illness, or of an inability to have a normal married life, while ordinary disappointments about character, fortune, or habits do not qualify. Third, the action belongs to the victim spouse (and the prosecutor); the deceiving spouse cannot sue on the basis of their own lie.

The trap is the clock, and France’s highest civil court has just made it unforgiving. Article 181 of the Civil Code provides: “Dans le cas de l’article précédent, la demande en nullité n’est plus recevable à l’issue d’un délai de cinq ans à compter du mariage.” (In the case of the preceding article, the action for nullity is no longer admissible after a period of five years from the marriage.) Five years from the wedding day — not from the discovery of the lie. On 20 May 2026 the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation applied that rule to an expatriate file in Cass. 1st civ., 20 May 2026, No. 24-22.299. A husband married in Togo on 23 September 2017 sued for nullity on 26 June 2023 for mistake as to his wife’s essential qualities, arguing that the truth had only emerged with a Lyon criminal judgment of 10 May 2023 convicting his wife of violence against him, so the clock should run from that revelation. The court answered: “Selon l’article 181 du code civil, la demande en nullité du mariage pour vice du consentement n’est plus recevable à l’issue d’un délai de cinq ans à compter du mariage.” (Under Article 181 of the Civil Code, an action for nullity of marriage for defective consent is no longer admissible after five years from the marriage.) And it added the sentence every expatriate spouse must read twice: “Il en résulte que s’il y a eu erreur sur les qualités essentielles de la personne, la date à laquelle l’époux a reconnu l’erreur est sans incidence sur le point de départ du délai de prescription.” (It follows that where there was a mistake as to the essential qualities of the person, the date on which the spouse recognized the mistake has no bearing on the starting point of the limitation period.) Married in September 2017, suit in June 2023: the action was time-barred (prescrite), nearly six years after the wedding, even though the criminal conviction proving the point dated from the previous month. The lesson is brutal and practical: if you suspect a forced consent or a concealed essential quality, have the file assessed immediately, because each month that passes consumes an irrecoverable deadline, and a parallel criminal case suspends nothing.

One related shield deserves a mention here because binational families meet it in emergencies. The family judge (juge aux affaires familiales, the dedicated family judge within the civil court, commonly shortened to JAF) is expressly competent for “la protection de la personne majeure menacée de mariage forcé” — the protection of an adult threatened with a forced marriage — under Article L213-3 of the Code of Judicial Organization. So where a forced marriage is being prepared rather than already celebrated, fast protective proceedings before the family judge exist alongside, and before, any later nullity action. Readers facing threats or violence right now will find the procedural emergency routes in our companion guide to the protection order against a violent partner in France.

B. “This Marriage Should Never Have Existed”: Absolute Nullity and Its Thirty-Year Clock

Absolute nullity polices the prohibitions no private agreement can waive. The list is short and each item maps to a real expatriate scenario. Article 144 of the Civil Code provides: “Le mariage ne peut être contracté avant dix-huit ans révolus.” (Marriage may not be entered into before the age of eighteen.) A marriage celebrated abroad involving a minor, valid perhaps under local law, can therefore be attacked in France. Article 147 of the Civil Code provides: “On ne peut contracter un second mariage avant la dissolution du premier.” (No second marriage may be entered into before the dissolution of the first.) Bigamy is the classic expatriate trap: a first marriage in Madagascar, Mali, Algeria, or elsewhere, never properly dissolved, followed by a second wedding in France or before a French consulate. Article 146-1 of the Civil Code adds a formality that surprises many couples married abroad: “Le mariage d’un Français, même contracté à l’étranger, requiert sa présence.” (The marriage of a French national, even entered into abroad, requires their presence.) A proxy or video-link wedding valid under some foreign laws fails this test when one spouse is French. Incest prohibitions (Articles 161 to 163) and the absence of any consent at all (Article 146) complete the catalogue. One modern clarification helps binational same-sex couples: Article 143 of the Civil Code provides: “Le mariage est contracté par deux personnes de sexe différent ou de même sexe.” (Marriage is entered into by two persons of different sex or of the same sex.) A same-sex marriage validly celebrated abroad is not attackable on that ground in France.

The regime for these cases is deliberately open. Article 184 of the Civil Code provides: “Tout mariage contracté en contravention aux dispositions contenues aux articles 144 , 146, 146-1 , 147 , 161 , 162 et 163 peut être attaqué, dans un délai de trente ans à compter de sa célébration, soit par les époux eux-mêmes, soit par tous ceux qui y ont intérêt, soit par le ministère public.” (Any marriage entered into in breach of the provisions of Articles 144, 146, 146-1, 147, 161, 162 and 163 may be challenged, within thirty years from its celebration, either by the spouses themselves, or by anyone with an interest therein, or by the public prosecutor.) Thirty years instead of five, and standing for the first wife or husband, the children of the first bed, creditors, and the prosecutor — because bigamy and child marriage offend public order, not just one spouse. Within bigamy, the first spouse holds a personal weapon: Article 188 of the Civil Code provides: “L’époux au préjudice duquel a été contracté un second mariage peut en demander la nullité, du vivant même de l’époux qui était engagé avec lui.” (The spouse to whose prejudice a second marriage was entered into may seek its nullity, during the very lifetime of the spouse who was bound to them.) You do not have to wait for anyone’s death to attack the second union.

Bigamy files often produce a procedural knot — two marriages, each side attacking the other — and the Court of Cassation has given the solution. In Cass. 1st civ., 11 April 2018, No. 17-17.530, a French man had married a Malagasy woman in Tananarive (Antananarivo), a union transcribed onto French civil-status records by the French consulate on 15 February 2012. The Nantes prosecutor sued to annul that marriage for bigamy, pointing to an earlier undissolved marriage in Maroantsera (Madagascar). The husband asked the court to stay (sursis à statuer) while his own action to annul the first marriage ran its course; the appeal court refused, calling that outcome speculative and noting the bailiff’s return marked “adresse vague et inconnue” (vague and unknown address). The Court of Cassation quashed, visa on Article 189 of the Civil Code: “Vu l’article 189 du code civil” (In view of Article 189 of the Civil Code), because “si les nouveaux époux opposent la nullité du premier mariage, la validité ou la nullité de ce mariage doit être jugée préalablement” (where the new spouses plead the nullity of the first marriage, the validity or nullity of that marriage must first be adjudicated). In plain terms: a court cannot annul your second marriage for bigamy while your challenge to the first marriage is still pending — the first marriage must be judged first. For expatriates with layered marital histories across two continents, the order of battle matters as much as the merits: attack the first union before defending the second.

II. Suing in France and Living With the Judgment: Courts, European Jurisdiction, Children, and Property

Winning on the ground is half the file; the other half is procedure and aftermath. Annulment follows its own court track, distinct from divorce; for binational couples a European regulation decides which country’s court may hear the case; and the judgment’s retroactive erasure stops where the law protects the good-faith spouse and, always, the children. This part maps that second half step by step, so you know where to file, what the prosecutor does in your case, and what concretely remains standing after the court declares the marriage void.

A. Where to File, Who Defends the Marriage, and Which Country Decides for Binational Couples

The nullity action is brought before the tribunal judiciaire (the ordinary civil court with general jurisdiction), and representation by an avocat (attorney admitted to represent parties in court) is mandatory, not optional. Article 760 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides: “Les parties sont, sauf disposition contraire, tenues de constituer avocat devant le tribunal judiciaire. La constitution de l’avocat emporte élection de domicile.” (The parties are, unless otherwise provided, required to appoint an attorney before the tribunal judiciaire. The appointment of the attorney implies election of domicile.) In Paris that means the tribunal judiciaire de Paris; elsewhere, the court of the place where the defendant lives or, in some configurations, where the marriage was celebrated — your avocat settles venue (compétence territoriale) at the first appointment, because a filing before the wrong court wastes months. Do not confuse this track with divorce: the family judge’s statutory list covers divorce, legal separation, their consequences, parental authority, support, and protection against forced marriage, as Article L213-3 of the Code of Judicial Organization details — the nullity action itself follows the ordinary civil track with its mandatory attorney, while the judge then rules on the children’s arrangements “comme en matière de divorce” (as in divorce cases), as will be seen below.

Expect a third party in the proceedings: the prosecutor. In absolute-nullity cases the procureur de la République (Republic’s prosecutor) can initiate the case alone — the 2018 Malagasy bigamy file above was brought by the Nantes prosecutor — and in relative-nullity cases Article 180 gives the ministère public standing alongside the spouses. The prosecutor also receives notice and may intervene to defend public order, for example where a marriage looks like a mariage gris (a sham or exploitative marriage used to obtain residence or nationality) or, conversely, where annulment is sought abusively to destroy residence rights derived from the marriage. That last point carries a warning for foreign spouses: a marriage-based residence permit (titre de séjour) can be re-examined when the underlying marriage is judicially erased, so coordinate the family case with your immigration position from day one rather than discovering the interaction after judgment.

For couples spread across borders, Europe answers the “which country” question before France answers anything else. Article 3 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1111 of 25 June 2019 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of decisions in matrimonial matters (Brussels II ter) gives the courts of a Member State jurisdiction over marriage annulment on several alternative bases: the spouses shared habitual residence, their last shared habitual residence where one of them still lives, the respondent habitual residence, a joint application filed where either spouse lives, or the applicant own habitual residence subject to a prior-residence period that is shorter where the applicant holds that State nationality, as well as the shared nationality of both spouses. In practice: two spouses living in Paris sue in France; a British spouse who stayed in Lyon after the couple last shared home there can sue in France while the other lives in London; and two French nationals living abroad can sue in France on their joint nationality. Note the asymmetry that traps the unwary: the short residence period suffices only for an applicant who is a French national, while a foreign applicant needs a full year of prior residence — check the correct basis before filing. Once the French court gives judgment, the decision is sent for transcription in the margin of the civil-status records (mention en marge des actes d’état civil), so that birth and marriage certificates issued afterwards reflect the nullity; the Court of Cassation models this itself by ordering, in its 11 April 2018 bigamy decision, that “le présent arrêt sera transmis pour être transcrit en marge ou à la suite de l’arrêt cassé” (this judgment shall be transmitted to be transcribed in the margin of or following the quashed judgment). Ask your avocat to verify the marginal entry a few weeks after the judgment becomes final, because prefectures, consulates, and notaires all read those margins.

B. What the Erasure Spares: the Good-Faith Spouse, Always the Children, and the Property Unwind

Here French law shows its humanity: the marriage is erased, but not against everyone. The mechanism is the putative marriage. Article 201 of the Civil Code provides: “Le mariage qui a été déclaré nul produit, néanmoins, ses effets à l’égard des époux, lorsqu’il a été contracté de bonne foi. Si la bonne foi n’existe que de la part de l’un des époux, le mariage ne produit ses effets qu’en faveur de cet époux.” (A marriage declared void nevertheless produces its effects as between the spouses, where it was entered into in good faith. Where good faith exists on the part of only one of the spouses, the marriage produces its effects only in favour of that spouse.) Good faith (bonne foi) means marrying honestly, unaware of the defect: the wife who believed her husband divorced, the husband who did not know his bride was still a minor under French law, the spouse who never suspected the first undissolved union. Where both spouses knew — two adults staging a convenience marriage, for instance — neither keeps any marital effect, and the erasure is total between them. Where only one knew, the effects survive solely for the innocent one: inheritance rights against the other’s estate, the matrimonial property regime’s advantages, and claims built on married life remain available to the good-faith spouse while the bad-faith spouse keeps nothing.

The Court of Cassation polices this protection strictly, and its most recent lesson concerns what a spouse actually knew — not what the other spouse knew. In Cass. 1st civ., 10 December 2025, No. 22-20.184, a woman had married a man in 2002 who had always presented himself as divorced. In reality he had been told back in August 1997 by the notaire handling his parents’ succession that he was merely separated as to bed and board (séparé de corps — a court-ordered separation that relaxes cohabitation but does not dissolve the marriage, unlike divorce), and a former mayor had even received him to explain that the wedding could not be celebrated because he was not divorced from his first wife. The appeal court refused the wife any putative effect. The Court of Cassation quashed, recalling that “le mariage qui a été déclaré nul produit néanmoins ses effets à l’égard de celui des époux qui a contracté de bonne foi” (a marriage declared void nevertheless produces its effects for the spouse who entered into it in good faith), because the lower court’s reasons — all describing what the husband had been told — were “impropres à caractériser” (incapable of establishing) that those warnings had ever reached the wife before the wedding. The rule for your file: good faith is assessed personally, spouse by spouse, at the date of celebration. Gather every contemporaneous proof of your own ignorance — messages where he claimed to be divorced, the wedding file as presented to the mairie or consulate, testimony from relatives present at the preparations — because the court will not impute to you what only the other side was told.

Children are protected unconditionally, and this is the point to carry to any worried parent. Article 202 of the Civil Code provides: “Il produit aussi ses effets à l’égard des enfants, quand bien même aucun des époux n’aurait été de bonne foi. Le juge statue sur les modalités de l’exercice de l’autorité parentale comme en matière de divorce.” (It also produces its effects for the children, even where neither spouse was in good faith. The judge rules on the terms of exercise of parental authority as in divorce matters.) Legitimacy, filiation, maintenance, and residence are untouched by the nullity: the judge fixes autorité parentale (parental authority — the bundle of rights and duties over the child’s person and property), the child’s habitual residence, visitation and contact schedules, and the pension alimentaire (periodic child-support payment) exactly as after a divorce. An annulment therefore never renders a child “illegitimate” and never relieves a parent of support — arguments sometimes brandished in negotiations have no legal basis.

Property follows the same logic of protected reliance. Where the marriage is declared putative for one or both spouses, the matrimonial property regime — community, separation, or tailored contract — produces its effects and the liquidation (liquidation du régime matrimonial, the accounting that values each spouse’s claims before dividing) proceeds as if the marriage had been valid, which is why keeping the marriage contract (contrat de mariage), bank statements, and proof of each asset’s origin matters from the first meeting with your avocat. Readers who signed a French marriage contract before the wedding should revisit its clauses now, with our guide to the French marriage contract and prenup options for expats at hand, because a separation-of-property clause and a community clause produce very different liquidations once the court rules. Where neither spouse acted in good faith, the marriage produces no effect between them: each in principle recovers their own, and the shared assets must be disentangled without the regime’s help — a far messier and costlier unwind. And where the five-year clock of Article 181 has already run out, remember that divorce remains fully available on its own grounds, with its own financial orders; compare the two routes in our walkthrough of contested divorce in France for expats before choosing. The strategic question is never “annulment or nothing” — it is “annulment, divorce, or both in sequence,” answered with deadlines in hand.

Conclusion

Annulment in France is a scalpel, not a second divorce: relative nullity erases a marriage whose consent was forced or extracted by a lie about an essential quality, but only within five years of the wedding day — the date you discovered the truth changes nothing, as the Court of Cassation confirmed in May 2026. Absolute nullity erases marriages that violated public order — minority, bigamy, incest, the absent French spouse — at almost anyone’s suit for thirty years, with bigamy files resolved in a strict order: the first marriage first. The case runs before the tribunal judiciaire with a mandatory avocat, the prosecutor watching over public order, and European jurisdiction rules deciding whether France may hear a binational file at all. And the erasure stops where reliance was honest: the good-faith spouse keeps the marriage’s effects, the children always do, and the judge organizes parental authority and support as after a divorce. If any of these patterns matches your marriage — pressure from family, a hidden divorce or criminal past, a spouse who may still be married elsewhere — have the file, the wedding certificate, and the timeline assessed now: in nullity, the calendar is the case.

📄 Official circular