KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Moscow Seizes French Factories: Can a French Group Sue Russia and Get Paid in Paris?

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Moscow Seizes French Factories: Can a French Group Sue Russia and Get Paid in Paris?

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 16 October 2026, the Kremlin added five new names to the list of European businesses placed under compulsory administration in Russia. Among them is a French flooring group with two plants in Russia, alongside an Irish paper-packaging business, a Belgian hygiene-products maker, a German plastics producer and an American metal-packaging company. Their combined Russian revenue exceeds 50 billion roubles, roughly 532 million euros, according to Euronews, which reported the decree on 16 October 2026. The Russian assets were handed to an interim management company registered only in February 2026.

This is not an isolated gesture. A month earlier, the same mechanism struck a Swiss food giant, a German hypermarket chain, a French retailer, a French home-improvement chain and a French packaging holding, whose assets were transferred to another recently created vehicle. The first targets, back in 2023, were a Danish brewer and a French dairy group. Each wave follows the same script: a presidential decree, an interim administrator, and a Western parent company that keeps legal title while losing every practical power over its subsidiary.

The timing matters. While Moscow seizes European factories, Washington is floating the opposite move: the United States has proposed that European countries unfreeze part of Russia’s sovereign assets and channel them into an entity funding Ukraine’s reconstruction, as Reuters reported on 15 October 2026, and Germany’s chancellor answered that frozen Russian assets must stay in Europe. Five days earlier, the Council of the European Union adopted its largest-ever listings package, 1,569 individuals and entities, including 826 Russian companies and 743 of their chief executives, bringing total Ukraine-related listings close to 4,600. Seizure and freeze now mirror each other across the continent.

For a French group with plants, staff and bank accounts in Russia, the questions are brutally practical. Was the 16 October decree lawful, and what does interim administration change on the ground? What does France freeze in return, and who in Paris must apply the freeze? Where can a French investor sue Russia, and what can it realistically recover in a French court if it wins? This analysis answers each question from French and European texts, with the official sources quoted word for word.

I. Moscow seizes, Brussels freezes: what the 16 October decree changes for a French group

A. Is the seizure of French subsidiaries lawful, and what does interim administration mean in practice?

The mechanism dates to a Russian presidential decree signed in April 2023, which authorised temporary administration over certain Russian assets of foreign companies. The first companies caught were a Danish brewer and a French dairy group. The September 2026 wave extended it to a Swiss food group, a German hypermarket chain, a French retailer, a French home-improvement chain and a French packaging holding. The 16 October 2026 decree continues the series with five more European groups, including the French flooring maker that operates two of its thirty-four worldwide plants in Russia and kept paying Russian taxes, as its 2024 annual report records.

Temporary administration is not, on paper, a transfer of ownership. The shares remain registered in the parent’s name while an outside manager takes control of the subsidiary: it appoints management, controls cash, signs contracts and decides production. For the French parent, the distinction is theoretical. Dividends stop, reporting lines break, auditors qualify the accounts, and every strategic decision is taken by someone the shareholder did not choose. Economists call this creeping expropriation. Lawyers ask a narrower question: does the measure breach the investment treaty France concluded for exactly this situation?

That treaty is the accord between France and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics on the encouragement and reciprocal protection of investments, signed in Paris on 4 July 1989 and published in France by decree number 91-1062 of 14 October 1991, published on Légifrance. It is the instrument French investors invoke when Moscow takes their assets, as the international press itself notes when it describes compensation claims under bilateral investment treaties concluded with EU member states. Its article 3 states the general standard of treatment in these terms: Article 3 commits each contracting party to secure, on its territory and in its maritime zone, fair and equitable treatment in line with the principles of international law for investments made by investors of the other party, ruling out any unjust or discriminatory step capable of hindering the management, maintenance, enjoyment or liquidation of those investments.

Fair and equitable treatment, non-discrimination and free enjoyment of the investment are therefore the yardsticks. A decree that removes the shareholder’s control while leaving title in place, that targets groups from so-called unfriendly states, and that installs managers with no link to the business, is tested precisely against that language: unjust or discriminatory measures hindering management, maintenance, enjoyment or liquidation of the investment.

The treaty’s expropriation clause is even more direct. Article 4 provides: Article 4 bars the parties from taking, on their territory and in their maritime zone, expropriation or nationalisation measures, or any other measures whose effect is to strip the other party’s investors of their investments, except for a public purpose and provided the measures are neither discriminatory nor contrary to a commitment given to an investor of the kind mentioned in article 8. Three cumulative conditions appear: public purpose, non-discrimination, and respect for specific commitments given to the investor. A retaliatory seizure waved through days before a European summit, aimed at companies of designated states, struggles with at least two of them.

Where a dispossession measure is taken, the treaty fixes the compensation rule itself: Any dispossession measure taken must trigger prompt and adequate compensation matching the real value of the investments concerned on the eve of the day the measures are taken or become publicly known. Prompt and adequate compensation, measured at the real value on the eve of the measure or of its public announcement, freely transferable, paid without delay in convertible currency, and bearing interest at the appropriate rate from thirty days after the measure. That valuation date matters enormously for the October 2026 wave: the rouble value of two flooring plants, a packaging business or a retail network is assessed before the decree destroyed it, not after.

None of this means the treaty decides the politics. Moscow reads its 2023 decree as a sovereign response to Western freezes; Paris and Brussels read the seizures as unlawful expropriation. Only an arbitral tribunal applying the treaty can settle that dispute, which is why the second half of this analysis turns to procedure. Before that, the mirror image deserves equal attention, because French companies and banks live under it every day.

B. How does France freeze Russian assets in return, from Brussels listings to Paris compliance?

While Moscow administers European factories, Paris immobilises Russian money. The legal chain starts in Brussels. European restrictive measures are adopted on the basis of articles 75 and 215 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, and the regulations that list names, freeze funds and ban making resources available apply directly in France. No French statute is needed to make a Council listing binding on a Paris bank; the regulation itself does the work. The 12 October 2026 package shows the scale: 826 listed companies plus 743 chief executives in a single day, on top of a stock approaching 4,600 listings, each one freezing every euro held in the Union and banning any funds from being made available to the listed person.

French domestic law organises who applies the freeze and how. The centrepiece for practitioners is article L. 562-4-1 of the monetary and financial code, which obliges the persons subject to anti-money-laundering duties to build the machinery of compliance: “Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 561-2 mettent en place une organisation et des procédures internes pour la mise en œuvre des mesures de gel des avoirs et d’interdiction de mise à disposition ou d’utilisation des fonds ou ressources économiques prévues au présent chapitre, aux articles L. 712-4 et L. 712-10 et par les règlements européens portant mesures restrictives pris en application des articles 75 ou 215 du traité sur le fonctionnement de l’Union européenne, ainsi que l’interdiction de contournement de ces mesures.” Banks, insurers, payment institutions and very many non-financial businesses must therefore run screening procedures, apply freezes in their French branches and subsidiaries abroad, and police circumvention, with the parent company of a French group required to define the organisation at group level. The full text is on Légifrance, article L. 562-4-1 of the monetary and financial code, in force since 26 February 2022.

Alongside European measures, the French State keeps national freeze powers. Article L. 562-2 allows the economy and interior ministers to freeze, jointly, for six months renewable, funds linked to terrorism, and its text is published on Légifrance. Article L. 562-3 gives the economy minister a parallel six-month renewable power for funds linked to activities sanctioned or prohibited by United Nations resolutions, and its text is published on Légifrance. The general definitions sit in article L. 562-1 of the same code. For a French group, the practical consequence is a double exposure: its Russian subsidiary is administered in Moscow while its Paris treasury must screen every payment, freeze any listed counterparty and document its procedures, because a missed listing is both a regulatory breach and a criminal risk.

This mirror explains the American proposal and the German answer. Washington suggests unfreezing part of Russia’s sovereign assets parked in Europe, notably at the Brussels clearing house, to fund reconstruction and restart talks. Berlin replies that the assets must stay in Europe as leverage. Paris, which hosts some of the frozen funds in its own banks and applies the same regulations, sits between the two: bound by European law to keep the freeze, exposed to Russian retaliation against its companies, and asked by its ally to release what its own courts may one day be asked to attribute. Readers following the American angle of the sanctions story can also read our companion analysis of what Washington’s pause of Russia sanctions changes for French companies.

The symmetry is imperfect, and the difference matters for litigation. European freezes immobilise assets without transferring title; the listed owner remains owner and can challenge the listing before the EU General Court in Luxembourg. Russian interim administration keeps title too but hands the business to a stranger, with challenge routes that foreign investors distrust. That asymmetry pushes French groups toward the one forum both sides accepted in advance: investment arbitration under the 1989 treaty.

II. How a French group sues Russia and turns a win into money collected in France

A. Where does a French investor sue a state that seizes its factory?

The answer is written in article 7 of the 1989 accord. Any dispute between one contracting party and an investor of the other, concerning the effects of a measure taken by the first and relating to the management, maintenance, enjoyment or liquidation of an investment, including transport and sale of goods, dispossession or the transfers protected by article 5, must first be settled amicably as far as possible. Then comes the time limit that every counsel diaries first: If such a dispute cannot be settled amicably within six months of being raised by either disputing party, it may be submitted to arbitration in writing. Six months from written notice, the investor may file for arbitration. The provision continues: The dispute is then settled finally under the arbitration rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law as adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in its resolution 31/98 of 15 December 1976. Final settlement under the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules as adopted in 1976. The treaty text is published at Légifrance, decree 91-1062 of 14 October 1991.

Three features make this clause attractive to the October 2026 targets. First, consent is already given: no need to negotiate a compromise after the seizure, the state accepted arbitration in the treaty itself. Second, the tribunal is ad hoc under UNCITRAL Rules, not an institution seated in either capital, which sidesteps the legitimacy objections both sides raise against each other’s courts. Third, the protected transfers in article 5 cover investment income, loan repayments, sale and liquidation proceeds and the compensation owed under article 4, so the claim can combine the value of the seized plants, lost profits and blocked transfers in a single case.

The treaty also answers the subrogation question that worries insurers and state-backed guarantors. Its article 6 allows a contracting party that runs a guarantee scheme against non-commercial risks to extend it case by case to investments in the other party, and provides that a party which pays under such a guarantee is thereby subrogated to the rights and claims of that investor, particularly those defined in article 7. A French public guarantee that compensates the flooring maker or the retailer is subrogated into the arbitration claim and can pursue Moscow in the investor’s shoes.

Filing is only half the battle. Russia routinely refuses to appear in investment cases brought by investors from states it calls unfriendly, and a default award still requires proof of jurisdiction, breach and quantum. Counsel must establish the French nationality of the investor through the corporate chain, date the investment before the dispute crystallised, document the decree and the administrator’s acts, value the business the day before the measure, and quantify the transfers blocked since. Tribunals have handled such files before, from energy majors to mid-size manufacturers, and the 1989 treaty’s valuation language gives them the method. The harder question is the next one: once the award is signed, where is the money?

B. The award is signed: what can actually be seized in France if Moscow refuses to pay?

An UNCITRAL award against a state is enforced in France like any foreign arbitral award, through exequatur before the Paris judicial court, with appeal to the Paris court of appeal. The governing text is article 1514 of the code of civil procedure: “Les sentences arbitrales sont reconnues ou exécutées en France si leur existence est établie par celui qui s’en prévaut et si cette reconnaissance ou cette exécution n’est pas manifestement contraire à l’ordre public international.” Existence plus compatibility with international public policy: that is the whole test, and the article is published on Légifrance. The Cour de cassation confirmed the breadth of the regime on 13 January 2021, in a case about an award rendered in Egypt: “les dispositions des articles 1514 et suivants du code de procédure civile sur la reconnaissance et l’exécution des sentences arbitrales sont applicables à la fois aux sentences arbitrales internationales et aux sentences rendues à l’étranger, quel que soit, pour ces dernières, leur caractère interne ou international”, Cour de cassation, first civil chamber, 13 January 2021, number 19-22.932. An investment award rendered by an ad hoc tribunal seated abroad enters France through the same door.

Russia’s predictable defence is annulment-style resistance at the enforcement stage, invoking international public policy: sanctions circumvention, illegality of the investment, corruption in the underlying contracts. French courts know the script. On 23 March 2022 the Cour de cassation restated the judge’s office in these terms: “Il résulte de l’article 1520, 5°, du code de procédure civile que le juge de l’annulation doit rechercher si la reconnaissance ou l’exécution de la sentence est compatible avec l’ordre public international.” The annulment action itself “n’est ouvert que si”, in the words of article 1520 of the code of civil procedure, one of five closed grounds is met, from lack of jurisdiction to breach of due process and contrariety to international public policy. In the 2022 case, which concerned a bank taken over in Central Asia and allegations of money laundering, the Court approved judges who verify compatibility with international public policy, recalling that the prohibition of laundering belongs to the principles “dont l’ordre juridique français ne saurait souffrir la violation, même dans un contexte international”, Cour de cassation, first civil chamber, 23 March 2022, number 17-17.981. For a French award-creditor, the lesson is symmetrical: keep the file clean, because the public-policy door swings both ways.

Winning exequatur does not yet fill the bank account. Enforcement against a foreign state meets immunity from execution, codified in France after the great Argentine-debt battles. The key provision is article L. 111-1-3 of the code of civil enforcement procedures: “Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur les biens, y compris les comptes bancaires, utilisés ou destinés à être utilisés dans l’exercice des fonctions de la mission diplomatique des Etats étrangers ou de leurs postes consulaires, de leurs missions spéciales ou de leurs missions auprès des organisations internationales qu’en cas de renonciation expresse et spéciale des Etats concernés.” The text is on Légifrance, article L. 111-1-3. On 13 March 2024 the Cour de cassation gave that article its strictest reading: “doivent être interprétées strictement les dispositions de l’article L. 111-1-3 du code des procédures civiles d’exécution, selon lesquelles les biens, y compris les comptes bancaires, utilisés ou destinés à être utilisés dans l’exercice des fonctions de la mission diplomatique des Etats étrangers ou de leurs postes consulaires, de leurs missions spéciales ou de leurs missions auprès des organisations internationales ne peuvent faire l’objet de mesures conservatoires ou de mesures d’exécution forcée qu’en cas de renonciation expresse et spéciale des Etats concernés”, adding that an express waiver of immunity from execution suffices for ordinary state property without any additional special waiver, Cour de cassation, first civil chamber, 13 March 2024, number 21-17.599. Embassy accounts and mission aircraft are therefore out of reach; commercial assets used for non-sovereign purposes are the realistic targets, provided the creditor proves their allocation.

That is where optimism meets arithmetic. Russian commercial property in France available for seizure has shrunk after successive freeze waves, competing creditors queue with their own awards, and every attempted attachment triggers immunity litigation that lasts years. The press summarises the enforcement odds bluntly: companies whose assets are seized can in principle claim compensation through investment arbitration, while turning such rulings into money actually collected from the Kremlin and its entities is, in practice, close to impossible, as Euronews wrote on 16 October 2026. Practitioners respond with the standard toolkit: attach debts owed by French counterparties to Russian state entities, intercept receivables, target aircraft and ships outside diplomatic use, assign the award to a funder that can wait, and negotiate a discounted settlement once the award exists, because a final award changes the price of every discussion, including with insurers and with the French State if a guarantee was paid.

One final French peculiarity deserves a warning. A group that rushes to move funds, restructure ownership or sell the Russian subsidiary at any price to beat the administrator may breach the very European freeze and anti-circumvention rules its Paris compliance department administers under article L. 562-4-1. Selling to a listed buyer, routing payments through intermediaries to dodge a freeze, or hiding the ultimate beneficiary exposes directors to the criminal sanctions attached to restrictive measures. Defence against Moscow must never become an offence in Paris: every step, from the six-month treaty notice to the attachment of a Paris account, is taken with counsel checking both ends of the mirror.

Conclusion

The 16 October 2026 decree confirms that no European group still operating in Russia is safe from interim administration, and French industry is on the front line, from flooring plants to retail networks. The legal answer available in Paris is methodical rather than miraculous: test the seizure against the fair-treatment and expropriation clauses of the 1989 Franco-Soviet investment accord, notify the dispute and use the six-month window to prepare an UNCITRAL claim, value the loss the day before the decree, obtain exequatur under article 1514, survive the public-policy defences of article 1520, and enforce only against non-sovereign assets within the strict immunity limits restated by the Cour de cassation in 2024. European freezes will not be lifted by Paris alone, Washington’s unfreeze trial balloons do not change the regulations applicable in France, and Moscow’s administrators do not negotiate the price of return. In this frozen conflict of assets, the French investor that documents early, notifies on time and enforces where the law allows keeps the strongest hand for the settlement that eventually comes.

📄 Official circular