KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Should Your American Family Buy That French Home Through an SCI? Shares, Taxes, and What Happens When Someone Dies

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Should Your American Family Buy That French Home Through an SCI? Shares, Taxes, and What Happens When Someone Dies

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American family falling in love with a stone house in the Dordogne, an apartment in Paris, or a villa near Aix-en-Provence, and the French notaire (the neutral public officer who handles every French real estate closing) asks a question no American title company ever asks: do you want to buy this home through an SCI? An SCI, short for société civile immobilière, is a French non-trading property company whose only job is to own and manage real estate. Instead of your names appearing directly on the deed, the SCI owns the house and each family member owns shares, called parts sociales, in the company. For Americans buying together across generations, that single choice reshapes who decides what, who pays which tax, what happens when a parent dies, and how the United States taxes the whole arrangement. This guide walks through the full picture in plain English: how your family creates the company, how control really works, what the French tax bills look like, and what happens to the shares at death, divorce, or departure.

Why this matters now is simple. American buyers often purchase as a couple, with adult children contributing, or with one spouse American and the other French. Direct joint ownership under France’s default rules can freeze decision-making, force a sale among heirs, or expose the survivor to claims from children of a prior marriage. An SCI does not erase French forced heirship (the réserve héréditaire, the share of the estate the law reserves for children) or French taxes, but it moves many fights from the house itself to the company’s shares, where written bylaws, called statuts, can organize voting, entry of new members, and buyouts in advance. Used well, it keeps a vacation home shared peacefully for decades. Used carelessly, it creates annual filings, Franco-American tax mismatches, and bitter deadlock between relatives who assumed a handshake was enough.

I. How an SCI Works When Americans Buy a French Home Together

A. What an SCI Is and How Your Family Creates One Before the Purchase

Start with the legal building block. French law defines the basic company contract this way: “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” In English: a company is formed by two or more people who agree to pool property or effort toward a shared benefit or shared savings. The full text is stated in Article 1832 of the Civil Code. An SCI is simply the civil, non-commercial version of that idea: the statute book confirms that “Les dispositions du présent chapitre sont applicables à toutes les sociétés civiles, à moins qu’il n’y soit dérogé par le statut légal particulier auquel certaines d’entre elles sont assujetties” meaning the general civil-company rules apply to every civil company unless a special statute says otherwise, per Article 1845 of the Civil Code. In practice, that means your family signs tailored statuts, contributes cash that funds the purchase, receives parts sociales in proportion to each contribution, registers the company, and then the company itself signs the deed, called the acte authentique, before the notaire.

Two people minimum are required, which fits most American family projects: spouses, siblings, parents and adult children, or unmarried partners. A single-member SCI does not exist in the way a single-member American LLC does, so a solo buyer cannot use this vehicle alone and must either buy directly or bring in a second member. Contributions are usually cash wired before closing, but a parent can also contribute an existing French property into the company, which triggers its own transfer taxes and valuation issues and should be modeled before anyone signs. The statuts must name the company, state its purpose (acquisition, ownership, and management of real estate), fix its duration, describe each contribution, allocate the shares, organize management, and set the rules for admitting newcomers and valuing departing members. Precision here pays for decades because courts enforce what the family actually wrote, not what relatives remember discussing at the kitchen table.

Formation follows a fixed sequence that American buyers should calendar like a closing checklist. First, the family finalizes the statuts in writing and appoints the initial manager, called the gérant, who will sign for the company. French law provides that “La société est gérée par une ou plusieurs personnes, associées ou non, nommées soit par les statuts, soit par un acte distinct, soit par une décision des associés” which means the company is managed by one or more managers, whether members or not, appointed by the bylaws, a separate document, or a member vote, under Article 1846 of the Civil Code. Second, the company deposits its capital in a French bank, publishes a formation notice in an authorized legal journal, and files for registration with the companies register, after which it receives its SIREN number and can open its own bank account, sign the preliminary contract, and appear at closing. The official business-formation portal explains each filing for civil companies on service-public.fr, and your notaire coordinates the timing so the freshly registered SCI exists on the day the deed is signed. Families wiring dollars should lock the exchange rate, document each wire as that person’s capital contribution, and keep the paper trail because the United States will later ask who funded what.

Costs at creation are modest compared with the purchase price but real: legal drafting of serious statuts, publication fees, registration fees, and the notaire’s transfer taxes and fees on the property acquisition itself, which run roughly seven to eight percent of the price for older homes. An SCI does not reduce those acquisition taxes. What it buys is governance: parents can hold a majority of shares while giving children minority stakes, a couple can give each spouse blocking rights, and unrelated co-buyers can weight votes by money invested. One warning for mixed-nationality couples: the marital property regime still matters. An American married under a U.S. community-property or separate-property agreement who contributes joint funds to a French SCI should have the notaire record the source of funds and the regime characterization in the file, because divorce courts later trace whether the shares are community property, separate property, or partly reimbursable. Our detailed guide on how American marriages interact with French deeds, Can One Spouse Sell a French Home Bought by an American Couple?, explains why that paper trail decides later fights.

Practical tip before you commit: model three scenarios with your advisers on one page. Scenario one, direct ownership in both spouses’ names. Scenario two, SCI with parents holding most shares. Scenario three, SCI with shares split across two generations. For each, write down who can sell, who can borrow against the house, what happens if one member dies, and what the U.S. tax classification looks like. Many American families pick the SCI only after seeing that direct ownership would force unanimous heir agreement for every future decision, while the SCI concentrates daily power in the gérant and reserves big decisions for a defined majority. The rest of this guide gives you the rules to fill in that one-page comparison correctly.

B. Shares, Votes, and Who Controls the House Day to Day

Inside an SCI, the house belongs to the company and the family members own claims on the company. That separation is the whole point. The gérant handles daily business: paying the property tax, hiring the roofer, collecting rent from a tenant or seasonal guest, filing the company’s declarations, and representing the SCI before the bank. Major acts such as selling the house, borrowing a large sum, or admitting a stranger as a member require a member vote under the statuts or, where the statuts are silent, unanimity, because “Les décisions qui excèdent les pouvoirs reconnus aux gérants sont prises selon les dispositions statutaires ou, en l’absence de telles dispositions, à l’unanimité des associés” meaning decisions beyond the manager’s powers follow the bylaws or unanimity by default, per Article 1852 of the Civil Code. Families who leave the statuts vague therefore hand every disgruntled minority member a veto over a future sale, which is exactly how vacation homes become unsellable for a decade.

Choose the gérant carefully and write the removal rule before anyone is angry. The default statute says: “Sauf disposition contraire des statuts le gérant est révocable par une décision des associés représentant plus de la moitié des parts sociales. Si la révocation est décidée sans juste motif, elle peut donner lieu à dommages-intérêts.” It adds the judicial backstop: “Le gérant est également révocable par les tribunaux pour cause légitime, à la demande de tout associé.” In English, the manager can be removed by holders of more than half the shares unless the bylaws say otherwise, removal without just cause can trigger damages, and any member can also ask a court to remove the manager for legitimate cause. See Article 1851 of the Civil Code. The courts apply that last sentence seriously. In a leading decision, the Court of Cassation held that “le gérant d’une société civile est révocable par les tribunaux pour cause légitime, à la demande de tout associé” meaning a civil-company manager can be removed by the courts for legitimate cause at any member’s request, and it quashed an appeal ruling that had demanded proof of especially grave intentional misconduct. See Cass. 3rd civ., March 12, 2014, No. 13-14.374. For an American family, the lesson is concrete: document management carefully, keep bank statements clean, and do not assume the founding parent-manager is irremovable when children who own shares lose confidence.

Selling or giving away shares is deliberately harder than selling a house. The default rule states: “Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées qu’avec l’agrément de tous les associés” which means shares can be transferred only with every member’s approval, under Article 1861 of the Civil Code. The statuts may relax that to a majority, let the gérant approve, or waive approval for transfers to existing members, spouses, or lineal relatives, and most family SCIs waive approval for gifts to children while keeping approval for sales to outsiders. Every proposed transfer must still be formally notified to the company and each member with a request for approval. When approval is refused, the law organizes a buyout rather than trapping the seller forever, and valuation fights go to an independent expert: “la valeur de ces droits est déterminée, en cas de contestation, par un expert désigné, soit par les parties, soit à défaut d’accord entre elles, par jugement du président du tribunal judiciaire ou du tribunal de commerce compétent, statuant selon la procédure accélérée au fond et sans recours possible” meaning value is set by an agreed or court-appointed expert ruling under a fast-track procedure with no appeal, per Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code. American families should write their own valuation formula into the statuts anyway, because the expert must apply any contractual valuation rules the parties agreed in advance, and a clear formula avoids paying an expert to reinvent the price of the family home.

Day-to-day money needs the same discipline. Open a dedicated SCI bank account, fund operating costs by member contributions recorded in the books, and never pay personal expenses from the company account. If the SCI rents the property furnished on a regular basis, get tax advice first: French courts and the tax administration can recharacterize habitual furnished rental as a commercial activity, which can push a civil company toward corporate tax with harsh consequences for a structure chosen to stay transparent. Keep minutes of annual meetings, record every vote on repairs above an agreed threshold, and have the gérant report income and expenses yearly. American members should also calendar U.S. obligations from day one: a French SCI is generally treated as a foreign corporation or partnership for U.S. purposes depending on elections, which can mean Form 5471 or Form 8865 filings, foreign bank account reports, and current U.S. taxation of rental income with foreign tax credits. The U.S.-France income tax treaty helps with double taxation but does not erase reporting. Families that treat the SCI like a casual joint checking account pay for it twice, once in French disorganization and once in American penalties.

II. What an SCI Costs, How France Taxes It, and What Happens at Death

A. French Tax Bills Your SCI Must Pay and How Americans Avoid the 3% Surcharge

France taxes the SCI the way it taxes the underlying real estate, with one dangerous surcharge that American owners of U.S. entities already know. Start with the recurring French property taxes, which the SCI pays as owner: the local property tax (taxe foncière) billed yearly to the owner, and any applicable second-home surcharges the municipality votes. Rental income is the next layer. By default a family SCI is fiscally transparent, meaning the company itself pays no income tax and each member reports that member’s share of rents and deductible charges on that member’s own French return, at progressive rates plus social surcharges where applicable. The SCI can instead elect corporate tax (impôt sur les sociétés), which taxes profits inside the company at the corporate rate and changes the later taxation of sales and distributions dramatically. The election is usually irrevocable in practice and rarely suits a family vacation home, but it can fit a long-term rental strategy where owners want to depreciate the building and retain earnings. Model both paths with numbers before electing, because unwinding a corporate-tax SCI can crystallize the very gain the family hoped to defer.

Wealth tax is the layer American owners most often overlook. France imposes an annual tax on high-value real estate holdings: “Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière” meaning an annual tax on real estate assets called the real-estate wealth tax is established, under Article 964 of the General Tax Code. The threshold is 1.3 million euros of net taxable real estate value assessed each January 1, and the base expressly includes “Des parts ou actions des sociétés et organismes établis en France ou hors de France appartenant aux personnes mentionnées au 1° du présent article, à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de biens ou droits immobiliers détenus directement ou indirectement par la société ou l’organisme” meaning shares of companies at home or abroad count to the extent their value represents underlying French or foreign taxable real estate, per Article 965 of the General Tax Code. An American family whose Paris apartment plus Provençal house sits inside one SCI must therefore add the real-estate fraction of the shares, subtract qualifying debt, and test the 1.3 million euro line every year. Nonresidents are taxed only on French real estate and SCI shares representing French real estate, while new arrivals may benefit from a temporary five-year partial exemption on foreign holdings. The tax administration’s wealth-tax pages on impots.gouv.fr publish the yearly thresholds and filing dates that control each return.

The surcharge Americans fear most is the annual three percent tax on French real estate held through opaque entities. The statute provides that qualifying legal entities “sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits” meaning they owe an annual tax equal to three percent of the market value of the buildings or rights, under Article 990 D of the General Tax Code. A French SCI with fully disclosed French-resident or treaty-country members that files its disclosures is not the target: the statute opens with “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas applicable” for listed exempt persons and then conditions relief on having a seat in France, the European Union, or a country with an administrative-assistance or qualifying treaty relationship with France, among other tests, under Article 990 E of the General Tax Code. In plain terms, a garden-variety family SCI whose members are identified to the French tax administration each year does not pay the three percent levy; an American LLC or trust that hides behind layers and files nothing can be billed three percent of the property’s market value every single year. Our companion guide on that exact trap, My French Apartment Is Held by My American LLC and France Wants 3% Every Year, shows the filings, the May deadline, and the regularization path. Families choosing between a U.S. LLC and a French SCI for the same house should read it before signing, because the SCI route with transparent members is normally the way to keep the three percent tax out of the picture.

Sales deserve their own calculation because Americans face two capital-gains systems at once. When the SCI sells the house, France taxes the French-source gain under French rules for individuals (for a transparent SCI) with taper relief that grows with years of ownership and a full exemption for a genuine primary residence, while the United States taxes its citizens’ worldwide gains and then allows a foreign tax credit subject to baskets and limits. The 1978 U.S.-France income tax treaty allocates taxing rights but the credit mechanics, the different holding periods, and the currency gain or loss on a dollar-funded purchase mean the two bills never match to the dollar. Keep every notaire settlement statement, every improvement invoice from a registered contractor, and every SCI capital account ledger, because both countries compute basis from documents, not memories. Gifts of SCI shares to children during life follow French gift-tax scales with family allowances that reset on a fifteen-year clock, plus U.S. gift-tax reporting for large transfers, so annual small gifts of shares can move value gradually while preserving paperwork the notaire will demand at the final succession.

A final American-side warning belongs in every SCI file memo. The United States asks about foreign companies, foreign accounts, and foreign trusts every April, and the penalties for silence dwarf the French filing fees. Depending on elections and facts, members may need to report the SCI as a controlled foreign corporation or foreign partnership, report the SCI’s French bank accounts, and disclose interests in any French life-insurance-type savings (assurance-vie) the SCI or members hold. The income treaty and the estate treaty reduce double tax but neither treaty excuses information returns. Bring your American CPA into the SCI decision before the French deed is signed, not the following March, and align the French transparency choice with the American entity classification so the same euro of rent is not taxed to different people in different years.

B. Death, Divorce, and Exit: What Happens to the Shares When Life Changes

Death does not dissolve the family SCI, which surprises Americans raised on joint tenancy where the survivor automatically takes all. French law states the opposite default: “La société n’est pas dissoute par le décès d’un associé, mais continue avec ses héritiers ou légataires, sauf à prévoir dans les statuts qu’ils doivent être agréés par les associés” meaning the company is not dissolved by a member’s death but continues with heirs or legatees unless the bylaws require the surviving members to approve them, per Article 1870 of the Civil Code. The same article lets the family write the opposite outcomes in advance: automatic dissolution at death, continuation only among survivors, or continuation with the surviving spouse, designated heirs, or a person named in the bylaws or a compliant will. For an American couple owning a French home with children from a prior marriage, that clause is the document that decides whether the survivor keeps effective control of the house or must negotiate with stepchildren who just inherited shares. Draft it deliberately, coordinate it with each spouse’s will and any EU choice-of-law clause, and review it after every birth, marriage, or divorce.

Succession law then decides who gets the shares, and here Americans meet French forced heirship. The reserve rule caps lifetime and testamentary gifts: gifts “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre” meaning they cannot exceed one-half with one child, one-third with two children, or one-quarter with three or more children, under Article 913 of the Civil Code. The same article adds the modern safety net for cross-border families: “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci” meaning each child can take a compensatory levy on assets located in France at death to restore the reserved rights French law grants, within their limits. Put simply, an American will that leaves everything to the surviving spouse cannot reliably disinherit children as to French-situs value; the children can claw back the protected fraction from the French property or SCI shares. Our guide on disinheriting, choice of law, and the safety net works through the election mechanics, while the 1978 U.S.-France estate and gift tax treaty, summarized on impots.gouv.fr, decides which country taxes the transmission and how the other country credits it.

Court decisions show how these clauses play out when families stop agreeing. In a Paris family dispute over several property companies, a daughter sought court permission to withdraw from the SCI, and the appeal court refused, reasoning that family quarrels alone were not enough without proof the conflict paralyzed the companies. The Court of Cassation quashed that reasoning, holding that the lower court should have asked “si les justes motifs ne résidaient pas dans la disparition de l’affectio societatis consécutive aux conflits familiaux opposant les associés,” meaning whether just cause lay in the disappearance of the shared will to cooperate together following the family conflicts between the members, alongside lost confidence in the manager, criminal complaints, and opposed views on managing the buildings. See Cass. 3rd civ., April 4, 2019, No. 17-31.052 (visa of Article 1869). The statute behind that outcome lets a member leave “dans les conditions prévues par les statuts ou, à défaut, après autorisation donnée par une décision unanime des autres associés” meaning on the bylaws’ terms or, failing that, with unanimous approval of the others, and adds that “Ce retrait peut également être autorisé pour justes motifs par une décision de justice” meaning withdrawal can also be authorized for just cause by a court, per Article 1869 of the Civil Code. A second family saga, centered on the Trianon property company (“la société civile immobilière Trianon (la SCI)”), tested legacies of SCI shares across two deaths, community-property liquidation, and competing claims between a nephew-heir and legatees, illustrating why share legacies must be coordinated with the bylaws’ approval clause and the surviving members’ rights. See Cass. 1st civ., September 2, 2020, No. 19-14.604. For American readers, both cases carry the same message: write the exit before the crisis, because judges will enforce the approval, valuation, and buyout machinery the family adopted, and will supply a just-cause exit only when cooperation has genuinely collapsed.

Divorce and voluntary departure need pre-written answers too. If a spouse-member divorces, the shares owned by that spouse are divided or compensated under the applicable marital regime and succession-election documents, not automatically transferred to the other spouse. If the statuts require approval for transfers to ex-spouses, the departing member’s shares are bought out at the contractual or expert-set price. If one sibling simply wants out because the family never uses the house, the same buyout path applies: request approval, negotiate price under any contractual formula, and, failing agreement, ask the court to appoint the valuation expert described above. European succession rules add one more tool for Americans domiciled in France: EU Regulation No. 650/2012 lets a person choose in a compliant will the law of that person’s nationality to govern the succession as a whole, a choice American testators in France should discuss explicitly (see the choice-of-law chapter of EU Regulation No. 650/2012 as published on EUR-Lex, the EU official law portal), while French notaires still apply French formalities, creditor protections, and real-estate registration rules to the French house itself. After any death, calendar the French filing deadline immediately: “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine;” and “D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” meaning six months when the decedent died in metropolitan France and one year in all other cases, per Article 641 of the General Tax Code. Our step-by-step guide for heirs living in America, The Six- and Twelve-Month Succession Declaration, the Tax Bill, and the Treaty Credit, pairs with this SCI guide when the shares, rather than the house directly, are what the heirs inherit.

Do not forget the surviving spouse’s own protections, which operate alongside the SCI. When children survive, the spouse takes, at the spouse’s option, either lifetime use (usufruit) of all existing assets or outright ownership of one-quarter, because “le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux” under Article 757 of the Civil Code, with a parallel rule granting one-quarter outright when not all children are common. A married couple’s SCI can reinforce that protection by pairing the bylaws with a gift between spouses (donation au dernier vivant) calibrated under Article 1094 within forced-heirship limits, a technique explained in Can an American Couple Protect the Survivor With a Donation au Dernier Vivant?. The practical sequence for a family closing next month is therefore: choose the SCI or direct ownership, fix the manager and majorities, write the death-and-divorce clauses, sign coordinated wills with any nationality choice of law, and diary the tax filings in both countries. An SCI cannot love your children for you, but it can force the conversation that keeps the house out of court.

Conclusion

For an American family buying one French home to share for decades, an SCI is neither a tax shelter nor a way around forced heirship. It is a governance contract: the company owns the house, the family owns shares, the gérant runs daily life, and the statuts decide sales, entries, and buyouts before grief or divorce makes agreement impossible. France taxes the structure transparently in most family cases, adds wealth tax when the real-estate fraction crosses 1.3 million euros, and spares transparent filers the three percent surcharge aimed at opaque foreign holders. At death the company survives, the heirs step into the shares subject to any approval clause, forced heirship caps what any will can redirect, and the estate files within six or twelve months depending on where the decedent died. Get those five points into solid statuts, coordinated wills, and dual-country tax filings, and the French house stays what you bought it to be: a shared home, not a shared lawsuit. Leave them vague, and the same house becomes a case study in how good families fund other people’s legal fees.

📄 Official circular