You live in the United States. You own a Paris apartment, a house in Provence, or shares in a French société civile immobilière (SCI, a civil real-estate company). A French envelope arrives, or a notaire mentions that your net French real estate sits above 1.3 million euros, and someone uses the letters IFI. That is not a U.S. property-tax bill and it is not the transfer tax you paid at closing. The impôt sur la fortune immobilière (IFI, France’s annual tax on real-estate wealth) is due if the net value of the relevant assets on 1 January exceeds 1,300,000 euros. France does not tax the Brooklyn brownstone. It does tax the French walls, and the fraction of company shares those walls represent.
The rules sit in the code général des impôts (CGI, the French tax code), starting at article 964. A New York living trust, a Delaware LLC, and the hope that the treaty will sort it out do not erase the tax. The 1994 United States–France convention lists the old French wealth tax and lets France tax capital represented by French real property and by companies that are mostly French real property. The 30 percent principal-residence cut does not follow you to Manhattan. The 75 percent “cap” is written for people who have their domicile fiscal (tax domicile) in France. A U.S. mortgage can reduce the base only if it exists on 1 January, is actually borne by you, and is tied to a taxable French asset. This hub asks two questions: do you owe IFI from America, and how is it valued, filed, paid, and contested when the avis d’imposition (tax notice) ignores your tenant or your loan. It is not a visa note and not a substitute for the annual French rental-income return.
I. Do I owe French IFI on a home I own from the United States?
A. Who is taxable from America, the €1.3 million threshold, and what counts as French real estate?
Article 964 of the CGI opens with a definition, not a slogan: “Il est institué un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière.” In English: an annual tax on real-estate assets is created under the name impôt sur la fortune immobilière. The same article then names who is in the net: “Sont soumises à cet impôt, lorsque la valeur de leurs actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est supérieure à 1 300 000 € :” persons whose assets listed in article 965 exceed 1,300,000 euros. Two classes of individuals follow. First, persons who have their tax domicile in France, on their article 965 assets located in France or outside France, with a five-year inbound limit for people who were not French-domiciled during the five calendar years before they became French-domiciled. Second — and this is the American who kept a real home in the United States — “Les personnes physiques n’ayant pas leur domicile fiscal en France, à raison des biens et droits immobiliers mentionnés au 1° de l’article 965 situés en France et des parts ou actions de sociétés ou organismes mentionnés au 2° du même article 965 , à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de ces mêmes biens et droits immobiliers.” Non-domiciled individuals are taxable on French real property and real-property rights, and on shares in companies or other bodies, only up to the fraction of those shares that represents the same French real property. The last sentence of article 964 is the calendar that matters: “Les conditions d’assujettissement sont appréciées au 1er janvier de chaque année.” Liability is tested on 1 January of each year. A sale in March does not erase 1 January. A purchase in February does not create IFI for that calendar year.
Tax domicile is not “where your passport was issued” and it is not a 183-day count, a myth already unpacked in the firm’s note on when French tax residence starts for an American arriving mid-year. Article 4 B of the CGI states: “1. Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal ; b. Celles qui exercent en France une activité professionnelle, salariée ou non, à moins qu’elles ne justifient que cette activité y est exercée à titre accessoire ;” and “c. Celles qui ont en France le centre de leurs intérêts économiques.” A person is treated as having a French tax domicile if that person has in France a home (foyer) or the place of principal stay, a professional activity that is not shown to be accessory, or the center of economic interests. The same paragraph then yields to treaties: “Les personnes qui satisfont à l’un au moins des critères fixés aux a à c du présent 1 ne peuvent toutefois pas être considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France lorsque, par application des conventions internationales relatives aux doubles impositions, elles ne sont pas regardées comme résidentes de France.” If a double-tax convention treats you as a resident of the other State, French domestic domicile does not, by itself, make you a French resident for the convention. For a couple whose real family home is in Paris while one spouse still has a U.S. job and a U.S. house, article 4 B can pull the household into French residence. For the classic American who lives, works, and schools children in the United States and keeps a French pied-à-terre, article 964, 2°, is the charging provision: French real estate only, if the net French real-estate wealth on 1 January exceeds 1,300,000 euros.
The base is described in article 965: “L’assiette de l’impôt sur la fortune immobilière est constituée par la valeur nette au 1er janvier de l’année :” the IFI base is the net value on 1 January of (1°) real property and real-property rights belonging to the persons named in article 964, and to their minor children when those persons have legal administration of the children’s property, and (2°) shares in companies and bodies established in France or abroad, up to the fraction of their value that represents real property or real-property rights held directly or indirectly. Service-Public, the French government’s citizen site, says the same thing in plainer language for a person whose tax domicile is abroad: French real property and rights held by the household; shares in real-estate companies that hold French real estate; and shares in companies that hold real estate in France and abroad, but only up to the French property. The tax administration’s page for non-residents is equally direct: if you are a non-resident, and subject to treaties, you are taxable to IFI where you hold net French real-estate wealth above 1,300,000 euros, including property held directly and indirectly on 1 January.
Married couples are assessed jointly, except in the separated-taxation cases listed in article 6 of the CGI. Article 964 also places partners bound by a pacte civil de solidarité (PACS, the French civil partnership) and persons living in notorious concubinage under a common assessment. Americans who bought “in one name” while married under a community regime, or who share the French home with a partner, cannot treat IFI as a solo U.S. 1040 exercise. The 1,300,000 euro gate is a household gate on 1 January, after debts that the statute allows. It is not a per-apartment gate. Two modest flats, a parking space, a cellar, and SCI shares can add up. Furniture, U.S. securities, and a U.S. house are not in the non-resident base. A French assurance-vie (life-insurance investment contract) is in the base only to the extent unit-linked funds represent taxable real-estate assets, which is the rule in article 972.
Professional real estate can fall out of the base under article 975, and article 965 itself ignores, subject to anti-avoidance, small holdings in genuine industrial, commercial, craft, agricultural, or professional companies. Article 966 is the trap for a family SCI: “n’est pas considérée comme une activité industrielle, commerciale, artisanale, agricole ou libérale l’exercice par une société ou un organisme d’une activité de gestion de son propre patrimoine immobilier.” Managing the company’s own real-estate wealth is not a commercial activity for this purpose. Parking the Paris apartment in an SCI, or in a U.S. LLC that does nothing but hold the flat, does not turn the walls into a “business asset.” It usually keeps them in IFI, and it can add a separate 3 percent annual tax if the American vehicle does not file the disclosure that stops that levy, a regime already mapped in the guide on an American LLC that holds a French apartment.
B. Does the US-France tax treaty stop IFI, and what about an SCI, an LLC, a trust, or an usufruct?
The sentence Americans want to hear is that the United States–France tax treaty forbids France from levying a wealth tax on a U.S. resident. The treaty text does the opposite for French real estate. The Convention of 31 August 1994, in the official United States text published by the IRS, is a convention on taxes on income and capital. Article 2 (Taxes Covered) provides that, for France, the convention covers taxes imposed on behalf of the State on total income, on total capital, or on elements of income or of capital, and it lists in particular the wealth tax, named in French as l’impôt de solidarité sur la fortune. IFI replaced the impôt de solidarité sur la fortune (ISF, the former wealth tax on almost all assets) from 2018. Article 2, paragraph 2, of the same Convention extends the convention to identical or substantially similar taxes imposed after signature, in addition to or in place of the existing taxes. IFI is the wealth tax that took the place of ISF, narrowed to real estate. It is not a free pass.
Article 23 (Capital) then allocates taxing rights. Paragraph 1(a) allows capital represented by real property referred to in Article 6, and situated in a Contracting State, to be taxed in that State. Paragraph 1(b) allows capital represented by shares, rights, or an interest in a company whose assets consist at least 50 percent of real property situated in a Contracting State, or derive at least 50 percent of their value, directly or indirectly, from such real property, to be taxed in that State. France may tax the Paris apartment. France may tax shares in a company that is at least half French real property, directly or through other entities. The treaty is a map of who may tax, not a refund check. It does not require the Internal Revenue Service to credit IFI against U.S. federal income tax, because IFI is not an income tax. U.S. estate tax is a different treaty (the 1978 estate and gift convention) and a different event. IFI is due while you are alive, every year the 1 January snapshot exceeds the threshold.
Wrapping the apartment in a company is the move that produces the most expensive correspondence. Article 965 already looks through companies. The Cour de cassation, France’s highest ordinary court, sitting in its commercial, financial and economic chamber, has shown how little a foreign holding structure plus a treaty “real-estate company” clause will do when French look-through rules are read into the treaty. In an opinion published in the Bulletin on 6 May 2026, pourvoi no. 24-22.185, a Russian tax resident had filed ISF returns for 2015 and 2016 showing a 100 percent stake in a Cypriot company, which in turn held Swiss companies and 5 percent of two French SCIs that owned French real estate, the taxpayer’s daughter holding the other 95 percent. He asked for his money back on the ground that the Franco-Russian wealth-tax article should be read narrowly, without French internal look-through and without attributing the daughter’s 95 percent. The Court quoted the former charging rule for non-residents: “Selon l’article 885 A, 2°) du code général des impôts, en sa rédaction alors applicable, sont soumises à l’impôt annuel de solidarité sur la fortune, lorsque la valeur de leurs biens est supérieure à la limite de la première tranche du tarif fixé à l’article 885 U, les personnes physiques n’ayant pas leur domicile fiscal en France, à raison de leurs biens situés en France.” Non-residents were taxable on their property located in France. It then held that the treaty notion of a company whose assets consist principally of French real estate, which the convention itself did not define, “doit avoir le sens que lui attribuent les dispositions de l’article 750 ter, 2°), alinéas 1, 2 et 4 du code général des impôts ainsi que, par renvoi de ce texte, celles de l’article 990 D du même code.” The pourvoi was rejected. The decision is an ISF case, not an IFI case. It still tells an American with a Delaware LLC, a Cypriot holdco, or a family split of SCI shares what a French court does with a wealth-tax treaty that has to be interpreted through French look-through statutes. IFI’s own article 965 now performs a similar look-through without waiting for the old ISF articles.
A simpler SCI does not fare better. In Cass. com., 2 April 2025, pourvoi no. 23-14.568, Luxembourg-domiciled taxpayers had declared ISF for 2017 on shares in two French SCIs, Les Myosotis and Le Melèze bleu, which owned French real estate, then claimed the France–Luxembourg treaty required those wealth items to be taxed only in Luxembourg. The Court rejected the pourvoi. After finding that the SCIs fell under article 8, 1°, of the CGI, with results declared by each partner as rental income, it held that the court of appeal had correctly deduced “que les parts des sociétés civiles immobilières en cause étaient imposables à l’ISF en France.” SCI shares were taxable in France for wealth-tax purposes. Article 23 of the U.S. convention, described above, points the same way for a company that is at least 50 percent French real property. Americans who already hold through an SCI should read this together with the firm’s guide on SCI shares, taxes, and succession, because the annual IFI snapshot and the later inheritance file are two different taxes on the same walls.
A U.S. living trust is not a hole in article 965. Article 970 of the CGI states: “Les actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 placés dans un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis sont compris, pour leur valeur vénale nette au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, selon le cas, dans le patrimoine du constituant ou dans celui du bénéficiaire qui est réputé être un constituant en application du II du même article 792-0 bis.” Article 965 assets placed in a trust are included, at net market value on 1 January, in the estate of the settlor or of the beneficiary who is treated as a settlor. The exception for certain irrevocable charitable trusts does not describe a California revocable living trust that holds a Paris flat. France also expects annual trust reporting, with heavy fines, a regime already described in the article on a California living trust that owns a Paris apartment. IFI and the trust-reporting fine can stack.
Usufruct (the right to use and take the fruits of property, usufruit) is not a way to make the walls vanish. Article 968 states: “Les actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 grevés d’un usufruit, d’un droit d’habitation ou d’un droit d’usage accordé à titre personnel sont compris dans le patrimoine de l’usufruitier ou du titulaire du droit pour leur valeur en pleine propriété.” Assets encumbered with a usufruct, a right of habitation, or a personal right of use are included in the usufructuary’s or right-holder’s wealth at full-ownership value. There are exceptions — legal surviving-spouse usufruct, certain reserved-usufruct sales to a non-heir, gifts to public bodies — in which the tax is split along the age scale in article 669. A homemade life estate drafted in English on a U.S. form, or a reserved usufruct sold to a child, must be tested against those exceptions. If it does not fit, the usufructuary declares 100 percent.
None of this erases the inbound five-year limit in article 964 for a person who actually moves the tax home to France after five years abroad: during that window the new French resident is taxed only as a non-resident would be, on French-situs real estate. The person who stays in the United States never needs that window. The person who is about to move should not assume that French residence automatically unlocks both the 30 percent cut and the 75 percent cap. Those two reliefs are narrower than the version repeated at dinner.
II. How is IFI calculated, declared, and challenged from America?
A. How is the apartment valued, why the 30% primary-residence cut does not apply, and which debts including a U.S. mortgage can be deducted?
Valuation is a 1 January market exercise, not a Zillow screenshot and not the price you paid in 2012. Article 973, I, states: “La valeur des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est déterminée suivant les règles en vigueur en matière de droits de mutation par décès.” Article 965 assets are valued under the rules that apply to inheritance-transfer taxes. Those rules start at article 761: “Pour la liquidation des droits de mutations à titre gratuit, les immeubles, quelle que soit leur nature, sont estimés d’après leur valeur vénale réelle à la date de la transmission, d’après la déclaration détaillée et estimative des parties, sans distraction des charges, sauf, en ce qui concerne celles-ci, ce qui est dit aux articles 767 et suivants .” Real property is estimated at its true market value (valeur vénale réelle) on the transmission date, on a detailed estimate by the parties, without subtracting encumbrances except as the following articles allow. The next sentence of article 761 is easy to misread: “Pour les immeubles dont le propriétaire a l’usage à la date de la transmission, la valeur vénale réelle mentionnée au premier alinéa est réputée égale à la valeur libre de toute occupation.” Where the owner has the use of the property at the transmission date, market value is deemed equal to the value free of any occupation. IFI borrows that inheritance-tax method. Service-Public tells the filer to declare each taxable property at the price at which it could have been sold on the market on 1 January. A tenant in place, a short remaining lease, a class-G energy rating, or a building with a pending roof assessment can support a lower figure than a vacant, renovated dual-aspect flat on the same floor. An occupied-as-owner apartment is not automatically discounted just because you sleep there three weeks a year. The administration will compare Paris notarial statistics, asking prices, and actual sales. Your task is a reasoned 1 January estimate, with comparables, not a round number chosen to sit just under 1,300,000 euros.
The 30 percent principal-residence abatement is the relief every American has heard about and almost no non-resident can use. Article 973 continues: “Par dérogation au deuxième alinéa de l’article 761 , un abattement de 30 % est effectué sur la valeur vénale réelle de l’immeuble lorsque celui-ci est occupé à titre de résidence principale par son propriétaire.” By derogation from article 761, a 30 percent abatement is applied to market value when the building is occupied as the owner’s principal residence. In a joint assessment, only one building can take that abatement. Principal residence, in French tax language, is the home where you actually live, not the apartment you would like to live in “someday” and not the pied-à-terre you occupy on vacation. If your foyer is in the United States, the French walls are a secondary residence. They are valued without the 30 percent cut. Moving to France later can change that for future 1 January snapshots, once the French home is in fact the principal residence. It does not rewrite last 1 January. An American who assumes that becoming a French resident automatically unlocks both the 30 percent cut and the 75 percent cap, without testing domicile and actual occupation, is reading a brochure, not article 973 or article 979.
Debts are where a U.S. mortgage either saves real money or does nothing. Article 974, I, states: “Sont déductibles de la valeur des biens ou droits immobiliers et des parts ou actions taxables les dettes, existantes au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition, contractées par l’une des personnes mentionnées au 1° de l’article 965 et effectivement supportées par celle-ci, afférentes à des actifs imposables et, le cas échéant, à proportion de la fraction de leur valeur imposable :” deductible debts are those that exist on 1 January, contracted by a person named in article 965, 1°, actually borne by that person, and related to taxable assets, including, where relevant, only in proportion to the taxable fraction. The list that follows is closed in spirit: (1°) acquisition of real property or real-property rights; (2°) repair and maintenance actually borne by the owner, including sums advanced for a tenant and not recovered by 31 December of the year the tenant left; (3°) improvement, construction, reconstruction, or enlargement; (4°) taxes on the properties other than those that normally fall on the occupier, but not taxes on the income the properties generate; (5°) acquisition of article 965, 2°, shares, prorated to the underlying taxable real estate. A purchase-money loan on the French apartment, in your name, outstanding on 1 January, is the paradigm of 1°. A home-equity line on a U.S. house, used to buy furniture or to pay U.S. taxes, is not. A loan that exists only inside a family company, or that was taken from yourself, your spouse, your PACS partner, your concubine, or your minor children, is carved out by article 974, III, unless a narrow “normal conditions” proof is available for loans from other relatives or from a controlled company. Interest-only and bullet loans are not deducted at face value forever: article 974, II, amortizes a loan that repays principal at term, and treats a loan with no repayment term as losing one-twentieth of principal per year.
There is a further brake for large, heavily geared portfolios. Article 974, IV, states: “Lorsque la valeur vénale des biens ou droits immobiliers et des parts ou actions taxables excède 5 millions d’euros et que le montant total des dettes admises en déduction en application des I, II et III au titre d’une même année d’imposition excède 60 % de cette valeur, le montant des dettes excédant ce seuil n’est admis en déduction qu’à hauteur de 50 % de cet excédent.” When market value of the taxable real property and shares exceeds 5 million euros and deductible debts exceed 60 percent of that value, the excess debts are deductible only at 50 percent of that excess, unless the taxpayer shows the debts were not contracted with a mainly tax purpose. Article 973, II, also stops a controlled company from manufacturing a deduction with intra-group acquisition debt. Americans who put the flat in an SCI and then lent the SCI the money need that paragraph before they celebrate a paper loan.
Once net taxable value is known, the rate table in article 977 applies only if you are in the tax at all, that is, if net value exceeds 1,300,000 euros. The statute says: “1. Le tarif de l’impôt est fixé à : Fraction de la valeur nette taxable du patrimoine Tarif applicable (en pourcentage) N’excédant pas 800 000 € 0 Supérieure à 800 000 € et inférieure ou égale à 1 300 000 € 0,50 Supérieure à 1 300 000 € et inférieure ou égale à 2 570 000 € 0,70 Supérieure à 2 570 000 € et inférieure ou égale à 5 000 000 € 1 Supérieure à 5 000 000 € et inférieure ou égale à 10 000 000 € 1,25 Supérieure à 10 000 000 € 1,50”. The slice of net taxable wealth that does not exceed 800,000 euros is taxed at 0 percent; above 800,000 and up to 1,300,000 euros, 0.50 percent; above 1,300,000 and up to 2,570,000 euros, 0.70 percent; above 2,570,000 and up to 5,000,000 euros, 1 percent; above 5,000,000 and up to 10,000,000 euros, 1.25 percent; above 10,000,000 euros, 1.50 percent. Because the gate is 1,300,000 euros, a person who is in the tax pays on the slice between 800,000 and 1,300,000 as well. A small smoothing rule exists just above the gate. Article 977, 2, states: “Pour les redevables dont le patrimoine imposable a une valeur nette taxable égale ou supérieure à 1 300 000 € et inférieure à 1 400 000 €, le montant de l’impôt calculé selon le tarif prévu au tableau du 1 est réduit d’une somme égale à 17 500 €-1,25 % P, où P est la valeur nette taxable du patrimoine.” Between 1,300,000 and 1,400,000 euros, the tax computed from the table is reduced by 17,500 euros minus 1.25 percent of P, where P is net taxable wealth. That is a cliff-smoother, not a reason to understate value.
The 75 percent cap that French newspapers discuss is not a non-resident tool. Article 979, I, begins: “L’impôt sur la fortune immobilière du redevable ayant son domicile fiscal en France est réduit de la différence entre, d’une part, le total de cet impôt et des impôts dus en France et à l’étranger au titre des revenus et produits de l’année précédente, calculés avant imputation des seuls crédits d’impôt représentatifs d’une imposition acquittée à l’étranger et des retenues non libératoires et, d’autre part, 75 % du total des revenus mondiaux nets de frais professionnels de l’année précédente, après déduction des seuls déficits catégoriels dont l’imputation est autorisée par l’article 156 , ainsi que des revenus exonérés d’impôt sur le revenu et des produits soumis à un prélèvement libératoire réalisés au cours de la même année en France ou hors de France.” IFI of a taxpayer who has tax domicile in France is reduced by the difference between, on one side, IFI plus income taxes due in France and abroad on the previous year’s income and, on the other, 75 percent of worldwide net professional-expense income of the previous year. The charging words limit the cap to a taxpayer who has tax domicile in France. A U.S.-domiciled owner is outside that sentence.
Donations that generate a 75 percent IFI reduction under article 978, capped at 50,000 euros, are a separate, optional gift to listed French public-interest bodies. They are not a substitute for a valuation file or a real loan.
B. How do I file from the United States, pay, and contest an avis, including Paris and Île-de-France practice?
IFI is a self-assessed tax. Article 982, I, 1, states: “Les redevables mentionnent la valeur brute et la valeur nette taxable des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 sur la déclaration annuelle prévue à l’article 170 . Ils joignent à cette déclaration des annexes conformes à un modèle établi par l’administration, sur lesquelles ils mentionnent et évaluent les éléments de ces mêmes actifs.” Taxpayers report the gross value and the net taxable value of article 965 assets on the annual income-tax return provided for by article 170, and they attach administration-model annexes on which they list and value those assets. In practice that annex is form no. 2042-IFI. The tax administration’s 2026 calendar, updated 22 July 2026, is concrete. Online filers follow the income-tax geographic waves (21 May, 28 May, or 4 June 2026 depending on the French department). Paper filers have until Tuesday 19 May 2026. Non-residents who have French-source income may file IFI online with their income return; the online deadline given for them is Thursday 21 May 2026. Non-residents who file on paper have until Tuesday 19 May 2026. If you have no French-source income to declare but net taxable real-estate wealth exceeds 1,300,000 euros, the non-resident service tells you to file form no. 2042-IFI-COV without an income return, plus the IFI annexes.
Paper packs for non-residents go to a single Île-de-France address, not to the centre des finances publiques of the arrondissement where the apartment sits. The Direction des impôts des non-résidents (DINR, the tax directorate for non-residents) publishes the address of the Service des impôts des particuliers non-résidents (SIPNR): 10 rue du Centre, TSA 10010, 93465 Noisy-le-Grand CEDEX. That is the administrative home of the file, even when the property is in the 7th arrondissement of Paris or in Neuilly. Payment is triggered by the avis d’imposition. Above 300 euros, payment must be made online on impots.gouv.fr or the impots.gouv app, from a bank account in the SEPA zone. Americans who still have no euro account in the SEPA zone discover, at payment time, that opening one is not a theoretical FATCA story; it is how the tax is paid. Automatic debit, either in one installment after the due date or in ten monthly payments from January to October, is offered through the personal space on impots.gouv.fr.
Article 983 adds a procedural sting that EU residents are spared and U.S. residents are not: “Les personnes possédant des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 situés en France sans y avoir leur domicile fiscal […] peuvent être invitées par le service des impôts à désigner un représentant en France dans les conditions prévues à l’article 164 D .” Persons who own article 965 assets in France without having their tax domicile there may be invited to designate a representative in France. The exemption from that invitation is written for persons domiciled in another EU Member State or in another EEA State that has both administrative-assistance and collection-assistance conventions with France. The United States is not on that list. If DINR invites you to name a representative, ignoring the letter is not a strategy.
Silence is expensive. Article 1728, 1, of the CGI states that failure to file a return or instrument that contains elements needed to assess or compute the tax “entraîne l’application, sur le montant des droits mis à la charge du contribuable ou résultant de la déclaration ou de l’acte déposé tardivement, d’une majoration de : a. 10 % en l’absence de mise en demeure ou en cas de dépôt de la déclaration ou de l’acte dans les trente jours suivant la réception d’une mise en demeure […] ; b. 40 % lorsque la déclaration ou l’acte n’a pas été déposé dans les trente jours suivant la réception d’une mise en demeure […].” A 10 percent surcharge applies if there was no formal notice to file, or if you file within thirty days of receiving one; 40 percent applies if you still have not filed thirty days after that notice. An 80 percent surcharge is reserved for a concealed activity, which is not the usual IFI fact pattern, but 10 percent and 40 percent are ordinary. Late payment interest stacks on top. Filing a reasoned 2042-IFI, even while you dispute a comparable, is safer than hoping DINR will not notice a Paris apartment that already appears on a notarial deed, a taxe foncière roll, and a rental return.
If the avis overstates value, the first move is a réclamation (administrative claim) to the service that issued it, with comparables, the lease, photographs, the energy report, the co-ownership minutes that show a special assessment, and the loan statement as of 31 December. Paris practice is fact-heavy. The administration reads the Chambre des notaires de Paris statistics and asking prices in the same street. A furnished rental licensed for short stays does not receive the same discount as a long empty-lease apartment with a tenant who has been there for a decade. A Haussmannian flat with a pending façade ravalement voted in general meeting is not the same asset as a renovated copy on the next landing. Île-de-France files are still DINR files: you do not walk into the local Paris tax office with a paper bag of photos and expect the 7th arrondissement to reassess a non-resident IFI. If the claim is rejected or ignored, the next court is the administrative court, not the judicial court that handled your purchase. For a DINR assessment, territorial competence follows the non-resident service, which sits in Noisy-le-Grand in Seine-Saint-Denis, in Île-de-France. The lawyer who already holds a French power of attorney for the purchase can often reuse that channel; a U.S. notarized letter that has not been apostilled will not.
IFI does not replace the other French bills that already attach to the same walls. Taxe foncière (annual property tax) is due whether or not you cross 1,300,000 euros. Rental income remains on the income-tax return and, for many non-residents, under the treaty article on income from real property, as explained in the rental return and treaty-credit guide. A later death is an inheritance-tax file, with forced heirship and the 2021 compensatory levy, described in the inheritance-law guide for American families, not an IFI refund. Selling will raise the non-resident capital-gains withholding, which is a different code article and a different form. The IFI return is the annual photograph. It must match the deed, the SCI register, the trust schedule, and the loan statement, because those documents will be in the file when DINR writes back.
Conclusion
IFI is an annual French tax on net real-estate wealth above 1,300,000 euros on 1 January. An American whose tax domicile remains in the United States is not taxed on worldwide real estate. That person is taxed on French real property, French real-property rights, and the real-estate fraction of company shares, including an SCI, an LLC, and most family holding chains. The 1994 United States–France convention covers the old French wealth tax and substantially similar successor taxes, and article 23 allows France to tax capital represented by French real property and by companies that are at least half French real property. The Cour de cassation’s Bulletin decision of 6 May 2026, pourvoi no. 24-22.185, shows how a wealth-tax treaty’s “real-estate company” clause is read through French look-through statutes; the 2 April 2025 rejection in pourvoi no. 23-14.568 shows SCI shares remaining in a non-resident’s French wealth-tax base. Neither case is an invitation to ignore IFI because the structure is foreign.
The 30 percent principal-residence abatement follows a home you actually occupy as your main residence, not a pied-à-terre. The 75 percent cap in article 979 is written for a taxpayer who has tax domicile in France. A U.S. mortgage reduces the base when it exists on 1 January, is borne by you, and paid for a taxable French asset; a loan on American property, a circular family loan, or a bullet loan left at face value year after year will not do the work you hope. File the 2042-IFI (or 2042-IFI-COV if you have no French income), send paper to SIPNR in Noisy-le-Grand when that is your channel, pay the avis through SEPA, and contest value with a Paris-grade comparable file rather than with silence. For a dwelling in Paris or elsewhere in Île-de-France, the market evidence is local and the non-resident service is local to the region even when you remain in the United States. The next useful step is a 1 January balance sheet of the French walls, the shares, the trusts, and the debts, drawn to article 965 and article 974, before the May deadline and not after the surcharge in article 1728 has already attached.