KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Iran’s PS752 Appeal at the ICJ: What the 3 September 2026 Order Changed and What France Would Test

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Iran’s PS752 Appeal at the ICJ: What the 3 September 2026 Order Changed and What France Would Test

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 3 September 2026, the President of the International Court of Justice signed a short procedural order that kept one of the most politically charged aviation cases in the world alive and moving. In the case concerning the Appeal relating to the Jurisdiction of the ICAO Council under Article 84 of the Convention on International Civil Aviation (Islamic Republic of Iran v. Canada, Sweden, Ukraine and United Kingdom), the Court extended to 21 October 2026 the time limit for Iran to file its Reply and to 22 March 2027 the time limit for the four respondent States to file their Rejoinder. Behind those dry dates lies the unresolved legal reckoning for Ukraine International Airlines Flight PS752, shot down over Tehran on 8 January 2020 with 176 people on board, and a jurisdictional battle that will decide whether the ICAO Council — the governing body of world civil aviation — is even allowed to judge Iran’s conduct.

For an international audience, this case is a live masterclass in how aviation justice actually works once a surface-to-air missile hits a civilian airliner: why four grieving States took Iran before the ICAO Council rather than straight to court, how Article 84 of the 1944 Chicago Convention turns the Council’s jurisdictional ruling into an appealable decision before The Hague, and why a one-month extension fought over the summer of 2026 matters to the families still waiting for accountability. This analysis reconstructs the order of 3 September 2026 from the Court’s own documents, then applies the French test: had the PS752 reckoning come to Paris — where the flight recorders were read out in July 2020 — what would French courts have examined before hearing a claim against Iran, under which exact articles, and where would state immunity have stopped the case cold.

I. Iran’s appeal against the ICAO Council: what the Court was asked to decide

A. Why can a State appeal an ICAO Council decision to the International Court of Justice?

The starting point is a mechanism most non-specialists have never heard of, although it governs every international flight. The Convention on International Civil Aviation, adopted at Chicago on 7 December 1944, created the International Civil Aviation Organization and gave its 36-member Council a quasi-judicial role: under Article 84, disagreements between States over the interpretation or application of the Convention can be brought before the Council, and a State dissatisfied with the Council’s decision can appeal it to the International Court of Justice. That appeal route is exactly what Iran activated. According to the Registry’s press release of 17 April 2025, Iran’s application appeals a 17 March 2025 ruling of the ICAO Council, issued in proceedings the four States had jointly brought against Iran on 8 January 2024 under the dispute-settlement clause of the 1944 Chicago Convention (ICJ Press Release 2025/18; ICJ case page 198).

The underlying facts are not in dispute between the parties and were established within days of the tragedy. The Ukraine International Airlines flight was shot down on 8 January 2020 by an Iranian ground-to-air missile, killing 176 people, and three days after the crash the Iranian army admitted that the plane had been shot down “by mistake”, as France 24 reported at the time (France 24, 27 June 2020). The four applicant States — Canada, Sweden, Ukraine and the United Kingdom, all of which lost nationals — argue before the ICAO Council that the destruction of the aircraft breached the Chicago Convention. Iran does not defend the shooting itself in this phase; it attacks the forum. The press release describes the subject matter as a disagreement over how to interpret and apply the Chicago Convention after the Iranian military mistakenly destroyed Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 in flight on 8 January 2020, and defines the case before The Hague as Iran’s challenge to the legal validity of the ICAO Council’s 17 March 2025 ruling dismissing Iran’s preliminary objections.

Iran asks the Court for four precise declarations, and their wording matters because they frame everything the judges will have to decide. Iran asks the Court to declare, first, that its “First Objection” deprives the ICAO Council of jurisdiction over the complaint the four States filed on 8 January 2024; second, that its “Second Objection” strips the United Kingdom of standing to claim or to take part before the Council; third, that the Council’s voting procedure, including a substantive post-vote amendment to one paragraph of the ruling, fundamentally breached fair-procedure requirements by merging two separate objections into a single vote; and fourth, that the Council’s decision is without legal effect. The jurisdictional basis invoked is Article 84 of the Chicago Convention itself, in conjunction with Article 36, paragraph 1, and Article 37 of the Statute of the Court. In plain terms: this is not yet a trial about who pays for 176 deaths. It is a trial about whether the aviation tribunal that wants to hold that trial is legally entitled to do so — and about whether the United Kingdom, whose standing Iran contests, is even allowed to sit at the claimant table.

One parallel track must be kept separate to avoid a confusion that even good commentators make. Alongside the Chicago Convention proceedings before the ICAO Council, the same four States filed a joint application against Iran on 4 July 2023 concerning the same downing but under a different treaty — the 1971 Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Civil Aviation, the Montreal Convention on aviation security. That second case attacks the shooting as an internationally wrongful act; the ICAO appeal attacks only the Council’s competence to hear the Chicago Convention complaint. The two cases can therefore produce two different outcomes: the Court could uphold the ICAO Council’s jurisdiction while the merits of State responsibility are still litigated elsewhere, or it could annul the Council’s decision and force the four States back to the Montreal Convention track alone. For families and for States computing litigation risk, that fork is the whole ballgame, because the forum determines the remedies.

B. Why did the Court extend Iran’s deadline to 21 October 2026?

The order of 3 September 2026 — signed by President Iwasawa Yuji and Registrar Santiago Villalpando, with the French text authoritative — is a case-management decision, but its recitals read like a condensed diary of the written phase, and every date in it is a litigation signal (Order of 3 September 2026). By an order of 19 June 2025, the Court had fixed 19 January 2026 for Iran’s Memorial and 19 August 2026 for the Counter-Memorial of the four respondent States. Iran’s Memorial was filed within time. The Counter-Memorial was filed on 27 March 2026, almost five months ahead of its deadline — an unusually fast filing that practitioners read as a show of force: the four States, backed by the families’ associations that have documented every step of the case on their public timeline, wanted the record to show they were ready long before the clock ran out. Then, by an order of 21 May 2026, the Court directed a second round of pleadings — a Reply by Iran and a Rejoinder by the respondents — fixing 21 September 2026 and 21 January 2027 as the respective limits.

That timetable held until late August. By a letter dated 25 August 2026, Iran’s Co-Agent asked for a one-month extension of the Reply deadline, giving two reasons: the work of its legal team had been disrupted by recent armed attacks on the country, and Iran was simultaneously preparing written pleadings in two other cases pending before the Court. The Registrar immediately transmitted the request to the four respondent States, as Article 44, paragraph 3, of the Rules of Court requires. Their answer, dated 28 August 2026, objected. The respondents argued that Iran’s workload concern had already been taken into account when the Court set the second-round limits, pointed out that in another case Canada had not objected to Iran’s own request for more time — a reciprocity argument designed to paint the objection as principled rather than punitive — and, above all, that the families of the PS752 victims needed the dispute resolved quickly.

The President split the difference in the way The Hague usually does: he granted the extension but kept it tight. The order moves the Reply deadline to 21 October 2026 for Iran and the Rejoinder deadline to 22 March 2027 for the four respondent States, while reserving what comes next for further decision. Three lessons follow for anyone watching international litigation. First, the Court credited Iran’s disruption claim at least partially — Presidents do not move deadlines on makeweight letters — which tells observers something about how the summer 2026 military confrontation affected the functioning of a State legal apparatus that is simultaneously defending multiple fronts in The Hague. Second, the respondents’ families-first argument did not block the extension but is now on the record, and it will weigh heavily if Iran seeks further delays: having demanded speed in the name of the victims, the four States have built the rhetorical foundation to oppose the next request. Third, the calendar now points to hearings no earlier than late 2027 on the jurisdictional appeal alone, more than seven years after the missile strike — a pace the families’ associations, which marked March 2026 with both the early Counter-Memorial filing and a landmark ICAO reform of accident-investigation independence, experience as justice delayed, however normal it is by ICJ standards.

The stakes of that jurisdictional ruling deserve one blunt paragraph, because they explain why five States are spending millions on what looks like procedure. If the Court rejects Iran’s appeal, the ICAO Council proceeds to the merits of the Chicago Convention complaint and Iran faces an authoritative aviation-law finding that its military unlawfully destroyed a civilian airliner in flight — a finding with political, precedential and reparations consequences far beyond aviation. If the Court declares the Council’s decision null and void, the Chicago track collapses and the four States must carry the entire accountability effort through the parallel Montreal Convention case and through domestic criminal proceedings, with no ICAO merits ruling to lean on. And the United Kingdom’s standing point is not decorative: if London were excluded from the ICAO track, the coalition’s diplomatic arithmetic changes. Jurisdiction first, merits later — that is the order of battle, and the 3 September order simply armed both sides with a few more weeks to sharpen their weapons.

II. What France would test if the PS752 reckoning came to Paris

A. Could French courts hear a damages claim against Iran despite State immunity?

France is not a bystander in the PS752 story. When Iran recovered the cockpit voice and flight data recorders but lacked the technical means to read them out, it was France’s Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for civil aviation safety — the BEA — that did the work in Paris. As France 24 reported on 27 June 2020, France undertook to download the recorders from the airliner downed by an Iranian missile in January, with the BEA acting at Tehran’s request while Iran remained responsible under global rules for the formal accident inquiry, and with repair and readout work on both recorders starting on 20 July. Canadian investigators — 57 Canadian citizens were among the 176 dead — sent a team to Paris to participate. The Paris readout therefore sits at the evidentiary heart of every PS752 proceeding in the world, and French lawyers know the file better than most: the transcript confirmed outside interference with the aircraft, and the readout was conducted under the very Chicago Convention system whose Article 84 mechanism is now before the Court.

Suppose, then, that relatives of victims seized a French court with a damages claim against Iran. The first and probably fatal question would be immunity from jurisdiction, and French case law states the rule in terms worth quoting exactly because they decide the issue before any discussion of fault. On 3 March 2021, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in decision no. 19-22.855 (official text on courdecassation.fr), held: “Selon les principes de droit international coutumier, les Etats étrangers bénéficient d’une immunité de juridiction lorsque l’acte qui donne lieu au litige participe, par sa nature ou sa finalité, à l’exercice de la souveraineté de ces Etats et n’est donc pas un acte de gestion.” Foreign States enjoy immunity from jurisdiction when the act giving rise to the dispute participates, by its nature or purpose, in the exercise of their sovereignty and is therefore not an act of management. The test is binary — sovereign act or management act — and the Court applies it strictly, examining the nature and purpose of the act at the date it was committed.

Applied to PS752, that test shuts the courtroom door. The destruction of the airliner was carried out by Iran’s armed forces, operating an air-defence system during a period of heightened military alert, with military personnel pulling the trigger on a military weapons system pursuant to military rules of engagement. Whatever the criminal or moral assessment of the strike — and the four applicant States call it an internationally wrongful act — no French court could characterise the firing of a surface-to-air missile by a national army as an act of management. It is the textbook example of an act participating by nature and purpose in the exercise of sovereignty, the modern equivalent of the sovereign-command cases in which French courts have always upheld immunity. The claimant in the 2021 case tried to escape immunity by invoking Article 6, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on Human Rights and the right of access to a court; the Court of Cassation rejected the appeal. A PS752 claimant invoking the same article would meet the same answer: in French law, immunity from jurisdiction for sovereign acts is itself a rule of international law that Article 6 accommodates, not a denial of justice the Convention condemns.

The blocked path is otherwise straightforward. French tort law gives every victim a cause of action in one famous sentence — article 1240 of the Civil Code provides: “Tout fait quelconque de l’homme, qui cause à autrui un dommage, oblige celui par la faute duquel il est arrivé à le réparer.” Any act whatever of man which causes damage to another obliges him by whose fault it occurred to repair it. Firing a missile at a civilian airliner is plainly a fault within that article, and causation and damage are documented to the last recorder frame. But article 1240 designates the debtor, not the forum: it says Iran must repair, without saying a Paris court may order it to. Between the victims and a French judgment stands the immunity wall restated in 2021, and French judges would enforce it proprio motu if necessary, before even opening the damages file. That is precisely why the four States chose the interstate route — ICAO Council, ICJ, Montreal Convention — rather than sending families into domestic courts one by one: only State-against-State proceedings bypass the immunity that protects Iran in every national courtroom, Paris included.

One narrow door remains theoretically ajar and must be mentioned for completeness, because clients always ask about it. Had individual perpetrators — commanders, operators — been present on French soil, French criminal courts could have examined individual criminal responsibility, which State immunity does not cover in the same way. But no PS752 suspect is in France, Iran does not extradite its own military personnel, and the French criminal investigation, unlike the Canadian, Swedish, Ukrainian and British interstate actions, has no defendant to try. For families with a French connection, the realistic French contribution is therefore evidentiary rather than jurisdictional: the BEA readout, Paris laboratory findings and French expert testimony feeding the interstate cases, not a standalone Paris trial against Tehran.

B. Could a French judge seize Iranian assets to enforce a judgment?

Assume the harder question is answered — a judgment or arbitral award condemns Iran to compensate the PS752 families, whether from the ICJ’s parallel track, an arbitration, or a foreign court — and the creditors find Iranian property in France. Can a French enforcement judge seize it? Here French law is exceptionally detailed, because Parliament codified State execution immunity after a wave of creditor raids on foreign assets, and the resulting articles read like a checklist the judge must work through line by line. The gateway is article L. 111-1-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures: “Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger que sur autorisation préalable du juge par ordonnance rendue sur requête.” No conservatory or enforcement measure against property belonging to a foreign State without prior judicial authorisation by order on petition. Seizure first, permission later is forbidden; the judge sees the file before the bailiff moves.

Authorisation is then granted only on narrow statutory grounds. Article L. 111-1-2 of the same code provides: “Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée visant un bien appartenant à un Etat étranger ne peuvent être autorisées par le juge que si l’une des conditions suivantes est remplie : 1° L’Etat concerné a expressément consenti à l’application d’une telle mesure ; 2° L’Etat concerné a réservé ou affecté ce bien à la satisfaction de la demande qui fait l’objet de la procédure ; 3° Lorsqu’un jugement ou une sentence arbitrale a été rendu contre l’Etat concerné et que le bien en question est spécifiquement utilisé ou destiné à être utilisé par ledit Etat autrement qu’à des fins de service public non commerciales et entretient un lien avec l’entité contre laquelle la procédure a été intentée.” Express consent, earmarked property, or — after a judgment or award — property specifically used for non-public commercial purposes with a link to the debtor entity. The same article then lists what counts as public-purpose property shielded from the third route, from diplomatic and military assets to cultural heritage and tax claims. And article L. 111-1-3 adds an absolute lock for one category: “Des mesures conservatoires ou des mesures d’exécution forcée ne peuvent être mises en œuvre sur les biens, y compris les comptes bancaires, utilisés ou destinés à être utilisés dans l’exercice des fonctions de la mission diplomatique des Etats étrangers ou de leurs postes consulaires, de leurs missions spéciales ou de leurs missions auprès des organisations internationales qu’en cas de renonciation expresse et spéciale des Etats concernés.” Diplomatic-mission property — immunity yields only to an express and special waiver.

French courts apply that architecture to aircraft with a rigour PS752 creditors should study, because the leading recent case concerned exactly that: the seizure of a State aircraft. In its decision of 13 March 2024, no. 21-17.599, Republic of Congo v. Commisimpex (official text on courdecassation.fr), the First Civil Chamber ruled on a creditor’s June 2020 seizure of an aircraft belonging to Congo, executed under two arbitral awards. The Court recalled: “Selon les principes du droit international coutumier reflétés par la Convention des Nations Unies du 2 décembre 2004 sur les immunités des Etats et de leurs biens, la renonciation expresse à l’immunité d’exécution suffit pour que les biens d’un Etat, quels qu’ils soient, puissent faire l’objet d’une mesure d’exécution, sans que soit en outre requise une renonciation spéciale.” An express waiver of execution immunity suffices for State property generally, with no additional special waiver required. But it immediately fenced off diplomacy: “selon l’article 22, § 3 de la Convention de Vienne sur les relations diplomatiques du 18 avril 1961, les locaux de la mission, leur ameublement et les autres objets qui s’y trouvent, ainsi que les moyens de transport de la mission, ne peuvent faire l’objet d’aucune saisie ou mesure d’exécution”, so that “doivent être interprétées strictement les dispositions de l’article L. 111-1-3”, and the appeal court had “exactement déduit que la renonciation expresse à l’immunité d’exécution, consentie par cet Etat dans le litige l’opposant à la société Commisimpex, suffisait pour que l’actif en cause affecté à la présidence de la République puisse faire l’objet d’une mesure d’exécution, sans que soit, en outre, requise une renonciation spéciale”, having found the aircraft was not among the means placed at the disposal of Congo’s diplomatic mission in France.

The transposition to Iranian assets in France is direct and sobering. A presidential or military aircraft, diplomatic bank accounts and embassy premises would fall under the strict L. 111-1-3 lock — as the Second Civil Chamber confirmed on 12 June 2025, no. 21-11.991 (official text on courdecassation.fr), recalling that under Article 22 of the Vienna Convention “Les locaux de la mission, leur ameublement et les autres objets qui s’y trouvent, ainsi que les moyens de transport de la mission, ne peuvent faire l’objet d’aucune perquisition, réquisition, saisie ou mesure d’exécution.” Only commercial-use property linked to the debtor entity, or property Iran expressly consented to expose, could be authorised for seizure — and Iran, unlike Congo in that case, has signed no waiver. French judges would therefore ask PS752 creditors three questions in order: do you have an enforceable title against Iran, is the targeted asset used for non-public commercial purposes with a link to the debtor, and is it free of diplomatic assignment? Most Iranian assets in France fail at least one of those gates. That is also why French courts police aviation conventions literally rather than generously: on 8 February 2023, the Commercial Chamber, no. 21-17.932 (official text on courdecassation.fr), partially quashed a Versailles ruling in an air-cargo dispute turning on the article 22.3 compensation cap of the Montreal Convention — a reminder that in Paris, treaty text is applied as written, caps included, and enforcement creativity finds no indulgence.

Conclusion

The order of 3 September 2026 changed no substantive right, but it set the last procedural rails before the jurisdictional battle is joined: Iran’s Reply by 21 October 2026, the four States’ Rejoinder by 22 March 2027, then the Court’s ruling on whether the ICAO Council may judge the downing of Flight PS752 — and whether the United Kingdom may sit among its judges’ accusers. If the Council’s jurisdiction survives, aviation law gains its first ICAO-merits ruling on the military destruction of a civilian airliner, with reparations logic to follow. If it falls, accountability migrates fully to the parallel Montreal Convention case filed on 4 July 2023 and to domestic criminal files, a longer and thinner road the families have walked since January 2020. Either way, the French lesson stands apart from the outcome: Paris contributed the decisive technical evidence through the July 2020 BEA readout, yet French courtrooms remain closed to direct claims by a double lock — immunity from jurisdiction for the sovereign act of firing the missile, and immunity from execution for the assets that could pay for it, unlockable only by waiver, commercial use or an enforceable title plus a judge’s prior order. For victims’ lawyers, the strategy writes itself: feed the interstate cases with the best evidence, map Iranian commercial assets early against articles L. 111-1-1 to L. 111-1-3, and never promise a Paris judgment that immunity arithmetic forbids. The Hague will decide the forum; France will decide, asset by asset, what enforcement is actually worth.

📄 Official circular