KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My Notaire Says Buy the French House Through an SCI: Forced Heirship, the 3% Tax, and US Reporting

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My Notaire Says Buy the French House Through an SCI: Forced Heirship, the 3% Tax, and US Reporting

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

The email from the notaire (the French public officer who authenticates real-estate deeds) lands in your inbox the week before you fly to Paris. The apartment is in your name in the draft, then a second version appears: you and your spouse will form a société civile immobilière, an SCI, a French civil company whose only job is to hold real estate. The pitch is familiar to every American buyer. The SCI will avoid French forced heirship. The SCI will turn the house into shares. The SCI will make the succession a simple transfer of paper. None of those sentences is a statute. An SCI is a real French company, with real creditors, a real manager, and real tax forms. It is not a Delaware LLC with a French accent, and it is not a substitute for a will that elects the law of your nationality.

This article is for the American who is being asked to buy the house through an SCI, or who already did. It explains what the Civil Code actually does when you form the company, what happens to the parts sociales (the ownership units of the company) when a shareholder dies, why French inheritance tax still looks through the company to the French building, and which annual 3 percent levy can destroy a structure that was sold as a tax saver. Visa questions belong elsewhere. The question here is simpler and more expensive: once you own French bricks, does putting them in an SCI change the civil-law and tax-law results you were promised?

The short answer, developed below, is that an SCI can be a useful management tool for a family that already understands unlimited liability, annual accounts, and the need to file French and US returns in parallel. It is a poor instrument for the goal most Americans actually name in the meeting with the notaire: making French forced heirship and French succession tax disappear. Those results are governed by other texts, which the company does not repeal.

I. Does an SCI let an American avoid French forced heirship on a house?

A. What is a French SCI and how is it different from a US LLC?

French law does not know the American limited-liability company. What it knows is the société, the company, defined at the opening of the Civil Code’s company title. Article 1832 of the Civil Code states: “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” In English: two or more people agree by contract to contribute property or work to a common enterprise, in order to share the profit or the saving that may result. The same article allows a one-person company only in the cases the statute provides. An SCI used to buy a vacation home is almost always a multi-member civil company. It is not a filing with a US secretary of state.

The SCI is civil, not commercial, because of its object. Article 1845 of the Civil Code provides: “Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés auxquelles la loi n’attribue pas un autre caractère à raison de leur forme, de leur nature, ou de leur objet.” A company is civil whenever the law does not give it another character by reason of its form, nature, or object. The official business guide of the French administration, Société civile immobilière (SCI) : ce qu’il faut savoir, last verified on 7 October 2025, describes the SCI as a civil company whose object is to acquire or build one or more buildings, then to manage and administer them. The same page warns that the principal activity must remain civil, for example the rental of unfurnished premises, and must not become commercial, for example buying to resell or operating furnished tourist lets with hotel-type services. Americans who plan to list the apartment on a platform as a furnished short-term rental are therefore not looking at a standard SCI fact pattern; they are looking at a commercial-taint problem, and they already have a separate analysis of furnished rentals on this site.

Legal personality does not exist because you signed bylaws in a hotel meeting room. It exists when the company is registered. Article 1842 of the Civil Code states: “Les sociétés autres que les sociétés en participation visées au chapitre III et que les sociétés de libre partenariat spéciales mentionnées à l’ article L. 214-162-13 du code monétaire et financier jouissent de la personnalité morale à compter de leur immatriculation.” Except for the partnerships that article carves out, companies enjoy legal personality from the date of their registration. Until then, the relationships among the future shareholders are only a contract. In Paris, that registration is filed with the registry of the Commercial Court, the greffe du tribunal de commerce. The building itself is still acquired by a notarial deed recorded with the land-publicity service, the service de la publicité foncière. Forming the SCI does not replace the compromis de vente, the cooling-off period, and the closing mechanics of a French purchase. It adds a company on top of them.

The most important civil difference with a Delaware LLC is liability. French consumer pages sometimes sell the SCI as a shield. The Civil Code does the opposite. Article 1857 of the Civil Code provides: “A l’égard des tiers, les associés répondent indéfiniment des dettes sociales à proportion de leur part dans le capital social à la date de l’exigibilité ou au jour de la cessation des paiements.” Toward third parties, the shareholders are indefinitely liable for the company’s debts, in proportion to their share of capital at the date the debt falls due or at the date of a cessation of payments. Indéfiniment does not mean jointly and severally for 100 percent in every case, but it does mean there is no statutory cap at the amount of your contribution. A contractor who renovates the Paris apartment, a bank that lent to the SCI, or the tax office that assessed the company can reach the shareholders’ personal assets for their fraction. Service-Public says the same thing in administrative language: the shareholders have an undefined financial liability (une responsabilité financière indéfinie) toward the SCI’s debts, and their personal estate may be used to pay the company’s creditors. If your US counsel told you the SCI would wall off the house the way an LLC walls off a Florida rental, that advice does not describe article 1857.

Shares are not freely transferable. Article 1861 of the Civil Code opens with: “Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées qu’avec l’agrément de tous les associés.” The shares may be transferred only with the approval of all the shareholders. The bylaws may relax that unanimity, and transfers to ancestors or descendants are, unless the bylaws say otherwise, exempt from approval. Transfers between two spouses who are both already shareholders must be in a notarial deed or in a private deed that has a certain date other than the transferor’s death. The practical result for an American couple is the opposite of the easy-paper-transfer sales pitch: you cannot sell your 50 percent to a friend, a trust, or a child from a first marriage unless the statute or the bylaws let you, and the other shareholder agrees when agreement is required. Compare that with a US LLC operating agreement you can amend in an afternoon. The SCI’s operating rules live in French bylaws that a French judge will read, not in a California contract.

French comparison guides aimed at domestic buyers stress the absence of a statutory minimum capital, easier management than indivision (the default co-ownership of an asset by several people), and the ability to give shares over time. Those points can be true for a French family that already lives inside French gift-tax allowances. They do not answer the American questions this desk actually receives: Will France still tax my children on the apartment when I die in New York? Will a US living trust be recognized as shareholder? Will the IRS treat the SCI as a partnership, a corporation, or a passive foreign investment company? The living-trust question is already mapped on this site for houses titled in a US revocable trust that France does not treat as a French fiducie. Putting the same house into an SCI does not import the trust. It creates a second legal person whose shareholders still have to be identified, approved, and taxed.

One last mechanical point before succession. The company is administered by a gérant, a manager, who may or may not be a shareholder. Collective decisions belong to the shareholders. Article 1844 of the Civil Code states that every shareholder has the right to take part in collective decisions. If a share is split between a usufructuary (the person who has the right to use the property or collect its fruits) and a bare owner, both may attend; the voting right on the allocation of profits belongs to the usufructuary. Americans who were told they could keep control by retaining a 1 percent managing share and giving 99 percent to the children need to read the bylaws and article 1844 together, not a brochure. Control is a function of the manager’s powers and of the majority rules in the bylaws. It is not a slogan.

B. What happens to SCI shares when you die, and does the réserve still apply?

The succession myth is the reason most Americans are in the notaire’s conference room. The old story, still repeated in English-language forums, is that French forced heirship, the réserve héréditaire, applies to French immovables, whereas SCI shares are movable property, so the American deceased’s national law (no reserved share for children) will govern the shares. That story mixed three different questions: which law governs the succession as a whole, which assets sit in France for tax, and whether a child can claw French assets when the governing law gives the child nothing. Current texts separate those questions. An SCI answers none of them by itself.

Start with what the company does at death, which is a company-law question, not a conflict-of-laws question. Article 1870 of the Civil Code provides: “La société n’est pas dissoute par le décès d’un associé, mais continue avec ses héritiers ou légataires, sauf à prévoir dans les statuts qu’ils doivent être agréés par les associés.” The company is not dissolved by a shareholder’s death; it continues with the heirs or legatees, unless the bylaws require those people to be approved by the remaining shareholders. The bylaws may instead dissolve the company, continue it with the surviving shareholders only, or continue it with the surviving spouse, one or more heirs, or another person designated in the bylaws or, if the bylaws allow, by will. Article 1870-1 of the Civil Code then cuts off the heir who does not become a shareholder: “Les héritiers ou légataires qui ne deviennent pas associés n’ont droit qu’à la valeur des parts sociales de leur auteur.” Heirs or legatees who do not become shareholders are entitled only to the value of the deceased’s shares. That value is determined as of the date of death under the appraisal mechanism of article 1843-4.

The Cour de cassation, France’s highest ordinary court, has applied those two articles strictly. In a decision of 2 September 2020, pourvoi no. 19-14.604, published in the Bulletin, the First Civil Chamber wrote: “Selon l’article 1870, alinéa 1, du code civil, la société civile n’est pas dissoute par le décès d’un associé, mais continue avec ses héritiers ou légataires, sauf à prévoir dans les statuts qu’ils doivent être agréés par les associés.” It continued: “L’article 1870-1 du même code prévoit que les héritiers ou légataires qui ne deviennent pas associés n’ont droit qu’à la valeur des parts sociales de leur auteur.” The holding that followed is the operational warning for American estates: “Il en résulte que, s’il n’est associé, l’héritier n’a pas qualité pour percevoir les dividendes, fût-ce avant la délivrance du legs de ces parts à un légataire.” If the heir is not a shareholder, the heir has no standing to collect dividends, even before a legacy of the shares is delivered to a legatee. The full decision is on the Court’s site at Cour de cassation, 2 September 2020, no. 19-14.604. The family fight in that case was about an SCI named Trianon, specific legacies of shares, and who could collect what after two deaths. The legal point for a buyer is simpler. Death does not hand your children the keys to the Paris apartment. Death hands them either shareholder status, if the bylaws and the other shareholders let them in, or a cash claim for the value of the shares. A cash claim against an SCI that owns an illiquid apartment is not a way of avoiding French succession. It is a new lawsuit dressed as estate planning.

The same First Civil Chamber’s companion idea was confirmed for the Third Civil Chamber on 9 March 2023, pourvoi no. 21-21.698, also published in the Bulletin. The Court held: “une société civile étant présumée continuer avec les héritiers d’un associé décédé, il incombe à celui qui dénie la qualité d’associé à l’héritier d’un associé d’établir l’existence d’une stipulation contraire des statuts.” Because a civil company is presumed to continue with the heirs of a deceased shareholder, the person who denies the heir’s status as shareholder must prove a contrary clause in the bylaws. The decision is at Cour de cassation, 9 March 2023, no. 21-21.698. If your bylaws are silent, the default is continuation with the heirs, not a freeze-out. If your bylaws require approval and the surviving American spouse votes no, the children may be stuck with a valuation claim under 1870-1 while the apartment stays in the company. That is a French company-law result. It is not a US probate result, and it is not an escape from French forced heirship.

Forced heirship itself sits in article 913 of the Civil Code, in force in its current wording since 1 November 2021. The reserved fractions are still the classic ones: gifts and wills may not exceed one-half of the estate if the deceased leaves one child, one-third if two children, one-quarter if three or more. The 2021 sentence that matters for Americans is the last one: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” When the deceased or at least one of the children is, at death, a national of an EU member state or habitually resident there, and when the foreign law that governs the succession offers the children no reserved-share mechanism, each child may take a compensatory levy, the prélèvement compensatoire, on the assets situated in France on the date of death, so as to be restored to the reserved rights French law would have given, and no more. The conditions are cumulative. A purely American family, none of whom is an EU national or EU habitual resident, does not walk into that sentence. A mixed family, with one child living in Paris or holding a French or other EU passport, does. The SCI does not write the family out of article 913. If the levy is available, it is available against the assets situated in France on the date of death (biens existants situés en France au jour du décès). Shares of a French-seated SCI that owns a French building are a French asset in that discussion. The child who was disinherited from a house titled in the deceased’s own name has a parallel analysis in our article on the réserve héréditaire and the compensatory levy. Buying through an SCI is not a reliable way to step outside that article.

The reduction action that enforces the réserve has its own clock. Article 921 of the Civil Code provides: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” The action to reduce gifts and bequests that invade the reserved share is time-barred five years after the succession is opened, or two years after the heirs learned of the infringement of their reserved share, and in any event ten years after death. An SCI share legacy that strips a reserved heir is not safer because it is a company document. It is still a liberalité that article 921 can reach, on those deadlines, if French reserved-share law applies to the file.

Which law applies to the succession as a whole is no longer the old split between movable and immovable property, at least in a French court dealing with a death on or after 17 August 2015. EU Regulation 650/2012, which French notaries present as applying to international successions generally and not only to intra-EU families, uses a single law for the entire estate. In the absence of a choice, that law is the law of the deceased’s last habitual residence. The Conseil supérieur du notariat’s note on Regulation 650/2012 states that this connecting factor determines, in principle, the law applicable to the whole of the succession operations, even if that law is the law of a non-member state. An American who dies habitually resident in New York is, in that system, under New York law for the whole estate, house or SCI shares alike, subject to the specific French mechanisms that the Regulation and article 913 still allow. The American who wants New York or California law can also elect the law of his or her nationality in a will, the professio juris, which this desk has already described for an American will covering a French house. You do not need an SCI to make that election. You need a will that French authorities can read.

The older case law on reserved shares and foreign wills remains useful as history, and dangerous as a template. On 4 July 2018, pourvoi no. 17-16.515, published in the Bulletin, the First Civil Chamber, applying the older conflict rule of article 3 of the Civil Code to French immovables, held that the trial court had correctly deduced that “la dévolution successorale desdits immeubles devait tenir compte des règles de la réserve héréditaire, laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel”. The devolution of those immovables had to take account of the reserved-share rules, which, as domestic public policy, could not be displaced by testamentary provisions drawn under the law of the deceased’s domicile and personal status. The decision is at Cour de cassation, 4 July 2018, no. 17-16.515. That was a file about French immovables and a Moroccan-law will, under the pre-Regulation conflict rule for land. It is not a holding that an SCI share is a magic movable. It is a holding that, when French immovable conflict rules applied, French reserved-share law was treated as domestic public policy. Since 17 August 2015 the conflict analysis in a French court starts with Regulation 650/2012. Since 1 November 2021 the compensatory levy in article 913 has its own EU-nationality and EU-residence conditions. Anyone who still sells the SCI as a way to turn the house into a movable and escape the réserve is selling a map of a road that French private international law rebuilt a decade ago.

French inheritance tax is a separate layer, and here the SCI is often worse than useless as a hiding place. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code taxes gratuitous transfers. When the donor or the deceased does not have a French tax domicile, paragraph 2° reaches “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France” Movable and immovable property situated in France, including immovables held indirectly. The article then treats as French, in proportion to the French real estate in the balance sheet, “Sont également considérées comme françaises les actions et parts de sociétés ou personnes morales non cotées en bourse dont le siège est situé hors de France et dont l’actif est principalement constitué d’immeubles ou de droits immobiliers situés sur le territoire français” Unlisted shares of a foreign company whose assets consist mainly of French real estate are themselves treated as French, in that proportion. A French-seated SCI that owns a Paris apartment is not a foreign wrapper at all; it is a French company holding a French immovable. A Delaware company that owns the same apartment, or that owns the SCI, is the fact pattern paragraph 2° was written to catch. The look-through is the point. You cannot make the apartment leave France for inheritance-tax purposes by inserting a company whose only asset is the apartment.

II. What taxes does an American actually pay on a French SCI?

A. How do I calculate the 3% tax, IFI, and the 5% share-transfer duty?

The tax that American structures actually trigger, and that French-language SCI brochures aimed at domestic families almost never mention, is the annual 3 percent tax on the fair market value of French real estate held by legal entities. Article 990 D of the General Tax Code provides: “Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” Legal entities, legal persons, bodies, fiducies, or comparable institutions that own, directly or through an interposed entity, one or more buildings situated in France, or that hold real rights in those buildings, owe an annual tax equal to 3 percent of the fair market value of those buildings or rights. Three percent of value, every year, is not a filing fee. On a €1 million apartment it is €30,000 a year before any income tax, property tax, or US tax. The French tax administration’s page Taxe sur valeur vénale (TVVI), updated 26 May 2023, repeats that the tax hits French and foreign entities, with or without legal personality, that hold French real estate directly or indirectly on 1 January.

The Cour de cassation, Commercial, Financial and Economic Chamber, sitting in a section formation on 28 May 2026, pourvoi no. 24-18.404, restated the same text as the rule of decision: “Selon le premier de ces textes, les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” The Court was deciding a collection-procedure fight about a chain of companies and who had to receive later notices, not a family SCI. The statutory quote in the decision is still the one that applies to an American LLC, a Delaware holding company, or a trust that the French statute treats as a comparable institution. The decision is at Cour de cassation, 28 May 2026, no. 24-18.404. If your New York advisor’s chart shows a US LLC owning the French SCI owning the apartment, article 990 D reads that chart from the bottom: someone in the chain is close enough to the building to be the taxpayer, and interposed entities can be jointly liable.

There is an exemption, and it is a filing, not a vibe. Article 990 E of the General Tax Code lists the cases in which the 990 D tax is not applicable The useful case for an American-owned SCI or US company is 3°, which covers entities that have their seat in France, in an EU member state, or in a country that has concluded with France an administrative-assistance convention against tax fraud and evasion, or a treaty giving them the same treatment as French-seated entities. The United States is in that treaty network; that is why the exemption is available in principle, not why it is automatic. Inside 3°, letter d) exempts entities “Ou qui déclarent chaque année, au plus tard le 15 mai, au lieu fixé par l’arrêté prévu à l’article 990 F du présent code, la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier, l’identité et l’adresse de l’ensemble des actionnaires, associés ou autres membres qui détiennent, à quelque titre que ce soit, plus de 1 % des actions, parts ou autres droits, ainsi que le nombre des actions, parts ou autres droits détenus par chacun d’eux” The entity must declare each year, no later than 15 May, the location, description, and value of the buildings owned on 1 January, and the identity and address of every shareholder or member who holds more than 1 percent, with the number of shares each holds. Letter e) is a partial version of the same idea, with a prorated exemption for the portion of capital whose holders were identified. Impots.gouv.fr says that French companies that already file a 2072 or 2038 return containing those 3° d) particulars are dispensed from form 2746, and that other qualifying foreign entities obtain the 3° e) exemption by filing form 2746 spontaneously by 15 May. A US LLC that owns French real estate and files nothing is the fact pattern the 3 percent tax was designed to punish. A French SCI that files its ordinary 2072 and identifies the American shareholders is usually in the dispensed class, which is one of the few genuine advantages of using a French-seated SCI rather than a naked US company on the title. It is an advantage that lasts only as long as the filing is made.

Wealth tax is the next layer, and the SCI does not remove it. Article 964 of the General Tax Code creates “un impôt annuel sur les actifs immobiliers désigné sous le nom d’impôt sur la fortune immobilière”. That is the annual tax on real-estate assets known as IFI. People are subject to it when the value of their article 965 assets exceeds €1,300,000. Nonresidents are in at 2°: “Les personnes physiques n’ayant pas leur domicile fiscal en France, à raison des biens et droits immobiliers mentionnés au 1° de l’article 965 situés en France et des parts ou actions de sociétés ou organismes mentionnés au 2° du même article 965 , à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de ces mêmes biens et droits immobiliers.” Individuals who do not have their tax domicile in France are taxed on French real-estate rights and on shares of companies, to the extent of the fraction of share value that represents those same French real-estate rights. Article 965, 2° puts into the IFI base “Des parts ou actions des sociétés et organismes établis en France ou hors de France appartenant aux personnes mentionnées au 1° du présent article, à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de biens ou droits immobiliers détenus directement ou indirectement par la société ou l’organisme.” Shares of companies established in France or abroad, to the extent of the fraction of their value representing real-estate rights the company holds directly or indirectly. An American nonresident who owns a €2 million Paris apartment through an SCI still has a French IFI question. The company is a fractioning device, not an exemption. The mechanics of the nonresident IFI return are the same cluster as our second-home IFI filing and US credit article. Forming the SCI does not take the apartment out of article 964. It changes the line on which the apartment is declared.

The transfer tax when you later sell the shares is not the 0.1 percent rate people remember from listed stock. Article 726 of the General Tax Code sets registration duties on transfers of corporate rights. Ordinary shares of a non-real-estate company that is not a joint-stock company are at 1° bis, 3 percent after a small per-share allowance. Real-estate-predominant entities are at 2°: “A 5 % : – pour les cessions de participations dans des personnes morales à prépondérance immobilière.” Five percent on transfers of interests in legal persons with a real-estate predominance. The definition follows immediately: a legal person, of whatever nationality, whose rights are not traded on a regulated market or a multilateral trading facility, and whose assets are or were, during the year before the transfer, mainly composed of buildings or real-estate rights situated in France, or of interests in other unlisted real-estate-predominant entities. A classic family SCI that owns one Paris apartment is the textbook prépondérance immobilière. The 5 percent is assessed on the price expressed plus charges, or on the real value if higher. Americans who were told that selling SCI shares is cheaper than selling the apartment need to run both numbers. A direct sale of the building incurs the ordinary land-registration taxes and notaire’s tariff. A sale of the shares incurs article 726 at 5 percent if the company is real-estate predominant, plus the agrément process under article 1861, plus whatever the buyer demands as a discount for buying a company with history, debts, and a gérant. Sometimes the share deal is still rational. It is never free.

If the SCI later has only one shareholder, the company does not vanish by magic. Article 1844-5 of the Civil Code provides that the gathering of all shares in one pair of hands “n’entraîne pas la dissolution de plein droit de la société.” It does not automatically dissolve the company. Any interested person may petition for dissolution if the situation is not regularized within one year. For an American who outlives a co-shareholder and becomes the sole remaining associé, the clock is one year, not infinity, and a Paris court can be asked to dissolve if nobody regularizes. That is another reason not to treat the SCI as a will substitute. It is a company that can fall out of the two-person pattern article 1832 used as its starting point, and French company law then imposes a cleanup.

B. How are SCI profits taxed in France and reported to the IRS?

On the French income-tax side, the default SCI is transparent. It is not, by default, a corporate taxpayer. Article 8 of the General Tax Code taxes certain company members personally on their share of the company’s profits. After the rules for general partnerships, the article says: “Il en est de même, sous les mêmes conditions : 1° Des membres des sociétés civiles qui ne revêtent pas, en droit ou en fait, l’une des formes de sociétés visées au 1 de l’article 206 et qui, sous réserve des exceptions prévues à l’article 239 ter , ne se livrent pas à une exploitation ou à des opérations visées aux articles 34 et 35” The members of civil companies that do not take, in law or in fact, one of the corporate forms listed in article 206(1), and that do not carry on a commercial or similar exploitation within articles 34 and 35, are personally subject to income tax on their share of the profits. Service-Public’s SCI page states the cash-flow consequence Americans dislike: shareholders are taxed on their fraction of the result even when the SCI does not distribute that amount. If the company collects rent, pays the taxe foncière, and keeps a cash reserve for the roof, you may still have French taxable income. A nonresident American reports that French-source real-estate income on the nonresident return. A US citizen reports it again on the US return and then claims the foreign tax credit the treaty allows, which is a credit-computation problem, not a reason to ignore the French return.

Article 206 of the General Tax Code lists the persons that are subject to corporate income tax, the impôt sur les sociétés, by reason of their form: among others, sociétés anonymes, sociétés à responsabilité limitée that have not elected the partnership regime, and other legal persons carrying on a lucrative exploitation. A civil SCI is not in that automatic list. It can opt into corporate tax. That option is a one-way door for practical purposes and changes the French treatment of contributions, of later share sales, and of the 5 percent contribution duty Service-Public describes when real estate is contributed to an IS company. Americans sometimes elect IS because a French accountant said depreciation would look better. The election also makes the company look more like a corporation for any US classification analysis. That is a trade, not a free lunch. It should be modeled on both sides of the Atlantic before the option is filed, not after the first 2072 is in the archive.

The US reporting overlay is where SCI files go to die in an IRS examination, and it is also where this article must stay inside what the French sources actually prove. France will tax the rent and the company under articles 8 or 206 regardless of what the IRS thinks the SCI “is.” The United States, which taxes its citizens on worldwide income, will classify the same SCI under US entity-classification rules. A multi-member foreign eligible entity is commonly a partnership for US purposes unless it elects to be a corporation. A corporate classification, especially of a company whose income is passive rent, is the fact pattern that leads US accountants to the passive foreign investment company, or PFIC, analysis and to Form 8621. This desk has already walked through a PFIC cleanup on French bank funds. An SCI that has elected French corporate tax, or that the IRS treats as a corporation, can present a related problem, with different forms (often 5471 rather than, or in addition to, 8865). This article does not pretend to classify your SCI from a French lawyer’s desk. It does say that a claim that the notaire created an SCI so the IRS will ignore it is not a classification election. If you already have French mutual funds in a PFIC mess, adding an opaque French company around the apartment is how a house purchase inherits a second US penalty regime.

Beneficial-ownership and banking complete the picture. French banks that open an SCI account will ask for the complete chain of shareholders, FATCA forms, and a French tax identification number for the company. A US LLC sitting above the SCI will be asked the same questions, plus why a US company needs a French current account. The 990 E declaration that keeps the 3 percent tax off the file is, in substance, a beneficial-owner list delivered to the tax office by 15 May. Americans who wanted anonymity from an SCI are looking at the wrong century. The company is on the commercial registry. The building is on the land registry. The 2072 or the 2746 names everyone above 1 percent. The only opacity an SCI still offers is the opacity of a poorly kept minute book, which helps nobody when a shareholder dies and article 1870 has to be applied.

What, then, is an SCI actually good for, for an American? It is useful when several members of a family will co-own French real estate for a long time, want a manager, want to give or sell fractions without conveying the building each time, and are willing to run a company: annual meetings, a French tax return, a US information return, and the 15 May transparency filing if a foreign entity is in the chain. It is useful when the alternative is a naked indivision among siblings who do not get along, because article 1861 plus a well-drafted approval clause can block a hostile sale of a share more cleanly than the default co-ownership statute. It is not useful as a forced-heirship eraser, as a US-trust substitute, as a 3 percent-tax shelter, or as an IFI eraser. Those jobs are done, if they can be done at all, by a will that elects national law, by the article 913 conditions that either apply to your family or do not, by actually filing 990 E, and by the IFI return on the French fraction. The notaire who offers the SCI as a single instrument that performs all four jobs is bundling a company formation with a conflict-of-laws lecture the company does not contain.

A Paris purchase adds logistics, not a different Civil Code. The SCI’s seat, if you place it in Paris, is registered at the Paris commercial-court registry. The deed that puts the apartment into the SCI is received by a Paris notaire and published by the Paris land-publicity service. The tax office that will want the 2072, and the 2746 if a US company sits above, is the French administration identified on impots.gouv.fr, not a New York County clerk. If you are buying in Île-de-France, build those French filing addresses into the closing checklist the way you would build a FIRPTA withholding into a Florida sale. They are not optional local color.

Conclusion

An SCI is a French civil company with legal personality from registration, unlimited proportional liability for its shareholders, restricted transfer of shares, and a death regime that either admits the heirs as shareholders or pays them the value of the shares. That is articles 1832, 1842, 1845, 1857, 1861, 1870, and 1870-1, applied by the Cour de cassation in 19-14.604 and 21-21.698. It is not a US LLC, and it is not a will.

French forced heirship and French inheritance tax do not vanish because the apartment is behind shares. Article 913 still sets reserved fractions and, since 2021, a compensatory levy on assets situated in France when its EU-nationality or EU-residence conditions are met. Article 750 ter still taxes French immovables held directly or indirectly, and unlisted foreign companies whose assets are mainly French real estate. Regulation 650/2012 already gives a single succession law, usually last habitual residence, with a nationality election available in a will. The movable-share trick is not how those texts work.

The taxes that do change are often the ones that get worse. Article 990 D assesses 3 percent of fair market value on entities that hold French real estate, unless article 990 E’s declaration is made on time. Articles 964 and 965 keep SCI shares in the IFI base to the extent they represent French buildings. Article 726 charges 5 percent on transfers of real-estate-predominant interests. Article 8 taxes transparent SCI members on undistributed profits. The IRS will ask its own classification questions on top. If the notaire’s SCI draft is in your closing binder, read the bylaws against 1870 and 1861, read the ownership chart against 990 D and 750 ter, and do not sign because someone translated parts sociales as units in a blocker. The company will survive the closing. The myth will not survive the first death or the first 15 May.

📄 Official circular