KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Father Cut Me Out of His French House: Claiming Your Réserve Héréditaire and Prélèvement Compensatoire

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Father Cut Me Out of His French House: Claiming Your Réserve Héréditaire and Prélèvement Compensatoire

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your father lived in New York, wrote his will under New York law, left the Paris apartment to your brother, and left you nothing. The will says so in plain English, signed before an American notary public, and your brother tells you the matter is closed. For many American families with a house in France, this is the moment when bad advice costs hundreds of thousands of euros, because a will that is perfectly valid in New York can still fail against the forced share that French law gives to children. That forced share is called the réserve héréditaire, and since a French statute of 2021, a child cut out by a foreign-law will has a second weapon as well: a make-up levy on the French property known as the prélèvement compensatoire. This guide explains, in plain American English, how much of a French estate must go to the children, which country’s law decides, how you force the reduction of excessive gifts, how the 2021 make-up levy works when the estate is governed by American law, what taxes France and the United States each take, and which papers a French notaire — the public officer who settles every French estate — will ask you for. A notaire is not the same as an American notary public: in France, the notaire is a highly trained legal officer appointed by the state who authenticates transfers, computes each heir’s share, collects the inheritance tax return, and releases the funds.

I. Can an American will really disinherit you from a French house?

The short answer American readers need first is this: no foreign will, however carefully drafted, can simply erase the rights French law gives to children over property in France, but those rights only help you if the correct law applies and if you act before the deadline. Everything else in this first part explains those two conditions. French succession law starts from the idea that children cannot be fully disinherited. The parent may favor one child, a new spouse, or a charity, but only within a free portion called the quotité disponible, meaning the freely disposable portion. The rest belongs to the children as a group and must reach them free of charges. When the estate includes a French house, that house counts in the calculation whether the deceased lived in Paris, in Brooklyn, or half the year in each place. The fight is therefore never only about what the will says. It is about how large the forced share is, which national law governs the succession, and whether the will’s choice of American law survives contact with the French forced share.

A. How much of the French estate must go to the children: one child, two children, three or more?

French law defines the forced share in the Civil Code in terms every American heir should learn by heart. Article 912 of the Civil Code states: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” In plain English, the forced share is the part of the estate that the law guarantees to protected heirs, called reserved heirs, provided they accept the inheritance. The same article adds: “La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The free portion is whatever is not reserved, and only that part can be given away freely by gifts during life or by will at death. The public information site of the French administration summarizes the same rule for non-lawyers on its page asking whether parents can disinherit children; see Peut-on déshériter ses enfants ?. The amounts themselves are fixed by Article 913 of the Civil Code, which provides: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” Put in American terms: with one child, gifts and legacies combined cannot exceed one half of the estate, so the child’s forced share is one half. With two children, gifts cannot exceed one third, so the two children share a forced two thirds, meaning one third each. With three or more children, gifts cannot exceed one quarter, so the children share a forced three quarters divided equally among them. A child who formally renounces the succession is generally not counted, unless that child is represented by his or her own descendants or received a reportable gift, under the mechanism of Article 845. Take a concrete example with round numbers. An American father dies owning a Paris apartment worth 900,000 euros and bank accounts of 300,000 euros, for a total estate of 1,200,000 euros, and leaves two children. The free portion is one third, or 400,000 euros. The two children together must receive 800,000 euros, or 400,000 euros each. If the will leaves the entire 900,000-euro apartment to the older child, the younger child does not walk away empty-handed: the younger child holds a legal claim for the missing amount against the gifts that exceeded the free portion. The remedy is the reduction action, the action en réduction, which means the lawsuit that cuts excessive gifts back down to the free portion, and it produces a money payment rather than a forced co-ownership of the apartment. Article 924 of the Civil Code confirms that logic: when a gift exceeds the free portion, the recipient must compensate the reserved heirs for the excess, and a reserved heir who also received gifts pays by taking less from the estate, in the mechanism called taking less, or moins prenant. To compute what is excessive, the notaire builds a fictional total mass of all property existing at death plus the value of lifetime gifts reunited fictitiously to that mass. Article 922 of the Civil Code states: “La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur.” Lifetime gifts are added back at their value on the day of death, based on their condition at the time of the gift, after deducting debts. That reunion rule surprises many American families, because a large lifetime gift to one child made ten years earlier still counts when measuring whether the other child’s forced share was invaded. Life insurance deserves a warning of its own. Under standard French case law, a life insurance payout normally escapes the forced-share calculation because it is treated as a direct right of the named beneficiary rather than estate property, which is why parents are sometimes advised to use it. But courts reclassify the premiums as excessive indirect gifts when the premiums were manifestly exaggerated for the parent’s means, and the October 2024 decision discussed below shows heirs routinely litigating that exact point over policies taken out with French insurers. Do not assume a policy automatically defeats your forced share, and do not assume it automatically saves the favored child’s gift either; each policy must be examined line by line. The spouse has a smaller forced share only when there are no descendants, which matters for blended American-French families: as long as any child accepts the succession, the children are the principal reserved heirs. Finally, remember that accepting the succession is a condition of the forced share. An heir who renounces generally loses the forced share attached to that acceptance, subject to representation by his or her own children. Never sign a renunciation sent by a sibling’s lawyer without independent advice, because the document may be presented as a mere formality while it destroys your entire claim.

B. Which law governs the French house: habitual residence or the election of American law?

Before any forced share can be computed, one question controls everything: is the succession governed by French law or by the law of an American state? Since August 17, 2015, that question is answered for France by a European regulation, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of July 4, 2012, often called Brussels IV, published in the Official Journal of the European Union L 201 of July 27, 2012 (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of July 4, 2012). The default rule is habitual residence: the law of the country where the deceased had his or her habitual residence at death governs the whole succession. Habitual residence, or résidence habituelle, means the place of the closest and most stable factual connection, assessed from all the circumstances of the last years of life, including how long and how regularly the person was present, and the conditions and reasons for that presence. Nationality alone does not decide, and the location of the property alone does not decide either. The regulation also offers an escape hatch that American families use constantly: the choice-of-law election, called professio juris, a Latin term meaning the formal choice of the applicable law expressed in the will. Under Article 22 of the regulation, a person may elect the law of a country of his or her nationality at the time of the choice or at death, so an American citizen can validly elect New York law or California law in the will. Our firm’s companion guide to that election, which explains the notarial formalities an American will must satisfy to be effective in France, is the natural starting point before reading further: American will for a French house: electing United States law before the French notaire. The leading French court decision on habitual residence reads like a cautionary tale written for American families. In a judgment of May 29, 2019, case number 18-13.383, published with the highest editorial markings, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the Court of Cassation, which is France’s supreme court for civil matters, dealt with a father who died in New York leaving three children and a will that disinherited one daughter. The daughter argued that her father had his habitual residence in Paris and sued her brother and sister in France for a court-ordered partition. The Court recalled the governing principle in these terms: “sont compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble d’une succession les juridictions de l’État membre dans lequel le défunt avait sa résidence habituelle au moment de son décès”, meaning the courts of the member state where the deceased had habitual residence at death hear the whole succession. It then approved a global assessment: the father divided his time between the United States and Paris without either period being decisive, so nationality and the location of the principal assets became the tie-breakers. The court listed American nationality, birth and death in New York, an entire professional life in New York real estate, a will drafted in New York declaring New York residence, close family mostly in the United States, several valuable New York buildings, a fixed New York address held for over forty years and shown on passports, burial chosen next to parents in Brooklyn, New York tax domicile, regular voting in New York, no French health coverage, and a treating physician in New York. The Paris apartment, filled with personal objects, paid for by the father, and used during surgeries in Paris, was not enough. Habitual residence was fixed in New York, and the French courts declared themselves without jurisdiction over the succession as a whole. The official decision is published at Cour de cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, May 29, 2019, No. 18-13.383. Three lessons follow for Americans. First, a Paris pied-à-terre, however beloved, does not by itself move habitual residence to France when the center of life remained American. Second, electing American law in the will does not spare the family a fight over jurisdiction for the French assets, because French courts keep jurisdiction over French immovable property in several configurations, and the French forced-share correction described below can still bite. Third, if habitual residence genuinely moved to France — retirement in Provence, French tax domicile, French doctor, daily life in France — then French law governs the whole succession by default, and the American will is read through French forced-share rules. Families should therefore preserve evidence of daily life early: tax notices, health coverage, voter registration, medical records, travel logs, and the address declared in the will itself, because courts weigh all of it together.

II. How do you actually get your money: reduction action, make-up levy, taxes, and the notaire file?

Knowing the forced share in theory is only half the battle. French successions move through the notaire’s office on strict timetables, and the disinherited child must convert a legal principle into a payment: either by reducing excessive gifts under French law, or, when American law governs and offers no forced share, by levying the 2021 make-up amount against the French assets. Both routes end at the same practical questions of proof, deadlines, taxes in two countries, and the file the notaire demands. This part walks through each step in the order a family actually meets them, including the specific courts and offices that handle Paris and Ile-de-France files, because most American-owned French property sits in that region.

A. How do you force the reduction or claim the make-up levy before the deadline runs out?

The classic weapon is the reduction action. Article 921 of the Civil Code reserves that action to the protected heirs, their heirs, and their assigns: neither the recipients of the gifts, nor the legatees, nor the creditors of the deceased can demand it. The same article sets the deadline that destroys more claims than any other rule: “Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” In English, the reduction action must be brought within five years after the succession opens, or within two years after the heirs learned of the invasion of their forced share, and never more than ten years after death. The Court of Cassation spelled out how those periods combine in a published judgment of February 7, 2024, case number 22-13.665: “Il résulte de ce texte que, pour être recevable, l’action en réduction doit être intentée dans les cinq ans à compter du décès ou, au-delà, jusqu’à dix ans après le décès à condition d’être exercée dans les deux ans qui ont suivi la découverte de l’atteinte à la réserve.” In other words, suing within five years of death is always timely; beyond five years you have until ten years after death, but only if you sue within two years after discovering the invasion. The official decision is at Cour de cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, February 7, 2024, No. 22-13.665. Older successions obey transitional rules that a second published decision clarified on October 23, 2024, case number 22-19.365, holding that for successions opened before January 1, 2007, the former thirty-year period was cut to five years by the prescription reform law of June 17, 2008, so that the action expired no later than June 18, 2013: “Il résulte du premier de ces textes, applicable aux successions ouvertes avant le 1er janvier 2007, que l’action en réduction d’une donation de nature à porter atteinte à la réserve se prescrit par trente ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession.” The full ruling, which annulled a Bastia appeal decision for ignoring the cut-off, is at Cour de cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, October 23, 2024, No. 22-19.365. Since the 2006 reform, the notaire who spots a possible invasion must warn each known heir individually, before any partition, of the right to demand reduction — see the final paragraph of Article 921. That warning letter is often the document that starts the two-year discovery clock, so keep it. The second weapon applies when the succession is governed by American law that gives children no forced share. The statute of May 31, 2021, rewrote the tail of Article 913 of the Civil Code to add this sentence: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” In English, when the deceased or at least one child was, at death, a national of a European Union member state or habitually resident there, and the applicable foreign law offers children no forced-share protection at all, each child may take a compensatory levy from the assets located in France at death, restoring the French forced share, capped at that share. Note the trigger conditions carefully. The levy needs a European anchor — a French or other EU nationality or habitual residence of the deceased or of at least one child — plus a foreign law with no protective mechanism for children. A New York will that leaves everything to one child typically satisfies the second condition, because New York has no forced share for adult children. But an all-American family with no EU nationality and no habitual residence in Europe cannot use the levy, even for a Paris apartment. Commentators, including the London analysis at Farrer & Co on the 2021 mechanism and its tension with Brussels IV, note that the levy remains controversial at the European level, with complaints arguing it conflicts with the regulation’s unity of the applicable law; the Farrer piece on the 2021 mechanism and the practitioner guide on forced heirship in France both agree on the core practice point that French notaires must now identify and inform children left without their French forced share. Our article adds what those general guides do not: the American-facing procedure. In practice, the disinherited child in Paris and the Ile-de-France region proceeds as follows. First, within weeks of learning of the death, write to the notaire handling the succession — for Paris property this is usually a Paris office, and court litigation goes to the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, the Paris trial court with jurisdiction over the location of the property — asserting reserved-heir status, requesting the Article 921 warning, and demanding a full statement of lifetime gifts with valuations. Second, commission an independent valuation of the Paris property and gather the American documents: the will, any trust instrument, probate filings, lifetime deeds, and bank records showing transfers. A living trust does not shield French real estate from the forced share or the levy, a point developed in our companion piece on executors and notaire control: American executor and the French house: notaire control, sale, and taxes. Third, have counsel compute the fictional mass under Article 922 and serve a formal demand for reduction or for the compensatory levy, identifying the French assets targeted. Fourth, if the favored heir refuses, file suit before the Paris court within the five-year safe period; do not drift toward the ten-year outer limit counting on the discovery extension, because courts examine when you actually received the notaire’s accounts. Practical Paris points: allow six to twelve months for the notaire phase when American documents need apostilles and sworn translations, expect the court to order a judicial valuation of the apartment, and budget for the notaire’s proportional fees plus counsel. If a parent has just died and the bank has frozen the accounts, the companion guide on proof of heirship and release of funds applies in parallel: American father died, French bank froze the account: heirship proof, tax, and release.

B. How much tax will France and the United States each take on your share?

Winning the forced share or the levy fixes the size of your slice. Tax decides how much of it you keep, and Americans face two tax systems at once. France taxes the slice under its gift and inheritance tax, the droits de mutation à titre gratuit, literally the transfer taxes on gratuitous transfers. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code sets the territorial scope: “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France, et notamment les fonds publics, parts d’intérêts, biens ou droits composant un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis et produits qui y sont capitalisés, créances et généralement toutes les valeurs mobilières françaises ou étrangères de quelque nature qu’elles soient, lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B”, and, where the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France, the French tax still reaches French immovable property and French movable assets. Read with the treaty below, this means the Paris apartment is taxed in France whether the father lived in New York or in Paris. The rates between parents and children are progressive. Article 777 of the General Tax Code fixes the direct-line scale from 5 percent on the first 8,072 euros of the net taxable share up to 45 percent above 1,805,677 euros, with intermediate brackets at 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 percent. Before applying those rates, each child deducts a personal allowance. Article 779 of the General Tax Code provides: “Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.”, a 100,000-euro allowance on each living child’s share, renewable for gifts every fifteen years. The surviving spouse, by contrast, is fully exempt from French inheritance tax, which matters when the American father was married: the spouse takes free of French tax while the children’s shares above the allowance are taxed. The inheritance tax return, called the déclaration de succession, must be filed with the French tax office within six months after death when death occurred in France, or within twelve months when death occurred abroad such as in New York, with interest and penalties for late filing. The notaire normally prepares and files it and pays the tax from estate funds before distributing. The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on worldwide transfers, so the same Paris apartment can in principle be taxed on both sides. Double taxation is relieved by the estate and gift tax treaty between France and the United States signed on November 24, 1978, whose consolidated text the French tax administration publishes at impots.gouv.fr, consolidated Franco-American convention of November 24, 1978, with article-by-article commentary in the official tax bulletin at BOFiP INT-CVB-USA-20, Convention between France and the United States on estates and gifts. The mechanism Americans must grasp is the foreign tax credit: the treaty allocates primary taxing rights over French immovable property to France and then lets the American side credit the French tax paid against the United States federal estate or gift tax on the same property, within treaty limits and ordering rules. Because the United States federal estate exemption remains very high — over thirteen million dollars per individual in recent years, with a scheduled change in the law that Congress debates regularly — most middle-class Paris apartments produce French tax but no residual American estate tax, while very large estates can owe on both sides with the credit softening the second bill. State-level estate taxes, such as New York’s own estate tax with its much lower exemption, are not covered by the treaty and must be modeled separately. Income tax follows its own track: if you later sell the recovered apartment, French capital gains rules and the treaty credit apply as explained in our companion guide to selling: American selling a French house: capital gains tax, treaty credit, and closing. Two compliance traps close this section. First, American heirs remain subject to United States information reporting on foreign accounts and foreign gifts or bequests above statutory thresholds, handled by your American CPA alongside the French return; the French payment does not replace American filings. Second, lifetime gifts from the father that are reunited fictitiously for the forced-share calculation keep their own tax history: a gift taxed in France fifteen or more years ago does not generate fresh French tax when it is merely counted back into the mass, but recent gifts can still affect allowances. Bring your American CPA and the French notaire into the same conversation before anyone signs the partition, because the partition deed, the acte de partage, meaning the authentic instrument dividing the estate, crystallizes both the civil and the tax positions at once.

Conclusion

An American will that cuts a child out of a French house is the beginning of the analysis, not the end. Measure the forced share under Articles 912 and 913, identify whether French law governs through habitual residence or American law through a valid election in the will, and remember the New York–Paris lesson that a beloved apartment does not by itself move a life centered in America to France. Then convert the principle into money: demand the reduction of excessive gifts within the five-year safe period, capped at ten years with prompt action after discovery, or, where American law governs and offers children no protection, levy the 2021 compensatory amount against the French assets if the European anchor is present. Price the victory net of tax by combining the French scale and the 100,000-euro allowance per child with the Franco-American treaty’s credit on the United States side. Above all, move early: write to the notaire, freeze the valuations, and refuse to sign any renunciation or partition until counsel has computed the fictional mass. Handled that way, the French house your father meant to give to one child becomes what French law intends — a family asset shared according to rules no private will can wish away.

📄 Official circular