KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
We Are an American Couple Buying a House in France: Should We Sign a PACS First, What the Survivor Really Gets, and What the IRS Still Taxes

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

We Are an American Couple Buying a House in France: Should We Sign a PACS First, What the Survivor Really Gets, and What the IRS Still Taxes

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American couple, unmarried, and you have found the house in France you want to buy together. A French friend tells you to sign a PACS before going to the notaire, the public officer who authenticates property sales and settles estates in France. A PACS, or pacte civil de solidarité, is the French registered civil partnership: less than a marriage, more than living together, open to same-sex and different-sex couples. Your questions are practical. Does the PACS change who owns the house? If one of you pays most of the mortgage, can that money be recovered later? If one of you dies, does the survivor keep the house, or can children from a first relationship take it back? And what does the United States tax, given that Washington does not treat a PACS as a marriage? This article answers those four questions in order, with the exact statutes, three published decisions of the Cour de cassation, the French high court for civil and criminal matters, and the tax rules on both sides of the Atlantic.

The short version is this. The PACS organizes your daily financial duties and gives you a default separation of property, but it never makes your partner your heir. Only a will gives the survivor rights in the house, and even a will cannot defeat the forced share of children, called the réserve héréditaire. At death France fully exempts the surviving partner from succession tax, but lifetime gifts between partners get only a fixed allowance, and breaking the PACS too soon claws that allowance back. On the American side, none of the French protections travel: PACS partners file as single, cannot split income, and get no unlimited marital deduction. The sections below walk through each step with the texts that control your file.

I. What Signing a PACS Changes the Day You Buy the French House

A. How Do We Sign a PACS Before the Purchase, and Who Owns the House We Buy Together?

A PACS is a contract, and the statute says so in its first line. Article 515-1 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Un pacte civil de solidarité est un contrat conclu par deux personnes physiques majeures, de sexe différent ou de même sexe, pour organiser leur vie commune.” Two adults of either sex organize their life together by contract. That contractual nature is the first thing Americans must absorb: a PACS creates only the effects the statute and your written PACS agreement, called the convention de PACS, give it. It does not copy marriage.

Signing is simpler than most Americans expect. Article 515-3 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Les personnes qui concluent un pacte civil de solidarité en font la déclaration conjointe devant l’officier de l’état civil de la commune dans laquelle elles fixent leur résidence commune ou, en cas d’empêchement grave à la fixation de celle-ci, devant l’officier de l’état civil de la commune où se trouve la résidence de l’une des parties.” You file a joint declaration before the civil registrar of the town where you set your common residence. Since the 2017 reform, the registrar of the town hall, and no longer the court clerk, records standard PACS filings, and a notaire can also record the agreement and tailor it. For an American couple closing on a house, the notarial route is usually the better one: the same notaire who authenticates your deed can draft a PACS agreement fitted to the purchase, choosing between separation of property and joint ownership of what you acquire together, called indivision, and stating each partner’s share in the deed itself. The government’s own guidance confirms the procedure and adds the warning that matters most for this article: to pass anything at death, the partner must write a will. France’s public service site states the rule plainly on its PACS procedure page, and the sections below explain why that will is indispensable.

Ownership during the PACS follows a default of separation. Article 515-5 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “chacun des partenaires conserve l’administration, la jouissance et la libre disposition de ses biens personnels.” Unless your agreement says otherwise, each partner keeps administration, enjoyment, and free disposal of personal property. In plain terms, what you earn and buy stays yours, and shared ownership exists only where you create it: by buying the house expressly in both names, typically fifty-fifty or in the proportions you fund, which the deed then records. Since the 2006 reform, the default regime is separation; the old default of joint ownership of acquisitions survives only if your agreement expressly opts into it. Tell the notaire before the preliminary contract, the compromis, what shares you want, because the shares written in the deed determine everything later: capital gains splits, rental splits, and the size of each partner’s estate.

Two cautions follow. First, debts for daily life bind both of you. Article 515-4 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Les partenaires liés par un pacte civil de solidarité s’engagent à une vie commune, ainsi qu’à une aide matérielle et une assistance réciproques. Si les partenaires n’en disposent autrement, l’aide matérielle est proportionnelle à leurs facultés respectives.” Partners owe each other common life, material support, and mutual assistance, and support is proportional to each one’s means unless agreed otherwise. Landlords, utilities, and household creditors can pursue either partner for ordinary living debts, except for manifestly excessive spending. Second, ending the PACS is unilateral and fast, which is both a feature and a danger. Article 515-7 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Le pacte civil de solidarité se dissout par la mort de l’un des partenaires ou par le mariage des partenaires ou de l’un d’eux.” Death or marriage dissolves it automatically, and a one-sided declaration to the registrar or the recording notaire ends it as well. If you marry each other later, the PACS ends and the marriage’s property regime takes over, a point couples who PACS in a hurry before closing and marry years later often forget to coordinate with their deed.

For couples who hesitate between a PACS and staying simply unmarried, our companion guide on the survivor rights of unmarried buyers and the tontine fix sets out the alternative, and couples weighing marriage itself should read our guide on which matrimonial property regime applies and what happens on divorce or death. The PACS sits between those two options: stronger than informal cohabitation, weaker than marriage, and decisive mainly through the will and the deed shares you pair with it.

B. I Paid Most of the Mortgage While My Partner Paid Less: Can I Claim That Money Back?

This is the dispute that fills family courts after PACS breakups: one partner earned four or five times more, paid every mortgage installment on the jointly owned home, and then demands a reimbursement claim, called a créance, at the split. The Cour de cassation answered that question in a published decision every PACS homeowner should know. On January 27, 2021, appeal number 19-26.140, decision number 103 FS-P, a man who had paid all the loan installments on the undivided house, the indivis home bought fifty-fifty before the PACS, claimed a credit for the period covered by the partnership. The high court rejected him. It held, and I quote, “les règlements relatifs à l’acquisition du bien immobilier opérés par celui-ci participaient de l’exécution de l’aide matérielle entre partenaires et en a exactement déduit, sans inverser la charge de la preuve, qu’il ne pouvait prétendre bénéficier d’une créance à ce titre.” Payments toward acquiring the property counted as performance of the mutual material support owed between partners, so no reimbursement claim existed for them. Read the full decision on the Cour de cassation website, appeal 19-26.140.

The reasoning turns entirely on the second sentence of article 515-4 quoted above: support proportional to means. The appeal court had found unequal contributive capacities, one income four to five times the other, bank statements showing the lower earner near zero, and loan installments the lower earner plainly could not have half-paid. The Cour de cassation endorsed that method: once a court sovereignly finds the payments matched the payer’s proportional share of support, those payments legally are support, not a loan to the couple. The holding generalizes well beyond the facts. Whoever earns more and pays more of a shared roof during the PACS should assume those overpayments are gone, absorbed into the duty of material assistance, unless a written agreement says otherwise.

Three practical consequences follow for American buyers. First, put the financing deal in the PACS agreement or in a side acknowledgment before the first payment. If one partner funds the down payment alone but takes only a half share in the deed, state whether the difference is a gift, a loan with a repayment date, or an unequal share reflecting the funding. A short clause beats a five-year lawsuit. Second, keep money traceable. Pay the down payment and the monthly installments by transfer from a personal account with the property reference in the memo line, and keep the foreign wire slips showing dollars converted to euros for this purchase. Third, align the deed shares with the money. If one partner contributes seventy percent of the price, consider taking seventy percent in the deed rather than an even split plus a vague promise to settle later. Deed shares are public, opposable to third parties, and far harder to relitigate than oral understandings about who really paid.

Note the boundary of the 2021 holding. It covers payments during the PACS that fit within proportional support. Money paid before the PACS began, a down payment documented as a loan, or payments far beyond any plausible support proportion can still ground a claim under ordinary unjust-enrichment or loan rules. And dissolving the PACS does not itself rewind the support: support performed stays performed. Couples who want a different outcome must contract for it up front, because courts will not rewrite the financing after the breakup.

II. What the Surviving Partner Gets When One of Us Dies, and What Each Country Taxes

A. Does My Partner Automatically Inherit the House, or Can My Children Take It Back?

No, your partner inherits nothing automatically. Article 731 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “La succession est dévolue par la loi aux parents et au conjoint successibles du défunt dans les conditions définies ci-après.” Intestate succession goes by law to relatives and to the surviving spouse. The PACS partner appears nowhere in the intestate order: no automatic share, no forced share, no priority. The government’s guidance says the same thing in practical terms: for the partner to take any part of the estate, a will is required. Sign the PACS and skip the will, and the survivor is a legal stranger to the estate, however many years you lived together and however jointly you paid the mortgage.

The will fixes the gap but meets a hard limit where children exist. This guide approaches the PACS from the pre-purchase side; for the post-death counterpart, see our companion analysis of whether an American partner can inherit from a French PACS partner, which covers the will, the property transfer, and the treaty from the heir’s side. Article 912 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” The forced share, the réserve, goes free of charges to protected heirs, and only the disposable portion, the quotité disponible, can pass by gift or will. Children are protected heirs; the PACS partner is not. With one child, the disposable portion is one half; with two children, one third; with three or more, one quarter. A will leaving the partner the entire half of the house you owned fails against two children, who can claw back the excess through the reduction action, called action en reduction. American testators used to unlimited testamentary freedom find this shocking, but French courts apply it mechanically, including against foreign wills covering French real estate where French law governs the succession.

Within the disposable portion, the statute gives the survivor two targeted tools, both conditional on a will. Article 515-6 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Les dispositions des articles 831, 831-2, 832-3 et 832-4 sont applicables entre partenaires d’un pacte civil de solidarité en cas de dissolution de celui-ci. Les dispositions du premier alinéa de l’article 831-3 sont applicables au partenaire survivant lorsque le défunt l’a expressément prévu par testament.” The preferential award rules apply between partners, and the survivor gets the preferential award of the home where the deceased expressly provided for it by will. In practice, the will should expressly grant the partner the right to be awarded the house lot on division, compensating the other heirs in money. The same article adds a housing bridge: when the PACS ends by death, the survivor can invoke the first two paragraphs of article 763 where the will so provides. Article 763 of the Civil Code provides, and I quote, “Si, à l’époque du décès, le conjoint successible occupe effectivement, à titre d’habitation principale, un logement appartenant aux époux ou dépendant totalement de la succession, il a de plein droit, pendant une année, la jouissance gratuite de ce logement, ainsi que du mobilier, compris dans la succession, qui le garnit.” The qualifying occupant gets one year of free use of the main home plus its furnishings. For the PACS survivor, that year is not automatic: it exists only if the will grants it. Draft both clauses, the preferential award and the one-year housing right, into each partner’s will, and mirror them so whichever partner dies first, the survivor is covered.

A 2018 decision of the Cour de cassation makes drafting and signing those wills easier than many notaires assumed. On February 28, 2018, appeal number 17-10.876, decision 210 FS-P+B+I, an appeal court had annulled an authentic will, the notarial will form, because one witness was bound by a PACS to the legatee, treating the partner as an in-law incapable of witnessing. The high court quashed that ruling. It held, and I quote, “l’alliance étant établie par le seul effet du mariage, la qualité de partenaire d’un pacte civil de solidarité n’emporte pas incapacité à être témoin lors de l’établissement d’un testament authentique instituant l’autre partenaire légataire, la cour d’appel a violé le texte susvisé” Relationship by marriage comes only from marriage itself, so PACS status alone does not disqualify a witness to the notarial will naming the other partner as legatee. Read the full decision on the Cour de cassation website, appeal 17-10.876. The lesson is not to recruit your partner’s PACS mate as your witness on purpose; it is that wills protecting a PACS partner rest on solid ground, and formal objections built on equating PACS with marriage fail.

Put the estate plan together in this order. First, each partner signs a will covering the French house share, with the preferential award clause and the one-year housing clause. Second, check the children’s arithmetic: size the gifts so they fit inside the disposable portion, and consider life insurance, assurance-vie with a named beneficiary, for any top-up, since its payout sits largely outside the estate. Third, verify the applicable law: Americans can usually choose American law for the succession under the European Succession Regulation, but that choice does not import American forced-share freedom into French land where French courts still police the réserve through clawback mechanics, so keep the French-law sizing even when an American-law election exists. Fourth, record everything with the notaire holding the deed, so the survivor’s file is found in days, not months.

B. How France Exempts the Survivor but Claws Back Early Gifts, and Why America Still Calls Us Single

France is generous at death and strict during life. Start with the good news. Article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code provides, and I quote, “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” The surviving spouse and the partner bound to the deceased by a PACS are exempt from death transfer duties. Whatever the survivor takes under the will, within the disposable portion, passes free of French succession tax. The rate table confirms the couple’s privileged lane: Article 777 of the General Tax Code applies its second table, and I quote, “Tableau II Tarif des droits applicables entre époux et entre partenaires liés par un pacte civil de solidarité” to spouses and PACS partners alike. File the estate declaration on time anyway, because exemption from tax is not exemption from paperwork, and late or missing declarations draw penalties and interest even at a zero rate.

Lifetime gifts are a different bargain. Article 790 F of the General Tax Code provides, and I quote, “Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit entre vifs, il est effectué un abattement de 80 724 € sur la part du partenaire lié au donateur par un pacte civil de solidarité.” Gifts between partners get an 80,724 euro allowance, with tax only above it. But the same article claws the allowance back from short-lived partnerships, and I quote, “Le bénéfice de cet abattement est remis en cause lorsque le pacte prend fin au cours de l’année civile de sa conclusion ou de l’année suivante pour un motif autre que le mariage entre les partenaires ou le décès de l’un d’entre eux.” End the PACS in the year it was signed or the next year for any reason other than marrying each other or death, and the allowance is retroactively lost. Couples who PACS on Monday, receive a large gift on Tuesday, and split the following spring pay full tax as if the allowance never existed. Time large gifts accordingly, and never use a convenience PACS as a gift-tax wrapper.

A May 2025 decision shows how a PACS can even cost a family an exemption it otherwise held. On May 28, 2025, appeal number 21-16.632, published in the Bulletin, the commercial chamber held that the sibling cohabitation exemption was unavailable to a person bound by a PACS to a third party. The exemption in Article 796-0 ter of the General Tax Code, and I quote, “Est exonérée de droits de mutation par décès la part de chaque frère ou soeur, célibataire, veuf, divorcé ou séparé de corps,” requires, among other conditions, a single, widowed, divorced, or judicially separated sibling constantly domiciled with the deceased for five years. The Court ruled, and I quote, “l’exonération prévue par ce dernier texte ne peut bénéficier à une personne qui, au jour de l’ouverture de la succession, était liée à un tiers par un pacte civil de solidarité.” A surviving PACS partner living with a brother or sister loses the sibling exemption because, through the common-life commitment of article 515-4, PACS life is incompatible with the single status the exemption demands. Read the full decision on the Cour de cassation website, appeal 21-16.632. Before signing, map every exemption each partner currently enjoys as a legally single person; the PACS signature can switch some of them off.

Now cross the Atlantic, where none of the French advantages automatically travel. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide gifts and estates, and for federal tax purposes it treats as married only couples lawfully married. The Treasury stated the marriage rule for federal tax in its ruling announcement of August 29, 2013, implementing IRS Revenue Ruling 2013-17: only couples lawfully married are treated as married for federal tax purposes. A PACS is a registered contract, not a marriage ceremony, so PACS partners are single in the eyes of the Internal Revenue Service. That single word, single, carries five consequences. You cannot file a joint federal return or split income. No unlimited marital deduction shelters gifts or bequests to your partner; lifetime gifts use the annual exclusion for the year of the gift and then eat into your lifetime exemption, reported on Form 709, the gift tax return. At death, what you leave your partner counts in your taxable estate with no marital deduction and no portability of unused exemption to a non-spouse. The French house you own directly sits in your American gross estate at its dollar value, and the French succession-tax exemption under article 796-0 bis generates no foreign tax credit because there is no French tax paid to credit. Finally, the 1978 France-United States estate and gift tax treaty allocates taxing rights over real estate to the country where the property sits and relieves double taxation by credit, but it does not create a marital status the Internal Revenue Code withholds. Run the French and American files in parallel from the first month: the French notaire does not file your American returns, and your American accountant cannot sign the French declaration.

Close the loop with three administrative habits. First, fund the purchase by wire from personal accounts and keep every slip: the notaire must verify the source of funds against money-laundering rules, and the paper trail sets both countries’ cost basis. Second, report the French bank accounts every year to the United States, since the PACS changes nothing about foreign-account reporting. Third, revisit the plan at each life event, birth of a child, new child from either side, marriage, breakup, or move back to the United States, because each event redraws the disposable portion, the deed shares, and the American exemption math. A PACS is a strong frame for buying together, but the picture inside the frame is painted by the will, the deed, and the two tax files.

Conclusion

An American couple buying a French house should treat the PACS for what it is: a useful contract, not a marriage and not an inheritance. Sign it before the notaire where it helps, choose your deed shares deliberately, and write into the agreement what happens to unequal payments, because the Cour de cassation treats the higher earner’s overpayments as support owed, not money lent. At death the partner takes nothing without a will, takes only within the disposable portion against children, and keeps the roof through the preferential award and the one-year housing right only where the will expressly grants them. France then exempts the survivor from succession tax while policing lifetime gifts with an allowance that evaporates if the PACS dies young, and a PACS with a third party can even forfeit a sibling’s cohabitation exemption. America, finally, ignores the PACS for marital status: single filing, no marital deduction, gift and estate returns on your own name, and no credit for French tax never paid. Sign the partnership, write the wills, size the shares, fund by traceable wire, and run both countries’ files together, and the French house can shelter you both under each country’s law.

📄 Official circular