You are an American parent with a house in France, a bank account in Paris, or children living on both sides of the Atlantic. Your US will leaves everything to your new spouse, or divides the estate unevenly between your children because one of them already received help buying a home in Austin. Then a French notaire tells you that none of that may survive contact with French law: your children may own a fixed fraction of your estate no matter what your will says, and any gift or bequest that eats into their share can be clawed back in court years later. For Americans raised on testamentary freedom, this is the single hardest idea in French succession law. It has a name, the réserve héréditaire (forced share), and it changes every estate plan that touches France. This guide explains, for an American reader with no French legal background, how much of your estate your children are guaranteed, how a disinherited child fights back and within what deadlines, when your choice of American law can protect your will and when it cannot, what the famous 2017 Jarre ruling about a California trust really decided, how the 2021 compensatory levy gives some children a second chance against foreign law, and how French and American death taxes interact. Every decisive statement below is anchored to the exact French statute, European regulation, or court decision quoted in the text.
I. Can an American Will Cut Out a Child When French Law Applies?
A. What Is the French Forced Share and How Much Must Each Child Receive?
Start with the vocabulary, because the French terms will follow you through every meeting with a notaire. The réserve héréditaire is the slice of your estate that the law reserves for certain heirs, called héritiers réservataires (forced heirs). For most American families that means your children, and only your children: since a 2006 reform, parents and siblings are no longer forced heirs in France. The rest of the estate is the quotité disponible (freely disposable share), the only part you can give to anyone you like, including a new spouse, a charity, or one favored child. The Civil Code states the distinction in one sentence:
“La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités.” (Article 912 of the Civil Code)
In plain English: the forced share must reach your children free of strings attached, and only what is left over is truly yours to direct. A bequest that burdens a child’s share with a lifetime obligation, a trust-like arrangement unknown to French law, or a condition that the child share the family home with a stepparent can itself violate the guarantee.
The size of the forced share depends only on how many children survive you, or are represented by their own children if one of them predeceased you. The fractions are fixed by statute and every notaire in France applies the same table:
“Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” (Article 913 of the Civil Code)
Translated into shares: with one child, the child is guaranteed one half and you can freely dispose of one half. With two children, each child is guaranteed one third, so the combined forced share is two thirds and your free share is one third. With three or more children, the children together are guaranteed three quarters, divided equally, and your free share is one quarter. Note what the rule covers: all voluntary transfers, whether made during your lifetime (donations) or by will (legs). You cannot defeat the forced share by giving the house away while you are alive and leaving an empty estate at death, because lifetime gifts are pulled back into the calculation.
That calculation has a technical name, the fictitious reunion (réunion fictive), and it is where American families most often discover the problem too late. The notaire rebuilds a theoretical estate: everything you own at death, plus everything you ever gave away, valued under specific rules, minus debts:
“La réduction se détermine en formant une masse de tous les biens existant au décès du donateur ou testateur. Les biens dont il a été disposé par donation entre vifs sont fictivement réunis à cette masse, d’après leur état à l’époque de la donation et leur valeur à l’ouverture de la succession, après qu’en ont été déduites les dettes ou les charges les grevant.” (Article 922 of the Civil Code)
Take a concrete example. An American father living in Lyon owns a house worth 700,000 euros and accounts worth 200,000 euros at death, so 900,000 euros on hand. Ten years earlier he gave 300,000 euros to his elder son to buy a home in Texas. The theoretical mass is 1,200,000 euros. With two children, the combined forced share is two thirds, or 800,000 euros, meaning 400,000 euros per child, and the freely disposable share is 400,000 euros. If his French will leaves 600,000 euros to his second wife, the free share is exceeded by 200,000 euros, and the children can demand that excess back even though the lifetime gift to the elder son counts toward filling his own share. Gifts made years earlier, a Paris apartment signed over to one child, or money wired to the United States all resurface in this arithmetic, which is why our companion guide on lifetime gifts between American siblings explains how the equalization mechanism works in detail (lifetime gifts and equalization between heirs).
One refinement matters for blended families. A child who formally renounces the succession (renonciation) is generally no longer counted when computing the shares, which increases the portions of the remaining children, unless the renouncing child is represented by his own descendants or received a gift that must be brought back into account. The statute says:
“L’enfant qui renonce à la succession n’est compris dans le nombre d’enfants laissés par le défunt que s’il est représenté ou s’il est tenu au rapport d’une libéralité en application des dispositions de l’article 845 .” (Article 913 of the Civil Code)
Renunciation is therefore not a tool for inflating the free share at the expense of the other children; the math protects whoever stays. If you are the child considering renunciation because the estate carries debts, read our guide on refusing a French succession before signing anything (how an American heir can renounce a French succession).
Compare this with what most Americans know from home. In almost every US state, you can disinherit an adult child entirely; only a surviving spouse has a protected minimum, the elective share, and even that varies by state. France reverses the picture: the spouse has no forced share at all, only targeted protections such as a one-year free occupancy of the family home and a lifetime right of use over it, while the children hold an untouchable collective guarantee. An American will that says “I intentionally leave nothing to my son” is perfectly valid in Texas and partially void in France, and the French notaire settling an estate that includes French property will apply the French fractions to the French assets unless a valid choice of foreign law displaces them, which is the subject of Part II.
B. How Does a Disinherited Child Fight Back, and How Long Does the Child Have?
French law gives the injured child a dedicated weapon, the action for reduction (action en réduction), which cuts excessive gifts and bequests down to the size of the free share. Three features define it: who can sue, in what order the gifts are attacked, and how the child is actually paid.
First, standing is narrow. Only the forced heirs themselves, or their own heirs and successors, can demand reduction. A disinherited child’s creditors cannot sue in the child’s place, and neither the beneficiaries of the excessive gifts nor the estate’s creditors can turn the action to their own profit:
“La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter.” (Article 921 of the Civil Code)
Second, the deadlines are strict and layered, and missing them ends the case. The same article fixes a five-year limitations period running from the opening of the succession, meaning the date of death, or two years running from the day the heirs learned that their forced share had been impaired, with an absolute ceiling of ten years from death:
“Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” (Article 921 of the Civil Code)
For an American child who learns late that a French parent died, or that a Paris apartment was signed away years earlier, the two-year discovery window matters enormously, but the ten-year guillotine is absolute. Do not wait for the family to agree; have the impairment assessed as soon as you learn of the death or the gift.
Third, there is an order of attack that protects lifetime gifts at the expense of testamentary ones. Wills are reduced before lifetime gifts are touched, and among lifetime gifts the most recent gift is attacked first, working backward in time:
“Il n’y aura jamais lieu à réduire les donations entre vifs, qu’après avoir épuisé la valeur de tous les biens compris dans les dispositions testamentaires ; et lorsqu’il y aura lieu à cette réduction, elle se fera en commençant par la dernière donation, et ainsi de suite en remontant des dernières aux plus anciennes.” (Article 923 of the Civil Code)
In practice this means a bequest of the French house to a surviving spouse is the first target, while a gift made decades ago to a sibling is the last. American parents who built a chain of gifts over the years should understand that the most recent transfer carries the most risk.
Fourth, and most reassuring for families who want to keep the house rather than sell it, reduction in modern French law is paid in money, not by tearing up the transfer. Since the 2006 reform, the beneficiary who received too much keeps the asset and pays the forced heir an indemnity equal to the excess:
“Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent.” (Article 924 of the Civil Code)
The surviving spouse who received the house therefore does not automatically lose it; she owes a debt to the children, secured and valued at the date of partition. If the children and the spouse cannot agree on who keeps the home, the preferential allotment mechanism lets the spouse or one heir take the house and compensate the others, a procedure our guide on the surviving spouse’s options walks through step by step (how a surviving spouse can keep the French house).
Fifth, the action can follow the property into the hands of a buyer. If the over-endowed beneficiary already sold the gifted house and turns out to be insolvent, the forced heirs can, after first pursuing the beneficiary’s own assets, sue the third-party buyer of the real estate, starting with the most recent sale:
“Après discussion préalable des biens du débiteur de l’indemnité en réduction et en cas d’insolvabilité de ce dernier, les héritiers réservataires peuvent exercer l’action en réduction ou revendication contre les tiers détenteurs des immeubles faisant partie des libéralités et aliénés par le gratifié.” (Article 924-4 of the Civil Code)
Anyone buying a French property from someone who received it by gift should therefore check the gift’s history with a notaire; a bargain purchase can carry a hidden lawsuit.
Finally, the system has an early-warning mechanism built into the settlement process. When the notaire handling the estate sees that a forced heir’s rights may have been impaired by the deceased’s gifts or will, the notaire must individually inform each known heir concerned, before any partition if possible, of the right to demand reduction. For American heirs, this is often the first letter that reveals the problem, and it should never be ignored: the five-year clock is already running. When the heir is a minor child, the parents cannot simply accept or waive these rights alone, as our guide on children who inherit French property explains (what an American parent can and cannot do for a minor heir).
II. Can American Law or a Choice-of-Law Clause Protect a Will That Cuts Out a Child?
A. Which Law Governs Your Estate: Where You Live, or the Law You Choose?
Everything in Part I assumed French law governs the succession. For cross-border families, that assumption must be tested first, because a European regulation now decides which country’s inheritance law applies to the whole estate, wherever the assets sit. Since August 17, 2015, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on international successions supplies a single conflict rule for all participating states, including France:
The default rule points to the country where the deceased lived rather than the country of citizenship: unless otherwise provided, the law applicable to the succession as a whole is the law of the State where the deceased had habitual residence at death (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of July 4, 2012 on international successions, Article 21(1)).
An American who retires to Provence and lives there for fifteen years will therefore normally die under French succession law, forced share included, even while remaining a US citizen. Conversely, an American who never left Ohio dies under Ohio law even for the Paris apartment, unless French courts must still intervene for the French real estate, which they will, as explained below.
But the regulation also offers an escape hatch that every American in France should know:
This choice, called professio juris, must be express, stated in a testamentary disposition or clearly shown by its terms, and it may designate the law of any State whose nationality the person holds when making the choice or at death, including one of several nationalities (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Article 22, choice of law).
This choice, called professio juris, must be express, stated in a testamentary disposition or clearly shown by its terms. A dual French-American citizen can therefore validly elect US law, and so can a solely American citizen living in France: nationality, not residence, is the key. Our dedicated guide walks through the exact clause a notaire expects and the formalities that make it stick (electing US law for a French house in your will). Two warnings accompany the opportunity. First, electing the law of a US state does not import US probate procedure into France; the French notaire still settles the French assets, applying the chosen American substantive law to shares and validity. Second, which US state’s law you elect matters, because succession law differs between New York, California, Florida, and Texas, and your will should name the state, not just “American law.”
French courts take habitual residence seriously as a factual question, and Americans feature prominently in the case law. In a 2019 decision, the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation approved an appeal court’s finding that a deceased person’s habitual residence was in New York, and drew the consequence that the French courts had no jurisdiction over the succession as a whole. The court’s own words were:
“a estimé que la résidence habituelle du défunt était située à New York, ce dont elle a exactement déduit que la juridiction française était incompétente pour statuer sur sa succession” (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, May 29, 2019, appeal no. 18-13.383, rejection: habitual residence in New York)
The lesson for families is practical: where you actually live in the years before death, the duration and regularity of your presence, the reasons for it, and the center of your family and social life determine the governing law more than your passport or the location of your accounts. An American splitting time between Florida and the Dordogne should document where real life happens.
A later ruling adds an important safety net when the deceased lived outside France but kept French ties. In 2022 the Court of Cassation quashed an appeal decision that had declared the French courts incompetent because the deceased habitually resided in the United Kingdom, holding that the lower court should have examined on its own motion its subsidiary jurisdiction, since its own findings showed the deceased held French nationality and owned property in France. The subsidiary-jurisdiction rule lets a Member State’s courts hear the case over assets on its territory when the deceased was its national, even if the habitual residence lay in a third country. The court stated the rule this way: “Selon ce texte, titré « Compétences subsidiaires », lorsque la résidence habituelle du défunt au moment du décès n’est pas située dans un État membre, les juridictions de l’État membre dans lequel sont situés des biens successoraux sont néanmoins compétentes pour statuer sur l’ensemble de la succession dans la mesure où le défunt possédait la nationalité de cet État membre au moment du décès.” (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, September 21, 2022, appeal no. 19-15.438, cassation) For American-French dual nationals who retire to the United States while keeping the family house in France, this means the French courts remain available for the French property, and the succession may end up split in practice between two proceedings that must be coordinated.
A related American trap deserves a blunt warning: the revocable living trust. Most US estate plans pour assets into a family trust, but France has no equivalent institution in its civil law, and a trust does not override the forced share or French tax on French assets. French tax law specifically pulls trust property into the transfer-tax net, providing that the property and rights forming a trust as defined by statute are subject to French death and gift duties when the connecting factors are met (Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code, expressly covering trusts). Funding the French house into a California or Delaware trust neither removes it from the notaire’s calculation nor shields it from French tax. Coordinate the trust with a French will containing an express choice of law, name a successor trustee who can actually deal with a French notaire, and never assume the trust document alone settles the French house.
B. When US Law Applies and a Child Gets Nothing: the Jarre Rule and the 2021 Safety Net
The hardest question comes when American law validly governs and, applying it, a child receives nothing. Can the disinherited child ask a French court to throw out the American law as contrary to French public policy? The answer was given by the most famous Franco-American succession decision ever rendered, concerning the estate of a celebrated French composer who had lived in California for nearly thirty years, placed his property in a family trust for his wife and their two young daughters, and left four children from earlier relationships with nothing under Californian law, which has no forced share. The children argued that the forced share was an essential principle of French law that barred the application of Californian law. On September 27, 2017, the First Civil Chamber rejected that argument with a sentence that every cross-border practitioner now cites:
On September 27, 2017, the First Civil Chamber rejected that argument, holding that a foreign law designated by the conflict rule which ignores the forced share is not in itself contrary to French international public policy and may be set aside only where its concrete application in the case at hand produces a result incompatible with principles French law regards as essential (Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, September 27, 2017, appeal no. 16-13.151, rejection, published in the Bulletin).
In everyday English: a foreign law is not contrary to French international public policy simply because it has no forced share. It can only be set aside if applying it in the specific case produces a result incompatible with principles France treats as essential. The court then verified concretely: none of the four adult children claimed that Californian law left them in economic hardship or need; the composer had lived in California for almost thirty years, his three youngest children were born there, and all his real estate plus most of his movable wealth sat in the United States; the trust benefited his wife, the mother of the two then-minor daughters. On those facts, letting Californian law govern did not shock French public policy, and the appeal was rejected.
Three practical consequences flow from this ruling for American families. First, before 2021, a well-structured American plan genuinely could disinherit a child as to French assets, provided the governing law was American, the family had a real and durable connection with the United States, and no child was left in need. Second, the test is concrete, not abstract: hardship and proximity decide, so an American who moves to France permanently, keeps the wealth in France, and cuts out a child living in France runs a far greater risk of seeing US law set aside than a Californian of thirty years with everything in Los Angeles. Third, the decision concerned successions opened before the 2021 reform, and the legislature responded to it directly, which brings us to the safety net.
After the Jarre ruling, Parliament created a compensatory levy (prélèvement compensatoire) that lets children deprived by a foreign no-forced-share law recover the equivalent from property located in France. The mechanism sits inside the very article that fixes the fractions, added by Law No. 2021-616 of May 21, 2021 for the protection of forced heirs:
“Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement et lorsque la loi étrangère applicable à la succession ne permet aucun mécanisme réservataire protecteur des enfants, chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” (Article 913, final paragraph, of the Civil Code)
Five conditions emerge from that single sentence, and each one matters. The succession must have been opened on or after November 1, 2021. The deceased or at least one of the children must have been, at death, a national of a European Union Member State or habitually resident there: a French father with American children qualifies through his own nationality, while a purely American family whose only French link is a vacation home, with everyone living in the United States, does not. The applicable foreign law must offer no reserve-like protective mechanism for children at all. The levy attaches only to assets physically located in France on the day of death, never to the American accounts or the Florida condo. And recovery is capped at the French forced-share rights, so the child is restored to the French minimum, not enriched beyond it. The government’s own English-language portal confirms the scheme for successions opened from November 1, 2021 (service-public.fr, Can we disinherit our children, English version), recalling that a fraction of the estate necessarily belongs to the descendants wherever French law applies. An American child of a French parent, or a child habitually resident in France, who is cut out by a valid American-law will should therefore ask a French court for the levy on the French house without delay, rather than assuming the Jarre outcome still governs.
Finally, the tax layer must be settled alongside the civil-law analysis, because winning the share is only half the battle. France taxes the transfer under its own connecting rules: worldwide assets, movable and immovable, when the deceased or donor was fiscally domiciled in France, and French-situs assets even when the deceased was domiciled abroad:
“Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France, et notamment les fonds publics, parts d’intérêts, biens ou droits composant un trust défini à l’article 792-0 bis et produits qui y sont capitalisés, créances et généralement toutes les valeurs mobilières françaises ou étrangères de quelque nature qu’elles soient, lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B ; 2° Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France, […] lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article précité.” (Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code)
Each child benefits from a personal allowance on what he or she receives from each parent, currently 100,000 euros, with any prior gifts from the same parent within fifteen years aggregated to prevent allowance shopping:
“Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” (Article 779-I of the General Tax Code)
And every lifetime gift must be disclosed in later transfers and declarations, since the parties must state in each deed and each estate filing whether earlier gifts from the same donor exist (Article 784 of the General Tax Code). On the American side, the France-United States estate and gift tax treaty of 1978, amended by later protocols, coordinates the two systems so the same house is not fully taxed twice: France generally keeps the primary right to tax its real estate, while the United States grants a credit against its own estate tax for the French duties paid, within treaty limits. The Internal Revenue Service lists France among the countries covered by a US estate and gift tax treaty (IRS, Estate and gift tax treaties, international), and the Treasury’s technical explanation to the amending protocol details how each country computes the credit (US Treasury, Technical Explanation of the France-US estate and gift tax protocol). A forced heir who recovers the French house through reduction or the compensatory levy therefore inherits a French tax bill computed on French values and French allowances, plus a US reporting and potential tax position that requires an American CPA working from the French notaire’s figures, not instead of them.
Conclusion
An American can disinherit a child as to French assets only by navigating three gates in order, and failing any one of them restores the child’s forced share. First, displace French law: sign a will with an express choice of American law under the European succession regulation, or accept that habitual residence in France will impose French fractions of one half, two thirds, or three quarters depending on the number of children. Second, survive the 2021 safety net: if the deceased or any child was an EU national or resident and the chosen law has no reserve mechanism, the disinherited child can levy the French assets up to the French minimum, whatever the will says. Third, survive the concrete public-policy test: even without the levy, a French court can set aside the foreign law if its application leaves a child in need or the family’s real life was in France. Time limits sharpen every option: five years from death, two years from discovery, ten years absolute for the reduction action, and a French tax return due within months of death. Map the governing law before signing anything, quantify the forced share on the reunited mass before promising the house to one person, and coordinate the French will, the American trust, and both countries’ tax filings as a single file. Handled early, the forced share becomes a number to plan around; discovered late, it becomes a lawsuit.