KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
He Left the Senate in 2022, the EU Kept Him Listed Until 2026: the Tkach Annulment and How to Challenge a Freeze From France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

He Left the Senate in 2022, the EU Kept Him Listed Until 2026: the Tkach Annulment and How to Challenge a Freeze From France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 22 September 2026, the Council of the European Union locked its Ukraine sanctions list for three full years. On 23 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union unlocked one name. The sequence matters more than either event alone. In its press release of 22 September 2026, the Council announced in its press release of 22 September 2026 that it had decided to prolong for another 36 months, until 22 September 2029, the restrictive measures targeting those responsible for undermining or threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine: a list covering more than 3 000 individuals and entities, combining travel restrictions for natural persons, asset freezes, and a ban on making funds or other economic resources available to listed persons and entities. The next morning, the Fourth Chamber of the General Court delivered its judgment in Tkach v Council, case T-584/24, and annulled the September 2024 and September 2025 acts keeping former Russian senator Oleg Polikarpovich Tkach on that very list. The Council had also, in the same review, declined to renew three individuals and one entity and removed three deceased persons from the list, proof that even inside a 36-month extension the list keeps moving in both directions.

This piece explains what the Tkach annulment changes for anyone with frozen funds or a frozen reputation in France. Mr Tkach sat in Russia’s Federation Council from 2004 to 2022 and was first listed on 9 March 2022, in the wave of designations that followed the full-scale invasion. Press reporting on the French-language judgment indicates that the September 2024 statement of reasons rested principally on his 2022 vote in the upper house ratifying the treaties with the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Luhansk, a vote taken on 22 February 2022 when, as the Kremlin’s own record confirms, the ratification laws had been adopted by the State Duma and approved by the Federation Council on 22 February 2022. Four years later, with the mandate long over and no fresh conduct put forward, the Court held that this was not enough to keep him listed. The lesson for listed persons, their banks and their counterparties runs through the whole sanctions practice our Paris office handles every week: the Council must prove, with current material, that the reason for listing is still true on the date of each renewal, and a file that merely repeats a 2022 vote will not survive a serious challenge. The companion rulings of the same chamber this month point the same way, as our analyses of the Gagarina annulment of 16 September 2026 and the Trotsenko dismissal of the same day explain in detail.

I. Why the General Court Removed a Former Russian Senator From the EU Sanctions List on 23 September 2026

The judgment was delivered at 9.30 in Luxembourg by the Fourth Chamber after a hearing held on 25 February 2026, in a case brought on 13 November 2024 against the September 2024 review acts and extended, as the outcome shows, to the September 2025 renewals. The listing criterion at issue was Article 2(1)(a) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP and Article 3(1)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 269/2014, which covers, as the press summary of the ruling explains, persons held responsible for, supporting or implementing actions undermining Ukraine’s territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence. That criterion is conduct-based: it catches what a person did, supported or implemented, not a status once held. Everything in the judgment flows from that distinction, and everything a listed person in France can reuse in their own file flows from it too.

A. From the March 2022 Listing to the Annulled 2024 and 2025 Relistings: What the File Actually Contained

Oleg Tkach entered the EU list on 9 March 2022 through the standard two-act mechanism of EU sanctions law: a Council Decision adopted under Article 29 TEU, paired with a Council Implementing Regulation adopted under Article 215 TFEU that names the person in Annex I to Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 of 17 March 2014 and freezes all of their funds and economic resources, however owned, held or controlled. The March 2022 implementing act was Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/396 of 9 March 2022, part of the package built on Council Decision (CFSP) 2022/329. At the time, the statement of reasons pointed to his seat in the Federation Council and to the ratification vote of 22 February 2022, when the upper house approved the treaties of friendship, cooperation and mutual assistance with the Donetsk and Luhansk entities, days before Russian troops crossed the border and days before the European Union condemned, in its declaration of 22 February 2022, the recognition of the non-government controlled areas of the Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts. For an initial listing in March 2022, that reasoning was of its time: the vote was a matter of days old, the office was current, and the link between the conduct and the criterion was direct.

The case turned on what happened afterwards. Mr Tkach left the Federation Council in the course of 2022, ending a mandate held since 2004. The Council nevertheless maintained him on the list at each six-monthly review, including through Council Decision (CFSP) 2024/2456 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/2455, both of 12 September 2024, which extended the measures until 15 March 2025, and then through Council Decision (CFSP) 2025/1895 and Council Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1894, both of 12 September 2025, which renewed the measures until 15 March 2026. The September 2025 round is documented in unusual detail: the Council’s acts of 12 September 2025 renewed the territorial-integrity listings “until March 15, 2026”, while declining to renew one individual and removing one deceased person, a reminder that the review is supposed to be individual even when 3,000 names are processed together. Mr Tkach’s action, filed on 13 November 2024, therefore attacked the September 2024 maintenance first, and the Court’s judgment of 23 September 2026 annulled both the 2024 and the 2025 retentions so far as they kept Oleg Polikarpovich Tkach on the Ukraine sanctions lists. In Luxembourg practice, applicants adapt their pleas to each renewal round as it arrives, so that the Court rules on the living list rather than on expired acts, and the Tkach outcome shows that discipline paying off across two full review cycles.

Two features of the file explain the result. First, the conduct relied upon never moved: the statement of reasons kept returning to the February 2022 ratification vote, an act performed in a parliamentary mandate that had itself expired. Second, nothing current was added: no post-2022 financing, no post-2022 office, no post-2022 statement or transaction capable of showing that the criterion was still satisfied in September 2024, still less in September 2025. A listing criterion framed around responsibility for, support for or implementation of undermining actions demands exactly that kind of updating, because each renewal is a new decision that must be justified on its own date. The Court’s answer, in substance, is that a former senator cannot be kept on the list indefinitely on the sole ground that he once voted as a senator. The vote explains the 2022 listing; it does not, four years later and without more, explain the 2024 or 2025 maintenance. Readers familiar with this month’s case-law will recognise the pattern: in Gagarina, the same chamber upheld the initial 2024 listing of the singer as a propaganda supporter and then annulled her March 2025 and September 2025 relistings because the file had gone stale, while in Trotsenko it dismissed the whole action because the Council had documented real, current industrial assets in revenue sectors. Tkach now completes the triptych from the other end of the spectrum: where the applicant’s only link to the criterion is a spent mandate and an old vote, the maintenance falls.

B. The Rule the Council Broke: Every Renewal Must Rest on Reasons That Are Still True

EU sanctions are temporary by design and reviewable by right. Decision 2014/145/CFSP applies for defined periods and must be affirmatively renewed, which is why the Official Journal carries a renewal pair every March and September, and why the 22 September 2026 move to a 36-month cycle until 22 September 2029 is such a structural event. The longer cycle does not dilute the legal standard: each maintenance remains an individual decision addressed to a named person, it must state the reasons for keeping that person listed, and those reasons must be capable of supporting the listing on the date the decision is taken. That is the combined effect of the duty to state reasons in Article 296 TFEU, the right to effective judicial protection in Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, and fifteen years of case-law from Kadi onwards holding that the Council must adduce sufficiently solid, specific and current material. The General Court does not second-guess the Council’s foreign policy; it checks that the file actually proves, today, what the reasons allege. Where the file proves only yesterday, the renewal is annulled, with the annulment taking effect for the acts challenged and the applicant may rely on the judgment in the next review round.

Applied to former office-holders, the rule bites in a predictable way. Status-based reasoning, that he was a senator when he voted, decays the day the mandate ends unless the Council shows continuity: continued influence, continued financing, continued public support, or a role in successor structures. Conduct-based reasoning, that he voted to ratify on 22 February 2022, decays more slowly but still decays, because the listing criterion targets ongoing responsibility, support or implementation, and a single historic vote, without any relapse or continuation, progressively loses its probative connection to present dangerousness. The Council’s strongest cards in such files are usually fresh material, intercepted transactions, recent appointments, recent statements, documented proximity to decision-makers, and its weakest card is repetition. Tkach confirms that repetition of a 2022 vote across the September 2024 and September 2025 reviews is the weakest card of all. The practical corollary for the Council is that it must either find new material before each review or delist, which is precisely what it did on 22 September 2026 for three living persons and one entity, alongside three deceased persons whose files had closed by operation of nature. For applicants, the corollary is symmetrical and encouraging: every renewal is a new opportunity to win, because every renewal obliges the Council to prove the present with the present.

The 36-month extension changes the tactics, not the standard. Until now, a losing applicant got a fresh Council decision to attack every six months; from 22 September 2026, the next general review falls in September 2029, which makes each individual remedy more valuable and each procedural deadline more dangerous to miss. Two months to bring an annulment action under Article 263 TFEU runs from notification or publication of the act concerning the applicant, and a listed person who sleeps through that window may wait years for the next review instead of months. Conversely, a listed person who sues each maintenance forces the Council to defend each file on current evidence, exactly the exercise the Council failed in Tkach. The judgment therefore arrives at the perfect moment for the new cycle: it tells every listed person with French assets that the longer lock-in makes litigation more necessary, not less, and it tells the Council that longer cycles will not insulate stale files from judges. Our office has been running these calendars for clients since 2022, and the Tkach method, attack the freshness of the evidence at each renewal, is now validated three times in eight days by the same chamber.

II. How to Challenge an EU Asset Freeze From France After the Tkach Judgment

Winning in Luxembourg is only half the matter for a person living, banking or owning property in France. An EU listing applies directly in all Member States, but it is French banks that freeze the accounts, French notaries that block the sales, and the French Treasury that grants or refuses the derogations that let a listed person eat, pay rent and pay lawyers. France adds its own national freeze layer on top of the EU one. A complete strategy therefore runs on two tracks at once: the Luxembourg track that removes the name from Annex I, and the Paris track that manages the money while the name is still there. The Tkach ruling strengthens the first track and changes nothing about the urgency of the second, because an annulment in Luxembourg does not retroactively unblock three years of frozen life in Paris.

A. The Luxembourg Track: Sue Each Renewal Within Two Months and Aim at the Freshness of the Evidence

Standing before the General Court is straightforward for a listed person: Article 263 TFEU gives any natural or legal person the right to challenge an act addressed to them or of direct and individual concern to them, and a person named in Annex I to Regulation No 269/2014 plainly qualifies. The action must be lodged within two months of the notification or publication of the maintaining act, a deadline the Court applies strictly, and it must identify precisely which acts are attacked, Decision and Implementing Regulation together, since the freeze flows from the pair. Tkach shows the full timeline of a well-run file: action of 13 November 2024 against the September 2024 acts, adaptation of the pleas to the September 2025 renewals, hearing on 25 February 2026, judgment on 23 September 2026. Roughly twenty-two months from filing to judgment is typical, which is why interim relief and parallel French derogations matter while the case is pending, and why the new 36-month review cycle makes filing against each individual maintenance, including relistings after a delisting, absolutely critical.

Pleas should be ordered the way the Fourth Chamber reasons. First, defective statement of reasons: the reasons must be specific enough to let the applicant understand what they are accused of and the Court to review it, which boilerplate repetition of a 2022 vote across 2024 and 2025 is not. Second, manifest error of assessment on the facts as of the renewal date: the mandate ended in 2022, the vote is spent, and no current conduct is shown, so the subsumption under Article 2(1)(a) of Decision 2014/145 and Article 3(1)(a) of Regulation No 269/2014 fails. Third, breach of the rights of the defence and the right to be heard before a maintenance that worsens or prolongs the situation, combined with Article 47 of the Charter where the Council withholds the underlying evidence while asking the Court to trust it. Fourth, proportionality and the right to property, framed realistically: the Court accepts that sanctions restrict property, as Trotsenko confirms, so these pleas support rather than carry a case, and they work best when the file is already stale. Evidence wins these cases, and the evidence that wins is negative evidence assembled positively: proof that the mandate ended, proof of resignation or non-renewal, proof of divestment with share registers and completion accounts, proof of residence and activity far from the sanctioned conduct, and a chronological exhibit showing that the Council’s latest document predates the renewal by years. The Council’s file in Tkach reportedly contained the vote and little else; an applicant who files a complete counter-file of post-mandate life makes that thinness visible to the judges.

Two companion lessons from this month should shape every new filing. From Gagarina, take the severability of time: an initial listing can be lawful while its renewals are not, so plead in the alternative, uphold-or-annul per period, and never let the strength of the 2022 reasons infect the analysis of the 2025 reasons. From Trotsenko, take the warning about divestment: selling assets after listing, without proof of a genuine and irreversible loss of control and benefit, does not purge the criterion, and the Court will examine the buyer, the price, the timing and the remaining links. Tkach adds the third lesson, the spent mandate: leaving the office that justified the listing starts a clock, and with each renewal the Council must show why the clock does not matter. Put together, the three September judgments give practitioners a complete map of the Fourth Chamber’s thinking, and a filing that cites all three, distinguishing its facts from Trotsenko and aligning them with Gagarina and Tkach, speaks the chamber’s own language back to it.

B. The Paris Track: Banks That Freeze, a Treasury That Authorises, and Courts That Punish Evasion

In France, the EU freeze bites through domestic obligations that every bank, insurer, notary and accountant must obey. French law defines the target with extreme breadth: Article L. 562-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code treats as funds cash, deposit balances, savings products, asset-management contracts, insurance surrender values, receivables, financial instruments, dividends and credit operations, and as economic resources every other asset usable to obtain funds, goods or services. The persons bound to enforce the freeze are equally broad: Article L. 562-4 of the same Code requires them, in the words of the Code, to “appliquer sans délai les mesures de gel et les interdictions de mise à disposition” and to inform the economy minister immediately, while Article L. 562-5 prohibits making funds or economic resources available, directly or indirectly, to or for the benefit of designated persons. Alongside the directly applicable EU regulations, France keeps a national relay: Article L. 562-3 of the Code empowers the economy minister to freeze for six months renewable the assets of persons designated under United Nations Chapter VII resolutions or acts adopted under Article 29 TEU or Article 75 TFEU, which is the domestic bridge between a Luxembourg listing and a Paris bank account. Banks report through the channel described by Article R. 562-3, covering frozen balances, credits to frozen accounts and any transaction suspected of breaching a freeze or a making-available ban.

The Paris track therefore starts with procedure, not with Luxembourg. First, identify the exact basis of each freeze in writing: an Annex I EU listing, a French ministerial order, or an over-compliant bank acting without either, because each basis leads to a different judge. Second, use the derogation machinery immediately: Article 4 of Regulation No 269/2014 allows the competent national authority, which in France is the Directorate General of the Treasury, to authorise the release of frozen funds for basic needs, legal fees and other defined purposes, and a reasoned written application with bank statements, invoices and fee agreements is the difference between a release in weeks and destitution for months. The Cour de cassation has just confirmed how central the Treasury’s gatekeeper role is: in its judgment of 5 February 2026 in the Libyan Investment Authority matter, the Second Civil Chamber held, on the analogous Libyan regulation, that no enforcement measure may be taken against frozen funds or resources where it would take them out of the debtor’s estate, or even where it would merely confer a simple priority right on the pursuing creditor, without the prior authorisation of the Director of the Treasury, adding that failing such authorisation no attachment of a frozen claim can be authorised or continued. The exact words deserve quotation because bailiffs and creditors in Paris still test the boundary: “ne peut être diligentée, sur des fonds ou des ressources économiques gelés, aucune mesure d’exécution qui aurait pour effet, non seulement de les faire sortir du patrimoine du débiteur, mais aussi de conférer au créancier poursuivant un simple droit de préférence, sans une autorisation préalable du directeur du Trésor”. A creditor chasing a listed debtor’s Paris assets and a listed person defending them both need that paragraph on their desk, and the full decision is published at Cass. 2e civ., 5 February 2026, No 23-15.936.

Third, never improvise around a freeze, because France punishes evasion with customs-law severity. Article L. 574-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code punishes evading freeze obligations or obstructing their implementation with the penalties of the Customs Code, under the investigation, prosecution and punishment rules of that Code. The criminal chamber illustrated the machinery in Cass. crim., 29 November 2023, No 22-85.867, where two association leaders convicted of evading national freezes, the first to what the Court records as “trois mois d’emprisonnement avec sursis probatoire, une amende douanière et une confiscation”, challenged the customs officers’ power to investigate: the Court approved the investigation on the ground that Article L. 574-3, in the Court’s words, “prévoit expressément que les modalités de constatation, de poursuite et de répression de cette infraction sont régies par le code des douanes”, while partly quashing the penalties imposed on one defendant as to confiscation and the customs fine and remanding those points to Douai. The case concerned terrorism freezes, but the enforcement architecture is shared, and the message for EU-listed persons in France is identical: move frozen money without a Treasury authorisation and the file becomes criminal. Fourth, challenge French decisions with French deadlines: any unfavourable individual decision must be reasoned, as Article L. 211-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration provides, since, in the words of the statute, “Les personnes physiques ou morales ont le droit d’être informées sans délai des motifs des décisions administratives individuelles défavorables qui les concernent”, and any court action must be brought, in the words of the Code, “dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée” under Article R. 421-1 of the Administrative Justice Code. National freezes of six months renewable, bank refusals to release, and Treasury refusals of derogation each obey these rules, and each missed deadline is a lost remedy.

Conclusion

The two days of 22 and 23 September 2026 will define sanctions practice for the rest of the decade. The Council’s 36-month extension until 22 September 2029 tells listed persons that the political track offers no near-term exit: the list of more than 3,000 names is locked, the asset freeze and the ban on making funds available continue in full, and only individual delistings, like those of 22 September itself, will thin it. The General Court’s Tkach judgment tells them where the exit actually lies: in the courtroom, one renewal at a time, by proving that the reasons are no longer true. A former Federation Council member listed for a February 2022 vote and kept on the list through September 2024 and September 2025 on the same vote has now been removed, because a spent mandate plus a stale vote does not satisfy a conduct-based criterion. The method generalises to every file where the Council recycles old material: calendar each maintenance, sue within two months, attack the freshness of the evidence, and work the Paris track in parallel with Treasury derogations, written bank demands and timely French appeals. Sanctions litigation has become a discipline of dates, and after Tkach the side that masters the calendar wins.

📄 Official circular