KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
We Bought Our French House With a Tontine Clause: What the Survivor Keeps, What the Children Can Claim, and What America Taxes

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

We Bought Our French House With a Tontine Clause: What the Survivor Keeps, What the Children Can Claim, and What America Taxes

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You are an American couple buying a stone house in the Dordogne, and the French notaire slides a strange clause across the desk. It is called a tontine, also written as a pacte tontinier, and the promise sounds perfect. Whoever of you lives longest will own the whole house automatically. No probate fight, no forced sale, no American-style joint tenancy paperwork. The children from a first marriage get nothing from this house, and the survivor keeps the roof over their head. Many American buyers sign it on the spot, reassured by a mechanism that seems to solve every cross-border inheritance worry in one paragraph. That signature deserves a second look. Under French law, the tontine is a gamble on survival, what lawyers call an aleatory contract, and the gamble only works if both buyers truly pay their share and face a comparable risk of dying first. When one spouse pays everything, when the age gap is wide, or when children with forced inheritance rights enter the picture, French courts can tear the clause apart and reclassify it as a disguised gift. The tax bill is equally two-faced. A married survivor may pay nothing in France, while an unmarried partner can lose sixty percent of the share to transfer tax, and the Internal Revenue Service looks at the same house through entirely different glasses. This article explains what the survivor really owns, how children can still claw back their protected share, what France taxes and at which rate, and where the American tax exposure sits.

I. We Bought Our French House With a Tontine Clause: What Does the Survivor Really Own?

A. How Does the Tontine Clause Make the Survivor Owner From the Day of Purchase?

A tontine clause, called in French a clause de tontine, a clause d’accroissement, or a pacte tontinier, is a paragraph inserted in the purchase deed, known as the acte de vente, signed before the notaire. The notaire is the French public officer who authenticates property transfers and settles estates, and nothing about a French purchase is final until that officer stamps it. The clause provides that when one of the co-buyers dies, the survivor is treated as if they had owned the entire property alone since the day of purchase. The first person to die is legally rewritten out of the story. As the First Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation put it in a published opinion of June 15, 2022, requested by the Criminal Chamber and registered under numbers 21-80.743 and 22-70.002: La clause de tontine, ou clause d’accroissement, est celle par laquelle, lorsque plusieurs personnes acquièrent un bien, le survivant des acquéreurs est réputé avoir été seul propriétaire depuis l’acquisition. In plain English, the survivor is deemed to have been the sole owner since the acquisition. The heirs of the first to die inherit nothing from this house, because in the eyes of French civil law the deceased never owned it.

The tax administration describes the same mechanism in its official doctrine, which quotes what it calls the constant case law of the Court of Cassation: the survivor receives the whole property subject to a condition of survival, called a condition suspensive de survie, while each buyer holds their own share subject to losing it if they die first, called a condition résolutoire de prédécès. The doctrine states: Une jurisprudence constante de la Cour de cassation analyse ces clauses comme conférant au survivant des coacquéreurs la propriété du bien tout entier, sous condition suspensive de survie, et à chacun d’entre eux la propriété de sa part, sous la condition résolutoire de son prédécès. The same opinion of the Court of Cassation adds a practical detail that matters when money moves across borders. While the survival condition is still pending, each tontine buyer may sell on their own the rights they hold under the pact, namely shared use of the property plus ownership conditioned on outliving the others: Tant que la condition de survie demeure pendante, un acquéreur en tontine a, sous la réserve de stipulations contraires, la possibilité d’aliéner seul les droits qu’il tient du pacte tontinier et qui consistent, d’une part, en la jouissance indivise du bien, d’autre part, en la propriété du bien conditionnée au prédécès de ses coacquéreurs. A buyer who sells their tontine rights before dying destroys the expected outcome, which is why lenders and future buyers examine these clauses with suspicion.

During the lifetime of both buyers, the tontine creates a lock that surprises Americans used to partition actions. In an ordinary co-ownership, called indivision, any co-owner can force a sale through the courts under the old maxim that nobody can be forced to stay in co-ownership. Under a tontine, that exit does not exist. The notarial profession warns buyers that unanimity is required for every decision, that neither buyer can force a court-ordered sale or partition, and that a falling-out leaves only two negotiated exits: sell together by agreement or have one buy out the other by agreement. For an American couple, this means the tontine protects the survivor only as long as the couple stays united. A separation turns the clause into a cage, and removing it requires the written consent of the very person you are separating from.

The entire structure stands or falls on risk, called aléa in French. A contract is aleatory when its economic outcome depends on an uncertain event, here who dies first. The Civil Code defines the concept in these terms: Il est aléatoire lorsque les parties acceptent de faire dépendre les effets du contrat, quant aux avantages et aux pertes qui en résulteront, d’un événement incertain. Both buyers must fund a genuine part of the price, and both must face a comparable life expectancy. The Court of Appeal of Poitiers restated the validity test on April 17, 2025, in a decision indexed under general docket number 23/02749, concerning a house bought in 1998 with a tontine clause: Cet acte pour être valide doit présenter un caractère onéreux et aléatoire. The court continued with the sentence every American buyer should memorize: Ainsi que l’a retenu le premier juge , le ‘pacte tontinier’ constituant un contrat aléatoire et onéreux, doit être requalifié en acte à titre gratuit lorsque les circonstances de fait sont telles que l’aléa disparait. When the facts wipe out the gamble, judges reclassify the arrangement as a gift, with gift consequences. The court listed the warning signs: L’absence d’aléa, qui permet de caractériser l’intention libérale, peut résulter de ce que l’une des parties a financé l’acquisition en totalité ou dans une proportion très supérieure à la moitié, ainsi que d’une différence d’âge significative ou d’états de santé différents. One party paying everything, or a wide age or health gap, signals a disguised gift rather than a shared bet on life.

In that Poitiers case, the children of the deceased husband argued exactly this. Their father had married a much younger woman, the couple had bought halves of a house, and the children claimed the wife could only fund her half and repay her loans because the husband fed her accounts. The court examined bank statements, a 59,760 euro loan repaid in monthly installments from 1998 onward, a later home loan taken out by the wife in 2007, and her inheritance prospects, then held that accusations built on assumptions prove nothing: the sons offered no evidence of regular transfers or hidden accounts supporting their theory. Because the judges confirmed the first-instance ruling, the tontine survived and the widow kept the house. The lesson for Americans cuts both ways. A tontine funded fifty-fifty with traceable personal money, between spouses of comparable age, resists attack. A tontine where the American husband wires the full price from a US account while his younger wife signs for half invites the children to replay the Poitiers arguments, this time perhaps with wire records that prove the point. Keep every bank trace, every loan schedule, every currency transfer slip. The notaire records the declared origin of funds in the deed, and that declaration becomes exhibit one if the clause is ever challenged.

B. Can Our Children From a First Marriage Attack the Tontine and Claw Back Their Share?

Children occupy a protected position in French succession law that has no equivalent in most American states. A portion of every estate, called the réserve héréditaire, is locked by statute for certain heirs, and only the remainder, called the quotité disponible, can be given away freely. The Civil Code defines the two halves this way: La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent. La quotité disponible est la part des biens et droits successoraux qui n’est pas réservée par la loi et dont le défunt a pu disposer librement par des libéralités. The fractions depend on the number of children: Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre. With one child, half the estate is untouchable. With two children, two thirds are locked. With three or more, three quarters are ring-fenced. An American will that leaves everything to the surviving spouse cannot override these fractions for French-situs assets, and readers facing that exact collision should study our companion analysis of choosing American law in a US will and the compensatory levy that can follow: how a professio juris clause interacts with forced heirship and how a disinherited child recovers through the compensatory levy.

A valid tontine sidesteps this whole battlefield, because the house legally bypasses the estate. The deceased is deemed never to have owned it, so there is nothing for the children to count in the reserve. That is precisely why the tontine tempts American buyers in blended families, and precisely why children attack the clause itself rather than the will. Two attack routes exist. The first is requalification, described above: prove the gamble was fake, turn the tontine into a disguised gift, and pull the house back into the estate calculation. The Poitiers ruling shows courts demand hard financial evidence, not suspicions about salaries or pensions, but American families often leave a cleaner paper trail than French ones, with international wires and single-source funding that make the proof easier. The second route is the reduction action, called action en réduction, which lets protected heirs claw back excessive gifts. Only the protected heirs, their own heirs, or their assigns may bring it. Neither other gift recipients, nor legatees, nor the creditors of the deceased may request it or benefit from it: La réduction des dispositions entre vifs ne pourra être demandée que par ceux au profit desquels la loi fait la réserve, par leurs héritiers ou ayants cause : les donataires, les légataires, ni les créanciers du défunt ne pourront demander cette réduction, ni en profiter. The same article sets the clocks that govern American heirs living across the Atlantic: Le délai de prescription de l’action en réduction est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès. Five years from the death, or two years from learning of the harm, capped at ten years. An American child who learns late that a French house vanished into a tontine still holds a live claim for years, and the notaire settling the estate must warn the affected heirs individually, before any partition if needed, when the file suggests their protected rights may have been harmed: Lorsque le notaire constate, lors du règlement de la succession, que les droits réservataires d’un héritier sont susceptibles d’être atteints par les libéralités effectuées par le défunt, il informe chaque héritier concerné et connu, individuellement et, le cas échéant, avant tout partage, de son droit de demander la réduction des libéralités qui excèdent la quotité disponible.

When the clawback succeeds, the remedy is money, not bricks. The recipient compensates the protected heirs up to the excessive portion, however large the excess: Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité, quel que soit cet excédent. Payment by a protected heir is taken by retaining value, set off in priority against their own rights in the reserve: Le paiement de l’indemnité par l’héritier réservataire se fait en moins prenant et en priorité par voie d’imputation sur ses droits dans la réserve. For the surviving spouse, a further rule softens the blow. Gifts received from the deceased count against the spouse’s own inheritance rights, and if they fall short of the statutory spousal rights, the spouse may claim the top-up, never exceeding the special spousal disposable portion: Les libéralités reçues du défunt par le conjoint survivant s’imputent sur les droits de celui-ci dans la succession. Lorsque les libéralités ainsi reçues sont inférieures aux droits définis aux articles 757 et 757-1 , le conjoint survivant peut en réclamer le complément, sans jamais recevoir une portion des biens supérieure à la quotité définie à l’article 1094-1 . A surviving American wife who keeps the tontine house and also inherits as spouse sees the two advantages netted against each other rather than stacked.

Three practical consequences follow for American buyers. First, the tontine protects a surviving spouse against children only when the clause itself is bulletproof: balanced funding with documents, comparable ages, no hidden top-up from one side. Second, children of a first marriage are not disarmed by a tontine the way an American testator might hope. They can fund a requalification case from abroad, hire a French avocat, and run the prescription clocks from the day they discover the harm. Third, estate planning should pair the tontine with honest alternatives rather than rely on it alone. A coordinated gift to the children during lifetime, structured as an anticipated partition through a donation-partage deed, can buy peace at a known tax cost, as explained in our guide to giving the French house to the children now. Where the family already holds the property through a company, the shares of a société civile immobilière, the French family property company universally shortened to SCI, offer different levers, detailed in our guide to running SCI shares from America. And when the succession opens, the land-registry mechanics that unblock a sale are described in our walkthrough of the attestation immobilière, while the options when the estate carries debt are mapped in our guide to accepting, renouncing, or capping liability.

II. What Tax Bills Hit the Survivor of a French Tontine House?

A. How France Taxes the Survivor: Spouse, PACS Partner, or Unmarried Buyer?

For tax purposes, France refuses to follow the civil-law fiction to its happy end. Even though the deceased is deemed never to have owned the house, the survivor is treated as receiving the deceased’s share by gift at death. The governing text provides: Les biens recueillis en vertu d’une clause insérée dans un contrat d’acquisition en commun selon laquelle la part du ou des premiers décédés reviendra aux survivants de telle sorte que le dernier vivant sera considéré comme seul propriétaire de la totalité des biens sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis à titre gratuit à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement. Cette disposition ne s’applique pas à l’habitation principale commune à deux acquéreurs lorsque celle-ci a une valeur globale inférieure à 76 000 €, sauf si le bénéficiaire opte pour l’application des droits de mutation par décès . Every tontine survivor therefore faces transfer tax on the half they absorb, computed under the rates in force on the day of death and according to the family link between the deceased and the survivor. The official doctrine confirms the two cumulative conditions for this regime: the succession must have opened after the 1980 Finance Act took effect, and the tontine contract must postdate September 5, 1979. It adds that when the survivor also inherits in another capacity, the tontine share is added to their inheritance portion for computing the tax, and that a survivor who inherits nothing else must still file: Dans le cas contraire, il doit souscrire une déclaration de succession dans les conditions de droit commun.

The rate then depends entirely on who the survivor is. A married couple pays nothing. Since the 2007 reform, the surviving spouse and the partner bound by a civil solidarity pact, the pacte civil de solidarité universally called PACS, are fully exempt from death transfer duties: Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité. For an American couple married in the United States and owning in France, the French exemption applies regardless of where the wedding took place, provided the marriage is recognized. A couple in a PACS enjoys the same full exemption, which is one more reason Americans settling in France formalize their union. The picture flips brutally for unmarried buyers. Cohabiting partners, called concubins, are treated as strangers for transfer-tax purposes. After a stated allowance, the rate hits sixty percent. The tariff sets Entre parents jusqu’au 4e degré inclusivement 55 Entre parents au-delà du 4e degré et entre personnes non-parentes 60, and the allowance available on each inherited share is a modest sum fixed by statute: A défaut d’autre abattement, à l’exception de celui mentionné au III, un abattement de 1 594 € est opéré sur chaque part successorale. On a 400,000 euro half-share passing to an unmarried American partner, the arithmetic is roughly sixty percent of 398,406 euros, or about 239,000 euros of French tax. The tontine that was supposed to protect the survivor can bankrupt them. Any unmarried American couple signing a tontine must price this outcome before the notaire, not after the funeral.

One narrow exception softens the regime for modest main homes. When the property was the shared main residence of both buyers at death and its total value sits below 76,000 euros, the transfer escapes death duties and falls back under transfer tax on paid transfers, capped at a maximum legal rate of 5.81 percent. At Paris or coastal prices this shelter rarely matters, but for a small rural cottage it can cut the bill dramatically. Note the trap inside the favor: the survivor who prefers death-duty treatment, for instance because an exemption would apply, may expressly opt back into it. Every other tontine survivor files, values the absorbed half at its open-market worth on the day of death, and pays within the standard succession deadlines. American survivors should also remember that France taxes the worldwide estate of French residents and the French-situs assets of nonresidents, so domicile and treaty analysis belong in the file from day one. The French return is only half the story, because the same half-share then crosses the Atlantic on paper.

B. What Does America Tax When a US Person Survives a French Tontine?

The United States taxes its citizens and domiciliaries on death regardless of where they live or where the property sits. The Internal Revenue Service describes the levy in broad terms: The Estate Tax is a tax on your right to transfer property at your death. It consists of an accounting of everything you own or have certain interests in at the date of death. Fair market value controls, not the purchase price, and the total of all counted items forms what is called the gross estate. Certain deductions then apply, including debts, administration expenses, and property passing to a surviving spouse or charity, to reach the taxable estate. Filing is required only above the statutory threshold for the year of death, counting the gross estate plus adjusted taxable gifts. For the tontine survivor, the threshold question is what the deceased American owned at death. French civil law answers nothing, since the first to die is deemed never to have owned the house. American tax law does not automatically adopt French fictions, and no published IRS guidance examined for this article classifies the French pacte tontinier as American joint tenancy with right of survivorship or as anything else. That silence is itself the warning. The surviving and the deceased’s American filings must take a reasoned position, disclose it, and defend it with the deed, the funding traces, and professional opinions, because the two countries start from opposite premises about who owned what.

The bilateral safety net is the estate and gift tax treaty signed on November 24, 1978, as amended by the protocol of December 8, 2004, whose scope the French tax administration maps in its official commentary. The top-level desk page identifies the relevant instruments: INT – Conventions fiscales entre la France et les Etats-Unis d’Amérique, and the dedicated estate-treaty chapter confirms that the amended convention applies to gifts made and to successions of persons dying on or after the stated dates: L’article 19, paragraphe 2 de la convention modifiée prévoit que les stipulations qu’elle comporte s’appliquent aux donations effectuées et aux successions de personnes décédées à compter du 21 décembre 2006. In practice, French-situs real estate remains taxable in France, the United States taxes its persons on top, and the treaty plus domestic foreign-tax-credit mechanics relieve the double hit within their limits. The detailed credit arithmetic for an American heir paying French duties is worked through in our guide to the IRS estate-tax credit on a French house, which readers should open alongside this article before deciding anything.

Three American-side traps deserve explicit flags, each framed as a question for the file rather than a settled answer. First, funding. If one spouse paid the whole price from a US account, the contribution funding the other half may constitute a gift for American gift-tax purposes at purchase, years before anyone dies, with reporting consequences that the French deed does not address. Second, basis. An American heir normally hopes for a stepped-up income-tax basis in inherited property, but an asset the decedent is deemed never to have owned fits awkwardly into that framework, and the survivor who later sells must reconstruct basis from the original purchase, the French tax paid, and the treaty position taken. The sale-side computation, French capital gains plus social charges and the American credit, sits here: selling a French house from America. Third, elections. A married couple might achieve simpler and safer results with a French-American will pair, a professio juris election for the estate law, and lifetime gifts, rather than betting everything on a clause whose American tax treatment is uncharted. None of this argues for ignoring the tontine. It argues for signing it with both tax systems modeled in advance: the French return computed under article 754 A at the correct kinship rate, the American position papered with the deed and the wire history, and the children informed early enough that no one discovers the clause at the reading of the will.

Conclusion

The tontine clause does what it promises only for buyers who respect its logic. Fund it evenly with traceable money, sign it at comparable ages, marry or conclude a PACS if the survivor is meant to keep a roof without a tax catastrophe, and keep every document the way a litigator would. The survivor is then deemed owner since day one, the heirs of the first to die take nothing from the house, and French tax either vanishes between spouses or arrives at a known rate. Stray from that discipline and each protection reverses. A one-sided payment or a wide age gap hands the children a requalification case. A blended family hands them standing, years of prescription, and a notaire obliged to warn them. An unmarried survivor inherits a sixty percent bill. An American file adds a classification question the IRS has never answered in print and a treaty that relieves double taxation without simplifying it. No accident, no intrusion, and no established liability is at issue here beyond these documented mechanics, signed contracts govern before any general analysis does, and only the courts decide contested cases. Measured against those yardsticks, the tontine remains a fine tool for a united couple with aligned funding, and a dangerous reflex everywhere else.

📄 Official circular