Kohen Avocats · Paris law firm
—

Maître Hassan KOHEN assists English-speaking clients throughout France, including in urgent proceedings. Initial strategic review: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Attorney-client privilege · No commitment

Paris Bar Urgent defence & litigation Official CNB profile (avocat.fr)
Hassan Kohen, immigration lawyer in Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney · Paris Bar

France EU Long-Term Resident Card Refused: Residence, Resources and How to Appeal (2026 Guide)

Speak with a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

You have lived in France for five years or more, you applied for the card that finally puts an end to yearly renewals — the carte de résident portant la mention « résident de longue durée-UE » (resident card marked “EU long-term resident”) — and the préfecture (the local immigration authority) has said no. In many files the refusal does not arrive alone: it comes with an obligation de quitter le territoire français (OQTF) (order to leave French territory), sometimes with a time limit of thirty days, sometimes without any delay at all. This guide explains, on the basis of the texts in force on 12 October 2026 and the two most recent court rulings on this exact card, who qualifies, why refusals happen, and which court action, within which deadline, can overturn them. No outcome can be promised. The deadlines, however, are rigid, and missing one usually ends the case before it begins.

The two 2026 rulings point in opposite directions, and that is precisely why they are useful. On 3 August 2026 the Conseil d’État (the supreme administrative court) refused to overturn a rejection: the applicant’s income over the previous five years was too low and too irregular, and even a recent promise of a permanent contract could not cure that finding. Seven weeks later, on 23 September 2026, the Paris administrative court of appeal annulled a refusal served on an American university teacher whose earnings had dipped below the minimum wage during the Covid years: the court held that the administration had misread the resources condition. Read together, the two decisions draw the real borderline — between a temporary dip in income that a judge will forgive and a structural lack of stable resources that a judge will not. Everything below follows that borderline, step by step.

I. Who can obtain the EU long-term resident card in France

A. Five years of lawful, unbroken residence — and the permits that never count

The starting point is article L. 426-17 of the CESEDA, the French code on the entry and residence of foreign nationals and the right of asylum. A foreign national who shows five years of regular, uninterrupted residence in France under a temporary card, a multi-year card or a resident card, stable, regular and sufficient resources, and health insurance is issued a resident card marked “résident de longue durée-UE” valid for ten years — subject only to the exceptions listed in article L. 426-18. The European rule behind this is article 4(1) of Directive 2003/109/EC of 25 November 2003, which the Conseil d’État recalls in Conseil dÉtat, 3 August 2026, No. 497914: Member States grant the status to third-country nationals who have resided legally and continuously on their territory during the five years immediately preceding the application. Note the word “immediately”: the five years are the five years before your application, not any five years in your past.

Not every year spent in France counts. Article L. 426-18 of the CESEDA excludes whole categories of stay whose purpose the European legislature regarded as temporary. Years spent as a student (étudiant, including the mobility programme), as a trainee (stagiaire, including intra-corporate ICT trainees and their families), as a posted ICT worker (salarié détaché ICT) and family, as a seasonal worker (travailleur saisonnier), as a researcher on certain talent passports (passeport talent) with spouse and children, as a beneficiary of subsidiary protection, as a retraité (retired) card holder, or under the refugee and stateless resident cards of articles L. 424-1 and L. 424-3 cannot be aggregated to reach the five years. The practical consequence is harsh and frequently misunderstood: a doctoral student who spent four years on a student card and then one year on an employee card has one qualifying year, not five. Time as a student simply does not exist for this calculation. Similarly, years spent under a private-and-family-life temporary card that was later withdrawn because the marriage had the sole purpose of obtaining a residence permit or French nationality are expressly discarded by article L. 426-17 itself. Before applying, reconstruct your five years permit by permit, and count only the qualifying cards.

Continuity matters as much as legality. Gaps in permits, even short ones, give the administration its easiest ground for refusal: a person who was undocumented for several months inside the five-year window was not residing “régulièrement” (lawfully) during that period. Keep every card, every renewal receipt (récépissé), and every proof of timely renewal applications. The third condition of the trio is the simplest to evidence and the easiest to forget: health insurance (assurance maladie). Affiliation to the French social security system, or equivalent coverage, must be shown at the date the administration decides. Salaried workers are generally covered automatically; self-employed persons, doctoral students changing status, and family members must check that their cover is effective and documented, because a missing certificate can sink an otherwise complete file.

The card, once granted, is valid for ten years. That duration is stated in article L. 426-17 itself, and it is the main practical prize of the route: a decade without renewals, with access to employment and self-employment on the same terms as nationals under the equal-treatment rule of the directive. But validity is not the same as permanence of the status. Under article 9 of Directive 2003/109/EC, the status is lost after twelve consecutive months of absence from EU territory, and in any event after six years of absence from the Member State that granted it — although Member States must provide a facilitated procedure to re-acquire it. The same article adds a protection worth knowing: expiry of the permit alone never withdraws the status itself. An expired card is an administrative problem to fix, not the end of the status. Long absences, on the other hand, genuinely end it — so holders who plan extended stays outside Europe should take advice before leaving.

B. Money, integration and proof: the resources test, the republican-integration condition and the documents that decide everything

The resources condition causes more refusals than all the others combined, and it is the condition the two 2026 rulings interpret. Article L. 426-17 requires resources that are stable, regular and sufficient to support the applicant without recourse to the French social assistance system, and then states: « Les ressources mentionnées au premier alinéa doivent atteindre un montant au moins égal au salaire minimum de croissance. » In English: the resources must reach an amount at least equal to the statutory minimum wage (the SMIC). Only the applicant’s own resources count: family benefits and the main unemployment and minimum-income allowances are disregarded, which means a file carried by social minima fails even if the household budget looks comfortable. One statutory exception exists and should be invoked whenever it applies: the resources condition does not apply to applicants receiving the disabled adult allowance (allocation aux adultes handicapés) or the supplementary old-age allowance. If that is your situation, say so expressly in the application and attach the award decision, because the administration does not always spot it.

The decisive question — the one litigated in both 2026 cases — is how the five-year history relates to the SMIC figure. The administration’s reflex is to demand five years above the SMIC. The courts say otherwise. In CAA Paris, 23 September 2026, No. 26PA00772, an American national who entered France in 2015 and worked as a temporary teaching and research associate (attaché temporaire d’enseignement et de recherche) at Paris XIII University had declared income of 28,102 euros in 2018, 19,119 euros in 2019, then 14,121 euros in 2020 and 13,727 euros in 2021, before rebounding to 38,288 euros in 2022. The prefect of police refused the card solely because the 2020 and 2021 income fell below the SMIC. The court annulled the refusal and ordered the card issued within two months, holding: « ces mêmes dispositions n’imposent pas que le demandeur ait disposé, sur la période antérieure qui est prise en considération, de ressources égales à ce même montant. » In English: the statute does not require the applicant to have had resources equal to the SMIC throughout the earlier period taken into account. The SMIC figure is tested at the date the administration decides; the earlier years serve to assess the nature, level and trajectory of the income, not to impose five years above the floor. The court added that the temporary fall was attributable to the Covid epidemic’s effect on the teaching hours entrusted to the applicant, and that his resources sufficed for his needs.

The mirror image came seven weeks earlier from the supreme court. In Conseil d’État, 3 August 2026, No. 497914, a Chilean spouse of a French national challenged both the refusal of the EU long-term card and a thirty-day removal order. The Conseil d’État first confirmed the method: the documentary requirements of item 58 of annexe 10 to the CESEDA — proof of sufficient, stable and regular resources over the previous five years — merely let the administration assess stability, regularity and sufficiency at the date of its decision, “sans requérir que ces ressources soient d’un montant égal ou supérieur au SMIC”, without requiring those resources to equal or exceed the SMIC. In English: the five-year paperwork proves the pattern; it does not add a second SMIC test. But the applicant still lost: the court of appeal had found, by a sovereign assessment of the evidence with no distortion of the file, that given the amount and the irregularity of the income over the five preceding years, and despite a recent promise of a permanent contract, he did not show stable, regular and sufficient resources. A promise of future employment does not retroactively stabilise five irregular years. The lesson for applicants is therefore double-edged and entirely practical: a temporary, explicable dip below the SMIC — illness, Covid, a short gap between contracts — can be defended if the overall trajectory is stable and the current income reaches the SMIC; a structurally low or erratic income cannot, even with a fresh job offer in hand. For a full analysis of the procedural side of such refusals, readers may consult an immigration lawyer in Paris handling residence permit refusals and removal orders.

Money is not the only substantive condition. Article L. 426-19 of the CESEDA provides: « La décision d’accorder la carte de résident portant la mention ” résident de longue durée-UE ” prévue à l’article L. 426-17 est subordonnée au respect des conditions d’intégration républicaine prévues à l’article L. 413-7. » In English: granting the card is conditional on meeting the republican-integration requirements of article L. 413-7. Article L. 413-7 assesses integration in particular on the result of a civic examination above a regulatory threshold and on a command of French sufficient to understand clear conversation, produce simple coherent speech on everyday subjects, and briefly present an idea; the mayor of the applicant’s commune is consulted for an opinion, deemed favourable after two months of silence, and applicants over sixty-five are exempt from the language component. In practice, applicants who have completed years of lawful residence usually satisfy this through their civic and language record, but the file should still contain the examination results and any language certificates rather than assuming the point.

Finally, the documentary burden is regulatory and strict. Article R. 431-11 of the CESEDA refers applicants to the list fixed by ministerial order in annexe 10, whose item 58 requires the five-year resources evidence discussed above. Build the file as the judge will read it: five years of tax notices (avis d’imposition), pay slips, employment contracts, bank statements, proof of health cover, proof of uninterrupted lawful residence, and — where income dipped — a short, dated explanation with supporting evidence (medical certificates, employer’s letter on reduced hours, proof of the rebound). A refusal that ignores a complete file, or that applies a five-years-above-SMIC rule the courts have now twice rejected, is precisely the kind of legal error (erreur de droit) that gets annulled.

II. When the préfet says no: challenging the refusal and the removal order

A. Attacking the refusal itself: gracious appeal, hierarchical appeal and the administrative court within two months

A refusal arrives either as an express written decision or as silence: if the administration does not answer within four months of registration of the application, an implied refusal (décision implicite de rejet) is born, and the time limits run from there. The official Justice guidance on refusals and withdrawals of resident cards — including the EU long-term variant — sets out the options plainly: a gracious appeal (recours gracieux) to the prefect who decided, and/or a hierarchical appeal (recours hiérarchique) to the Ministry of the Interior, preferably within two months of notification so that the right to go to court is preserved, and, if the administration refuses or stays silent, an action before the administrative court within two months of an express refusal — or, after an implied refusal born of four months of silence, within two months once that silence period has expired. Two months, then, is the number to write down twice: once for the optional administrative appeals, once for the court.

The application to the tribunal administratif (administrative court) of your place of residence should ask for three things: annulment of the refusal, an injunction ordering the prefect to issue the card within a stated time, and costs under article L. 761-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice. The Paris case shows what a winning request looks like: the court not only annulled the prefect of police’s decision but ordered delivery of the card within two months — transferring the file to the territorially competent prefect if needed — and awarded 1,200 euros in costs. Frame the grounds around the holdings above: misapplication of the resources rule (SMIC required only at the decision date), manifest error of assessment where a temporary dip was treated as structural insufficiency, and, where relevant, failure to consider the trajectory and current level of income. Attach the full five-year documentary chain plus the explanation of any dip; the cases turn on evidence, not on rhetoric. Note that courts decide on the strongest ground and stop there — in Paris the judges expressly ruled on the resources error “without needing” to examine the other pleas — so lead with your best argument and document it heaviest.

Two practical warnings complete the picture. First, in Paris the competent authority is the prefect of police (préfet de police); everywhere else it is the territorial prefect of your department — address every appeal to the authority that actually signed, and file the court action at the tribunal of your residence. Second, legal aid (aide juridictionnelle) can be requested at the latest when the court action is filed, which matters because the one-month removal-order deadline below leaves no time to arrange funding afterwards. The refusal challenge and the removal-order challenge usually travel together in one file before the same court; the next section explains the second half, whose deadlines are even shorter.

B. The removal order attached to the refusal: thirty days to leave, one month to reach the judge

When the prefect refuses the card, the same order very often imposes an OQTF with a voluntary departure period. Article L. 612-1 of the CESEDA states: « L’étranger faisant l’objet d’une décision portant obligation de quitter le territoire français dispose d’un délai de départ volontaire de trente jours à compter de la notification de cette décision. » In English: the foreign national has thirty days from notification to leave voluntarily. The prefect may exceptionally grant longer, or extend it, for case-specific reasons — and that extension, if your circumstances warrant it (schooling children, medical treatment, a pending professional qualification), should be requested in writing immediately, not raised for the first time before the judge.

The challenge to that standard removal order goes to the administrative court under article L. 614-1 of the CESEDA, through the procedure whose time limits are fixed by decree: article R. 911-1 provides that “le tribunal administratif peut être saisi dans le délai d’un mois à compter de la notification de la décision”, the court must be seized within one month of notification — and it decides within six months, with no extension of the deadline by a parallel administrative appeal. One month, not two: the removal order runs on a faster clock than the refusal itself, so calendar both from the day of notification and file the removal-order challenge first. The Chilean applicant in the August 2026 Conseil d’État case received exactly this standard format — refusal of both the long-term card and the private-life card, plus a thirty-day OQTF with a designated country of return — and litigated all three together, which is the normal and correct way to proceed.

Beware the accelerated variants. If the order is issued without a departure delay, or if you are placed under house arrest (assignation à résidence) or in administrative detention (rétention administrative), different emergency procedures apply with deadlines counted in days and hours: article L. 921-1 gives seven days to seize the court where the foreign national is under house arrest, with judgment within fifteen days, and detention cases run on a ninety-six-hour clock. These are lawyer-within-hours situations. Finally, an entry ban (interdiction de retour sur le territoire français, IRTF) may accompany or follow the OQTF and can be challenged under article L. 614-4; check every page of the prefect’s order, because clients regularly discover the ban only when a later visa application fails. Challenge the refusal, the departure-delay decision, the removal order, the destination country and any entry ban together, before the right court, inside the shortest applicable deadline — and keep proof of notification dates for each.

Conclusion

The EU long-term resident card rewards five years of lawful, continuous, insured life in France with a ten-year card — provided the applicant’s own resources reach the SMIC at the date of the decision and republican integration is shown. The 2026 case law has clarified the resources test in both directions: a temporary, explicable dip below the SMIC does not disqualify, as the Paris court held on 23 September 2026 when it ordered the card issued; a structurally low and erratic income does, as the Conseil d’État confirmed on 3 August 2026 despite a fresh promise of permanent employment. If the prefect refuses, the calendar is everything: gracious or hierarchical appeal preferably within two months, court action against the refusal within two months of an express decision (or after four months of silence), and court action against a standard removal order within one month of notification, with emergency clocks of days or hours in detention cases. Assemble five years of tax and pay evidence, explain every dip with dated proof, verify the permit history excludes no qualifying year, and challenge every part of the order together. For readers facing a refusal with a thirty-day order already running, an early assessment by an immigration lawyer in Paris experienced in permit refusals and administrative appeals is the surest way to turn these deadlines from traps into remedies.

📄 Official document

Our data comes from the Cour de cassation (Judilibre), the Conseil d'État, the DILA, the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights.

Legal database search

Find a decision, a text or an analysis

More than 100,000 decisions annotated by our artificial intelligence, indexed in real time.

    Search powered by Meilisearch on kohenavocats.com.

    What our clients say

    4,885 Google reviews
    Share your review
    Contact Mobile
    3 weeks ago

    Very satisfied! I would like to thank Maître Esther Cornu here, who managed to resolve a very complicated dispute in a divorce and family law matter...Thanks to Maître Cornu, a judgment was handed down in my favour even though it was far from a foregone conclusion...So I recommend this law firm

    Google review translated from French

    Claude Frasson
    3 weeks ago

    A precise and concrete analysis and an immediate response. Excellent.

    Google review translated from French

    Basel Alali
    3 weeks ago

    I highly recommend this lawyer for his professionalism, honesty, and transparency. He helped me successfully and guided me through the process with great care and expertise. What I particularly appreciated was his honest approach and the fact that he recommended practical, cost-effective options instead of immediately pushing for the most expensive solution. He genuinely focused on finding the right approach for my situation. I’m very grateful for his support and would definitely recommend him to anyone looking for a trustworthy and professional lawyer in France.

    beatrice lefevre
    3 weeks ago

    Thank you for this detailed, precise help, with a proposal at the end on whether or not to continue (very quick response as well)

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-pierre Steinmetz
    1 month ago

    Very good advice given by Maître Cornu during our meeting on 16 October.

    Google review translated from French

    John Roberts
    1 month ago

    Very professional and responsive service. The lawyer quickly and carefully checked the validity of my wife’s residence permit in light of a specific legal regime. His work gave us clarity, whereas the usual administrative procedures were long and ambiguous. I appreciated his efficiency and professionalism, and I recommend his services.

    Google review translated from French

    Jean-François PAPA
    1 month ago

    I would like to warmly thank Maître Esther Cornu for her professionalism, her availability and the quality of her support. In a case of particular importance for my professional future, she showed great responsiveness, rigour and a gift for explaining things, taking the time to answer my questions precisely and to explain the various legal steps to me. I particularly appreciate the clarity of her analyses, her seriousness and her commitment in following up my case. Many thanks to Maître Esther Cornu for listening and for her support. I highly recommend!

    Google review translated from French

    Sandra Imbert
    1 month ago

    A huge thank you to Maître Esther Cornu from Kohen Avocats for her support during a particularly difficult time. Her attentiveness, empathy, and humanity touched me deeply. She was able to answer my questions with clarity and sensitivity, while demonstrating great professionalism and fully respecting the confidentiality of the case. Beyond her professional qualities, I met a deeply humane lawyer whose support made a real difference. I sincerely recommend her.

    Google review translated from French

    Djamel Haddouche
    1 month ago

    I am facing a dispute with my employer, and the support provided by Maître Hassan COHEN as well as Maître Esther Cornu is excellent. The answers are clear and well-thought-out, they genuinely listen, and interactions are very pleasant. Thank you again, I highly recommend.

    Google review translated from French

    Nima Sdc
    1 month ago

    A law firm that is attentive to its clients. Maître Kohen and his team are very, very professional and truly master their field.

    Google review translated from French

    jules p
    1 month ago

    I highly recommend Cabinet Kohen, and particularly Maître Esther Cornu, who supported me throughout my case. She skillfully combined attentiveness and expertise to guide me through these difficult and stressful times. She was always available to answer all my questions with precision and responsiveness. Thanks to her preparation work, I was able to approach the situation with much greater peace of mind. Her kindness and humanity made me feel at ease throughout our exchanges. I am very grateful to her for her support and professionalism. You can trust her with your eyes closed.

    Google review translated from French

    Jocelyne Chassard
    2 months ago

    I have just spoken on the phone with Monsieur Chahdi from your law firm: I wanted to congratulate you on your online article regarding order no. 519225 of the Conseil d’État dated August 30, 2026. You clearly explained the content of this order, which does not grant prefectures a general blank check to replace a demonstration ban with a restrictive receipt modifying one or more circumstances of a demonstration, but which, in a specific case, held that the applicants had not sufficiently demonstrated a serious and disproportionate infringement on the fundamental freedom to publicly express opinions. As I told Mr. Chahdi, I am facing this restrictive receipt issue in Reims for a demonstration scheduled for tomorrow afternoon in front of the judicial court: the organizer has just filed an urgent fundamental freedom petition (référé-liberté) before the Châlons-en-Champagne Administrative Court. Monsieur Chahdi initially seemed surprised by the call from an 'ordinary citizen', but he listened to me and answered with courtesy.

    Google review translated from French

    Menah'em
    3 months ago

    I would like to express my gratitude to the Kohen Avocats law firm and especially to Maître Chahdi. From our very first phone call, Maître Chahdi was available, attentive, and offered remarkable advice. The firm's reception and follow-up reflect a very high level of standards and expertise. Many thanks to the entire team for their support and impeccable professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Мария Двирник
    3 weeks ago
    Moula Brahimi
    3 weeks ago

    Good experience. And good work, thank you for everything.

    Google review translated from French

    Faiza Traduction
    1 month ago
    Alain Arsaut
    1 month ago

    Saw Hassan on the TV news

    Google review translated from French

    TOULEIMAT HACHEM
    1 month ago
    emilie lepicard
    1 month ago
    إبراهيم عيسى
    1 month ago
    Monique Firmin
    2 months ago

    Excellent phone reception. Great professionalism.

    Google review translated from French

    Louna Sisi
    2 months ago

    Excellent

    Google review translated from French

    Sophie Lascar
    3 months ago
    Solal Gaillard
    3 months ago
    Preliminary case review

    Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

    Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

    • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
    • Personal reply within 24 working hours
    • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    80 €TTC

    Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

    • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
    • Secure payment, no card details stored
    • Terms and fee agreement

    Cliquez or drag your files here
    All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

    Sending...

    Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
    Terms · Privacy policy.

    Free legal AI

    A question of French law? Ask Judith.

    Judith searches the French codes, the Constitution, the European Convention on Human Rights and the courts’ decisions, then shows you the texts and the passages of rulings that may answer your question, with their official source. Free, no account; she writes nothing for you. Questions and results are in French. Discover Judith, the firm’s free legal AI.

    Three searches a day. Your question is recorded and reviewed by the firm to improve the tool: do not enter names or sensitive information.