KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
ABTA Tells Britons Not to Apply for ETIAS: Scam Sites, French Border Queues and How UK Travellers to France Get Their Money Back

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

ABTA Tells Britons Not to Apply for ETIAS: Scam Sites, French Border Queues and How UK Travellers to France Get Their Money Back

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 13 October 2026, Britain’s travel association ABTA told British holidaymakers not to apply for the European ETIAS travel waiver, because the scheme is suspended and more than 150 websites are already offering to obtain a document that does not exist yet. The warning matters far beyond Britain: the same waiver will apply to Americans, Canadians and Australians travelling to France, the same Entry/Exit System queues are forming at French border posts, and French law already decides what happens when a traveller pays a copycat site, is refused entry, or loses a package holiday to border chaos. This article gives the French lawyer’s reading of the story: why no one should pay for ETIAS today, which French criminal rules catch the scam sites, what a refusal of entry at a French airport or juxtaposed control really triggers, and how package travellers get their money back under the French Tourism Code as interpreted by the Cour de cassation on 9 July 2025.

I. Do Not Apply for ETIAS Now: the ABTA Warning and the 150 Copycat Sites

A. What ABTA Announced on 13 October 2026 and Why ETIAS Is on Hold

According to The Guardian’s report of 13 October 2026, ABTA’s director of public affairs Luke Petherbridge stated that while ETIAS was due to come into force this year, it is now back on hold, adding that ABTA believes it should not be brought in until the Entry/Exit System is fully operational and working properly. The two systems were designed to start together: the Entry/Exit System (EES), the European Union’s biometric registration of third-country entries and exits, began its rollout on 12 October 2025, as ABTA’s own traveller guidance records, while ETIAS, the European Travel Information and Authorisation System created by Regulation (EU) 2018/1240, was supposed to follow once EES worked. Both have been repeatedly postponed, and the persistent problems after the introduction of EES, including the software at French entry points described by the British press in September 2026, have kept ETIAS suspended with no launch date set.

When it eventually goes live, ETIAS will concern every visa-exempt non-EU traveller entering the Schengen area, including British, American, Canadian and Australian visitors to France, at a fee that has risen from 7 euros to 20 euros, with no payment required for travellers over 70 and under 18. ABTA’s research found public awareness of the coming requirements rising from 41 percent in 2024 to 56 percent now, which is exactly the awareness gap in which copycat websites thrive. Petherbridge’s practical message, quoted in the press, was blunt: travellers cannot and should not apply for an ETIAS now. There is, to date, nothing to apply for, and money paid today buys at best a worthless promise and at worst an identity-theft kit.

The French dimension of the delay is concrete. EES is, in the words of the 13 October reporting, in full operation, but European authorities have told border posts that no penalties will be enforced where officers suspend the system when queues escalate. That flexibility avoided the worst over the summer: ABTA surveys found only 46 percent of visitors to Europe reporting full checks, half of those waiting less than thirty minutes, and only 13 percent queueing for an hour. For France, which receives British travellers through airports, ports and juxtaposed controls, the same tradeoff applies every day: full biometric registration or fluid queues. Anyone travelling to Paris, the Riviera or the Alps this autumn should therefore expect the current hybrid regime to continue, with selective full checks, possible long waits at peak times, and no ETIAS requirement whatsoever. Readers who want the general French framework for ETIAS refusals once the system is live can also read our companion analysis of the ETIAS delay, refusal of entry and how to challenge a French border decision, which this article completes with the scam and refund angles raised by the ABTA warning.

B. The 150 Unofficial ETIAS Sites: What French Criminal Law Says About Sellers of a Nonexistent Document

The most striking figure in the 13 October warning is the count relayed by ABTA: European authorities believe more than 150 websites offering ETIAS already exist, while there is only one official site travellers should use once the scheme is live. The European border agency Frontex had warned about scam websites long before ETIAS was due to start. Commercial intermediaries may lawfully file applications on a client’s behalf once applications exist, but Frontex described risks ranging from data protection failures and identity theft to extortionate fees, with some unofficial sites providing inaccurate information about who needs an ETIAS while mimicking the layout of the official website and using convincing domain names. The European Union’s own guidance states the test plainly: all official European Union website addresses are in the europa.eu domain, and the only ETIAS address to trust is travel-europe.europa.eu/etias.

Seen from France, selling an ETIAS authorisation today is not a grey marketing practice; it is the sale of a nonexistent administrative document, and French criminal law has a name for obtaining money by making a victim believe in an imaginary power or product. Article 313-1 of the French Criminal Code provides: “L’escroquerie est le fait, soit par l’usage d’un faux nom ou d’une fausse qualité, soit par l’abus d’une qualité vraie, soit par l’emploi de manoeuvres frauduleuses, de tromper une personne physique ou morale et de la déterminer ainsi, à son préjudice ou au préjudice d’un tiers, à remettre des fonds, des valeurs ou un bien quelconque, à fournir un service ou à consentir un acte opérant obligation ou décharge.” (in substance: deceiving a person, by a false identity or fraudulent manoeuvres, so that they hand over funds or consent to an obligation) The full text is published at Article 313-1 of the Code pénal on Légifrance. The offence carries five years’ imprisonment and a 375,000 euro fine. A site that today takes 20 euros or more for an ETIAS filing, while no filing exists, presents precisely the profile the statute describes: a supposed official capacity, a deceived traveller, and funds handed over for nothing.

That qualification matters for two practical reasons. First, victims who paid from France, including British residents in France and American or Canadian visitors who used a French connection, can file a criminal complaint for fraud before the French authorities and report the site to the French illegal-content reporting platform, keeping every receipt, screenshot and email header, because the deception, the payment and the service supposedly rendered are documented entirely online. Second, the fraud analysis sits alongside consumer and data-protection remedies: payment by card opens the chargeback route with the issuing bank, and the harvesting of passport numbers and biometric-adjacent data by a copycat site is exactly the identity-theft scenario Frontex flagged. The single reflex that avoids all of this is the one ABTA gave: apply nowhere until the European Union announces a launch date, and then only through the europa.eu address. Anyone who has already paid should treat the payment as evidence, not as an application, and act on the refund and complaint tracks in parallel rather than waiting to see whether a document ever arrives.

II. Entering France While the New Border Regime Beds In: Refusal, Holding Areas and Package Refunds

A. Refused Entry at a French Border Post: the Decision, the Holding Area and the Correct Challenge

ETIAS being suspended does not mean French borders are open without conditions. The applicable rules today are the Schengen Borders Code, Regulation (EU) 2016/399, combined with the French Code of Entry and Residence of Foreigners and Asylum (CESEDA), and the EES biometric layer added by Regulation (EU) 2017/2226. French domestic law states the entry requirement in direct terms. Article L. 311-1 of the CESEDA provides: “Pour entrer en France, tout étranger doit être muni” (“To enter France, every foreigner must hold”) the visas and documents it lists, expressly referring to Article 6 of the Schengen Borders Code, and Article L. 311-2 of the CESEDA adds: “Un étranger ne satisfait pas aux conditions d’entrée sur le territoire français lorsqu’il se trouve dans les situations suivantes” , meaning a foreigner in one of the listed situations does not satisfy the entry conditions,, starting with threat to public order and Schengen Information System alerts for refusal of admission. Where those conditions are not met, Article L. 332-1 of the CESEDA states: “L’étranger qui ne satisfait pas aux conditions d’admission prévues au titre I peut faire l’objet d’une décision de refus d’entrée, sans préjudice des dispositions particulières relatives au droit d’asile et à la protection internationale ou à la délivrance de visas de long séjour.” (in substance: a foreigner not meeting the admission conditions may be refused entry, subject to the specific asylum and long-stay visa rules). And Article L. 333-1 of the CESEDA underlines its immediate force: “La décision de refus d’entrée sur le territoire français dont l’étranger fait l’objet peut être exécutée d’office par l’autorité administrative.” (in substance: the administration may enforce the refusal decision directly).

A traveller refused at Paris-Charles de Gaulle, Paris-Orly, Marseille, a Channel port or a juxtaposed control is therefore facing an enforceable administrative decision, not a negotiation, and the next question is material: waiting where, under which safeguards, before return. French law answers with the holding area, the zone d’attente. Article L. 341-1 of the CESEDA provides: “L’étranger qui arrive en France par la voie ferroviaire, maritime ou aérienne et qui n’est pas autorisé à entrer sur le territoire français peut être placé dans une zone d’attente située dans une gare ferroviaire ouverte au trafic international figurant sur une liste définie par voie réglementaire, dans un port ou à proximité du lieu de débarquement ou dans un aéroport, pendant le temps strictement nécessaire à son départ.” (in substance: a person arriving by rail, sea or air without entry authorisation may be held in a waiting area at the station, port or airport for the time strictly needed for departure). Judicial control of extended holding is real but time-framed: Article L. 342-1 of the CESEDA allows the judicial judge to authorise holding beyond ninety-six hours for no more than eight days, ruling on the effective exercise of the foreigner’s rights. Those rights are listed at Article L. 343-1 of the CESEDA: “L’étranger placé en zone d’attente est informé, dans les meilleurs délais, qu’il peut demander l’assistance d’un interprète et d’un médecin, communiquer avec un conseil ou toute personne de son choix et quitter à tout moment la zone d’attente pour toute destination située hors de France.” (in substance: the person held must promptly be told, in a language they understand, of the rights to an interpreter, a doctor and counsel, and of the right to leave at any time for a destination outside France). The information must be given in a language the person understands.

The most useful recent illustration comes from Paris, weeks before the ABTA warning. By an order of 9 September 2026 (RG 26/05087), the Paris Court of Appeal ruled on an Interior Ministry appeal against a Bobigny judicial judge’s refusal to extend a Lebanese traveller’s holding in an airport waiting area. The court confirmed, following settled Cour de cassation case law (2nd Civil Chamber, 7 June 2001, appeal no. 99-50.053), that the judicial judge ruling on an application to extend holding in a waiting area has no jurisdiction to assess the lawfulness of the administrative refusal-of-admission and holding decisions, in particular the grounds adopted by the administration. That recent Paris order of 9 September 2026 (RG 26/05087) illustrates the split. The lesson for a refused British, American or Canadian traveller is structural: the judicial judge in holding proceedings checks detention safeguards and time limits, while the refusal itself is challenged before the administrative court. Confusing the two tracks wastes the short time available. The correct reflexes are immediate and parallel: request the written reasoned refusal form, ask for an interpreter and counsel, contact the consulate, keep boarding passes and EES printouts showing queues and checks, and have the administrative challenge prepared without waiting for release, because the decision is enforceable from notification.

B. When Border Chaos Ruins the Trip: Terminating the Package and Making the Seller Refund

The second half of the ABTA story is commercial: travellers who bought package holidays to France and face hours of EES queues, missed connections or even refusal of one member of the party. Here French law is unusually protective, because the Tourism Code provisions at stake transpose the European package-travel directive, Directive (EU) 2015/2302, and have just been clarified by the Cour de cassation in terms that reach beyond the pandemic cases that produced them. Article L. 211-14, II, of the Tourism Code provides: “Le voyageur a le droit de résoudre le contrat avant le début du voyage ou du séjour sans payer de frais de résolution si des circonstances exceptionnelles et inévitables, survenant au lieu de destination ou à proximité immédiate de celui-ci, ont des conséquences importantes sur l’exécution du contrat ou sur le transport des passagers vers le lieu de destination.” (in substance: free termination before departure where extraordinary and unavoidable circumstances at or near the destination significantly affect performance or carriage). The traveller then receives a full refund of payments made, with no additional compensation. Symmetrically, the organiser may itself terminate and refund in full, without extra compensation, where extraordinary and unavoidable circumstances prevent performance and it notifies the traveller promptly before departure.

The Cour de cassation gave these provisions their full practical scope on 9 July 2025 (First Civil Chamber, appeal no. 23-22.063, decision no. 373 FS-D of 9 July 2025). The case concerned a Mediterranean cruise sold for October 2020 and cancelled in the pandemic context, and the Court held that under Article L. 211-14, III, 2°, of the Tourism Code, the organiser or retailer may terminate the contract and reimburse the traveller in full, with no additional compensation, where extraordinary and unavoidable circumstances prevent performance and termination is notified to the traveller promptly before departure. The Court added that the Covid-19 pandemic may as such fall within extraordinary and unavoidable circumstances. The decision recalls that the pandemic is capable of falling within unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances under Article 12 of Directive 2015/2302, citing the CJEU rulings of 8 June 2023 (UFC-Que Choisir and CLCV, C-407/21) and 4 October 2024 (GF, C-546/22).

Three holdings of that decision matter directly for border-disruption cases. First, the assessment is effects-based: following the Court of Justice’s 4 October 2024 ruling (GF, C-546/22, paragraph 50), an event can prevent performance even where it does not make performance objectively impossible, which is precisely the profile of multi-hour EES queues that cause missed onward travel without closing the border. Second, the seller’s liability for performance is strict: a trader selling a package is automatically liable for the services in the contract, whether performed directly or by other providers, without prejudice to its right of recourse against them, the full text being at Article L. 211-16 of the Tourism Code. A retailer cannot therefore hide behind the airline, the border police or the EES software: it answers to the traveller first and recovers against the organiser afterwards. Third, the Court settled the upstream chain: an agency that has refunded the traveller may recover from the organiser the sums received for unperformed services, plus any damages owed to the traveller for late notification, and that recourse is not conditional on fault. Refunds must follow promptly, through the mechanism of Article R. 211-10 of the same code.

Translated into advice for a British family whose French package collapses at the border this autumn, the sequence is the following. Before travelling, no ETIAS payment to anyone, and written confirmation from the organiser of what happens if EES queues cause a missed connection. At the border, documentary discipline: keep timed proof of queue length, of the checks undergone, of any refusal form, and of every disrupted service, because extraordinary circumstances are proved by effects, not by press cuttings. After the event, written termination invoking Article L. 211-14 where the conditions are met, or a strict-liability claim under Article L. 211-16 for improperly performed services, addressed to the retailer who sold the package, with a full refund of payments as the baseline and additional compensation only where the statute allows it. Keep copies of every exchange with the retailer and the organiser, send termination and refund requests in writing with proof of receipt, and diarise the refund deadline, because a file with dated queue evidence, a refusal form where one exists, and complete payment records is the file that gets refunded without litigation. The retailer’s difficulties with its own suppliers are its recourse problem, not the traveller’s, and that allocation of risk is exactly what the Cour de cassation confirmed.

Conclusion

The ABTA warning of 13 October 2026 reduces to three operational rules for English-speaking travellers to France. Nothing ETIAS-related should be paid for anywhere until the European Union sets a launch date, and then only on the europa.eu official site, because the 150-plus existing offers sell a procedure that is suspended and expose buyers to fraud and identity theft punishable under Article 313-1 of the French Criminal Code. At the French border, entry remains governed by the Schengen Borders Code and Articles L. 311-1, L. 311-2, L. 332-1 and L. 333-1 of the CESEDA, with holding under Articles L. 341-1 to L. 343-1, judicial control of time limits, and, as the Paris Court of Appeal recalled on 9 September 2026, challenges to the refusal itself directed to the administrative court. And where the trip is a package, Articles L. 211-14 and L. 211-16 of the Tourism Code, read through the Cour de cassation’s 9 July 2025 decision, put the refund duty on the seller first, with strict liability and an effects-based test for extraordinary circumstances that fits EES queue chaos better than travellers assume. Do not pay for ETIAS, document everything at the border, and claim the refund from the party who sold the journey: that is the whole autumn strategy in one sentence.

📄 Official circular