Kohen Avocats — Employment law
Poor performance dismissal lawyer in Paris: grounds, evidence and challenge
Missed targets, mistakes or lack of autonomy: for a poor performance dismissal (licenciement pour insuffisance professionnelle), the firm examines the criticisms, the training and the resources provided, then prepares your reply or your case before the employment tribunal.
Received a notice to attend or a dismissal letter? Send the document and the date you received it so the applicable time limits can be checked.
Poor performance · Paris
Have your situation reviewed
Employee or employer, send the written criticisms and the appraisals to our employment law firm in Paris.
Permanent contract
Personal ground
and evidence
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
Understanding and challenging a poor performance dismissal
Employment law · Paris 16th
Your poor performance dismissal lawyer in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Employment law
- Employees and employers
- Paris and the Paris region
A notice to attend arrives after a difficult appraisal interview. You are criticised for mistakes, missed targets or a lack of autonomy. The firm examines the facts, the duties assigned and the resources available in order to assess the genuine and serious cause (cause réelle et sérieuse) required by Article L1232-1 of the French Labour Code (Code du travail). It also checks whether the employer adapted the employee to the job and provided training, in light of Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code.
As an employee, you want to understand the criticisms and prepare your reply. As an employer, you want to assess a file before taking a decision. The firm analyses the documents, checks the procedure and calculates the claims that could be brought. If the matter goes to court, it prepares the case before the employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes), which has jurisdiction over individual disputes arising from the employment contract (Article L1411-1 of the French Labour Code). You can send the notice to attend or the letter you received and reach the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Understanding the ground
Compare the criticisms with the duties, the targets and the actual working conditions.
Preparing the evidence
Review the appraisals, the correspondence and the training, then build a verifiable chronology.
Deciding what comes next
Prepare the interview, consider an amicable solution or organise the case before the employment tribunal.
Characterising the dismissal
Poor performance, results or misconduct?
A dismissal must be based on a genuine and serious cause. The judge assesses the evidence produced by both parties (Article L1232-1 of the French Labour Code, Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code).
Ability to perform the job
Poor performance
A personal ground
- Mistakes in tasks, organisational difficulties or lack of autonomy, to be examined in concrete terms.
- Compare the duties actually assigned with the skills expected.
- Check the support and the resources available.
Conduct complained of
Disciplinary misconduct
A distinct characterisation
- Do not infer misconduct from repeated mistakes alone.
- Look for a deliberate failure to act or deliberate ill will where poor performance is sanctioned.
- Read the letter and characterise the facts, without stopping at its heading.
“Poor performance, save in the case of a deliberate failure to act or deliberate ill will on the part of the employee, does not constitute misconduct.” (our translation)
Cass. soc., 17 September 2025, No. 24-16.336, para. 6
In this disciplinary dismissal case, repeated accounting errors did not relieve the judges of the duty to examine whether they were deliberate. The Court quashed the decision to require that examination; it does not hold that every professional error would rule out a non-disciplinary dismissal.
Results
A figure does not describe all the work
A missed target calls for analysis: the comparison period, the sector assigned, the tools, the resources, changes in the job and the difficulties reported. Review of the cause of the dismissal is based on the evidence in the file (Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code). In the judgment of 6 May 2025, the Court relied in particular on the comparison with colleagues of similar experience, the support measures and the lack of autonomy of a managerial employee to uphold the dismissal (Cass. soc., 6 May 2025, No. 23-23.294, paras. 7 to 9).
Adaptation to the job and resources provided
Before blaming the failure on the employee
The employer must ensure that employees are adapted to their job and must see to it that they remain able to hold employment. This obligation is set out in Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code.
The work required
Reconstructing the expectations
The firm compares the contract, the job description and the instructions received. A change of tool, method or duties should be placed in time. These elements make it possible to examine the adaptation required by Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code and whether the ground for termination is genuine in light of Article L1232-1 of the French Labour Code.
The help actually provided
Documenting the support
Training programmes, mentoring, replies to requests for help and access to tools are useful documents. Their content must be read: a training course attended does not necessarily address the difficulty complained of. The judge weighs the parties' evidence under Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code.
Performance improvement plan
A document to analyse
A performance improvement plan can help to understand the expectations, the resources offered and the exchanges. Its title proves neither poor performance nor compliance with the adaptation obligation. Article L6321-1 sets out that obligation; it does not, on its own, provide for a universal document bearing that name. The firm also looks for the collective agreement provisions applicable to the case.
Lack of training is not dealt with by an automatic formula. The difficulties, the needs linked to the job and the measures taken must be identified, then their effect on the criticisms assessed (Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code, Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code).
Preparing the file
Which facts and which documents to compare?
The judge forms an opinion on the basis of the evidence provided by the parties. If any doubt remains, it benefits the employee (Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code).
- Contract, amendments, job description and the collective agreement shown on the payslips.
- Notice to attend, dismissal letter, envelope and any clarification of the grounds.
- Successive appraisals, dated targets and results tables with their context.
- Training requests, programmes attended, mentoring and support reports.
- Exchanges about the mistakes complained of, the instructions, the difficulties and the resources available.
- Payslips, length of service, notice, outstanding paid leave and sums already paid.
Employee
Answering each criticism
A good earlier appraisal, a technical difficulty that was reported or a contradictory instruction should be set against the facts relied on. These documents feed into the review provided for by Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code; none of them decides the outcome on its own. The firm prepares a dated, precise reply linked to the documents available.
Employer
Keeping the context as well
The file must make it possible to examine the work expected, the difficulties observed and the support measures. In the case decided on 6 May 2025, the Court upheld the dismissal in light of a set of findings, in particular the comparative results and the autonomy required:
“From these findings and statements, it was entitled to infer, without being required to examine the disciplinary complaint concerning unacceptable conduct towards a client, that the dismissal was based on a genuine and serious cause.” (our translation)
Cass. soc., 6 May 2025, No. 23-23.294, para. 9
The partial quashing ordered on other claims did not call into question this ruling on the dismissal.
Interview, letter and challenge
The procedure and the time limits to check
Keep the dates on which letters were presented and received. They are used to check the time limits under Articles L1232-2, R1232-13 and L1471-1.
5 days
working days at least before the interview
2 days
working days at least before the dismissal is sent
15 days
to request clarification
12 months
general limitation period for challenging the dismissal
Notice to attend
The employer invites the employee to a meeting before any decision is taken. At least five working days must separate the presentation or hand delivery of the notice to attend from the preliminary interview (Article L1232-2 of the French Labour Code).
Interview
The employer sets out the grounds being considered and hears the employee's explanations. The employee may be assisted under the conditions laid down by law (Article L1232-3 of the French Labour Code, Article L1232-4 of the French Labour Code).
Notification
The registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt states the grounds. It cannot be sent less than two working days after the date scheduled for the interview (Article L1232-6 of the French Labour Code).
Clarification
The employee may request clarification within fifteen days of notification. The employer then has fifteen days from receipt to reply, if it so wishes (Article R1232-13 of the French Labour Code).
Challenge
The employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes) hears the dispute. An action concerning the termination is, in principle, time-barred twelve months after its notification (Article L1411-1 of the French Labour Code, Article L1471-1 of the French Labour Code).
The lawyer prepares the interview with you. The assistance provided for by Article L1232-4 of the French Labour Code is given by a member of the company's staff or, where the company has no employee representative bodies, by an employee adviser (conseiller du salarié). The text does not provide for a right to be accompanied by an outside lawyer.
Grounds
The letter sets the scope of the dispute
The letter, as clarified where applicable, sets the limits of the dispute as to the grounds. Insufficient reasons do not automatically make the dismissal unjustified, in particular where the employee did not request clarification (Article L1235-2 of the French Labour Code). The firm examines the initial letter, any request and the reply together.
Limitation periods
Identifying each claim
Article L1471-1 distinguishes actions relating to the performance of the contract, in principle two years from knowledge of the facts, from those relating to its termination, in principle twelve months from its notification. It provides for exclusions, in particular for salary, discrimination and harassment. Salary claims are subject to the three-year time limit in Article L3245-1 of the French Labour Code, with the rules on the recoverable period laid down by that text. The starting point and the legal characterisation must be checked for each claim.
Termination sums and compensation
Which payments to examine?
The calculation distinguishes the sums due on termination from any compensation for an unjustified dismissal. It depends on the legislation, length of service, salary and the applicable collective agreement.
Entitlements on termination
Severance pay
For a permanent contract (CDI), Article L1234-9 of the French Labour Code provides for severance pay from eight months of uninterrupted service, except in the case of gross misconduct. The statutory minimum is one quarter of a month's salary per year of service up to ten years, then one third per year beyond that (Article R1234-2 of the French Labour Code). The reference salary is determined using the more favourable formula provided for by Article R1234-4 of the French Labour Code. The firm compares this calculation with the applicable collective agreement provisions.
End of the contract
Notice and paid leave
The notice period depends on length of service and on any more favourable provisions (Article L1234-1 of the French Labour Code). If the employer releases the employee from working it, the payment in lieu of notice preserves the corresponding salary and benefits (Article L1234-5 of the French Labour Code). Accrued but untaken leave gives rise to the payment in lieu provided for by Article L3141-28 of the French Labour Code.
Dismissal without genuine and serious cause
The Article L1235-3 scale
If the proposed reinstatement is refused by either party, the judge awards compensation between the minimum and maximum amounts in Article L1235-3 of the French Labour Code. The table depends on length of service in complete years; some minimum amounts are lower where the company usually employs fewer than eleven employees. The exact line of the table must be applied, without announcing a flat rate or a guaranteed amount.
Nullity
Exceptions to the scale
The scale does not apply to the cases of nullity listed in Article L1235-3-1 of the French Labour Code, in particular those linked to a fundamental freedom, harassment or discrimination, under the conditions set by that text. If the employee does not ask for the contract to continue or reinstatement is impossible, the compensation cannot be less than the salary for the last six months. A disagreement over a performance appraisal does not, on its own, amount to one of these cases of nullity.
Procedural irregularity
A procedural defect distinct from the grounds
Where the grounds remain genuine and serious but the procedure is irregular, Article L1235-2 of the French Labour Code provides for compensation capped at one month's salary. Compensation for an unjustified dismissal is a separate question. The firm keeps these claims apart so as not to confuse the timetable, the reasons given in the letter and whether the criticisms are well founded.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about poor performance dismissal in France
What is a dismissal for poor performance in France?
It is a dismissal for personal reasons based on difficulties in carrying out the duties assigned. It must be justified by a genuine and serious cause, in accordance with Article L1232-1 of the French Labour Code. The file may concern mistakes, poor organisation or a lack of autonomy, but these criticisms must be examined in context.
The lawyer compares the requirements of the job, the facts relied on and the employee's explanations. They check the training and the resources made available, in light of Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code. In the event of a dispute, the judge assesses the evidence of both parties and any remaining doubt benefits the employee (Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code). An unfavourable assessment by a manager therefore does not remove the need to work on the documents.
Is poor performance gross misconduct in France?
It is not misconduct, unless there is a deliberate failure to act or deliberate ill will on the part of the employee. The Court of Cassation restated this in a disciplinary dismissal case involving repeated accounting errors (Cass. soc., 17 September 2025, No. 24-16.336). The seriousness of the possible consequences does not replace an examination of whether the failings were deliberate.
The facts described in the letter must be read, not just its heading. The judge reviews their characterisation and assesses whether there is a genuine and serious cause under Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code. For the employee as for the employer, confusing an inability to carry out a task with a refusal to do so can change the analysis of the dismissal and of the payments due.
Can I be dismissed in France for missing my targets?
It is necessary to understand what the results reveal about the work actually done. The review provided for by Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code leads to an examination of the targets, the period, the resources, the support and the employee's explanations. The firm checks in particular whether the comparisons are based on comparable situations and whether the difficulties had been reported.
In the judgment of 6 May 2025, the Court upheld a dismissal taking into account results below those of colleagues of comparable experience, support measures and the lack of autonomy found in a managerial post (Cass. soc., 6 May 2025, No. 23-23.294). This decision illustrates an overall assessment: it does not turn every missed target into an automatic ground for dismissal.
Can I challenge my dismissal if my employer did not provide training?
The lack of suitable training is a point to examine. Under Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code, the employer ensures that employees are adapted to their job and maintains their capacity to hold employment. To assess the file, this obligation must be compared with the specific difficulties criticised and the changes made to the duties, tools or organisation.
Gather requests for help, the replies received, the programmes followed and the reports on support. A list of training courses does not always describe what was learnt or the needs of the job. The judge examines these elements together with the whole file, under Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code. The analysis does not make it possible to announce that the dismissal will automatically be set aside whenever training is missing.
Is a warning or a performance improvement plan required before dismissal in France?
Professional support should not be confused with a sanction. The statutory procedure for dismissal for personal reasons provides in particular for a notice to attend, an interview and a reasoned notification (Article L1232-2 of the French Labour Code, Article L1232-6 of the French Labour Code). These texts do not, on their own, require a prior number of warnings or a document entitled performance plan. Any collective agreement safeguards specific to the case still need to be checked.
The employer remains bound to adapt the employee to the job (Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code). A plan can document the expectations and the help offered, but it is not enough to prove the ground for dismissal. Conversely, sanctioning mere poor performance raises the distinction between poor performance and misconduct restated by Cass. soc., 17 September 2025, No. 24-16.336.
How does the procedure for a poor performance dismissal work in France?
The employer invites the employee to an interview before deciding on dismissal. The interview cannot take place less than five working days after the registered letter is presented or the notice to attend is handed over (Article L1232-2 of the French Labour Code). During the interview, the employer states the grounds being considered and hears the employee's explanations (Article L1232-3 of the French Labour Code).
If the employer then decides to dismiss, it sends a registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt stating the grounds. It cannot be sent less than two working days after the date scheduled for the interview (Article L1232-6 of the French Labour Code). Keep the letters, envelopes and proofs of receipt. The firm checks these steps and any collective agreement safeguards, distinguishing procedural irregularities from the central question: do the criticisms justify the dismissal?
Can my lawyer attend the pre-dismissal interview with me?
The right to assistance provided for by Article L1232-4 of the French Labour Code concerns a person chosen from among the company's staff. Where there are no employee representative bodies, the employee may also choose an employee adviser (conseiller du salarié) from the official list. This article does not give a right to insist on the presence of a lawyer from outside the company at the interview.
The lawyer can nevertheless prepare this interview with you: reading the notice to attend, organising the documents, identifying the questions and working on replies to the known criticisms. The interview must allow the employer to set out the grounds being considered and to hear your explanations (Article L1232-3 of the French Labour Code). After the interview, send the firm a factual account and any new documents handed over or received.
What evidence do I need to challenge a poor performance dismissal?
Start with the dismissal letter and any clarification of it, which set the limits of the grounds in dispute (Article L1235-2 of the French Labour Code). Add the contract, any amendments, the job description, successive appraisals, the targets and the correspondence about the difficulties. For each criticism, state the date, the circumstances and the documents that allow its accuracy or its explanation to be discussed.
Documents relating to training and to the resources available are used to examine the duty to adapt the employee under Article L6321-1 of the French Labour Code. The judge reaches a decision on the basis of both parties' evidence and may order investigative measures; any remaining doubt benefits the employee (Article L1235-1 of the French Labour Code). An earlier favourable appraisal is useful to set against recent criticisms, without guaranteeing the outcome of the dispute on its own.
What compensation is due after a poor performance dismissal in France?
For an employee on a permanent contract (CDI) with at least eight months of uninterrupted service, Article L1234-9 of the French Labour Code provides for statutory severance pay, except in the case of gross misconduct. Its minimum is calculated under Article R1234-2 of the French Labour Code: one quarter of a month per year up to ten years, then one third per year beyond that. The reference salary is governed by Article R1234-4 of the French Labour Code. An applicable collective agreement may call for a different calculation to be examined.
The notice period must also be checked (Article L1234-1 of the French Labour Code), as must the payment in lieu where the employer releases the employee from working it (Article L1234-5 of the French Labour Code) and accrued but untaken leave (Article L3141-28 of the French Labour Code). These sums are distinct from any compensation for an unjustified dismissal, which is subject to review by the judge and to the rules of Article L1235-3 of the French Labour Code.
What compensation scale applies to an unfair dismissal in France?
Where the dismissal is without genuine and serious cause and either party refuses the proposed reinstatement, Article L1235-3 of the French Labour Code provides for compensation between the minimum and maximum amounts in its table. Length of service is counted in complete years. Some minimum amounts differ for companies usually employing fewer than eleven employees. The amount therefore cannot be announced without the details of the case.
The cases of nullity listed in Article L1235-3-1 of the French Labour Code follow different rules. If the employee does not ask for the contract to continue or reinstatement is impossible, the compensation cannot be less than the salary for the last six months. Disputing a performance assessment is not enough to establish nullity: its own legal basis must be checked.
What is the time limit to challenge a dismissal before the employment tribunal?
An action concerning the termination of the contract is, in principle, time-barred twelve months after its notification, under Article L1471-1 of the French Labour Code. The same text provides for exclusions, in particular for actions relating to salary, discrimination or harassment. Each claim must therefore be characterised and its starting point checked, without applying a single time limit to all the sums claimed.
An action for payment of salary is subject to the three-year time limit laid down in Article L3245-1 of the French Labour Code, which also specifies the period the claim may cover. Send the firm the initial letter, any clarification and their dates promptly. The employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes) settles individual disputes and rules on the case if conciliation fails (Article L1411-1 of the French Labour Code).
What if my dismissal letter is vague about the poor performance?
Within fifteen days of notification of the dismissal, the employee may request clarification by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt or by hand delivery against a receipt. The employer has fifteen days from receipt of this request to clarify the grounds, if it so wishes (Article R1232-13 of the French Labour Code). Keep a copy of the request and the proofs of receipt.
The letter, as clarified where applicable, sets the limits of the dispute as to the grounds (Article L1235-2 of the French Labour Code). Where no clarification was requested, insufficient reasons do not, on their own, deprive the dismissal of a genuine and serious cause. The lawyer therefore distinguishes a lack of precision in the letter from an absence of facts genuinely justifying the dismissal, then prepares the appropriate claims.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Articles of the French Labour Code (Code du travail) checked in the version in force on 13 October 2026. The decisions cited link to the text published by the Court of Cassation.
Case law: Cass. soc., 17 September 2025, No. 24-16.336 and Cass. soc., 6 May 2025, No. 23-23.294.
Further reading
Law as stated on 13 October 2026. This page covers dismissal for personal reasons on grounds of poor performance (insuffisance professionnelle) of a private-sector employee.
Facing a dismissal for poor performance?
Send the notice to attend, the letter or the disputed appraisals. The firm examines the facts and the documents to prepare the next steps.