You are sitting in a Paris notaire’s office — the civil-law public officer who alone can transfer French real estate by authentic deed — and someone has just offered you a sentence that sounds like an American joint tenancy with right of survivorship. Put a clause de tontine, also called a clause d’accroissement or tontine clause, in the purchase deed. If one of you dies, the survivor will be treated as if he or she had owned the whole apartment from the closing date. The children of a first marriage, the story goes, will have nothing to seize in that home. For an American couple buying in the 11th arrondissement, in Neuilly, or in a house in Yvelines, that promise is the entire point of the clause. It is also where French law and French tax part company with the slogan.
French default co-ownership is not joint tenancy. Two names on a French deed create indivision, ordinary co-ownership, and any co-owner can later demand a partition. A tontine is a contractual overlay, not a property default. It can keep the home out of the deceased buyer’s estate if the clause is genuine. French courts can still recharacterize it as a disguised gift. The tax office, under article 754 A of the tax code (Code général des impôts), generally treats the accruing share as a gratuitous transfer even when civil law says there was no succession. And on 9 April 2026 the Cour de cassation, France’s highest ordinary court, held that a tontine covering all the shares of a two-person société civile immobilière (SCI, a French real-estate holding company) is incompatible with the rule that a company must have at least two members and “entraîne ainsi la nullité de la société.”
This article is for Americans buying a French home together, married or not, including second-marriage households and couples who were told to “just put it in an SCI.” It explains how the clause actually works, when children can unwind it, what tax the survivor pays, and which French tools — a donation au dernier vivant (a gift between spouses that takes effect at death), a PACS, or a time-limited indivision agreement — belong in the same file. It is not a substitute for a review of your draft deed.
I. Can a tontine clause let my American spouse keep the whole French home?
A. How does a French tontine work compared with a US joint tenancy?
Start with what the deed actually does, because American buyers import the wrong picture. In most U.S. states, spouses who take title as joint tenants with right of survivorship hold an undivided whole, and the deceased spouse’s share vanishes at death without a probate transfer of that asset. France does not give you that default. If two Americans simply buy “fifty-fifty,” they are in indivision. Article 815 of the Civil Code is blunt: “Nul ne peut être contraint à demeurer dans l’indivision et le partage peut toujours être provoqué, à moins qu’il n’y ait été sursis par jugement ou convention.” No one can be forced to remain in co-ownership, and partition can always be demanded unless a judgment or a contract has postponed it. After a death, that means the deceased buyer’s heirs — including children of a first marriage — step into the indivision and can force a sale.
A tontine tries to prevent that result by rewriting who is deemed to have owned the property from day one. In a published advisory opinion of 15 June 2022, the First Civil Chamber of the Cour de cassation defined the device in a sentence every notaire uses. “La clause de tontine, ou clause d’accroissement, est celle par laquelle, lorsque plusieurs personnes acquièrent un bien, le survivant des acquéreurs est réputé avoir été seul propriétaire depuis l’acquisition.” In English: when several people buy a property together, the surviving buyer is deemed to have been the sole owner since the acquisition. You can read that opinion, issued under numbers 21-80.743 and 22-70.002 and published in the Court’s Bulletin, on the Cour de cassation’s site.
The same opinion describes what each buyer actually holds while both are alive. “Tant que la condition de survie demeure pendante, un acquéreur en tontine a, sous la réserve de stipulations contraires, la possibilité d’aliéner seul les droits qu’il tient du pacte tontinier et qui consistent, d’une part, en la jouissance indivise du bien, d’autre part, en la propriété du bien conditionnée au prédécès de ses coacquéreurs.” Until the survival condition is resolved, and unless the deed says otherwise, a tontine buyer may transfer the rights the pact gives him: undivided enjoyment of the property, plus ownership that is conditional on the co-buyers dying first. That is not the same thing as “we both own it the American way, and neither of us can sell.” Many Paris deeds add a lock — a clause forbidding sale, attachment, or partition until the survivor is known. The 2022 opinion makes clear that the lock is a stipulation, not the legal essence of tontine. If your draft deed is silent, one buyer may be able to assign his tontine rights.
Why does French law allow this overlay at all? Because the contract is aléatoire, aleatory: each buyer accepts that the economic result depends on an uncertain event, namely who dies first. Article 1108 of the Civil Code draws the line: “Le contrat est commutatif lorsque chacune des parties s’engage à procurer à l’autre un avantage qui est regardé comme l’équivalent de celui qu’elle reçoit. Il est aléatoire lorsque les parties acceptent de faire dépendre les effets du contrat, quant aux avantages et aux pertes qui en résulteront, d’un événement incertain.” A commutative contract is a bargained exchange of equivalents. An aleatory contract lets gain and loss turn on an uncertain event. If both buyers are about the same age and health, each pays a genuine share of the price, and neither is obviously about to die, the survival condition can supply that uncertainty. If one buyer is terminally ill, pays almost nothing, and dies weeks after the deed, the “bet” looks like a gift wearing a tontine costume. That is the civil-law hinge on which children later sue.
Two practical consequences follow for Americans before anyone dies. First, the property is not supposed to fall into the deceased buyer’s French estate. The survivor is deemed to have been the owner all along, so there is, in principle, no share for the notaire to allot to children under the intestacy rules or under a will. Second, that civil-law vanishing act does not mean “no tax” and does not mean “the children have no remedy.” The tax code, discussed in Part II, generally pretends there was a gratuitous transfer anyway. And if a court finds that there was never a real alea, the tontine is recharacterized as a libéralités — a gratuitous disposition — which article 893 of the Civil Code confines to gifts during life or wills: “La libéralité est l’acte par lequel une personne dispose à titre gratuit de tout ou partie de ses biens ou de ses droits au profit d’une autre personne. Il ne peut être fait de libéralité que par donation entre vifs ou par testament.”
Compare that with the other French ways of buying together, because the notaire will put them on the table in the same meeting. Ordinary indivision is cheap and flexible and, after a death, dangerous for the survivor, because article 815 lets heirs force a sale. A convention d’indivision, a co-ownership agreement, can postpone partition, but article 1873-3 of the Civil Code caps a fixed term at five years: “La convention peut être conclue pour une durée déterminée qui ne saurait être supérieure à cinq ans. Elle est renouvelable par une décision expresse des parties.” It is a pause button, not a survivorship title. An SCI, discussed below, changes the asset from a building into shares, which is a different succession and tax problem. None of those devices is a U.S. joint tenancy. If you need the survivor to keep the roof, you are choosing among imperfect French tools, not reproducing California or New York title.
The Chamber of Notaries of Greater Paris describes the marketing version of tontine in almost the same words as the 2022 opinion: the last surviving buyer is treated as having been the sole owner from the acquisition date, and the children of the predeceased buyers are left without a right in that asset. That is the client-facing promise. The rest of this article is the part the brochure compresses: the children can still sue if the alea was fake, the tax office still sends a bill, unmarried partners can face a 60 percent rate, and an SCI tontine on 100 percent of the shares can collapse the company.
B. When can children of a first marriage unwind the tontine, and does it work on SCI shares?
The lawsuit American blended families actually meet is not a metaphysical debate about joint tenancy. It is a French reduction or hotchpot claim by the deceased buyer’s children, often children of a first marriage, arguing that the tontine was a disguised gift of the home to the surviving spouse or partner. Article 843 of the Civil Code is the general hotchpot rule: “Tout héritier, même ayant accepté à concurrence de l’actif, venant à une succession, doit rapporter à ses cohéritiers tout ce qu’il a reçu du défunt, par donations entre vifs, directement ou indirectement.” Every heir coming to an estate must bring back into account what the deceased gave him during life, directly or indirectly, unless the gift was expressly made outside his share. If the tontine is recast as such a gift, the survivor does not automatically lose the keys, but the value comes back into the family math.
The Cour de cassation faced exactly that pattern on 12 January 2022. A husband bought an apartment with his wife by deed of 2 May 2013 containing a tontine pact. He died on 27 June 2013 — seven weeks later — leaving the wife and two children of a previous marriage. The Colmar Court of Appeal held that the tontine was a disguised gift to the wife. The First Civil Chamber, in a decision published in the Bulletin and the Court’s Rapport, did not retry the disguise question; that branch of the appeal was declared inadmissible. What it did decide, after quoting article 758-6 of the Civil Code, is how that gift is brought into account against a surviving spouse. The Court wrote: “La cour d’appel a retenu que le pacte tontinier compris dans l’acte d’achat de l’appartement constituait une donation déguisée de [E] [C] en faveur de son épouse.” Then: “Il s’ensuit que cette donation est soumise au rapport dans les limites et selon les modalités prévues à l’article 758-6 du code civil.” The disguised gift is subject to the special hotchpot that article 758-6 organizes for the surviving spouse. The full decision is here.
Article 758-6 itself says: “Les libéralités reçues du défunt par le conjoint survivant s’imputent sur les droits de celui-ci dans la succession. Lorsque les libéralités ainsi reçues sont inférieures aux droits définis aux articles 757 et 757-1, le conjoint survivant peut en réclamer le complément, sans jamais recevoir une portion des biens supérieure à la quotité définie à l’article 1094-1.” Gifts the surviving spouse received from the deceased are charged against that spouse’s inheritance rights. If they fall short of the statutory spouse’s share, the spouse can claim the difference, but can never take more than the disposable portion defined for gifts between spouses. In a second-marriage file, that is the children’s way in: they do not have to prove that tontine is illegal in the abstract. They have to prove that, on these facts, there was no genuine survival bet, so the pact was a gift, and then they use articles 843, 758-6, and the forced-heirship rules to pull value back.
Forced heirship is the second blade. Article 913 of the Civil Code still reads, in its first sentence, that gifts and wills “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” With one child, the deceased may dispose of only half; with two children, one-third; with three or more, one-quarter. The rest is the réserve héréditaire, the children’s reserved share. Since 1 November 2021 the same article adds a compensatory levy when foreign law governs and offers the children no reserved-share mechanism, and when the deceased or at least one child is an EU national or EU habitual resident: the children may take a levy on assets located in France. A tontine that French civil law treats as a true aleatory purchase is not, by itself, a gift that eats the réserve. A tontine that a court recasts as a gift is. The reduction action has a short clock. Article 921 of the Civil Code provides that the time limit “est fixé à cinq ans à compter de l’ouverture de la succession, ou à deux ans à compter du jour où les héritiers ont eu connaissance de l’atteinte portée à leur réserve, sans jamais pouvoir excéder dix ans à compter du décès.” Five years from the opening of the estate, or two years from knowledge of the injury to the reserved share, never more than ten years from death. American children who discover the Paris deed years later can still be inside that window.
What facts typically destroy the alea? The 12 January 2022 file is a teaching example because the dates are in the judgment: the tontine deed and the death were seven weeks apart. Courts also look at who paid the price, whether the shares in the deed match the money, whether one buyer was elderly or ill, and whether the parties were already in a relationship in which one was supporting the other. Equal ages, equal contributions wired from each buyer’s account, and a deed that records those contributions are the minimum hygiene. A “we will sort the money out later” closing, or a parent who pays 90 percent so that a much younger partner is on the title, is how the clause becomes exhibit A in a disguised-gift trial. None of that is a mysterious French trick. It is the aleatory contract of article 1108 failing on the facts.
Americans who were told to buy through an SCI now have a separate, newer problem. Families use an SCI so that the building sits in a company and the individuals own shares, often because they want governance rules, a later gift of shares, or a cleaner story for several children. Notaires sometimes insert a tontine in the bylaws so that the surviving co-shareholder is deemed to have been the sole shareholder from incorporation. On 9 April 2026, the Third Civil Chamber, in a decision published in the Bulletin, rejected an appeal that asked only to treat such a clause as unwritten, and in doing so stated the structural rule. “La clause de tontine ou d’accroissement stipulée dans les statuts d’une société civile est celle qui attribue au dernier survivant, de manière rétroactive, la propriété des parts incluses dans le pacte tontinier.” When the clause covers all the shares, “elle emporte leur réunion en une seule main au décès de l’avant-dernier tontinier.” That reunion is not the ordinary one-shareholder situation that article 1844-5 of the Civil Code allows to continue for a year. It is retroactive to the company’s birth. The Court then held: “lorsqu’elle porte sur l’ensemble des parts d’une société civile, la clause statutaire d’accroissement ou de tontine est contraire à la disposition imposant que la société soit instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes.” And: “Une telle clause entraîne ainsi la nullité de la société.” The judgment is here.
The statutory hook is article 1832 of the Civil Code: “La société est instituée par deux ou plusieurs personnes qui conviennent par un contrat d’affecter à une entreprise commune des biens ou leur industrie en vue de partager le bénéfice ou de profiter de l’économie qui pourra en résulter.” A company is formed by two or more persons, except where the law provides otherwise. A tontine that pretends there was only ever one shareholder from day one collides with that rule if it covers the entire capital of a two-person SCI. The 2026 Court did not merely strike a sentence from the bylaws. It said the proper sanction is nullity of the company. For an American couple whose Paris apartment sits in a two-member SCI with a last-survivor clause on 100 percent of the shares, that is not a drafting quibble. Nullity of the SCI can unwind the vehicle that holds the title, with creditor, tax, and land-registry consequences that a survivorship slogan never mentioned. If you already bought that way, the file needs a corporate and real-estate review, not a hopeful rereading of the bylaws. If you have not yet signed, do not put a tontine on all the shares of a two-person SCI. The SCI route is a different tool, described in the firm’s guide on buying a French home through an SCI; it is not a tontine shortcut.
One more civil-law limit matters when the couple is not married. A tontine does not require marriage. Unmarried partners and PACS partners can use it, which is why notaires offer it to couples who cannot make a donation au dernier vivant. A PACS under article 515-1 is only “un contrat conclu par deux personnes physiques majeures, de sexe différent ou de même sexe, pour organiser leur vie commune.” It is not a marriage and it does not, by itself, make the partner an heir. Article 515-6 gives the surviving PACS partner, if the PACS ends by death, the temporary housing protection of the first two paragraphs of article 763 — a year in the home — not ownership of the home. So a tontine can look, to an unmarried American couple, like the only way to keep the apartment. The tax section below is why that “only way” can be the most expensive way.
II. What French tax does the surviving American pay, and what should we sign instead?
A. How does article 754 A tax the tontine, and when does the 76,000 euro exception apply?
Civil law and tax law do not tell the same story about tontine, and American clients lose money when they hear only the civil-law sentence. Civilly, if the clause holds, the survivor was always the owner, so the home is not inherited. Fiscally, France wrote a special rule to stop people from using that sentence to skip inheritance tax. Article 754 A of the General Tax Code provides: “Les biens recueillis en vertu d’une clause insérée dans un contrat d’acquisition en commun selon laquelle la part du ou des premiers décédés reviendra aux survivants de telle sorte que le dernier vivant sera considéré comme seul propriétaire de la totalité des biens sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis à titre gratuit à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement.” Property collected under a tontine inserted in a joint acquisition contract is, from a tax point of view, deemed transferred for no consideration to each beneficiary of the accrual. That is a gratuitous-transfer fiction. It is not a compliment and it is not optional.
The tax administration’s official commentary says the same thing in plainer language. In BOI-ENR-DMTG-10-10-10-10, paragraph 270, the tax authorities write that under the first paragraph of article 754 A the goods “sont, au point de vue fiscal, réputés transmis, à titre gratuit, à chacun des bénéficiaires de l’accroissement,” and that the tax is liquidated at the rates in force on the day of death according to the relationship between the deceased and the beneficiary. If the beneficiary is also an heir for other reasons, the tontine value is added to his share. If not, “il doit souscrire une déclaration de succession dans les conditions de droit commun” — he must file an ordinary inheritance-tax return. The parallel commentary on onerous transfers, BOI-ENR-DMTOI-10-10-30-10, paragraph 180, explains why the fiction exists: a constant Cour de cassation analysis would otherwise have taxed the accruing share as a sale, and article 754 A was written “pour limiter l’évasion fiscale.” You can read those pages on bofip.impots.gouv.fr and the companion ruling.
The Commercial Chamber of the Cour de cassation drew the civil-tax split as early as 8 November 2005, in a decision published in the Bulletin. Two co-purchasers had bought with an accrual clause and a joint loan. After the first death, the survivor tried to deduct the deceased’s half of the loan as an estate debt. The Court refused. The share had been collected “en application de la clause d’accroissement stipulée dans l’acte d’acquisition en commun du 3 mai 1990 et non par voie de succession.” Because the survivor did not take the property by way of succession, he could not use the estate-debt deduction. The decision is here. For an American survivor, that holding is operational. You may owe French gratuitous-transfer tax on the accruing half even though the notaire tells you the apartment “never entered the estate,” and you should not assume the deceased’s mortgage slice is a French estate debt you can subtract from that tax.
Who is exempt, and who pays 60 percent? If the tontine is taxed as a transfer on death, article 796-0 bis of the General Tax Code is the spouse-and-PACS shield: “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” The surviving spouse and the surviving PACS partner are exempt from inheritance tax on death. A married American couple, or a couple who concluded a French PACS, can therefore often keep the fiscal cost of a genuine tontine to filing and notary work rather than a tax check — provided the administration treats the 754 A fiction as death duties, which is how the official commentary liquidates the tax. Unmarried partners who never PACS’d are in a different table. Article 777 fixes the rates. Tableau III ends: “Entre parents au-delà du 4e degré et entre personnes non-parentes 60.” Between relatives beyond the fourth degree and between unrelated persons, the rate is 60 percent. Two Americans who buy as boyfriend and girlfriend, put a tontine in the deed, and skip both marriage and PACS, are asking the survivor to pay 60 percent French tax on the accruing share of a Paris apartment. On a 800,000 euro home acquired half and half, that is 60 percent of 400,000 euros before any argument about valuation and debts. The civil-law slogan “the children get nothing” does not mention that invoice.
There is a narrow statutory exception, and American buyers in Paris almost never fit it. The second sentence of article 754 A says the gratuitous-transfer rule “ne s’applique pas à l’habitation principale commune à deux acquéreurs lorsque celle-ci a une valeur globale inférieure à 76 000 €, sauf si le bénéficiaire opte pour l’application des droits de mutation par décès.” It does not apply to the shared principal residence of two purchasers when the whole property is worth less than 76,000 euros, unless the beneficiary elects death-transfer duties. The tax commentary, BOI-ENR-DMTG-10-10-10-10, paragraph 290, repeats the threshold and the consequence: “Dans cette hypothèse, le transfert de propriété est en effet soumis aux droits de mutation à titre onéreux.” In that hypothesis the transfer is subject to the duties on sales, not inheritance tax. Paragraph 210 of the companion ruling lists four cumulative conditions: two purchasers, an immovable, their shared principal home on the date of the first death, and a global value below the statutory amount. A pied-à-terre you visit three weeks a year is not a shared principal residence. A Marais apartment at 2026 prices is not worth less than 76,000 euros. Married retirees who actually live in a modest house in a declining rural market might meet the test; the typical American purchase in Paris or the inner Île-de-France belt will not. If you somehow do meet it, the survivor can still elect death duties — which, for a spouse or PACS partner, can be the better election because of article 796-0 bis.
Valuation and filing still matter even when the rate is zero. The commentary says the rights are liquidated on the value at death and according to the relationship, and that a beneficiary who is not otherwise an heir must file a succession declaration. Americans living in the United States will need a French tax number, a notaire or lawyer who can file, and an apostilled death certificate. Do not wait for U.S. probate to finish before asking what French return is due. The civil-law idea that “there is no succession in the apartment” is not a license to ignore the tax calendar. If the tontine is later recast as a disguised gift, the tax analysis can shift again, because a gift during life and a death transfer are not the same schedule or the same exemptions. That is one reason the 12 January 2022 file, with its seven-week gap between deed and death, is so expensive for the surviving spouse: the children pull the value into the estate math, and the tax office is not bound by the family’s preferred label.
U.S. reporting sits on top. A French apartment is a foreign asset. The tontine does not erase Form 8938 or FBAR questions for accounts used to buy and maintain the property, and it does not erase the need to ask whether a U.S. estate-tax return is due on the deceased American’s worldwide estate. The choice of succession law and the surviving spouse’s housing rights are separate files. Tontine answers a title question. It does not file your IRS forms.
B. Tontine vs donation au dernier vivant, PACS, and indivision: what to do before a Paris closing?
If the notaire’s sentence was “this is how French couples protect the survivor,” you are being offered one tool as if it were the only tool. For a married American couple, the Civil Code already contains a gift between spouses that is designed for this problem. Article 1094-1 provides that, when the deceased leaves children, he may give the other spouse “soit de la propriété de ce dont il pourrait disposer en faveur d’un étranger, soit d’un quart de ses biens en propriété et des trois autres quarts en usufruit, soit encore de la totalité de ses biens en usufruit seulement.” In other words, the surviving spouse can be given the disposable portion in full ownership, or a quarter in ownership plus three-quarters in usufruct (the right to use the property and collect its fruits), or the entire estate in usufruct only. That is the donation au dernier vivant, the gift to the last living spouse. It does not pretend the children were never heirs. It works inside the réserve of article 913. It is revocable in the ways French law allows, and it does not try to erase the home from the estate by a retroactive ownership story. The firm’s dedicated guide on the donation au dernier vivant for American couples is the document to read next if you are married and the real goal is to house the survivor without picking a fight you cannot win with the children.
The spouse’s legal share without any gift is already more than many Americans expect. Article 757 says that if the deceased leaves children, the surviving spouse takes, at his or her option, “l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux et la propriété du quart en présence d’un ou plusieurs enfants qui ne sont pas issus des deux époux.” Usufruct of everything, or ownership of one-quarter — but if there is a child who is not a child of both spouses, the surviving spouse is limited to ownership of one-quarter, without the usufruct option. That is why second-marriage households buy tontine: article 757 does not give the new spouse the house. Tontine tries to take the house out of that calculation. The 12 January 2022 decision is the reminder that when the alea is missing, the house comes back into the calculation through the special spouse hotchpot of article 758-6, and the children of the first marriage are the people in the courtroom.
Unmarried couples have a different menu. They cannot use article 1094-1, which is a spouse’s article. They can conclude a PACS, which opens the inheritance-tax exemption of article 796-0 bis if they later die, and which gives the survivor the temporary housing right of article 515-6, but which still does not make the partner an heir. They can write wills, within the réserve if French succession law applies. They can buy in indivision and sign a five-year agreement under article 1873-3, knowing that any heir can later demand partition when the term ends. Or they can use a tontine and budget the 60 percent rate on the accruing share unless they marry or PACS before the first death. There is no painless unmarried version of “the survivor keeps the Paris apartment tax-free.” Anyone who tells you otherwise is skipping article 777.
Divorce and breakup are the other forgotten scenes. A tontine with a lock on sale can freeze the apartment while two people who no longer live together still need a partition. Article 815 is the French instinct: nobody has to stay in indivision. A well-drafted tontine often disables that instinct on purpose. Before you accept a clause that forbids sale until one of you dies, ask what happens if you separate next year. Married couples also need to know that one spouse cannot always sell a family home alone; the firm’s article on article 215 and spousal consent is the companion to this one on that point. The purchase contract that comes before the authentic deed — the compromis de vente or the promesse unilatérale — is where the tontine language should already appear as a condition of the deal, not as a surprise at the notaire’s table. The choice between compromis and promesse is a separate decision; do not sign either until the survivorship clause, the funding plan, and the tax path are in writing.
In Paris and Île-de-France the practical file is local even when the buyers live in New York. The authentic deed will be received by a notaire who can operate in France; the land-registry formalities run through the service de la publicité foncière for the situation of the property, which for a Paris apartment is the Paris land-registry office that covers that arrondissement. If a dispute later arises — children attacking the tontine, a blocked sale, an SCI whose bylaws copied the 2026 trap — the tribunal judiciaire of Paris or of the suburban département where the property sits is the civil court. The Chamber of Notaries of Greater Paris is the professional body American buyers actually meet in the first appointment, and it is also the body that publishes the three-way choice of tontine, indivision, or SCI. Bring to that appointment, in English and in French if you can, proof of each buyer’s funds, your marriage certificate or PACS, the ages and parentage of every child, and a one-page statement of who will live in the home. If the home is not going to be your principal residence, say so. The 76,000 euro exception dies on that fact, and so does a lot of casual tax talk.
A working checklist, without pretending it replaces advice on your deed, runs as follows. If you are married and the children of a first marriage are the real risk, price a donation au dernier vivant and a will that respects article 913 before you accept a tontine that a court can recast as a gift. If you are unmarried and you refuse to marry or PACS, model the 60 percent line of article 777 on the accruing half before you fall in love with the survivorship sentence. If someone proposes an SCI, read the 9 April 2026 decision before you put a last-survivor clause on all the shares. If you still want a tontine on the building itself, fund it equally, record the payments, avoid a deed signed on the eve of a foreseeable death, and decide in the deed whether tontine rights can be assigned. If you are already the survivor, do not assume silence from the tax office equals a clean file; article 754 A may still want a declaration. Children who were left out have their own remedies, described in the guide for an American heir omitted from a French estate.
Conclusion
A French tontine is not a U.S. joint tenancy, and it is not a magic wand against children or against the tax office. It is an aleatory clause that, when it is genuine, deems the surviving buyer to have been the sole owner from the acquisition date, as the Cour de cassation stated on 15 June 2022. When it is not genuine — when one buyer dies weeks after a deed that the money and the medical facts cannot explain — French courts treat it as a disguised gift, and the First Civil Chamber held on 12 January 2022 that such a gift is pulled into the surviving spouse’s special hotchpot. When the same idea is pasted onto all the shares of a two-person SCI, the Third Civil Chamber held on 9 April 2026 that the clause is contrary to article 1832 and entails nullity of the company. Fiscally, article 754 A still deems the accruing share a gratuitous transfer, with a 76,000 euro principal-residence exception that almost no Paris purchase will meet, a death-duty exemption for spouses and PACS partners, and a 60 percent rate for unrelated survivors. Married Americans often have a cleaner tool in article 1094-1. Unmarried Americans have to look at PACS, wills, and the real tax arithmetic before they sign. The right time to have that argument is in the draft deed, not in a courtroom after a funeral.