Your father was American, he owned a house in France, and he never signed a will. The first question an American family asks in that situation is usually whether an American probate court will sort it out. The answer, for the French house, is no. When there is no will, French intestacy law, called the dévolution légale (the statutory devolution of the estate), fixes exactly who inherits and in which shares, and a French notaire (the public officer who alone can settle French successions, authenticate the title transfer, and collect the death taxes) runs the file. The children come first and split everything equally, the surviving spouse takes either the ownership of one quarter or the lifetime use of the whole depending on the family picture, and more distant relatives only inherit if nobody closer survives. A six- or twelve-month tax clock starts running on the day of death, the house sits in joint ownership until everyone agrees on a sale or a buyout, and both France and the United States may tax the same transfer, with a bilateral treaty organizing the credit so the family does not pay twice. This guide walks through each step in plain English, with the exact code articles, the two court decisions that matter most, and the Franco-American death-tax treaty, so an American heir knows what to sign, what to file, and what to ask the notaire at the first meeting.
I. My Father Died Without a Will: Which Law Decides Who Gets the French House
A. Habitual Residence Controls, the Choice He Never Made, and the French Court That Keeps the File
Dying without a will means dying ab intestat (intestate), and an intestate estate is distributed strictly according to the statute, not according to what the family remembers the deceased wanted. For an American who owned property in France, the threshold question is which country’s statute applies. Since August 17, 2015, that question is answered for deaths in France by a European text that applies even when the deceased was American: Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on jurisdiction and applicable law in succession matters. Its general rule, in Article 21, is short: unless the Regulation says otherwise, the statute of the country where the deceased had their habitual residence at death governs the estate as a whole. In practice, habitual residence means real life, not paperwork: where your father actually lived day to day, kept his home, paid his bills, and organized his family and social life. An American who retired to the Dordogne and lived there year-round dies under French succession law for the whole estate, including any American accounts, while an American who lived in Florida and merely vacationed in a Provençal farmhouse dies under Florida law for the whole estate, including the French house. The same Regulation allowed your father, while alive, to choose American law instead, since Article 22 lets a living person elect the law of their nationality to govern the whole succession instead. But that choice had to be locked into a written disposition while alive, because the Regulation requires the election to appear expressly in a will-like declaration or to result clearly from its terms. A will he never wrote cannot carry a choice he never made, so the default habitual-residence rule governs. The full official text of the Regulation is published by the European Union (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, Articles 21 and 22), and the notaire will open the file by establishing residence first, which is why the family should bring proof of where the deceased really lived: leases or title deeds, utility bills, tax notices, health-insurance records, and travel history.
Two practical consequences follow. First, when the applicable law turns out to be that of a US state, the French notaire still handles the French house but must apply Floridian, Californian, or New York intestacy law to it, and the family will usually be asked to supply an American legal opinion, called a certificat de coutume (a certificate of foreign law signed by a qualified lawyer), explaining who inherits under that state’s statute. American families who want French law to govern should know that the vehicle for that choice was a will containing an express professio juris clause, as explained in our guide to electing US law for a French house by will; without that document, the choice simply does not exist. Second, whatever law applies, the French house itself stays anchored to the French courts and the French land registry. For successions opened before August 17, 2015, the old French conflict rules still govern, and the Court of Cassation confirmed the anchor in a decision of April 14, 2021 (First Civil Chamber, appeal no. V 19-24.773, Cass. civ. 1re, 14 April 2021), holding that “Selon ces principes, les tribunaux français sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession mobilière lorsque le défunt avait son domicile en France. Ils sont compétents pour statuer sur une succession immobilière pour les immeubles situés en France.” In that case the deceased had lived in Sweden, the disputed gift was a French building donated back in 1961, and the French courts still took the case and applied French reduction rules to claw the excess gift back into the children’s shares. The lesson for an American family is symmetrical: a Florida executor’s letters testamentary do not move a French house, and the settlement happens before the French notaire, as our Florida executor guide explains step by step.
One more boundary matters before counting shares. French law protects children against disinheritance through the réserve héréditaire (the forced share that must go to the children), and since 2021 an American child cut out by a foreign applicable law can levy a compensatory claim directly on the French assets. Article 913 of the Civil Code sets the ceiling on lifetime gifts and testamentary dispositions: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” The same article then adds the cross-border safety net: “chaque enfant ou ses héritiers ou ses ayants cause peuvent effectuer un prélèvement compensatoire sur les biens existants situés en France au jour du décès, de façon à être rétablis dans les droits réservataires que leur octroie la loi française, dans la limite de ceux-ci.” In a no-will case this mechanism rarely changes the outcome, because intestacy already gives the children at least their forced share, but it becomes decisive when the deceased made large lifetime gifts, for example a house signed over to a new spouse, that shrink the estate below the children’s guaranteed portion. Families who suspect such gifts should read our guide to claiming the réserve and the prélèvement compensatoire alongside this article, and should tell the notaire about every donation immediately, since gifts can be brought back into the accounting through the action en réduction that the 2021 decision above illustrates.
B. Children First, the Spouse’s Quarter or Usufruct, and the Shares When There Are No Children
French intestacy works by orders, and each order wipes out the next. Article 734 of the Civil Code lists four orders: first the children and their descendants, second the parents together with siblings, third the other ascendants, and fourth the other collateral relatives, adding that “Chacune de ces quatre catégories constitue un ordre d’héritiers qui exclut les suivants.” If your father left children, they take everything, subject only to the surviving spouse’s rights described below, and no parent, sibling, or cousin inherits a euro. Within the children’s order, equality is absolute: Article 735 provides that “Les enfants ou leurs descendants succèdent à leurs père et mère ou autres ascendants, sans distinction de sexe, ni de primogéniture, même s’ils sont issus d’unions différentes.” A child from a first marriage, a child born outside marriage, and an adopted child with full adoption effects all stand on the same footing, and if one child predeceased the father, that child’s own children step into the predeceased parent’s shoes through representation and split that branch’s portion. Concretely, two American siblings inheriting a French house each own one half of it in indivision (joint undivided ownership), three siblings each own one third, and the notaire will ask for every birth certificate and family record book, the livret de famille, to map each branch before drafting anything.
The surviving spouse, meaning the person still married to the deceased on the day of death, divorced or not yet but not a mere partner, takes a share carved out of the children’s portion, and the size of that share turns entirely on whether all the children are common to both spouses. Article 757 of the Civil Code states the rule in full: “Si l’époux prédécédé laisse des enfants ou descendants, le conjoint survivant recueille, à son choix, l’usufruit de la totalité des biens existants ou la propriété du quart des biens lorsque tous les enfants sont issus des deux époux et la propriété du quart en présence d’un ou plusieurs enfants qui ne sont pas issus des deux époux.” The usufruit (usufruct) is the lifetime right to use the property and take its income, while the nue-propriété (bare ownership) belongs to the children, who become full owners when the usufruct ends. So a widowed stepmother of children from her husband’s first marriage receives one quarter in full ownership and nothing more by operation of law, with no option to claim the whole-life usufruct instead. The Court of Cassation said exactly that on March 5, 2025 (First Civil Chamber, appeal no. Z 23-11.430, Cass. civ. 1re, 5 March 2025), in a case that could hardly be more on point for American readers, since the two heiresses claiming through their late mother were domiciled in California and Belgium: “en présence d’un enfant non commun, les droits légaux du conjoint survivant ne pouvaient être que de la propriété du quart des biens existants, sans faculté d’option pour l’usufruit de la totalité de ces biens” The appeals court had treated the widow as if she had drifted into a total usufruct for lack of a formal choice, and the high court quashed that reasoning completely, sending the case back to Montpellier and ordering the losing party to pay costs. For a blended American-French family, the message is blunt: count the branches first, because the spouse’s legal portion is fixed by the children’s origin, not by what feels fair, and any usufruct beyond the legal share must come from a gift or a will, which by hypothesis does not exist here.
When the deceased leaves no children and no descendants, the spouse’s portion grows and the parents and siblings re-enter the picture. If both parents survive alongside the spouse, Article 757-1 divides the estate three ways: “Si, à défaut d’enfants ou de descendants, le défunt laisse ses père et mère, le conjoint survivant recueille la moitié des biens. L’autre moitié est dévolue pour un quart au père et pour un quart à la mère.” If only one parent survives, that parent’s quarter passes to the surviving spouse, who then holds three quarters. If the parents are gone but siblings or their descendants survive, the split between the surviving parent generation and the siblings follows Article 738: “Lorsque les père et mère survivent au défunt et que celui-ci n’a pas de postérité, mais des frères et soeurs ou des descendants de ces derniers, la succession est dévolue, pour un quart, à chacun des père et mère et, pour la moitié restante, aux frères et soeurs ou à leurs descendants.” And when neither descendants nor parents survive, the spouse takes everything: Article 757-2 provides that “En l’absence d’enfants ou de descendants du défunt et de ses père et mère, le conjoint survivant recueille toute la succession.” Two refinements deserve attention in American families. First, property the deceased had himself received from a predeceased ascendant by gift or succession, and which still sits identifiably in the estate, partially returns to that side of the family under Article 757-3: “les biens que le défunt avait reçus de ses ascendants par succession ou donation et qui se retrouvent en nature dans la succession sont, en l’absence de descendants, dévolus pour moitié aux frères et soeurs du défunt ou à leurs descendants” A farmhouse your father inherited from his own French mother and still owns at death can therefore partly swing back toward his siblings even though his widow takes the rest. Second, needy ascendants other than the parents hold a maintenance claim against the estate under Article 758, which grants them a support annuity, a créance d’aliments, when the spouse takes all or three quarters; tell the notaire if a dependent elderly grandparent exists, because that pension is carved out before anyone splits the remainder.
II. Paperwork, Deadlines, and Taxes: Unlocking the House and Paying Both Countries
A. How American Heirs Prove Their Rights: the Notoriété Deed, the Bank, and the Spouse’s Roof
France has no probate court that appoints an executor and issues letters of administration. The heirs designated by statute step into the deceased’s shoes automatically: Article 724 of the Civil Code provides that “Les héritiers désignés par la loi sont saisis de plein droit des biens, droits et actions du défunt.” The practical problem is proving that status to a bank, a buyer, and the tax office, and the instrument for that proof is the acte de notoriété (the heirship deed drawn up by the notaire). Article 730-1 explains that “La preuve de la qualité d’héritier peut résulter d’un acte de notoriété dressé par un notaire, à la demande d’un ou plusieurs ayants droit.” The notaire assembles the death certificate, the family records, any marriage contract, and the negative will search from the national file of last wishes, hears the heirs’ sworn statement of their entitlement, and the deed is then noted in the margin of the death record. American heirs should arrive with apostilled birth and marriage certificates, the death certificate, the parents’ marriage contract if any, and a list of every bank account, policy, and property, because the notaire cannot guess at assets held across two continents. Signing that deed does not by itself mean accepting the debts, since Article 730-2 warns that “L’affirmation contenue dans l’acte de notoriété n’emporte pas, par elle-même, acceptation de la succession.” The separate decision whether to accept outright, renounce, or accept only up to the net assets belongs to each heir individually under Article 768: “L’héritier peut accepter la succession purement et simplement ou y renoncer. Il peut également accepter la succession à concurrence de l’actif net lorsqu’il a une vocation universelle ou à titre universel.” An American heir who suspects the French house carries a heavy mortgage or hidden tax arrears should weigh the limited-acceptance option before touching a euro, using the framework in our guide to the heir’s three options, and should never sign bank paperwork that looks like an unconditional acceptance without advice.
With the heirship deed in hand, the bank releases the funds, the notaire publishes the title change at the land registry, and the house enters indivision among the co-heirs until the final split, called the partage. During that waiting period, nobody can sell the house alone: Article 815-3 of the Civil Code provides that “le consentement de tous les indivisaires est requis pour effectuer tout acte qui ne ressortit pas à l’exploitation normale des biens indivis et pour effectuer tout acte de disposition autre que ceux visés au 3°.” Day-to-day management can be decided by co-owners holding two thirds of the shares, but a sale, a mortgage, or a gift of the house requires unanimity, which is why one sibling in California can block a sale just as effectively as one in Paris, and why families in deadlock need a court-authorized exit route rather than a unilateral signature. The surviving spouse who lived in the house is protected during this period by two layers of housing rights that operate even against the children’s impatience. First, the one-year free roof: Article 763 grants that “il a de plein droit, pendant une année, la jouissance gratuite de ce logement, ainsi que du mobilier, compris dans la succession, qui le garnit.” These rights flow directly from the marriage itself, since the article adds that “Les droits prévus au présent article sont réputés effets directs du mariage et non droits successoraux” and no will can remove them, because “Le présent article est d’ordre public.” Second, the lifetime right: Article 764 provides that the qualifying spouse “a sur ce logement, jusqu’à son décès, un droit d’habitation et un droit d’usage sur le mobilier, compris dans la succession, le garnissant.” Only a deprivation expressed by authentic will in strict form can lift that lifetime right, and even then the spouse’s usufruct share survives under its own rules. Our American widow’s guide works through the valuations, the conversions into annuities, and the tax treatment of both rights in detail, which matters enormously when the children want to sell and the stepmother intends to stay.
The tax declaration clock runs in parallel and waits for no family negotiation. Article 641 of the General Tax Code sets the filing deadline for the déclaration de succession (the estate tax return listing every asset and claiming every allowance): “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” A father who died in France gives the family six months; a father who died in Florida, New York, or California gives twelve. The notaire usually prepares and files the return and pays the duties from estate funds, but late filing draws interest and penalties, so American heirs should mandate the notaire in writing during the very first meeting and keep wiring instructions ready, because French wire thresholds and American bank anti-fraud holds have derailed more than one deadline-week payment. If the family cannot agree on values or shares, the return can be filed with reservations and corrected later, but it must be filed. Heirs who discover the death late, which happens often when the generations live on different continents, should tell the notaire immediately: the administration can grant payment facilities, and voluntary disclosure always costs less than a reassessment after a land-registry cross-check reveals an undeclared transfer.
B. The French Death Tax, the American Return, and the Treaty Credit That Prevents Double Tax
France taxes the French house no matter where the deceased lived. The territorial rule sits in Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code, which provides that when the deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France, the duties catch “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France, et notamment les fonds publics français, parts d’intérêts, biens ou droits composant un trust défini à l’ article 792-0 bis et produits qui y sont capitalisés, créances et valeurs mobilières françaises, lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article précité.” A Florida father’s Provençal farmhouse, a Paris apartment held through a property company, and even shares in a company whose value is mostly French real estate all fall inside the French net, while his American brokerage accounts and his Florida home stay outside it. When the deceased was fiscally domiciled in France, the net widens to worldwide assets, with the treaty credit below softening the American side. Each heir is then taxed on a net share after a personal allowance, called an abattement. Article 779 grants that “Pour la perception des droits de mutation à titre gratuit, il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation” so each American child subtracts 100,000 euros from the taxable share of the French house, while a brother or sister subtracts a smaller allowance, since the same article provides that “il est effectué en cas de donation ou, lorsque les dispositions de l’article 796-0 ter ne sont pas applicables, en cas de succession, un abattement de 15 932 € sur la part de chacun des frères ou sœurs vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation.” The surviving spouse pays nothing at all in France: Article 796-0 bis states that “Sont exonérés de droits de mutation par décès le conjoint survivant et le partenaire lié au défunt par un pacte civil de solidarité.” Above the allowance, the progressive table in Article 777 runs from 5 percent on the first 8,072 euros per share up to 45 percent beyond 1,805,677 euros in the direct line, charges siblings 35 percent below 24,430 euros and 45 percent above, and takes 55 to 60 percent from distant relatives and strangers.
A worked example makes the arithmetic concrete. Take a Florida father who dies owning only a French country house worth 600,000 euros, leaving two American children and no spouse. Each child inherits a 300,000-euro share, subtracts the 100,000-euro allowance, and pays tax on 200,000 euros: 5 percent on the slice up to 8,072 euros (about 404 euros), 10 percent on the slice from 8,072 to 12,109 euros (about 404 euros), 15 percent on the slice from 12,109 to 15,932 euros (about 573 euros), and 20 percent on the remaining 184,068 euros (about 36,814 euros), for roughly 38,194 euros per child. Add the notaire’s regulated fees, the land-registry publication tax, and a valuation report if the tax office disputes the price, and the family understands why agreeing on a realistic value early saves money twice, once in duties and once in penalties. One trap then often surfaces: gifts the father made during his lifetime are added back to the taxable base, because Article 784 provides that “La perception est effectuée en ajoutant à la valeur des biens compris dans la donation ou la déclaration de succession celle des biens qui ont fait l’objet de donations antérieures, à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans” A 200,000-euro gift made five years before death therefore pushes the heir into higher brackets, while a gift made sixteen years earlier drops out of the calculation entirely, so the notaire must be told about every prior donation, French or American, with dates and amounts.
The United States taxes the same death from the other side, and the 1978 Franco-American estate and gift tax treaty organizes who gets the first bite and who grants the credit. Its real-estate rule could not be clearer: Article 5 of the Convention of November 24, 1978, in the official consolidated version published by the French tax administration, makes real property taxable in the country where it sits, so the French house is taxable in France. France therefore taxes the French house first, and the treaty then forces each country to relieve the double hit. On the French side, the mechanism provides that France taxes the whole estate but subtracts the American tax paid on the same transfer, capped at the slice of French tax attributable to the doubly taxed property. On the American side, the mirror rule applies when the deceased was a US citizen domiciled in France: the United States grants a credit equal to the French tax collected on the property. In the standard Florida-father case, the practical sequence is therefore: pay the French duties on the house within the twelve-month deadline, file the US federal estate tax return (Form 706) if the worldwide estate exceeds the filing threshold, which sits in the multi-million-dollar range under current law and must be confirmed for the year of death, and claim the treaty-based credit for the French tax against any US tax on the same house. American heirs also inherit the paperwork duties that come with foreign assets: a bequest from a foreign person above 100,000 dollars in a year is reportable to the IRS on Form 3520 (see the IRS Form 3520 page), foreign bank accounts the heir now controls can trigger annual FBAR and Form 8938 reporting (see the IRS Form 8938 page), and the house itself generally takes a date-of-death fair-market-value basis for computing the later American capital gain on resale. None of these American filings changes who owns the French house, but missing them turns a clean French settlement into an American penalty file, so the family needs a US tax preparer working in parallel with the French notaire from the first month, not after the French return is filed.
Conclusion
An American father who dies without a will leaves his French house to arithmetic, not to argument. Habitual residence picks the governing law, and without a written choice of law the notaire applies the default the Regulation imposes. The children split everything equally with the spouse’s quarter or usufruct carved out according to the branches, parents and siblings only inherit when no child survives, and the surviving spouse keeps a free year plus a lifetime roof that no family vote can remove. The heirs prove themselves with a notoriété deed rather than a probate order, agree unanimously or go to court to sell, file the French return within six or twelve months, pay France first on the French house under the treaty’s real-estate rule, and claim the credit at home. Families who move in that order, certificates ready, notaire mandated early, American preparer looped in from month one, convert a transatlantic shock into a managed file. Families who wait, sign bank forms blindly, or assume a Florida paper controls a French roof, pay for the same house twice, once in duties and once in avoidable penalties.