Alex paid 70 percent and Jordan paid 30 percent of a 600,000 euro stone house in the Dordogne. Both names are on the French purchase deed, the 70/30 split is written in, and the notaire added a tontine clause so the survivor would keep the whole house. Alex has two children from a first marriage; Jordan has none. Then Alex dies first. Jordan assumes the house is now fully theirs. The children assume their father paid for 70 percent of a house and that value must return to his estate. The French tax office treats the half that moved to Jordan as a taxable transfer between legal strangers. All three assumptions collide on the same property, and the deed signed years earlier decides most of the fight before it starts.
This pattern is common among American buyers in France: two partners buy together without marriage or a PACS (pacte civil de solidarite, the French registered partnership), contribute unequal amounts, and add a survivorship clause. Each choice is defensible alone. Combined, they can leave the survivor owing 180,000 euros in French transfer tax on a 600,000 euro house, expose the survivor to a clawback claim from the deceased partner’s children, and leave the partner who paid the most with the weakest protection. This article explains what unequal shares mean in French co-ownership, why a tontine clause sits badly with unequal money, how children attack the survivor’s share, and what the surviving American partner must file and pay in both countries. Our companion guide covers the basic mechanism: how a tontine clause lets the surviving American partner keep the French home, and what it costs in tax. This piece answers the harder follow-up: what changes when the money was never equal.
I. We did not pay 50/50 for our French house: what unequal shares really change
A. Our deed states 70/30: what co-ownership without marriage means when one partner paid more
Under French law, an unmarried couple buying a house together owns it in indivision. Indivision means joint ownership in undivided shares: each partner owns a percentage of the whole house rather than specific rooms, and no partner can sell or mortgage the house alone. That part surprises few Americans. What surprises many is that French law gives unmarried partners, called concubins, no inheritance rights against each other at all. The Civil Code defines their situation in one sentence: concubinage is a de facto union, characterized by a shared life showing stability and continuity, between two people of different sex or the same sex who live as a couple. A stable shared life creates no forced share, no survivor’s pension right in the house, and no tax allowance between the partners. If the deed says 70/30 and one partner dies with no further planning, the deceased partner’s 70 percent passes to that partner’s own heirs, usually children or parents, and the survivor is left co-owning the house with people they never chose.
The percentages in the deed control almost everything during the couple’s lifetime. Day-to-day management decisions can be taken by the partner or partners holding at least two-thirds of the shares: the co-owner or co-owners holding at least two-thirds of the undivided rights may, at that majority, carry out acts of administration relating to the undivided property, give a general management mandate, sell undivided movables to pay the debts of the co-ownership, and sign or renew most leases, with a duty to inform the others. In a 70/30 split, the partner who paid 70 percent can therefore decide most routine matters alone, from hiring a roofer to renewing a rental lease, while the 30 percent partner must be informed but cannot block. Selling the house, giving it away, or borrowing against it is different: those acts of disposal require everyone’s agreement. Either partner can therefore veto a sale, which is exactly what happens when an unmarried couple separates and one of them refuses to sign. French courts apply this lock strictly, and the Court of Cassation confirmed again on January 15, 2025 that where co-ownership exists, each co-owner is, under article 815 of the Civil Code, entitled to demand partition, since no one may be forced to remain in co-ownership, and partition may always be demanded, unless it has been stayed by judgment or agreement.
Daily occupation has its own price tag. When one partner lives in the house full time while the other lives in the United States and visits twice a year, the occupying partner is not simply enjoying their own property for free. Each co-owner may use and enjoy the undivided property according to its purpose, so far as compatible with the rights of the other co-owners, and a co-owner who uses or enjoys the undivided property privately owes compensation unless agreed otherwise. That compensation is called an indemnite d’occupation, an occupancy payment. Couples should set its amount, or waive it expressly, in a written co-ownership agreement rather than discovering it during a breakup valuation. The same written agreement, called a convention d’indivision, can organize everything the deed leaves open: who pays the property tax and insurance, how renovation costs are split, whether shares follow the money each partner actually wired, a right of first refusal if one partner wants to sell their share, and a lock-in period. The Civil Code expressly allows such tailor-made agreements: persons who hold rights to exercise over undivided property, as owners, bare owners or usufruct holders, may enter into agreements concerning the exercise of those rights. But the lock-in has a hard ceiling: the agreement may be concluded for a fixed term that may not exceed five years, renewable by express decision of the parties. A clause purporting to freeze the shares for twenty years would not survive a challenge, and the five-year renewable format is the correct tool.
For American buyers, the practical lesson of this first section is documentary. The partner who paid more must be able to prove it years later, from America, after the other partner’s death or after a breakup. Keep every wire confirmation showing which dollars left which American account, the exchange slips into euros, the notaire’s statement of funds breaking down each partner’s contribution, the loan offers if each partner borrowed separately, and proof of who repaid which monthly installment and who paid for the new roof. French courts and notaires reconstruct the true funding of a purchase from bank records, not from memories. When the deed states 70/30 but only one partner can document the transfers, the undocumented partner’s position weakens at exactly the moment it matters most.
B. We added a tontine clause anyway: why equal survivorship sits badly with unequal money
A tontine clause, also called a clause d’accroissement or accretion clause, is a survivorship pact written into the purchase deed. The Court of Cassation gave its authoritative definition in a published opinion of June 15, 2022: the tontine clause, or accretion clause, is the clause by which, where several persons acquire a property, the surviving acquirer is deemed to have been the sole owner since the acquisition. The survivor does not inherit the deceased partner’s share. Retroactively, the deceased partner is treated as never having owned anything, and the survivor is treated as having owned everything from the day of purchase. A standard notarial clause phrases it as follows: it is agreed between the acquirers, as an aleatory clause, that the first of them to die shall be deemed never to have owned the property covered by this deed, ownership being deemed always to have rested solely on the survivor’s head, with the deed adding that until death, each acquirer shall therefore own the acquired property subject to the resolutory condition of their predecease and the suspensive condition of their survival, and upon the first death, the predeceased’s heirs may claim no right over the property and the survivor shall be deemed to have been the sole owner since the date of this deed.
That mechanism works cleanly when both partners paid half and are roughly the same age and health, because the gamble is symmetrical: each had the same chance of surviving and taking all. It works badly with 70/30 money, and the reason is the aleatory character of the pact. A tontine is treated as a gamble, an aleatory contract, rather than a gift, precisely because each side risks losing everything. When one partner funded 70 percent of the price, the survivor’s windfall looks less like the payoff of a fair bet and more like a transfer of wealth from the partner who paid most. French courts may then recharacterize the excess as an indirect gift, a liberalite, meaning a voluntary enrichment of one person at the expense of another. The legal definition of a gift is strict: an inter vivos gift is an act by which the donor presently and irrevocably divests themselves of the thing given, in favor of the donee who accepts it. A tontine is not supposed to meet that definition, because nothing is given at signing and everything depends on who dies first. But when the contributions are lopsided, when the partners are twenty years apart in age, or when one was seriously ill at signing, the gamble argument thins, and a judge hearing the deceased partner’s children may conclude that part of the arrangement was a disguised gift all along. No article sets a numerical threshold, so each case turns on its facts: funding records, age gap, health, and the notaire’s file.
Two further features of the tontine surprise American buyers. First, the clause must be written into the original purchase deed. A couple that bought 70/30 five years ago and now wants to add survivorship cannot simply sign a side letter; restructuring after the fact means a new transfer with its own tax bill, which is why this planning belongs before the first signature, not after the first health scare. Second, the tontine does not fully freeze the property while both partners are alive. The Court of Cassation confirmed that so long as the survival condition remains pending, a tontine acquirer may, absent contrary stipulation, separately dispose of the rights they hold under the tontine pact, consisting of both undivided enjoyment of the property and ownership of the property conditioned on the co-acquirers’ predecease. In plain terms, a partner could sell or encumber their conditional rights to a third party, and a creditor could seize them. Couples who want a genuine lock should combine the tontine with a five-year renewable co-ownership agreement and, where the ages and contributions are too unequal for a tontine to be credible, consider the alternatives: keeping honest unequal shares with a detailed convention d’indivision, forming a societe civile immobiliere, the French family property company governed by the chapter applicable to all civil companies, or arranging crossed life interests so each partner holds a protected right to live in the house without pretending the money was equal. Each route has its own tax price, and the right answer depends on the couple’s ages, children, and funding, not on a one-size clause.
II. My partner died first and the children are challenging everything: who keeps the house and what tax applies
A. Can the children treat the survivor’s extra share as a disguised gift and claw it back
When Alex dies first, Jordan produces the deed and claims the whole house by survivorship. Alex’s two children from the first marriage then do what French succession law invites them to do: they examine whether their father’s estate was emptied to their detriment. French law protects children through the reserve hereditaire, the forced share that must reach each child regardless of wills and gifts. Gifts that eat into that protected share can be cut back through an action en reduction, a clawback claim. The rule is general: direct or indirect gifts that infringe the reserve of one or more heirs are reducible to the disposable portion at the opening of the succession. Only the protected heirs themselves can bring that claim: the reduction of lifetime gifts may be demanded only by those for whose benefit the law creates the reserve, by their heirs or assigns, in the terms of article 921 of the Civil Code. Jordan cannot sue to reduce anything; Alex’s children can. And gifts do not vanish into the past: every heir coming to a succession must return to the co-heirs everything received from the deceased by inter vivos gift, directly or indirectly, which is the accounting mechanism, called rapport, that forces lifetime advantages back into the pot before shares are computed.
Applied to the 70/30 tontine, the children’s argument runs as follows. Their father paid 420,000 euros of a 600,000 euro house and ended up, through the tontine, owning nothing at death, while Jordan, who paid 180,000 euros, ended up owning 600,000 euros of real estate. The children argue that the 240,000 euro difference, and potentially the whole accretion, was in substance an indirect gift from their father to Jordan, reportable to the estate and reducible so far as it invades their forced shares. Jordan answers that nothing was given: the tontine was a fair gamble, both partners accepted the same risk, and the survivor simply won the bet. The court then weighs the gamble. Roughly equal ages, roughly equal health, roughly equal contributions, and a notaire’s file documenting independent advice all support the gamble reading. A large age gap, a known serious illness at signing, contributions of 70/30 or 80/20 with no compensating arrangement, and loan repayments made entirely by the deceased partner all push toward recharacterization. There is no burden of proof shortcut: the children must prove the disguised gift, and Jordan must produce the funding records, medical context, and deed history that show a genuine aleatory pact. This is why the documentary advice in Part I is litigation advice, not paperwork for its own sake.
A recent court saga shows how these fights actually unfold. In a case decided on appeal in Grenoble on February 18, 2025, a couple married under separation of property had bought a building plot in 2010 with an accretion clause providing that the first to die would be deemed never to have owned it. The husband died in 2015, leaving his wife and a son born of his first marriage. In 2020 the son sued the widow and the notaire for 100,000 euros, contesting the scope of the survivorship clause rather than its bare validity, and the court of appeal confirmed the first court’s judgment in full. The full decision traces the deed clause, the family configuration, and the money claim. American readers should draw three lessons from it. First, children from a first marriage do sue, years after the death, and courts hear them. Second, the fight turns on the precise wording and scope of the clause, so the notaire’s drafting, reviewed before signing, matters more than any later explanation. Third, even a surviving spouse with a marriage certificate faces this litigation; an unmarried surviving partner with no family status faces it with fewer shields. For unmarried couples, the honest alternatives deserve real attention: unequal shares that reflect the money, a renewable co-ownership agreement organizing buyout prices and first-refusal rights, and, where the goal is truly to protect the survivor’s roof rather than to transfer capital, a life interest for the survivor instead of full survivorship ownership.
B. What the surviving American partner files and pays in France and in America
Assume Jordan survives and the tontine operates. French tax law does not treat the accretion as a tax-free nonevent between partners. Because the survivor is deemed to receive the deceased partner’s half, transfer tax applies to that half, and between two unmarried partners with no family link the rate is the maximum one. The schedule for collateral relatives and non-relatives taxes the net share at 35 to 45 percent between siblings, 55 percent between relatives up to the fourth degree, and 60 percent between more distant relatives and non-relatives. Two unmarried partners fall in the last bracket: 60 percent. Worse, the allowance that softens French succession tax for families does not exist for them. Article 779 of the General Tax Code grants a 100,000 euro allowance on each ascendant’s and each child’s share, allowances for siblings, nephews and nieces, and an allowance for disabled heirs, and no allowance to an unrelated partner. On the 600,000 euro example, the taxable half is 300,000 euros and the French bill is 180,000 euros, with no deduction. Compare the married or PACS-partnered couple next door: the surviving spouse and the partner bound to the deceased by a PACS are fully exempt from death transfer duties. The difference between signing a PACS at the town hall and remaining simple concubins can therefore be worth 180,000 euros on this single house, before any notaire fees or capital-gains history. Couples who refuse marriage for personal reasons should at least price the PACS honestly against the tontine-plus-tax route.
France taxes the French house even when the deceased partner lived in America. Tangible and intangible property situated in France is subject to French transfer tax on death and gifts even where the donor or deceased was not fiscally domiciled in France. The American survivor therefore cannot escape the French return by pointing to a Chicago domicile. The notaire in charge of the French file prepares and files the succession return, and the clock runs fast: returns must be filed within six months of death where the deceased died in metropolitan France, and within one year in all other cases. An American partner dealing with a death in France from across the Atlantic gets the one-year period, but a year passes quickly between the death certificate with apostille, the French translations, the heirship evidence, the bank releases, and the valuation. Late filing draws penalties and interest on top of the 60 percent, so the survivor should instruct the notaire within weeks, not months. Where tax was also paid abroad on the same property, transfer tax paid outside France may be credited against the French tax due, limited to the tax paid on property situated outside France, which mostly helps with foreign-situated assets rather than the French house itself. The 1978 United States France estate and gift tax treaty overlays this domestic machinery with tie-breaker and credit rules, and its interaction with the tontine’s retroactive ownership fiction is genuinely technical: the survivor should assume the French return comes first and the American filings second, with the treaty credit claimed on the American side, rather than assuming one filing covers both countries.
On the American side, the surviving partner faces paperwork rather than a second 60 percent bill, but the paperwork matters. The United States taxes its citizens and residents on worldwide transfers, with a high federal exemption threshold that leaves most middle-class survivors owing no federal estate tax while still having to file information returns. The survivor should keep a complete basis file from day one: the purchase deed and closing statement, proof of each partner’s funding share, improvement invoices, loan records, the French transfer-tax assessment and proof of payment for the foreign tax credit, and the appraisal used at first death. If the survivor later sells the house, the American capital-gain computation will depend on those records, and reconstructing a French renovation from a decade earlier without invoices is a losing exercise. French bank accounts opened for the purchase, the mortgage account, and any French investment account left over from the transaction carry their own annual American reporting duties, with thresholds and forms set by current IRS and FinCEN instructions that the survivor must check for the year concerned rather than relying on remembered figures. Separately, American estate planning documents should be aligned with the French structure: a A standard American revocable living trust does not take title to French real estate by itself, a choice-of-law clause for the succession under the European Succession Regulation can shape which law governs the estate as a whole, as explained in our guide to choosing American law for a French estate and what forced heirship still takes, and each partner needs a French-law-compatible will covering everything the tontine does not, from bank accounts to personal property. The worst outcome is the couple from the introduction discovering, after the first death, that their American wills say 50/50 while their French deed says tontine-takes-all: the contradiction guarantees litigation, and the notaire cannot resolve it without a judge.
Conclusion
Unequal money plus a tontine clause is the most dangerous combination in unmarried American buying in France. The deed’s percentages decide daily control and veto rights, the tontine’s retroactive fiction decides who is deemed to have owned what, the children’s forced-share claims decide whether the survivor’s windfall survives as a gamble or falls as a disguised gift, and the 60 percent non-relative rate with no allowance decides whether keeping the house is even affordable. Couples buying today should work through the decision tree in order. If contributions are roughly equal, ages are close, health is unremarkable, and neither partner has children from another relationship, a tontine clause in the purchase deed is a coherent tool, documented with funding proof and independent advice. If the money is 70/30 or more skewed, if there is a significant age or health gap, or if either partner has children, the honest structure usually wins: deed shares that mirror the money actually wired, a renewable five-year co-ownership agreement with buyout pricing and first-refusal rights, a PACS weighed openly against its tax value, a life interest for the survivor where the goal is shelter rather than capital, French-compatible wills on both sides, and a basis file the survivor can hand to both a French notaire and an American return preparer. Whatever the structure, commission it before signing the first offer, keep every transfer slip, and assume the children will one day read the deed more carefully than the couple did.