Kohen Avocats — Criminal defence
Fake Google Reviews Lawyer in Paris: Removal and Defamation
A review targets your business or professional activity. As your fake Google reviews lawyer in Paris, the firm examines the statements, evidence and time limits to identify appropriate requests for identification, removal or compensation. The firm handles these matters in its digital law practice: fake reviews, disparaging statements, search engine delisting and personal data.
Keep the review and its publication date. The ordinary limitation period for press offences is three months (Article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881): have your deadlines checked without waiting for the platform to respond.
Fake Google reviews · Paris
Have the disputed reviews assessed
Send screenshots, links and any replies received to our criminal defence firm in Paris to prepare the legal assessment.
Reviews
Assessment of the statements
and evidence
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
How to remove fake Google reviews
Online reviews · Protecting your reputation
Your fake Google reviews lawyer in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Criminal press law
- Reviews and reputation
- Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France)
A review makes inaccurate allegations against you, attacks your services or appears to come from an account created to harm you. Kohen Avocats examines the words used, their context and the publication date before proposing a course of action. Defamation (diffamation) and insult (injure) are defined by Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881; a disparagement (dénigrement) claim rests on a different legal basis, Article 1240 of the French Civil Code (Code civil). This distinction determines how the case proceeds.
We prepare reports to the platform, assess the available documents and consider whether to request identification, removal or compensation. We also check the arguments that could defeat the claim: permissible criticism, insufficient evidence, limitation or procedural errors. Send the full text and web address of each review, or contact the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45 to arrange a case assessment.
Official profile in the French National Bar Council (CNB) directory of lawyersOffice at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Classify each review
Identify the disputed statements, their target and the appropriate legal basis.
Preserve the evidence
Gather the publications, dates, correspondence and evidence contradicting the accusations.
Choose the remedy
Assess identification, removal and compensation separately, without promising any outcome.
Content matters more than labels
Fake reviews, defamation, insult or disparagement?
An unfavourable review does not become unlawful simply because the professional dislikes it. What it alleges and whom it targets must be examined precisely.
Law of 1881
Defamation and insult
Defamation is the allegation or imputation of a fact that harms a person’s honour or reputation. The person may be identifiable without being named, and the allegation may be expressed as a doubt. Insult is an offensive expression, a term of contempt or an invective that imputes no fact (Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881). A specific accusation of fraud and a value judgement about customer service therefore require different analyses. For public offences, dissemination to the public must also be examined: Articles 32 and 33 refer to the means of publication in Article 23 of the Law of 29 July 1881.
Civil liability
Disparagement of products or services
A communication discrediting products or services may give rise to civil liability under Article 1240 of the French Civil Code. The content, factual basis and context of the statements must be examined. In a dispute between telecommunications operators, the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) upheld the finding of disparagement arising from informing a competitor’s customers of legal proceedings that had not yet resulted in a decision (Cass. com., 7 March 2018, No. 16-16.645). This case does not make every criticism of a service unlawful. The Court explained: “First, [the operator]’s liability for disparagement was established because it had informed a competitor’s customers of legal proceedings that had not resulted in a decision; accordingly, the outcome of the unfair competition action has no bearing on the outcome of the disparagement claim;” (our translation) (same judgment).
Commercial practice
Fabricating fake reviews
Article L121-4 of the French Consumer Code (Code de la consommation) covers, among other practices, a trader falsely presenting themselves as a consumer (21°), an unverified assertion that reviews come from actual users (27°), and posting or commissioning fake reviews, or altering consumer reviews, to promote products (28°). The conditions of the commercial practice concerned must be established. An anonymous comment or a review by someone absent from the customer database does not, on its own, establish this offence.
Disparagement cannot be used to bypass the rules on defamation. The Cour de cassation reiterates that “abuses of freedom of expression provided for and punishable under the Law of 29 July 1881 cannot be compensated under Article 1240 of the Civil Code” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 7 March 2018, No. 17-12.027). The involvement of a competitor does not change this boundary.
Statutory penalties for an individual
Penalties depend on the offence established
A criminal fine and damages serve different purposes. The maximum penalties below do not prejudge the court’s decision.
12 000 €
public defamation of a private individual
12 000 €
public insult of a private individual, without provocation
1 year
discriminatory public defamation or insult
5 years
misleading commercial practice committed online
Articles 29, 32 and 33
Public defamation and insult
Public defamation of a private individual is punishable by a €12,000 fine (Article 32 of the Law of 29 July 1881). Public insult of a private individual, where not preceded by provocation, carries the same fine (Article 33 of the Law of 29 July 1881). These provisions supplement the definitions in Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881. They do not provide for imprisonment for these ordinary forms alone.
Public forms targeting a person or group because of origin, membership or non-membership of a particular ethnic group, nation, race or religion, or because of sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or disability, are punishable by one year’s imprisonment and a €45,000 fine; Article 32 also allows either penalty alone. For discriminatory insult committed by a person vested with public authority or entrusted with a public service mission, in or in connection with the performance of their duties or mission, Article 33 increases the penalties to three years and €75,000.
Articles L. 121-4 and L. 132-2
Misleading commercial practices
Where the conditions of Article L121-4 of the French Consumer Code are established, Article L132-2 of the French Consumer Code provides for a general penalty of two years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine. Commission through an online public communication service or a digital or electronic medium increases the penalties to five years’ imprisonment and a €750,000 fine. This aggravating provision must therefore be examined for a fake review campaign conducted online.
The same provision allows a proportional fine of up to 10% of average annual turnover calculated over the last three known financial years, or 50% of expenditure on the advertising or practice. Practices resulting in contracts and offences committed by an organised group are also covered by specific provisions: three years in the first case (Article L132-2-1 of the French Consumer Code) and seven years in the second (Article L132-2-2 of the French Consumer Code). The first provision does not reduce the five-year aggravated penalty applicable to online commission. Additional penalties are provided for by Article L132-3 of the French Consumer Code.
Article 1240 of the French Civil Code
Disparagement is not, in itself, a criminal offence
A civil action seeks to stop wrongful conduct and compensate proven harm. It requires proof of fault, loss and a causal link between them (Article 1240 of the French Civil Code). A fall in turnover or a lower rating does not suffice to attribute the entire loss to one comment. Claims must be documented and distinguished from any criminal proceedings justified by other facts.
Calculate before waiting
Three months for press offences: check the dates
The date you discover a review is not the same as its first publication date.
Ordinary time limit
Defamation and insult
Article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881 sets a limitation period of three full months for criminal proceedings and civil actions under that law, running from the facts or the last investigative or prosecutorial act interrupting the period. For online publication, the Cour de cassation uses the date it was first made available to users (Cass. crim., 11 June 2024, No. 23-86.920). Keeping the same publication online must not be mistaken for a time limit that starts again each day.
Special rules
One year for certain offences
Article 65-3 of the Law of 29 July 1881 extends the period to one year for, among others, the discriminatory forms of defamation and insult it lists. This exception does not apply to every aggressive or insulting review. The legal classification must match the statements, and steps already taken must be checked. This page presents the law in force on 13 October 2026; older facts also require a check of the rules applicable at the time.
Separate civil action
Five years under the ordinary civil rules
For a claim that truly concerns disparagement, Article 2224 of the French Civil Code sets a five-year limitation period from the day the claimant knew or should have known the facts enabling them to act. This period cannot revive a time-barred defamation claim by giving it another label (Cass. 1re civ., 7 March 2018, No. 17-12.027). A review’s age must therefore be assessed alongside its legal classification.
The starting point “must be set at the date of the first act of publication, which is the date on which the message was first made available to users.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 11 June 2024, No. 23-86.920, reasons, § 10
For offences subject to the ordinary rules of Article 65, reporting a review to Google or sending private formal notice does not interrupt the limitation period. An ordinary criminal complaint does not guarantee interruption either: before proceedings are initiated, this provision refers to prosecutorial requests for an investigation that meet its requirements. Article 65-3 excludes these special rules on prosecutorial requests for the offences it lists. Have the necessary procedural step checked without waiting for the platform’s response.
Identify, seek removal, claim compensation
Choose a response suited to the statements
We distinguish between preserving evidence, reporting to the platform and applying to the court. The outcome of each step still has to be established.
Before proceedings
Prepare and report
A file for each review
- Keep the full text, URL and known dates.
- Explain to the platform which passages are disputed and why.
- Consider contacting the identified author, without waiting for a response before checking the limitation period.
Subject to the legal conditions
Apply to the court
Separate requests
- Pre-action identification measure: Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure (Code de procédure civile, CPC).
- Removal on an urgent application (référé) before the president of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire): Article 835 of the CPC.
- Penalty payment (astreinte) to secure compliance with the decision: Article L. 131-1 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures (Code des procédures civiles d’exécution, CPCE).
Anonymous author
Identification must be justified
Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows legally admissible measures to obtain evidence before any proceedings, where there is a legitimate reason. The application must explain the intended dispute, the useful data and the recipient likely to hold it. A procedure without notice to the other party requires the conditions of Article 493 of the French Code of Civil Procedure to be met. Disclosure of technical data alone does not guarantee identification of a named individual.
Removal and compensation
The platform’s decision does not replace the court’s
Before the president of the judicial court, Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows, in particular, measures to end a manifestly unlawful disturbance, even where there is a serious dispute. An interim payment, however, requires an obligation that cannot seriously be disputed. A claim for damages on the merits has its own conditions. Procedural documents initiating press proceedings must comply with Article 53 of the Law of 29 July 1881, particularly as to the precise facts, their legal classification and the applicable provision.
Criminal proceedings
A criminal complaint needs a precise legal basis
For ordinary public defamation and insult of a private individual, Article 48 of the Law of 29 July 1881 requires a complaint from the person targeted. Article 85 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale) exempts press offences from the prior requirement for the prosecutor to drop the case or for a three-month wait, normally required for a complaint with civil-party petition (plainte avec constitution de partie civile) to be admissible. This exception does not remove press-law formalities or the need to check limitation.
Defence
Anticipate the author’s response
In defamation proceedings, proof of truth is governed by Article 35 of the Law of 29 July 1881, with its limits and exceptions. The offer to prove truth is subject to a ten-day period following service of the summons and the formalities of Article 55 of the Law of 29 July 1881. Any good-faith defence must also be examined: in a case concerning a bakery review, this possibility led to the refusal of interim relief, without a final determination of good faith on the merits. The court explained: “In these circumstances, the good-faith defence may be accepted by the court ruling on the merits, and publication of these statements therefore does not constitute a manifestly unlawful disturbance justifying intervention by the judge hearing the urgent application.” (our translation) (CA Paris, 2 July 2026, No. 25/16002).
Organise the case file
The stages of work and documents to gather
Keep the available evidence without altering the originals. A formal evidence report (constat) may supplement screenshots; we assess its usefulness for each case.
Preserve
Copy the entire review, its web address, the public profile and visible dates before replying.
Classify
Distinguish a factual accusation, an insult, criticism of a service and a possible misleading commercial practice.
Check the time limits
Establish the first publication date and steps already taken before choosing a course of action.
Prepare the requests
Separate the evidence relevant to identification, removal and compensation.
Follow up
Keep any replies and new publications so the case can be reassessed.
- Full text and screenshot of each review, plus the URLs of the review and business profile.
- Pseudonym, public profile link, publication and modification dates if known.
- Reports already submitted, replies received, formal notices or court documents.
- Relevant invoices, appointments and correspondence, with a careful search for pseudonyms.
- Evidence contradicting the alleged facts and an explanation of the dispute’s context.
- Cancellations, customer messages and business data relevant to assessing the loss.
Professions bound by confidentiality: Article 226-13 of the French Criminal Code (Code pénal) protects confidential information, and Article L1110-4 of the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique) covers information about people receiving care within the health system. Avoid any reply disclosing such information. A general reply inviting private contact may be considered if it neither confirms nor reveals anything protected by professional confidentiality.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about fake Google reviews
How can I remove fake Google reviews?
Removal can be requested, but it is not guaranteed simply because the professional disputes the review. Keep the publication, identify the disputed passages and explain why they are unlawful. Before the president of the judicial court, Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows, in particular, measures needed to end a manifestly unlawful disturbance. Article L131-1 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures allows the judge to attach a penalty payment to the decision.
Reporting to the platform and applying to the court are different procedures. A negative opinion may remain permissible, while a specific accusation may fall under Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881. The firm examines the evidence, context and opposing arguments before proposing action. It distinguishes removal of a specific review from deletion of an entire business profile, which does not follow automatically from disputing one comment.
Defamation, disparagement or insult: why does the legal classification matter?
Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881 distinguishes defamation, which imputes a fact harming honour or reputation, from insult, which uses offensive language without imputing a fact. Disparagement concerns discrediting products or services and falls under Article 1240 of the French Civil Code. The words used, the target of the statements and the context must be examined together.
The legal classification cannot be chosen to obtain a longer time limit. Defamation cannot be pursued as disparagement to avoid the Law of 1881. In Toulon, a claim brought as disparagement was reclassified as defamation, and the writ of summons was then annulled for failure to comply with Article 53: “Accordingly, the writ of summons will be declared null.” (our translation) (TJ Toulon, référés, 24 June 2025, No. 24/00895). This decision does not establish that the review was lawful on the merits.
What is the time limit for taking action?
For defamation and insult under the ordinary rules of the Law of 1881, Article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881 provides for three full months. Article 65-3 of the Law of 29 July 1881 extends the period to one year for, among others, the discriminatory forms it lists. For online publication, the starting point is generally when the message was first made available, rather than when the person targeted eventually discovered it (Cass. crim., 11 June 2024, No. 23-86.920).
A claim that truly concerns disparagement is subject to the five-year period under Article 2224 of the French Civil Code, calculated from the date the claimant knew or should have known the facts enabling them to act. It does not replace a time-barred defamation claim. Keep all dates and documents received. A report or private letter does not suffice to interrupt the press-law limitation period: the appropriate procedural step must be checked without waiting for Google’s response.
How can an anonymous reviewer be identified?
Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows a legally admissible measure to obtain evidence before any proceedings, where a legitimate reason justifies preserving or establishing evidence. A request for identification data must therefore be justified by the intended dispute and precisely defined. An application without notice to the opposing party also requires the conditions of Article 493 of the French Code of Civil Procedure to be met. Obtaining data does not guarantee certain identification of an individual.
A pseudonym alone does not justify every request. In a case concerning a notary (notaire), the Paris Court of Appeal refused identification: “There are therefore no grounds for disclosing the identification data of the authors of the disputed reviews.” (our translation) (CA Paris, 27 April 2022, No. 21/14958). The firm first checks the statements, available evidence and purpose of the measure, rather than promising to lift anonymity.
Can every negative review be challenged?
No. An unfavourable opinion is not necessarily defamation, insult or disparagement. Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881 requires, for defamation, the imputation of a fact harming honour or reputation. Insult requires offensive language without imputing a fact. An urgent application for removal must also meet the conditions of Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
The analysis goes beyond whether the author appears in a customer database. A pseudonym may prevent a match, and the experience described may arise from a different context. In the bakery case examined on 2 July 2026, the Paris Court of Appeal considered the author’s former delivery services and the possibility of a good-faith defence being accepted on the merits; it refused removal in interim proceedings (CA Paris, No. 25/16002). This decision does not finally determine good faith on the merits.
Google rejected my report: what can I do next?
Keep the report and reply, then have the statements and documents reassessed. The refusal does not remove the need to demonstrate the conditions for a court application. Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows, in particular, measures before the president of the judicial court to end a manifestly unlawful disturbance. If the author’s identity is unknown, a measure under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure may be considered separately.
The procedure depends on the legal classification. A claim under press law requires compliance with Article 53 of the Law of 29 July 1881 and a limitation check. Within its scope, Article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881 does not grant a new period because a report has been rejected. Appropriate steps must therefore be considered in parallel, without assuming that the platform must remove the review or that it is automatically liable. The amount of any penalty payment is requested and assessed in the individual case, without any promised scale.
What can I do if a competitor or fake customer posts reviews?
Gather the publications, links between accounts and evidence connecting the reviews to their author. The mere absence of the pseudonym from your invoices does not prove that no relationship existed. Article 1240 of the French Civil Code allows compensation to be sought for a proven civil wrong, but Article 29 of the Law of 29 July 1881 remains applicable where the statements constitute defamation or insult. Competitor status does not remove this distinction.
A misleading commercial practice may also be considered: Article L121-4 of the French Consumer Code covers, among other practices, a trader falsely posing as a consumer and posting fake reviews to promote products. These conditions must be established, without treating every suspicious review as an offence. The firm compares the publications with the available documents and assesses separately the legal basis for removal, compensation and any criminal proceedings.
Do special rules apply to healthcare and regulated professionals?
Professional confidentiality requires particular care, but does not prohibit all public statements. Article 226-13 of the French Criminal Code penalises disclosure of confidential information by a person entrusted with it. For people receiving care within the health system, Article L1110-4 of the French Public Health Code protects all information about them that comes to the professional’s attention, subject to statutory exceptions.
Avoid confirming a care relationship or disclosing details from a file to rebut a review. A general reply inviting private contact may be considered if it reveals no protected information. Requests for removal or identification remain subject to their ordinary conditions: being a doctor, lawyer or notary does not make them automatic. The firm prepares the response and relevant documents with you, checking what may be disclosed in the intended context.
What remedies can I obtain in practice?
The possible requests are separate: a pre-action identification measure subject to Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, removal in interim proceedings under Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, a penalty payment to secure compliance under Article L131-1 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures, and compensation for loss on the applicable legal basis. For disparagement, Article 1240 of the French Civil Code requires the loss to be linked to a proven fault.
Cancellations, messages received and alleged losses must be documented, and their connection with the reviews assessed. A lower rating or a fall in turnover does not automatically entitle you to the amount claimed. In civil proceedings, a contribution towards expenses not included in court costs (dépens) may be requested under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure; an award depends, among other factors, on fairness and the financial situation of the party ordered to pay. None of these outcomes is guaranteed.
Why use a lawyer rather than an online reputation agency?
The firm’s proposed work covers legal classification, limitation, evidence and the choice of remedies. It may include a reasoned report to the platform, contact with the author and preparation of proceedings. For press offences, Article 53 of the Law of 29 July 1881 requires precise identification and legal classification of the facts and the applicable provision, along with the other formalities required for the document to be valid. Article 65 of the Law of 29 July 1881 also requires monitoring of the time limits.
Explaining this work does not require disparaging an agency’s services. Managing an online presence does not replace analysis of an accusation or a court document. We assess what the documents support, possible objections and whether action is appropriate. The firm promises neither automatic removal of criticism, nor an improved rating, nor a return to a particular volume of calls.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Law of 29 July 1881, civil liability, procedure and commercial practices: provisions cited in the versions applicable on 13 October 2026.
Further reading
The linked pages cover other areas of law; their inclusion does not mean their rules apply to every online review. Page updated on 13 October 2026.
Does a review target your business?
Send the full text, its URL and the known dates. The firm examines the legal classification, time limits and evidence before proposing a course of action.