KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Wanted by Warsaw, Detained in London: the Kuczmierowski Surrender Hearing and What France Would Require Before Handing Him Over

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Wanted by Warsaw, Detained in London: the Kuczmierowski Surrender Hearing and What France Would Require Before Handing Him Over

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 24 September 2026, a 47-year-old Polish former senior official walked back into Westminster Magistrates’ Court in London for a four-day hearing that will decide whether Britain hands him to Poland. Michal Kuczmierowski, who headed Poland’s Government Agency for Strategic Reserves (RARS) from 2021, was arrested in London in early September 2024 at Warsaw’s request and has been fighting surrender ever since. Polish prosecutors charge him with involvement in organised crime, neglect of duty and abuse of power for financial gain over contracts worth more than 321 million zloty (about 88.7 million dollars) for power generators destined for Ukraine. His lawyers answer that the prosecution is politically motivated and that he cannot receive a fair trial under the government of Donald Tusk. That clash — a corruption file built around wartime procurement on one side, claims of political persecution and a compromised judiciary on the other — is the classic hard case of cross-border criminal law. This analysis explains what Westminster is deciding this week and, through a French lawyer’s lens, what would happen if the same file landed on the desk of the Paris investigating chamber: which judges would decide, which bars to surrender exist in French law, and where London and Paris reason alike and where they diverge.

I. Can Britain surrender a Polish former agency chief for corruption?

A. What Michal Kuczmierowski is accused of, and why London arrested him

Michal Kuczmierowski headed the Government Agency for Strategic Reserves, known by its Polish acronym RARS, from 2021. According to Reuters, he had been repeatedly praised by former prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki, including for organising a military hub at Rzeszow airport in eastern Poland after the war in neighbouring Ukraine began. The agency he ran bought strategic equipment at speed during the Covid-19 pandemic and then during the war in Ukraine. Polish investigators are now examining whether RARS sidestepped normal public procurement rules, allegedly favouring certain companies and overpaying for supplies such as generators and face masks, according to the Polish Press Agency PAP as relayed by Polskie Radio.

The criminal case, as presented by the Polish authorities and reported by Reuters on 22 September 2025, concerns contracts worth over 321 million Polish zloty for the purchase of more than 1,600 power generators. Polish prosecutors charged Kuczmierowski, together with another man, with alleged involvement in organised crime, neglect of duty and abuse of power for financial gain. The generators were destined for Ukraine, which gives the file its political charge: procurement presented at the time as emergency solidarity with a country at war is now presented by prosecutors as a vehicle for corruption. Kuczmierowski denies wrongdoing and his lawyers describe the arrest itself as a political attack, a characterisation relayed by the Law and Justice (PiS) opposition.

The arrest took place in London in early September 2024. Because the United Kingdom left the European Union, the European Arrest Warrant no longer operates between London and Warsaw. The arrest was made under the post-Brexit surrender arrangements of the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, whose Part Three, Title VII organises surrender in place of the framework decision on the European Arrest Warrant. Under that regime, a Polish judicial decision is transmitted to the British authorities, the National Crime Agency certifies it, the person is arrested and brought before Westminster Magistrates’ Court, which acts as the first-instance extradition court for the whole country. That is the procedural track Kuczmierowski has been on for two years.

His custodial history shows how seriously the British courts took the flight-risk question at first. After his arrest he was held in Wandsworth prison in south-west London, and judges turned down bail three times. In February 2025 the court finally agreed to release him on conditions, including regular police check-ins and a cash deposit. In June 2026, when a London judge pushed the full hearing back to 24 September, a spokesperson for Westminster Magistrates’ Court told PAP that the terms of his release had been amended to allow him to travel to Newcastle in north-east England. The September 2026 hearing, expected to last four days, is the substantive examination of the case: the district judge hears the evidence, the bars to surrender and the human-rights arguments, and then reserves the decision to a later date. When Kuczmierowski arrived at the court building in the week of 22 September 2026, the Reuters news agency picture desk recorded his attendance at the hearing that will decide whether he can be extradited to face the corruption charges.

Two collateral episodes sharpen the political dimension. In October 2025, Poland’s foreign minister Radoslaw Sikorski publicly said he had asked the British side to speed up the extradition, prompting Kuczmierowski’s lawyer to accuse the minister of attempting to politically influence the decision of an independent court, as reported by Notes from Poland. Separately, his lawyers sought a safe-conduct letter that would have protected him from arrest in Poland until the case concluded; Warsaw’s regional court rejected that request in September 2025, the third such attempt, after prosecutors objected each time. Neither episode decides the surrender question, but both will feature in the argument about whether the prosecution is driven by law or by politics.

B. The two defences Westminster must decide: politically motivated prosecution and unfair trial

The defence runs on two related but distinct tracks, and the distinction matters because British extradition law treats them differently. The first track is political motivation: the lawyers say Kuczmierowski is being pursued because he served the previous nationalist Law and Justice administration, and that the Tusk government has made holding PiS-era officials to account a political priority. The second track is fair trial: even if the charges were properly brought, the defence says, the current state of the Polish justice system means he would not receive a fair hearing in Warsaw. At the September 2025 hearing, the defence called the Polish lawyer Mikolaj Pietrzak as an expert witness; he gave evidence that the Tusk government’s reform aims were impossible to achieve given the election of the PiS-supported president Karol Nawrocki, who can obstruct legislative changes in the rule-of-law area.

The Polish authorities’ answer, set out in court filings summarised by Reuters, is candid about the starting point: their own lawyers acknowledged that there is, in their words, a significant amount of work to do to undo the changes brought about by PiS, which courts have found to have significantly undermined the rule of law. They accepted that Nawrocki’s election could obstruct the current government’s declared intention to introduce legislative changes. Their case is nevertheless that the Tusk administration’s declared commitments mean there is no systemic risk to a defendant’s right to a fair trial today. In other words, both sides agree that the Polish judiciary carries the scars of the rule-of-law crisis; they disagree on whether those scars still bleed.

Under the UK’s Extradition Act 2003, whose full text is published by the official legislation archive, a judge hearing a contested request from an EU member state must work through a fixed sequence: the initial formalities, then the statutory bars to surrender — including the rule against surrender where it is sought for an extraneous purpose such as the person’s political opinions — then the question of compatibility with the European Convention on Human Rights, and finally proportionality and the Home Secretary’s decision. Political motivation is therefore not a slogan in a London courtroom; it is tested as a precise legal question, with evidence, against the wording of the statute and the Convention. The fair-trial argument is tested the same way: the judge must ask whether surrender would expose the person to a real risk of a flagrant denial of justice in the requesting state, and whether the assurances and reforms invoked by Warsaw dispel that risk. The four days listed from 24 September 2026 exist for exactly that evidential inquiry, and the ruling will follow weeks or months later.

For an international reader, the point to retain is that Westminster decides this case on evidence about Poland’s courts, not on sympathy for either government. If the judge finds the prosecution proved to the criminal standard in the requesting state to be a genuine corruption file and the fair-trial guarantees sufficient, surrender follows and only the Home Secretary’s limited review and appeals stand in the way. If the judge finds the request is tainted by political purpose or that the trial awaiting Kuczmierowski would be flagrantly unfair, discharge follows and Poland can appeal to the High Court. Either outcome can then travel further up the appellate ladder. The September 2026 hearing is therefore a staging post, not the end of the road — but it is the hearing where the factual record on Poland’s judiciary gets built, and that record will shape everything after.

II. Would France hand over the same man to Poland?

A. How a French surrender file moves: arrest, investigating chamber, and the judges who decide

Suppose the same request had been addressed to France: a Polish judicial authority seeking a former agency chief found in Paris for organised corruption and abuse of office. The first point a French lawyer makes is that Poland is a European Union member state, so the European Arrest Warrant defined by Article 695-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure would apply, not classic extradition. That provision describes the warrant as a judicial decision issued by one member state with a view to the arrest and surrender by another member state of a person wanted for criminal prosecution or for the execution of a custodial sentence. Within the Union, surrender is a judge-to-judge mechanism built on mutual recognition, and corruption punishable by at least three years falls squarely within the serious offences for which the framework operates without double-criminality review.

The French procedure after arrest is fast and entirely judicial. The person arrested is brought before the general prosecutor, and if release is not ordered, the first president of the court of appeal or a designated judge orders detention or supervision under Article 695-28. The investigating chamber is seized immediately and the person appears before it within five working days of presentation to the prosecutor, under Article 695-29. If the person consents to surrender, the chamber informs them of the legal consequences and the irrevocable character of consent, asks whether they waive the specialty rule, and, if the legal conditions are met, grants surrender by judgment, as Article 695-31 provides. If they do not consent — the Kuczmierowski scenario — the chamber holds a full hearing on the legal conditions for execution of the warrant, and its judgment can be appealed to the Court of Cassation. The decision is therefore made by three professional judges of the court of appeal, with a supreme-court review, and no minister signs anything: that is the structural difference with classic extradition.

Classic extradition, which France would apply to a request from a non-EU state such as post-Brexit Britain itself, works differently and is worth describing because it shows the French philosophy. Article 696 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states the default rule: failing an international convention providing otherwise, the conditions, procedure and effects of extradition are determined by the chapter’s provisions. Article 696-8 requires the request to travel through diplomatic channels with the conviction, the committal order or the arrest warrant describing precisely the facts and their date, plus the applicable legal texts. After notification, Article 696-11 allows the first president to order detention under extradition committal or, where appearance is sufficiently guaranteed, supervision measures. Where the person refuses surrender, Article 696-15 seizes the investigating chamber, which delivers a reasoned opinion within one month of the appearance, and an appeal against that opinion can only attack formal defects capable of depriving it of the essential conditions of its legal existence. Then comes the French originality: if the chamber’s reasoned and final opinion rejects the request, Article 696-17 provides that extradition cannot be granted and the person is released; if the opinion is favourable, Article 696-18 provides that surrender is authorised by decree of the Prime Minister on the report of the justice minister, open to an action for excess of power within one month. And Article 696-19 allows release to be requested at any time from the investigating chamber, which rules within twenty days, or fifteen where the request came within forty-eight hours of committal. A recent illustration of how seriously Paris judges control post-surrender detention is the judgment of the criminal chamber of 10 June 2026, no. 26-82.138, which holds that compliance with the specialty principle is assessed by reference to the surrender decision made by the requested state.

Applied to our hypothesis, the lesson is institutional. In London, the district judge decides and the Home Secretary retains a defined role; in Paris, for an EU warrant, three judges of the investigating chamber decide and the executive has no signature at all. The argument that a foreign minister publicly pressed for acceleration — the Sikorski episode — would therefore land differently in each capital: in London it feeds the evidentiary debate on political motivation, while in Paris it would simply have no institutional addressee, since no minister authorises an EU surrender. That does not make the French route easier for the requesting state; it makes it purely judicial, and purely judicial review in France is exacting.

B. The three French bars that mirror the London fight: political purpose, flagrant denial of justice, specialty and double criminality

The first bar is political purpose, and French law states it bluntly. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure lists the cases where extradition is not granted, and its second ground provides, word for word: “Lorsque le crime ou le délit à un caractère politique ou lorsqu’il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique” — where the crime or offence is of a political character, or where the circumstances show that extradition is sought for a political purpose. For a European Arrest Warrant, the equivalent shield sits in Article 695-22, whose fifth ground commands refusal where it is established that the warrant was issued for the purpose of prosecuting or convicting a person on account of sex, race, religion, ethnic origin, nationality, language, political opinions, sexual orientation or gender identity, or where the person’s situation may be prejudiced on any of those grounds. A French chamber seized of a Kuczmierowski-type file would therefore ask the precise question Westminster asks: do the public statements of ministers, the timing of the charges after a change of government, and the selection of this defendant among comparable procurement decision-makers establish a political purpose? Corruption is not a political offence by nature, and French courts have always distinguished the objective character of the acts from the subjective motive of the request — but where the circumstances demonstrate that the request serves a political purpose, refusal is mandatory, not discretionary.

The second bar is the fair-trial guarantee, and here the Court of Cassation has forged a Convention-based control that goes beyond the letter of the statutes. The seventh ground of Article 696-4 already refuses extradition where the person would be tried by a court not ensuring the fundamental guarantees of procedure and defence rights. The criminal chamber drew the full consequence in its judgment of 28 March 2023, no. 22-84.382, concerning an Italian extradition request: it held that Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights obliges a requested state to satisfy itself that the person will not be exposed, in the requesting state, to a flagrant denial of justice, a risk that may arise in particular where a person convicted in absentia cannot obtain a fresh judicial ruling on the merits. In a Polish-rule-of-law file, the Paris chamber would transpose that reasoning from convictions in absentia to systemic judicial dependence: are the courts that would try the defendant independent tribunals established by law within the meaning of Article 6, and does the individual face a real, personal risk of flagrant unfairness? The Court of Justice of the European Union asks the same two-step question for warrants between member states — systemic deficiencies first, individual exposure second — in its judgments on detention conditions (Aranyosi and Caldararu, cases C-404/15 and C-659/15 PPU, 5 April 2016) and on judicial independence (LM, case C-216/18 PPU, 25 July 2018), while Petruhhin (case C-182/15, 6 September 2016) frames the protection of Union citizens facing extradition to third states. A Paris chamber would therefore examine the expert evidence on Poland’s judiciary exactly as Westminster does, but through the combined lens of Article 6 of the Convention and the Luxembourg case law — and the requesting state’s own admission that reforms remain unfinished would be weighed, not waved away.

The third bar combines specialty and double criminality, the two technical locks that protect the surrendered person after handover. Specialty means Poland could try Kuczmierowski only for the facts for which surrender was granted; any prosecution for other pre-surrender offences needs the executing state’s consent, and Article 695-46 gives jurisdiction over such consent requests to the investigating chamber that ordered surrender. Double criminality, meanwhile, is largely neutralised for corruption: Article 695-23 executes a warrant without review of double criminality where the conduct is punishable by at least three years in the issuing state and falls within the listed categories, which include corruption, fraud, money laundering and participation in a criminal organisation. Organised corruption over hundreds of millions of zloty would therefore pass that lock without difficulty — the defence battle would be fought on political purpose and fair trial, not on the characterisation of the acts. Two further optional refusal grounds of Article 695-24 deserve mention for completeness: surrender may be refused where the acts were committed in whole or in part on French territory, or where the wanted person is a French national or resident and the sentence can be executed in France. Neither would help a Polish national arrested in Paris for acts committed in Warsaw — but both show that French law keeps territorial and rehabilitative exits open even inside the mutual-recognition system. Readers interested in how London handles comparable surrender bars can consult the companion analysis of the new United Kingdom retrial test in extradition cases and what France still requires.

Conclusion

The Westminster hearing that opened on 24 September 2026 will not end with a headline on the same day; the district judge will reserve the decision, appeals may follow, and the Home Secretary retains a statutory role. But the shape of the case is already clear, and it is the shape of all great extradition trials: a heavy corruption file built on emergency wartime procurement, against a defence that the prosecution is political and the requesting judiciary unsafe. London will decide on evidence, through the Extradition Act’s bars and the Convention. Paris, faced with the same file under a European Arrest Warrant, would decide through its investigating chamber within days of arrest, testing political purpose under Article 695-22, exposure to a flagrant denial of justice under Article 6 of the Convention in line with the Court of Cassation’s approach of 28 March 2023, and specialty in line with the criminal chamber’s judgment of 10 June 2026 — with corruption passing double criminality without debate. Neither capital takes the requesting state’s word for it, and neither treats a minister’s impatience as evidence. The Kuczmierowski file will therefore be decided the way extradition files should be decided: fact by fact, guarantee by guarantee, with the liberty of one man measured against the health of an entire justice system.

📄 Official circular