They talk about us
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, lycée allocation in Paris
Lycée allocation lawyer in Paris: Affelnet and dérogation appeals
An unwanted Affelnet allocation, no place at the start of the school year, a refused dérogation, a disputed orientation decision: as lycée allocation lawyers in Paris, the firm reviews the decision, drafts the administrative appeal (recours gracieux) to the education authority, then brings the case before the administrative court and, where the urgency is genuine, before the urgent applications judge (juge des référés).
The firm can be reached 24/7. An orientation decision (décision d'orientation) that does not match your request is challenged before the appeals committee within three working days of its notification (Article D. 331-34 of the French Education Code, Code de l'éducation). An allocation decision is challenged before the administrative court within two months.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received a very high standard of support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order that my ex had applied for abusively
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has a complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer of sound advice, kind and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, handling disputes over school allocation, orientation decisions and catchment-area exemptions (dérogations) before the education authorities and the administrative court.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 12 October 2026.
Quick answer
Allocation to a seconde class (the first year of lycée) is an administrative decision of the education authority (autorité académique), based on the choices (vœux) entered in Affelnet and on the pupil's orientation decision. It can be challenged by an administrative appeal (recours gracieux), then before the administrative court within two months. The urgent applications judge can be asked to act, but requires concrete urgency: the Council of State (Conseil d'État) refused to suspend a Paris allocation, as the urgency relied on mere possibilities. A dérogation is requested within the limits of available places. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16e, reviews the decision, drafts the appeals and argues the case before the judge. Contact the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A refused allocation, no place at the start of the school year, a dérogation request left unanswered?
Understanding your situation
Lycée allocation and Affelnet in Paris, explained
Entry to lycée rests on two separate decisions, governed by the French Education Code (Code de l'éducation): the orientation decision, which sets the track (general and technological seconde or the vocational track), then the allocation decision, which names the school. Each has its own appeal, its own time limit and its own judge. Confusing the two loses days, sometimes the right to act. What you need to know, step by step.
Key points
Orientation and allocation: two decisions, two appeals
Who decides, on what criteria, and before whom to challenge it.
The orientation decision is taken by the head of the collège (lower secondary school). The choice belongs to the family; a decision that does not match its request must state reasons and can be appealed (Article L. 331-8).
The appeal is lodged within three working days before a committee chaired by the academic director; its decision is the final orientation decision (Articles D. 331-34 and D. 331-35).
The allocation decision is signed by the academic director of national education services (DASEN), acting under delegation from the rector (recteur), assisted by a committee (Article D. 331-38).
Lycées first take pupils from their catchment area (zone de desserte); a dérogation is granted only within the limit of the remaining places (Article D. 211-11).
Affelnet is only a tool. The Council of State has held that the order that created it “has the sole purpose of authorising the creation of an automated processing of personal data to facilitate the management, by the academic directors of national education services, who are responsible for it under the aforementioned provisions of Article D. 211-11 of the Education Code, of the allocation of pupils to lycées.” (our translation) (CE, 4 March 2022, No. 451932). What is challenged is the allocation decision, not the software.
In Paris, in the case decided by the Council of State on 6 May 2025, the allocation decision was taken by the rector of the Paris académie. The competent administrative court is the one within whose jurisdiction the authority that took the decision has its seat (Article R. 312-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice (Code de justice administrative)).
Your situation
An unwanted allocation, or no allocation at all
The two situations call for neither the same appeal nor the same urgency.
You are challenging the allocation obtained
- First check that the decision adversely affects you: a choice that was granted, even a lower-ranked one, can deprive you of standing to act (intérêt à agir).
- Ask for the reasons, the points score (barème) and, where relevant, the rules of the processing system used.
- Lodge a reasoned administrative appeal, which interrupts the time limit for bringing proceedings (Article L. 411-2 of the CRPA).
- Bring the case before the administrative court if the appeal is rejected, with an urgent application only if urgency can be shown.
Your child has no allocation at all
- Point out in writing that schooling is compulsory up to the age of sixteen and that pupils have the right to continue their education beyond it (Articles L. 131-1 and L. 122-2).
- Apply to the education authority without delay for an allocation consistent with the orientation decision obtained.
- Consider any offer received carefully: a refusal later weighs against you before the judge.
- Consider an urgent application if no solution is offered within a timeframe compatible with the pupil's schooling.
Before any appeal, there is a question of admissibility. The Nancy Administrative Court of Appeal ruled, in the case of parents whose daughter had been allocated to the lycée of their second choice: “even though this enrolment does not correspond to their first choice, they do not show an interest giving them standing to act against the contested decisions.” (our translation) (CAA Nancy, 20 October 2020, No. 18NC03223)
Depending on your situation, these points are checked first:
Appeals
Challenging an allocation or a dérogation refusal, step by step
From the administrative file to the administrative court.
Obtain the reasons and the points score
Allocation sheet, the pupil's points score and that of the last pupil admitted, capacity of the requested lycée: without these, no serious appeal can be written.
Write to the education authority
An administrative appeal to the DASEN (recours gracieux), or a hierarchical appeal to the rector (recours hiérarchique), lodged within the two-month time limit, interrupts that time limit. It sets out the facts, the pupil's situation and the supporting documents.
Document the reason
Health, disability, siblings, a particular course of study: dérogations are granted in an order of priority, within the limit of the places remaining once pupils from the catchment area have been admitted.
Administrative court and urgent applications
Application for annulment within two months; urgent application for suspension (référé-suspension) if the urgency is concrete; urgent application to protect a fundamental freedom (référé-liberté) only in the event of a serious and manifestly unlawful infringement.
The administrative appeal is the first real chance: it allows a fresh review before the start of the school year, when places become available. It must be precise, backed by figures and accompanied by the supporting documents, not merely express disagreement.
Timeline
Time limits, from the orientation decision to the court
Each stage has its own time limit, often very short at the outset.
The orientation decision
If it does not match the request, the family meets the head of school (chef d'établissement), then receives a reasoned decision (Articles L. 331-8 and D. 331-34).
The appeal within three working days
Within this time limit, the family states whether it accepts the decision or appeals; the appeals committee hears the parents who ask to be heard (Article D. 331-35).
Repeating the year as of right
If the requested track is not obtained, the family can have the pupil kept in the original class for one school year only (Article D. 331-37).
The allocation decision
Signed by the academic director, acting under delegation from the rector, according to the orientation decisions and the family's choices (Article D. 331-38).
The administrative or hierarchical appeal
Lodged within two months, it interrupts the time limit for bringing court proceedings (Article L. 411-2 of the CRPA).
The administrative court
Two months from notification of the decision or rejection of the appeal (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice); time limits can only be relied on against you if they were stated in the notification (Article R. 421-5).
Preparing the file
Documents to gather
What makes it possible to challenge the decision and, where necessary, to show urgency.
The allocation or refusal decision, with its date of notification and its statement of appeal routes.
The list of choices entered and their order, together with the final orientation decision.
The troisième (final year of collège) school reports and the results taken into account for the ranking.
The proof of address that determines the catchment area, and any change of address.
Medical documents, the MDPH (departmental disability office) decision or the personalised plan, in the event of a health condition or disability.
Correspondence with the collège, the rectorat and the lycée: emails, acknowledgements of receipt, replies.
Send what you have, even if incomplete: the firm identifies what is missing and prepares the appeal with you on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen answers based on the texts in force and on decisions of the administrative courts.
Can I challenge a lycée allocation made through Affelnet?
Yes. The allocation decision is an individual administrative decision. It is signed by the academic director of national education services, acting under delegation from the rector for courses located in the département, assisted by a committee (Article D. 331-38 of the French Education Code). Affelnet is used to manage choices and rankings; it does not replace the decision.
The challenge has two stages. First, an administrative appeal to the author of the decision (recours gracieux), or a hierarchical appeal to the rector (recours hiérarchique), lodged within the time limit for court proceedings, which interrupts that time limit (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration, CRPA). Then, if the appeal fails, an application to the administrative court within two months (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
The appeal must target a specific error: a miscalculated points score, a wrong address or catchment area, a choice entered incorrectly, a particular situation that was not examined, an orientation decision that was not followed. Mere disagreement with the result is not enough. For an overview of the situations arising at the start of the school year, see our article on refused or unwanted lycée allocations.
Our child got one of their choices, but not the first: can we act?
This is the first question to settle, because it determines whether the appeal is admissible. To bring a case before the judge, the decision must adversely affect you. The Nancy Administrative Court of Appeal ruled, in the case of parents whose daughter had been allocated to the lycée of their second choice: “even though this enrolment does not correspond to their first choice, they do not show an interest giving them standing to act against the contested decisions.” (our translation) (CAA Nancy, 20 October 2020, No. 18NC03223). The claim was declared inadmissible.
This decision calls for caution. A family whose choice has been granted must first ask what it is really challenging: the refusal of the first choice in itself, an error in calculating the ranking, a particular situation that was not examined. How the administrative appeal, and then the court application, is worded depends on this analysis.
It is also a reason to build the list of choices carefully, bearing in mind that a granted choice can close the route to the courts. The firm examines the decision and the choices before any appeal, to avoid proceedings bound to be found inadmissible.
My child has no lycée place at the start of the school year: what can we do?
Schooling is compulsory up to the age of sixteen (Article L. 131-1 of the French Education Code), and every minor has the right to continue their education beyond that age (Article L. 122-2). The education authority allocates pupils to state lycées taking into account the schools' capacity (Article L. 214-5). The administration must therefore seek, within a timeframe compatible with the pupil's schooling, an allocation consistent with the pupil's orientation decision.
The process is in writing: an allocation request sent to the education authority, recalling the orientation decision, the choices and the pupil's situation. The urgent applications judge can then be asked to act, but assesses what the administration has done. In a case decided on 31 October 2022, the pupil had been offered a place in his chosen course and within the catchment area, which his parents had refused; the judge held that, despite insufficient efforts, “the administration cannot be regarded as having seriously and manifestly unlawfully infringed the right to equal access to education so as to justify the intervention of the urgent applications judge on the basis of Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice.” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 31 October 2022, No. 468362).
An offer received should therefore be considered carefully before it is refused.
How do I get a dérogation for a lycée outside our catchment area?
Lycées first take pupils who live in their catchment area. Each year the academic director sets the maximum number of pupils for each school. Within the limit of the remaining places, pupils from another area can be enrolled there with the director's authorisation; when requests exceed the available capacity, the director sets the order of priority in line with the allocation procedures in force (Article D. 211-11 of the French Education Code). For a pupil who lives in another département, a dérogation also requires the favourable opinion of the academic director of the département of residence.
A dérogation is therefore not a right: it is an option limited by the lycée's capacity. A strong file documents the reason relied on (health, disability, a sibling at the school, a particular course or subject) with dated and precise documents, and follows the timetable set by the education authority.
If it is refused, the appeal focuses on two points: was the reason actually examined, and was the requested lycée in fact full? The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal upheld a refusal, noting that the lycée, saturated by pupils from its own catchment area, had been unable to grant any of the dérogation requests it received (CAA Paris, 25 October 2024, No. 23PA03115).
If our dérogation request goes unanswered, is it accepted?
The text provides for it: the dérogation request is deemed accepted if no answer has been given when a three-month period expires, running from the filing of the request in accordance with the timetable set by the education authority (Article D. 211-11 of the French Education Code). The person concerned can ask for a certificate of this implied acceptance (Article L. 232-3 of the CRPA).
The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal applied it: “Since she disputes having received a reply to this request before the expiry of the three-month period provided for by the aforementioned provisions of Article D. 211-11 of the Education Code, and since evidence to the contrary has not been produced, her request, received on 14 May 2021 at the latest, is deemed to have been accepted on 14 August 2021.” (our translation) (CAA Paris, 25 October 2024, No. 23PA03115).
But the same decision shows the limit. The implied acceptance was unlawful, since the lycée had no place available, and the administration could withdraw it within four months (Article L. 242-1 of the CRPA); it did so by allocating the pupil elsewhere. Keep proof of the filing date: it starts the time limit running.
Can an urgent application secure a lycée place before the start of the school year?
In theory it can, but the judge requires concrete urgency. An urgent application for suspension (référé-suspension) requires an application for annulment, urgency and a ground capable of creating serious doubt as to the lawfulness of the decision (Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
The Council of State has ruled on a Paris allocation. A pupil had been allocated to a general seconde class at the lycée of her fourth choice; the urgent applications judge of the Paris Administrative Court had suspended the decision. The Council of State set aside that order: the arguments based on the lost chance of entering a preparatory class (classe préparatoire), the weight of continuous assessment and the approaching start of the school year were not enough. It held: “Such circumstances rest on mere possibilities and do not entail a sufficiently immediate infringement of the situation of the applicants and their daughter.” (our translation) (CE, 6 May 2025, No. 496890).
Urgency is therefore shown by present facts: a total lack of schooling, an essential subject not taught at the allocated school, the pupil's state of health, an incompatible journey time supported by documents. An urgent application is only worth filing when these elements exist; otherwise, the administrative appeal and the application on the merits are more useful.
When is a référé-liberté possible?
The urgent application to protect a fundamental freedom (référé-liberté) allows the judge to order, within forty-eight hours, the measures needed to safeguard a fundamental freedom that the administration is infringing seriously and manifestly unlawfully (Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice). Representation by a lawyer is not compulsory for it (Article R. 522-5).
The threshold is high. In several cases from the Essonne decided on 31 October 2022, the urgent applications judge of the Council of State declined to intervene where the pupil had been offered an allocation in his orientation track and within his catchment area, even one far from his choices. In one of them, he so held “even though the allocated school does not correspond to any of the choices he had made and is located in an environment to which M. A... C... does not wish to go” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 31 October 2022, No. 468335).
The référé-liberté is therefore reserved for situations where the pupil remains without any suitable schooling, despite repeated and documented steps. It is prepared with the documents proving those steps and the lack of response.
Our child was refused the general seconde: how do we appeal?
The choice of orientation is the family's responsibility, but the decision belongs to the head of school after the opinion of the class council (conseil de classe) (Article L. 331-8 of the French Education Code). Where the proposal does not match the request, the family meets the head of school, then receives a reasoned decision. It then has three working days to state whether it accepts the decision or appeals against it (Article D. 331-34).
The appeals committee, chaired by the academic director, hears the parents who ask to be heard; its decision is the final orientation decision (Article D. 331-35). If the family does not agree with it, the family can ask for the pupil to be kept in the original class for one year (Article D. 331-37).
This appeal is a mandatory prior step. The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal ruled: “It follows from these provisions that the appeal before the appeals committee is a mandatory prior appeal. Consequently the decision taken by that body replaces the initial decision taken by the head of school, whose own defects can therefore no longer usefully be relied on.” (our translation) (CAA Paris, 9 June 2020, No. 19PA01196). The file is therefore prepared for the committee.
Can we find out the criteria and points score used for the allocation?
General administrative law allows this to a large extent. Where an individual decision is taken on the basis of algorithmic processing, it must include a statement informing the person concerned, and the rules defining that processing and the main features of its implementation are disclosed to them on request (Article L. 311-3-1 of the CRPA). On request, the administration discloses in particular the data processed, and the parameters and their weighting as applied to the person's situation (Article R. 311-3-1-2).
In its decision of 4 March 2022 (No. 451932), the Council of State did not settle whether these rules apply to Affelnet: it only held that these arguments were ineffective against the order creating the processing system. The request for disclosure is therefore addressed to the authority that took the allocation decision, citing these texts.
In practice, the allocation sheet and the points score of the last pupil admitted are often decisive. In the case decided by the Paris Administrative Court of Appeal on 25 October 2024, the comparison between the pupil's points score and that of the last pupil allocated was enough to justify the refusal. These figures are requested in writing, from the administrative appeal stage.
The allocated lycée is far away or unsuited to the pupil's health or disability: what are the remedies?
Distance alone is rarely enough. The judge mainly checks that the allocation respects the orientation track and the catchment area; it then examines the concrete evidence provided by the family. In a case from the Essonne decided on 31 October 2022, an alleged incompatibility between the pupil's health and the journey, not established by the documents produced, did not succeed before the urgent applications judge.
A health condition or disability changes the analysis. Every adolescent with a disability or a disabling health condition is enrolled in the school closest to their home, which is their reference school; if their needs require adapted arrangements, they can be enrolled in another school, with their parents' agreement (Article L. 112-1 of the French Education Code). A medical reason can also support a dérogation request.
The file rests on documents: precise medical certificates, MDPH (departmental disability office) decisions, the personalised schooling plan, the actual journey time, care requirements. The firm gathers them with the family before the administrative appeal, then uses them before the judge if necessary.
Should we enrol our child in the offered lycée while the appeal is pending?
In most cases, yes, for a simple reason: the pupil's schooling must not be interrupted during the proceedings. For a child under sixteen, parents are in any event required to enrol the child in a school, unless home education has been authorised (Article L. 131-5 of the French Education Code).
Refusing an offered place also has a litigation cost. Before the urgent applications judge, the existence of an offer consistent with the orientation decision, refused by the family, led the judge to rule out a serious infringement of access to education (CE, urgent applications judge, 31 October 2022, No. 468362).
Enrolment and the challenge are pursued at the same time: the family enrols the pupil, then lodges the administrative appeal within the time limits. Before taking any step, the firm examines with the family how enrolment affects its standing to act, particularly where the lycée obtained was among its choices. Our article on school allocation, catchment areas and dérogations details these trade-offs.
Do we need a lawyer before the administrative court, and which court should we apply to?
A lawyer is not compulsory to seek the annulment of an allocation decision: Article R. 431-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice requires representation by a lawyer only for certain claims, in particular those seeking payment of a sum of money. Urgent applications linked to a dispute exempt from that requirement are also exempt, and the référé-liberté always is (Article R. 522-5).
The competent court is the one within whose jurisdiction the authority that took the contested decision has its seat (Article R. 312-1). The application must be accompanied by the contested decision or, for an implied decision, by proof that the request was filed (Article R. 412-1). The two-month time limit only runs if the notification stated the appeal routes and time limits (Article R. 421-5).
The value of a lawyer lies in building the file: identifying the right decision, checking admissibility, choosing between an application on the merits and an urgent application, putting forward arguments the judge can accept. The firm acts in Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France); see also our page on our education law practice.
What are the fees to challenge a lycée allocation?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971, except in cases of urgency or force majeure: before you commit, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: review of the decision and administrative appeal, appeal before the orientation appeals committee, application to the administrative court, urgent application. Any new work is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
Legal aid (aide juridictionnelle) is available subject to means; the firm tells you whether you are eligible. For a first reading of the file, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis. First conversation on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked as at 12 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Article D. 331-38 of the French Education Code, allocation decision
- Article D. 211-11 of the French Education Code, catchment areas and dérogations
- Article L. 214-5 of the French Education Code, allocation to state lycées
- Article D. 331-35 of the French Education Code, orientation appeals committee
- Article D. 331-37 of the French Education Code, keeping the pupil in the original class
- Article L. 411-2 of the CRPA, administrative appeal and time limit
- Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, two-month time limit
- Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, urgent application for suspension (référé-suspension)
- CE, 6 May 2025, No. 496890, Paris allocation, urgency rejected
- CAA Paris, 25 October 2024, No. 23PA03115, implied dérogation and withdrawal
A lycée allocation to challenge?
Contact the firm as soon as the decision is notified. Hassan Kohen, avocat at the Paris Bar, examines the allocation, the orientation decision and the choices, drafts the administrative appeal or the orientation appeal, then brings the case before the administrative court when the file warrants it. The firm can be reached 24/7.