KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Extradition Refused? France Can Still Put You on Trial in Paris: the 6 October 2026 Ruling

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Extradition Refused? France Can Still Put You on Trial in Paris: the 6 October 2026 Ruling

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

In the same week that France’s highest criminal court cancelled two extradition opinions for skipped verifications, it issued a third extradition ruling that points in the opposite direction, and every foreign national wanted in France needs to understand it. On 6 October 2026, the Criminal Chamber of the Cour de cassation rejected the appeals against a Paris decision that had annulled an entire French criminal file built after two extradition refusals, one opposed to Kazakhstan and one opposed to Russia. The message of Criminal Chamber, 6 October 2026, no. 25-83.277 is blunt: when France refuses to hand you over, your case is not over, because France may decide to try you itself in Paris. But the same ruling draws a hard line around that power: a French prosecution after a refused extradition is lawful only on the strict statutory grounds listed in the Criminal Code, and a vague diplomatic letter that states no reason opens no such door.

This guide explains, for an international reader, what refusal followed by domestic prosecution means in practice. The first part reconstructs the 6 October 2026 ruling: two refused extraditions, a French investigation opened on the same facts, a Paris chamber that threw the whole file out, and a Cour de cassation that agreed the file had to go, while restating the exact conditions on which a French trial after refusal remains possible. The second part turns to the two shields every requested person should raise before that stage is ever reached: the European rule that forces France to warn your home EU Member State and let it claim you under a European Arrest Warrant, and the practical path of an extradition file handled in Paris, from provisional arrest to the government’s final decree. All citations come from the rulings themselves and the statutes they apply, each linked to its official source, and every time limit below is stated exactly as the text in force puts it, with the official link in the same sentence. French-speaking readers can read the French-language analysis of the same 6 October 2026 ruling.

I. Extradition refused, trial in France: what the Cour de cassation decided on 6 October 2026

A. Two refused surrenders, one French prosecution, and a file thrown out in Paris

The facts behind Criminal Chamber, 6 October 2026, no. 25-83.277 span three decades and four countries, and they are worth setting out precisely because they show how a refused extradition turns into a French case. Kazakhstan sought the extradition of the man for criminal prosecution on aggravated breach of trust and money laundering charges, for acts committed between 2005 and 2009 principally in Kazakhstan but also in Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom. By a letter of 27 October 2014, the French ambassador to Kazakhstan informed that country’s foreign minister that, for reasons relating both to domestic rules and to the international commitments of France, it had not been possible to bring the request before the French courts. Russia also sought the man’s extradition, and the decree granting that request after a favourable advising-chamber opinion was annulled by the Conseil d’Etat on the ground that extradition had been sought for a political purpose. On 27 July 2017 the Kazakh prosecutor general transmitted the facts to the French justice minister through diplomatic channels and lodged a criminal complaint in Paris on the same facts, asking for prosecution. On 2 April 2018 the Paris prosecutor opened a judicial investigation, and the man was placed under formal investigation on 5 October 2020 before applying to have procedural documents annulled.

The Paris advising chamber, second section, ruled on 1 April 2025 that the opening indictment of 2 April 2018 and the entire subsequent proceedings were void, and both a civil party and the prosecutor general appealed. Their argument was straightforward: the statute allows French prosecution of a foreigner whose extradition has been refused, no prior official denunciation by the refused state is required any more, and either refusal, the Kazakh one or the Russian one, should support the French case. The Criminal Chamber disagreed and rejected both appeals. To understand why that rejection matters, note first what the Court accepted without difficulty: a refusal letter signed by the French ambassador, as the representative of the French government and state in the country of accreditation, does count as a refusal of extradition by the French authorities, and the statute does not require the refusal to come from a judicial authority. The file therefore did not fail for lack of a competent refusing authority. It failed on the content of the refusals, and that is where the ruling becomes a practical manual.

On the Russian refusal, the reasoning is categorical. French law distinguishes two different things that English often merges: an offence that is political in nature, and a request made for a political purpose. Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states both, side by side: “il résulte des circonstances que l’extradition est demandée dans un but politique”, extradition is not granted. But the domestic-prosecution statute is narrower. As the Court puts it in Criminal Chamber, 6 October 2026, no. 25-83.277: “l’article 113-8-2 du code pénal, qui, introduisant une dérogation au principe de l’application de la loi pénale française aux infractions commises sur le territoire de la République, doit être interprété strictement, ne vise que le cas où le fait considéré revêt le caractère d’infraction politique”. Because the provision is an exception to territoriality, it must be read strictly, and it covers only the case where the act itself is a political offence. It follows, the Court holds, that a refusal opposed to Russia on the ground of the political purpose of the request cannot found French prosecution of the acts. A successful political-purpose defence against surrender does not automatically hand the French prosecutor a domestic case on the same facts.

On the Kazakh refusal, the lesson is about paperwork, and it is even more useful for defence teams. The ambassador’s 2014 letter spoke of domestic rules and international commitments without naming a ground. The Paris judges concluded that no explicit refusal motive corresponding to the statute’s exhaustive list could be derived from it, and the Cour de cassation approved exactly that reading: the judges had correctly concluded from the terms of the letter that “ils ne permettent pas de connaître le ou les motifs de ce refus et, en cet état, de s’assurer qu’ils entrent dans les prévisions de ce texte”, as the Court confirms in Criminal Chamber, 6 October 2026, no. 25-83.277. A refusal whose reasons are unknowable cannot be verified against the statutory list, and what cannot be verified cannot support prosecution. The practical consequence is immediate for anyone whose surrender has been refused by France: obtain the written refusal and read its stated ground, because only a refusal founded on one of the listed motives can later anchor a French trial, and a vagueness that once protected you against surrender may equally defeat a domestic prosecution built upon it.

The ruling adds one structural condition that frames every future file. Since the legislature removed the requirement of a prior official denunciation by the refused state, the conditions for French prosecution are no longer assessed solely through the wording of the refusal. But the Court holds in Criminal Chamber, 6 October 2026, no. 25-83.277 that “les faits commis hors du territoire de la République par un étranger ne peuvent être poursuivis en France que s’ils sont les mêmes que ceux ayant fait l’objet du ou des refus d’extradition de cet étranger fondés sur l’un des motifs énoncés par ce texte”. Identity of facts is mandatory: France can only try the same acts that were the subject of a refusal founded on a listed ground. A prosecutor cannot use a refusal concerning one set of facts as a springboard for trying different ones.

B. The four statutory doors to a French trial after refusal, read strictly

The provision at the centre of the ruling is Article 113-8-2 of the Criminal Code, and it repays close reading: “la loi pénale française est également applicable à tout crime ou à tout délit puni d’au moins cinq ans d’emprisonnement commis hors du territoire de la République par un étranger dont l’extradition ou la remise a été refusée à l’Etat requérant par les autorités françaises aux motifs, soit que le fait à raison duquel l’extradition avait été demandée est puni d’une peine ou d’une mesure de sûreté contraire à l’ordre public français, soit que la personne réclamée aurait été jugée dans ledit Etat par un tribunal n’assurant pas les garanties fondamentales de procédure et de protection des droits de la défense, soit que le fait considéré revêt le caractère d’infraction politique, soit que l’extradition ou la remise serait susceptible d’avoir, pour la personne réclamée, des conséquences d’une gravité exceptionnelle en raison, notamment, de son âge ou de son état de santé”. Four doors, each with its own evidentiary burden, and the statute adds that prosecution may only be brought at the request of the public prosecutor.

The first door covers penalties contrary to French public policy, which in extradition practice principally means punishments France will not lend its machinery to, such as irreducible life sentences without any review mechanism or penalties involving treatment incompatible with human dignity. A refusal built on this ground must show, concretely, what penalty the requesting state’s law attaches to the acts and why that penalty offends French public policy, with the applicable foreign provisions produced in the file. The requesting state is in any event required to produce the copy of the statutory texts applicable to the charged acts together with its request, since Article 696-8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure makes production of those texts part of a complete extradition request. Defence teams challenging a later domestic prosecution should therefore check two things: whether the refusal actually named this ground, and whether the foreign penalty it invokes is documented rather than asserted.

The second door, trial by a court without fundamental guarantees of procedure and defence rights, is the one most often decisive in cases involving states whose justice systems France distrusts. It mirrors one of the mandatory refusal grounds, and it requires an in-concreto demonstration tied to the requesting state’s courts as they would try this defendant, not a general report about a country. The 6 October ruling confirms the method by negative example: where the only record of the refusal is a diplomatic letter stating no ground, the court cannot verify that any listed motive was the real one, and the domestic case collapses. Conversely, where a refusal decision documents specific, current deficiencies in the requesting state’s trial guarantees for the acts concerned, the same door opens wide. Families and lawyers should therefore treat the reasoning of the refusal as the most valuable document in the file: it both blocks surrender and, if it is precise, authorises Paris to take over.

The third door, the political-offence character of the act, is the one the 6 October ruling most visibly narrows. Read strictly, it covers only acts that are themselves political offences, not ordinary financial or violent offences whose prosecution is allegedly motivated by politics. That distinction decided the Russian branch of the case: a decree annulled because surrender was sought for a political purpose says nothing about the political character of the underlying breach-of-trust and laundering charges, so it cannot carry a domestic prosecution under the statute. The related jurisprudence on refusal itself remains broader, since Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure refuses extradition both for political offences and for requests made for a political purpose, a two-branch shield examined in the recent analysis of how France tests the political-offence exception before surrendering anyone. The asymmetry is deliberate and must be kept in mind: the shield against surrender is wider than the sword of domestic prosecution, and winning on political purpose wins freedom from surrender without automatically winning immunity from a French courtroom.

The fourth door, consequences of exceptional gravity because of age or health, is the most fact-dependent and the least litigated, but its structure is identical: the refusal must have been founded on it, and the same facts must be at stake. Medical records, age documentation and evidence about detention conditions in the requesting state belong in the extradition file from the start, because they serve twice, first to obtain refusal and then, if the prosecutor later moves domestically, to delimit what France may try. In every case the threshold conditions apply cumulatively: a crime or an offence punishable by at least five years’ imprisonment, committed outside France by a foreign national, a French refusal grounded on a listed motive, identity between the refused facts and the prosecuted facts, and proceedings brought only at the prosecutor’s request. Miss one element and the French trial has no legal basis, exactly as the Paris chamber and the Cour de cassation held for the file decided on 6 October 2026.

II. Before refusal is even an option: two shields every person sought in France should raise

A. The European shield: France must warn your home EU state first

Long before any question of refusal or domestic prosecution arises, European Union law gives one category of requested persons a powerful preliminary shield. When France receives an extradition request from a non-EU state concerning a citizen of another EU Member State who has exercised free movement to France, France may not simply process the request bilaterally. It must inform the citizen’s home state, share the full file, and give that state the opportunity to claim its national under a European Arrest Warrant for the same acts. The rule comes from the Court of Justice in Petruhhin, C-182/15, 6 September 2016, as restated by the Cour de cassation in Criminal Chamber, 15 October 2025, no. 24-86.904, refined in By, C-398/19, 17 December 2020, also applied in Criminal Chamber, 15 October 2025, no. 24-86.904, and the Cour de cassation applied it with full force in Criminal Chamber, 15 October 2025, no. 24-86.904, a decision whose second cassation ground has gone largely unnoticed outside France.

The 2025 case concerned a Brazilian extradition request for firearms prosecutions against a man who held Austrian nationality. The advising chamber of Fort-de-France gave a favourable opinion without checking whether Austria had been informed. The Criminal Chamber quashed on two independent grounds, and the second is the European one. Recalling the Treaty provisions on non-discrimination and Union citizenship together with the Framework Decision on the European Arrest Warrant, the Court restated the duty in Criminal Chamber, 15 October 2025, no. 24-86.904 in these terms: “lorsqu’un État membre dans lequel un citoyen de l’Union, ressortissant d’un autre État membre, s’est déplacé, est destinataire d’une demande d’extradition d’un État tiers avec lequel il a conclu un accord d’extradition, il est tenu d’informer l’État membre dont ledit citoyen a la nationalité et, le cas échéant, à la demande de ce dernier État membre, de lui remettre ce citoyen, conformément aux dispositions de la décision-cadre 2002/584/JAI”. The duty of loyal cooperation then requires France to share not only the existence of the request but all the legal and factual material the third state supplied, and to keep the home state informed of any relevant change, so that it can decide whether to issue its own arrest warrant for prosecution.

The Fort-de-France chamber had done none of this: it gave its favourable opinion, in the words of Criminal Chamber, 15 October 2025, no. 24-86.904, “sans s’assurer que les autorités compétentes de l’Autriche, État membre dont l’intéressé a la nationalité, avaient été informées de l’existence d’une demande d’extradition le visant, de l’ensemble des éléments de droit et de fait communiqués par l’État tiers requérant dans le cadre de cette demande d’extradition, ni que cet État membre avait été mis en mesure d’apprécier l’opportunité d’émettre un mandat d’arrêt européen aux fins de poursuites pour les faits objet de la demande d’extradition”. Cassation followed on that ground alone. The same Brazilian file then produced a second cassation on 7 October 2026, no. 26-80.171, this time for a hearing that had not opened with the requested person’s interrogation, a hearing-form requirement examined in the companion coverage of the October 2026 double time-bar and hearing rulings. Taken together, the Brazilian saga shows a file quashed twice in twelve months, once for ignoring the home Member State and once for mishandling the hearing, which is the level of formal discipline French extradition practice now operates under.

For an EU citizen arrested in France on a third-state warrant, the practical checklist writes itself. Tell the advising chamber immediately of your Member-State nationality and put proof of it on the record. Require the chamber to verify, in the text of its opinion, that your home state’s competent authorities were informed of the request and given the complete file, and that they were kept updated on your situation. Ask what the home state answered and whether it intends to prosecute or to issue a European Arrest Warrant, since a home-state warrant takes precedence through surrender within the Union rather than extradition outside it. And remember that this shield applies regardless of the merits of the third state’s case: it is a procedural priority rule, not a judgment on guilt, and its breach alone is enough to send the opinion to the Cour de cassation, as the Austrian-nationality file proves.

B. Arrested in Paris on a foreign warrant: the file’s path and where to fight

Everything above becomes concrete the day someone is arrested in Paris on a foreign warrant, and the choreography of those first weeks decides which shields remain available. The standard path runs as follows. After provisional arrest, the person is placed in extradition detention, the formal request is notified, and the advising chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal is seized. The chamber hears the person, gives counsel the floor, hears the prosecution, and must deliver a reasoned opinion within one month of the person’s appearance unless further inquiries are ordered, an opinion that is unfavourable wherever the legal conditions are unmet or a clear error appears. Appeal lies to the Cour de cassation but on narrow grounds, since Article 696-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that “Le pourvoi formé contre un avis de la chambre de l’instruction ne peut être fondé que sur des vices de forme de nature à priver cet avis des conditions essentielles de son existence légale”. A favourable opinion is followed by a government decree authorising surrender, which can itself be challenged before the administrative courts, and only then does physical handover occur. The earliest hours of that detention, and how to challenge them, are covered in the firm’s guide to challenging provisional arrest and detention in France, which is the companion to read alongside this article.

At the hearing stage, the hearing-form discipline of October 2026 applies in full. Article 696-13 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires that “Lors de la comparution de la personne réclamée, la chambre de l’instruction constate son identité et recueille ses déclarations. Il en est dressé procès-verbal”, and the 7 October 2026 ruling treats the opening interrogation with its written record as the mandatory gateway to the debates rather than an optional formality. Concretely, defence teams in Paris should verify the minutes before arguing anything else: was the person questioned first, were identity and statements recorded, was counsel present with an interpreter where needed, and was the publicity of the hearing addressed where required. The 15 October 2025 ruling adds the presence point from the other direction: a favourable opinion given in the person’s absence, where extraction failed for reasons internal to the justice system and the hearing could have been postponed within the imperative time limits, does not stand, since every accused person has the right to defend themselves in person or through counsel of their choice, the guarantee stated in Article 6, paragraph 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

On limitation, the Paris chamber must now show its computation rather than assert its conclusion. The rule combines the treaty and the statute: extradition is refused where prosecution or punishment is time-barred under either the requesting state’s law or French law, and Article 696-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure fixes the anchors in these terms: “Lorsque, d’après la loi de l’Etat requérant ou la loi française, la prescription de l’action s’est trouvée acquise antérieurement à la demande d’extradition, ou la prescription de la peine antérieurement à l’arrestation de la personne réclamée”. Prosecution files are measured against the date of the extradition request, enforcement files against the date of arrest, each under both laws, with dates and provisions on the record. Old convictions enforced years later, the North-Macedonia pattern of 2013 facts, a 2019 sentence and a 2025 arrest, are the archetype to test: compute both clocks before conceding anything, because the chamber must do so on its own motion where the file raises the question.

If the chamber’s opinion is unfavourable to surrender, or the government refuses or a decree is annulled, the file does not necessarily end; it may convert into the domestic-prosecution track of Part I. That is the moment to deploy the 6 October 2026 reading defensively. Demand the written refusal and identify its stated ground among the four statutory doors, refusing to accept a generic reference to domestic rules or international commitments as a substitute. Check identity between the refused facts and any facts the Paris prosecutor now pursues, since different facts cannot ride on the earlier refusal. Contest any attempt to found domestic prosecution on a political-purpose refusal, which the Cour de cassation has now held insufficient as a matter of strict interpretation. And verify the threshold: only a crime or an offence carrying at least five years’ imprisonment qualifies, and only proceedings brought at the prosecutor’s request are valid. Handled this way, the very ruling that authorises France to try refused persons becomes the instrument that confines that power to its statutory bed, which is exactly how a court that quashes opinions for missing verifications would want its case law used.

Conclusion

The first week of October 2026 gave international observers the full picture of French extradition justice in three rulings. Refusal does not mean impunity: under Article 113-8-2 of the Criminal Code, France may try in Paris the foreign national it declines to surrender, but only for the same facts, only on one of four exhaustively listed grounds, only above the five-year threshold, and only at the prosecutor’s request, with vague diplomatic refusals and political-purpose findings excluded as foundations. Before that stage, European law interposes its own priority: an EU citizen sought by a third state must have their home Member State warned and given the chance to claim them under a European Arrest Warrant, on pain of cassation. And throughout, from the opening interrogation to the double time-bar computation, the advising chamber must show its verifications on the record, because an opinion that skips a mandatory check is not a valid opinion. Anyone arrested in France on a foreign warrant, or watching such a file from abroad, should therefore ask four questions in this order: was my home state warned, where is the opening interrogation record, where is the double limitation computation, and on which exact statutory ground does any threatened French trial rest. The October rulings answer what happens when any of those questions has no answer: the file goes back, or it goes nowhere.

📄 Official circular