On Saturday 17 October 2026, France lived through its worst day of street violence in years. What began as student-led marches against the cost of living and cuts to public services, joined by trade unions, farmers and the Yellow Vests, ended with burning city halls, looted boutiques and 1,200 arrests. In Limoges, a 140-year-old city hall was largely destroyed by fire; in Marseille, black-clad groups broke into city hall; in Lyon, protesters torched the tourist office. In Paris, Reuters reporters watched organised groups smash the windows of a Lacoste store, try to force the Galeries Lafayette department store and loot an SFR mobile phone shop, while cars burned across the capital. President Emmanuel Macron vowed that those responsible would be prosecuted and punished, and the Interior Minister put the turnout at around 550,000 people nationwide. For the thousands of foreigners who live in, work in or were simply visiting France that weekend — tourists, exchange students, business travellers, journalists — the shock was double: caught between rioters and riot police, some were hit by tear gas, stun grenades or rubber-bullet launchers. Four days before those riots, on 15 October 2026, the Versailles administrative court of appeal handed down a ruling that now reads like a manual for everything that happens next: it rejected a €68,043 claim from a man hit by a 40 mm rubber bullet during a 2015 crowd-control operation in Argenteuil, and in doing so it restated, point by point, when French police may use force, when the State pays, and what evidence decides a case. This guide explains that ruling and the remedies around it, step by step, for any foreigner hurt by French police during the October 2026 unrest.
I. Rubber bullets against protesters: what French law allows and what the Versailles ruling of 15 October 2026 decides
A. Tear gas, stun grenades and rubber bullets: when French police are allowed to use force to disperse a crowd
French law starts from a simple definition. “Constitue un attroupement tout rassemblement de personnes sur la voie publique ou dans un lieu public susceptible de troubler l’ordre public.” (Article 431-3 of the Criminal Code). The same article adds the dispersal rule that governed every police charge on 17 October: “Un attroupement peut être dissipé par la force publique après deux sommations de se disperser restées sans effet adressées dans les conditions et selon les modalités prévues par l’article L. 211-9 du code de la sécurité intérieure.” The mirror provision in the Internal Security Code states that an unlawful assembly “peut être dissipé par la force publique après deux sommations de se disperser demeurées sans effet” (Article L. 211-9 of the Internal Security Code), and it carves out the exception that matters most when a demonstration turns violent: “les représentants de la force publique appelés en vue de dissiper un attroupement peuvent faire directement usage de la force si des violences ou voies de fait sont exercées contre eux ou s’ils ne peuvent défendre autrement le terrain qu’ils occupent.” In plain terms, two orders to disperse must normally come first, but officers under attack — and on 17 October, more than 150 of them were injured, some pelted with stones, bricks, fireworks and acid-filled bottles according to police accounts relayed by Reuters and AFP — may use force immediately.
Beyond dispersal, the use of weapons obeys two famous principles: absolute necessity and strict proportionality. Officers “peuvent, outre les cas mentionnés à l’article L. 211-9, faire usage de leurs armes en cas d’absolue nécessité et de manière strictement proportionnée” (Article L. 435-1 of the Internal Security Code), in the five situations the article lists, including attacks on life or physical integrity. The police code of ethics says the same thing in even broader language: “Le policier ou le gendarme emploie la force dans le cadre fixé par la loi, seulement lorsque c’est nécessaire, et de façon proportionnée au but à atteindre ou à la gravité de la menace, selon le cas.” and “Il ne fait usage des armes qu’en cas d’absolue nécessité et dans le cadre des dispositions législatives applicables à son propre statut.” (Article R. 434-18 of the Internal Security Code). And the crowd-control regulation is categorical: “L’emploi de la force par les représentants de la force publique n’est possible que si les circonstances le rendent absolument nécessaire au maintien de l’ordre public dans les conditions définies par l’article L. 211-9. La force déployée doit être proportionnée au trouble à faire cesser et son emploi doit prendre fin lorsque celui-ci a cessé.” (Article R. 211-13 of the Internal Security Code). Anyone assessing footage from 17 October — tear gas volleys in Paris, water cannon in Bologna-style scenes, rubber-bullet fire, and at least one protester whose hand was torn off after handling a stun grenade — must measure it against those three sentences, not against outrage alone.
The criminal side mirrors this architecture. Ordinary violent injury causing more than eight days of total incapacity for work is punished by “trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende”: “Les violences ayant entraîné une incapacité totale de travail pendant plus de huit jours sont punies de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende.” (Article 222-11 of the Criminal Code). When the same offence is committed by an officer, the penalty rises: “L’infraction définie à l’article 222-11 est punie de cinq ans d’emprisonnement et de 75 000 euros d’amende lorsqu’elle est commise” in the listed aggravated circumstances, including “Par une personne dépositaire de l’autorité publique ou chargée d’une mission de service public dans l’exercice ou à l’occasion de l’exercice de ses fonctions ou de sa mission” (Article 222-12 of the Criminal Code). For lighter injuries the rule is parallel: “Les violences ayant entraîné une incapacité de travail inférieure ou égale à huit jours ou n’ayant entraîné aucune incapacité de travail sont punies de trois ans d’emprisonnement et de 45 000 euros d’amende lorsqu’elles sont commises” in the same aggravated circumstances, again including commission “Par une personne dépositaire de l’autorité publique ou chargée d’une mission de service public dans l’exercice ou à l’occasion de l’exercice de ses fonctions ou de sa mission” (Article 222-13 of the Criminal Code). An officer who strikes or shoots without lawful justification therefore faces the same criminal courts as anyone else, with heavier penalties because of the uniform. That is not theory: on 17 June 2025 the criminal chamber of the Court of Cassation reviewed a case in which an officer stood trial for exactly this offence, and the judgment records that “M. [J] [Z] a été poursuivi des chefs de violences par une personne dépositaire de l’autorité publique suivie d’une incapacité n’excédant pas huit jours et subornation de témoin, devant le tribunal correctionnel qui, par jugement du 4 mai 2023, l’a déclaré coupable de la première infraction et condamné à trois mois d’emprisonnement avec sursis” (Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, 17 June 2025, No. 24-84.706). A police officer convicted of violence, given a three-month suspended prison sentence: the criminal route against unlawful police force exists, it is used, and it convicts.
B. Why the Versailles court threw out a 68,043-euro rubber-bullet claim: bystanders, participants and the heavy-fault bar
The decision every foreign victim should now read is four days old. “M. H… relève appel du jugement du 22 décembre 2023 par lequel le tribunal administratif de Cergy-Pontoise a rejeté sa demande tendant à la condamnation de l’Etat à lui verser la somme de 68 043,33 euros en réparation des préjudices qu’il impute à un tir de lanceur de balles de défense (LBD) de diamètre 40 effectué par les forces de police durant la nuit du 13 au 14 juillet 2015, lors d’une opération de maintien de l’ordre à Argenteuil (Val-d’Oise).” (Administrative Court of Appeal of Versailles, 5th chamber, 15 October 2026, No. 24VE00500). A man hit by a 40 mm rubber-bullet launcher during a 2015 Bastille-night crowd-control operation asked the State for €68,043.33; the first-instance court refused; he appealed; on 15 October 2026 — two days before France exploded — the appeal court confirmed the refusal. The reasoning is a complete map of State liability for crowd control.
First, the court restates the two-track liability system. “L’utilisation par les forces de l’ordre d’une arme présentant un danger exceptionnel est susceptible d’engager la responsabilité de l’administration sans faute, en cas de dommage causé à des personnes tierces à une opération de maintien de l’ordre et, pour faute simple, en cas de dommage causé aux personnes visées par une telle opération.” In other words: bystanders can be compensated without any fault being proved if the weapon is exceptionally dangerous; people targeted by the operation must prove ordinary fault. But — and this is the point that will govern most October 2026 claims — the 40 mm rubber-bullet launcher does not qualify: it is, in the court’s words, an intermediate-force weapon whose normal, strictly regulated use carries only a very small probability of death, serious injury or permanent damage: “présente une probabilité, certes non nulle mais demeurant très faible, de provoquer une issue fatale, des blessures graves ou des lésions permanentes. L’emploi de cette arme n’est dès lors pas susceptible d’engager la responsabilité de l’Etat en raison de risques exceptionnels.” No no-fault liability for rubber bullets, then. Second, the general rule for crowd-control operations is severe: “La responsabilité de l’Etat en raison d’une opération de maintien de l’ordre ne peut être engagée qu’en cas de faute lourde.” Not any mistake — a heavy fault.
Third, and most instructive for foreigners who were actually in the crowd, the court drew a hard line between bystanders and participants — and it drew it with CCTV footage. The national police inspectorate (IGPN) had pulled the city cameras of Argenteuil: the claimant, who first said he had nothing to do with the violent group, was filmed among several dozen people throwing projectiles, lighting the fuses of firework mortars aimed at officers, then standing with the group as it smashed a site hut and looted a bank cash machine. The court concluded: “l’intéressé ne peut être regardé comme ayant la qualité de tiers à l’opération de maintien de l’ordre eu égard à sa présence répétée et prolongée parmi le groupe d’individus objet de cette opération.” His no-fault claim therefore failed: “Il résulte de ce qui précède que M. H… n’est pas fondé à rechercher la responsabilité sans faute de l’Etat pour risque.” His fault claim failed too, because the single rubber-bullet shot — aimed at the lower limbs, fired from a significant distance, at a man seen lighting a pyrotechnic device amid hours of continuous violence against officers — showed, in the court’s finding, “il ne résulte pas de l’instruction que celles-ci auraient fait un usage illégal et disproportionné du lanceur de balles de défense, ni fait, alors que le tir en cause visait les membres inférieurs et a été effectué à une distance importante, un usage non conforme aux conditions d’emploi de cette arme de maintien de l’ordre, et ainsi commis une faute lourde dans l’opération de rétablissement de l’ordre public de nature à engager la responsabilité de l’Etat.”
Fourth, the court closed the last door the claimant tried: State liability for damage caused by mobs themselves. “L’Etat est civilement responsable des dégâts et dommages résultant des crimes et délits commis, à force ouverte ou par violence, par des attroupements ou rassemblements armés ou non armés, soit contre les personnes, soit contre les biens.” (Article L. 211-10 of the Internal Security Code). The court recalled that “Cette responsabilité s’étend à la réparation des dégâts et dommages provoqués par l’intervention des forces de l’ordre contre les membres d’attroupements ou rassemblements” — so injuries inflicted by police while fighting a mob can in principle fall under this guarantee — but added the decisive filter: “ne peuvent être regardés comme étant le fait d’un attroupement ou rassemblement au sens de ces dispositions, les actes délictuels ne procédant pas d’une action spontanée dans le cadre ou le prolongement d’un attroupement ou rassemblement mais d’une action préméditée et organisée par un groupe structuré à seule fin de les commettre”. Because the Argenteuil violence was a prepared, concerted attack, the guarantee did not apply. Foreigners hurt on 17 October should note the double lesson: the L. 211-10 guarantee can cover police-intervention injuries during genuine riots, but courts examine, video by video, whether the victim stood with a structured violent group.
II. Hurt in the October 2026 riots as a foreigner: the complaint and compensation path after Versailles
A. Filing a criminal complaint from inside or outside France: the Article 85 civil-party route and what the June 2025 conviction proves
French criminal procedure is open to everyone on French soil, tourist or resident alike. The key that forces the justice system to act even when the prosecutor stays silent is the complaint with civil-party status: “Toute personne qui se prétend lésée par un crime ou un délit peut en portant plainte se constituer partie civile devant le juge d’instruction compétent en application des dispositions des articles 52, 52-1 et 706-42.” (Article 85 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The same article sets the admissibility lock that every foreign victim must know: “la plainte avec constitution de partie civile n’est recevable qu’à condition que la personne justifie soit que le procureur de la République lui a fait connaître, à la suite d’une plainte déposée devant lui ou un service de police judiciaire, qu’il n’engagera pas lui-même des poursuites, soit qu’un délai de trois mois s’est écoulé depuis qu’elle a déposé plainte devant ce magistrat, contre récépissé ou par lettre recommandée avec demande d’avis de réception, ou depuis qu’elle a adressé, selon les mêmes modalités, copie à ce magistrat de sa plainte déposée devant un service de police judiciaire”. Concretely: first file a simple complaint — at any police station or gendarmerie, or by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt to the public prosecutor of the place of the facts (Paris, Lyon, Marseille, Limoges, Lille, Nantes, Bordeaux, Toulouse, Strasbourg or Nice for the 17 October unrest) — keep the receipt, and if nothing happens within three months, or if the prosecutor formally declines, the investigating judge must take the case. The registered-letter route is tailor-made for victims who have flown home: it creates proof of filing from abroad without a second trip to France.
Time does not erase these cases quickly. “L’action publique des délits se prescrit par six années révolues à compter du jour où l’infraction a été commise.” (Article 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). A foreigner hurt on 17 October 2026 keeps the criminal route for six full years, which matters for injuries whose consequences — an eye, a hand, a jaw — take months to stabilise. And the June 2025 conviction quoted above proves the route is not decorative: an officer tried for violence as a person holding public authority, injuries under eight days, was found guilty and given a suspended prison term (Court of Cassation, criminal chamber, 17 June 2025, No. 24-84.706). Parallel avenues exist alongside the courts: the IGPN (and the IGGN for gendarmerie cases) investigates officers, as it did with the Argenteuil cameras in the Versailles case, and its reports feed both criminal files and administrative trials. A foreign victim can report facts to the IGPN in writing, in English if needed, while the criminal complaint runs its course; the two tracks reinforce each other rather than competing.
Evidence discipline decides these files, as Versailles shows with brutal clarity: the claimant lost largely because city cameras contradicted his first statement. The foreign victim’s checklist is therefore the opposite of improvisation. Get medical attention immediately and ask for a detailed medical certificate describing every lesion, however small, with the number of days of incapacity (ITT) stated by the doctor — the ITT figure drives the criminal classification (Articles 222-11 to 222-13) and the compensation thresholds below. Photograph injuries, torn clothing, impact marks and the exact location; save transport tickets, hotel bills and phone location data proving where you stood; note the time to the minute; collect names and phone numbers of witnesses before the crowd disperses; keep the clothes you wore unwashed; back up every video to cloud storage the same evening. If officers stop you, stay calm, state that you wish to contact your consulate and a lawyer, and do not sign any statement you do not understand. And tell the truth about where you were: Versailles proves that investigators will pull the cameras, and a contradicted victim loses both the criminal and the compensation case. Readers looking for the broader pre-October framework on police-weapon injuries at French demonstrations can usefully compare this general guide to compensation and criminal complaints after police-weapon injuries at French protests, which this article updates with the 15 October 2026 ruling and the October 2026 facts.
B. Getting compensated: State liability, the L. 211-10 mob-damage guarantee and victim compensation under Article 706-3
Three distinct money routes exist, and a well-advised victim walks all three in parallel. The first is State liability before the administrative courts, on the Versailles map: no-fault compensation if you were a genuine bystander hurt by an exceptionally dangerous weapon; fault-based compensation if you can show a heavy fault in the operation — a shot at close range, aimed at the head, fired after the trouble ended, or force used without the two warnings where they were required. Remember the Versailles court’s sentence: “La responsabilité de l’Etat en raison d’une opération de maintien de l’ordre ne peut être engagée qu’en cas de faute lourde.” Rubber bullets, classed as intermediate non-lethal force, will almost never open the no-fault door; your file must therefore document disproportionality with the same precision the IGPN uses — distances, angles, timing, orders given or not given, and medical proof of where the projectile struck.
The second route is the State guarantee for mob damage, and it is the most promising one for the night of 17 October precisely because that night was, undeniably, a riot. “L’Etat est civilement responsable des dégâts et dommages résultant des crimes et délits commis, à force ouverte ou par violence, par des attroupements ou rassemblements armés ou non armés, soit contre les personnes, soit contre les biens.” (Article L. 211-10 of the Internal Security Code). The Versailles court confirms that “Cette responsabilité s’étend à la réparation des dégâts et dommages provoqués par l’intervention des forces de l’ordre contre les membres d’attroupements ou rassemblements”, so a foreigner struck by a police projectile while officers fought looters can invoke the guarantee — provided the violence around him was the spontaneous action of a crowd rather than, as in Argenteuil, “une action préméditée et organisée par un groupe structuré à seule fin de les commettre”. The AFP’s account of 17 October — half a dozen masked young men attacking shops “in an organised way”, disconnecting cameras before smashing windows — shows how seriously courts will test this filter, street by street. Your statement and your evidence must therefore place you credibly outside any predatory group: a tourist crossing Paris, a student leaving a campus, a journalist covering the march — each with tickets, timestamps and witnesses to prove it.
The third route is the victim-compensation commission (CIVI), which pays even when the officer is never identified or convicted: “Toute personne, y compris tout agent public ou tout militaire, ayant subi un préjudice résultant de faits volontaires ou non qui présentent le caractère matériel d’une infraction peut obtenir la réparation intégrale des dommages qui résultent des atteintes à la personne, lorsque sont réunies les conditions suivantes” (Article 706-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure), with the standard gateway that the facts “soit ont entraîné la mort, une incapacité permanente ou une incapacité totale de travail personnel égale ou supérieure à un mois”. A rubber-bullet fracture, an eye injury, a hand destroyed by a grenade — the exact injuries Reuters documented on 17 October — routinely cross that one-month threshold, which is why the medical certificate’s ITT figure, set by an independent doctor and consistent across examinations, is the single most valuable document in the file. Keep every medical bill, including treatment received after returning home, with translations: the commission assesses full personal injury, and foreign medical costs documented with receipts belong in the claim. One practical warning closes the loop back to Versailles: none of these three routes survives a false first statement. The Argenteuil claimant was caught by cameras admitting, step by step, what he first denied; the administrative judges quoted the IGPN report at length and rejected everything. File early, describe precisely where you stood and what you did, and let the videos corroborate you instead of burying you.
Conclusion
The night of 17 October 2026 will generate hundreds of injury files, and the Versailles ruling of 15 October 2026 will sit on the desk of every judge who reads them. Its message is two-sided and every foreign victim should hold both sides at once. On one side, French law is genuinely protective: police force is fenced in by absolute necessity and strict proportionality, officers who cross the line face aggravated criminal penalties and are convicted, as the June 2025 suspended-sentence case shows, and the State guarantees compensation for riot damage including injuries caused by police intervention. On the other side, the bar is high and the cameras are everywhere: rubber bullets are classed as intermediate force that does not trigger no-fault liability, crowd-control fault must be heavy, mob-damage guarantees exclude organised predatory violence, and a victim filmed inside a violent group loses the bystander status that unlocks the best remedies. The foreigner who gets medical proof on day one, files a registered complaint, reports to the IGPN, preserves every ticket and video, and tells investigators exactly where he stood gives himself the strongest possible file under this framework — whether the projectile came from a rifle in Paris, Lyon, Marseille, Limoges or Lille.