KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Can a U.S. Living Trust Control French Property After the Grantor Dies? Recognition, Forced Heirship, and Estate Tax

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Can a U.S. Living Trust Control French Property After the Grantor Dies? Recognition, Forced Heirship, and Estate Tax

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

An American who places a French home, apartment, or French-company interest into a U.S. living trust may expect the successor trustee to take control immediately after death. That expectation is often incomplete. A living trust is a U.S. estate-planning arrangement: the grantor transfers or declares property for a trustee to administer for beneficiaries. The document can coordinate management and distribution, but it does not by itself answer every French question about title, succession, tax, or the authority to sell.

The French notary handling the estate must separate at least four issues. First, what exactly is located in France: a directly owned building, shares in a société civile immobilière (SCI, a French civil real-estate company), a bank account, or a contractual right? Second, which law governs the succession as a whole and the forced-heirship rights of children? Third, how does France classify and tax the trust arrangement? Fourth, what evidence allows the trustee, beneficiaries, and notary to sign a deed or release funds? A U.S. trust may be valid under the law chosen in its instrument while still requiring French formalities and a tax analysis before the French asset can be distributed or sold.

This article explains the practical path for an American family after the grantor dies. It focuses on a settled-life problem, not on visa procedure: recognition of a U.S. living trust, French forced heirship, the France–U.S. estate-tax treaty, trust reporting, and remedies when a beneficiary or co-heir blocks the French property. The starting point is the trust instrument and the chain of title, not the label “living trust.”

For the broader framework on protected heirs, the compensatory levy, and the treaty, see our guide to French inheritance law for American families. This article goes further into the trust-specific documents and decisions that determine whether a French property can actually be administered or sold.

I. Can a U.S. living trust own or control French property after the grantor dies?

A. What a living trust does in the United States—and what a French notary must verify

In the usual American revocable living trust, the grantor creates the trust during life, may act as the initial trustee, and can generally amend or revoke it. The successor trustee takes office after the triggering event defined by the document, often the grantor’s incapacity or death. The beneficiaries then receive distributions under the trust terms. The arrangement can make administration easier inside the United States, but it does not convert a French deed into a U.S. asset or remove the need to prove who may act in France.

The French tax code has its own definition. Article 792-0 bis of the Code général des impôts describes a trust, for French tax purposes, as a set of legal relationships created under the law of a state other than France, by a “constituant” or settlor, to place assets under the control of an “administrateur” or trustee for beneficiaries or a defined purpose. Those French terms are not a complete translation of every U.S. trust concept. They are functional categories used to determine reporting and taxation.

The notary will usually request the complete trust instrument, every amendment or restatement, schedules of assets, certificates of trusteeship, the death certificate, any will, family records, and documents proving the French asset. A short certification of trust may establish authority for an American bank, but it may not answer the French notary’s questions about revocability, beneficial rights, successor trustees, governing law, distribution standards, and the identity of all persons whose rights may be affected. Sending only the first page of the trust or a generic trustee certificate creates avoidable delay.

The property record matters just as much as the trust. If the deceased owned a French house directly, the notary must reconcile the trust transfer with the deed and the French land-publicity record. If the property was acquired through an SCI, the trust may have received shares rather than the building itself. The notary then needs the SCI articles, share ledger, transfer approvals, shareholder register, financial statements, and any pledge or loan documents. A trustee who has authority over shares is not automatically authorised to sign a deed selling an asset owned by the SCI. Corporate capacity, trust capacity, and succession capacity must align.

The same distinction applies to a French bank account, life-insurance policy, or securities account. The institution may have its own death procedures and may require an authenticated trustee certificate, a tax form, or a notarial act. A trust instruction to distribute cash does not override a bank’s duty to establish the person entitled to receive it. It also does not decide whether the distribution is a gift, an inheritance, the termination of an interest, or a payment of income under French tax law.

French private international law does not reject every foreign estate-planning device merely because France uses different concepts. In Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, September 27, 2017, appeal no. 16-17.198, a case involving a California family trust and French assets, the Court held that a foreign law ignoring the French reserve is not automatically contrary to international public policy. Its published formulation is: “Une loi étrangère désignée par la règle de conflit qui ignore la réserve héréditaire n’est pas en soi contraire à l’ordre public international français et ne peut être écartée que si son application concrète, au cas d’espèce, conduit à une situation incompatible avec les principes du droit français considérés comme essentiels.” In English, the practical lesson is that the result depends on the concrete family situation, the applicable law, the connection with the foreign state, and the effect on the heirs. The existence of a French home does not create a universal rule that a trust must fail; neither does a U.S. trust guarantee that French children have no claim.

That decision should be read with the older but still useful reasoning in Cour de cassation, First Civil Chamber, December 4, 1990, appeal no. 89-11.352. The Court stated: “Dans les successions internationales, la réserve se calculant sur chaque masse de biens soumise à une loi différente, les héritiers réservataires peuvent retenir toute la réserve que leur donne la loi française de la situation des immeubles.” This does not mean that every French property is automatically distributed under French succession law in every modern case. It does mean that a French immovable and an American trust cannot be analysed by looking only at the American distribution instructions. The asset’s location, the succession’s governing law, and the way the asset was held all matter.

For that reason, a French notary may ask an American trustee to obtain a legal opinion on the trust’s governing state law. The opinion should identify the trust’s current terms, explain whether title passed to the trustee, state when the successor trustee acquired authority, and distinguish legal title from a beneficiary’s expectancy. It should not simply say that the trust is valid in the United States. The French file needs a bridge between that conclusion and the particular French asset.

The notary will also check whether a will or trust contains an effective choice of succession law. Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 allows a person to choose the law of the state whose nationality the person possesses, and says that the choice must be express in a disposition of property upon death or demonstrated by its terms. An American national may therefore have a potentially important choice-of-law tool. The regulation governs succession law, not French transfer taxes, U.S. income-tax classification, trust reporting, or the formalities for recording a French conveyance. A trust clause should never be treated as a treaty or a tax exemption.

B. Why title, succession law, and the trust instrument are separate questions

A reliable post-death review follows a sequence. The first step is an asset map. List every French address, parcel, mortgage, shareholding, account, insurance policy, rental contract, and entity interest. For each item, record the registered owner, the person named in the trust schedule, the person who signed the transfer, the date of transfer, and the documents filed in France. The question is not merely “Was the property in the trust?” It is “What legal right was transferred, to whom, and was that transfer effective against third parties in France?”

The second step is to freeze assumptions about authority. The successor trustee may have administrative powers under the U.S. document, yet the French notary may require a formal deed of notoriety, a succession declaration, a court order, or an additional instrument before accepting a transfer or sale. A “deed of notoriety” is the French notarial document identifying the persons called to the estate. It is not interchangeable with an American probate order or a trustee affidavit. If the trust has two successor trustees, both may need to sign. If one declined or died, the file must prove the replacement.

The third step is to read the trust for operative, not marketing, language. The reviewer should locate the revocation power, the definition of incapacity, the successor-trustee provisions, the power to sell real property, the beneficiary class, the distribution standard, the termination date, the spendthrift clause, and any direction regarding foreign property. A revocable trust in which the grantor retained full control may be treated differently from an irrevocable discretionary trust funded for children. A trust that names a beneficiary but leaves distribution to trustee discretion is different from one that gives a fixed right on a stated date.

The French courts have repeatedly treated those distinctions as material in tax cases. In Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, March 31, 2009, appeal no. 07-20.219, the Court upheld the inclusion of assets in the wealth-tax base where the grantor’s trust was revocable and the grantor could obtain income or principal. The published summary focuses on the grantor’s continuing right to enjoy and dispose of the assets. That case is not a universal classification rule for every living trust. It is a warning that a revocable arrangement preserving control may be analysed as retained ownership for a French tax question.

By contrast, Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, November 18, 2020, appeal no. 18-14.242, dealt with the timing of a transfer from a trust under the version of Article 750 ter then applicable. The Court stated that, for assets placed in a trust, the taxable event was the transfer of ownership resulting from distribution of the trust assets to the final beneficiary at closure, which could occur after the settlor’s death. The official decision states: “le fait générateur des droits de mutation à titre gratuit est constitué par le transfert de propriété, qui, s’agissant de biens placés dans un trust, s’opère par l’effet de la distribution de l’actif du trust au bénéficiaire final, au jour de sa clôture, laquelle peut être postérieure au décès du constituant.” The decision shows why the trust timetable and the death date cannot be collapsed into one event. Its precise result also depended on the trust terms and the legislation before the current trust regime; it must be used as a framework, not as a shortcut.

The fourth step is to determine the law governing the succession as a whole. Under Regulation 650/2012, an express nationality choice can be important where an American has made a carefully drafted disposition. The U.S. national should not assume, however, that the mere use of a California, New York, Delaware, or other state-law trust proves a valid election for the entire succession. The document must satisfy the applicable form and the choice must be read with the deceased’s habitual residence, the nature of the assets, and any applicable mandatory provisions.

The formal validity of a French will illustrates the problem. Article 970 of the French Civil Code says: “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme.” An olographic will is a will written, dated, and signed entirely by the testator. Article 1007 further provides that “Tout testament olographe ou mystique sera, avant d’être mis à exécution, déposé entre les mains d’un notaire.” These rules do not turn an American trust into a French will. They explain why a notary must identify the instrument being relied upon, its form, and the route by which it can be put into effect in France.

The fifth step is to test what happens if no one can sign. Once a French property belongs to several heirs, it may be held in “indivision,” meaning shared ownership before partition. Article 815-5 of the Civil Code provides that an indivisor may seek judicial authorisation to carry out an act alone when another indivisor’s refusal jeopardises the common interest. Article 815-5-1 provides a separate route for a sale requested by holders of at least two-thirds of the undivided rights, with notice and court safeguards. The official Article 815-5 and Article 815-5-1 should be read with the property’s actual title. These remedies apply after the ownership and succession positions are established; they do not automatically give a trustee power that the trust document or French registration does not provide.

Before an American beneficiary signs a sale or distribution document, the file should therefore answer these questions in writing:

  • Is the French asset held directly, through an SCI, or through another vehicle?
  • Was the trust transfer recorded, and what evidence proves its effectiveness against third parties?
  • Is the trust revocable, irrevocable, discretionary, or fixed at the relevant date?
  • Who is the current trustee, and what instrument proves that person’s authority?
  • Does a will or trust contain an express and formally valid choice of succession law?
  • Are there children, a spouse, or other persons whose protected rights must be assessed?
  • Is the asset to be distributed, sold, retained, or placed into indivision?

If the answer to one of these questions is missing, the family should pause the distribution long enough to obtain the missing document. A fast U.S. trust administration does not necessarily produce a fast French closing.

II. What happens to forced heirship, French tax, and the estate process?

A. How French forced heirship and a choice of law limit the trust

French forced heirship is known as the “réserve héréditaire.” It is not a general promise that every child receives a French house. It is a protected portion of the succession when the relevant law makes the child a reserved heir and the child accepts the succession. Article 912 of the Civil Code defines it as: “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent.” The remaining freely disposable portion is the “quotité disponible,” the part the deceased could give away by gift or will.

If French succession law governs the relevant calculation, Article 913 sets the ordinary proportions: “Les libéralités, soit par actes entre vifs, soit par testament, ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre.” In plain terms, one child generally means a one-half reserve, two children a two-thirds reserve, and three or more children a three-quarters reserve, leaving the corresponding quotité disponible. The calculation is made on the legally relevant estate, after the applicable rules on gifts, debts, and aggregation have been identified. It is not safe to apply the percentages to the appraised value of the French home alone without reconstructing the estate.

The 2021 compensatory-levy mechanism is narrower than many summaries suggest. Article 913 includes a condition referring to a deceased person or at least one child who, at death, is an EU national or habitually resides in an EU Member State, together with the absence of a protective reserve mechanism under the foreign law applicable to the succession. The statutory language begins: “Lorsque le défunt ou au moins l’un de ses enfants est, au moment du décès, ressortissant d’un Etat membre de l’Union européenne ou y réside habituellement”. An American citizen living in the United States does not satisfy that condition merely because the family owns a home in France. The notary must check nationality, habitual residence, the applicable succession law, the date of death, and the wording of the article before describing a claim as a compensatory levy.

The choice of law can change the result. The 2017 California-trust decision, appeal no. 16-17.198, involved children who argued that the California law should be rejected because it did not know the French reserve. The Court did not adopt an automatic rule. It examined the concrete effect, the absence of a demonstrated situation of economic precariousness or need, and the close connection with California. An American family should not cite that decision as proof that a French child can always be excluded. Nor should a child cite the French reserve as proof that every trust distribution is void. The legal question is fact-sensitive.

If the trust or a separate will contains a valid Article 22 choice of American national law, the choice may govern the succession as a whole. It can reduce the risk of a fragmented analysis in which different assets are treated under different succession laws. It does not decide whether the trust transferred French title, whether French tax is due, whether a French mortgage must be discharged, or whether a French company’s articles restrict a share transfer. It also does not permit the instrument to ignore the mandatory form of every French act needed to sell or publish a transfer.

When a child believes that a disposition exceeds the disposable portion under the law that applies, the claim is usually described as an action for reduction. Article 921 of the Civil Code gives the action to reserved heirs, their heirs, or successors, and sets a five-year period from the opening of the succession or, in the alternative, two years from knowledge of the infringement, subject to an absolute ten-year limit from death. The current Article 921 must be checked against the date of death and the precise relief sought.

The financial remedy is not necessarily the return of the same house. Article 924 states that when a gift exceeds the disposable portion, the recipient must indemnify the reserved heirs up to the excessive portion. Its operative language is: “Lorsque la libéralité excède la quotité disponible, le gratifié, successible ou non successible, doit indemniser les héritiers réservataires à concurrence de la portion excessive de la libéralité”. The trust may therefore remain relevant even where the dispute ultimately becomes a monetary claim. A trustee who distributes before identifying potential reserved-heir claims can create a tracing, recovery, or indemnity dispute.

The French property’s ownership history also affects the remedy. If the grantor contributed a building to an SCI and the trust holds the shares, the heirs may argue about the value and succession treatment of the shares rather than claim that they directly own the building. If the trust transferred an asset but the transfer was never made effective against third parties, the parties may litigate the legal consequences of the registration gap. If several heirs now own the building, the indivision procedures in Articles 815-5 and 815-5-1 may be relevant to a sale, but a forced sale does not erase a dispute over reserve, valuation, or tax.

A practical reserve analysis should therefore include a family tree, the deceased’s nationality and habitual residence, the trust and will dates, every lifetime gift, the value and location of assets, the beneficiary designations, and evidence of acceptance or renunciation. An American family should not assume that a U.S. “per stirpes” clause has the same effect as a French hereditary entitlement. It may express the intended distribution while leaving the French legal classification to the applicable succession law and the notary’s review.

B. How French inheritance tax, trust reporting, and blocked property are handled

Civil succession and tax are separate analyses. Even if an American court or trust adviser concludes that the trustee owns legal title, France can apply its tax rules to a transfer involving French property, a French-resident deceased person, a French-resident beneficiary, or a trust holding assets within the French tax jurisdiction.

Article 750 ter of the Code général des impôts is a central starting point for gift and inheritance tax. In broad terms, it can expose worldwide assets where the donor or deceased was French tax resident, French-situs assets where that person was not French tax resident, and, subject to the statutory residence test, worldwide assets received by a beneficiary who was French tax resident for at least six of the preceding ten years. The residence of the American heir, the residence of the deceased, the place of the asset, and the trust’s distribution mechanics must be documented separately.

Article 792-0 bis contains a specific trust regime. It provides that the transfer by gift or succession of property or rights placed in a trust is subject to French transfer taxes according to the relationship between the transferor and the beneficiary, with special rules where beneficiaries are not individually determined or where assets remain in the trust. The current article says, in its opening tax rule, “La transmission par donation ou succession de biens ou droits placés dans un trust”. The detail matters: the relevant taxable event, the identity of the beneficiary, the nature of the trust, and the applicable table can affect the result. A distribution after the grantor’s death is not automatically tax-free because the property was placed in trust years earlier.

The 2020 decision in appeal no. 18-14.242 is useful on timing, but the current statutory regime must be applied to the current facts. The Court’s reasoning treats the final distribution at trust closure as a possible transfer-of-ownership event. A trustee who waits several years to close the trust should not assume that the death date alone resolves the French filing obligation. Conversely, a beneficiary should not assume that every payment of income is a succession distribution. The trust accounting, governing law, and beneficiary rights must be reviewed transaction by transaction.

Trust reporting is an additional obligation. Article 1649 AB of the tax code requires the administrator of a trust meeting the statutory connection to France to declare constitution, modification, extinction, terms, persons involved, and, in specified cases, the market value of assets. The current text of Article 1649 AB refers to a trust whose settlor or at least one beneficiary is French tax domiciled or that includes property or a right located in France. A U.S. trustee should not wait for a French beneficiary to discover the issue after a notary asks for a tax certificate. The trustee, the beneficiary, and the French tax adviser should identify who is legally responsible for each declaration and how the information will be obtained from U.S. custodians.

Article 990 J creates another trust-related tax question by subjecting individual settlors or beneficiaries of a trust within Article 792-0 bis to a levy at the highest rate referred to in Article 977, with the taxable assets depending in part on French tax residence and the location of assets. The official Article 990 J should be read in its current version. This levy is not the same as inheritance tax and is not a substitute for the transfer-tax analysis. It can become relevant while the grantor is alive or while the trust continues, which is why a post-death closing cannot be planned solely around the French succession return.

The France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention helps coordinate taxing rights, but it does not validate a trust or determine forced heirship. France’s official tax guidance confirms that the convention signed on November 24, 1978 and amended in 2004 applies to qualifying estates and gifts, with the amendment entering into force on December 21, 2006. See the French tax administration’s BOFiP guidance on the France–U.S. estate and gift tax convention.

The Treasury’s published protocol explains the credit mechanism. It states: “Double taxation shall be avoided in the following manner:” and, for a decedent domiciled in France, that “France shall tax the entire property comprising the estate or the gift” while allowing a deduction for qualifying U.S. tax paid, subject to limits. The U.S. Treasury protocol also contains rules for U.S. credits, marital deductions, information, and the effect of fiscal domicile. The treaty may reduce double taxation; it does not turn a French-situs asset into an exempt asset, remove the need for a French declaration, or answer whether the trust’s transfer was a gift, an inheritance, or a later distribution.

The U.S. side must be reviewed separately. A U.S. citizen or resident may have federal estate-tax, gift-tax, foreign-trust, foreign-account, or information-reporting obligations even when France has first taxing rights. The French notary’s statement of value is not a substitute for a U.S. estate return. The trustee should coordinate the French succession file with the U.S. estate attorney and tax preparer so that dates, valuations, beneficiary classifications, and tax paid are consistent. A treaty credit usually requires reliable information and does not arise from a verbal estimate of French tax.

The most common practical blockage is not a dramatic refusal of recognition. It is an incomplete file. The notary may be unable to sign because the trustee’s appointment is unclear, the trust schedule omits the French asset, the deceased’s will conflicts with the trust, an apostille or certified translation is missing, an SCI’s share transfer was not approved, a mortgage remains open, or a beneficiary’s address and tax residence cannot be proved. The family should obtain a written list of missing documents and respond item by item instead of sending repeated general emails.

If one beneficiary refuses to cooperate, first determine whether that person has a legal veto. A person who is only a discretionary beneficiary may not have the same power as a trustee or registered co-owner. A co-heir in indivision may have rights that a trust beneficiary does not. If the refusal threatens a common interest, Article 815-5 may support a request for judicial authorisation. If holders of at least two-thirds of the undivided rights seek a sale, Article 815-5-1 may provide a route through notice to the absent or dissenting co-owner and the judicial process. The court will not use those provisions to decide a hidden trust question without evidence of title and capacity.

The closing checklist should be assembled before the trustee promises a distribution date:

  • the complete trust instrument, amendments, schedules, and governing-law clause;
  • death, marriage, divorce, adoption, and birth records establishing the family chain;
  • the will, any express succession-law election, and proof of its form;
  • the French deed, land-publicity extract, mortgage statement, and property valuation;
  • SCI articles, share certificates, transfer records, and corporate approvals if an SCI is involved;
  • the successor-trustee acceptance and evidence of every trustee’s signing authority;
  • the deceased’s and each beneficiary’s tax residence for the relevant periods;
  • prior gifts, trust distributions, French tax returns, trust declarations, and U.S. estate-tax data;
  • a written calculation of reserve, disposable portion, transfer tax, treaty credit, and any annual trust levy;
  • a plan for distribution, sale, or indivision, including the documents the notary will sign.

That file allows the legal team to distinguish a genuine recognition problem from a missing administrative document. It also preserves evidence if an heir later challenges the distribution. A trustee should avoid distributing the French property first and asking whether French law recognises the distribution afterward. The safer order is to classify the asset, establish authority, determine succession law, calculate protected rights, resolve tax filings, and then execute the notarial transfer or sale.

Conclusion

A U.S. living trust can be an effective part of an American family’s estate plan, but it is not a self-executing French title document. After the grantor dies, the successor trustee must prove authority, identify the French asset, and coordinate with the notary. A direct home, an SCI interest, and a bank account do not create the same legal problem.

The trust’s distribution terms must then be tested against the succession law selected or otherwise applicable. French forced heirship may matter, but it is not triggered by an oversimplified rule that every American-owned French home is subject to the French reserve. The California decision in appeal no. 16-17.198 shows the importance of the concrete effect and the succession’s real connections. Articles 912, 913, 921, and 924 show what is at stake if French reserve rules apply. The compensatory-levy condition must be checked rather than assumed.

Tax has its own pathway. Articles 750 ter, 792-0 bis, 1649 AB, and 990 J can produce obligations at different times and for different reasons. The France–U.S. estate-tax convention can coordinate credits and taxing rights, but it does not replace French title formalities, trust reporting, or a U.S. filing review. The family should assemble the trust, property, family, residence, valuation, and tax documents before any irreversible distribution. That preparation is usually the quickest route to a defensible sale or transfer.

📄 Official circular