KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
EU General Court Keeps Tobacco Billionaire Kesaev on Russia Sanctions List: Why Paper Sell-Offs Fail and What It Means for Frozen Assets in France

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

EU General Court Keeps Tobacco Billionaire Kesaev on Russia Sanctions List: Why Paper Sell-Offs Fail and What It Means for Frozen Assets in France

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 2 September 2026, the General Court of the European Union closed another door in the Kesaev file. Sitting as its Tenth Chamber, the Luxembourg court dismissed in full the action brought by Russian billionaire Igor Kesaev against the March 2024, September 2024 and March 2025 renewals of his EU asset freeze, ordered him to bear the costs, and confirmed that distributing cigarettes in Russia is enough to stay on the sanctions list. The judgment, registered as case T-296/24 and published on EUR-Lex under reference ECLI:EU:T:2026:523, is the second defeat for the same applicant after the 4 September 2024 ruling in cases T-290/22 and T-763/22, which is now under appeal. For international readers, the interest of the ruling goes well beyond one fortune estimated by Forbes at several billion dollars. The court validated the broadest listing criterion in the Russia sanctions regime, treated the transfer of holdings to a personal foundation with open distrust, and restated that fundamental rights arguments do not dissolve a freeze decided on foreign policy grounds. For anyone with frozen funds, blocked transactions or enforcement proceedings in France, the message is concrete: paper reorganizations do not unlock accounts, creditors cannot seize frozen money without prior clearance from the French Treasury, and each six-month renewal of the EU lists is a deadline to act, not a routine to watch passively.

I. Why does a cigarette distributor stay on the EU sanctions list?

A. How the substantial revenue sector test catches businesses far from the battlefield

The Council first listed Igor Kesaev on 8 April 2022, then renewed the listing in September 2022, March and September 2023, March and September 2024, and March 2025. The statement of reasons stayed remarkably stable: Kesaev is described as co-owner and president of Mercury Group, linked to Megapolis Group, presented as the largest tobacco distributor in Russia, with a net worth assessed by Forbes at 3.6 billion US dollars, and qualified both as an influential businessman active in Russia and as a businessperson operating in economic sectors that provide a substantial source of revenue to the government of the Russian Federation, held responsible for the annexation of Crimea and the destabilization of Ukraine. The present action, lodged on 5 June 2024 and later extended to the September 2024 and March 2025 renewal acts, attacked those three renewal decisions under Council Regulation (EU) No 269/2014 and Council Decision 2014/145/CFSP, the two instruments that form the backbone of the EU individual sanctions regime against Russia.

The decisive legal hook is the third limb of listing criterion g, found in Article 2(1)(g) of Decision 2014/145/CFSP and mirrored in Article 3(1)(g) of Regulation No 269/2014, which covers businesspersons operating in Russia who are active in economic sectors providing a substantial source of revenue to the Russian government. Kesaev’s defense tried to shrink that hook. His core submission was that only the production and import of tobacco generate excise revenue for the Russian state, so that only producers and importers, and not a distributor such as Megapolis Group, could belong to a sector supplying substantial revenue within the meaning of the criterion. In his reading, only persons or entities that themselves pay such revenue into the state budget could be treated as operating in the relevant sector.

The General Court rejected that reading at points 161 to 163 of the judgment, in reasoning that every sanctions practitioner should read closely. The court recalled the wording of the criterion: it is the economic sector, and not the individual or company whose name appears on the lists, that must constitute a substantial source of revenue for the government of the Russian Federation, citing its earlier Zubitskiy ruling of 20 November 2024, case T-1074/23, point 124. Whether Megapolis Group itself pays excise duties is therefore, in the court’s words, without influence on the finding that its distribution business operates inside the tobacco sector. Point 162 of the judgment of 2 September 2026 states the rule plainly: under the third limb of criterion (g), the substantial-revenue test applies to the economic sector as a whole, not to the turnover or tax payments of the listed person or company itself. The sector-wide lens then survived the numbers test. Kesaev argued that tobacco excise represented only about 1.33 percent of the Russian federal budget in 2021 and that other sectors contribute more. The court answered at point 164 that this figure is a sufficient indication of the importance of the tobacco sector in the Russian economy, that revenue from the sector may be substantial even if other sectors yield more, and that the criterion does not require the Council to weigh the whole Russian tax base but only to verify whether the sector where the applicant operates provides substantial revenue to the Russian government.

The rest of the judgment systematically dismantles the constitutional-style pleas. The plea of illegality raised against criterion g failed. The alleged breach of the presumption of innocence and of rights of the defense, built on the idea that the criterion creates an irrebuttable presumption allowing the Council to sidestep its burden of proof, was set aside. The discrimination plea, invoking Article 21(1) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights over an alleged distinction based on social origin, was rejected. On proportionality, the court recalled at points 107 to 109, by reference to Bank Melli Iran and Bank of Industry and Mine, that property rights and the freedom to conduct a business are not absolute prerogatives and may be restricted, under Article 52(1) of the Charter, where the limitation is provided by law, respects the essence of those rights, and is necessary to meet objectives of general interest recognized by the Union. None of the pleas succeeded, so point 200 states that the action must be rejected in its entirety, and points 201 and 202 apply Article 134(1) of the Rules of Procedure: the unsuccessful applicant pays the costs. The operative part is blunt: the action is dismissed and Igor Albertovich Kesaev is ordered to pay the costs.

The prohibitions that flow from such a listing matter daily for banks, buyers and counterparties. Article 2 of Regulation No 269/2014 freezes every fund and economic resource belonging to, owned, held or controlled by a person or entity named in Annex I, and separately bans making any funds or economic resources available, directly or indirectly, to or for the benefit of those listed persons and entities. That double lock, freezing what exists and banning any fresh supply, is directly applicable in every Member State, including France, without any national transposition. Readers who followed the opposite outcome in the Inter Rao Lietuva ruling of 3 September 2026, where an EU freeze was struck down, now have the full picture: courts refuse guilt by ownership cascade, but they equally refuse escape by sector hair-splitting. The line is drawn case by case, on evidence, and the side that documents its position wins.

B. Why moving shares to your own foundation does not buy delisting

The second lesson of the Kesaev judgment concerns divestments, the classic move of listed businesspersons who reorganize their holdings and then ask to be removed from the lists. The file shows that in December 2023 the applicant transferred his stakes in Mercury Retail entities to his personal foundation, a move reported by several Russian retail trade outlets whose articles the Council placed on the file as evidence. The court did not treat that reorganization as a game changer. At point 106, the judges held that nothing in the wording or purpose of the third limb of criterion g forces the applicant to sell his holdings: such a sale is not a requirement imposed by the listing but an autonomous decision taken after listing so that the name can be removed, and that consequence, even if it follows from the listing, reflects the applicant’s own choice and cannot as such amount to an interference with his property rights and freedom to conduct a business. Even assuming such a sale were indirectly required and limited those rights, the court added, the limitation would still have to be tested against the general interest objectives of the Union rather than treated as automatically unlawful.

The practical signal to listed persons is stark. Transfers to related parties, family vehicles or personal foundations, executed after listing and without a genuine, verifiable and lasting loss of control and economic benefit, are weighed by the Council with distrust and do not by themselves demonstrate that the listing criterion has ceased to be met. The EU system does offer a real procedural path: recital 8 of Regulation No 269/2014 explains that designated persons receive the grounds for listing and may submit observations, and that the Council reviews its decision whenever observations or substantial new evidence call for it. But that review rewards substance, not paperwork. The Council re-examines every listing at each renewal, currently on a six-month cycle, and the General Court checks for manifest errors of assessment, respect for rights of the defense, the duty to state reasons, and proportionality. An applicant who arrives with press clippings about an internal reshuffle, while Forbes still ranks him among Russia’s billionaires and the operating business still distributes tobacco at national scale, fails that test exactly as Kesaev did.

There is also a timing discipline that foreign clients often discover too late. An annulment action before the General Court must be lodged within two months of notification or publication of the contested act, and it can only attack the acts in force at the time, extended where needed to later renewals. Kesaev’s 2024 action had to be adapted in December 2024 to catch the September 2024 renewal acts, and the March 2025 acts were folded into the same case. Miss the window and the renewal becomes final even if the underlying business has genuinely changed. An appeal lies to the Court of Justice, but only on points of law, which is the posture of Kesaev’s first case after the September 2024 defeat. For families and holding structures with assets in several Member States, the consequence is that delisting strategy must be built as a litigation file from day one: audited proof of real disposal, loss of voting rights and board control, arm’s length pricing, independent buyers, and filings synchronized with the Council’s renewal calendar, not a last-minute reshuffle followed by a hopeful letter.

II. What does the ruling change for frozen money and court cases in France?

A. How French courts handle frozen assets when no seizure moves without Treasury clearance

Because EU regulations apply directly, a freeze decided in Brussels bites in Paris the moment the name appears in the Official Journal. French law then organizes the domestic relay. Article L. 562-3 of the Monetary and Financial Code empowers the Minister for the Economy to order, for six months renewable, the freezing of funds and economic resources belonging to, held or controlled by persons designated under resolutions adopted under Chapter VII of the United Nations Charter or acts taken under Article 29 of the Treaty on European Union or Article 75 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Alongside that ministerial tool, Article L. 562-2 of the same Code provides the equivalent national freeze against terrorist financing, and Article L. 562-1 defines the key notions of funds, economic resources and freezing used across the chapter. The obligations then fall on the private sector: Article L. 562-4 requires banks, companies and individuals on national territory to apply freeze measures and non-availability orders without delay and to inform the Minister for the Economy immediately, a duty that extends to French-seated entities for their activity abroad, including branches and free provision of services. The mirror prohibition sits in Article L. 562-5, which forbids making funds or economic resources available, directly or indirectly, or using them for the benefit of frozen persons. Breach is not an administrative technicality: Article L. 574-3 punishes with the penalties of the Customs Code anyone, from the obligated entities and their managers to the frozen persons themselves, who evades the resulting obligations or obstructs their implementation. That architecture explains why French banks freeze first and ask questions later, and why any transaction touching a listed name needs a lawyer before it needs a banker.

The sharpest recent statement of French judicial practice came from the Court of Cassation itself on 5 February 2026. In its second civil chamber ruling no. 23-15.936, opposing a Kuwaiti construction company to the Libyan Investment Authority, the court approved the Paris Court of Appeal’s refusal to authorize a saisie-attribution, the French garnishment that immediately appropriates the seized claim, against funds frozen under EU Regulation No 2016/44 on Libya. The holding deserves attention from every creditor of a sanctioned debtor. The court ruled that no enforcement measure which would take frozen funds out of the debtor’s estate, or even merely grant the pursuing creditor a right of preference, may proceed without prior authorization from the Director of the Treasury, the national authority designated under Article 11(2) of the Regulation. It added that the freeze affects seizure not only in its effectiveness but in its very validity, and that the Treasury authorization is required upstream, not only later at the payment stage. The judgment then neutralized the most common objection: the Sapin 2 Act of 9 December 2016, which introduced prior authorization by the enforcement judge for conservatory and enforcement measures against property of foreign states, codified in Article L. 111-1-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures, did not remove the administrative precondition. By virtue of the primacy of Union law, the administrative authorization must come before the judge’s authorization, and an enforcement judge who authorized a measure on frozen funds without proof of Treasury clearance would itself breach the EU Regulation. In the absence of a release issued by the Directorate General of the Treasury, the enforcement judge could not authorize the garnishment on frozen assets. The appeal was rejected and the pursuing company ordered to pay costs and 3,000 euros under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

That 2026 ruling did not come from nowhere. On 10 July 2020, the Court of Cassation sitting as full assembly, in the Bank Sepah cases nos. 18-18.542 and 18-21.814, referred two questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union on Iranian frozen assets claimed by American creditors holding Delaware judgments. The French supreme court asked whether the EU Iran Regulations, including Regulation (EC) No 423/2007, Regulation (EU) No 961/2010 and Regulation (EU) No 267/2012, must be read as barring, without prior authorization from the national competent authority, a measure with no attributive effect such as a French judicial security or protective seizure on frozen assets, and whether it matters that the claim predates UN Security Council Resolution 1737 (2006) and has nothing to do with the Iranian nuclear and ballistic program. The referral shows the method French courts apply to freeze litigation: where the EU text is unclear, Luxembourg decides, and national judges wait. Taken together, Bank Sepah 2020 and the Libyan Investment Authority ruling of February 2026 draw a coherent French doctrine. Protective and enforcement measures on frozen assets need prior Treasury authorization, the judge comes second, and any shortcut invalidates the seizure. Our earlier analysis of the EU debate over seizing Russian state assets immobilized at Euroclear for a reparations loan sits at the state level of the same problem; Kesaev and the French garnishment cases show the individual level, where the freeze is already solid and the litigation turns on authorizations.

B. What should a listed person, a creditor or a bank in France do this week

For a listed person holding accounts, securities, real estate or company shares in France, the Kesaev ruling resets the strategy. First, treat every six-month renewal as a litigation deadline: submit observations and genuinely new evidence to the Council before the renewal, because the Council must review its decision in light of observations and substantial new evidence, and a thin file at renewal stage becomes a thin case before the General Court. Second, stop believing in cosmetic exits. The December 2023 transfers to a personal foundation did not move the Luxembourg judges, and French law adds its own weapons against sham arrangements: Article 1341-2 of the Civil Code allows a creditor to have acts performed by the debtor in fraud of its rights declared unenforceable against it, and the older Article 1341-1 preserves the oblique action for neglected rights. A genuine exit means a real buyer, a real price, a real loss of voting power and board seats, verified by documents a judge can trust, and it must be completed and evidenced before the renewal under attack, not announced afterwards. Third, map the French administrative path in parallel with the Luxembourg action: where funds are needed for legal defense, maintenance or court-ordered payments, requests for Treasury authorization must be filed early with full supporting documents, because the February 2026 case law makes that clearance the gateway to everything else. Fourth, calendar the two-month annulment deadline from each contested act and prepare the adaptation of claims to later renewals, exactly as Kesaev’s counsel had to do in December 2024, or the newest freeze survives by default.

For a creditor owed money by a frozen person or entity, the order of battle is now settled by the Court of Cassation. Do not start with the enforcement judge. Start with the Directorate General of the Treasury and obtain the prior authorization to pursue frozen funds or resources, identifying precisely the assets, the claim and the measure envisaged. Only then seize the enforcement judge, because without that clearance the saisie-attribution or protective seizure is not merely ineffective but invalid, and the debtor will get it set aside with costs. Frame the request honestly: the 2026 ruling covers measures that would move value out of the estate and even measures conferring a mere preference, so structuring the seizure to look harmless does not avoid the authorization. Where the debtor is a foreign state or a state entity such as a sovereign fund, add the Sapin 2 layer and seek the enforcement judge’s authorization under Article L. 111-1-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures as well, remembering that the judicial authorization comes after, never instead of, the Treasury clearance. Creditors holding foreign judgments should also verify exequatur requirements early, since the authorization analysis assumes an enforceable title, and should budget for the reality that authorized enforcement on frozen assets remains exceptional, slow and closely supervised.

For banks, payment institutions, insurers, notaries and company directors operating in France, the compliance program writes itself from Articles L. 562-4, L. 562-5 and L. 574-3. Screen continuously against the consolidated EU lists, because a client clean in the morning can be listed by an afternoon regulation. Freeze without delay upon designation, block both existing balances and incoming flows, refuse any direct or indirect making available, and notify the Minister for the Economy immediately through the proper channels. Document every step, since criminal exposure under the Customs Code penalties attaches not only to willful circumvention but to obstructing implementation, and managers and agents are expressly within the scope. Treat every request to restructure holdings, move shares to foundations or trusts, change beneficiaries or reroute payments for a listed client as a red flag requiring independent legal review before execution, because facilitating a sham can combine sanctions breach with fraud exposure. And when in doubt between the commercial pressure of a major client and the text of the Regulation, remember the arithmetic of the Kesaev file: a 3.6 billion dollar fortune, elite counsel, five constitutional-style pleas, and a unanimous dismissal with costs. The freeze held. Build files, calendars and authorizations as if a judge will read them, because one will.

Conclusion

The 2 September 2026 Kesaev judgment will not make headlines like a battlefield map, but it will shape sanctions practice for years. It confirms that the sector test reaches far beyond arms, oil and banks into any industry that feeds substantial revenue to the Russian state, tobacco included. It establishes that paper divestments to related vehicles do not erase the listing criterion and that the decision to sell is the applicant’s own choice, not a violation of property rights. And it aligns with the French enforcement doctrine restated in February 2026: frozen means frozen until the Treasury says otherwise, and judges come second. Read together with the Inter Rao Lietuva ruling striking down a cascade freeze the very next day, the message of the first week of September 2026 is balanced and demanding. Courts will annul freezes built on assumption, and they will uphold freezes built on evidence. Listed persons must therefore litigate with documents rather than declarations, creditors must clear the Treasury before seizing, and banks must freeze first and verify continuously. In that environment, early advice is not a luxury but the difference between a file that moves and assets that sleep.

📄 Official circular