KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
A Former ICC Judge Just Won the Nobel Peace Prize as the Court Faces US Sanctions: What France Does When an Atrocity Suspect Is on French Soil

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

A Former ICC Judge Just Won the Nobel Peace Prize as the Court Faces US Sanctions: What France Does When an Atrocity Suspect Is on French Soil

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 9 October 2026, the Norwegian Nobel Committee awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to Navanethem “Navi” Pillay, a former judge of the International Criminal Court, for her efforts to promote peace and international law. A few hours later, the United States imposed institutional sanctions on the very Court where she once sat. Three days after that, on 12 October 2026, France publicly condemned those sanctions, recalled that a French judge of the Court was among the sanctioned, and reaffirmed what it called its unfailing support for the ICC. For readers outside France, the sequence raises a practical question that goes beyond ceremony: when a person suspected of genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes is present on French soil, what does France actually do? French law gives two answers, and both are backed by recent decisions of the Cour de cassation sitting in its most solemn formation. France surrenders suspects to The Hague through a fast-track judicial procedure, and, where no international court or foreign State claims the suspect, it prosecutes them itself before its own courts. This article explains both tracks, the conditions that govern them, and the rulings that define their limits.

I. Why the Nobel Prize to a Former ICC Judge Is a Legal Event for France

A. Who was crowned in Oslo, and for what record?

Navi Pillay, 85, is a South African jurist whose career spans the layers of modern international criminal justice. According to the Nobel Committee and international press coverage of the award, she was the first woman to open a law practice in Natal under apartheid, later served on South Africa’s High Court, sat as a judge on the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and then on the International Criminal Court, served as United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008 to 2014, and until recently chaired the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory. The Nobel Committee presented the prize as a reminder that the rule of law, national and international, underpins the system set up to keep peace, and warned that the system of international law is under tremendous pressure while its institutions are under attack. The Committee made no reference in its citation to any particular State, but the context was unmistakable: the laureate received the news in Nuremberg, in the building where the first international criminal tribunal sat in 1945 and 1946, while the Court she once served was under American sanctions.

Part of the laureate’s recent record explains why the choice resonated so strongly. The UN commission she chaired concluded that genocide had been committed in Gaza, a finding the concerned State dismissed as scandalous, according to Reuters’ reporting of October 2026. Whatever assessment one makes of that report, its legal status is clear: a commission of inquiry documents facts and offers legal characterisations, but it neither indicts nor convicts anyone. Only a competent court can do that. That distinction is precisely where France enters the picture, because France is both a State Party to the Rome Statute and one of the few countries whose courts actively try atrocity crimes committed abroad by foreigners against foreigners. Before examining the French machinery, it is worth noting how Paris positioned itself politically in the days surrounding the prize.

B. Why France took sides three days after the prize

On 12 October 2026, the French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs published a statement condemning the new American sanctions targeting the International Criminal Court, available on the Ministry’s official website. Paris noted that after a series of targeted measures adopted on the basis of an American presidential decree of 6 February 2025, which had already hit judges and staff including French judge Nicolas Guillou, it was now the institution itself that was targeted. France called on the United States to withdraw the sanctions and reaffirmed its unfailing support for the ICC and its staff, describing the Court’s role as essential in fighting impunity. The statement added that France, together with its European partners and the other States Parties to the Rome Statute, was actively working to ensure that the Court can continue fulfilling its mission independently and impartially, so that justice is rendered to the victims of the most serious crimes.

For an international reader, three points in that statement matter more than the diplomatic vocabulary. First, France treats cooperation with the ICC as a standing commitment, not a discretionary gesture: support is described as unfailing and tied to the Rome Statute, the treaty France ratified. Second, Paris links its position to European coordination, which means any suspect, counsel or victim dealing with France will face a consistent European posture rather than an isolated national stance. Third, the reference to a sanctioned French judge sitting on the Court shows that the sanctions dispute is not abstract for France: it touches French nationals serving international justice. Words, however, do not arrest suspects. The rest of this article turns to what French courts and prosecutors concretely do when an atrocity suspect is found in France, starting with surrender to The Hague.

II. What France Concretely Does When an Atrocity Suspect Is on French Soil

A. How France surrenders suspects to the ICC: a judicial fast track measured in days

France does not treat a request from the International Criminal Court as ordinary mutual legal assistance. The Code of Criminal Procedure devotes a full chapter to cooperation with the Court, and its logic is one of speed and judicial control, with the Paris anti-terrorism prosecution office at the centre. The starting point is article 627-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which provides that “Les demandes d’entraide émanant de la Cour pénale internationale sont adressées aux autorités compétentes en vertu de l’article 87 du statut en original ou en copie certifiée conforme accompagnées de toutes pièces justificatives. Ces documents sont transmis au procureur de la République antiterroriste qui leur donne toutes suites utiles.” The full text is published on Légifrance. In urgent cases the documents may even be sent directly to that prosecutor by any means. In practice, this means an ICC request lands on the desk of a specialised magistrate in Paris who is legally bound to act on it, not on a diplomatic circuit where it could wait.

The same chapter organises protective measures for assets and evidence. Article 627-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that “L’exécution sur le territoire français des mesures conservatoires mentionnées au k du paragraphe 1 de l’article 93 du statut est ordonnée, aux frais avancés du Trésor et selon les modalités prévues par le présent code, par le procureur de la République antiterroriste. La durée maximale de ces mesures est limitée à deux ans.” The provision is published on Légifrance. Freezing orders, seizures and other conservatory measures requested by the Court can therefore be executed in France within a capped and renewable framework, with the Treasury advancing the costs. For victims’ counsel and for defence lawyers alike, this is a concrete point: ICC-ordered asset freezes can bite on French bank accounts and real property, and they follow French procedural forms once ordered.

The core of the procedure is the surrender itself, and here French law is deliberately faster than classic extradition. There is no governmental phase and no ministerial discretion: the decision belongs to the judiciary. Article 627-8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that “Lorsque la chambre de l’instruction constate qu’il n’y a pas d’erreur évidente, elle ordonne la remise de la personne réclamée et, si celle-ci est libre, son incarcération à cette fin.” The text is published on Légifrance. The review is intentionally narrow: the investigation chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal checks for manifest error and refers every other question to the ICC itself. It must rule within fifteen days of the wanted person’s appearance before it, and if there is an appeal on points of law, the criminal chamber of the Cour de cassation decides under similarly tight constraints. Readers familiar with French extradition practice will recognise the contrast: in surrender to the ICC, France has removed the political filter entirely.

The timetable continues after the order becomes final. Article 627-10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that “La personne réclamée est remise dans un délai d’un mois à compter du jour où cette décision est devenue définitive”, failing which the person must be released, and it requires that the decision, the place and date of surrender and the length of detention served be brought to the knowledge of the Court. The provision is published on Légifrance. A one-month surrender deadline backed by release is a powerful discipline on the authorities, and it is also a guarantee for the person sought: detention pending surrender to the ICC cannot drift. Anyone arrested in France on an ICC warrant should therefore expect three things in quick succession: presentation to the Paris investigation chamber, a ruling within about two weeks on manifest error only, and transfer within a month once the ruling is final, with release as the sanction for delay. The broader mechanics of arrest and detention following an international alert in France, including the strict time limits that protect the person arrested, are examined in detail in our analysis of arrest, detention and release deadlines after an international alert in France, and the specific path of ICC suspects arrested on French soil is traced in our account of the first ICC trial of a suspect whose surrender engages French cooperation duties.

Two practical consequences follow for an international audience. First, France is a high-compliance transit and residence State: an ICC suspect who sets foot in France faces a specialised prosecutor, a fifteen-day judicial review and a one-month transfer clock, with no political authority able to block the process. Second, the mirror image is equally important: because France surrenders so readily to The Hague, the question of whether France could instead try the suspect itself only arises where no international court and no foreign State claims the person. That second track, prosecution before French courts under universal jurisdiction, is where the Cour de cassation has built its most significant recent case law.

B. How France prosecutes atrocity crimes itself: universal jurisdiction and its judge-made boundaries

Where the ICC does not claim a suspect and no State requests extradition, France may try the person before its own courts for crimes committed abroad by a foreigner against foreign victims. This is universal jurisdiction, and its flagship provision is article 689-11 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In its current version, stemming from the reform of 20 November 2023, the article provides that “Hors les cas prévus au sous-titre Ier du titre Ier du livre IV pour l’application de la convention portant statut de la Cour pénale internationale, ouverte à la signature à Rome le 18 juillet 1998, peut être poursuivie et jugée par les juridictions françaises toute personne soupçonnée d’avoir commis à l’étranger l’une des infractions suivantes : 1° Le crime de génocide défini au chapitre Ier du sous-titre Ier du titre Ier du livre II du code pénal ; 2° Les autres crimes contre l’humanité définis au chapitre II du même sous-titre Ier ; 3° Les crimes et les délits de guerre définis aux articles 461-1 à 461-31 du même code.” The full text is published on Légifrance. Three cumulative locks then frame the provision. First, presence: “La personne soupçonnée doit avoir une résidence habituelle sur le territoire français, celle-ci se définissant par un lien de rattachement suffisant avec la France”, assessed on the length and conditions of presence, the reasons for it, the person’s stated wish to settle or remain, and family, social, material or professional ties. Second, prosecutorial monopoly: “La poursuite de ces crimes ne peut être exercée qu’à la requête du procureur de la République antiterroriste”, the Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor, to the exclusion of direct complaints by victims before the investigating judge. Third, subsidiarity: prosecution is possible only “si aucune juridiction internationale ou nationale ne demande la remise ou l’extradition de la personne”, and the prosecution office must verify the absence of ICC proceedings, of any other competent international court’s request, and of any extradition request by another State. The two tracks of this article are therefore articulated: surrender first, French prosecution only in the gap.

The substantive definitions sit in the Criminal Code. Article 211-1 defines genocide as “le fait, en exécution d’un plan concerté tendant à la destruction totale ou partielle d’un groupe national, ethnique, racial ou religieux, ou d’un groupe déterminé à partir de tout autre critère arbitraire, de commettre ou de faire commettre, à l’encontre de membres de ce groupe, l’un des actes suivants : – atteinte volontaire à la vie ; – atteinte grave à l’intégrité physique ou psychique ; – soumission à des conditions d’existence de nature à entraîner la destruction totale ou partielle du groupe ; – mesures visant à entraver les naissances ; – transfert forcé d’enfants”, punishable by life imprisonment, as published on Légifrance. Crimes against humanity and war crimes are defined in the neighbouring chapters. These definitions matter far beyond theory, because the Cour de cassation has made the comparison between French definitions and the law of the State where the facts occurred the decisive test of French jurisdiction.

The leading saga concerns Syria, and it proceeded in two acts. In the first, the criminal chamber ruled on 24 November 2021, on appeal no. 21-81.344, in a case against a Syrian national investigated in Paris for torture, crimes against humanity and complicity. The Court held that the double-criminality condition of article 689-11 required the foreign legislation to contain an offence with a constituent element relating to an attack on a civilian population pursuant to a concerted plan: “Dès lors, l’exigence posée par l’article 689-11 du code de procédure pénale, selon laquelle les faits doivent être punis par la législation de l’Etat où ils ont été commis, inclut nécessairement l’existence dans cette législation d’une infraction comportant un élément constitutif relatif à une attaque lancée contre une population civile en exécution d’un plan concerté.” Since Syria had not ratified the Rome Statute and its criminal code punished murder, torture and rape but not crimes against humanity as such, the Court quashed the Paris investigation chamber’s ruling and declared the French courts without jurisdiction. The decision, published in the Bulletin and available on Légifrance, threatened to close the French forum for Syrian cases altogether.

The second act reversed the outcome. Seized in its most solemn formation, the Assemblée plénière ruled on 12 May 2023, on appeal no. 22-80.057, that the 2021 ruling was to be set aside and rejected the appeal against the Paris investigation chamber: “DÉCLARE nul et non avenu l’arrêt rendu par la chambre criminelle de la Cour de cassation le 24 novembre 2021, qui a cassé et annulé, en toutes ses dispositions, l’arrêt de la chambre d’instruction de la cour d’appel de Paris du 18 février 2021 ; REJETTE le pourvoi”. The full decision is available on Légifrance. On the substance, the plenary Court held that the double-criminality condition “ne requiert pas une identité de qualification et d’incrimination”, relying on the parliamentary debates preceding the 2010 statute: “il suffit que les faits soient pénalement sanctionnés ; or tous les États du monde incriminent l’assassinat et le meurtre.” Ordinary murder, torture and rape provisions in the foreign code therefore satisfy the condition, even where that code knows no category of crimes against humanity. The same day, in a second plenary ruling on appeal no. 22-82.468 concerning alleged torture, enforced disappearances and war crimes attributed to members of an armed group active in Syria between 2012 and 2018, the Court likewise “REJETTE le pourvoi”, as published on Légifrance. Together, the two 12 May 2023 rulings reopened and secured the French forum for Syrian atrocity cases: French courts are competent even though Syria is not a party to the Rome Statute and does not criminalise crimes against humanity as such.

The most recent plenary milestone extends the lesson to the intersection of sanctions and criminal liability. On 25 July 2025, the Assemblée plénière ruled on appeal no. 24-84.071 against a dual French-Syrian national, a former governor of the Syrian central bank personally listed under European Union sanctions, investigated in Paris since December 2022 for complicity in crimes against humanity and war crimes, aggravated money laundering and participation in a criminal association. The Court “REJETTE le pourvoi”, leaving the prosecution intact, as published on Légifrance. The message for compliance officers, bankers and executives is direct: an EU sanctions listing and a French atrocity-crimes investigation can run in parallel against the same person, on connected facts, and the criminal track survives the highest judicial review. Combined with the April 2026 Paris verdict in the case of a French multinational tried for its dealings in Syria, a matter widely reported by the French press, the picture is consistent: France is one of the few jurisdictions where operating in or with a regime accused of atrocities can lead simultaneously to administrative freezing and to a criminal trial.

Three practical lessons emerge for anyone concerned by these proceedings, whether as counsel, victim, witness or executive. First, presence in France is the trigger: habitual residence, understood as a sufficient link, founds French jurisdiction, and the assessment is factual and forward-looking, covering the foreseeable duration of stay. Second, the Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor holds the keys: no French atrocity prosecution begins without that office, and the office must first confirm that neither the ICC nor any other court or State claims the person, which makes the surrender track of this article’s first part the mandatory first check. Third, the double-criminality objection has been defused for the core crimes: since May 2023, the defence cannot defeat French jurisdiction merely by showing that the State where the facts occurred has no autonomous offence of crimes against humanity. The American sanctions now targeting the ICC do not alter any of this: they are unilateral measures of a non-State Party, while French jurisdiction over atrocity crimes flows from French statutes and from the Rome Statute France ratified, a posture Paris expressly confirmed on 12 October 2026. The interaction between American sanctions on international courts and France’s statutory cooperation framework is analysed in our study of the United States sanctions against the ICC and France’s cooperation duties, and the American sanctions toolbox as it affects persons in France is examined in our analysis of sanctions, cooperation and the blocking statute.

Conclusion

The Nobel Peace Prize awarded to Navi Pillay on 9 October 2026 changes no statute and creates no jurisdiction. Its significance lies elsewhere: at the very moment the institutions of international justice are sanctioned and publicly attacked, the prize restates that accountability for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes remains the stated horizon of the international order, and France has positioned itself unambiguously on that side, in writing, on 12 October 2026. For the international reader, the consequence is practical rather than symbolic. France is a State where an atrocity suspect faces two coordinated tracks: rapid judicial surrender to The Hague within weeks, or prosecution before French courts under universal jurisdiction where no other forum claims the person. The Cour de cassation, in plenary formation, has twice confirmed the second track in the last three years, including as recently as July 2025, and Parliament has modernised its conditions while keeping the Paris anti-terrorism prosecutor as gatekeeper. Defence teams should therefore verify, before any travel or residence in France, whether an ICC warrant, a foreign extradition request or a French preliminary inquiry exists, and under which track the person would fall. Victims and associations should address the Paris anti-terrorism prosecution office, the only authority able to open the French track, with facts showing a sufficient French link. Executives and financial institutions operating in high-risk zones should treat EU sanctions listings and French criminal exposure as parallel risks managed under different rules. The law, in short, is already in place; the Nobel week of October 2026 simply recalled why France intends to keep applying it.

📄 Official circular