Kohen Avocats — Customs law
French customs lawyer in Paris: customs disputes and criminal defence
Inspection by French customs, seizure, undeclared cash, disputed import: we examine the official records, the duties claimed and the prosecution to prepare your response.
A search visit, a customs detention, a summons or a notice of recovery (avis de mise en recouvrement)? Keep every document and its date of notification, then send us the documents for review.
Customs law · Paris
Have your case reviewed
Official report (procès-verbal), inventory, detention decision, declaration or settlement proposal: send us the documents and their dates, with any supporting evidence you have.
Customs
Inspection, debt
and defence
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
Understanding your customs case
Customs law · Paris 16th
Have the inspection reviewed, prepare the defence
- Paris Bar
- Customs inspection
- Paris and the Paris region
- Negotiated and contentious
A seized consignment, cash held at the border, a summons or a notice of recovery (avis de mise en recouvrement) each call for a different response. A person placed in customs detention is entitled, in particular, to the assistance of a lawyer, under the conditions and reservations laid down by law (Article L. 432-5 of the French Customs Code (Code des douanes), Article L. 432-6 of the Customs Code). A customs debt is challenged through its own procedure (Article L. 331-1 of the Customs Code).
The review covers the documents you have received, the chronology of the inspection, the goods or funds concerned and the possible responses. You can request a preliminary review for €80 incl. VAT through the form on this page, with a written analysis within 24 working hours, or call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45. Consultation formats and fees are shown in the booking module at the bottom of the page.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Identify the procedure
Inspection, search of premises, customs detention, seizure, assessment or prosecution: start with the official records and their dates.
Reconstruct the facts
Cross-check declarations, invoices, transport documents, agency agreements and evidence of the origin of the funds.
Compare the options
Examine the terms of a settlement proposal and the arguments for a challenge before choosing a response.
Border, business, home
Inspection, search and customs detention: know your rights
The inspection of goods, means of transport and persons is governed by Article L. 422-1 of the Customs Code. The places where these checks may take place at any time include, in particular, airports and railway stations open to international traffic (Article L. 422-2 of the Customs Code). A search of a home is subject to other safeguards.
On the premises
Judicial authorisation, except in flagrante delicto
To investigate the offences referred to in Article L. 423-6 of the Customs Code, authorised officers may search private premises where the items sought are located. They are accompanied by a judicial police officer (OPJ) or an authorised officer. Except for an offence caught in the act (délit flagrant), an order from the liberty and custody judge (JLD) is required. The order mentions the right to call on counsel; doing so does not suspend the operations (Article L. 423-7 of the Customs Code). The search may not begin before six in the morning or after nine in the evening (Article L. 423-14 of the Customs Code).
Two remedies
The order and the operations
The authorisation is challenged before the first president of the court of appeal within fifteen days of its delivery, receipt or service (Article L. 423-13 of the Customs Code). The conduct of the operations is challenged separately, within fifteen days of the delivery or receipt of the official report or the inventory (Article L. 423-19 of the Customs Code). These remedies do not have suspensive effect. Keep every document and the proof of its notification.
A person
Customs detention
A regulated deprivation of liberty
It requires an offence caught in the act (délit flagrant) provided for by the Customs Code, other than the offences in Title III of Book V, punishable by imprisonment, and the needs of the investigation (Article L. 432-1 of the Customs Code). Its initial duration is twenty-four hours; an extension of no more than twenty-four hours requires the written, reasoned authorisation of the public prosecutor (Article L. 432-2 of the Customs Code).
Funds
Temporary detention of cash
A measure concerning the funds
A failure to declare may lead to the temporary detention of the funds under Article L. 152-4 of the French Monetary and Financial Code (Code monétaire et financier). This measure is distinct from the detention of a person, and from confiscation ordered by a court.
The detained person is informed, in particular, of the right, after giving their identity, to answer questions or to remain silent, and of the rights to a lawyer and to a doctor (Article L. 432-7 of the Customs Code, Article L. 432-5 of the Customs Code). The lawyer's involvement may be deferred in the cases defined by Article L. 432-6 of the Customs Code: access should not be presented as absolute.
Detention and official reports
Challenging liability and the evidence
The holder of goods involved in a fraud is deemed responsible for the fraud (Article L. 522-3 of the Customs Code). The defence must address this presumption and the documents supporting it, rather than relying on a mere claim of ignorance.
“He can only rebut this presumption by proving the steps taken to ascertain the nature of the goods transported in order to establish his good faith.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 17 February 2021, No. 20-81.282
This judgment applies former Article 392, whose rule is now set out in Article L. 522-3 of the Customs Code. The Court quashed the acquittal of a lorry passenger on the customs offence because the absence of criminal intent was not enough to establish those steps. It upheld the other provisions, in particular those relating to drugs. The judgment therefore neither merges the offences nor means that every passenger is guilty.
Due diligence
Concrete evidence to gather
Documents checked, loading conditions, instructions received, reservations expressed and exchanges with the principal can be examined to document good faith. The text also provides an exception for public carriers, their employees or agents, who accurately and properly identify their principals so that effective proceedings can be brought against the real offender (Article L. 522-3 of the Customs Code). This exception is not a general immunity for carriers.
Two officers
Findings and statements
The physical findings in official reports drawn up by two officers are conclusive unless challenged through forgery proceedings (inscription de faux). The accuracy and truthfulness of the statements recorded are only presumed true until proven otherwise (Article L. 444-1 of the Customs Code). For official reports drawn up by a single customs officer, the text allows evidence to the contrary (Article L. 444-2 of the Customs Code). The number of signatories and the nature of each statement matter.
“this evidential value does not attach to the deductions and assessments made by those officers.” (our translation)
Cass. com., 22 January 2025, No. 22-23.957
In this judgment concerning imported paper, the Court distinguishes the references noted on the invoices from the deduction that earlier imports concerned the same products as samples taken later. It upholds this distinction in the evidence, while quashing the total annulment of the notice of recovery, because only some of the duties were unjustified. In that case, a partial irregularity was therefore not enough to wipe out the whole debt.
Business and customs broker
Reconstruct the mandate and the declaration
The declarant is liable for the omissions and irregularities referred to in Article L. 522-1 of the Customs Code; the principal faces the same penalties if the declaration follows their instructions. The customs debt is also governed by Article 77 of the Union Customs Code. This debt must be distinguished from criminal liability and from any contractual claim. On representation, the Court points out that “customs representation must be express and cannot be presumed.” (our translation) (Cass. com., 11 February 2026, No. 24-18.748). That decision concerned, in particular, import VAT under the texts applicable to the dispute; the distinction between types of mandate is now laid down in Articles 18 and 19 of the UCC.
Travel and border crossings
Undeclared cash: the fine and what happens to the funds
Cash of €10,000 or more must be declared when carried: Article L. 152-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code covers transfers to or from another EU Member State; Article 3 of Regulation (EU) 2018/1672 governs entry into and exit from the Union. Carrying this amount is not prohibited.
10 000 €
declaration threshold, amount included
50 %
fine provided for the failure to declare
30 days
maximum duration of the initial detention of the funds
90 days
maximum total duration, renewals included
Threshold: Article L. 152-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code and Article 3 of Regulation 2018/1672. Fine and durations: Article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code. Any deposit of the funds (consignation) after ninety days follows a separate regime.
Check the declaration
The route, the amount, the carrier and the information declared must be reconstructed. The regulation also requires the cash to be made available for control, and treats the obligation as unfulfilled where the information is incorrect or incomplete (Article 3 of Regulation 2018/1672).
Identify the detention measure
The failure to declare allows the temporary detention of the entire amount. The reasons are notified. After ninety days, a deposit (consignation) may be authorised by the public prosecutor if the investigation requires it, for up to twelve months from the first day of detention (Article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code, II).
Challenge the penalty
The statutory fine of 50 % does not relieve the court of the duty to consider the scale and seriousness of the facts and the personality of the offender. The judgment of 2 April 2025 quashed the penalties alone, without calling the finding of guilt into question (Cass. crim., 2 April 2025, No. 23-86.683).
Distinguish confiscation
Confiscation is not the automatic consequence of detention: it requires the additional conditions of Article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code, III, relating in particular to other customs offences. The documented origin of the funds must be examined against these conditions, without promising their return.
“the mere finding of a breach of the declaration obligation is sufficient to justify the temporary detention under Article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 16 September 2026, No. 25-84.752
The judgment of 16 September 2026 distinguishes this detention from the regime of Article L. 152-4-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code, which applies, where there are indications of criminal activity, to amounts below the threshold or already declared. It does not say that all undeclared cash can be permanently confiscated. A declaration therefore does not rule out every detention, and the absence of a declaration is not enough to justify every confiscation.
Gather withdrawal statements, sale or loan agreements, proof of income, and documents relating to the owner of the funds and to the project being financed. Keep the decisions on detention, renewal or deposit and their dates.
Business, importer, declarant
Origin, classification and customs value
For non-Union goods liable to import duty and released for circulation in the Union (mise en libre pratique), the debt is incurred when the declaration is accepted, and the declarant is the debtor. In indirect representation, the person on whose behalf the declarant acts is also a debtor (Article 77 of the Union Customs Code). The question of the duties owed is separate from that of the offences.
Describe the product
Technical data sheets, composition, use and commercial references make it possible to discuss the declaration and the comparisons with other goods (Cass. com., 22 January 2025, No. 22-23.957).
Explain the price
The primary basis is the transaction value, that is the price actually paid or payable, adjusted where necessary, under the conditions of Article 70 of the Union Customs Code.
Document the flows
The customs broker's mandate, invoices, payments, transport costs and royalties should be cross-checked against the declaration (Article 19 of the Union Customs Code, Article 71 of the Union Customs Code).
Value
The invoice does not settle the whole question
The additions provided for in Article 71 of the Union Customs Code include, in particular, certain transport costs, assists supplied by the buyer and royalties, under the conditions of the text. If the transaction value method cannot be applied, the secondary methods follow the order and rules of Article 74 of the Union Customs Code. You therefore need to identify the precise ground on which the value is challenged, the amounts used and the documents supporting them.
Declaration
Correcting without promising immunity
Article 173 of the Union Customs Code allows certain amendments on application, but restricts them once the authorities have announced an examination, found an inaccuracy or released the goods. Its paragraph 3 provides for a possibility after release within three years of acceptance, in order to comply with the obligations of the procedure concerned. This mechanism does not, on its own, amount to a general exemption from liability for the declarant (Article L. 522-1 of the Customs Code).
Assessment
Respond on the grounds and the calculations
The person liable is informed of the grounds and amount of the proposed assessment and invited to submit observations under the prescribed procedure (Article L. 311-3 of the Customs Code). Prepare a response that separates the product, the alleged origin, the classification, the value and the calculation of duties, linking each point of disagreement to the documents. An intentional false declaration aimed at obtaining a financial advantage falls, in particular, under Article L. 513-8 of the Customs Code: not every error should be described from the outset as that offence.
Duties and penalties
A fine does not replace the debt
When it upholds the claim for payment of duties compromised or evaded, the court cannot exempt the person liable from paying them, regardless of any penalties (Article L. 611-4 of the Customs Code). This does not prevent you from disputing the existence or calculation of the debt, or from applying for remission or repayment in the cases and under the conditions of Article 116 of the Union Customs Code.
Penalties, settlement and the court
Choosing a response based on the case file
Penalties
Classify the facts before quantifying the risk
The basic regime for prohibited goods and tobacco provides for three years' imprisonment and a fine of twice the value of the goods involved in the fraud (Article L. 513-1 of the Customs Code). Dual-use goods subject to the restrictions of Regulation (EU) 2021/821 fall under a regime of five years and three times the value (Article L. 513-2 of the Customs Code); certain dangerous goods, under a regime of ten years and ten times the value (Article L. 513-3 of the Customs Code). For other goods, intentional smuggling or import without declaration carries five years and twice the value (Article L. 513-4 of the Customs Code). Commission by an organised gang increases the penalties (Article L. 513-5 of the Customs Code). Confiscation is governed in particular by Article L. 514-4 of the Customs Code. These texts are not a scale to be applied without first classifying the facts.
The measure
Mitigation is possible, under conditions
Article L. 521-1 of the Customs Code allows, in particular, tax fines to be reduced below their minimum, taking into account the scale and seriousness of the offence and the personality of the offender. Some confiscations remain mandatory in the cases of Article L. 521-2 of the Customs Code. For an undeclared transfer of capital, the Court points out that “in customs matters, any fine must be reasoned.” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 2 April 2025, No. 23-86.683). That decision applies the provisions in force before the recodification; it does not guarantee any reduction in an individual case.
Agreement
Customs settlement
Check the written scope
The customs authorities may agree a settlement at the request of the offender (Article L. 613-1 of the Customs Code). Once proceedings have been brought, the agreement in principle of the judicial authority is required under the conditions of Article L. 613-2 of the Customs Code. After a final judgment, the tax penalties imposed can no longer be settled (Article L. 613-3 of the Customs Code). The agreement must be examined before any acceptance, including as regards the goods and the duties still in dispute.
Challenge
The appropriate remedies
Distinguish assessment from prosecution
The criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) hears offences (délits) (Article 381 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale)). Disputes concerning the payment, security or repayment of debts collected by customs fall within the jurisdiction of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) (Article L. 332-1 of the Customs Code). Territorial jurisdiction depends on the applicable rules, not merely on the firm's Paris address (Article L. 332-5 of the Customs Code).
3 years
to challenge a notice of recovery, subject to the UCC
6 months
time limit for the administrative reply set by the text
2 months
to bring the case before the court after the reply or the specified silence
15 days
for the remedies specific to searches of premises
Challenge to the notice of recovery (avis de mise en recouvrement, AMR): Article L. 331-1 of the Customs Code. Referral to the court after the reply or the expiry of the six-month period: Article L. 332-2 of the Customs Code. Searches: Article L. 423-13 of the Customs Code and Article L. 423-19 of the Customs Code. Each starting point must be checked against the notifications: these time limits are not interchangeable.
A challenge does not in itself suspend the enforcement of an EU customs decision (Article 45 of the Union Customs Code). For a debt, the request to defer payment and the security required are governed by Article L. 331-2 of the Customs Code, subject to that European text. Do not confuse the time limit for a challenge with permission to defer payment.
- Official reports, inventories and decisions on seizure, detention or deposit.
- Search order and proof of notification of each document.
- Customs declarations, invoices, transport documents and product data sheets.
- The customs broker's mandate, instructions and exchanges with the principal.
- Proof of ownership and origin of the funds or goods.
- Settlement proposal, notice of recovery and summonses.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about French customs law
What are the penalties for smuggling or importing goods without declaring them in France?
The first step is to identify the goods, the facts and their date. For prohibited goods or tobacco, the basic regime provides for three years' imprisonment and a fine of twice the value of the goods involved in the fraud (Article L. 513-1 of the Customs Code). Dual-use goods subject to the movement restrictions of Regulation (EU) 2021/821 and certain dangerous goods follow separate regimes (Article L. 513-2 of the Customs Code, Article L. 513-3 of the Customs Code). For other goods, intentional acts carry five years' imprisonment and twice the value (Article L. 513-4 of the Customs Code).
Commission by an organised gang increases the penalties (Article L. 513-5 of the Customs Code). Confiscation is also provided for (Article L. 514-4 of the Customs Code). These provisions, which result from the recodification of 1 May 2026, do not make it possible to announce an individual sentence before reading the file. The classification, the value used, the circumstances and the possibilities of mitigation must be examined, in particular in the light of Article L. 521-1 of the Customs Code. The old isolated reference to Article 414 no longer correctly describes the law in force.
I was carrying cash without declaring it to French customs: what happens now?
The declaration threshold is €10,000, amount included. Article L. 152-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code concerns transfers to or from another EU Member State; Article 3 of Regulation 2018/1672 covers entry into or exit from the Union. A failure to declare exposes you to the 50 % fine provided for by Article L. 152-4 of the Monetary and Financial Code, and to the temporary detention of the entire amount under the conditions of the same article.
Detention and confiscation are distinct. Detention may be based solely on the failure to declare, as the judgment of 16 September 2026 points out (Cass. crim., 16 September 2026, No. 25-84.752). Confiscation requires the additional conditions of paragraph III of Article L. 152-4. Keep the evidence of the origin, ownership and destination of the funds, as well as every decision handed to you. The judgment of 2 April 2025 also requires reasons for the fine and findings justifying confiscation, without setting aside the finding of guilt (Cass. crim., 2 April 2025, No. 23-86.683).
I did not know what was in the load: am I liable?
A mere claim of ignorance is not enough where the presumption attached to holding the goods applies. Article L. 522-3 of the Customs Code deems the holder of goods involved in a fraud to be responsible. Under former Article 392, the Court of Cassation required proof of the steps taken to ascertain the nature of the goods transported and to establish good faith (Cass. crim., 17 February 2021, No. 20-81.282). It quashed an acquittal on the customs offence that was based solely on the absence of criminal intent.
You therefore need to examine the holding of the goods itself, then the documents and checks actually carried out: loading conditions, instructions, transport documents, reservations and exchanges. Article L. 522-3 provides an exception for public carriers, their employees or agents, where they accurately and properly identify their principals so that effective proceedings can be brought against the real offender. This rule does not remove the need to examine each person's status. The judgment does not mean that every passenger in a vehicle is automatically convicted.
Can French customs search my home or business premises?
Authorised officers may search private premises to investigate the offences referred to in Article L. 423-6 of the Customs Code. They are accompanied by a judicial police officer (OPJ) or an authorised officer. Except for an offence caught in the act (délit flagrant), each search must be authorised by an order of the liberty and custody judge (JLD). The order mentions the possibility of calling on counsel, without the operations being suspended (Article L. 423-7 of the Customs Code). The search may not begin before six in the morning or after nine in the evening (Article L. 423-14 of the Customs Code).
The authorisation may be challenged before the first president of the court of appeal within fifteen days of its delivery, receipt or service (Article L. 423-13 of the Customs Code). A separate remedy concerns the conduct of the operations, running from the delivery or receipt of the official report or the inventory (Article L. 423-19 of the Customs Code). Keep these documents and their dates: a challenge to the order does not replace a challenge to the operations.
Which court hears customs cases in France?
The answer depends on what the case is about. Offences (délits) are tried by the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) (Article 381 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The judicial courts hear disputes concerning the payment, security or repayment of debts collected by customs (Article L. 332-1 of the Customs Code). These debt disputes are therefore not the same as criminal proceedings, even if the documents come from the same inspection.
For the debt, the administrative challenge and the referral to the court follow the steps of Articles L. 331-1 and L. 332-2. The disputes referred to in Article L. 332-5 of the Customs Code fall, territorially, under the court for the place where the notice was issued or where the office or department that established the debt is located. The mere fact that the firm is based in Paris does not give the Paris courts jurisdiction. Finally, the remedies specific to the authorisation and conduct of a search are brought before the first president of the court of appeal (Article L. 423-13 of the Customs Code, Article L. 423-19 of the Customs Code).
Is a French customs fine automatic?
An amount set by law does not allow a court to apply it without giving reasons. For an undeclared transfer of capital, the judgment of 2 April 2025 requires the court to take into account the scale and seriousness of the facts and the personality of the offender (Cass. crim., 2 April 2025, No. 23-86.683). The Court quashed the penalties because the judgment applied 50 % of the amounts without that explanation and did not establish the conditions for confiscation; it upheld the finding of guilt.
The power of mitigation is now found in Article L. 521-1 of the Customs Code, which allows, in particular, a tax fine below its minimum. It guarantees neither a reduction nor an exemption in your case. Some confiscations remain mandatory in the cases of Article L. 521-2 of the Customs Code. Preparation must therefore cover the classification, the basis of the penalty, the facts and personal circumstances, with supporting evidence rather than a general plea for leniency.
What is a customs settlement in France?
It is an agreement that the customs authorities may grant at the request of the offender in the matters provided for by Article L. 613-1 of the Customs Code. Its regime depends on the stage of the proceedings. Once proceedings have been brought, a proposal must be submitted to the judicial authority for agreement in principle, under the conditions of Article L. 613-2 of the Customs Code. After a final judgment, the tax penalties imposed can no longer be settled (Article L. 613-3 of the Customs Code).
The agreement must be read to find out which facts, penalties, sums and goods it covers, what obligations it contains and what effects its performance produces. Article 6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides that a settlement extinguishes the public prosecution where the law expressly allows it: a mere proposal should not be presented as having already ended the prosecution. Nor can a settlement be described, in every case, as a conviction or an automatic admission of criminal liability. Its value should be weighed against the grounds for challenge available in the file.
Can French customs reports be challenged?
Yes, but the way to challenge it depends on what the official report states. When drawn up by two officers, it is conclusive as to physical findings unless challenged through forgery proceedings (inscription de faux). The accuracy and truthfulness of the statements it records are only presumed true until proven otherwise (Article L. 444-1 of the Customs Code). When drawn up by a single customs officer, it is presumed true until proven otherwise (Article L. 444-2 of the Customs Code). Presenting all official reports as subject to the same regime is therefore inaccurate.
The Court of Cassation also distinguishes findings from the officers' deductions and assessments, which do not benefit from this enhanced evidential value (Cass. com., 22 January 2025, No. 22-23.957). Each passage, its authors and the documents on which it relies must be analysed. Signing or refusing to sign should not be treated as a universal way of neutralising the report. Keep the copy handed to you, the annexes and the factual evidence that allow you to discuss precisely what is recorded.
My goods were seized by French customs: can I get them back?
Return may be possible, but it depends on the measure, the goods and the procedure. Article L. 631-2 of the Customs Code allows the court to order release before ruling on the offences. Where release benefits an owner acting in good faith who is not being prosecuted under the Customs Code, the text provides that no security or deposit is required, subject to repayment of any storage and preservation costs incurred.
Confiscation may, however, be provided for by Article L. 514-4 of the Customs Code, and it is mandatory for the categories listed in Article L. 521-2 of the Customs Code. For property and assets seized during a search, Article L. 423-18 of the Customs Code provides for release if the judge finds that they do not derive from the offences under investigation. You need to provide the inventory, proof of ownership, invoices and evidence of good faith. None of these texts makes it possible to promise the return of all goods, particularly where they are subject to mandatory confiscation.
Can a company be prosecuted for its customs broker's mistakes?
Using a customs broker does not, on its own, settle how liability is shared. Article L. 522-1 of the Customs Code makes the declarant liable for the omissions, inaccuracies and irregularities referred to in the text, without prejudice to any recourse against its principal. If the declaration was drawn up according to the principal's instructions, the principal faces the same penalties. You therefore need to find the mandate, the data transmitted and the instructions actually given.
The debt calls for a different analysis: under Article 77 of the Union Customs Code, the declarant is the debtor and, in indirect representation, so is the person on whose behalf the declarant acts. Articles 18 and 19 of the UCC distinguish the types of mandate. The commercial chamber's judgment of 11 February 2026 points out that representation must be express and cannot be presumed (Cass. com., 11 February 2026, No. 24-18.748). That judgment concerned, in particular, import VAT; it should not be turned into a general exemption for the importer or the customs broker.
Smuggling and drug trafficking: how do the two fit together?
The offences and the rules of evidence must be distinguished, rather than inferring the customs outcome from the criminal outcome on the drugs alone. In the judgment of 17 February 2021, the Court quashed only the provisions relating to the customs offence: reasoning based on the absence of criminal intent was not enough to justify the acquittal in the face of the presumption attached to holding the goods (Cass. crim., 17 February 2021, No. 20-81.282). The other provisions were upheld.
This does not mean that all charges can be combined without examination. This page sets out no general rule on cumulative penalties. It invites you to address each offence, its material element, the holding of goods alleged and the evidence of good faith, now in the light of Article L. 522-3 of the Customs Code. The customs penalty also depends on the precise category of goods and the circumstances, in particular Article L. 513-3 of the Customs Code for the dangerous goods covered by its text. A defence must start from the facts and the exact charges.
How much does a customs defence lawyer cost in France?
There is no single amount that applies to every case. Fees are set in agreement with the client and, save for the statutory exceptions, by a written fee agreement specifying their amount or method of calculation, the foreseeable work and the expected costs (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971). The same text prohibits fees set solely according to the outcome of the case. It allows an additional success fee on top of the fee for the work carried out.
The firm offers a preliminary review of the case for €80 incl. VAT through the form on this page, with a written analysis within 24 working hours. Consultation formats and fees are shown in the booking module at the bottom of the page. The preliminary review does not state the total cost of proceedings or their outcome. To define the engagement, send us the documents you have received, their dates and the main supporting documents: reviewing them makes it possible to distinguish an assessment issue, a seizure or a prosecution.
What is customs detention in France?
It is a measure concerning a person, distinct from the detention of cash. It requires an offence caught in the act (délit flagrant) provided for by the Customs Code, other than the offences in Title III of Book V, punishable by imprisonment, together with the needs of the investigation (Article L. 432-1 of the Customs Code). It may not exceed twenty-four hours, with an extension of no more than twenty-four hours on the written, reasoned authorisation of the public prosecutor where the investigation justifies it (Article L. 432-2 of the Customs Code).
The person has, in particular, the rights to a doctor, to a lawyer and to have a relative informed, under the conditions and reservations of the text (Article L. 432-5 of the Customs Code). They are informed of the choice to answer questions or to remain silent after giving their identity (Article L. 432-7 of the Customs Code). In some cases, the lawyer's involvement may be deferred (Article L. 432-6 of the Customs Code). The notification, the times and the decisions taken must be checked, rather than transposing wholesale all the rules of another measure of deprivation of liberty.
Can French customs and the tax authorities work together?
Public finance officers and customs officers may share with each other, spontaneously or on request, documents and information gathered in the course of their duties, under the conditions of Article L. 83 A of the French Tax Procedure Code (Livre des procédures fiscales). The same set of invoices or flows may therefore lead to checks by several authorities. This exchange of information does not mean that the procedures, debts and penalties merge.
In a customs case, it is necessary in particular to distinguish the action for criminal penalties, the action for customs tax penalties and the action for duties compromised or evaded (Article L. 611-1 of the Customs Code, Article L. 611-4 of the Customs Code). The term customs tax penalty does not, on its own, refer to a direct tax reassessment. Gather the letters from each authority and the replies already sent separately, then cross-check the common facts. Our pages on tax audits and tax fraud help identify related issues, without assuming the same court or the same time limit for every aspect.
What happens to customs duties that were evaded?
They are not replaced by the fine. Article L. 611-4 of the Customs Code provides that the customs authorities bring the claim for payment of duties and taxes compromised or evaded and that, when it upholds the claim, the court cannot exempt the person liable from paying them, regardless of any penalties. This does not mean that every sum claimed is necessarily correct: the incurrence of the debt, its debtor and its calculation must be examined.
For goods released for circulation in the Union (mise en libre pratique), these questions fall in particular under Article 77 of the Union Customs Code. The amounts can be disputed through the challenge procedure of Article L. 331-1 of the Customs Code, and remission or repayment can be requested in the cases and under the conditions of Article 116 of the Union Customs Code, for example for an overcharge. Limitation or deferral of payment cannot be inferred from the amount of the fine alone. Keep the notice of recovery, the declarations concerned and the calculation details to isolate each point of disagreement.
What is customs value and why is it disputed?
It is used to determine the basis on which duties are calculated where the tariff depends on value. The primary method is the transaction value, that is the price actually paid or payable for the goods when sold for export to the Union, adjusted where necessary and under the conditions of Article 70 of the Union Customs Code. The value is therefore not always just the figure shown on a commercial invoice.
Article 71 of the Union Customs Code provides for certain additions, in particular for transport costs, assists supplied by the buyer or royalties meeting the conditions of the text. If the transaction value method cannot be used, Article 74 of the Union Customs Code sets out secondary methods. A disagreement may concern the actual price, the adjustments or the method used, without every discussion amounting to fraud. To examine it, cross-check contracts, invoices, payments, transport costs and licences. You then need to check how each correction affects the duties claimed and distinguish this issue from any penalty.
Does filing an amended customs declaration protect me from prosecution?
An amendment should not be presented as a general immunity. Article 173 of the Union Customs Code allows certain amendments after the declaration has been accepted, but sets limits: in particular, the amendment under its paragraph 1 can no longer be permitted once an examination of the goods has been announced or the inaccuracy has been found. After release, its paragraph 3 allows an amendment on application within three years of acceptance in order to comply with the obligations of the procedure concerned.
You therefore need to distinguish the declaration mechanism, the debt and any liability. Article L. 522-1 of the Customs Code deals with omissions and irregularities attributable to the declarant and, depending on the instructions given, to the principal. Before filing a correction, gather the initial declarations, the corrected calculations, the date on which the error was discovered and all exchanges with customs. These documents make it possible to assess the basis of the request and its timing; they do not make it possible to promise, as a matter of principle, that there will be no prosecution.
Do French customs offences also apply to private individuals?
Yes. The obligations to declare cash apply to carriers who are natural persons, including when they carry it on behalf of someone else. Article L. 152-1 of the Monetary and Financial Code covers amounts of €10,000 or more carried to or from another Member State; Article 3 of Regulation 2018/1672 governs entry into or exit from the Union. The fact that the trip is personal therefore does not remove the obligation.
For goods, the criminal provisions on import without declaration or smuggling are not limited to businesses (Article L. 513-1 of the Customs Code, Article L. 513-4 of the Customs Code). The precise regime depends on the goods, the facts and the legal elements of the offence. The invoices, the route and the documents handed over must be examined, without treating every purchase brought back from a trip as fraud. The allowances, quantities and restrictions specific to each product are not quantified here: they require a check tailored to the goods and the journey concerned.
What role does European Union law play in French customs cases?
The Union Customs Code governs, in particular, representation, value, the debt, amendments and appeals. Articles 18 and 19 of the UCC distinguish the types of mandate, Article 70 of the Union Customs Code sets the primary valuation method and Article 77 of the Union Customs Code identifies the debtors in the situations it covers. The French code, for its part, provides for inspection powers, procedures and penalties: both sets of rules must be read according to the question at issue.
Article 44 of the Union Customs Code provides a right of appeal against customs decisions that directly and individually concern the person to whom they are addressed, but Article 45 of the Union Customs Code specifies that an appeal does not in itself suspend the decision and sets out the conditions for suspension. A European argument must therefore be tied to a specific provision and to the facts. This page refers exclusively to the verified official text on EUR-Lex; it does not claim that a general appeal to EU law would be enough to annul an inspection, a debt or a penalty.
Why instruct a firm of criminal defence lawyers in a French customs case?
Where the case involves customs detention or prosecution for an offence (délit), the defence must examine the person's rights, the evidence and the penalty. The right to the assistance of a lawyer during customs detention is provided for, under conditions and reservations, by Articles L. 432-5 and L. 432-6. The criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) hears offences (Article 381 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). These aspects explain why a criminal law analysis is useful in the cases that call for one.
The subject is not limited to criminal trials, however: a challenge to a debt follows a separate procedure before the judicial court (Article L. 332-1 of the Customs Code), and value or debt issues require a reading of the Union Customs Code. The choice of adviser should therefore match the problem you face. The preliminary review offered on this page makes it possible to examine the documents before deciding on the next steps. It is neither a promise of outcome nor a claim that every customs difficulty requires criminal proceedings.
Sources and related pages
Legal texts and related pages
The French articles cited were checked on 26 October 2026. The Customs Code is cited here using the numbering in force since 1 May 2026. Judgments delivered under earlier texts are presented in their context. The Union Customs Code is available on EUR-Lex.
Further reading
Page updated on 26 October 2026.
A customs case to review?
Send us the documents you have received, with their dates. Preliminary review for €80 incl. VAT through the form, with a written analysis within 24 working hours. Consultations and fees in the booking module.