KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
Retiring in France as an American: Healthcare, Pension Taxes, and Estate Rules Once You Live There

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

Retiring in France as an American: Healthcare, Pension Taxes, and Estate Rules Once You Live There

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Every year, thousands of Americans trade their US health plan and their W-2 for a village house in the Dordogne, an apartment in Paris, or a cottage near the sea in Brittany. The dream is simple: slow mornings, good bread, and a health system that does not send a bill for calling an ambulance. The legal reality is manageable, but it is not automatic. France gives retired Americans access to one of the best health systems in the world, taxes their pensions under a treaty signed in 1994, and applies its own succession rules to everything they own on French soil once they live there. Each of these three blocks — health coverage, pension taxation, and estate planning — runs on its own statute book, its own forms, and its own deadlines. This article walks through all three in order, with the exact statutes, the exact treaty language, and three recent court decisions that show how judges actually apply the health-coverage charge that surprises American retirees most.

One boundary first. Getting the long-stay visa that lets you settle in France is an immigration procedure, handled elsewhere on this site. This article starts the day you arrive with that visa in your passport: how you join the health system, how your US pensions are taxed once France becomes your home, and how to organize the French house so your children inherit it without a fight or a surprise tax bill. Terms are explained as they come. PUMA is the protection universelle maladie, France’s universal health coverage. CPAM is the caisse primaire d’assurance maladie, the local health fund office where you register. CSM is the cotisation subsidiaire maladie, the yearly health contribution some residents pay. PASS is the plafond annuel de la sécurité sociale, the social-security ceiling figure the administration uses as a yardstick for thresholds.

I. Health Coverage After the Move: How American Retirees Join the French System

American retirees sometimes assume that Medicare travels with them. It does not. Medicare coverage outside the United States is essentially nonexistent, and France does not give newcomers instant health coverage on arrival either. The French system opens its doors after a waiting period, charges a contribution calibrated to your capital income if you do not work, and leaves a share of every medical bill for you or your top-up insurer to pay. Understanding these three mechanics before you move saves real money. If you want the short overview first, read our pillar guide for Americans retiring in France; the present article goes further on each point, with the court decisions and treaty mechanics the overview does not cover.

A. PUMA After Three Months: Who Qualifies and How American Retirees Register

The foundation is a single sentence of statute. Article L160-1 of the Social Security Code provides: “Toute personne travaillant ou, lorsqu’elle n’exerce pas d’activité professionnelle, résidant en France de manière stable et régulière bénéficie, en cas de maladie ou de maternité, de la prise en charge de ses frais de santé dans les conditions fixées au présent livre.” In plain English: anyone who works in France, or who lives in France on a stable and regular basis without working, gets their health costs covered. A retired American who settles in France with a valid residence permit falls squarely in the second group: no job is required, residence is enough.

Two adjectives do all the work: stable and régulière (regular, meaning lawful). Stability is a facts-and-time test spelled out in the regulations and confirmed by the Urssaf, the agency that collects the contributions, which explains that it means living in metropolitan France or the listed overseas territories without interruption for more than three months. You must have lived in France continuously for more than three months. Short trips abroad do not necessarily break continuity, but the clock starts when you actually settle, not when your visa is issued. Regularity means lawful presence: a valid long-stay visa followed by a titre de séjour (residence permit). A Paris court confirmed that the permit most retirees hold does the job: “le titulaire d’une carte de séjour mention « visiteur », qui admet au séjour la personne titulaire d’un visa long d’une durée supérieure à trois mois mention « visiteur » remplit les conditions de séjour régulier au sens de ces dispositions” (Paris Judicial Court, May 31, 2024, case no. 21/00198, full decision on courdecassation.fr). The visiteur card — the standard permit for financially self-sufficient people who promise not to work in France — satisfies the lawful-residence condition.

Registration is a deliberate step, not an automatic event. You file a request with the CPAM of your place of residence, with proof of identity, lawful stay, and three months of continuous presence (utility bills, lease, bank statements). The fund examines the file and, if the conditions are met, enrolls you and eventually issues a carte Vitale, the green smart card you hand over at every doctor’s office and pharmacy. Keep copies of everything you submit and note the filing date: the three-month clock and the paper trail matter if coverage is ever disputed. One practical warning from the case law below: enrolling late does not erase what you owe, so file as soon as the three months are up rather than waiting for the first doctor’s visit.

What PUMA pays is generous but not total. The public scheme typically reimburses around 70 percent of the regulated fee for a general practitioner visit and a share of hospital and pharmacy costs, with long-term serious illness (affection de longue durée) covered at 100 percent of the regulated rate. The regulated fee (tarif de convention) is not always the fee the doctor charges: specialists in Paris and other big cities often bill above it (dépassements d’honoraires), and the excess stays yours. That gap is why nearly every resident buys a mutuelle, a private top-up health policy that pays the share the public scheme leaves behind. Budget for both from day one: the public coverage and the monthly mutuelle premium.

Low-income retirees should know about a second layer of statute. Article L861-1 of the Social Security Code opens a no-premium or subsidized top-up: “Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 160-1 ont droit à une protection complémentaire en matière de santé dans les conditions suivantes : 1° Sans acquitter de participation financière lorsque leurs ressources ainsi que celles des autres personnes membres du même foyer sont inférieures à un plafond déterminé par décret”. If your household resources fall below a set ceiling, the complémentaire santé solidaire covers the top-up at zero or near-zero premium. An American living only on a small Social Security check may qualify after becoming a stable resident — ask the CPAM or the local centre communal d’action sociale rather than assuming you earn too much.

Two common American misunderstandings deserve a clear correction. First, the European S1 portable-health document that EU pensioners carry between member states has no American equivalent: the United States has no social-security coordination instrument with France covering health care for retirees (the France-US totalization agreement coordinates pension quarters, not health coverage). You cannot transfer Medicare credits into PUMA; you qualify through residence alone. Second, private American insurance — even a generous expatriate policy — does not replace PUMA and, as the courts repeat, does not exempt you from the French contribution described next.

B. The Price of Coverage: the CSM Levy, Private Insurance, and the Top-Up Mutuelle

Here comes the surprise that generates most of the litigation: France charges residents who do not work and live on capital income a yearly health contribution, the cotisation subsidiaire maladie (CSM), often called the “PUMA tax” in expatriate forums. It is not a penalty and it is not optional. Article L380-2 of the Social Security Code, in the wording quoted by the Paris Court of Appeal, states: “Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 160-1 sont redevables d’une cotisation annuelle lorsqu’elles remplissent les conditions suivantes : 1° Leurs revenus tirés, au cours de l’année considérée, d’activités professionnelles exercées en France sont inférieurs à un seuil fixé par décret. […] 2° Elles n’ont perçu ni pension de retraite ou d’invalidité, ni rente, ni aucun montant d’allocation de chômage au cours de l’année considérée.” Two cumulative tests: little or no French professional income, and no French pension, annuity, or unemployment benefit. The American retiree living on US Social Security and investment income typically meets both — US pensions are not French pensions — and that is exactly when the CSM bites.

The courts have spelled out the arithmetic in terms a retiree can apply. “Il résulte des articles L160-1, L160-6, L380-2 et D380-1 du code de la sécurité sociale qu’une personne de nationalité étrangère peut être redevable de la cotisation subsidiaire maladie dès lors que les conditions cumulatives suivantes sont remplies : elle ouvre droit à la prise en charge de ses frais de santé, disposant d’une résidence stable et régulière en France, sans toutefois être concernée par les dispositions de l’article L160-6 du Code de la sécurité sociale […] ses revenus d’activités professionnelles exercées en France sont inférieurs au seuil de 10 % du plafond annuel de la sécurité sociale, et elle n’a perçu ni pension de retraite, ni rente, ni allocations de chômage au titre de l’année considérée […] ses revenus du patrimoine sont supérieurs à 25 % du plafond de la sécurité sociale.” (Paris Judicial Court, May 31, 2024, no. 21/00198, full decision). Three cumulative conditions: covered residence, French professional income below 10 percent of the PASS with no pension received, and capital income above 25 percent of the PASS. Miss any one of the three and no CSM is due; meet all three and it is.

The rate and formula come from the Urssaf’s official guidance for PUMA beneficiaries, which sets a degressive rate of 6.5 percent that falls as professional income rises, computed from the capital-income base minus half the PASS with a phase-out tied to professional income (Urssaf, Bénéficiaire de la PUMA). Concretely, a retired couple living entirely on dividends, rental income, and capital gains can owe several thousand euros a year — in one decided case the validated bill reached 12,996 euros for a single year. The contribution is assessed with a delay (often two years after the income year), so keep reserves: the first CSM bill typically lands just as you feel settled.

Three defenses routinely raised by Americans have all failed in court, and knowing that saves legal fees. First, “I never registered, so I owe nothing.” Rejected: “l’absence d’affiliation au régime de sécurité sociale, qui dépend d’une démarche volontaire de l’assurée, ne peut suffire à l’exclure de son assujettissement à la cotisation subsidiaire maladie, compte-tenu de son caractère d’ordre public” — skipping registration cannot exclude you because the charge is a matter of public policy (Paris Judicial Court, May 31, 2024, no. 21/00198, full decision). Second, the private-insurance argument Rejected twice over: “il ne résulte d’aucune disposition légale qu’une décision préalable d’affiliation soit nécessaire à l’assujettissement de la personne concernée à la cotisation subsidiaire maladie” — no prior enrollment decision is legally required before the charge applies (Paris Judicial Court, January 25, 2024, no. 22/02568, full decision) — and the same court adds that “cet assujettissement est obligatoire et d’ordre public, sans qu’une contrepartie soit automatiquement nécessaire”, meaning the charge stands even if you never actually claimed a euro of French health care. Third, the constitutional challenge: the claimant invoked the interministerial circular and the Constitutional Council’s decision no. 2018-735 QPC of September 27, 2018, which says “les cotisations dues en application de l’article L380-2 sont acquittées exclusivement par des personnes bénéficiant, en cas de maladie ou de maternité, de la prise en charge de leurs frais de santé et sont affectées au financement de ces frais” — but the court read that as confirming, not defeating, the levy, since PUMA coverage is a right the resident simply had to claim: “il suffisait à la cotisante de se rapprocher de la Caisse Primaire d’Assurance Maladie pour en solliciter le bénéfice si elle le souhaitait.”

The Court of Appeal has now put its weight behind the agencies. Recording Urssaf’s position, it notes that enrollment follows automatically once the criteria are met and that no prior enrollment decision is needed before the CSM is due (Paris Court of Appeal, June 27, 2025, no. 22/01239, full decision). The outcome: “DÉCLARE régulier l’appel de cotisation subsidiaire maladie du 15 décembre 2017” — the assessment stands, the late-billing argument fails, and the private policy changes nothing. For the retiree, the lesson is blunt and useful: register with the CPAM on time, keep the private policy as a bridge for the first three months and as a complement afterwards, buy the mutuelle, and budget the CSM as a recurring cost of French retired life rather than fighting it.

One related trap: the regularity condition in Article L111-2-3 of the Social Security Code sends the details to regulation, and lawful stay must be maintained continuously. An expired permit or a long unexplained absence can suspend coverage and complicate re-enrollment. Renew the titre de séjour on time, keep proof of continuous address, and tell the CPAM when you move — coverage follows the fund of your new department, not you automatically.

II. Money and Succession Once France Is Home: Pensions, Property, and Passing It On

Becoming a French resident rewires your tax life. France taxes its residents on worldwide income, and the moment your foyer — your home and principal place of stay — moves to France, your US pensions enter the French return. Article 4 B of the General Tax Code sets the test: “Sont considérées comme ayant leur domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 A : a. Les personnes qui ont en France leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal”. Live most of the year in your French house and France considers you its taxpayer. That sounds alarming until you read the treaty: the France-United States convention allocates each type of pension to one country and gives a credit mechanism so the same dollar is not taxed twice. The treaty text, published by Decree no. 96-222 of March 15, 1996 and explained in the official BOFiP commentary on the France-US convention, controls.

A. US Pensions Under the France-US Treaty: What France Taxes and How Double Tax Is Relieved

Start with the three pension buckets, because the treaty treats each differently. First, private and employer pensions — 401(k) distributions, IRA withdrawals, company pensions, federal-employee pensions that are not military or civil-service remuneration under Article 19. Article 18(a) of the convention covers pensions and similar remuneration, including every sum paid under a retirement scheme either periodically or as a lump sum, when paid to a resident who beneficially owns them for past employment: such pensions are taxable only in the state of residence. Read carefully: a pension paid to a French resident for past work is taxable only in France — even if the pension comes from a US employer and even if it arrives as a lump sum. The United States, under the treaty, steps back. France taxes the full amount under domestic law: Article 79 of the General Tax Code (“Les traitements, indemnités, émoluments, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères concourent à la formation du revenu global servant de base à l’impôt sur le revenu”), softened by Article 158-5-a: “Les pensions et retraites font l’objet d’un abattement de 10 % qui ne peut excéder 4 439 €.” Every retiree gets a 10 percent reduction on pensions, capped per tax household. Declare the gross US pension on the French return (forms 2042 and the foreign-income schedule 2047, filed each spring on impots.gouv.fr), apply the 10 percent, and pay French income tax at the progressive scale.

Second bucket: Social Security — US Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability checks. Article 18(b) reverses the rule for social-security benefits: pensions and other sums paid under one state’s social-security legislation to a resident of the other state are taxable only in the paying state. A Social Security check paid to a French resident is taxable only in the United States. France does not tax it — but France still wants to see it: the amount is reported on the French return so it can be counted for the effective-rate calculation described next, with a matching credit wiping out the French tax on it. Do not confuse the two buckets: the private pension is taxed in France, the Social Security check in America. Mixing them up on the return is the single most common filing error in retiree files. Our dedicated guide to US Social Security checks taxed in France and our IRA and 401(k) guide for retirees in France work through each bucket with numbers.

Third bucket: government-service pensions — US military retirement pay, federal civil-service annuities, state-government pensions for work as a public employee. These fall under Article 19 (public remuneration), not Article 18, and the default rule taxes them only in the paying state (the United States), with an exception when the recipient is a French resident holding French nationality. If you retired from US public service and now live in France as a dual citizen, get advice on your exact status before filing: Articles 18 and 19 interact, and the wrong box on the return produces either double tax or an adjustment.

The relief mechanics sit in Article 24. Article 24(1)(a) keeps US-source income that the treaty assigns to the United States reportable on the French return of a French resident; the American tax is not deductible, but France grants a credit imputable against the French tax. In practice this is exemption with progression done through a credit: the US-taxed income goes on the French return, pushes the marginal rate applied to your France-taxed income, and generates a French credit equal to the French tax attributable to it — so no double payment, but the US income still lifts the rate on the rest. Keep the US tax notices (Form 1040, SSA-1099, 1099-R): the French administration can ask for proof of the American tax paid, and for US citizens the treaty adds an explicit compliance string — certain benefits for a France-resident US citizen apply only with proof that US federal income-tax obligations have been met. File the US return every year even when the treaty assigns taxation to France; the IRS taxes citizens worldwide regardless of residence, and the treaty credit on the US side (foreign tax credit, Form 1116) is what prevents the mirror-image double tax on your France-taxed pensions. Retirees billed French social charges on top of income tax on their US pensions have a separate line of defense, explained in our CSG and CRDS challenge guide.

Two timing notes complete the picture. Before the move, French-source pensions paid while you are still a US resident suffer withholding: Article 182 A of the General Tax Code (“les traitements, salaires, pensions et rentes viagères, de source française, servis à des personnes qui ne sont pas fiscalement domiciliées en France donnent lieu à l’application d’une retenue à la source”). Once you become a French resident, the withholding logic falls away and worldwide declaration takes over. And if you keep renting out a French property while drawing pensions, that rental income is declared alongside — the treaty gives France the taxing right over French real estate, with the US credit on the American return (see our guide for Americans renting out a French house).

B. Owning a French Home in Retirement: Property Taxes, Gifts to Children, and Forced Heirship

Most retired Americans in France own their home, and ownership brings two yearly taxes plus a succession regime that overrides American estate planning reflexes. The yearly pair: taxe foncière, paid by the owner every autumn, and the housing-occupancy levy that now targets second homes in tense zones. Our detailed walkthrough for American owners facing the wealth tax and second-home surcharge covers the Impôt sur la Fortune Immobilière (IFI), which catches worldwide real estate above 1.3 million euros once you are a French resident — a threshold a Paris apartment plus a US house can cross faster than expected. Budget all three before buying: the purchase price is only the entry ticket, as our notaire closing-costs guide shows.

The deeper shock is succession law. An American will that leaves everything to the surviving spouse works in Ohio; in France, children have a legally protected minimum called the réserve héréditaire (forced share) that no will can defeat, as explained in our guide to forced heirship and the levy choice. Since August 2015, EU Regulation 650/2012 lets you choose in your will the law of your nationality to govern the whole succession — an American in France can elect US law — but that election does not erase French inheritance tax, and France’s 2021 prélèvement compensatoire claws back protection for children disinherited under a foreign law in some configurations. Wills need a Franco-American review, not a translation: have the document checked against both systems before signing anything.

The tax side of death and gifts turns on residence. Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code casts a wide net: “Sont soumis aux droits de mutation à titre gratuit : 1° Les biens meubles et immeubles situés en France ou hors de France […] lorsque le donateur ou le défunt a son domicile fiscal en France au sens de l’article 4 B”. Once you are domiciled in France, France taxes gifts and inheritances on property anywhere in the world — including the US brokerage account and the Florida condo — with a credit system under the 1978 France-US estate and gift tax treaty softening double taxation. The allowances (abattements) are per beneficiary and renew every fifteen years: 100,000 euros per parent per child for gifts and inheritances, 80,724 euros between spouses (with a full exemption for surviving spouses on succession), far less for siblings and nothing for unrelated persons, where the rate hits 60 percent. Retirees who plan to help children with a house deposit should give early and in the right order: a donation-partage dividing the French house among the children during lifetime locks in values, uses each allowance, and prevents the indivision fights that fill French courts.

Protecting the surviving spouse deserves its own paragraph, because the surviving spouse is usually the first person the plan must shelter. French intestacy gives the spouse a choice between full ownership of one quarter or lifetime use (usufruit) of everything — plus a one-year right to remain in the home without paying compensation and, by statute, a lifetime right to live there that can be claimed against the children. Our guide for American surviving spouses compares the options with numbers. Consider also the marital property regime: Americans married without a French contract who settle in France may want a regime change toward a community with attribution to the survivor, executed before a notaire. And if the couple holds the house through a family company, read our analysis of buying through an SCI before assuming the company still helps in retirement — it often complicates the succession it was meant to simplify.

Finally, two paperwork reflexes that cost nothing and prevent everything. First, make sure the French house’s title, the will, the marriage regime, and the beneficiary clauses (clauses bénéficiaires) of any life-insurance contracts all tell the same story; contradictions between an American trust, a French will, and an insurance clause are the raw material of litigation (see our piece on California living trusts and French houses). Second, keep a French-language file with the treaty articles, the will, the property deed (acte de vente), and the US tax filings where your children can find it — the French bank account statements included, since the notaire settling the succession will ask for all of them within six months of death.

Conclusion

Retiring in France as an American rests on three pillars, each with its own logic. Health coverage is a right earned by three months of continuous lawful residence and bought with the CSM contribution when you live on capital — register with the CPAM early, carry a mutuelle, and treat the Urssaf assessment as routine rather than outrageous. Pension taxation follows the 1994 treaty’s split: private pensions taxed in France with the 10 percent allowance, Social Security taxed in America, government pensions under their own article, and Article 24’s credit smoothing every overlap. Succession follows French forced heirship and worldwide taxation once you are domiciled here, softened by treaty credits, renewable allowances, and lifetime gifts made in the right form. None of this requires fear or guesswork — only the right filing, in the right office, in the right order. Set the three pillars straight in your first year, review them when a law or a treaty position changes, and the French retirement you pictured becomes an administrative routine instead of a yearly surprise.

📄 Official circular