KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
US Sanctions the ICC as an Institution While France Clears a Wanted Aircraft: What Paris Must Do When an ICC Suspect Lands or Is Arrested

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

US Sanctions the ICC as an Institution While France Clears a Wanted Aircraft: What Paris Must Do When an ICC Suspect Lands or Is Arrested

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

On 9 October 2026, the United States imposed sanctions on the International Criminal Court as an institution, only hours after one of its former judges won the Nobel Peace Prize. The Court answered that the designation was an attempt to obstruct justice, and eight foreign ministers, including France’s, replied in a joint statement regretting and strongly disagreeing with the American move. Two weeks earlier, Paris had authorised the aircraft of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu — wanted by the Court since 2024 — to cross French airspace, with the Foreign Ministry stating that the clearance fully complied with international law. Condemnation in The Hague’s defence on one side, open skies for a wanted man on the other: France’s posture raises a precise legal question. What must Paris actually do when a person sought by the ICC is on French soil, in transit, or merely flying over? This article gives the answer from inside French procedure: the news of October 2026, the overflight controversy, and the step-by-step arrest-and-surrender mechanism of articles 627 to 627-10 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure.

I. A sanctioned Court and a French sky that stayed open: the events of September and October 2026

A. United States sanctions against the ICC in October 2026: what Washington decided and how Paris reacted

According to Reuters, the Trump administration imposed sanctions on the International Criminal Court on Friday 9 October 2026, hours after former ICC judge Navanethem Pillay won the Nobel Peace Prize, putting Washington on a diplomatic collision course with European allies. The Court’s institutional response was unusually blunt: it described the sanctions as an attempt to obstruct justice and to stop the Court from doing what it was created to do, calling the move an assault on the rule of law and on the foundations of the international legal order, striking at the principle that no one stands above the law. It added that the designation aimed to disrupt its operations and to intimidate those working for or cooperating with it.

This October escalation did not come out of nowhere. France had already condemned an earlier American round in a statement dated Paris, 19 August 2026, published by the Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs: France had learned of new US sanctions against the President of the ICC and a member of the Office of the Prosecutor, adding to those already adopted against eleven judges of the institution. The same statement sets out the French doctrine Paris has repeated ever since: France condemns all threats and coercive measures against the Court, its staff and supporting civil society organisations, regards them as an attack on the Court and on all 125 States Parties to the Rome Statute and as contrary to judicial independence, and expresses solidarity with the judges targeted.

The October 2026 reactions followed the same line across European capitals. The foreign ministers of Canada, Denmark, Germany, France, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands and Britain declared in a joint statement that, as committed supporters of the ICC, they regretted and strongly disagreed with the announced American sanctions, warned that the measures would significantly affect the Court’s work, its staff and their families if implemented, and reaffirmed their united support for the Court alongside dialogue with non-States Parties. The European Commission added that the EU stood ready to take any necessary measures to let the Court keep investigating and prosecuting war crimes and crimes against humanity, and to protect the interests of EU operators within the single market. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, through his spokesperson, said the decision marked a serious blow to the collective pursuit of international criminal justice, of which the ICC is a key pillar.

Two practical details from the Reuters compilation matter for anyone advising clients exposed to the American measures. First, Belgium’s foreign minister Maxime Prevot announced that support for the ICC would be discussed with his EU counterparts, insisting that Europe must act and calling for activation of the EU Blocking Statute to protect the Court, on the ground that the Court’s independence cannot depend on whom it investigates. Readers who want the full analysis of that European shield should read the companion analysis of how US sanctions against the ICC interact with France’s cooperation duties and the EU Blocking Statute. Second, the Dutch foreign minister noted that the sanctions would not take effect immediately and that service providers could keep working for the ICC, since a six-month period before effect left room for Dialogue. A six-month window before effect is not an amnesty, but it is a timetable that banks, counsel and contractors working with the Court must diary immediately.

On the other side, Prime Minister Netanyahu publicly thanked Washington: he commended the American president and secretary of state for the decision to sanction the ICC, presenting the Court as a political body rather than a court and as a threat to law-abiding democracies and national sovereignty. Israel, which is not a party to the Rome Statute, rejects the Court’s jurisdiction and contests the 2024 warrants against Netanyahu and his former defence chief Yoav Gallant. That contestation sets the stage for the French chapter of the story: what does a State Party that defends the Court do when the wanted man approaches its airspace?

B. A wanted aircraft over France: why Paris says the ICC warrant did not oblige it to act

On 24 September 2026, Reuters reported from Paris that France had defended letting the aircraft of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu cross French airspace en route to the United Nations, taking the view that international law required no action even though an ICC arrest warrant stood against him over alleged war crimes. The legal reasoning, given by Foreign Ministry spokesperson Pascal Confavreux, deserves close reading because it draws the exact boundary France claims between its obligations and their limits: the clearance fully complied with international law, since in Paris’s reading the Rome Statute imposes no obligations concerning overflights of national territory by a state aircraft carrying a passenger targeted by an arrest warrant.

Three factual elements in the Reuters dispatch deserve attention. First, France recalled its status: it is a signatory of the ICC’s founding Rome Statute and is formally bound to cooperate with the Court, including by arresting suspects who enter its territory. The contrast is therefore deliberate — arrest on entry, no action on overflight. Second, flight-tracking data showed the aircraft flying over Greece, Italy and France, while Italy’s Foreign Ministry could not immediately say whether Israeli authorities had sought overflight permission. Third, Reuters recalled that the previous year the same traveller had flown a circuitous route to New York skirting the airspace of several European countries, including France. In 2025 the route avoided France; in 2026 it crossed it with authorisation. The shift is political, but its legal dressing is a claim about the Rome Statute’s silence on overflight.

Is that claim correct? The honest answer distinguishes three situations that public commentary often confuses: mere overflight without landing, transit of a person already arrested and being surrendered, and presence on the territory. The Rome Statute’s transit provision, article 89(3), governs the case where a person is being transported through a State Party’s territory for surrender to the Court: the State of transit must authorise the passage, with a simplified regime for air transport where no landing is scheduled, and a duty to detain the person if an unscheduled landing occurs. That regime presupposes custody and a surrender in progress. It does not address a foreign state aircraft that simply crosses the sky with a wanted passenger on board and no intention to land. France’s statement exploits exactly that textual gap: no custody, no surrender in progress, no landing — hence, in Paris’s reading, no obligation triggered.

Human rights organisations reject the broader French posture on immunity, and their objection predates the overflight. In a press release of 27 November 2024, the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) and the Ligue des droits de l’Homme stated their categorical disapproval of French diplomacy’s statements about the alleged immunity of the two Israeli officials, insisting that the ICC arrest warrants must apply under Article 27 of the Rome Statute, which rules out any immunity in that context. FIDH recalled that under article 27(2) of the treaty, immunities or special procedural rules attached to official capacity do not bar the Court from exercising jurisdiction over the person concerned. The organisation added that under Chapter IX of the Rome Statute, France is fully bound to cooperate with the Court, including by arresting and surrendering wanted persons found on its territory.

FIDH also invoked the precedent that now frames every debate on non-arrest: on 24 October 2024, Pre-Trial Chamber II found that by failing to arrest Mr Putin while he was on its territory and to surrender him, Mongolia had breached its duty to cooperate under the Rome Statute and prevented the Court from exercising its functions and powers within the meaning of article 87(7). The Chamber affirmed that the personal immunity of heads of State cannot be opposed to the ICC without any waiver, and that States Parties must arrest and surrender persons subject to Court warrants whatever their official position. The Mongolia finding concerned physical presence on the territory — the one situation where the duty is undisputed. France’s overflight position does not deny that duty; it argues the duty never arose at 35,000 feet. Whether the Court’s judges would accept that reading if a case were ever referred under article 87(7) against a State Party that knowingly cleared the flight path remains untested, and a prudent adviser does not present an untested reading as settled law.

The result is a paradox that structures the rest of this article. The same government that condemns American sanctions as an attack on the Court and on all 125 States Parties maintains that its own skies may lawfully carry a man the Court wants to try. Both positions can be sincerely held only if the line between presence and overflight holds. The next part therefore examines the side of the line where France admits no exception: what happens, hour by hour and court by court, when a person sought by the ICC is arrested on French soil.

II. Arrested on an ICC warrant in France: the surrender procedure step by step

A. Arrest on French soil on an ICC warrant: the first 24 hours, the 5-day transfer and the Paris prosecutor

French cooperation with the ICC is not governed by ordinary extradition law. It sits in a dedicated title of the Code of Criminal Procedure whose opening provision states the principle: “Pour l’application du statut de la Cour pénale internationale signé le 18 juillet 1998, la France participe à la répression des infractions et coopère avec cette juridiction dans les conditions fixées par le présent titre.” The provision adds that the rules apply to any person prosecuted before the Court or convicted by it for acts constituting, within the meaning of articles 6 to 8 and 25 of the Statute, genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes. That is article 627 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: France takes part in punishing genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes as defined by articles 6 to 8 and 25 of the Rome Statute, and cooperates with the Court under the conditions of that title.

Two channels must be distinguished from the first minute, because they involve different magistrates. Requests for legal assistance from the Court are sent to the competent Article 87 authorities “en original ou en copie certifiée conforme accompagnées de toutes pièces justificatives” and “transmis au procureur de la République antiterroriste qui leur donne toutes suites utiles”, with urgency transmission allowed “directement et par tout moyen à ce magistrat” under article 627-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Arrest requests for surrender follow a different route: “Les demandes d’arrestation aux fins de remise délivrées par la Cour pénale internationale sont adressées, en original et accompagnées de toutes pièces justificatives, aux autorités compétentes en vertu de l’article 87 du statut qui, après s’être assurées de leur régularité formelle, les transmettent au procureur général près la cour d’appel de Paris et, dans le même temps, les mettent à exécution dans toute l’étendue du territoire de la République.” Urgency transmission goes to the territorially competent prosecutor under article 627-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In plain terms: mutual assistance runs through the antiterrorism prosecutor in Paris, while an arrest-and-surrender request is executed nationwide and centralised on the prosecutor general at the Paris Court of Appeal.

The arrested person’s rights clock starts immediately. “Toute personne appréhendée en vertu d’une demande d’arrestation aux fins de remise doit être déférée dans les vingt-quatre heures au procureur de la République territorialement compétent”, and within that period “les dispositions des articles 63-1 à 63-7 du présent code lui sont applicables” — the custody safeguards of French garde à vue. After verifying identity, the prosecutor informs the person “dans une langue qu’elle comprend, qu’elle fait l’objet d’une demande d’arrestation aux fins de remise et qu’elle comparaîtra, dans un délai maximum de cinq jours, devant le procureur général près la cour d’appel de Paris”, and adds that she may be assisted “par un avocat de son choix ou, à défaut, par un avocat commis d’office”, with whom she may speak immediately. That is article 627-5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. For counsel, the checklist at this stage is short and non-negotiable: identity verification, language of notification, immediate access to the lawyer, and the five-day horizon before Paris.

Paris centralisation then takes over. “La personne réclamée est transférée, s’il y a lieu, et écrouée à la maison d’arrêt du ressort de la cour d’appel de Paris”, and “Le transfèrement doit avoir lieu dans un délai maximum de cinq jours à compter de sa présentation au procureur de la République, faute de quoi la personne réclamée est immédiatement libérée sur décision du président de la chambre de l’instruction de la cour d’appel de Paris, à moins que le transfèrement ait été retardé par des circonstances insurmontables.” The prosecutor general notifies the person, again “dans une langue qu’elle comprend”, of the arrest request and the charges, and receives her statements with her lawyer under article 627-6 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Note the sanction: a missed five-day transfer means immediate release, unless insurmountable circumstances are shown. French ICC procedure, unlike ordinary extradition, concentrates every subsequent step in Paris — a point that also explains why the Court’s first trial of a surrendered Libyan suspect, examined in the analysis of the El Hishri case, the ICC’s first Libya trial and the French surrender mechanism, turned on the same Paris judicial actors.

Two protective mechanisms complete the arrest phase. First, conservatory measures on assets: “L’exécution sur le territoire français des mesures conservatoires mentionnées au k du paragraphe 1 de l’article 93 du statut est ordonnée, aux frais avancés du Trésor et selon les modalités prévues par le présent code, par le procureur de la République antiterroriste”, for a maximum of two years, renewable once at the Court’s request, under article 627-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In October 2026, with American sanctions targeting the Court’s own finances and European asset freezes multiplying, that two-year ceiling matters to anyone whose funds are caught between a foreign sanction and an ICC protective measure. Second, the contrast with Interpol-based arrest is instructive: a person stopped in France on a red notice follows a different detention-and-release timetable, described in the guide to arrest in France on an Interpol red notice and the 30-day release rule. An ICC surrender request is heavier, faster in its centralisation, and narrower in the defences it allows — which is the subject of the next section.

B. Challenging surrender to the ICC from Paris: the investigating chamber, manifest error and cassation

Once the wanted person is before the prosecutor general, “La chambre de l’instruction est immédiatement saisie de la procédure”, and “La personne réclamée comparaît devant elle dans un délai de huit jours à compter de sa présentation au procureur général”, with a possible additional eight days at the request of the prosecution or the defence. An examination follows, debates are held and judgment given in public hearing, “sauf si la publicité est de nature à nuire au bon déroulement de la procédure en cours, aux intérêts d’un tiers ou à la dignité de la personne”. That is article 627-7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: eight days to appear, adversarial hearing, publicity as the default.

The decisive provision is the next one, and defence lawyers must read it without wishful thinking: “Lorsque la chambre de l’instruction constate qu’il n’y a pas d’erreur évidente, elle ordonne la remise de la personne réclamée et, si celle-ci est libre, son incarcération à cette fin. Toute autre question soumise à la chambre de l’instruction est renvoyée à la Cour pénale internationale qui lui donne les suites utiles.” The chamber rules “dans les quinze jours de la comparution”, and on appeal “la chambre criminelle de la Cour de cassation statue dans un délai de deux mois suivant la réception du dossier” under article 627-8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The standard is manifest error — erreur évidente — and nothing more. Guilt or innocence, the political context, the American sanctions debate, immunity arguments of the article 27 versus article 98 type: all of that belongs to The Hague, not to Paris. The Paris judges check identity, the formal regularity of the request and the absence of obvious mistake; every other question is referred to the Court. Compared with extradition, where French courts examine double criminality and human-rights bars in depth, ICC surrender is a deliberately narrow gate, because the requested State trusts the ICC’s own judicial process to hear the substance.

Release pending surrender is possible but framed by the Statute itself. “La mise en liberté ou la mainlevée ou la modification du contrôle judiciaire ou de l’assignation à résidence sous surveillance électronique peut être demandée à tout moment à la chambre de l’instruction de la cour d’appel de Paris qui procède conformément à l’article 59 du statut et à la procédure prévue aux articles 148-1 et suivants du présent code”, with a reasoned public decision referring to article 59(4) of the Statute, under article 627-9 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Article 59 of the Rome Statute requires the custodial State to consider whether, given the gravity of the alleged crimes, urgent and exceptional circumstances justify interim release and whether safeguards exist to ensure surrender. In practice, release pending ICC surrender is exceptional: the crimes within the Court’s jurisdiction weigh heavily against it, and the chamber must satisfy itself that the person will actually board the plane to The Hague.

The end of the road is strictly timetabled. The chamber’s order, the place and date of surrender and the length of detention are notified to the Court, and “La personne réclamée est remise dans un délai d’un mois à compter du jour où cette décision est devenue définitive, faute de quoi elle est immédiatement libérée sur décision du président de la chambre de l’instruction, à moins que sa remise ait été retardée par des circonstances insurmontables.” That is article 627-10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: one month from finality, then immediate release absent insurmountable circumstances. A related provision shows the cooperative logic pushed to its limit: “Toute personne détenue sur le territoire de la République peut, si elle y consent, être transférée à la Cour pénale internationale à des fins d’identification ou d’audition ou pour l’accomplissement de tout autre acte d’instruction”, with transfer authorised by the Minister of Justice under article 627-15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. France can therefore lend a detainee to the Court for testimony — consent and ministerial authorisation required — just as it must hand over a wanted person once the narrow manifest-error test is passed.

Put together, the French mechanism is a funnel: nationwide execution of the arrest request, 24 hours to see a prosecutor with custody safeguards, a maximum of five days to reach Paris, eight days to stand before the investigating chamber, fifteen days for its surrender order, two months for the Court of Cassation on appeal, one month to carry out the handover. Each deadline missed without insurmountable circumstances means release. Each substantive argument beyond manifest error belongs to The Hague. That is the procedure France defends in its statements — and it is also the procedure that makes the overflight question of Part I so pointed: everything the law describes with such precision applies on the ground, while the sky above remains, in Paris’s own words, outside any obligation.

Conclusion

October 2026 leaves France in a position that is coherent only if one accepts its central distinction. Washington has now sanctioned the International Criminal Court as an institution; Paris condemns the move as an attack on all 125 States Parties and on judicial independence, joins seven partners in expressing regret and strong disagreement, and works — with Belgium openly demanding it — toward European shields including the Blocking Statute. At the same time, Paris maintains that clearing a wanted man’s state aircraft through its airspace fully complied with international law because the Rome Statute imposes no overflight obligation. The Mongolia precedent shows where the undisputed duty lies: a suspect on the territory must be arrested and surrendered, personal immunity being no bar before the ICC. Between American coercion against the Court and French cooperation with it, the practical lesson for counsel is threefold. First, diary the American timetable: the six-month delayed effect announced by The Hague’s host country is a window for compliance planning, not a reprieve. Second, treat any landing, transit with custody, or even unscheduled stop on French soil as triggering the articles 627 to 627-10 funnel — 24 hours, five days, eight days, fifteen days, one month — with manifest error as the only lever in Paris. Third, never confuse the sky with the ground: what Paris tolerates at altitude it is bound to seize on the tarmac, and the difference between the two is not politics but the text of the Statute as France reads it. Whether the ICC’s judges would read it the same way, were a knowing overflight clearance ever referred under article 87(7), is the question this crisis has left open — and the one the next aircraft crossing European skies may force them to answer.

📄 Official circular