Kohen Avocats — Criminal defence
Criminal appeal lawyer in Paris: appealing a criminal judgment
Judgment, time limit, scope of the appeal and appeals by the prosecution: our criminal appeal lawyer in Paris examines your decision and prepares your defence before the Paris Court of Appeal (cour d'appel de Paris).
Has a judgment just been handed down? The time limit for appealing a judgment of the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) is in principle ten days, with specific starting points (Article 498 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale)). Send us the decision without delay.
Criminal appeal · Paris
Have your judgment reviewed
Send the decision and the documents you have received to our criminal defence firm in Paris so that the analysis of your appeal can be prepared.
Appeal
Judgment, time limit
and defence
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16th
Preparing your criminal appeal (appel pénal) in Paris
Criminal appeal · Paris 16th
What a criminal appeals lawyer does in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Criminal court appeals
- Defence and civil parties
- Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France)
After a criminal judgment, the lawyer first examines the full decision, its date and the way in which it was brought to your attention. The time limit for appeal in criminal court cases is in principle ten days, with specific starting points laid down by law (Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The firm checks this timetable, any appeals by the other parties and the points to be challenged: guilt, sentence or compensation.
Kohen Avocats prepares your defence before the Paris Court of Appeal: review of the case file, analysis of the procedural arguments, documents on your personal circumstances and written submissions (conclusions). The court re-examines the case only within the limits of the appeals lodged and of the rights of those who lodged them (Article 509 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Contact the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45 and send the judgment so that this analysis can be prepared.
Official profile in the French National Bar Council (CNB) directory of lawyersFirm located at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Checking the time limit
Judgment, summons, service and notice of appeal (déclaration d'appel): reconstructing the dates before any decision is taken.
Defining the appeal
Identifying the parts of the judgment being challenged and assessing the risk arising from the other parties' appeals.
Preparing the hearing
Taking up the relevant arguments again, updating the documents and preparing the requests to be put to the court.
Admissibility and notice of appeal
How to appeal a conviction within the time limit
The timetable depends on the judgment, on whether you were present or represented, and on the notification documents. Being absent when the judgment was delivered is not always enough to postpone the start of the time limit (Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
10 days
standard time limit for a criminal court judgment · art. 498
5 days
extra for the other parties · art. 500
20 days
for the chief prosecutor at the court of appeal (procureur général) after a conviction · art. 505
24:00 (midnight)
expiry at the end of the last day, subject to extension · art. 801
Starting point
Delivery or service of the judgment
In principle, time runs from the delivery of a judgment given after an adversarial hearing (jugement contradictoire). After an adversarial hearing, for a party who was absent and not represented when the judgment was delivered, postponing the start of the time limit until service requires that neither that party nor their representative was informed of the date on which judgment would be delivered (date du délibéré). Other situations are provided for where the defendant (prévenu) was tried in their absence (Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). A judgment by default or by repeated default (itératif défaut) is governed by Article 499. Certain judgments imposing imprisonment that have not been served on the defendant in person fall under the specific regime of Article 498-1.
Computation
The last day and appeals by the other parties
The time limit expires at midnight on the last day. A deadline falling on a Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday or non-working day is extended to the next working day (Article 801 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In the event of a conviction, the procureur général may also appeal within twenty days of the delivery of the decision (Article 505 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). An appeal by one party opens to the others the additional five-day period of Article 500: this does not always mean five days from that appeal. The French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) applies an overall time limit of fifteen days, subject to the statutory extensions (Cass. crim., 11 June 2025, No. 24-87.210, decision not to refer a priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality (QPC)).
Form
At the registry of the court that gave judgment
The notice of appeal is made to the clerk (greffier) of the court that delivered the judgment. It is signed by the clerk and by the appellant, a lawyer or a person holding a special power of attorney (fondé de pouvoir spécial), with the particulars required by Article 502. A person in detention may also lodge their appeal with the prison governor, who records, dates, signs and forwards the notice (Article 503 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). A relative may gather the documents; being a relative does not in itself replace the special power of attorney required to lodge the appeal.
Sending the judgment to the firm prepares the review of the case. It does not replace the notice of appeal required by Article 502. Have the registration of the appeal checked and keep a copy of the notice.
Guilt, sentence and civil interests
Choosing what the court will re-examine
Criminal court judgments can be appealed. The defendant and the public prosecution (ministère public) may appeal on the criminal charges (action publique); the civil party (partie civile) has a right of appeal only in respect of its civil interests (intérêts civils), that is, its claims for compensation (Article 496 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 497 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Guilt and sentence
Challenging the criminal decision
Specifying the offences concerned
- Disputing the facts and their legal classification within the scope of the appeal.
- Identifying the offences being challenged where the judgment convicts on several.
- Also stating whether the civil parts of the judgment are challenged (Article 502).
Sentence only
Limiting the appeal
One or more penalties, or the arrangements for applying them
- Not challenging the finding of guilt in your own appeal.
- Preparing the requests concerning the penalties imposed.
- Examining the prosecution's appeal separately: it may give the appeal proceedings a wider scope (Article 509).
Limiting the scope
Can you change the scope of your appeal?
The defendant may go back on a limitation to the sentence within one month of the notice of appeal; if the hearing takes place before then, they may do so at the hearing. They may also limit an appeal that was initially unlimited, up until the hearing (Article 502 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Where the limitation was made neither by the defendant's lawyer nor in the lawyer's presence, Article 509 allows the defendant to go back on that limitation at the hearing.
Risk on appeal
An appeal by the prosecution changes the analysis
Where the defendant alone appeals, the court cannot make their position worse. On an appeal by the public prosecution, it may rule in the defendant's favour or against them, within the limits of the case referred to it (Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). An appeal by the prosecution that is not limited may reopen partial acquittals (relaxes partielles) (Cass. crim., 15 May 2024, No. 23-86.129). Not appealing does not prevent the public prosecution from lodging its own appeal.
“Under this provision, the court of appeal may not, on the sole appeal of the defendant, the person civilly liable, the civil party or the insurer of any of those persons, make the appellant's position worse.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 24 June 2026, No. 25-88.142, § 7
Withdrawal
Checking which appeals will remain
If the defendant or the civil party withdraws their main appeal, the cross-appeals (appels incidents) lapse, provided the withdrawal follows the formalities of an appeal and is made at least two months before the hearing. It does not cancel another main appeal. Less than two months before the hearing, the prosecution may still withdraw the appeal it lodged after the defendant's, but the cross-appeals no longer lapse automatically (Article 500-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Hearing and enforcement of the judgment
Preparing the defence before the court of appeal
Checking the judgment
Noting the type of decision and the documents needed to calculate the time limit (art. 498).
Lodging the appeal
Specifying the parts of the judgment being challenged and keeping the notice of appeal (art. 502).
Reading all the appeals
Examining who lodged each appeal, when, and with what scope, including the prosecution's appeal (art. 509).
Preparing for the hearing
Gathering the first-instance written submissions, the supporting documents and the points to be argued.
Defending before the court
The defendant is questioned; the defendant or their lawyer always speaks last (art. 513).
Examining the appeal judgment
Considering the next steps and a possible appeal on points of law (pourvoi) for breach of the law (art. 567).
Before the merits
Raising the relevant procedural nullities again
Pleas of nullity (exceptions de nullité) must be raised before any defence on the merits (Article 385 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 512 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In a case where the prosecution had appealed against a judgment annulling procedural acts, the Cour de cassation reiterated that the defendant had to raise the plea again before the court of appeal. The firm checks what had been argued and what remains admissible on appeal.
“In so ruling, whereas it was for the defendant alone, even as respondent, to raise again, before any defence on the merits, the plea he had submitted to the criminal court, the court of appeal disregarded the aforementioned provisions and the principle set out above.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977, § 8
While the appeal is pending
Checking detention and enforceable measures
An appeal in principle suspends enforcement of the judgment, subject to the statutory exceptions (Article 506 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). It does not, by itself, lead to the release of a defendant placed or kept in detention after an immediate appearance trial (comparution immédiate) (Article 397-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Certain penalties may be provisionally enforceable (Article 471 of the Code of Criminal Procedure); an interim award to the civil party (provision) may also be enforceable despite the appeal (Article 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The operative part of the judgment (dispositif) must be read measure by measure.
There are statutory time limits for detained defendants. In immediate appearance proceedings, the court must rule within four months of the detained defendant's appeal against the judgment on the merits (Article 397-4). The regime of Article 509-1 provides for a four-month time limit for bringing the defendant before the court, with exceptional extensions and cases where it is six months. These regimes must be distinguished.
Assize court, police court and Cour de cassation
Identifying the right remedy
Assize court (cour d'assises)
A re-examination whose scope can be limited
An appeal against a conviction handed down at first instance is heard by another assize court or by the same assize court with a different composition (Article 380-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The time limit is in principle ten days from delivery of the judgment, with the exception for service provided for by Article 380-9. The accused (accusé) or the public prosecution may limit the appeal to certain offences. They may also limit it to the sentence without challenging the finding of guilt (Article 380-2-1 A). On an appeal by the accused alone, their position cannot be made worse (Article 380-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The procureur général may also appeal against acquittals (Article 380-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Police court (tribunal de police)
A criminal appeal is not available for every judgment
For the defendant and the public prosecution, an appeal lies in particular where the applicable fine is that for a fifth-class minor offence (contravention), where a driving licence suspension under point 1° of Article 131-16 of the French Criminal Code (Code pénal) has been imposed, or where the fine imposed exceeds the maximum for a second-class minor offence. The article also provides for cases specific to civil interests and to forestry prosecutions. The civil party may always appeal in respect of its civil interests (Article 546 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The firm checks the penalty and the appellant's standing before choosing the remedy.
Court of Cassation
Reviewing the legality of a decision given at last instance
An appeal on points of law (pourvoi en cassation) brings before the Criminal Chamber any breach of the law affecting a decision given at last instance (Article 567 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The Cour de cassation does not rule on the merits of cases, unless otherwise provided by statute (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Judicial Organisation (Code de l'organisation judiciaire)). The standard time limit for a criminal pourvoi is ten clear days (jours francs), subject to the specific starting points set out in Article 568. It is not calculated in the same way as the time limit for appeal.
Preparing the analysis of the appeal
Documents to send to the firm
Send the documents you have, even if the file is incomplete. Tell us straight away the date of the judgment, any detention and any hearing already scheduled.
- The full judgment, with its operative part and the date it was delivered.
- The summons, the notice of the date of judgment (avis de délibéré) and the documents served on you.
- The notice of appeal and copies of the other parties' appeals.
- The written submissions and documents produced at first instance.
- Up-to-date evidence of employment, address, family situation, training or medical care.
- Documents relating to the harm suffered, payments made and compensation.
Service of a document does not always start the time limit: it must be considered alongside the type of judgment and the circumstances of the hearing (Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 498-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 499 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Also send the envelopes and delivery notices.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about criminal appeals
The ten-day time limit has passed: can I still appeal?
The starting point must be checked before concluding that an appeal is late. For a judgment given after an adversarial hearing, time generally runs from delivery of the judgment. In certain situations covered by Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, it runs from service. Being absent when judgment is delivered is not enough on its own: after an adversarial hearing, whether you were informed of the date of judgment also matters.
Next, check the extensions of the last day provided for by Article 801 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. For certain convictions carrying a prison sentence, where the judgment has not been served on the defendant in person, Article 498-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for a specific regime linked to knowledge of the conviction. An obstacle that made it impossible to appeal in time may also be examined (Cass. crim., 11 June 2025, No. 24-87.210). These situations do not automatically reopen the time limit: send the judgment and all the documents you have received.
Can I receive a harsher sentence if I appeal?
If you alone appeal, the court cannot make your position worse: this is the protection provided by Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. However, an appeal by the public prosecution may allow a harsher decision, within the limits of the parts of the judgment referred to the court. The appeals actually registered, their admissibility and their scope must therefore be examined. The risk cannot be assessed solely on the basis that you initiated the appeal.
The public prosecution has the appeal rights provided for by Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 500 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and, for the procureur général following a conviction, Article 505 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The additional five-day time limit is not always calculated from your notice of appeal. The firm compares these appeals with the judgment to explain which points can still be argued.
Can I appeal against my sentence without challenging the conviction?
Yes. Article 502 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows an appeal on the criminal charges to be limited to the penalties imposed, some of those penalties or the arrangements for applying them. The notice of appeal must state this limitation. The same provision also allows the offences concerned to be specified where there are several convictions. Whether the decision on civil interests is challenged must be checked separately.
The defendant may withdraw a limitation to the sentence within one month of the notice of appeal, or at the hearing if it takes place sooner. Where the limitation was made neither by the defendant's lawyer nor by the defendant in the lawyer's presence, Article 509 of the Code of Criminal Procedure also allows it to be withdrawn at the hearing. Finally, limiting your appeal does not limit the prosecution's appeal: both notices must be read together before determining what the court will re-examine.
What is a cross-appeal in French criminal proceedings?
A cross-appeal is an appeal linked to an earlier appeal. Article 500 of the Code of Criminal Procedure gives the other parties an additional five days when one party appeals within the statutory time limit. Article 500-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure also treats an appeal lodged after an earlier appeal within the time limits of Articles 498 or 505 as a cross-appeal where the appellant expressly describes it as such. An appeal lodged after yours is therefore not necessarily a cross-appeal.
This distinction matters if withdrawal is being considered. If the defendant or civil party withdraws their main appeal in the required form at least two months before the hearing, the cross-appeals lapse, including the prosecution's. Withdrawal does not cancel another main appeal. The additional time limit must be calculated under the rules for computing time limits, rather than by automatically adding five days to the date of the first appeal.
Do I have to serve my sentence while my appeal is pending?
Enforcement of the judgment is generally suspended during the time limits for appeal and the appeal proceedings, subject to the statutory exceptions listed in Article 506 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This rule does not allow you to stop complying with an ongoing measure on your own initiative. The operative part of the judgment must be read to identify the decisions concerning liberty and the measures declared enforceable.
In particular, an appeal does not cancel an order placing or keeping a defendant in detention after an immediate appearance trial (Article 397-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Certain penalties may be declared provisionally enforceable (Article 471 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The judgment may also order provisional payment of damages or an interim award to the civil party despite the appeal (Article 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Send the full decision to the firm: a general answer about the suspensive effect of an appeal cannot establish which obligations remain in your case.
Which court hears an appeal from the criminal court in Paris?
An appeal against a criminal court judgment is heard by the court of appeal's criminal appeals chamber (chambre des appels correctionnels) (Article 496 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The firm prepares and presents your defence before the Paris Court of Appeal. The chamber generally comprises a presiding judge and two other judges. Article 510 nevertheless provides for a single judge in certain cases, with exceptions and the option to request a panel of judges.
The hearing includes an oral report by one of the judges, questioning of the defendant and submissions by the parties. The defendant or their lawyer always speaks last (Article 513 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The court does not necessarily reconsider the entire judgment: its remit depends on the notices of appeal and the appellants' standing (Article 509 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The firm prepares its requests within that scope.
Can a civil party appeal in a French criminal case?
Yes, but its right of appeal covers its civil interests only (Article 497 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). A civil party can challenge the rejection or the amount of its compensation claims. Its appeal alone cannot result in a criminal conviction or a harsher sentence. Its challenge over compensation must be distinguished from any appeal by the public prosecution on the criminal charges.
Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure prohibits a civil party from bringing new claims on appeal, while allowing it to seek an increase in damages for harm suffered since the first decision. The review therefore starts with the claims made before the criminal court, the judgment and the evidence of harm. Gather the first-instance written submissions, the relevant medical or financial documents and the documents relating to consequences arising since the judgment.
The prosecution has appealed: what are the risks?
An appeal by the public prosecution allows the court to rule in the defendant's favour or against them (Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). It may therefore expose the defendant to a harsher outcome, although this is not automatic. The notice must be read: does it cover all the criminal charges, certain offences, the sentence or particular penalties? Article 502 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Article 509 of the Code of Criminal Procedure govern that scope.
The Cour de cassation held that a prosecution appeal, whether a main appeal or a cross-appeal, that is not expressly limited brings all the criminal charges against the defendants concerned before the court of appeal (Cass. crim., 15 May 2024, No. 23-86.129). Partial acquittals may therefore be re-examined. The firm checks the appeal's admissibility, the parts of the judgment reopened and the arguments to present on each point.
What happens to procedural nullities upheld at first instance?
Where an appeal challenges a judgment that upheld a plea of nullity, you should not assume it will be upheld again without being raised. Such pleas must be presented before any defence on the merits (Article 385 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, applicable before the court of appeal under Article 512 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The Cour de cassation quashed a decision upholding a nullity on the prosecution's appeal when the defendant was absent and unrepresented.
It explained that the defendant, even as respondent, had to raise again the plea presented before the criminal court (Cass. crim., 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977). The firm therefore reviews the earlier written submissions and checks that they are presented on appeal before the merits are discussed. The admissibility of a new nullity challenge requires a separate assessment; see also our page on procedural nullities in criminal proceedings.
Can I withdraw my criminal appeal?
Yes. Article 500-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure governs withdrawal and its effects. Where the defendant or civil party withdraws their main appeal using the formalities required for a notice of appeal, at least two months before the hearing, the cross-appeals lapse, including the public prosecution's. This consequence does not extend to another main appeal.
Less than two months before the hearing, cross-appeals no longer lapse automatically. The public prosecution may nevertheless withdraw an appeal lodged after the defendant's if the defendant withdraws theirs. Withdrawal is recorded by an order of the presiding judge of the criminal appeals chamber. Before any step is taken, the firm checks the status of each appeal, the hearing date and the parts of the judgment that would remain disputed: withdrawing does not guarantee that the appeal proceedings will end.
Can I appeal against an assize court judgment?
A conviction handed down at first instance may be retried by another assize court or by the same court with a different composition (Article 380-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The time limit for appeal is generally ten days from delivery of the judgment, with a postponement until service in the specific situation covered by Article 380-9 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The judgment and the circumstances in which it was delivered must be examined to calculate the deadline.
The re-examination does not necessarily cover everything. The accused or the public prosecution may limit the appeal to certain offences. They may also limit it to the sentence without challenging the findings of guilt (Article 380-2-1 A of the Code of Criminal Procedure). On an appeal by the accused alone, their position cannot be made worse (Article 380-3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The procureur général may also appeal against acquittals (Article 380-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The strategy therefore requires all notices of appeal to be read.
How much does a criminal appeal cost in France?
The firm reviews the judgment and the work required before proposing the terms of its engagement. The volume of the case file, the disputed points and the hearings to prepare determine the scope of the work. The cost cannot be inferred solely from the fact that the case involves a criminal appeal.
Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971 provides that fees are agreed with the client and that a written agreement specifies, in particular, the amount of the fees or how they are determined, and the anticipated costs and disbursements. The provision makes exceptions including urgency, force majeure and full legal aid. Send the judgment and details of any legal expenses insurance or application for legal aid (aide juridictionnelle): reviewing them helps prepare the discussion without assuming that cover will be granted.
How long will I wait for my criminal appeal hearing?
The hearing date cannot be predicted from the judgment alone. There are, however, statutory time limits where a defendant is detained. After an immediate appearance trial, the court must rule within four months of the detained defendant's appeal against the judgment on the merits; otherwise, the defendant is released unless detained for another reason (Article 397-4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Under Article 509-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the defendant must appear before the court within four months of the appeal or of any subsequent placement in detention. Two exceptional extensions of four months, supported by reasons, are possible. The provision increases these periods to six months for certain offences or certain acts committed abroad. The applicable regime must be identified: these rules neither estimate waiting times in Paris nor guarantee a hearing on a stated date.
What is the difference between an appeal and a pourvoi en cassation?
An appeal allows the appellate court to re-examine the decision within the limits set by the notices of appeal and the appellants' standing (Article 509 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). It may concern guilt, penalties or civil interests. Preparation therefore focuses on the issues actually before the court, with the documents and arguments relevant to them.
An appeal on points of law concerns a decision given at last instance and seeks to have it quashed for breach of the law (Article 567 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The Cour de cassation does not rule on the merits, unless otherwise provided by statute (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). The standard time limit in criminal cases is ten clear days, with specific starting points (Article 568 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The decision being challenged must therefore be identified before choosing the remedy and calculating its time limit.
Is it always worth appealing a criminal judgment?
No. The review starts with the judgment's reasoning, the points you dispute and the requests you wish to put to the court. A challenge to the finding of guilt must be distinguished from a dispute over the sentence and a claim concerning civil interests. Article 502 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows the scope of the appeal to be specified; this option should be used after reading the case file.
The risk also depends on the other appeals: Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure prohibits making the defendant's position worse on their appeal alone, but allows a decision in their favour or against them on an appeal by the public prosecution. Not appealing does not prevent the prosecution from lodging its own appeal. The firm examines these factors with you, within the applicable time limit, to decide what requests to make. No outcome can be guaranteed simply by lodging an appeal.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Articles checked in the version applicable on 13 October 2026. Unless otherwise stated, references are to the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Decisions cited
24 June 2026, No. 25-88.142: protection against a harsher outcome · 15 April 2026, No. 25-84.977: raising nullity pleas again · 15 May 2024, No. 23-86.129: prosecution appeal · 11 June 2025, No. 24-87.210: cross-appeal time limit, QPC not referred.
Further reading
Page updated on 13 October 2026.
A criminal judgment to challenge?
The firm checks the time limit, examines the scope of the appeals and prepares the requests to put to the court. Send the judgment and any service documents you have.