Kohen Avocats, URSSAF joint liability lawyers for principal contractors in Paris
URSSAF joint liability lawyer in Paris: vigilance duty and defence
An URSSAF vigilance certificate (attestation de vigilance) to obtain, a subcontractor reported for undeclared work, a letter from URSSAF (the French social security contributions agency) declaring you jointly liable, contribution reductions cancelled: our URSSAF joint liability lawyers set up the checks for companies that subcontract and defend the principal contractor or project owner held liable. Joint financial liability (solidarité financière) requires a breach, an official report (procès-verbal) and sums that relate to your own works.
The firm can be reached 24/7. Where URSSAF invokes joint financial liability outside an audit under Article L. 243-7, you have thirty days, extended to sixty on request, to submit your observations (Article R. 133-8-2 of the French Social Security Code, Code de la sécurité sociale); the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) must then be referred to within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice tailored to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to point his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar: social security litigation, URSSAF audits, the duty of vigilance and principal contractors' joint financial liability.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Anyone who enters into a contract worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax must check, when the contract is concluded and then periodically until the end of its performance, that the other party is registered and declares its activity and its employees (Articles L. 8222-1 and R. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code, Code du travail); they are deemed to have done so if, every six months, they obtain the URSSAF vigilance certificate (attestation de vigilance) and proof of registration (Article D. 8222-5). Otherwise, they are jointly liable with the contracting party that was the subject of an official report (procès-verbal) for the offence of undeclared work for payment of its taxes, levies, contributions, penalties and surcharges, in proportion to the value of the services (Articles L. 8222-2 and L. 8222-3). URSSAF also cancels the principal contractor's contribution reductions, up to a ceiling (Article L. 133-4-5 of the French Social Security Code). From 26 December 2026, the project owner will also have to check the subcontractors it approves (Article L. 8222-1-1). Kohen Avocats, URSSAF joint liability lawyers in Paris 16th, advises companies that subcontract and defends those that URSSAF holds liable, from the amicable appeal to the social division of the court (pôle social). Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A certificate to check, a letter from URSSAF, joint liability to contest?
Understanding your situation
The principal contractor's joint financial liability (solidarité financière), explained
Vigilance is proven by specific documents, gathered at signature and then every six months (Article D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code). What to check, when URSSAF can make you jointly liable, how it must proceed, what you risk on your own contributions, and how to defend yourself.
Prevent
The duty of vigilance (obligation de vigilance): who checks what, and when
Four rules set the scope; the courts read the documents literally.
A threshold: the checks are mandatory for any transaction worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax (Article R. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code). They cover the other party's registration and its social security and tax returns, when the contract is concluded and then periodically until the end of its performance (Article L. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code).
Documents: the company is deemed to have carried out the checks if, when the contract is concluded and every six months, it obtains the certificate confirming that social security returns have been filed and contributions paid, less than six months old, whose authenticity it confirms with the collection body, and, where registration is mandatory, a K or K bis extract, an extract from the National Business Register (Registre national des entreprises) or a quotation bearing the registration number (Article D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code).
A complete certificate: where the other party employs staff, the vigilance certificate states the company's identification details, the number of employees and the total pay declared; the principal contractor checks its accuracy online or by means of a security code (Article D. 243-15 of the French Social Security Code, Article L. 243-15).
Special cases: for a contracting party established abroad, the check covers the equivalent regulations of its country and its obligations in France (Article L. 8222-4 of the French Labour Code), using the documents listed in Article D. 8222-7, written in French or translated (Article D. 8222-8). A private individual contracting for personal use needs only one of the documents (Article D. 8222-4).
The list cannot be replaced. The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) holds that the principal contractor “is deemed to have carried out the checks required by Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code where it has obtained from its contracting party the documents listed in Article D. 8222-5 of the Labour Code” (our translation). It overturned the judgment that had accepted sworn statements from the manager and a certificate from the self-employed scheme: the subcontracting company, which employed staff, had not provided the vigilance certificate, “which meant that the principal contractor had not carried out the checks incumbent upon it” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-21.152). On remittal, the Bordeaux Court of Appeal upheld the enforcement order (contrainte), noting that the texts “provide for no other document that can replace this certificate” (our translation) and holding that the principal contractor's good faith and reminders were irrelevant (CA Bordeaux, ch. sociale sect. B, 23 October 2025, No. 25/00595).
The documents themselves are not always enough. The presumption of vigilance “does not apply where there is a discrepancy between the declarations shown on these documents and the volume of working hours needed to perform the service” (our translation): the Court of Cassation overturned the judgment that had accepted a certificate declaring two employees and a payroll of 691 euros, without examining whether those figures were consistent with the information available to the principal contractor (Cass. 2e civ., 30 January 2025, No. 22-19.808). The same duty of vigilance applies to the employment of foreign nationals without a work permit (Article L. 8254-1 of the French Labour Code), with a separate joint liability for wages, compensation, removal costs and the administrative fine (Article L. 8254-2), and, for a foreign service provider posting employees, a check before the posting begins (Article L. 1262-4-1 of the French Labour Code).
See also our articles on the vigilance certificate and the principal contractor's joint financial liability and on foreign subcontractors posting employees to France.
The risk
Joint financial liability: conditions, scope and the 26 December 2026 reform
Joint liability is not automatic: each condition must be checked in the URSSAF file.
The breach
Anyone who fails to comply with Article L. 8222-1, and anyone convicted of having used, directly or through an intermediary, the services of a person engaged in undeclared work, is jointly liable with the person who was the subject of an official report for the offence of undeclared work (Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code).
The sums
Taxes, levies and compulsory contributions, with penalties and surcharges, owed by the contracting party; repayment of the public aid it received; the pay, compensation and charges due for the employment of undeclared employees (Article L. 8222-2, 1° to 3°).
The measure
These sums are determined “in proportion to the value of the works carried out, the services provided, the goods sold and the pay applicable in the profession” (our translation) (Article L. 8222-3 of the French Labour Code).
The injunction
The project owner or principal contractor informed in writing, by an inspection officer, a trade union, a professional association or an employee representative body, that a contracting party, subcontractor or sub-delegate in an irregular situation is involved “immediately orders its contracting party to put an end to this situation without delay” (our translation); otherwise, it is jointly liable (Article L. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code). Public bodies have a similar obligation (Article L. 8222-6).
The criminal aspect
Knowingly using, directly or through an intermediary, the services of a person engaged in undeclared work is prohibited (Article L. 8221-1 of the French Labour Code) and punishable by three years' imprisonment and a fine of 45,000 euros (Article L. 8224-1). The offence requires knowledge of the undeclared work; joint liability under Article L. 8222-2, by contrast, penalises the mere failure to check.
26 December 2026
Article L. 8222-1-1, introduced by Law No. 2026-534 of 25 June 2026, enters into force “on a date set by decree, and at the latest six months after the promulgation of this law” (our translation) (Article 95, III, of the law); Légifrance gives 26 December 2026: the project owner “periodically checks, until the end of performance of the subcontract of a minimum amount” (our translation), that the subcontractor it approves completes its formalities; the list of documents is to be set by decree (Article L. 8222-1-1 of the French Labour Code). From the same date, joint liability extends to breaches of this provision (Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code, as worded from 26 December 2026).
The official report is the key document. These reports are authoritative until proven otherwise (Article L. 8271-8 of the French Labour Code), but the principal contractor may challenge their existence or content: the Court of Cassation then holds that “the collection body is required to produce this report before the social security court where the principal contractor disputes the existence or content of this document” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128), and that the annexes form part of it: “This production must include all the annexes that supplement the report drawn up against the subcontractor.” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-15.899). The contributions claimed must also relate to your own worksites: joint liability can only be enforced if the evaded contributions “relate to the works it carried out on behalf of the same principal contractor” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 January 2026, No. 23-19.281).
Until 26 December 2026, the duty of vigilance under Article L. 8222-1 covers only the direct contracting party. The Court of Cassation has held that, for the purposes of Article L. 8222-1, “the project owner is not subject to a duty of vigilance towards its contracting party's subcontractor” (our translation), even one approved with direct payment, and overturned the judgment that had held it jointly liable although the main contractor had not been the subject of any official report (Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121). The new Article L. 8222-1-1 creates a separate duty to check, but only for the subcontractors the project owner approves; the injunction under Article L. 8222-5 already covers subcontractors reported in writing.
The proportion is argued with the documents in hand. In a judgment unfavourable to the principal contractor, the Metz Court of Appeal noted that URSSAF must produce the official report, show a service worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax and establish the failure to check; since the company did not produce its quotations or separate out the worksites below the threshold, the court upheld a calculation made “on the basis of all the sums invoiced to it” (our translation) and ordered the principal contractor to pay 27,349 euros (CA Metz, ch. sociale, sect. 3, 15 October 2026, No. 24/01906). See also our article on the project owner's vigilance towards approved subcontractors.
The procedure
How URSSAF holds the principal contractor liable
Two routes coexist, each with its own formalities; every step starts a time limit.
After an audit
Where joint liability is sought following an audit under Article L. 243-7, the inspector sends a letter of observations (lettre d'observations) to the principal contractor; the Court of Cassation held that, under the law applicable to the dispute, a letter signed by the collection inspector was valid (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-17.622, Article R. 243-59 of the French Social Security Code).
Outside an audit
Since 1 January 2026, where the reassessment does not result from such an audit, it is notified to the principal contractor or project owner “by a dated document signed by the director of the collection body” (our translation), sent by any means giving a certain date of receipt (Article R. 133-8-2 of the French Social Security Code, introduced by Decree No. 2025-1338 of 26 December 2025).
The required content
This document states the provisions breached by the contracting party and those on which joint liability is based, the period of undeclared work, the references of the official report, the nature of the sums, their amount broken down by year and the calculation method, as well as the option of being assisted by an adviser (Article R. 133-8-2).
The observations
Thirty days from receipt, extended to sixty on request. The director must reply: “Each observation expressed in a detailed manner receives a reasoned reply.” (our translation) (Article R. 133-8-2).
Recovery
At the end of the adversarial period, if payment is not made, the body starts recovery with a formal notice (mise en demeure) (Article L. 244-2 of the French Social Security Code) stating the cause, nature and amount of the sums claimed and the period to which they relate (Article R. 244-1).
Appeals
The amicable appeals board must be referred to within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code), a mandatory step before any court action (Article L. 142-4); these time limits can only be relied on if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A).
The amount must be broken down. Under Article R. 243-59 as then applicable, the Court of Cassation held that the letter of observations must, “in order to ensure the adversarial nature of the audit and safeguard the rights of the defence of the principal contractor whose joint financial liability is sought, specify year by year the amount of the sums due” (our translation), and annulled, without remittal, a letter claiming 149,847 euros together with the formal notice that followed (Cass. 2e civ., 13 February 2020, No. 19-11.645). The 2026 text restates this requirement of an amount broken down by year.
Contributions become time-barred three years after the end of the calendar year for which they are due (Article L. 244-3 of the French Social Security Code), but this period is extended to five years where an illegal work offence is recorded in an official report (Article L. 244-11). The principal contractor does not have all of the subcontractor's defences: according to the Court of Cassation, it “cannot, on the other hand, raise against the collection body those affecting the formal notice served, where applicable, on its subcontractor” (our translation), and URSSAF “may choose to pursue only the principal contractor” (our translation) for recovery of the sums (Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 22-23.817).
See also our pages on the URSSAF letter of observations, the URSSAF formal notice and the URSSAF enforcement order (contrainte), and our article on the two procedures for holding the principal contractor liable.
Your own contributions
Cancellation of the principal contractor's contribution reductions
A penalty separate from joint liability, which concerns the reductions relating to your own employees, not those of the subcontractor.
Where the principal contractor fails to meet one of the obligations under Article L. 8222-1 and its contracting party has, during the same period, engaged in undeclared work, the body cancels the contribution reductions or exemptions the principal contractor received on the pay of its own employees; the same penalty applies to failure to issue the injunction under Article L. 8222-5 (Article L. 133-4-5 of the French Social Security Code).
The cancellation applies for each month in which the conditions are met, and is calculated under the rules of Article L. 133-4-2 (Article L. 133-4-5, I).
It is capped at the total amount of the sums due under joint liability; where there has been no cancellation in the previous five years, the cap is reduced to 15,000 euros for an individual and 75,000 euros for a legal entity (Article L. 133-4-5, II).
Only partial cancellation is possible where the concealment represents a limited proportion (Article L. 133-4-2, III), assessed against thresholds of 10% or 5% of declared pay (Article R. 133-8 of the French Social Security Code); for the principal contractor, its own payroll is substituted for that of the employees of the audited person (Article L. 133-4-5).
Outside an audit under Article L. 243-7, the reassessment is notified to the principal contractor by a document signed by the director, which sets out the references of the official report, the breach, the period and the proposed amount, with thirty days to submit observations (Article R. 133-8-1 of the French Social Security Code).
The 35% reassessment surcharge applicable in cases of undeclared work may be reduced for a principal contractor that pays under the conditions of Article L. 243-7-7; under the reform, which enters into force on the same date as Article L. 8222-1-1 (Article 95, III, of the law of 25 June 2026, with Légifrance dating this version 25 December 2026), it will no longer be liable for it if it pays in full, or submits a payment schedule accepted by the director of the body, within a time limit set by decree adopted after consultation of the Council of State (Article L. 243-7-7 of the French Social Security Code, as worded from 25 December 2026).
Here too, the official report must be produced. The Court of Cassation approved a court of appeal which, URSSAF having failed to produce it although the principal contractor disputed it, “correctly inferred that the reassessment made in respect of the cancellation of the reductions or exemptions of social security contributions received by the latter had to be annulled” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 10 April 2025, No. 22-23.377).
The procedure was clarified in 2026, at first in a direction unfavourable to the principal contractor: the director “may delegate signing authority to a collection inspector of the body to sign the documents to be sent to principal contractors” (our translation), the Audited Contributor's Charter (Charte du cotisant contrôlé) need not be mentioned, and sending the official report to the public prosecutor has no bearing. But the same judgment quashes on a useful point: late-payment surcharges “run only from the date on which the amount of this penalty becomes payable” (our translation), that is, one month after the formal notice sent to the principal contractor (Cass. 2e civ., 29 January 2026, No. 23-18.747).
See also our articles on cancellation of the principal contractor's exemptions and on reduced cancellation where concealment is limited.
Two stages
Organising vigilance, or contesting joint liability
The same rule is worked on before the contract and after the letter from URSSAF.
You want to secure your subcontracting
- Identify transactions worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax, worksite by worksite rather than invoice by invoice.
- Obtain the vigilance certificate and proof of registration at signature and then every six months, and check the certificate's authenticity.
- Compare the declared workforce with the volume of work entrusted, include clauses on document delivery and termination, and deal immediately with any written report.
URSSAF declares you jointly liable
- Demand the official report and all its annexes, and check that it concerns works carried out for you.
- Check the document received: signatory, required content, breakdown by year, calculation method, time limit for reply.
- Challenge the threshold, the proportion, the period, the limitation period and the validity of the subcontractor's reassessment.
Irregularities in the subcontractor's reassessment benefit the principal contractor. The Constitutional Council preserved its right to challenge the regularity of the procedure and the merits and enforceability of the sums, and the Court of Cassation infers from this that “the principal contractor may rely, in support of its challenge to joint financial liability, on the irregularities affecting the reassessment made against its contracting party on grounds of undeclared work” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128). Applying this rule, the Poitiers Court of Appeal annulled an enforcement order for 73,037 euros after holding void the letter of observations sent in 2016 to the subcontractor, signed by the inspectors and not by the director as Article R. 133-8 then required, since the procedure fell under the fight against illegal work and not under an audit pursuant to Article L. 243-7: “this irregularity renders the principal contractor's joint financial liability procedure irregular too” (our translation) (CA Poitiers, 1 October 2026, No. 22/02715).
The arguments the firm examines in every case:
The firm acts for principal contractors, public or private project owners and main contractors, in advisory work and litigation, before URSSAF, the amicable appeals board and the social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire). Where criminal proceedings are brought for using undeclared work, it also defends before the criminal courts (see our page on undeclared work in criminal law). A subcontractor facing a reassessment will find its own defence on the page URSSAF reassessment for undeclared work.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is the principal contractor's duty of vigilance in France?
It is the obligation, for anyone who enters into a contract for work, the supply of services or a commercial transaction, to check that the other party completes its formalities: registration where mandatory, and returns to the social protection bodies and the tax authorities, including the pre-employment declaration and the issue of payslips (Article L. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code, which refers to Articles L. 8221-3 and L. 8221-5). The check is made when the contract is concluded, and then periodically until the end of its performance.
The French Social Security Code lays down the same rule for contributions: the principal contractor checks that its contracting party is up to date with its filing and payment obligations towards the collection bodies (Article L. 243-15 of the French Social Security Code). In practice, proof is provided by the documents listed in Article D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code, provided at signature and then every six months.
This obligation should not be confused with the duty of vigilance of large companies in respect of human rights and the environment: it targets undeclared work. Failure to comply exposes you to joint financial liability (Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code) and to cancellation of your own contribution reductions (Article L. 133-4-5 of the French Social Security Code). The firm works with you to set up a collection and checking procedure suited to your volume of subcontracting.
From what contract amount does the duty of vigilance apply?
From 5,000 euros excluding tax. The checks are mandatory “for any transaction worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax” (our translation) (Article R. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code). The text refers to the transaction, not to each invoice: a worksite or a service invoiced in several instalments must be assessed as a whole. The Metz Court of Appeal thus looks at “the total amount of the services invoiced per worksite” (our translation) (CA Metz, ch. sociale, sect. 3, 15 October 2026, No. 24/01906).
The threshold must be proven, and the burden of proof turns against a disorganised company. In a judgment unfavourable to the principal contractor, the Metz Court of Appeal held that URSSAF had to show a service worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax; but the company, which claimed to work mainly on small quotations, produced none, and its invoices did not make it possible to separate out the worksites below the threshold. The court therefore upheld a calculation made “on the basis of all the sums invoiced to it” (our translation) and ordered the principal contractor to pay 27,349 euros (CA Metz, ch. sociale, sect. 3, 15 October 2026, No. 24/01906).
So keep, for each subcontractor, the accepted quotations, the purchase orders and a summary per worksite. For the project owner, the new Article L. 8222-1-1, applicable from 26 December 2026 according to Légifrance, leaves it to a decree to set the minimum amount of the subcontract concerned (Article L. 8222-1-1 of the French Labour Code).
Which documents should you request from a subcontractor or service provider in France?
For a contracting party established in France, two sets of documents, when the contract is concluded and then every six months until the end of its performance (Article D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code). First, the certificate confirming that social security returns have been filed and contributions paid, provided for in Article L. 243-15 of the French Social Security Code and known as the vigilance certificate (attestation de vigilance), less than six months old, whose authenticity you check with the collection body. Second, where registration is mandatory, a K or K bis extract, an extract from the National Business Register, a quotation or commercial document bearing the name, address and registration number, or the court registry's electronic acknowledgement of receipt.
No other document can replace this list. The Court of Cassation overturned a court of appeal that had been satisfied with sworn statements and a certificate from the self-employed scheme concerning only the manager: the principal contractor is deemed vigilant “where it has obtained from its contracting party the documents listed in Article D. 8222-5 of the Labour Code” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-21.152). On remittal, the Bordeaux Court of Appeal upheld the enforcement order for more than 20,000 euros in contributions (CA Bordeaux, ch. sociale sect. B, 23 October 2025, No. 25/00595).
If the subcontractor employs foreign nationals who require a work permit, the check also covers this point (Article L. 8254-1 of the French Labour Code). The firm drafts for you the list of documents, the contractual clause on their delivery and the six-monthly reminder schedule.
How do you check that an URSSAF vigilance certificate is authentic?
With URSSAF itself. The certificate is secured by an authentication system issued by the collection body, and the principal contractor checks the accuracy of the information it contains online or, on request, directly with that body by means of a security code (Article D. 243-15 of the French Social Security Code). Article D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code makes this check a condition of the presumption of vigilance: an unchecked certificate offers no protection.
It must also be read. Where the contracting party employs staff, the certificate states the number of employees and the total pay declared. The Court of Cassation holds that the presumption of vigilance “does not apply where there is a discrepancy between the declarations shown on these documents and the volume of working hours needed to perform the service” (our translation). It overturned, to the principal contractor's detriment, a judgment that had accepted a certificate declaring two employees and 691 euros of pay, without examining whether those figures were consistent with the information available to it (Cass. 2e civ., 30 January 2025, No. 22-19.808).
In practice, keep the certificate, dated proof that it was checked and a note on the workforce needed for the worksite entrusted. The firm audits these files before an audit and identifies high-risk subcontractors.
The subcontractor is established abroad: what must be checked?
Its obligations in its own country and its obligations in France. Where the contracting party working in France is established or domiciled abroad, the check covers the obligations arising from the equivalent regulations of its country of origin and those applicable to it in respect of its activity in France (Article L. 8222-4 of the French Labour Code).
The documents are set by Article D. 8222-7 of the French Labour Code: a document showing its individual identification number assigned under Article 286 ter of the French General Tax Code or, failing that, its identity and address; a document certifying that its social security position is in order under Regulation (EC) No. 883/2004 or an international social security agreement, together with, where the law of its country so provides, a document from the social security body certifying that it is up to date; and, where registration in a professional register is mandatory in its country, proof of that registration. These documents are written in French or accompanied by a translation (Article D. 8222-8 of the French Labour Code).
If the service provider posts employees, the principal contractor or project owner must also check, before the posting begins, that it has made its declarations; failing a copy of the declaration, it must itself send a declaration to the labour inspectorate within forty-eight hours of the start of the posting (Article L. 1262-4-1 of the French Labour Code). See our article on foreign subcontractors and the posting declaration.
What is the principal contractor's joint financial liability (solidarité financière)?
It is the obligation, for anyone who has not complied with the duty of vigilance, to pay together with its contracting party reported for undeclared work. Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code makes it jointly liable for payment of taxes, levies and compulsory contributions, penalties and surcharges, where applicable the repayment of public aid, and the pay, compensation and charges owed to undeclared employees. URSSAF can then claim these sums from you directly, and may even choose to pursue only you (Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 22-23.817).
The debt is not unlimited. The sums payable are determined “in proportion to the value of the works carried out, the services provided, the goods sold and the pay applicable in the profession” (our translation) (Article L. 8222-3 of the French Labour Code). And the Court of Cassation requires a link with your own worksites: joint liability can only be enforced if the evaded contributions “relate to the works it carried out on behalf of the same principal contractor” (our translation). It approved the annulment of formal notices sent to a company unconnected with the audited worksite (Cass. 2e civ., 8 January 2026, No. 23-19.281).
Joint liability comes on top of the cancellation of your own contribution reductions (Article L. 133-4-5 of the French Social Security Code). Using your invoices and the official report, the firm reconstructs the share genuinely attributable to your orders.
Is the project owner liable for its main contractor's subcontractors?
Until 26 December 2026, in principle no, as far as vigilance is concerned. The Court of Cassation holds that, for the purposes of Article L. 8222-1 of the French Labour Code, “the project owner is not subject to a duty of vigilance towards its contracting party's subcontractor” (our translation), even if it approved that subcontractor and agreed to direct payment; it quashed the judgment that held it jointly liable although the main contractor, its only contracting party, had not been reported (Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121).
Two qualifications. First, the injunction: a project owner informed in writing, in particular by an inspection officer, that a subcontractor in an irregular situation is involved must immediately order its contracting party to put an end to it, failing which it is jointly liable (Article L. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code). Second, the reform: Article L. 8222-1-1, introduced by the law of 25 June 2026, enters into force on a date set by decree, and at the latest six months after its promulgation (Article 95, III), that is, 26 December 2026 according to Légifrance; it requires the project owner to check periodically that the subcontractor it approves under the law of 31 December 1975 or the French Public Procurement Code completes its formalities, for subcontracts of a minimum amount, by means of documents to be listed by decree (Article L. 8222-1-1 of the French Labour Code). Joint liability will then cover this breach (Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code, as worded from 26 December 2026). A private individual building for personal use remains excluded.
The firm can adapt your subcontractor approval procedures now. See our article on the project owner's vigilance towards approved subcontractors and our page on construction law.
Does URSSAF have to prove the subcontractor's undeclared work?
Yes, through the official report. Joint liability requires a contracting party “that was the subject of an official report for the offence of undeclared work” (our translation) within the meaning of Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code. These reports are authoritative until proven otherwise (Article L. 8271-8 of the French Labour Code), but they must be produced if you dispute them.
The Court of Cassation holds that enforcing joint liability does not depend on the report being sent to the principal contractor beforehand, but that “the collection body is required to produce this report before the social security court where the principal contractor disputes the existence or content of this document” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128). It adds: “This production must include all the annexes that supplement the report drawn up against the subcontractor.” (our translation) Since the four annexes sent to the public prosecutor were not produced, the reassessment was annulled (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-15.899).
URSSAF must also establish the failure to check and, according to the Metz Court of Appeal, that the service was worth at least 5,000 euros excluding tax; in that case, the report produced on appeal was sufficient and the company was ordered to pay, as it had no documents on its worksites (CA Metz, ch. sociale, sect. 3, 15 October 2026, No. 24/01906). The firm systematically requests the full official report and checks its dates, the employees named and the worksites.
How does URSSAF hold a principal contractor jointly liable?
It depends on the route taken. If joint liability is sought following an audit under Article L. 243-7 of the French Social Security Code, the inspector sends you a letter of observations; the Court of Cassation held that, under the law applicable to the dispute, a letter signed by the collection inspector rather than by the director was valid (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-17.622).
In other cases, since 1 January 2026, the reassessment is notified to you “by a dated document signed by the director of the collection body” (our translation) (Article R. 133-8-2 of the French Social Security Code). This document states the provisions breached by the contracting party and those on which joint liability is based, the period of undeclared work, the references of the official report, the nature of the sums, their amount broken down by year and the calculation method, and the option of being assisted by an adviser. You have thirty days to submit your observations, sixty on request; each detailed observation calls for a reasoned reply. If payment is not made at the end of this period, URSSAF sends you a formal notice (Article R. 244-1 of the French Social Security Code).
The breakdown by year is a long-standing safeguard: the Court of Cassation annulled, without remittal, a letter of observations that did not specify “year by year the amount of the sums due” (our translation), together with the formal notice that followed it (Cass. 2e civ., 13 February 2020, No. 19-11.645). See our article on the two procedures for holding the principal contractor liable and our page on the URSSAF letter of observations.
Can the reassessment made against the subcontractor be contested?
Yes. As the Court of Cassation points out, the Constitutional Council declared Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code constitutional on condition that the principal contractor can challenge the regularity of the procedure and the merits and enforceability of the sums. The Court of Cassation infers from this that “the principal contractor may rely, in support of its challenge to joint financial liability, on the irregularities affecting the reassessment made against its contracting party on grounds of undeclared work” (our translation), even if the subcontractor contested nothing (Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128).
The Poitiers Court of Appeal applied this on 1 October 2026: the letter of observations sent to the subcontractor, signed in 2016 by the inspectors and not by the director as Article R. 133-8 then required for a procedure against illegal work conducted outside an audit under Article L. 243-7, was void, and “this irregularity renders the principal contractor's joint financial liability procedure irregular too” (our translation); the enforcement order for 73,037 euros was annulled (CA Poitiers, 1 October 2026, No. 22/02715).
The limit is clear: the principal contractor “cannot, on the other hand, raise against the collection body those affecting the formal notice served, where applicable, on its subcontractor” (our translation), which led to the dismissal of its appeal; nor does the court have to join the subcontractor or its employees to the proceedings (Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 22-23.817). The firm therefore insists, before the court, on production of the official report and all its annexes (Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128; Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-15.899), and selects the arguments that matter.
Does the principal contractor lose its own contribution reductions?
Yes, this is a separate penalty. Where it has failed to meet one of the obligations under Article L. 8222-1 and its contracting party has, during the same period, engaged in undeclared work, URSSAF cancels the contribution reductions or exemptions it received on the pay of its own employees, month by month (Article L. 133-4-5 of the French Social Security Code). The cancellation is capped at the amount of the sums due under joint liability and, where there has been no cancellation in the previous five years, at 15,000 euros for an individual and 75,000 euros for a legal entity.
The safeguards of joint liability apply: where the disputed official report was not produced, the Court of Cassation approved a court of appeal that “correctly inferred that the reassessment made in respect of the cancellation of the reductions or exemptions of social security contributions received by the latter had to be annulled” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 10 April 2025, No. 22-23.377). By contrast, in 2026, it accepted the director's delegation of signing authority to an inspector and held irrelevant the question of whether the report had been sent to the public prosecutor; it quashed only on late-payment surcharges, which run only one month after the formal notice sent to the principal contractor (Cass. 2e civ., 29 January 2026, No. 23-18.747).
A reduced cancellation is available where the concealment represents a limited proportion of the activity (Article L. 133-4-2 of the French Social Security Code, Article R. 133-8). See our article on cancellation of the principal contractor's exemptions.
What are the time limits for contesting URSSAF joint liability?
Three time limits matter. The first is for observations: thirty days from receipt of the URSSAF document, extended to sixty on request, the extension being deemed accepted in the absence of a reply (Article R. 133-8-2 of the French Social Security Code). This is the time to request the official report, challenge the calculation and produce your vigilance documents.
The second is for the appeal. The decision is first contested before the amicable appeals board, referred to within two months of its notification (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code); this prior appeal is mandatory before going to the social division of the judicial court (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code). These time limits can only be relied on if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A of the French Social Security Code).
The third is the limitation period for the debt. Contributions become time-barred three years after the end of the calendar year for which they are due (Article L. 244-3 of the French Social Security Code), but this period is extended to five years where an illegal work offence is recorded in an official report (Article L. 244-11 of the French Social Security Code). Since joint liability presupposes such a report, the longer period is intended to apply: the Angers Court of Appeal held that the principal contractor's obligation “follows the same regime as the obligation of the subcontractor who committed the offence” (our translation) and that the “limitation period applicable to the principal contractor in matters of joint financial liability is therefore the five-year period” (our translation) (CA Angers, ch. sécurité sociale, 29 September 2026, No. 23/00138). The calculation is made year by year. See our pages on the amicable appeals board and the social division of the court (pôle social).
Is the principal contractor's good faith enough to avoid joint liability?
No. Joint financial liability penalises an objective failure to carry out the checks, not an intention. The Bordeaux Court of Appeal, ruling after the case was quashed, held irrelevant the principal contractor's good faith, its written reminders, its early request for a new certificate and the urgency of the works, since the texts “provide for no other document that can replace this certificate” (our translation); it upheld the enforcement order (CA Bordeaux, ch. sociale sect. B, 23 October 2025, No. 25/00595, following Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-21.152).
Good faith does, however, carry its full weight in criminal law. The offence covers “knowingly” (our translation) using, directly or through an intermediary, the services of a person engaged in undeclared work (Article L. 8221-1 of the French Labour Code), punishable by three years' imprisonment and a fine of 45,000 euros (Article L. 8224-1 of the French Labour Code); for legal entities, Article L. 8224-5 adds in particular the fine applicable to legal entities, prohibitions and publication of the decision. A conviction on this count itself gives rise to joint liability (Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code).
The firm therefore keeps the two fields separate: in social security law, it challenges the objective conditions of joint liability; in criminal law, it contests knowledge of the undeclared work. See our page on undeclared work in criminal law and on unlawful supply of labour (délit de marchandage).
What are the fees of an URSSAF joint liability lawyer in Paris?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: audit of vigilance documents and subcontracts, drafting of clauses and the internal procedure, reply to the URSSAF document or the letter of observations, appeal to the amicable appeals board, proceedings before the social division of the court, appeal. Any new work is covered by an addendum, with no unexpected invoicing. The fixed fee reflects what is genuinely at stake in the case: the amount claimed under joint liability, the number of years concerned, any cancellation of your own contribution reductions, the number of subcontractors involved and the time limits already running.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, via the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles L. 8222-1, R. 8222-1, D. 8222-4 and D. 8222-5 of the French Labour Code: duty of vigilance, 5,000-euro threshold, documents
- Articles L. 8222-4, D. 8222-7, D. 8222-8 and L. 1262-4-1 of the French Labour Code: foreign contracting party, posting of workers
- Articles L. 8222-2, L. 8222-3, L. 8222-5 and L. 8222-6 of the French Labour Code: joint financial liability, proportion, injunction
- Article L. 8222-1-1 and Article L. 8222-2 of the French Labour Code (as worded from 26 December 2026): project owner's vigilance towards approved subcontractors, not yet in force on 31 October 2026
- Articles L. 8221-1, L. 8221-3, L. 8221-5, L. 8224-1, L. 8224-5 and L. 8271-8 of the French Labour Code: undeclared work, criminal penalties, official reports
- Articles L. 8254-1 and L. 8254-2 of the French Labour Code: vigilance and joint liability for employing foreign nationals without a work permit
- Articles L. 243-15 and D. 243-15 of the French Social Security Code: vigilance certificate, content and authentication
- Articles L. 133-4-5, L. 133-4-2, R. 133-8 and R. 133-8-1 of the French Social Security Code: cancellation of the principal contractor's contribution reductions, reduced cancellation, procedure
- Articles R. 133-8-2, R. 243-59, L. 244-2 and R. 244-1 of the French Social Security Code: holding the principal contractor liable, letter of observations, formal notice
- Article L. 243-7-7 of the French Social Security Code and its wording from 25 December 2026: reassessment surcharge and reduction for the principal contractor
- Articles L. 244-3, L. 244-11, L. 142-4, R. 142-1 and R. 142-1-A of the French Social Security Code: limitation period, amicable appeal, time limits
- Law No. 2026-534 of 25 June 2026 and Decree No. 2025-1338 of 26 December 2025 (Official Journal): reform of the project owner's vigilance, procedure under Article R. 133-8-2
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 5 December 2024, No. 22-21.152: list of documents in Article D. 8222-5
- Cass. 2e civ., 30 January 2025, No. 22-19.808: discrepancy with the volume of work
- Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121: project owner and its contracting party's subcontractor
- Cass. 2e civ., 8 January 2026, No. 23-19.281: contributions linked to works for the same principal contractor
- Cass. 2e civ., 23 June 2022, No. 20-22.128: irregularities in the subcontractor's reassessment, production of the official report
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-15.899: production of the annexes to the official report
- Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 22-23.817: the subcontractor's formal notice cannot be relied on by the principal contractor
- Cass. 2e civ., 13 February 2020, No. 19-11.645: amount of the sums year by year
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-17.622: letter of observations signed by the inspector
- Cass. 2e civ., 10 April 2025, No. 22-23.377: cancellation of exemptions without the official report being produced
- Cass. 2e civ., 29 January 2026, No. 23-18.747: delegation of signing authority and late-payment surcharges
- CA Metz, ch. sociale, sect. 3, 15 October 2026, No. 24/01906: 5,000-euro threshold and calculation of the sums
- CA Poitiers, 1 October 2026, No. 22/02715: nullity of the subcontractor's reassessment and enforcement order annulled
- CA Angers, ch. sécurité sociale, 29 September 2026, No. 23/00138: five-year limitation period for the joint liability claim
- CA Bordeaux, ch. sociale sect. B, 23 October 2025, No. 25/00595: vigilance certificate cannot be replaced, good faith irrelevant
Further reading
A subcontractor reported for undeclared work, a letter from URSSAF, joint liability to contest?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send us the document received from URSSAF, your subcontracts and quotations, the vigilance certificates and registration extracts collected, and your invoices: Hassan Kohen examines the conditions for joint liability, the calculation and the time limits, then advises you on the right course of action: observations, amicable appeal, proceedings before the social division of the court, or bringing your vigilance procedures into compliance.