In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, amicable appeals against French social security bodies in Paris
Commission de recours amiable lawyer in Paris: meet the CRA deadline
CPAM, URSSAF, CAF, pension fund or MSA: before any court action, a decision of the body must in principle be challenged before its amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) within two months of its notification. As your commission de recours amiable lawyer in Paris, the firm drafts the claim, checks the time limits and the competent board, then brings the case before the court if the board rejects the appeal or remains silent: the social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire) or, for the in-work benefit (prime d'activité) and housing benefits, the administrative courts.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The amicable appeals board must be referred to within two months of the notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code, Code de la sécurité sociale); this time limit can only be raised against you if it was stated, together with the available remedies, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice adapted to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome he secured for my defence in court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, who knows how to point his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he has done.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, social security litigation, appeals before amicable appeals boards (commissions de recours amiable) and the social division of the judicial court.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) is the mandatory step before the court: court actions against decisions of social security bodies must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code), brought before the board set up within the council or board of directors of each body, within two months of the notification of the decision (Article R. 142-1). This time limit can only be raised if it appears, together with the available remedies, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A). If no decision is given within two months of receipt of the claim, the claim may be treated as rejected (Article R. 142-6), and the social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire) may be seized within two months, a time limit that can only be raised if it appears in the acknowledgement of receipt of the claim (Article R. 142-1-A, III). Medical disputes go before the medical amicable appeals board (commission médicale de recours amiable) (Article R. 142-8). Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts for insured persons, benefit recipients, contributors and employers. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Received a decision from a fund or from URSSAF, with a two-month time limit running?
Understanding your situation
The commission de recours amiable, explained
The prior appeal is a precondition for going to court (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code). What the board examines, the time limit for referring a case to it, how to draft the claim, what happens after its decision or its silence, and the specific rules on URSSAF debt recovery.
Key points
A board within each body, and an appeal that conditions the court case
The board is not a court: it emanates from the council of the body that took the decision, and it must be referred to before any appeal to the court.
Mandatory appeal: court actions brought in social security litigation matters, except for the setting of workplace accident contribution rates referred to in 7° of Article L. 142-1, must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code).
Body concerned: claims against decisions of social security bodies and of the agricultural social insurance scheme (mutualité sociale agricole), for employees or the self-employed, are submitted to an amicable appeals board set up within the council, the board of directors or the regional body of each organisation (Article R. 142-1).
Composition: in the general scheme, two representatives of insured persons and two representatives of employers and self-employed workers, sometimes a fifth member; three and three at the national old-age insurance fund (caisse nationale d'assurance vieillesse); two representatives of the self-employed and two of employees in the agricultural social insurance scheme (Article R. 142-2).
Decision: the board gives its opinion to the council, which rules and notifies its decision, unless it has delegated its powers to the board; the decision states its reasons and specifies the time limits and available remedies (Article R. 142-4).
The scope is broad. Social security litigation includes in particular disputes relating to the application of social security and agricultural social insurance legislation and regulations, and to the recovery of contributions (Article L. 142-1, 1° and 2°). A refused benefit, a claim for repayment of an overpayment (indu), a disputed affiliation or a formal notice (mise en demeure) to pay contributions therefore go, in principle, through the board of the body that took the decision.
Several decisions nevertheless fall outside the board. The penalties and sanctions under Articles L. 114-17 and L. 114-17-1 are not subject to the prior appeal (Article L. 142-4): "The penalty shall state its reasons and may be challenged before the specially designated judicial court" (our translation) (Article L. 114-17-2). Nor does the board procedure apply to medical disputes, which are entrusted to the medical amicable appeals board, or to certain disputes over the remission of surcharges (Article R. 142-7). Finally, where the decision was taken by a committee provided for by a statutory text or by the articles of association, or following its opinion, the council rules directly on the claim (Article R. 142-5).
Decisions of the commission for the rights and autonomy of disabled persons also fall within social security litigation (Article L. 142-1, 8°), but they are not taken by a fund: see our page on our MDPH disability decisions lawyer. Workplace accidents and occupational diseases have their own rules on recognition: see our workplace accident lawyer page. The main page for this area is our social security law lawyer page.
The time limit
Two months from notification, on one condition
The time limit is short, but it only runs if the decision was properly notified, with the available remedies and time limits.
Starting point
The board "must be referred to within two months of the notification of the decision against which the persons concerned intend to lodge a claim" (our translation) (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code).
Notification
Decisions of the bodies are notified by any means that gives the notification a certain date, and prior appeals are governed by the Code on relations between the public and the administration (code des relations entre le public et l'administration), subject to specific provisions (Article R. 142-1-A, I).
Condition for the time limit to apply
"These time limits can only be raised on condition that they, together with the available remedies, were stated in the notification of the contested decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application" (our translation) (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
Late appeal
Once the properly notified time limit has passed, the claim is time-barred (forclose) and the appeal subsequently brought before the court is declared inadmissible, as illustrated by the judgment of the Versailles Court of Appeal cited below.
The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) draws all the consequences of this condition. Where the acknowledgement of receipt of the prior appeal does not state the time limits and remedies, "the time bar on the court action cannot be raised against an applicant whose prior appeal, which constitutes an application within the meaning of the aforementioned text, was the subject of an implicit rejection decision by the amicable appeals board" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-15.393). Likewise, a notification that does not state the time limit for the court action does not cause it to run: the Court holds that "in the absence of proper notification of the remedies and time limits" (our translation), the two-month time limit does not run (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186).
Where the notification is proper, on the other hand, the time limit is strict. The Versailles Court of Appeal declared inadmissible the appeal of an insured person who had written to the board two days after the time limit expired, without producing the postal receipt for the letter, and refused to treat sick leave for asthenia as an impediment: this circumstance "cannot constitute a case of force majeure" (our translation) (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712). And an improper notification does not exempt you from referring the matter to the board: for the Paris Court of Appeal, the burden of proving the prior referral lies "with the party who alleges it" (our translation), and an appeal brought directly before the court remains inadmissible (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782).
The firm dates the time limit from the document that starts it running: the acknowledgement of receipt of the notification, the statement of available remedies, the acknowledgement of receipt of the appeal. See our article on the time bar on appeals before the CPAM amicable appeals board.
The claim
Choosing the right board, then writing as if for the judge
The claim sets what the court will be able to examine afterwards: its subject matter counts as much as its timing.
Amicable appeals board
- Administrative decisions of the body: eligibility conditions, amount of a benefit, overpayment (indu), affiliation.
- Contributions: formal notice (mise en demeure) from URSSAF or the MSA after an audit.
- Claim sent to the secretariat of the board of the body that took the decision, with the decision and the supporting documents.
Medical amicable appeals board
- Medical disputes, state or degree of invalidity, unfitness for work, permanent incapacity for work and its rate.
- Written application, with a copy of the contested decision, sent by any means that gives a certain date of receipt.
- Reasoned opinion, "which is binding on the paying body" (our translation).
The choice of board follows from the texts. For medical disputes and for invalidity, unfitness for work and permanent incapacity, the prior appeal is submitted to a medical amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-8), to which the consulting medical officer (praticien-conseil) sends the full medical report supporting his or her decision (Article L. 142-6); it gives an opinion that is binding on the body (Article R. 142-8-5). Getting it wrong is costly: an insured person challenging a refusal to recognise an occupational disease based on two grounds had referred the matter only to the amicable appeals board, without challenging before the medical board the incapacity rate set by the medical adviser; the Paris Court of Appeal held that, for disputes falling within both boards, "the failure to make the mandatory prior referral to one or other board", subject to certain cases of transfer, "is sanctioned by the inadmissibility of the appeal" (our translation), and, since the medical board had not been seized, declared the action inadmissible (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 18 September 2026, No. 23/06494).
A decision that combines an administrative ground and a medical ground must therefore be challenged before both boards, each for its own part. The amicable appeals board then stays its ruling until the opinion of the medical board, which is binding on it, and then "rules on the appeal as a whole" (our translation); in the absence of a decision, implicit rejection only occurs at the end of a period "of six months from the lodging of the prior appeal" (our translation) (Article R. 142-9-1). The claim itself is drafted like written submissions (conclusions): the decision concerned, the facts, the legal texts, numbered documents and a precise request. Documents sent afterwards affect the timetable: if documents are produced by the claimant after the claim has been lodged, the two-month period after which the claim may be treated as rejected "only runs from the date of receipt of those documents" (our translation) (Article R. 142-6).
What the firm checks and gathers before writing:
See our articles on medical disputes before the medical amicable appeals board and on the prior appeal before the CPAM amicable appeals board.
After the board
Decision, silence, then the social division of the judicial court
Rejection, express or implicit, opens the way to an appeal before the court, within a new two-month time limit.
Reasoned decision
The council, or the board acting under delegation, rules and notifies a reasoned decision, which specifies the time limits and available remedies; after a reassessment (redressement), it details for each ground the amounts cancelled and those still due (Article R. 142-4).
Two months of silence
Where the decision has not been brought to the applicant's attention within two months, running from receipt of the claim, "the person concerned may treat the claim as rejected" (our translation) (Article R. 142-6).
Time limit for court action
Unless otherwise provided, the time limit for bringing a court action is two months from the notification of the contested decision, subject to the same condition that the remedies and time limits be stated (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
Competent court
The social division of the specially designated judicial court (Article L. 211-16 of the French Code of Judicial Organisation, Code de l'organisation judiciaire), in principle the one for the area where the claimant lives; certain contribution disputes fall within the area of the head office of the collection body (Article R. 142-10). Court actions concerning the in-work benefit (prime d'activité) and personal housing benefits are, by contrast, brought before the administrative courts (Article L. 845-2 of the French Social Security Code; Article L. 825-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code, Code de la construction et de l'habitation).
Application
Lodged with or sent to the court registry by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, with a brief statement of the grounds, a list of documents and the contested decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, the initial decision and the prior appeal (Article R. 142-10-1).
Decision during the proceedings
The time bar cannot be raised against a claimant who challenged an implicit decision solely because he or she did not bring the matter before the court against the express rejection decision issued during the proceedings (Article R. 142-10-1).
The Court of Cassation takes a pragmatic approach to the timing of the referral to the court. Where the appeal is brought before the court before the board has ruled, the absence of a decision "does not prevent this appeal from being admissible, provided that a decision, implicit or express, has been issued before the judge rules" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 24-14.447). The same rule applies before the medical amicable appeals board, in favour of an employer who had brought the matter before the court before the fund's decision (Cass. 2e civ., 29 January 2026, No. 23-19.898). And forgetting the board can be remedied: the inadmissibility of an appeal brought directly before the court "does not prevent a new court action from being brought, after the amicable appeals board of the body has been seized, provided that it is brought before the time bar expires" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 22 October 2020, No. 19-18.175).
Once seized, the court decides the dispute itself: it must "rule on the merits of the dispute, the arguments raised before it alleging an irregularity in the decision of the amicable appeals board being ineffective" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756). Criticising only the board's decision is therefore pointless; it is the initial decision that must be challenged. Finally, the time limit for court action is unforgiving: a company that had received proper notification of the board's decision, stating the time limits and remedies, and had only brought the matter before the court almost two years later, saw its appeal declared time-barred, the Court of Cassation approving the lower court judges who had "correctly inferred that the company's court action of 28 November 2018 was time-barred" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 16 October 2025, No. 23-16.695).
Several of these judgments were given under earlier versions of the texts, in particular former Article R. 142-18, which then set the time limit for court action: this page applies their principle, the time limits applicable today being those of Articles R. 142-1, R. 142-1-A and R. 142-6. Our page on our social division of the judicial court lawyer details the court proceedings. See also our article on implicit rejection decisions and the time bar.
URSSAF and debt recovery
Formal notice, heads of reassessment, enforcement order (contrainte)
After an audit, it is not the letter of observations (lettre d'observations) that is challenged before the board, but the formal notice (mise en demeure).
Any action or proceedings to recover contributions must be preceded by a formal notice sent by registered letter or by any means that gives a certain date of receipt, whose content must be precise and reasoned (Article L. 244-2 of the French Social Security Code).
The formal notice specifies the cause, nature and amount of the sums claimed, the surcharges and penalties, the period concerned and, after an audit, the reference and dates of the letter of observations (Article R. 244-1).
The board's decision issued after a reassessment details, for each ground of reassessment, the amounts that are cancelled, where applicable, and those the contributor still owes under the formal notice (Article R. 142-4).
If the formal notice has no effect after one month, the director may issue an enforcement order (contrainte); the objection (opposition) is lodged with the court secretariat within fifteen days of its notification or service, and it must state its grounds, with a copy of the enforcement order (Article R. 133-3).
If no objection is lodged, the enforcement order has all the effects of a judgment and in particular confers the benefit of a judicial mortgage (Article L. 244-9).
Referring the matter to the board too early is a common mistake. For the Paris Court of Appeal, "the decision taken at the end of a recovery procedure does not consist of the letter of observations or the replies of the collection inspector, but of the notification of the formal notice that follows" (our translation): the board seized before the formal notice had been seized to no purpose, the company had not lodged a claim against the formal notice, and the court confirmed that "The appeal brought directly before the court following notification of the formal notice is therefore inadmissible. The formal notice is therefore final." (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/00516).
The claim also sets the boundaries of the court case. The contributor may raise before the court "arguments other than those raised before the amicable appeals board, provided that they concern the heads of reassessment previously contested" (our translation); but if only some of them were contested, "the dispute cannot be extended to the other heads" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 12 May 2022, No. 20-18.078). As regards the enforcement order, the Court of Cassation holds that a contributor who did not challenge the formal notice before the board may, in support of the objection, "challenge the regularity of the procedure and the merits of the grounds of the enforcement order" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 22 September 2022, No. 21-10.105). The judgment distinguishes the contributor who seized the board and then did not challenge its decision in time: in that case, the Court had approved a court of appeal holding that the objection remained admissible, but that "the merits of the disputed reassessment could no longer be discussed" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 4 April 2019, No. 18-12.014), a judgment whose solution was abandoned in 2022 for the contributor who had not seized the board, but maintained in that situation.
URSSAF litigation has its own pages: URSSAF litigation lawyer, the URSSAF amicable appeals board (CRA URSSAF), the URSSAF letter of observations, the URSSAF formal notice and the URSSAF enforcement order. See also our article on objecting to an enforcement order since the 2022 reversal of case law.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is the commission de recours amiable (amicable appeals board)?
It is the body within each social security organisation that examines claims against its own decisions, before any court case. Claims lodged against decisions of social security bodies and of the agricultural social insurance scheme "are submitted to an amicable appeals board composed and set up within the council, the board of directors or the regional body of each organisation" (our translation) (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code). The CPAM, URSSAF, the CAF, the pension fund and the MSA each have their own.
It brings together directors of the body: in the general scheme, two representatives of insured persons and two representatives of employers and self-employed workers (Article R. 142-2). It gives its opinion to the council, which rules, unless it has delegated its powers to the board; the decision states its reasons and specifies the time limits and available remedies (Article R. 142-4). Its secretariat is run by staff of the body.
Going through it is mandatory: court actions must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4). It is not a judge, and the court seized afterwards decides the merits of the dispute itself, criticisms directed only at the board's decision being ineffective (Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756). Yet it is at this stage that the date of the appeal and the heads of the challenge are fixed: the claim should be prepared with the same care as an application to the court.
What is the time limit to appeal to the commission de recours amiable?
Two months. The board "must be referred to within two months of the notification of the decision against which the persons concerned intend to lodge a claim" (our translation) (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code). The time limit runs from the notification, which the body must make by any means that gives a certain date (Article R. 142-1-A, I).
It comes with a condition: "These time limits can only be raised on condition that they, together with the available remedies, were stated in the notification of the contested decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application" (our translation) (Article R. 142-1-A, III). A decision notified without its remedies and time limits therefore does not cause the time limit to run, and the Court of Cassation applies the rule to the acknowledgement of receipt of the prior appeal (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-15.393).
Where the notification is proper, the court applies the time limit to the letter. The Versailles Court of Appeal held time-barred an insured person who had written to the board two days too late, without producing proof of the date of sending, and did not accept his sick leave as a case of force majeure (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712). The firm advises acting well before the deadline, by a method of sending that leaves a dated record, and keeps proof of posting.
How do I file a claim with the commission de recours amiable, and at what address?
In writing, at the address given in the notification of the contested decision. The decision must state the available remedies (Article R. 142-1-A, III): it is this section that designates the competent board and its secretariat. The firm does not rely on an address found elsewhere, because some funds have several boards (Article R. 142-2) or, in certain cases, entrust the examination of claims to the board of another body (Article R. 142-3).
Prior appeals are governed by the Code on relations between the public and the administration, subject to specific provisions (Article R. 142-1-A, I). In practice, the claim identifies the claimant and the contested decision, sets out the factual and legal grounds, attaches the supporting documents and makes a precise request: annulment, a quantified reduction, payment of a benefit. It is sent by a method that proves its date, because the date matters: the Versailles Court of Appeal applied the time bar to a letter dated two days after the deadline, for which no postal receipt was produced (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712).
It is better to send everything at once: if documents are produced after the claim has been lodged, the period after which the claim may be treated as rejected only runs from the date of their receipt (Article R. 142-6). For a medical dispute, the application goes to the secretariat of the medical amicable appeals board, with a copy of the decision (Article R. 142-8).
The commission de recours amiable has not replied: what can I do?
Treat the claim as rejected, then bring the matter before the court. Where the decision has not been brought to the applicant's attention within two months, "the person concerned may treat the claim as rejected"; this period "runs from receipt of the claim by the social security body" (our translation) (Article R. 142-6 of the French Social Security Code). The social division of the judicial court is then seized by application, accompanied by the initial decision and the prior appeal (Article R. 142-10-1).
The time limit for acting against this implicit rejection depends on the acknowledgement of receipt of the appeal. If that acknowledgement did not state the time limits and remedies, "the time bar on the court action cannot be raised against an applicant" (our translation) whose prior appeal was implicitly rejected (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-15.393). If it did state them, the two-month time limit under Article R. 142-1-A, III, applies: the firm calculates it as soon as the acknowledgement is received.
If the board replies after the court has been seized, the appeal remains valid: the time bar cannot be raised solely because the claimant did not bring the matter before the court against the express decision issued during the proceedings (Article R. 142-10-1). See our article on implicit rejection decisions.
Can I go straight to court without going through the commission de recours amiable?
No, unless the texts provide for an exception. Court actions must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code), and the Paris Court of Appeal points out that failure to refer the matter to the board beforehand "therefore renders the referral to the court inadmissible, the burden of proving this prior referral lying with the party who alleges it" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782). The exceptions are limited: the penalties under Articles L. 114-17 and L. 114-17-1 are challenged directly before the court (Articles L. 142-4 and L. 114-17-2), as is an objection to an enforcement order (Article R. 133-3).
The mistake is not always irreparable. The Court of Cassation holds that the inadmissibility of an appeal brought directly before the court "does not prevent a new court action from being brought, after the amicable appeals board of the body has been seized, provided that it is brought before the time bar expires" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 22 October 2020, No. 19-18.175).
It also accepts that the court may be seized before the board has ruled, if the board was seized beforehand: the appeal is admissible provided that a decision, implicit or express, has been issued before the judge rules (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 24-14.447). This tolerance presupposes a claim actually lodged with the board before the court is seized.
I missed the two-month deadline: is my appeal lost?
Not necessarily. Before giving up, read the notification again. The two-month time limit under Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code can only be raised if it, together with the available remedies, was stated in the notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1-A, III). The same article governs the time limit for appealing to the court, and the Court of Cassation holds, in relation to a decision on the incapacity rate, that "in the absence of proper notification of the remedies and time limits" (our translation), that time limit does not run (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186). The body must also prove the date of receipt: the Paris Court of Appeal noted, in a survivor's pension (pension de réversion) case, that the lack of a certain date of receipt prevented the time bar from being raised against the insured person (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782).
The same judgment shows the limit: an improper notification still allows you to refer the matter to the board, it does not allow you to go straight to court. The insured person, who could not show any referral to the board, saw her appeal declared inadmissible.
If the notification was proper and received, the time limit applies strictly, and an ordinary impediment is not enough: the Versailles Court of Appeal held that sick leave for asthenia "cannot constitute a case of force majeure" (our translation) (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712). The firm reconstructs the timeline from the acknowledgements of receipt, the statements in the notification and the date on which the appeal was sent.
Commission de recours amiable or medical board: which one should I refer to?
It all depends on the nature of the dispute. The amicable appeals board examines claims against decisions of the body (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code). For medical disputes, for the state or degree of invalidity, for unfitness for work and for permanent incapacity for work, the prior appeal is submitted to a medical amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-8), and the amicable appeals board procedure does not apply (Article R. 142-7, 3°). The medical board receives the full medical report of the consulting medical officer (Article L. 142-6) and gives an opinion "which is binding on the paying body" (our translation) (Article R. 142-8-5).
A single decision may call for both appeals. In a case decided by the Paris Court of Appeal, the fund had refused to recognise an occupational disease not listed in the tables, on the grounds, first, that it did not appear in the tables and, second, that the incapacity rate was below the threshold; the insured person had referred the matter only to the amicable appeals board, without challenging the rate before the medical board. His appeal was declared inadmissible (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 18 September 2026, No. 23/06494).
Silence is not counted in the same way: two months before the amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-6), four months from the lodging of the appeal before the medical board (Article R. 142-8-5). For an appeal falling within both boards, the amicable appeals board waits for the opinion of the medical board, which is binding on it, and, by way of exception, implicit rejection only occurs after six months from the lodging of the prior appeal (Article R. 142-9-1). See our article on medical disputes.
Can I raise new arguments before the court?
Yes, within the scope of what was contested before the board. The Court of Cassation holds that a contributor challenging a reassessment "may, in the course of the court action, raise arguments other than those raised before the amicable appeals board, provided that they concern the heads of reassessment previously contested" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 12 May 2022, No. 20-18.078). In that case, the company could rely before the court on the absence of prior notice of the audit and the nullity of the formal notice, in support of the heads already submitted to the board.
The limit is clear: where the challenge before the board concerned only certain heads, "the dispute cannot be extended to the other heads, but it is for the court to examine the relevance of these nullity arguments with regard to the heads of reassessment already contested" (our translation) (same judgment). A head not contested before the board is therefore beyond the reach of the court.
Two practical consequences follow. The claim must cover all the heads or all the decisions you intend to dispute, even if the arguments are developed later. And there is no point in focusing the argument on the board's decision itself: the court must rule on the merits of the dispute, arguments alleging an irregularity in that decision being ineffective (Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756). The prior appeal remains required by Article L. 142-4 of the French Social Security Code.
URSSAF: should I appeal to the board against the letter of observations or against the formal notice?
Against the formal notice. After an audit, the letter of observations opens an adversarial period of thirty days, extended to sixty on request, in which to reply (Article R. 243-59, III); recovery proceedings must then be preceded by a precise and reasoned formal notice (Article L. 244-2 of the French Social Security Code), which states in particular the reference and dates of the letter of observations and the amounts corrected after the exchanges (Article R. 244-1).
The Paris Court of Appeal draws the rule from this: "the decision taken at the end of a recovery procedure does not consist of the letter of observations or the replies of the collection inspector, but of the notification of the formal notice that follows" (our translation). A company that had referred the matter to the board after the inspector's reply, and then had not lodged a claim against the formal notice, lost its appeal, the court holding that "The formal notice is therefore final." (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/00516).
The claim against the formal notice must cover each head of reassessment you intend to dispute, because the dispute cannot later be extended to heads that were not contested (Cass. 2e civ., 12 May 2022, No. 20-18.078). The board's decision details, for each ground of reassessment, the amounts cancelled and those still due (Article R. 142-4). See our pages on the CRA URSSAF, the URSSAF letter of observations and the URSSAF audit.
I received an enforcement order (contrainte) without appealing to the board: can I still challenge it?
Yes, by an objection to the enforcement order, within a very short time limit. If the formal notice has no effect after one month, the director may issue an enforcement order; the debtor lodges an objection with the secretariat of the competent court "within fifteen days of notification or service", and "The objection must state its grounds; a copy of the contested enforcement order must be attached to it" (our translation) (Article R. 133-3 of the French Social Security Code). Failing that, the enforcement order has all the effects of a judgment (Article L. 244-9).
Since 2022, the Court of Cassation has held that "a contributor who has not challenged the formal notice before the amicable appeals board may, in support of the objection to the enforcement order issued on the basis of that notice, challenge the regularity of the procedure and the merits of the grounds of the enforcement order" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 22 September 2022, No. 21-10.105). The objection is then the contributor's only effective remedy before a court.
The position is different for a contributor who referred the matter to the board and then let the time limit against its decision expire. The 2022 judgment expressly distinguishes this situation and, in such a case, the Court had approved a court of appeal holding that the objection was admissible but that "the merits of the disputed reassessment could no longer be discussed" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 4 April 2019, No. 18-12.014). See our URSSAF enforcement order lawyer page.
CAF, pension fund, MSA: is the procedure the same?
Yes for most benefits, but three of them follow a different route. Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code covers the decisions of all social security bodies and of the agricultural social insurance scheme, for employees or the self-employed: the family allowance fund (caisse d'allocations familiales, CAF), the pension fund and the MSA each have their board, which must be referred to within two months of notification, subject to the condition that the remedies and time limits be stated (Article R. 142-1-A, III). In the texts reviewed, it is the composition that differs: three representatives of employers and three of insured persons at the national old-age insurance fund, two representatives of the self-employed and two of employees at the MSA (Article R. 142-2).
Three benefits paid by the CAF follow their own rules. For the in-work benefit (prime d'activité), the claim goes before the amicable appeals board, but "Court actions relating to the decisions mentioned in the first paragraph of this article are brought before the administrative courts" (our translation) (Article L. 845-2 of the French Social Security Code). For personal housing benefits, the prior appeal is brought before the amicable appeals board of the paying body (Article R. 825-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code), the director rules after its opinion (Article R. 825-2), and appeals against these decisions "are brought before the administrative courts" (our translation) (Article L. 825-1). For the earned income supplement (revenu de solidarité active, RSA), the claim is the subject of an administrative appeal "to the president of the departmental council" (our translation), the amicable appeals board giving only an opinion under the conditions set by the agreement concluded with the body (Article L. 262-47 of the French Social Action and Families Code).
For other benefits, the case-law rules are common to all. The Court of Cassation held admissible the appeal of a recipient of the disabled adult allowance (allocation aux adultes handicapés) who had brought the matter before the court before the board's decision, that decision having been issued before judgment: the absence of a decision "does not prevent this appeal from being admissible, provided that a decision, implicit or express, has been issued before the judge rules" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 24-14.447). In pension matters, the Paris Court of Appeal declared inadmissible the appeal of a widow who could not show any referral to the board concerning her survivor's pension (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782).
Each body has its own pages: CAF lawyer, CARSAT lawyer, MSA lawyer and CPAM lawyer. See also our articles on overpayments of the disabled adult allowance and on refused widowhood allowance.
Do I need a lawyer before the commission de recours amiable?
It is not mandatory. The claim can be drafted by the person concerned and, afterwards before the social division, "The parties may defend themselves" (our translation) (Article L. 142-9 of the French Social Security Code); they may also be assisted or represented by a relative, a trade union or professional representative, or the delegate of an association of disabled and injured workers or of an association established for at least five years in the field of the economic and social rights of users, holding a special power of attorney if not a lawyer.
A lawyer helps you avoid losing the case before it begins. The decisions cited on this page show this: an appeal two days late (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712), a claim sent too early, before the formal notice (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/00516), a challenge brought only before the amicable appeals board instead of the medical board (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 18 September 2026, No. 23/06494), or a claim limited to certain heads of reassessment, which prevents others from being discussed before the court (Cass. 2e civ., 12 May 2022, No. 20-18.078). Conversely, a notification without remedies and time limits, or an incomplete acknowledgement of receipt, may mean that a time bar thought to have been reached cannot be raised (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-15.393).
The firm checks the notification and the competent board, drafts the claim with its supporting documents, monitors the time limit for a reply, then prepares the application before the social division of the judicial court and represents the insured person, the benefit recipient, the contributor or the employer there.
How much does a commission de recours amiable lawyer cost?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: you know, before committing, what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or method of calculating the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The same text prohibits fees set solely according to the outcome of the case: "Any setting of fees based solely on the judicial outcome is prohibited" (our translation).
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: analysis of the notification and time limits, claim before the amicable appeals board or the medical amicable appeals board, follow-up of the reply, application and hearing before the social division of the judicial court, objection to an enforcement order, appeal. The amount takes into account what is at stake and the volume of documents to be examined, benefits file, medical file or audit report. Any new engagement gives rise to an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a first opinion on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, results in a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, verified on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code, L. 142-4, L. 142-6 and L. 142-9: social security litigation, mandatory prior appeal and its exceptions, medical report, representation of the parties
- Articles R. 142-1, R. 142-1-A, R. 142-2, R. 142-4 and R. 142-5: amicable appeals board, time limits and when they can be raised, composition, reasoned decision, special committees
- Articles R. 142-6 and R. 142-7: implicit rejection, documents produced after the claim, exclusions
- Articles R. 142-8, R. 142-8-5 and R. 142-9-1: medical amicable appeals board, opinion, implicit rejection, appeals falling within both boards
- Articles R. 142-10 and R. 142-10-1: competent court, application, express decision during the proceedings
- Articles R. 243-59, L. 244-2, R. 244-1, R. 133-3 and L. 244-9: letter of observations and adversarial period, formal notice, enforcement order, objection
- Article L. 845-2 of the French Social Security Code: in-work benefit (prime d'activité), court actions before the administrative courts
- Articles R. 825-1, R. 825-2 and L. 825-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code: personal housing benefits, prior appeal and administrative courts
- Article L. 262-47 of the French Social Action and Families Code: earned income supplement (RSA), appeal to the president of the departmental council
- Articles L. 114-17-1 and L. 114-17-2: financial penalties, direct challenge before the court
- Article L. 211-16 of the French Code of Judicial Organisation: specially designated judicial courts
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-15.393: time bar cannot be raised without a compliant acknowledgement of receipt
- Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 23-16.186: time limit not stated in the notification
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 24-14.447: court seized before the board's decision
- Cass. 2e civ., 29 January 2026, No. 23-19.898: same rule before the medical board
- Cass. 2e civ., 22 October 2020, No. 19-18.175: new appeal after referral to the board
- Cass. 2e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-27.756: irregularities in the board's decision are ineffective
- Cass. 2e civ., 16 October 2025, No. 23-16.695: court action time-barred
- Cass. 2e civ., 12 May 2022, No. 20-18.078: new arguments and contested heads of reassessment
- Cass. 2e civ., 22 September 2022, No. 21-10.105: objection to an enforcement order without referral to the board
- Cass. 2e civ., 4 April 2019, No. 18-12.014: board decision not challenged and objection to an enforcement order
- CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 18 December 2025, No. 23/02712: board seized two days too late
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782: proof of the prior referral
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 18 September 2026, No. 23/06494: wrong board seized
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/00516: board seized before the formal notice
A French social security decision to challenge before the commission de recours amiable, with a time limit that is running?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the decision and its notification, with the envelope or the acknowledgement of receipt, any claim you have already made and its acknowledgement of receipt, and the documents you have: Hassan Kohen checks the time limits, the competent board and the heads to be contested, then tells you the appropriate route, a claim before the amicable appeals board or the medical board, an application before the social division of the judicial court or an objection to an enforcement order.