They talk about us
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, URSSAF reassessment for undeclared work in Paris
URSSAF reassessment lawyer for undeclared work in Paris
Undeclared work report (procès-verbal de travail dissimulé), letter of observations (lettre d'observations), flat-rate assessment of wages, cancellation of contribution reductions, reassessment surcharge, self-employed worker (auto-entrepreneur), volunteer or intern reclassified as an employee: as URSSAF reassessment lawyers, the firm assists companies, associations and self-employed workers in their dealings with URSSAF (the social security contributions agency), from the inspection to the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire), to challenge the reassessment and reduce it. Everything starts with the letter of observations and the thirty-day time limit for replying to it.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The person inspected has thirty days to reply to the letter of observations, a time limit that can be extended to sixty days (Article R. 243-59 of the French Social Security Code, Code de la sécurité sociale); a matter is referred to the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1), and an objection to an enforcement order (opposition à contrainte) must be lodged within fifteen days (Article R. 133-3).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome he achieved for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives good advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, URSSAF litigation on undeclared work: inspection, letter of observations, reclassification, amicable appeal and social division of the court.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Undeclared work (travail dissimulé) takes two forms: concealment of activity and concealment of salaried employment (Articles L. 8221-3 and L. 8221-5 of the French Labour Code, Code du travail). Where it is established, URSSAF reassesses contributions on the actual remuneration or, failing evidence to the contrary on the length of employment and the remuneration, on a flat-rate assessment equal to 25 % of the annual social security ceiling (Article L. 242-1-2 of the French Social Security Code). It also withdraws contribution reductions and exemptions (Article L. 133-4-2) and applies a surcharge to the reassessment according to a scale that depends on the date on which the procedure was initiated (Article L. 243-7-7). The period inspected increases from three to five years where the offence is recorded in an official report (procès-verbal) (Articles L. 244-3 and L. 244-11). The reassessment does not require proof of fraudulent intent, but a final criminal acquittal (relaxe) is binding on the court ruling on contributions, and the reclassification of a registered worker requires a permanent relationship of legal subordination (Article L. 8221-6 of the Labour Code). A challenge goes through the reply to the letter of observations, then the amicable appeals board and the social division of the judicial court (Articles R. 243-59 and R. 142-1). Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts for the inspected company or association, the principal contractor and the self-employed worker. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Received an official report, a letter of observations or a formal notice?
Understanding your situation
The URSSAF reassessment for undeclared work, explained
Remuneration paid in return for undeclared work is, failing evidence to the contrary, assessed on a flat-rate basis (Article L. 242-1-2 of the French Social Security Code). What URSSAF must establish, how the amount is built up, when a status is reclassified, and how to challenge the reassessment before the amicable appeals board and then the social division of the court.
Key points
Before discussing an amount: four points to check
What is alleged, who recorded it, in what framework, and over what period.
The classification: concealment of activity, where a for-profit activity is carried on by a person who, intentionally evading their obligations, has not applied for mandatory registration or has not made the declarations owed to social protection bodies or to the tax authorities, in particular by failing to declare part of their turnover; or concealment of salaried employment, where the employer intentionally evades the pre-hiring declaration or the issue of a payslip, records fewer hours than those actually worked, or omits the declarations of wages and contributions (Articles L. 8221-3 and L. 8221-5 of the Labour Code).
The finding: the offence is investigated by authorised inspection officers, including sworn and approved officers of the social security bodies (Article L. 8271-1-2), and recorded in official reports that are authoritative until proven otherwise (Article L. 8271-8). URSSAF may reassess contributions on the basis of the official reports sent to it (Article L. 243-7-5 of the Social Security Code).
The framework of the inspection: a contribution base inspection (contrôle d'assiette), preceded by a notice of inspection at least thirty days before the first visit, or an inspection conducted to detect undeclared work, which is exempt from that notice; in the latter case, the interview prior to the letter of observations is not offered (Article R. 243-59, I and II). The persons interviewed are heard with their consent (Article L. 8271-6-1 of the Labour Code).
The period: contributions are time-barred after three years from the end of the calendar year for which they are due (Article L. 244-3); this period is extended to five years where an illegal work offence is recorded in an official report (Article L. 244-11).
The reassessment is not a criminal conviction, and its logic is different. The Court of Cassation holds that, "where it stems from a finding of an offence of undeclared work through concealment of salaried employment, the reassessment has the sole purpose of recovering the contributions relating to that employment, without it being necessary to establish the employer's fraudulent intent" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 13-22.943). Good faith is therefore not enough to defeat the contributions; it remains decisive before the criminal court, however, and a final acquittal can bring down the reassessment, as explained in the tab on challenging it.
The framework of the inspection determines the safeguards. For the Court of Cassation, the provisions of Article R. 243-59 "apply to the inspection initiated by the collection bodies on the basis of Article L. 243-7 of the Social Security Code" (our translation), "even where the inspection has led to a finding of breach of the prohibitions mentioned in Article L. 8221-1 of the Labour Code" (our translation); it set aside the judgment that had disregarded the inspected contributor's charter (charte du cotisant contrôlé) on that ground (Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 10-13.699). Before any reply, the firm therefore identifies the procedure followed, from the notice of inspection, the interview reports and the letter of observations.
The criminal side of undeclared work, punishable by three years' imprisonment and a fine of 45 000 euros (Article L. 8224-1 of the Labour Code), is covered on our page undeclared work lawyer in Paris; this page deals only with contributions. The conduct of an URSSAF inspection, outside undeclared work, also has its own page: URSSAF inspection lawyer in Paris. See also our articles on the unannounced inspection without prior notice and on the missed pre-hiring declaration.
The calculation
Base, flat rate, exemptions, surcharge: how the reassessment amount is built up
Four layers that add up, each with its own rule and its own defence.
Actual base
Sums paid to the worker whose employment was concealed, or to the contractor reclassified as an employee, are brought back into the contribution base, on the basis of the sums actually paid; in the case decided, a self-employed driver (auto-entrepreneur) who was reclassified, the calculation was based on the invoices paid by the company (Cass. 2e civ., 28 November 2019, No. 18-15.333).
Flat-rate assessment
Failing evidence to the contrary as to the actual length of employment and the remuneration paid, remuneration is assessed on a flat-rate basis at 25 % of the annual ceiling in force at the time of the finding, and is deemed to have been paid during the month in which the offence is recorded; for a private individual employer referred to in 3°, 4° or 6° of Article L. 133-5-6, it is equal to half of that ceiling (Article L. 242-1-2).
Exemptions withdrawn
The benefit of any contribution reduction or exemption is withdrawn where illegal work is found; the body cancels it, within the limitation period applicable to the offence, where the offence is recorded in an official report (Article L. 133-4-2, I and II).
Partial cancellation
Cancellation is only partial where the concealment results solely from the reclassification of a worker presumed to be self-employed, or where it represents a limited proportion of the activity, except where a minor, a vulnerable person or an organised gang is involved (Article L. 133-4-2, III). A limited proportion means sums not exceeding 10 % of declared remuneration for employers with fewer than twenty employees, and 5 % in other cases (Article R. 133-8).
Surcharge
The reassessment is increased by a surcharge, at a rate that depends on the date on which the procedure was initiated: 25 %, or 40 % in aggravated cases, for procedures initiated before 1 June 2026 (2023 wording); 35 % or 50 % from 1 June 2026 (Article 44 of Law No. 2025-1403); 35 %, 50 % or 60 % for an organised gang, for procedures initiated from a date set by decree and no later than 1 January 2027 (Article 77 of Law No. 2026-534).
Reduction
Except in cases of repeat offending, the person inspected may benefit from a reduction of ten points, raised to twenty points under the scale of the Law of 25 June 2026, if they pay all sums due within thirty days of notification of the formal notice (mise en demeure) or have a payment schedule accepted within that time limit; the reduction is notified by the director once full payment has been recorded (Article L. 243-7-7, II).
Evidence to the contrary against the flat rate is demanding. The Court of Cassation requires the employer to provide "proof not only of the actual length of employment of the undeclared worker, but also of the exact amount of remuneration paid to that worker during that period" (our translation), and set aside the judgment that had ruled out the flat rate solely on the ground that the accounts were not deficient (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-13.703). It is not impossible: the Paris Court of Appeal ordered URSSAF to recalculate the contributions of an undeclared cook over ten days, "on the basis of the elements of the employment contract" (our translation), as the payslip issued by another restaurant showed that he could not have worked for the company the previous month (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 6 September 2024, No. 21/00445).
The cancellation of exemptions and the surcharge are penalties. The Court of Cassation holds that "the penalty provided for by the aforementioned Article L. 133-4-2 is in the nature of a punishment" (our translation); since the Law of 23 December 2016 extended to unlawful supply of labour (marchandage), illegal lending of labour and employment of a foreign national without authorisation a penalty already applicable to undeclared work, it ruled it out for employment of a foreign national without authorisation committed before 1 January 2017. In that case, it also pointed out that cancellation is partial only in the two cases provided for by law (Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 23-15.729). The Criminal Chamber draws another consequence from this: the surcharges under Article L. 243-7-7 and the withdrawal of exemptions "are in the nature of a punishment" (our translation) and cannot form part of the loss for which URSSAF obtains compensation before the criminal court (Cass. crim., 21 January 2025, No. 23-81.543).
The applicable scale is checked procedure by procedure, at the date on which each procedure was initiated: the successive versions of Article L. 243-7-7 and their transitional provisions are cited in the sources tab. Where there is a new finding within five years, the surcharge was already raised to 45 % or 60 %; the Law of 25 June 2026 adds a rate of 70 % and uses as its criterion the offence recorded at one of the two findings. See our articles on the flat-rate assessment, on the cancellation of exemptions and on the surcharge scale under the Law of 25 June 2026.
Reclassification
Self-employed, volunteer, intern: when URSSAF reclassifies a status as employment
The contract signed does not bind the agency; proof of a relationship of subordination does.
The general social security scheme (régime général) covers any person who is employed or working in any capacity whatsoever for one or more employers, whatever the amount and nature of their remuneration, the form, nature or validity of their contract or the nature of their status (Article L. 311-2 of the Social Security Code).
Persons registered with the trade and companies register, the national business register, the register of commercial agents or with URSSAF are presumed not to be bound to the principal contractor by an employment contract, in carrying out the registered activity (Article L. 8221-6, I, of the Labour Code).
The presumption falls if the person provides their services in conditions that place them in a permanent relationship of legal subordination; concealment of salaried employment is then established if the principal contractor intentionally evaded its obligations as an employer by this means (Article L. 8221-6, II).
These persons "fall within the general social security scheme only if it is established that their activity places them in a permanent relationship of legal subordination towards a principal contractor" (our translation); they may ask URSSAF for a ruling, and an absence of reply within two months or a negative reply protects them, unless the activity is substantially changed or the information given was incorrect (Article L. 311-11).
An internship requires an agreement between the intern, the host organisation and the educational institution (Article L. 124-1 of the French Education Code, Code de l'éducation); no agreement may be concluded to perform a regular task corresponding to a permanent job, to cope with a temporary increase in activity, to fill a seasonal job or to replace an absent employee (Article L. 124-7).
A volunteer is someone who, according to the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal, "contributes spontaneously and without self-interest, with no relationship of subordination" (our translation) (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 4-8a, 7 January 2025, No. 22/01667). Flat-rate expense allowances without receipts and imposed tasks tip the relationship over.
The presumption of non-employment is rebutted on specific facts. The Court of Cassation approved bringing back into the contribution base the sums paid to a heavy goods vehicle driver registered as a self-employed worker (auto-entrepreneur), who drove the company's lorries, used its licence and presented himself on sites as a member of the company; the presumption, which applies to self-employed workers, "may be rebutted if it is established that they provide services to the principal contractor, directly or through an intermediary, in conditions that place them in a permanent relationship of legal subordination towards it" (our translation), the driver having "no independence in the organisation and performance of his work" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 28 November 2019, No. 18-15.333).
The burden of that proof lies on the agency. "It follows that it is for the collection body, in order to bring back into the base the sums paid by a principal contractor to a natural person benefiting from the presumption of non-employment, to prove the existence of a relationship of legal subordination between the principal contractor and that person" (our translation); but in the same case, the Court of Cassation censured the judges who had not examined whether that proof resulted from the inspection report, "whose statements are authoritative until proven otherwise" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-13.944). The Rennes Court of Appeal cancelled the entire undeclared work reassessment of a sports club which used, among others, a self-employed fitness coach who was a former employee: "Mere integration into an organised service is not sufficient to establish the existence of a relationship of subordination if it does not appear that the self-employed worker is otherwise subject to the alleged employer's power to direct, monitor and discipline" (our translation) (CA Rennes, 9e ch. sécurité sociale, 28 May 2025, No. 21/04078).
Conversely, the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal upheld an enforcement order (contrainte) of 590 759 euros against an association whose "volunteers", recruited for their skills and given imposed tasks, were in reality placed under its authority (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 4-8a, 7 January 2025, No. 22/01667). See our articles on the self-employed worker reclassified as an employee, on the reclassified association volunteer and on sham interns.
Both sides
You are the inspected company, or the targeted self-employed worker
The same texts, two readings, and different arguments.
You are the employer or the principal contractor
- Check the framework of the inspection, the interviews and the letter of observations, head of reassessment by head of reassessment.
- Challenge the reclassification: the contractor's real independence, other clients, own equipment, no disciplinary power.
- Put forward proof of the length of employment and the exact remuneration to rule out the flat rate, and dispute the cancellation of exemptions and the surcharge rate.
You are a self-employed worker
- Distinguish a reporting oversight from concealment of activity: intent is an element of the offence (Article L. 8221-3 of the Labour Code) and matters above all before the criminal court, since URSSAF does not have to prove it in order to reassess; a final acquittal is then binding on the court ruling on contributions.
- Reconstruct the actual turnover, with bank records and invoices in support, against URSSAF's own reconstruction.
- Check the period used, the limitation period and the surcharges, then bring the appeals within the time limits.
A principal contractor that has not checked, when the contract was concluded and then periodically, that its co-contractor is complying with its formalities (Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code) is jointly and severally liable for payment of the contributions, penalties and surcharges owed by that co-contractor (Article L. 8222-2), and loses its own contribution reductions up to the amount of those sums, capped at 15 000 euros for a natural person and 75 000 euros for a legal entity where no cancellation has been ordered against it in the previous five years (Article L. 133-4-5 of the Social Security Code). This regime is covered on our page URSSAF joint financial liability.
The arguments the firm examines in every case:
Appeals
Challenging an URSSAF reassessment: from the letter of observations to the social division
Each step has its time limit, and what is not said in time is hard to make up for.
Letter of observations
It states the purpose of the inspection, the documents consulted, the period checked and the observations, with reasons given for each head of reassessment, together with the calculation method, the amount and the surcharges envisaged; where an undeclared work report has been sent, it gives its reference and the facts recorded. The person inspected has thirty days to reply, sixty on request, and each detailed observation calls for a reasoned reply (Article R. 243-59, III).
Formal notice
Recovery is preceded by a precise and reasoned formal notice (mise en demeure) (Article L. 244-2), which states the cause, nature and amount of the sums, the surcharges and penalties, the period, and the reference and dates of the letter of observations (Article R. 244-1).
Amicable appeal
Court proceedings must be preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4): the matter must be referred to the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1).
Social division of the court
Unless otherwise provided, the time limit for bringing court proceedings is also two months, and these time limits can be relied on only if they were stated, together with the available means of appeal, in the notification of the decision (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
Enforcement order
If the formal notice has had no effect after one month, the director may issue an enforcement order (contrainte); a reasoned objection must be lodged within fifteen days of its notification or service (Article R. 133-3). For enforcement orders issued from a date set by decree, and no later than 1 January 2027, an order resulting from a finding of illegal work will be provisionally enforceable two days after its notification (Article L. 244-9 and Article 93 of Law No. 2026-534).
Appeal
The time limit for appealing against a judgment of the social division is one month in contentious matters (Article 538 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, Code de procédure civile).
A criminal acquittal is a major argument. For the Court of Cassation, "final decisions of the criminal courts ruling on the merits of the public prosecution have absolute authority in civil matters, with regard to everyone, as to what was necessarily decided concerning the existence of the offending act, its legal classification and the guilt or innocence of those to whom the act is attributed" (our translation); it approved the cancellation of a reassessment after the acquittal of the company and its manager, URSSAF being unable to rely on the fact that no intent is required in order to reassess (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-14.382). Nor can the final acquittal of the company director alone, for acts relating to his professional activity, be disregarded on the ground that it does not concern the company; the Court of Cassation set aside the judgment that had done so and referred the case to another court of appeal (Cass. 2e civ., 9 April 2026, No. 24-10.226). It does not wipe out everything: the five-year limitation period remains available to URSSAF as soon as an official report has been drawn up, "the acquittal judgment having no bearing in this respect" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 12 March 2020, No. 18-21.648).
The absence of the official report from the file, on the other hand, is not enough. The letter of observations is an "essential formality" (our translation) that informs the employer of the elements taken into account, and "the collection body is not required to attach to the letter of observations the official report recording the offence of undeclared work, whose references are communicated, nor to produce it in the proceedings" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 19 March 2026, No. 23-22.032). The defence therefore focuses on the facts set out in the letter of observations, on the interviews and on the documents the company can put forward.
See our pages on the URSSAF letter of observations, the URSSAF formal notice, the amicable appeals board, the social division of the court and the URSSAF enforcement order, as well as our articles on the binding effect of criminal judgments and on disclosure of the official report.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
Can I challenge an URSSAF reassessment for undeclared work?
Yes, at every stage. During the adversarial period, the person inspected has thirty days to reply to the letter of observations, a time limit that can be extended to sixty days; each detailed observation receives a reasoned reply from the officer, setting out the amounts dropped and those still envisaged (Article R. 243-59, III, of the Social Security Code). After the formal notice, the matter must be referred to the amicable appeals board within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1), and then to the social division of the judicial court.
The arguments fall into three groups. Procedure: the framework of the inspection, consent to interviews, the content of the letter of observations and of the formal notice. Merits: the existence of salaried employment or of a concealed activity, the relationship of subordination. Calculation: evidence against the flat rate, partial cancellation of exemptions, the surcharge scale, the time-barred period.
A challenge succeeds when the facts do not stand up. The Rennes Court of Appeal cancelled the entire undeclared work reassessment of a sports club, URSSAF having failed in particular to show any power to direct and discipline the self-employed fitness coach (CA Rennes, 9e ch. sécurité sociale, 28 May 2025, No. 21/04078). The Court of Cassation upheld the cancellation of a reassessment after the final acquittal of the company and its manager (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-14.382). The firm reads the inspection file before choosing the arguments.
Does URSSAF have to prove fraudulent intent?
No for the reassessment of contributions, yes for a criminal conviction. The Labour Code defines concealment of salaried employment as the employer intentionally evading its reporting obligations (Article L. 8221-5 of the Labour Code). But the Court of Cassation holds that, "where it stems from a finding of an offence of undeclared work through concealment of salaried employment, the reassessment has the sole purpose of recovering the contributions relating to that employment, without it being necessary to establish the employer's fraudulent intent" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 13-22.943). In that case, it set aside the judgment that had cancelled the enforcement order on the ground that intent had not been shown.
The lower courts apply the same rule. The Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal points out that "the intentional element of the offence does not have to be established by the collection body" (our translation) (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 4-8a, 7 January 2025, No. 22/01667); the Rennes Court of Appeal, that "the intentional element is therefore not a condition for the civil recovery of contributions" (our translation) (CA Rennes, 9e ch. sécurité sociale, 28 May 2025, No. 21/04078).
Good faith is not without effect, however. A final criminal acquittal is binding on the court ruling on contributions, even if it is based on the absence of intent: the Court of Cassation approved the cancellation of the reassessment in that situation (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-14.382). See our article on the intentional element of undeclared work.
How does URSSAF calculate a flat-rate reassessment?
By a fixed rule, where it does not have the actual remuneration figures. Remuneration paid or owed to an employee in return for undeclared work is, "failing evidence to the contrary as to the actual length of employment and the remuneration paid" (our translation), assessed on a flat-rate basis at 25 % of the annual social security ceiling in force at the time of the finding, and deemed to have been paid during the month in which the offence is recorded. For a private individual employer referred to in 3°, 4° or 6° of Article L. 133-5-6, the flat-rate assessment per employee is equal to half of that ceiling (Article L. 242-1-2 of the Social Security Code).
Evidence to the contrary must cover two elements at once. According to the Court of Cassation, the employer must provide "proof not only of the actual length of employment of the undeclared worker, but also of the exact amount of remuneration paid to that worker during that period" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-13.703). The two proofs are cumulative: establishing the length of employment alone is not enough.
Objective documents can, however, reduce the reassessment. The Paris Court of Appeal ordered URSSAF to recalculate the contributions of an undeclared cook "on the basis of the elements of the employment contract" (our translation), over ten days, because a payslip issued by another employer showed that he could not have worked for the company the previous month (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 6 September 2024, No. 21/00445). The same court specifies that the employer must provide that proof "during the inspection period" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 6 September 2024, No. 21/00445): the firm therefore gathers, from the visit onwards, the rotas, contracts, payslips and bank statements that establish the length and the amount. See our article on the flat-rate assessment of contributions.
What is the surcharge on an undeclared work reassessment in 2026?
It depends on the date on which the procedure was initiated, as three scales follow one another. For procedures initiated before 1 June 2026, the reassessment is increased by 25 %, and by 40 % in the aggravated cases referred to in Article L. 8224-2 of the Labour Code, with a possible reduction of ten points (Article L. 243-7-7, wording in force from 2023 to 2025). The Social Security Financing Act for 2026 raised these rates to 35 % and 50 % for procedures initiated from 1 June 2026 (Article 44 of Law No. 2025-1403 of 30 December 2025, wording resulting from that law).
The Law of 25 June 2026 on combating social security and tax fraud keeps 35 % and 50 %, creates a rate of 60 % for acts committed by an organised gang and raises the reduction to twenty points; it applies "to procedures initiated from a date set by decree" (our translation), and no later than 1 January 2027 (Article 77 of Law No. 2026-534, Article L. 243-7-7). Where there is a new finding within five years, the surcharge was already raised to 45 % or 60 % depending on the rate applied the first time; this scale adds a rate of 70 % and uses the offence recorded at one of the two findings.
The reduction requires, except in cases of repeat offending, full payment of the contributions, penalties and late-payment surcharges within thirty days of notification of the formal notice, or a payment schedule accepted within that time limit. A later wording, resulting from Article 95 of the same law, provides that the person inspected "benefits" (our translation) from this reduction and deals with the position of the principal contractor (future version, Article 95). The firm checks the date on which each inspection was initiated before weighing payment against a challenge. See our article on the surcharge scale under the Law of 25 June 2026.
Why is URSSAF cancelling our contribution reductions?
Because the law attaches this penalty to a finding of illegal work. The benefit of any full or partial contribution reduction or exemption is withdrawn where illegal work offences are found, including undeclared work; where the offence is recorded in an official report, the body carries out the cancellation within the limitation period applicable to the offence (Article L. 133-4-2, I and II, of the Social Security Code). The cancellation covers all of the employer's reductions, not only those relating to the undeclared employee.
It is only partial in two situations: the concealment results solely from the reclassification of a worker presumed to be self-employed, or it represents a limited proportion of the activity, except where a minor subject to compulsory schooling, a vulnerable or dependent person, or an organised gang is involved. The proportion cancelled is then equal to the ratio between twice the evaded remuneration and the remuneration paid to all staff, up to a limit of 100 % (Article L. 133-4-2, III). A limited proportion means sums not exceeding 10 % of declared remuneration for an employer with fewer than twenty employees, and 5 % above that (Article R. 133-8).
The Court of Cassation holds that "the penalty provided for by the aforementioned Article L. 133-4-2 is in the nature of a punishment" (our translation), and infers from this that it applies to employment of a foreign national without authorisation, unlawful supply of labour (marchandage) and illegal lending of labour only for acts committed after the entry into force of the Law of 23 December 2016, which extended to those offences a penalty already applicable to undeclared work. It also points out that partial cancellation is available only in the two cases provided for, which ruled it out for employment of a foreign national without authorisation (Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 23-15.729). See our article on the cancellation of exemptions.
How many years back can URSSAF go?
Three years as a rule, five years where there is an official report of illegal work. Social security contributions are time-barred after three years from the end of the calendar year for which they are due, and from 30 June of the following year for self-employed workers (Article L. 244-3 of the Social Security Code). Where an illegal work offence is recorded in an official report, this period, like those for the recovery action and the enforcement of the order, is extended to five years (Article L. 244-11).
The extension depends solely on the official report. The Court of Cassation holds that "the five-year limitation period replacing the three-year limitation period is subject only to the recording of an illegal work offence in an official report drawn up by the collection inspector" (our translation), and that a subsequent acquittal has no bearing on this point (Cass. 2e civ., 12 March 2020, No. 18-21.648); the judgment was given under the former wording of Article L. 244-3, whose rule now appears in Article L. 244-11. In the same decision, however, it set aside the validation of the enforcement order for the employee in respect of whom the managers had been acquitted: the acquittal does not shorten the period, but it can bring down the head of reassessment it concerns.
The firm therefore checks the existence and date of the official report, the period covered by the letter of observations and the formal notice, and any suspension of the limitation period during the adversarial phase of a contribution base inspection (Article L. 244-3). See our article on the length of the inspection and the limitation period.
Can URSSAF reclassify a self-employed worker (auto-entrepreneur) as an employee?
Yes, if the agency proves a permanent relationship of legal subordination. A registered person is presumed not to be bound to their principal contractor by an employment contract, but the presumption falls where their services place them in a permanent relationship of legal subordination; concealment of salaried employment is then established if the principal contractor intentionally evaded its obligations by this means (Article L. 8221-6 of the Labour Code). These workers fall within the general scheme only if it is established that their activity places them in such a relationship (Article L. 311-11 of the Social Security Code).
The burden of proof lies on URSSAF. "It follows that it is for the collection body, in order to bring back into the base the sums paid by a principal contractor to a natural person benefiting from the presumption of non-employment, to prove the existence of a relationship of legal subordination between the principal contractor and that person" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-13.944). The inspection report may, however, be sufficient to provide that proof, as its statements are authoritative until proven otherwise.
Everything turns on the facts. Reclassification was upheld for a driver without his own vehicle, who used the company's lorries, fuel and licence (Cass. 2e civ., 28 November 2019, No. 18-15.333). It was rejected for a fitness coach who had other clients and his own equipment, the court noting that the existence of an employment relationship depends "on the factual conditions in which the professional activity is carried out" (our translation) (CA Rennes, 9e ch. sécurité sociale, 28 May 2025, No. 21/04078). See our article on the self-employed worker reclassified as an employee.
Volunteers and interns: when does URSSAF treat it as undeclared work?
When the reality of the relationship is that of salaried employment. The general scheme covers any person working in any capacity whatsoever for one or more employers, whatever the form, nature or validity of their contract or the nature of their status (Article L. 311-2 of the Social Security Code). The label of volunteer or intern therefore offers no protection if the person performs work under the authority of an employer who gives orders, monitors their performance and disciplines failings.
For volunteers, the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal keeps to the case-law definition: someone who "contributes spontaneously and without self-interest, with no relationship of subordination" (our translation). It upheld an enforcement order of 590 759 euros against an association that paid the so-called volunteers flat-rate expense allowances without receipts and recruited them for their skills, to carry out imposed tasks (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 4-8a, 7 January 2025, No. 22/01667).
For interns, an internship is based on an agreement between the intern, the host organisation and the educational institution (Article L. 124-1 of the Education Code), and no agreement may be concluded to perform a regular task corresponding to a permanent job, to cope with a temporary increase in activity, to fill a seasonal job or to replace an absent employee (Article L. 124-7). The firm examines the agreements, the tasks assigned and the actual supervision. See our articles on the reclassified volunteer and on sham interns.
What is the undeclared work report worth, and should I obtain it?
It has real evidential weight. Breaches of the prohibitions on undeclared work are recorded in official reports that "are authoritative until proven otherwise" (our translation) and are sent directly to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République) (Article L. 8271-8 of the Labour Code). URSSAF may reassess contributions on the basis of the information they contain (Article L. 243-7-5 of the Social Security Code). To challenge them, you therefore have to put forward contrary evidence, not merely deny them.
The official report does not have to be attached to the letter of observations. Where a finding of undeclared work has been sent, the letter must state its reference and the facts recorded by the officers (Article R. 243-59, III). For the Court of Cassation, "the collection body is not required to attach to the letter of observations the official report recording the offence of undeclared work, whose references are communicated, nor to produce it in the proceedings" (our translation); it set aside the judgment that had cancelled the formal notice on that ground (Cass. 2e civ., 19 March 2026, No. 23-22.032).
The defence is therefore built on the letter of observations itself: the facts it sets out, the interviews it mentions, the period and the calculation it uses. The court must, moreover, examine what the official report establishes before rejecting the reclassification (Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-13.944). See our article on disclosure of the official report.
The inspection took place without prior notice: is it lawful?
It all depends on its purpose. An inspection of compliance with social security legislation is preceded, at least thirty days before the first visit, by a notice of inspection that refers to the inspected contributor's charter; the body is not required to send it where the inspection is carried out to detect undeclared work offences, but if it intends to pursue other points of the regulations, a notice must be sent (Article R. 243-59, I, of the Social Security Code).
URSSAF cannot mix the two regimes to its advantage. For the Court of Cassation, the safeguards of Article R. 243-59 "apply to the inspection initiated by the collection bodies on the basis of Article L. 243-7 of the Social Security Code" (our translation), even where that inspection leads to a finding of undeclared work; it set aside the judgment that had disregarded the contributor's charter on the ground that the inspection targeted undeclared work, applying the former wording of Article R. 243-59 (Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 10-13.699).
In an inspection to detect undeclared work, the officers may interview the employer and any paid person, wherever they may be, but with that person's consent; a person suspected of an offence has the rights attached to a voluntary interview (audition libre) (Article L. 8271-6-1 of the Labour Code). The record of consent appears in the interview report, and signing that report constitutes consent (Article R. 243-59, II). The firm checks the notice, the interviews and their form. See our article on the unannounced inspection without prior notice.
The company director was acquitted in the criminal courts: does the reassessment fall?
Yes, for the facts that were tried, where the acquittal is final and given on the merits. The Court of Cassation holds that "final decisions of the criminal courts ruling on the merits of the public prosecution have absolute authority in civil matters, with regard to everyone, as to what was necessarily decided concerning the existence of the offending act, its legal classification and the guilt or innocence of those to whom the act is attributed" (our translation). It approved the cancellation of a reassessment after the acquittal of the company and its manager, noting that the fact that URSSAF does not have to establish fraudulent intent does not set this principle aside (Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-14.382).
The acquittal of the director alone cannot be disregarded on the ground that it does not concern the company. The Court of Cassation set aside the judgment that had refused to take it into account on the ground that it concerned the natural person and not the company, "whereas it found that the company's director had been acquitted of undeclared work for acts relating to his professional activity by a final decision of a trial court ruling on the merits of the public prosecution" (our translation), and referred the case to the Montpellier Court of Appeal, which must rule again on the reassessment (Cass. 2e civ., 9 April 2026, No. 24-10.226).
Three limits remain. The acquittal applies only to the facts tried: it benefits the head of reassessment relating to the employee it concerns, not the others; and the five-year limitation period remains available as soon as an official report has been drawn up (Cass. 2e civ., 12 March 2020, No. 18-21.648). A decision by the prosecutor to drop the case (classement sans suite) is not a court judgment. The firm coordinates the criminal defence and the contributions litigation. See our article on the binding effect of criminal judgments and our page undeclared work lawyer.
Do I have to pay the reassessment while my appeal is pending?
The question arises as soon as the formal notice is received, for two reasons. The first concerns the surcharge: except in cases of repeat offending, the person inspected may benefit from a reduction of ten points, raised to twenty points under the scale of the Law of 25 June 2026, if they pay all the contributions, penalties and late-payment surcharges notified within thirty days of notification of the formal notice, or submit within that time limit a payment schedule accepted by the director; the reduction is notified once full payment has been recorded (Article L. 243-7-7, II, of the Social Security Code). Whatever the choice, the matter must be referred to the amicable appeals board within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1).
The second concerns enforced recovery. If the formal notice has had no effect after one month, the director may issue an enforcement order, against which a reasoned objection must be lodged within fifteen days (Article R. 133-3); failing that, it has all the effects of a judgment (Article L. 244-9). For enforcement orders issued from a date set by decree, and no later than 1 January 2027, an order resulting from a finding of illegal work will be provisionally enforceable as of right two days after its notification, with the president of the court able to stay enforcement where there is a serious argument and manifestly excessive consequences (Article L. 244-9 and Article 93 of Law No. 2026-534).
The firm costs out both options, payment with a reduction or a challenge without payment, in the light of the arguments available in the case. See our article on the enforcement order for undeclared work and its provisional enforcement.
Is the principal contractor affected by its subcontractor's reassessment?
Yes, if it has not exercised due diligence. Any person who concludes a contract above a minimum amount must check, on conclusion and then periodically until the end of its performance, that the co-contractor is complying with its registration and declaration formalities (Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code). Failing that, it is jointly and severally liable, with the party against whom an official report for the offence of undeclared work has been drawn up, for payment of the contributions, penalties and surcharges owed by that party (Article L. 8222-2).
The principal contractor also loses its own contribution reductions and exemptions, for each of the months concerned, where its co-contractor engaged in undeclared work during the same period (Article L. 133-4-5 of the Social Security Code). The cancellation is capped at the amount of the sums due under joint liability; the cap is reduced to 15 000 euros for a natural person and 75 000 euros for a legal entity where no cancellation has been ordered against it in the previous five years. The surcharge charged to it may be reduced on the same payment conditions as for the inspected company (Article L. 243-7-7, II). This regime changes no later than 25 December 2026: a principal contractor that pays the sums due within a time limit set by decree, or submits within that time limit an accepted payment schedule, will no longer be jointly and severally liable for the surcharges (Article L. 243-7-7, future version, Article 95 of Law No. 2026-534).
This regime has its own page: see URSSAF joint financial liability. The firm acts for the principal contractor as well as for the subcontractor, on the basis of the due-diligence certificates (attestations de vigilance) obtained and the dates of the contract.
What are the fees for an URSSAF reassessment lawyer in an undeclared work case?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing yourself, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The agreement specifies the amount of the fees, or the method for determining them, covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expenses and disbursements envisaged; fees take into account in particular the difficulty of the case and the work carried out, and the law prohibits setting them solely according to the outcome in court. The agreement may, however, provide, in addition to payment for the services performed, a supplementary fee based on the result obtained or the service rendered.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: assistance during the inspection, reply to the letter of observations, claim before the amicable appeals board, objection to an enforcement order, proceedings before the social division, appeal. Any new engagement gives rise to an amendment, with no unexpected invoicing.
For an initial opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 8221-1 of the Labour Code, L. 8221-3, L. 8221-5 and L. 1221-10: prohibition of undeclared work, concealment of activity and of salaried employment, pre-hiring declaration
- Article L. 8221-6: presumption of non-employment and permanent relationship of legal subordination
- Articles L. 8271-1-2, L. 8271-6-1 and L. 8271-8: inspection officers, interviews, evidential weight of official reports
- Articles L. 8222-1, L. 8222-2, L. 8224-1 and L. 8224-2: due diligence and joint liability of the principal contractor, penalties and aggravated cases
- Articles L. 311-2 of the Social Security Code and L. 311-11: affiliation to the general scheme, registered workers
- Article L. 242-1-2: flat-rate assessment of remuneration
- Articles L. 133-4-2, R. 133-8 and L. 133-4-5: full or partial cancellation of reductions and exemptions, principal contractor
- Article L. 243-7-7: reassessment surcharge, version resulting from the Law of 25 June 2026; earlier versions of 2023 and of 2025, future version
- Article 44 of Law No. 2025-1403 of 30 December 2025, Articles 77, 93 and 95 of Law No. 2026-534 of 25 June 2026: application over time of the surcharges, of the provisional enforcement of the enforcement order and of the principal contractor regime
- Articles L. 243-7, L. 243-7-5 and R. 243-59: inspection, reassessment based on an official report, notice of inspection, letter of observations
- Articles L. 244-3 and L. 244-11: three-year limitation period, extended to five years
- Articles L. 244-2, R. 244-1, L. 244-9 and R. 133-3: formal notice, enforcement order, objection
- Articles L. 142-4, R. 142-1 and R. 142-1-A: prior appeal, amicable appeals board, time limits
- Articles L. 124-1 of the Education Code and L. 124-7: internship agreement, prohibited tasks
- Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure: time limit for appeal
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 13-22.943: reassessment without proof of fraudulent intent
- Cass. 2e civ., 9 October 2014, No. 10-13.699: safeguards of a contribution base inspection that revealed undeclared work
- Cass. 2e civ., 28 November 2019, No. 18-15.333: self-employed driver reclassified
- Cass. 2e civ., 12 March 2020, No. 18-21.648: five-year limitation period and scope of the acquittal
- Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-13.944: burden of proving the relationship of subordination
- Cass. crim., 21 January 2025, No. 23-81.543: surcharges and cancellation of exemptions, punitive nature
- Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 23-15.729: cancellation of exemptions, non-retroactivity and cases of partial cancellation
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 September 2025, No. 23-13.703: evidence against the flat-rate assessment
- Cass. 2e civ., 19 March 2026, No. 23-22.032: official report not attached to the letter of observations
- Cass. 2e civ., 9 April 2026, No. 24-10.226: acquittal of the director and binding effect of criminal judgments
- Cass. 2e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-14.382: reassessment cancelled after acquittal of the company and its manager
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 6 September 2024, No. 21/00445: flat rate ruled out on proof of the period of employment
- CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 4-8a, 7 January 2025, No. 22/01667: volunteers reclassified as employees
- CA Rennes, 9e ch. sécurité sociale, 28 May 2025, No. 21/04078: presumption of non-employment upheld, reassessment cancelled
Further reading
An official report, a letter of observations, an URSSAF reassessment to challenge?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the notice of inspection if there is one, the interview reports, the letter of observations or the formal notice, with the date you received them, and the contracts or invoices concerned: Hassan Kohen, avocat at the Paris Bar, examines the procedure, the legal classification, the calculation and the time limits, then tells you the appropriate route: reply to the letter of observations, amicable appeal, objection to an enforcement order, action before the social division or appeal.