In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, employer's inexcusable fault (faute inexcusable) in Paris
Employer's inexcusable fault lawyer in Paris: proof and compensation
An accident at work or an occupational disease that occurred when the danger was known, a conciliation request to the social security fund, a claim before the social division of the court (pôle social), increase of the annuity, expert assessment and calculation of losses, defence of the employer whose liability is alleged: as an inexcusable fault lawyer in Paris, the firm assists victims, their relatives and businesses at every stage. Everything starts from one simple question: was the employer aware, or should it have been aware, of the danger?
The firm can be reached 24/7. The claim is time-barred after two years, running in particular from the day of the accident or from the end of payment of the daily allowances (Article L. 431-2 of the French Social Security Code, Code de la sécurité sociale). From 1 November 2026, the annuity of victims whose condition is consolidated on or after that date comprises an occupational part and a functional part, both of which are increased in the event of inexcusable fault.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received a very high standard of support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome secured for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He listens very well, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete mastery of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he has done.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar: accidents at work and occupational diseases, employer's inexcusable fault, litigation before the social division of the court (pôle social).
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Where an accident at work or an occupational disease is due to the employer's inexcusable fault (faute inexcusable), the victim or the victim's dependants are entitled to additional compensation (Article L. 452-1 of the French Social Security Code). The Cour de cassation finds such fault where the employer was aware, or should have been aware, of the danger and did not take the measures needed to protect the employee from it. Recognition gives entitlement to an increase in the annuity or lump sum (Article L. 452-2) and to compensation for the losses that the annuity does not cover (Article L. 452-3); these sums are advanced by the social security fund, which recovers them from the employer. Failing an amicable agreement, the social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire) decides (Article L. 452-4). The time limit is two years (Article L. 431-2). For victims whose condition is consolidated on or after 1 November 2026, the annuity consists of an occupational part and a functional part, both increased. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts for the victim, the victim's relatives and the employer. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
An accident at work, an occupational disease, an employer's fault to be recognised?
Understanding your situation
The employer's inexcusable fault (faute inexcusable), explained
The victim of an inexcusable fault is entitled to additional compensation (Article L. 452-1 of the French Social Security Code). What characterises the fault, how and within what time limit to have it recognised, what the employer can argue in response, and what compensation covers before and since the reform of 1 November 2026.
Key points
Inexcusable fault: four conditions to be met
What the victim must establish, and what the judge examines first.
An accident at work or an occupational disease: an accident at work is any accident, whatever its cause, occurring as a result of or in the course of work (Article L. 411-1 of the French Social Security Code). Inexcusable fault is grafted onto this scheme and does not replace it (Article L. 452-1).
A danger of which the employer was, or should have been, aware: the employer takes the measures necessary to ensure safety and protect the physical and mental health of workers (Article L. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code, Code du travail), assesses the risks and records them in the single risk assessment document (document unique) (Articles L. 4121-3 and R. 4121-1).
Measures that were absent or insufficient to protect the employee from that danger: prevention, information and training, suitable organisation and resources (Article L. 4121-1), implemented in accordance with the general principles of prevention, starting with avoiding risks and combating them at source (Article L. 4121-2).
A link with the harm: the employer's fault need not be the decisive cause of the accident or disease; it must be one of its necessary causes.
The definition comes from case law. For the Cour de cassation, a breach of the statutory safety obligation amounts to inexcusable fault where the employer "was or should have been aware of the danger to which the worker was exposed and did not take the measures necessary to protect the worker from it" (our translation). In the same case, it set aside the judgment that had ruled out the fault even though the judges' findings showed "that the protective measures implemented by the employer were ineffective" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 October 2020, No. 18-26.677). A measure that exists on paper is therefore not enough: it must actually protect.
The causal link is assessed broadly. The Cour de cassation points out that the fault need not have been the decisive cause of the occupational disease: "It is sufficient that it be one of the necessary causes of the occupational disease from which the victim suffers" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278). The employer's fault therefore need not be the sole cause of the harm.
Awareness of the danger has its limits. The Versailles Court of Appeal ruled out inexcusable fault in an accident resulting from "an unprecedented chain of circumstances" (our translation), since the risk that materialised was not known to the company and could not be anticipated (CA Versailles, 5e ch., 15 December 2022, No. 22/00057). The firm therefore reconstructs what the employer knew, or ought to have known, before the accident: previous incidents, warnings, the single risk assessment document, instructions, inspection reports. See our article on the absence of a single risk assessment document and inexcusable fault.
The procedure
From the social security fund to the pôle social: the steps and the time limit
Two years to act, a possible amicable phase, then the judge.
Occupational nature
Inexcusable fault presupposes an accident at work or an occupational disease. It does not depend on the fund's decision to recognise the claim: the Cour de cassation holds that its recognition, being independent of that decision, "does not imply that the accident was previously declared to the fund" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-19.080).
The two-year time limit
The rights of the victim or of the victim's dependants are time-barred after two years running, in particular, from the day of the accident or from the end of payment of the daily allowance (Article L. 431-2 of the French Social Security Code).
Conciliation
The victim may apply to the social security fund to seek an amicable agreement with the employer on the existence of the fault and the amount of the increase and of the compensation (Article L. 452-4). This application interrupts the limitation period until notification of the outcome of the conciliation attempt.
The pôle social
Failing agreement, the competent social security court, seised by the victim, the victim's dependants or the fund, decides (Article L. 452-4). This litigation falls within the jurisdiction of specially designated judicial courts (Article L. 211-16 of the French Code of Judicial Organisation). The victim joins the fund to the proceedings so that the judgment is binding on it (déclaration de jugement commun).
Expert assessment
Once the fault is recognised, the judge sets the increase and may order a medical expert assessment to evaluate the losses. The judge may set the consolidation date for the heads of loss not covered by the annuity, without being bound by the date set by the fund.
Payment
The increase is paid by the fund, which recovers its capitalised value from the employer (Article L. 452-2); compensation for losses is paid directly to the beneficiaries by the fund, which recovers the amount from the employer (Article L. 452-3).
The starting point of the time limit must be watched closely. The Cour de cassation holds that the two-year limitation period "starts to run from the date of the accident or from the end of payment of the daily allowance" (our translation), that it is interrupted by an action seeking recognition of the occupational nature of the injury, but that the employer's challenge seeking to have the fund's acceptance of the claim declared unenforceable against it "does not interrupt the two-year limitation period" (our translation) of the victim's action; in that case, the action, brought more than two years after the daily allowances ended, was held to be time-barred (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-16.197). Criminal proceedings also interrupt the time limit, but only "the bringing of a criminal prosecution for the same facts" (our translation) (Article L. 431-2, last paragraph; Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-19.080): filing a criminal complaint and the records of the preliminary investigation are not sufficient (Cass. 2e civ., 21 October 2021, No. 20-11.766).
The conciliation request protects the victim. According to the Cour de cassation, applying to the fund interrupts the limitation period, and a new period starts to run "only from the notification, by the fund to the parties, of the outcome of the conciliation attempt" (our translation); as long as the fund has not informed the victim of the outcome regarding the additional compensation, the claim remains admissible (Cass. 2e civ., 5 September 2024, No. 22-16.220).
The time limit sometimes starts earlier than people think: the end of the daily allowances does not always coincide with notification of consolidation. The firm calculates the time limit at the first appointment and interrupts it without delay. See our articles on the two-year limitation period and its interruptions and on conciliation before the social security fund, and our page on proceedings before the pôle social.
Both sides
You are the victim or a relative, or you are the employer whose liability is alleged
The same texts read differently depending on your position.
You are the victim or a dependant
- Calculate the two-year time limit and interrupt it, through a conciliation request to the fund or a claim before the pôle social.
- Gather evidence of awareness of the danger: written warnings, previous incidents, the single risk assessment document, witness statements, the labour inspectorate's investigation.
- Seek the maximum increase, an expert assessment and compensation for each head of loss not covered by the annuity.
You are the employer whose liability is alleged
- Check the limitation period and, where appropriate, challenge the occupational nature of the accident or disease.
- Demonstrate the measures taken: risk assessment, training, equipment, instructions, effective checks.
- Dispute the causal link, the exposure to the risk in your company and the assessment of each head of loss, and involve your insurer.
The employer retains a defence of its own: the Cour de cassation points out that "the employer remains entitled to challenge the occupational nature of the accident at work, the occupational disease or the relapse where its inexcusable fault is alleged by the victim or the victim's dependants" (our translation). A finding that the fund's acceptance of the claim is unenforceable against the employer does not, however, shield it: even when pronounced by a decision that has become final, it "does not prevent the fund from bringing its recourse action against the employer" (our translation); the Cour de cassation set aside the judgment that had dismissed the fund's claim for reimbursement and remitted the case to the Rouen Court of Appeal (Cass. 2e civ., 26 June 2025, No. 23-16.183). Recognition of the fault by a decision that has become final "entails the obligation for the employer to pay the sums for which it is liable" (our translation), whatever the conditions in which the fund informed it (Article L. 452-3-1 of the French Social Security Code).
The points the firm examines in every case:
The employer answers for the fault with its own assets. Article L. 452-4 of the French Social Security Code states that "The person who committed the inexcusable fault is liable on their personal assets for its consequences" (our translation) and that "The employer may insure itself against the financial consequences of its own inexcusable fault" (our translation) or that of the persons to whom it delegated management authority. The regional pension and occupational health fund (caisse d'assurance retraite et de la santé au travail) may then impose an additional contribution on it. The first step for a company whose liability is alleged is therefore to report the claim to its insurer. See our article on the unenforceability of the fund's decision against the employer and the fund's recourse action.
Compensation
Increase of the annuity, compensable losses and the reform of 1 November 2026
What recognition brings, and what changes depending on the consolidation date.
The increase
The victim or the victim's dependants receive an increase in the benefits due for accidents at work. For a lump sum, the increase may not exceed the amount of that lump sum; for an annuity, the increased annuity may not exceed the fraction of the annual salary corresponding to the reduction in capacity, or that salary in the event of total incapacity (Article L. 452-2 of the French Social Security Code).
The listed losses
Independently of the increase, the victim claims compensation for physical and mental suffering endured, aesthetic damage, loss of amenity and the loss or reduction of career advancement prospects (Article L. 452-3, in the version applicable to consolidations before 1 November 2026; for later ones, the article refers to suffering endured before consolidation).
The 100% rate
If the victim has a permanent incapacity rate of 100%, a flat-rate allowance equal to the statutory minimum wage in force at the consolidation date is also awarded (Article L. 452-3).
Functional impairment
Under the scheme prior to the reform, the annuity does not compensate permanent functional impairment (déficit fonctionnel permanent), which is therefore compensated in addition in the event of inexcusable fault.
Since 1 November 2026
For victims whose condition is consolidated on or after that date, the annuity comprises an occupational part and a functional part (Article L. 434-2 in its version applicable on 1 November 2026), and the increase applies to both parts (Article L. 452-2 in the same version).
Relatives
In the event of a fatal accident, dependants entitled to an annuity, as well as ascendants and descendants who are not entitled to one, may claim compensation from the employer for their non-pecuniary loss (préjudice moral) (Article L. 452-3).
Permanent functional impairment was reopened by the full court (assemblée plénière). Reversing its case law, the Cour de cassation held that "the annuity does not compensate permanent functional impairment" (our translation) (Cass. ass. plén., 20 January 2023, No. 20-23.673). It inferred that the victim of an inexcusable fault "may claim compensation for permanent functional impairment, which the annuity or the lump-sum payment are not intended to compensate" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 16 May 2024, No. 22-23.314), then specified that this head of loss includes, after consolidation, "impairment of physiological functions and of psychological integrity" (our translation), the suffering endured and "the loss of quality of life and the disturbances experienced by the victim in their personal, family and social living conditions" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 25-15.843). The social security court assesses this head of loss "without being bound by the permanent incapacity rate determined by the fund" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988).
The reform changes the balance for recent consolidations. From 1 November 2026, the annuity consists of an occupational part "corresponding to the loss of earnings and the occupational impact of the incapacity" (our translation) and a functional part "corresponding to the victim's permanent functional impairment" (our translation) (new Article L. 434-2); in the event of inexcusable fault, "the increase applies to the occupational part and the functional part" (our translation), and the increase of the functional part may be paid as a lump sum at the victim's request (new Article L. 452-2). New Article L. 452-3 refers to "all losses not subject to flat-rate compensation under this book" (our translation), including suffering endured "before the consolidation date" (our translation). These rules do not apply to everyone: under paragraph V of Article 90 of Law No. 2025-199 of 28 February 2025, as amended by Article 95 of Law No. 2025-1403 of 30 December 2025, "It applies to victims whose condition is consolidated from that date" (our translation) (note under Article L. 452-2 of the French Social Security Code; Article 3 of Decree No. 2026-354 of 7 May 2026).
The annuity scheme is therefore determined by the victim's consolidation date. A separate question concerns the heads of loss not covered by the annuity: for those alone, the judge hearing the inexcusable fault claim may set the consolidation date "without being bound by the date adopted by the social security body" (our translation), this determination not entailing "any challenge to the final nature of the decisions taken by the fund for determining the benefits paid under social security legislation" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988). No text identified gives the date so set by the judge any effect on the choice between the old and the new annuity scheme. The decisions cited here were handed down under the texts in force before the reform. See our articles on the reform of 1 November 2026 and functional impairment, on the consolidation date set by the judge and on calculating the increase of the annuity.
Proof
Proving the fault: presumptions, documents and common situations
The burden of proof lies with the victim, except in two cases where the law reverses it.
The risk had been reported: inexcusable fault is established as of right for the injured worker where the worker or a staff representative on the social and economic committee (comité social et économique) had reported to the employer the risk that materialised (Article L. 4131-4 of the French Labour Code).
The employee was on a fixed-term or temporary contract in a high-risk position: inexcusable fault is presumed to be established for an employee on a fixed-term contract, a temporary agency worker or a trainee assigned to a position presenting particular risks without having received enhanced safety training (Articles L. 4154-2 and L. 4154-3).
The temporary agency worker: the user company is regarded as having taken the employer's place in directing the work, and the employer remains bound by the obligations arising from inexcusable fault, without prejudice to its action for reimbursement against the person who committed the fault (Article L. 412-6 of the French Social Security Code).
Warnings and the right to withdraw: the worker immediately alerts the employer to any work situation which the worker has reasonable grounds to believe presents a serious and imminent danger (Article L. 4131-1 of the French Labour Code). A dated warning email is a key document.
Safety training: the employer organises practical and appropriate safety training for newly hired workers, those who change position or technique, and temporary agency workers (Article L. 4141-2).
The single risk assessment document: the employer records and updates the risk assessment in it, with an inventory for each work unit, including thermal conditions (Article R. 4121-1).
Reporting is assessed in concrete terms. The Cour de cassation set aside the judgment that had refused the presumption to an employee who had forwarded a threatening letter to her employer, "so that she had reported to it the risk of assault to which she was exposed" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 July 2021, No. 19-25.550). For the temporary agency worker, the presumption under Article L. 4154-3 "can be rebutted only by proof that the employer gave the employee the enhanced safety training" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-23.694).
Outside the presumptions, proof remains the victim's burden, and the 2026 case law makes it heavier for occupational diseases. The Cour de cassation now holds that "it is for the victim who seeks recognition of the employer's inexcusable fault to prove that they were exposed to the risk of their disease while working for that employer" (our translation), since acceptance of the claim by the fund creates "neither a presumption that the disease is occupational nor a presumption of exposure to the risk at any particular employer" (our translation); the dependants of an asbestos victim thus lost against a former employer (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278). A known danger is not enough either: the Paris Court of Appeal ruled out inexcusable fault in the assault of an employee by a customer, since the employer, which knew of the danger, had "put in place numerous protection systems and provided adequate safety training" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 28 June 2024, No. 21/00069).
See our articles on reporting the risk and the presumption under Article L. 4131-4, on temporary agency workers and enhanced training, on occupational disease and successive employers and on assault on an employee at the workplace. For recognition of the disease itself, see our page occupational disease lawyer in Paris.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is an employer's inexcusable fault in France?
It is the fault that allows the victim of an accident at work or an occupational disease to obtain more than the flat-rate social security benefits. Article L. 452-1 of the French Social Security Code refers to it without defining it: "Where the accident is due to the inexcusable fault of the employer or of those to whom it delegated management authority" (our translation), the victim or the victim's dependants are entitled to additional compensation.
The definition comes from the Cour de cassation, which links it to the statutory safety obligation in Article L. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code, under which "The employer takes the measures necessary to ensure safety and protect the physical and mental health of workers" (our translation). A breach of this obligation amounts to inexcusable fault where the employer "was or should have been aware of the danger to which the worker was exposed and did not take the measures necessary to protect the worker from it" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 October 2020, No. 18-26.677).
Two elements must therefore be established: awareness of the danger, whether the employer had it or ought to have had it, and the absence or inadequacy of protective measures. Nor does the fault have to be the decisive cause of the harm: it is sufficient that it be one of its necessary causes (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278). The employer's intentional fault falls under a different scheme, which opens an ordinary-law action against the person who committed it (Article L. 452-5 of the French Social Security Code).
How do you prove an employer's inexcusable fault?
The burden of proof lies with the victim or the victim's dependants, unless there is a statutory presumption. It must be shown that the employer was or should have been aware of the danger and did not take the necessary measures. The useful documents are often within the company: the single risk assessment document, which the employer must keep up to date with an inventory of risks for each work unit (Article R. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code), minutes of the social and economic committee, machine inspection reports, job descriptions, training certificates, warning emails, the labour inspectorate's investigation or criminal proceedings.
For occupational diseases, the Cour de cassation tightened the requirement in 2026: "it is for the victim who seeks recognition of the employer's inexcusable fault to prove that they were exposed to the risk of their disease while working for that employer" (our translation). The fund's decision accepting the claim is not proof against any particular employer, and the dependants who could not prove exposure to asbestos at the former employer had their claim dismissed (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278).
A known danger is not always enough. The Paris Court of Appeal ruled out the fault in the assault of an employee by a customer, since the employer had "put in place numerous protection systems and provided adequate safety training" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 28 June 2024, No. 21/00069). The firm therefore builds the evidence on two fronts at once, what the employer knew and what it did, and where necessary asks for disclosure of the documents held by the company. See our article on the burden of proving exposure since 25 June 2026.
When is inexcusable fault presumed?
In two cases provided for by the French Labour Code, the victim does not have to prove awareness of the danger. The first is the reported risk: inexcusable fault "is established as of right" (our translation) for a worker who suffers an accident at work or an occupational disease where the worker or a staff representative on the social and economic committee had reported to the employer the risk that materialised (Article L. 4131-4 of the French Labour Code). The Cour de cassation does not require a formal warning: it accepted as a report the conduct of an employee who had forwarded to her employer a threatening letter received in a context of tension, "so that she had reported to it the risk of assault to which she was exposed" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 July 2021, No. 19-25.550).
The second concerns fixed-term and temporary contracts. Inexcusable fault "is presumed to be established" (our translation) for employees on fixed-term contracts, temporary agency workers and trainees injured while assigned to positions presenting particular risks to their health or safety, if they had not received enhanced safety training (Articles L. 4154-2 and L. 4154-3 of the French Labour Code). This presumption "can be rebutted only by proof that the employer gave the employee the enhanced safety training" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-23.694).
The firm systematically explores these two routes before building the ordinary proof: an email, a register or minutes of the social and economic committee are sometimes enough to turn the debate around. See our article on reporting the risk and the presumption of inexcusable fault.
What is the time limit for an inexcusable fault claim in France?
Two years. The rights of the victim or the victim's dependants to the benefits and compensation under Book IV are time-barred after two years running, in particular, "from the day of the accident or from the end of payment of the daily allowance" (our translation) (Article L. 431-2 of the French Social Security Code). For occupational diseases, the date of the accident is replaced, for the purposes of this limitation period, by the date on which the victim is informed by a medical certificate of the possible link between the disease and an occupational activity (Article L. 461-1).
Several acts interrupt this time limit. The last paragraph of Article L. 431-2 provides that, in the case of an accident likely to lead to recognition of inexcusable fault, the limitation period is interrupted "by the bringing of a criminal prosecution for the same facts or of an action seeking recognition of the occupational nature of the accident" (our translation), which the Cour de cassation applies (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-19.080). A complaint or a preliminary investigation is not enough: "Neither the filing of a complaint recorded in an official report nor the other reports drawn up by judicial police officers during the preliminary investigation constitute a ground for interrupting this limitation period" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 21 October 2021, No. 20-11.766). Applying to the fund for conciliation also interrupts the limitation period, and the new period runs "only from the notification, by the fund to the parties, of the outcome of the conciliation attempt" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 5 September 2024, No. 22-16.220).
Other acts do not interrupt it. The employer's challenge seeking to have the decision accepting the claim declared unenforceable against it "does not interrupt the two-year limitation period" (our translation) of the victim's action: an action brought more than two years after the end of the daily allowances was held to be time-barred (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-16.197). The firm establishes the exact date of the last payment of daily allowances and acts before the deadline. See our article on the limitation period for inexcusable fault claims.
How does the procedure work, from the CPAM to the pôle social?
In two possible stages. The victim or the victim's dependants may first apply to the primary health insurance fund (caisse primaire d'assurance maladie, CPAM) to seek an amicable agreement with the employer on the existence of the inexcusable fault, the amount of the increase and the compensation under Article L. 452-3 (Article L. 452-4 of the French Social Security Code). This phase is not compulsory, but it interrupts the limitation period until notification of its outcome (Cass. 2e civ., 5 September 2024, No. 22-16.220). It can only lead to an amicable agreement between the fund, the victim and the employer, the judge deciding if there is no agreement (Article L. 452-4).
Failing agreement, "it is for the competent social security court, seised by the victim or the victim's dependants or by the primary health insurance fund, to decide" (our translation), and the victim must join the fund to the proceedings so that the judgment is binding on it (Article L. 452-4). Social security litigation falls within the jurisdiction of specially designated judicial courts, through their social division (pôle social) (Article L. 211-16 of the French Code of Judicial Organisation).
The judge rules on the fault and on the increase, and may order a medical expert assessment before assessing the losses. For the heads of loss not covered by the annuity, the judge sets the consolidation date and assesses permanent functional impairment without being bound by the fund, where appropriate by ordering an investigative measure (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988). The firm drafts the conciliation request, the application and the written submissions, assists the victim at the expert assessment and pleads the case. See our page on proceedings before the pôle social and our article on conciliation before the social security fund.
What compensation is available for an employer's inexcusable fault?
Recognition has two effects. The first is the increase of the benefits paid for the accident at work. For a lump sum, the increase may not exceed the amount of that lump sum; for an annuity, it is set so that the increased annuity does not exceed the fraction of the annual salary corresponding to the reduction in capacity, or the salary itself in the event of total incapacity (Article L. 452-2 of the French Social Security Code). In the event of death, the total of the dependants' annuities and increases may not exceed the annual salary.
The second is compensation for losses that the annuity does not cover: physical and mental suffering, aesthetic damage and loss of amenity, loss or reduction of career advancement prospects and, for a permanent incapacity of 100%, a flat-rate allowance equal to the statutory minimum wage at the consolidation date (Article L. 452-3, in the version applicable to consolidations before 1 November 2026; for later ones, the article refers to suffering endured before consolidation). The list is not closed: other heads of loss may be compensated if they are not already covered by Book IV, including permanent functional impairment for consolidations before 1 November 2026 (Cass. 2e civ., 16 May 2024, No. 22-23.314).
The victim does not pursue the employer to be paid: "Compensation for these losses is paid directly to the beneficiaries by the fund, which recovers the amount from the employer" (our translation) (Article L. 452-3), and the increase follows the same route (Article L. 452-2). The amount depends on the after-effects, the victim's age and the medical file: the firm calculates each head of loss from the documents, without announcing any outcome. See our article on calculating the increase of the annuity and our page accident at work lawyer in Paris.
Is permanent functional impairment compensated?
Yes, for victims whose condition was consolidated before 1 November 2026, following a reversal of case law. For years, the Cour de cassation held that the annuity also compensated permanent functional impairment. In 2023, the full court held the opposite: "All of these considerations lead the Court to hold henceforth that the annuity does not compensate permanent functional impairment" (our translation) (Cass. ass. plén., 20 January 2023, No. 20-23.673). The Second Civil Chamber drew the consequence for inexcusable fault: the victim "may claim compensation for permanent functional impairment, which the annuity or the lump-sum payment are not intended to compensate" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 16 May 2024, No. 22-23.314).
The scope of this head of loss is broad. In a judgment of 15 October 2026, the Cour de cassation specifies that it includes, after consolidation, "impairment of physiological functions and of psychological integrity" (our translation), the physical and mental suffering endured and "the loss of quality of life and the disturbances experienced by the victim in their personal, family and social living conditions" (our translation), and sets aside the judgment that had refused to compensate difficulty in carrying out everyday activities (Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 25-15.843). The social security court assesses this loss at its own discretion, "without being bound by the permanent incapacity rate determined by the fund" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988).
For victims whose condition is consolidated on or after 1 November 2026, the annuity comprises a functional part "corresponding to the victim's permanent functional impairment" (our translation), increased in the event of inexcusable fault (Articles L. 434-2 and L. 452-2 in their version applicable from that date). See the next question and our article on the judgment of 15 October 2026 and the reform.
What does the reform of 1 November 2026 change for inexcusable fault?
It overhauls the permanent incapacity annuity. Stemming from Article 90 of Law No. 2025-199 of 28 February 2025, and implemented by Decree No. 2026-354 of 7 May 2026, which "enters into force on 1 November 2026" (our translation) (Article 3 of the Decree), it divides the annuity into an occupational part "corresponding to the loss of earnings and the occupational impact of the incapacity" (our translation) and a functional part "corresponding to the victim's permanent functional impairment" (our translation), calculated in functional incapacity points according to a scale that takes age into account (Article L. 434-2 of the French Social Security Code, version applicable on 1 November 2026).
In the event of inexcusable fault, "the increase applies to the occupational part and the functional part" (our translation), and the increase of the functional part may be paid as a lump sum at the victim's request (new Article L. 452-2). New Article L. 452-3 opens compensation for "all losses not subject to flat-rate compensation under this book" (our translation), in particular suffering endured "before the consolidation date" (our translation).
The criterion for application is consolidation, not the date of the accident or of the judgment: "It applies to victims whose condition is consolidated from that date" (our translation) (paragraph V of Article 90 of Law No. 2025-199 as amended, note under Article L. 452-2). A victim whose condition was consolidated before 1 November 2026 remains under the old scheme, with separate compensation for permanent functional impairment (Cass. 2e civ., 16 May 2024, No. 22-23.314). The consolidation date therefore becomes a key issue. It is not the same as the date that the judge hearing the inexcusable fault claim may set solely for the heads of loss not covered by the annuity, without calling into question the fund's final decisions on benefits (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988); no text identified gives that latter date any effect on the annuity scheme. See our article on the reform of 1 November 2026.
Is the judge bound by the consolidation date or incapacity rate set by the fund?
For social security benefits, yes; for additional compensation, no. In a judgment of 3 September 2026, the Cour de cassation abandoned its earlier case law, which declared inadmissible a victim seeking a consolidation date other than the fund's unchallenged date. It holds that the judge hearing the inexcusable fault claim, when the consolidation date is disputed for the purpose of compensating heads of loss not covered by Book IV, must set it at their own discretion, "without being bound by the date adopted by the social security body" (our translation) for determining benefits (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988).
The same judgment applies to the rate. The court assesses permanent functional impairment "without being bound by the permanent incapacity rate determined by the fund" (our translation) under the conditions of Article L. 434-2 of the French Social Security Code, that decision being final only for statutory benefits. The court of appeal, which had refused a further expert assessment on these two points, was overturned.
The scope is limited. The new date does not allow the victim to obtain compensation from the employer for items covered, "even restrictively" (our translation), by the Social Security Code, nor to call into question the fund's final decisions on benefits. Challenging the permanent incapacity rate for benefit purposes remains a separate type of litigation (Article L. 142-1, 5°). The firm decides, with the medical file in hand, whether to ask the judge for a different date or rate. See our article on the consolidation date set by the judge.
Occupational disease and several employers: whom should you sue?
The employer whose fault is at issue, which requires proof of exposure to the risk while working for that employer. The Cour de cassation accepts that the fact that the victim was exposed while working for several employers does not prevent the victim from proving that one of them committed inexcusable fault; but, in its judgment of 25 June 2026, it holds that "it is for the victim who seeks recognition of the employer's inexcusable fault to prove that they were exposed to the risk of their disease while working for that employer" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278).
It thus departs from its 2017 position, which placed on the employer the burden of proving that the disease was not attributable to it. Acceptance of the disease under the occupational injury legislation creates "neither a presumption that the disease is occupational nor a presumption of exposure to the risk at any particular employer" (our translation). In that case, the witness statements produced did not prove exposure to asbestos at the former employer and the disease declaration did not mention that company: the dependants and the compensation fund lost.
Evidence is therefore prepared employer by employer: employment certificates, job descriptions, statements from former colleagues describing the tasks and products, exposure records, medical monitoring. The two-year time limit under Article L. 431-2 of the French Social Security Code applies to each action. See our articles on successive employers and proof of exposure and on the reversal of 25 June 2026, and our page occupational disease lawyer in Paris.
Temporary agency worker: who is liable for inexcusable fault?
The user company is regarded as having taken the employer's place in directing the work; the temporary work agency remains liable to the victim and can seek recourse against the user company that committed the fault. For the application of Articles L. 452-1 to L. 452-4, "the user, the head of the user company or those to whom they delegated management authority are regarded as having taken the place of the employer in directing the work" (our translation); the employer remains bound by the obligations arising from inexcusable fault, without prejudice to the action for reimbursement it may bring against the person who committed the fault (Article L. 412-6 of the French Social Security Code).
Proof is easier where the temporary agency worker held a high-risk position. Temporary agency workers assigned to positions presenting particular risks to their health or safety receive enhanced safety training (Article L. 4154-2 of the French Labour Code), and inexcusable fault is presumed to be established if they were deprived of it (Article L. 4154-3). The Cour de cassation dismissed a user company's appeal: the presumption "can be rebutted only by proof that the employer gave the employee the enhanced safety training" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-23.694).
The employer remains liable to the victim, the fund being joined to the proceedings so that the judgment is binding on it (Article L. 452-4 of the French Social Security Code), and it may seek recourse against the user company that committed the fault (Article L. 412-6). The firm checks the list of high-risk positions, which the employer draws up after consulting the occupational physician and the social and economic committee (Article L. 4154-2), and the training records. See our article on temporary agency workers, the presumption and the user company.
Fatal accident at work: what rights do the victim's relatives have?
Relatives have rights of their own. In the event of a fatal accident, a pension is paid from the date of death to the persons and under the conditions provided for by the code (Article L. 434-7 of the French Social Security Code). If inexcusable fault is recognised, these annuities are increased, the total of the annuities and increases paid to all the dependants not being allowed to exceed the amount of the victim's annual salary (Article L. 452-2).
Dependants entitled to an annuity, as well as ascendants and descendants who are not entitled to one, may also claim compensation from the employer for their non-pecuniary loss before the social security court (Article L. 452-3). The heirs may also pursue the victim's action for the losses the victim personally suffered before death: this is what the dependants did in the case decided by the full court in 2023, which overturned the refusal to compensate the suffering endured by the victim (Cass. ass. plén., 20 January 2023, No. 20-23.673).
The two-year time limit also runs for relatives (Article L. 431-2), but it does not run against a minor child of the victim: the Cour de cassation holds, on the basis of Article 2235 of the French Civil Code, that this limitation period is governed by the ordinary rules, so that "it is suspended during the minority of the dependants of the victim of an accident at work" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 21 October 2021, No. 20-11.766). For other relatives, only "the bringing of a criminal prosecution for the same facts" (our translation) interrupts the time limit (Article L. 431-2, last paragraph), and, in that case, the complaint dropped by the prosecutor (classée sans suite) and the investigation reports had not interrupted the limitation period, the appeal judgment being quashed only with regard to the minor child (Cass. 2e civ., 21 October 2021, No. 20-11.766). The firm then coordinates the two sets of proceedings, criminal and social security. See our article on fatal accidents at work and the rights of dependants.
Employer facing an inexcusable fault claim: how to defend yourself?
Through procedure first. The two-year limitation period is checked from the date of the accident and the end of the daily allowances (Article L. 431-2 of the French Social Security Code); it has already led to a victim's action being declared time-barred (Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-16.197). The employer may also challenge the occupational nature of the accident or disease, as it "remains entitled to challenge the occupational nature" (our translation) where its inexcusable fault is alleged (Cass. 2e civ., 26 June 2025, No. 23-16.183). For occupational diseases, the victim must prove exposure to the risk while working for that employer (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278).
On the merits next, by demonstrating the measures taken: risk assessment and the single risk assessment document, training, equipment, instructions, effective checks. The courts rule out the fault where the risk was not foreseeable, as in an accident resulting from "an unprecedented chain of circumstances" (our translation) (CA Versailles, 5e ch., 15 December 2022, No. 22/00057), or where the protection was suited to the known danger (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 28 June 2024, No. 21/00069). The existence of measures is not enough if they were ineffective (Cass. 2e civ., 8 October 2020, No. 18-26.677).
Finally, on the consequences. A finding obtained against the fund that its acceptance of the claim is unenforceable against the employer does not prevent the fund's recourse action (Cass. 2e civ., 26 June 2025, No. 23-16.183), but, according to the Cour de cassation, that action is exercised "within the limit, for the recovery of the amount of the increase of the accident at work annuity awarded to the victim by reason of the employer's inexcusable fault, of the rate notified to the employer" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988). The employer may insure itself against the financial consequences of its inexcusable fault (Article L. 452-4): the claim must be reported to the insurer without delay. The firm also defends businesses in these proceedings. See our article on the fund's recourse action.
What are the fees of an inexcusable fault lawyer in Paris?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or method of determining the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the anticipated costs and disbursements. The same text prohibits fees set solely on the basis of the outcome of the case: "Any setting of fees solely according to the judicial outcome is prohibited" (our translation).
The firm favours a fixed fee for each stage: analysis of the case and calculation of the time limit, conciliation request before the fund, application and hearing before the pôle social on the fault and the increase, assistance at the medical expert assessment, assessment of the losses, appeal and, for the employer, defence and third-party claim against the insurer. The amount takes account of what is at stake and of the volume of documents, medical files and company records. Any new engagement gives rise to an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For an initial opinion on documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 452-1, L. 452-2 and L. 452-3 of the French Social Security Code: inexcusable fault, increase, compensable losses (versions in force until 31 October 2026)
- Articles L. 452-2 and L. 452-3 of the French Social Security Code: increase of both parts of the annuity and compensable losses, version applicable on 1 November 2026
- Articles L. 452-3-1, L. 452-4 and L. 452-5 of the French Social Security Code: employer's obligation, conciliation and court, insurance, intentional fault
- Articles L. 434-1 and L. 434-2 of the French Social Security Code: lump-sum payment and annuity (versions in force until 31 October 2026)
- Articles L. 434-1 and L. 434-2 of the French Social Security Code: occupational part and functional part, version applicable on 1 November 2026
- Paragraph V of Article 90 of Law No. 2025-199 of 28 February 2025 and Article 3 of Decree No. 2026-354 of 7 May 2026: entry into force on 1 November 2026, victims whose condition is consolidated from that date
- Articles L. 411-1, L. 431-1, L. 431-2 and L. 461-1 of the French Social Security Code: accident at work, benefits, two-year limitation period, starting point for occupational diseases
- Articles L. 412-6, L. 434-7, L. 453-1 and L. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code: user company, dependants, victim's fault, social security litigation
- Articles L. 4121-1, L. 4121-2, L. 4121-3 and R. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code: safety obligation, principles of prevention, risk assessment, single risk assessment document
- Articles L. 4131-1, L. 4131-4 and L. 4141-2 of the French Labour Code: warning and right to withdraw, reported risk, safety training
- Articles L. 4154-2 and L. 4154-3 of the French Labour Code: enhanced training and presumption for fixed-term and temporary contracts
- Article L. 211-16 of the French Code of Judicial Organisation: judicial courts with jurisdiction in social security matters
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 8 October 2020, No. 18-26.677: definition of inexcusable fault, ineffective measures
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-22.278: proof of exposure to the risk, necessary cause
- Cass. 2e civ., 8 July 2021, No. 19-25.550: reported risk and the presumption under Article L. 4131-4
- Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-23.694: presumption under Article L. 4154-3 for temporary agency workers
- Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-19.080: interruption by criminal proceedings, independence from the fund's acceptance of the claim
- Cass. 2e civ., 21 October 2021, No. 20-11.766: complaint and investigation do not interrupt, suspension during minority
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 April 2024, No. 22-16.197: starting point of the limitation period, time-barred action
- Cass. 2e civ., 5 September 2024, No. 22-16.220: interruption by application to the fund
- Cass. 2e civ., 26 June 2025, No. 23-16.183: recourse action despite unenforceability
- Cass. ass. plén., 20 January 2023, No. 20-23.673: the annuity does not compensate permanent functional impairment
- Cass. 2e civ., 16 May 2024, No. 22-23.314: compensation for permanent functional impairment
- Cass. 2e civ., 15 October 2026, No. 25-15.843: content of permanent functional impairment
- Cass. 2e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 23-22.988: consolidation date and rate set by the judge
- CA Versailles, 5e ch., 15 December 2022, No. 22/00057: unprecedented risk, fault ruled out
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 28 June 2024, No. 21/00069: assault on an employee, suitable measures, fault ruled out
Further reading
A workplace accident, an industrial disease, employer negligence to be recognised?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the accident or disease declaration, the fund's decision accepting the claim, the fund's notifications, the sick notes and any documents you have: Hassan Kohen checks the time limit, the evidence of awareness of the danger and the applicable scheme according to the consolidation date, then advises you on the appropriate route: conciliation before the fund, a claim before the pôle social, expert assessment or defence of the employer.