They talk about us
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, business cybersecurity lawyers in Paris
Cybersecurity lawyer in Paris: prevent, respond, obtain redress
GDPR security obligations, preparing for NIS 2, legal management of a cyberattack or data breach, notification to the CNIL, criminal complaint and cyber insurance, claims against the IT service provider or defence against its customers: as a cybersecurity lawyer in Paris, the firm assists businesses before, during and after the incident, and also defends service providers who are held liable. Time limits start running as soon as the attack is discovered.
The firm can be reached 24/7. A personal data breach must be notified to the CNIL without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours (Article 33 of the GDPR); compensation by an insurer for an attack on an information system requires a criminal complaint filed no later than 72 hours after the victim becomes aware of it (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code, Code des assurances).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a case involving a protection order (ordonnance de protection) requested abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar, business cybersecurity, legal management of cyberattacks, IT contracts and liability litigation.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The data controller and its processor implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to ensure a level of security appropriate to the risk (Article 32 of the GDPR). In the event of a personal data breach, the CNIL is notified without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours (Article 33), the data subjects are informed if the risk is high (Article 34), and failure to notify is a criminal offence (Article 226-17-1 of the French Criminal Code, Code pénal). An insurer only pays compensation for an attack on an information system after a criminal complaint has been filed no later than 72 hours after the victim becomes aware of it (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code). The NIS 2 Directive has not yet been transposed into French law as at 31 October 2026. After the incident, the IT service provider is liable for its breaches of contract (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code, Code civil), but the courts also take into account the share of responsibility of a victim that failed to define its needs. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts both for the business that suffered the attack and for the service provider held liable. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A cyberattack in progress, a data breach, a service provider to hold liable?
Understanding your situation
Business cybersecurity law, explained
Data security is a legal obligation (Article 32 of the GDPR). What the law requires before an incident, the time limits that start running from the cyberattack, the liability of the service provider and the insurer, and the contracts that prepare for the day everything stops.
Key points
What the law requires before any attack
IT security is not only a technical matter: it is an obligation whose observance is reviewed by the CNIL and by the courts.
Measures appropriate to the risk: taking into account the state of the art, the costs of implementation and the risks for individuals, the controller and the processor must ensure "a level of security appropriate to the risk", in particular through pseudonymisation and encryption, the ability to restore the availability of data after an incident and a process for regularly testing the measures (Article 32 of the GDPR).
Processors that are selected and supervised: the controller uses only processors providing sufficient guarantees, and the contract binding them provides in particular that the processor takes all measures required under Article 32 and allows for audits, including inspections (Article 28 of the GDPR).
A data breach procedure ready to use: notification to the CNIL, information of individuals where the risk is high, and documentation of every breach, "comprising the facts relating to the personal data breach, its effects and the remedial action taken" (Articles 33 and 34 of the GDPR).
Sector-specific rules to follow: Directive (EU) 2022/2555, known as NIS 2, strengthens the cybersecurity requirements for many entities. As at 31 October 2026, the bill transposing it, adopted by the Senate on 12 March 2025 and then by a special committee of the National Assembly on 10 September 2025, has not yet been debated in plenary session (National Assembly legislative file). Our NIS 2 lawyer page follows this timetable.
The CNIL assesses these obligations in concrete terms, and the Council of State (Conseil d'État) upholds its approach. It confirmed a €250,000 fine imposed on an optical retail chain after an attack on its website, holding that the vulnerability behind the breach of the data of nearly 200,000 customers was "the direct consequence of the failure by Optical Center to carry out regular checks on the technical and organisational measures taken by its processor responsible for the security of its website" (our translation) (CE, 10th ch., 26 April 2022, No. 449284). Entrusting security to a service provider therefore does not exempt a business from supervising it.
The size of the organisation does not change the principle. For a practitioner who had configured his own imaging server himself and failed to encrypt his patients' data, the Council of State upheld the finding of a "breach of the basic requirements of IT security" (our translation), while reducing the fine from €3,000 to €2,500, as there had been no breach of the notification obligation (CE, 10th and 9th ch. combined, 22 July 2022, No. 449694).
Breaches of Articles 25 to 39 of the GDPR, including security and notification, expose the business to an administrative fine of up to €10 million or, for an undertaking, 2% of its total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher (Article 83 of the GDPR). Processing data without the measures prescribed by Article 32 is also punishable by five years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine (Article 226-17 of the French Criminal Code). General GDPR compliance is covered on our GDPR lawyer page.
The crisis
Cyberattack: the time limits that run from discovery
Several obligations start at the same time, towards different recipients. Missing them costs an insurance cover, a fine or a lawsuit.
Evidence
Before any restoration work, the business has the attack formally recorded and preserves the logs. If there is a legitimate reason to establish, before any proceedings, evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend, a measure of inquiry may be ordered on an ex parte application or in urgent proceedings (référé) (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
CNIL
If personal data are affected, the controller notifies the breach to the CNIL "without undue delay and, where feasible, not later than 72 hours after having become aware of it", unless there is no risk to individuals; beyond that, the notification is accompanied by reasons for the delay (Article 33 of the GDPR).
Processor
The hosting provider, software publisher or managed IT service provider that discovers the breach notifies it to its client, the controller, without undue delay after becoming aware of it (Article 33, paragraph 2, of the GDPR).
Individuals
When the breach is likely to result in a "high risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons", the data subjects are informed without undue delay, unless the data were effectively encrypted, the risk has been neutralised or the effort would be disproportionate (Article 34 of the GDPR).
Criminal complaint
Insurance compensation for losses caused by an attack on an information system is conditional on a criminal complaint being filed "no later than seventy-two hours after the victim becomes aware of the attack" (our translation); the rule applies to legal entities and to individuals acting in a professional capacity (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code).
Insurer
The loss is reported to the insurer as soon as the insured becomes aware of it and at the latest within the period set by the policy, which cannot be shorter than five working days; forfeiture of cover for late notification provided for in the policy requires the insurer to prove that the delay caused it a loss (Article L. 113-2 of the French Insurance Code).
Notification to the CNIL is not always required. The Council of State holds that the obligation to notify "does not apply to the controller where the CNIL itself informed it of the breach and opened its investigation on the basis of information brought to its attention by other means" (our translation) (CE, 10th and 9th ch. combined, 22 July 2022, No. 449694). Outside these cases (no risk to individuals, breach discovered by the CNIL itself), failing to notify a breach that had to be notified is a criminal offence: five years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for the controller, and the same penalties for the processor that does not alert its client (Article 226-17-1 of the French Criminal Code).
The two 72-hour time limits must not be confused. The GDPR one concerns the CNIL and presupposes personal data; the Insurance Code one concerns the authorities competent to receive the criminal complaint and is a condition for payment of the insurance compensation. An attack that affects no personal data requires no notification to the CNIL, but the complaint is still necessary in order to be compensated.
Paying a ransom, the criminal complaint and the criminal law aspects are covered in detail on our pages business hit by ransomware, filing a complaint within 72 hours of a cyberattack and whether or not to pay the ransom. Prosecuting the perpetrators is covered on our cybercrime lawyer page.
Both sides
You are the business that was attacked, or the service provider held liable
After an intrusion, the client looks for someone liable and the service provider defends its work. The same documents serve both sides.
You are the victim business
- Gather the contract, the quote, the invoices and the correspondence describing the security and backup services entrusted to the provider.
- Have the technical cause of the intrusion established by an expert, if necessary appointed by the court.
- Quantify each head of loss: business interruption, restoration, data to be rebuilt, ransom paid, expert fees.
You are the service provider held liable
- Establish the exact scope of the engagement: what was sold and what was not.
- Produce the advice and warnings given, and the proposals that went unanswered.
- Rely on the client's own fault, the absence of a specification document and the clauses the client actually accepted, within the limit of the essential obligation.
The courts may apportion liability. The Reims Court of Appeal held that the provider responsible for installing a server was bound by an enhanced obligation of means and that it had to prove "that it exercised all due diligence to achieve the expected result, but also that it committed no fault in performing its obligations" (our translation); it found the provider liable for the configuration that had allowed the ransomware attack, but only to the extent of 50%, because "the absence of a specification document and the provision of insufficient information to its contracting partner also contributed to the occurrence of the damage" (our translation) (CA Reims, 28 April 2026, No. 24/01502). The ransom paid was compensated in the same proportion. The same court set aside the limitation of liability clause relied on by the provider: its general terms and conditions had been neither attached to the accepted quote nor signed by the client, and therefore could not be enforced against it.
The arguments the firm examines in every case:
Litigation
After the incident: who is liable for the damage
Service provider, insurer, bank, employee, individuals whose data were leaked: each relationship has its own rule and its own case law.
Service provider
A debtor who fails to perform its obligation is ordered to pay damages unless it shows that performance was prevented by force majeure (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code). It is liable only for damage that was foreseeable when the contract was concluded, except in the case of gross or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3).
Force majeure
It requires an event beyond the debtor's control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and "whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures" (our translation) (Article 1218 of the French Civil Code).
Clauses
"Any clause which deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed not written" (our translation) (Article 1170 of the French Civil Code): a liability cap cannot render meaningless the security commitment that was sold.
Insurer
Losses caused by fortuitous events or by the fault of the insured are borne by the insurer, "unless formally and specifically excluded in the policy" (our translation) (Article L. 113-1 of the French Insurance Code).
Bank
The user takes all reasonable steps to keep its personalised security credentials safe (Article L. 133-16 of the French Monetary and Financial Code, Code monétaire et financier); the payer bears the losses from an unauthorised transaction that result from its fraudulent conduct or gross negligence (Article L. 133-19). For a business, the account agreement may derogate from this rule (Article L. 133-2): it is the first document to read.
Individuals
Any person who has suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement of the GDPR has the right to receive compensation from the controller or processor (Article 82 of the GDPR).
The Poitiers judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) refused to treat a cyberattack as force majeure for a debtor whose obligation is performed online. It was ruling on the case of a training organisation whose platform had become inaccessible: "It cannot be disputed that a cyberattack is beyond the control of the debtor of a contractual obligation. It cannot, however, be argued that such an event was unforeseeable" (our translation) at the date of the contract, for the debtor "of an obligation that is performed online" (our translation) (TJ Poitiers, 28 May 2026, No. 25/02161). The service provider was ordered to compensate its client.
The victim can also lose. The Nanterre commercial and economic activities court (tribunal des activités économiques) dismissed all the claims of a company hit by ransomware against its managed IT service provider: "The parties produce no document or contract describing the internal and external backup services ordered." (our translation) It also found that the company did not prove that it had passed on to its provider the technical prerequisites required by its cyber insurer, and ordered it to pay the provider's invoices (TAE Nanterre, 22 October 2025, No. 2023F02360). Likewise, the Paris Court of Appeal held that a provider had complied with its obligations under the antivirus contract, "in view of the technical work carried out and the proposal of an additional antivirus protection solution to which the client did not respond" (our translation); the same judgment, however, found it had failed in its managed IT services engagement and ordered it to reimburse the costs the client had had to incur with other providers (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 20 January 2023, No. 20/05569).
On the insurance side, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) holds, regarding an exclusion clause linked to the closure of an establishment, that such a clause "is not formal where it does not refer to precise criteria and requires interpretation" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-14.482). But a cyber insurance policy only covers what it describes: for a business whose website had been duplicated, the Brive-la-Gaillarde judicial court noted that the costs and losses cover "covers the amount of the processing costs, but does not provide for compensation for lost data" (our translation), and dismissed the claim (TJ Brive-la-Gaillarde, 2 October 2026, No. 25/00386). IT disputes in general are covered on our IT litigation lawyer page; see also our article on a cyberattack made possible by obsolete software.
Prevention
Contracts, insurance, internal procedures: preparing for the day of the attack
Lawsuits lost after a cyberattack are often lost for lack of written evidence. What is drafted before the incident decides what can be argued afterwards.
A contract that describes the security and backup services sold: scope, frequency, storage location, restoration tests. Without this document, the victim cannot prove its provider's breach.
A specification document and complete information for the provider: the client has a duty to cooperate, and its silence can halve its compensation.
Processing clauses that comply with Article 28 of the GDPR: the measures under Article 32, assistance with the obligations under Articles 32 to 36, prior written authorisation for any other processor, audits and inspections.
A liability cap compatible with the essential obligation of the contract (Article 1170 of the French Civil Code), and a realistic alert period in the event of an incident.
A cyber insurance policy reviewed before any claim: the covers actually taken out, exclusions, technical prerequisites imposed, notification deadlines.
Internal procedures: dual approval of transfers, employee training, administrator access rights limited to their tasks, an incident response plan.
Internal procedures also protect the employer in relation to its employees. After a CEO fraud, the Paris Court of Appeal held that the dismissal of the accountant who had executed the transfer was without real and serious cause, noting that "the employer does not show that it had put in place an internal procedure securing the approval of financial flows to protect itself against this type of scam, or that it had provided training to its employees on the risks of cybercrime" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 5, 20 June 2024, No. 21/09789). Conversely, an administrator's technical access does not entitle them to read everything: a person who reads messages "for purposes unrelated to their duties and without the knowledge of the holders of the messages, even if, as network administrator, they have, by virtue of their functions, a general right of access to the email system" (our translation) is guilty of fraudulently remaining in an information system (Cass. crim., 2 September 2025, No. 24-83.605).
The service provider's duty to inform exists, but it has to be proved. A party who knows information whose importance is decisive for the other party's consent must inform the other party where the latter legitimately does not know that information or relies on its contracting partner, and it is for the party claiming that information was owed to it to prove that the other party owed it, with the other party then having to prove that it provided it (Article 1112-1 of the French Civil Code). The firm drafts and reviews hosting, managed IT services, SaaS and maintenance contracts, the security schedules imposed by large corporate clients, and IT charters. The general drafting of these contracts is presented on our IT contracts lawyer page.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does a cybersecurity lawyer do?
A cybersecurity lawyer deals with the legal side of cyber risk, before, during and after the incident. Before, the lawyer identifies the business's obligations: data security, with measures ensuring "a level of security appropriate to the risk" (Article 32 of the GDPR), selection and supervision of processors (Article 28), sector-specific rules such as NIS 2 once transposed. The lawyer drafts or reviews the IT contracts, the security schedule, the IT charter and the cyber insurance policy.
During the attack, the lawyer qualifies the incident legally and keeps track of the time limits: notification to the CNIL, information of individuals, a criminal complaint within 72 hours to preserve insurance compensation (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code), notification to the insurer, preservation of evidence. The lawyer coordinates with the technical experts, who alone contain the attack and restore the systems: the lawyer carries out neither digital forensics nor remediation.
Afterwards, the lawyer handles the claims: action against the defaulting service provider, challenging a refusal of cover, defence against customers, employees or the CNIL. The firm also acts for service providers accused of having let the attack through. Case law shows that the outcome depends on the written record: a provider was held liable for half of the losses from a ransomware attack, as its client had not drawn up a specification document (CA Reims, 28 April 2026, No. 24/01502).
Ransomware attack: do you have to notify the CNIL, even if no data was stolen?
Often, yes, as soon as personal data are affected and the breach presents a risk to individuals. A personal data breach is defined broadly: a breach of security leading to the accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alteration, unauthorised disclosure of, or access to, personal data (Article 4, point 12, of the GDPR). Ransomware that makes a customer file inaccessible can amount to one, even without any data being stolen.
The controller notifies the breach to the CNIL "without undue delay and, where feasible, not later than 72 hours after having become aware of it", unless it is unlikely to result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals. After 72 hours, the notification is accompanied by reasons for the delay, and the information may be provided in phases (Article 33 of the GDPR). Every breach, whether notified or not, is documented internally. This time limit must not be confused with that of the criminal complaint required by the insurer, which also runs from the time the victim becomes aware of the attack (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code): both steps are prepared in parallel from day one.
The Council of State has set out a limit: the obligation does not apply where the CNIL itself informed the controller of the breach and opened its investigation; it reduced the fine on that ground (CE, 10th and 9th ch. combined, 22 July 2022, No. 449694). Outside these cases (no risk, breach discovered by the CNIL itself), failing to notify a breach that had to be notified is a criminal offence punishable by five years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine (Article 226-17-1 of the French Criminal Code). The firm prepares the notification, its timeline and its follow-up submissions. The general data breach procedure, outside cyberattacks, is presented on our GDPR lawyer page.
Do you have to inform customers or employees whose data were leaked?
Only if the risk is high. When a personal data breach is likely to result in a "high risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons", the controller communicates it to the data subject without undue delay, in clear and plain language, with the nature of the breach, a contact point, the likely consequences and the measures taken (Article 34 of the GDPR).
Three situations exempt the controller from doing so: protection measures applied to the affected data that render them unintelligible, such as encryption; subsequent measures that ensure the high risk is no longer likely to materialise; disproportionate effort, in which case a public communication or similar measure replaces it. If the controller has not informed the individuals, the supervisory authority may, after considering the risk, require it to do so.
The threshold differs from that for notification to the CNIL, which covers any risk. Employees are also concerned: the Poitiers Court of Appeal ordered an employer to pay damages, on the basis of its health and safety obligation (Article L. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code, Code du travail), for the online exposure of an employee's geolocation data (CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 26 June 2025, No. 22/01398). The firm drafts the communication with the content required by Article 34, without any unnecessary admission of liability.
Cyber insurance: which time limits must you meet to be compensated?
Two time limits, both running from the discovery of the attack. The first is the criminal complaint deadline, and it is short. Payment of compensation under an insurance clause covering losses and damage caused by an attack on an automated data processing system is conditional on the victim filing a criminal complaint "no later than seventy-two hours after the victim becomes aware of the attack" (our translation) (Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code). The provision covers the offences punished by Articles 323-1 to 323-3-1 of the French Criminal Code, including fraudulent access to or remaining in a system (Article 323-1 of the French Criminal Code).
The rule applies only to legal entities and to individuals acting in the course of their professional activity. The time limit runs from awareness of the attack, not from the attack itself: the date of discovery must therefore be documented from day one. The complaint is filed with the competent authorities, and the public assistance service guides victims; see our article on 17Cyber and filing a complaint after a hack.
The complaint does not replace the notification of the claim to the insurer. The insured notifies the insurer as soon as it becomes aware of the loss and at the latest within the period set by the policy, which cannot be shorter than five working days (Article L. 113-2 of the French Insurance Code). The firm drafts the complaint within the time limit, then the claim notification and the statement of losses. See our article on the complaint within 72 hours and, for the criminal proceedings themselves, our hacking lawyer page.
The insurer refuses to cover the cyberattack: what can you do?
Re-read the policy, cover by cover, then challenge the exclusion relied on. Losses caused by fortuitous events or by the fault of the insured are borne by the insurer, "unless formally and specifically excluded in the policy" (our translation) (Article L. 113-1 of the French Insurance Code). The Court of Cassation holds that such clauses "must be formal and limited" (our translation) and that an exclusion clause "is not formal where it does not refer to precise criteria and requires interpretation" (our translation); it quashed the judgment that had applied an ambiguous clause linked to the closure of an establishment (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-14.482). The rule is not specific to cyber risk: it derives from Article L. 113-1 and applies to every policy.
The damage must still fall within a cover. The Brive-la-Gaillarde judicial court dismissed the claim of a business that had been the victim of a cloned website and diverted vouchers: its costs and losses cover "covers the amount of the processing costs, but does not provide for compensation for lost data" (our translation), and the loss claimed, namely the loss of electronic vouchers and the refund of tickets sold, did not fall within any of the covers taken out (TJ Brive-la-Gaillarde, 2 October 2026, No. 25/00386). The same judgment rejected the alleged breach of the duty to advise: the insured did not show that it had informed its insurer of the existence of intangible assets.
Two further checks apply: the complaint filed within 72 hours (Article L. 12-10-1) and the claim notification, whose lateness leads to the forfeiture provided for in the policy only if the insurer proves a loss (Article L. 113-2). The firm challenges the refusal in writing, then before the court.
Is our IT service provider liable for the cyberattack?
It is if it failed to meet its obligations and that failure made the attack possible. A debtor who fails to perform its obligation is ordered to pay damages, except in the case of force majeure (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code). According to the Reims Court of Appeal, a provider that designs and installs a complex system is bound by an enhanced obligation of means: it must prove "that it exercised all due diligence to achieve the expected result, but also that it committed no fault in performing its obligations" (our translation). Relying on the expert report, which identified the server's default configuration as the vector of the compromise, the court awarded compensation for business interruption, restoration and the ransom, for half of the amounts (CA Reims, 28 April 2026, No. 24/01502).
Everything depends on the contract. The Nanterre commercial and economic activities court dismissed the claims of a company hit by ransomware, as no document described the backups ordered (TAE Nanterre, 22 October 2025, No. 2023F02360). The Paris Court of Appeal held that a provider had fulfilled its obligations under the antivirus contract, after proposing additional protection to which its client never responded; it did, however, find that the provider had failed in its managed IT services engagement and ordered it to reimburse the costs incurred with other providers (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 20 January 2023, No. 20/05569).
The firm therefore starts with the written record: quote, contract, invoices, general terms and conditions, correspondence. It has the technical cause established, if necessary through a court-ordered expert assessment, then quantifies the loss head by head. It also defends the service provider held liable, on the scope of its engagement and its client's fault.
Is a cyberattack a case of force majeure?
Rarely. Force majeure exists where an event beyond the debtor's control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded "and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures" (our translation), prevents the performance of its obligation (Article 1218 of the French Civil Code). The three conditions are cumulative. The Poitiers judicial court ruled out unforeseeability and noted that the debtor had shown no measure taken to prevent the attack.
It was ruling on the case of a training organisation deprived of its platform: "It cannot be disputed that a cyberattack is beyond the control of the debtor of a contractual obligation. It cannot, however, be argued that such an event was unforeseeable at the date of the disputed contract, concluded on 28.9.2023, by the debtor of an obligation that is performed online." (our translation) The service provider was ordered to compensate its client's financial and non-material loss (TJ Poitiers, 28 May 2026, No. 25/02161).
The argument must still be examined according to the attack, the date of the contract and the measures taken: a temporary impediment suspends performance, unless the resulting delay justifies termination of the contract. The firm raises or contests it, depending on which side of the case it is on, and checks whether the contract adjusts force majeure or provides for a limitation clause, within the limit of the essential obligation (Article 1170 of the French Civil Code).
Does an IT security flaw expose the business to sanctions?
Yes, where personal data are involved, and on three fronts: administrative, criminal and civil. The CNIL may impose an administrative fine of up to €10 million or, for an undertaking, 2% of the total worldwide annual turnover of the preceding financial year, whichever is higher, for breaches of Articles 25 to 39 of the GDPR, including security and notification; the amount takes into account in particular the seriousness, negligence, the measures taken and cooperation (Article 83 of the GDPR).
The Council of State reviews these sanctions. It upheld a €250,000 fine against an optical retail chain, the breach of the data of nearly 200,000 customers being the direct consequence of the failure to supervise its processor regularly, and a weak password policy having increased the risk (CE, 10th ch., 26 April 2022, No. 449284). Under criminal law, processing data without the measures prescribed by Article 32 of the GDPR is punishable by five years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine (Article 226-17 of the French Criminal Code), as is failure to notify (Article 226-17-1).
Finally, individuals whose data were exposed may seek compensation for their damage (Article 82 of the GDPR). The firm helps the business document, from the time of the incident, the security measures taken and how they were supervised, which will weigh on the sanction. How a CNIL inspection unfolds and how to challenge a sanction are presented on our GDPR lawyer page; see also our article on a CNIL sanction after a health data breach.
Which cybersecurity obligations already apply while waiting for NIS 2?
Those of the GDPR, for every business that processes personal data, because NIS 2 is not yet applicable under French law. Directive (EU) 2022/2555, known as NIS 2, was published in the Official Journal of the European Union on 27 December 2022 and must be transposed by each Member State. In France, the bill on the resilience of critical infrastructure and the strengthening of cybersecurity, which transposes it, was tabled in the Senate on 15 October 2024, adopted by the Senate on 12 March 2025 and then by the special committee of the National Assembly on 10 September 2025; as at 31 October 2026, it had not been debated in plenary session (National Assembly legislative file). ANSSI, the French national cybersecurity agency, states that NIS 2 will enter into force in France once the act, its decrees and its orders have been published.
The GDPR obligations already apply, whatever the sector: security appropriate to the risk (Article 32 of the GDPR), notification of personal data breaches (Article 33), supervision of processors (Article 28). Failure to implement security measures and failure to notify are also criminal offences (Articles 226-17 and 226-17-1 of the French Criminal Code). Preparing for NIS 2 means first complying with them, and organising cyber risk governance that can absorb the future incident notification obligations.
The scope of NIS 2, the categories of entities and the timetable are detailed on our NIS 2 lawyer page, updated at each parliamentary stage.
Fraudulent transfer after CEO fraud: must the bank reimburse?
It depends on the payment instrument used and on the business's negligence. The user of a payment service takes all reasonable steps to keep its personalised security credentials safe (Article L. 133-16 of the French Monetary and Financial Code), and bears all the losses from an unauthorised transaction if they result from fraudulent conduct on its part or if it failed, intentionally or through gross negligence, to meet its obligations (Article L. 133-19). For a business, the account agreement may derogate from these rules (Article L. 133-2 of the French Monetary and Financial Code): it is the first document to read.
The Court of Cassation points out that, in the case of an unauthorised transaction, "the payment service provider can only escape liability where the user of the payment service fails through gross negligence" (our translation) to meet its obligations. In a case where the bank had executed an international transfer sent by fax, bearing a signature imitating that of the company director, even though fax was no longer the agreed instrument, it held that "the bank, which had agreed to execute a payment transaction by means of such an instrument, could not accuse the company of gross negligence" (our translation) (Cass. com., 8 October 2026, No. 25-17.510).
The firm analyses the account agreement, the agreed channels and the timeline, then claims reimbursement from the bank. The criminal side of the fraud is covered on our CEO fraud page, and phishing on our phishing victim page.
Can you dismiss an employee who was tricked by a fake email?
Not automatically. Any dismissal on personal grounds must be justified by a real and serious cause (Article L. 1232-1 of the French Labour Code), and the mistake of an employee manipulated by a fraudster is assessed in light of the organisation the employer had put in place.
The Paris Court of Appeal held that the dismissal for gross misconduct of an accountant who had executed a transfer requested by a fraudster posing as the company director was without real and serious cause. It noted that "the employer does not show that it had put in place an internal procedure securing the approval of financial flows to protect itself against this type of scam, or that it had provided training to its employees on the risks of cybercrime" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 5, 20 June 2024, No. 21/09789). The employer was ordered to pay the termination indemnities.
Each case remains specific: a deliberate and repeated breach of written instructions is not treated like a mistake made under pressure. The firm advises the employer before any disciplinary sanction and defends the employee concerned. See our article on the employee dismissed after a CEO fraud and, where business activity is halted by the attack, our article on wages during a cyberattack.
After a data breach, must the business compensate its customers and employees?
Only if each of them proves their damage. Any person who has suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement of the GDPR has the right to receive compensation from the controller or processor; the processor is liable only for its own obligations or for acting outside its instructions, and each is exempt from liability if it proves that it is not in any way responsible for the event giving rise to the damage (Article 82 of the GDPR).
The Court of Cassation holds that "a mere infringement of the General Data Protection Regulation does not, in itself, give rise to a right to compensation" (our translation): the court must assess whether the person establishes that the infringement caused them material or non-material damage. It quashed the judgment that had inferred the loss from the breach alone (Cass. soc., 24 June 2026, No. 24-22.792). The damage can nevertheless be non-material and consist of anxiety: the Poitiers Court of Appeal found an "indisputable non-material loss resulting from the fear of misuse of the data by an unauthorised third party and/or the loss of control over that personal data" (our translation), compensated with €3,000 on the basis of the employer's health and safety obligation; it did, however, dismiss the claim based on the GDPR, as there was no loss distinct from the one already compensated (CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 26 June 2025, No. 22/01398).
The firm defends the attacked business that receives claims after a data breach: proof of the security measures taken, attribution of the event causing the damage, challenge to the alleged loss. Claims brought by the individuals themselves are presented on our GDPR lawyer page; see also our article on a customer database scraped during a cyberattack.
How do you preserve evidence of a computer intrusion?
By securing it before any restoration work, then having it formally recorded. Connection logs, ransom messages, security alerts and correspondence with the service provider are kept on an isolated medium, with their dates. The criminal complaint and any future claim depend on them: fraudulently accessing or remaining in a system is punishable by three years' imprisonment and a €100,000 fine, and by five years and €150,000 where data are deleted or modified or the system's operation is impaired (Article 323-1 of the French Criminal Code).
The court may order an expert assessment before any proceedings if there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). The Paris urgent applications judge appointed an expert to describe IT disruptions, their origin and their perpetrators, pointing out that "urgency, the existence of a manifestly excessive disturbance or of imminent danger and the absence of serious dispute are not required" (our translation) for such a measure (TJ Paris, réf., 6 May 2025, No. 25/51066).
The threat can come from inside. The Court of Cassation upheld the conviction of a network administrator who read the manager's emails, as his technical access right did not entitle him to consult the messages for purposes unrelated to his duties (Cass. crim., 2 September 2025, No. 24-83.605). The firm organises the formal record of evidence, the ex parte application or urgent proceedings, then the criminal complaint. See our hacking lawyer page.
What are the fees of a cybersecurity lawyer?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Act of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or the method for determining the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the various costs and expenses envisaged. The law waives this requirement in particular in cases of urgency or force majeure, which may be the case on the first day of a cyberattack: the agreement is then signed as soon as the crisis allows.
The firm favours fixed fees per stage: review of the contracts and the insurance policy, drafting of a security schedule or a data breach procedure, legal management of an incident (notification, complaint, insurance claim), formal notice or response, court-ordered expert assessment, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Technical experts' fees are in addition to the lawyer's fees. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For an initial opinion based on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. If an attack is in progress, the first contact is by phone on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources of this page, verified on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR): definition of a personal data breach (Article 4, point 12), processor (Article 28), security of processing (Article 32), notification to the CNIL (Article 33), communication to data subjects (Article 34), compensation (Article 82), fines (Article 83)
- Article L. 12-10-1 of the French Insurance Code: criminal complaint within 72 hours, a condition for compensation
- Articles L. 113-1 and L. 113-2 of the French Insurance Code: formal and limited exclusion, notification of the claim
- Articles 226-17 and 226-17-1 of the French Criminal Code: failure to ensure security and failure to notify a personal data breach
- Article 323-1 of the French Criminal Code: fraudulent access to and remaining in an automated data processing system
- Articles 1112-1, 1170, 1218, 1231-1 and 1231-3 of the French Civil Code: duty to inform, essential obligation, force majeure, contractual liability, foreseeable damage
- Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: measures of inquiry before any proceedings
- Articles L. 133-2, L. 133-16 and L. 133-19 of the French Monetary and Financial Code: contractual derogation for professionals, security of payment credentials, unauthorised transactions
- Articles L. 1232-1 and L. 4121-1 of the French Labour Code: real and serious cause, employer's health and safety obligation
- Bill on the resilience of critical infrastructure and the strengthening of cybersecurity: transposition of Directive (EU) 2022/2555 (NIS 2), legislative file
- Article 10 of Act No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. com., 8 October 2026, No. 25-17.510: fraudulent transfer order, gross negligence cannot be raised against the company
- Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-14.482: exclusion clause requiring interpretation
- Cass. soc., 24 June 2026, No. 24-22.792: GDPR infringement without proven damage
- Cass. crim., 2 September 2025, No. 24-83.605: network administrator, fraudulently remaining in a system
- CA Reims, 28 April 2026, No. 24/01502: enhanced obligation of means, shared liability, ransom compensated
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 20 January 2023, No. 20/05569: antivirus, additional protection left unanswered; failure in managed IT services compensated
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 5, 20 June 2024, No. 21/09789: employee tricked by CEO fraud, dismissal without cause
- CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 26 June 2025, No. 22/01398: exposed data, non-material loss, health and safety obligation
- TAE Nanterre, 22 October 2025, No. 2023F02360: backup not described in the contract, victim's claims dismissed
- TJ Poitiers, 28 May 2026, No. 25/02161: cyberattack foreseeable for an online service
- TJ Brive-la-Gaillarde, 2 October 2026, No. 25/00386: cyber cover limited to processing costs
- TJ Paris, réf., 6 May 2025, No. 25/51066: IT expert assessment before any proceedings
- CE, 10th ch., 26 April 2022, No. 449284: failure to supervise the processor, fine upheld
- CE, 10th and 9th ch. combined, 22 July 2022, No. 449694: basic security, no notification required if the CNIL discovered the breach
A cyberattack, a data breach, a defaulting service provider?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send us the date the incident was discovered, the technical findings, your service providers' contracts, your insurance policy and the data affected: Hassan Kohen checks the time limits that are running, then advises you on the appropriate course of action: notification, criminal complaint, insurance claim, formal notice, expert assessment, legal action or defence before the court.