They talk about us
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, IT litigation in Paris
IT litigation lawyer in Paris: failed projects, court experts, damages
Software delivered out of line with the contract, an ERP integration that never goes live, refused acceptance testing, failing hosting, a disputed invoice or a terminated maintenance contract: as an IT litigation lawyer in Paris, the firm handles IT disputes (contentieux informatique) from evidence to hearing, for the client company as well as for the service provider, the software publisher or the integrator. Everything starts with the contract, the project correspondence and what an expert will still be able to examine.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The limitation period for obligations between traders is five years (Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code, Code de commerce); it is suspended when the court orders an investigative measure before any proceedings (Article 2239 of the French Civil Code, Code civil). Evidence, however, is lost much sooner: a system that has been modified or uninstalled can no longer be examined by an expert.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome of my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to point his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar: IT litigation, service provider liability and digital contracts.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
An IT service provider must deliver a solution that conforms to the contract and, before signing, find out what its client needs in order to offer a suitable product; the client must express its needs and cooperate in the project. When performance goes off track, the French Civil Code (Code civil) offers several remedies, which can be combined unless they are incompatible: withholding your own performance, seeking specific performance, reducing the price, terminating the contract, claiming damages (Article 1217 of the Civil Code). Termination requires a sufficiently serious non-performance (Article 1224) and leads to restitution (Article 1229). Evidence is unrestricted between traders (Article L. 110-3 of the French Commercial Code); a court-appointed expert assessment can be ordered before any proceedings where there is a legitimate reason (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). A limitation of liability clause is enforceable in principle: it is deemed unwritten if it deprives the essential obligation of its substance (Article 1170), and the courts set it aside in the event of gross negligence (faute lourde), which must be inferred from the seriousness of the debtor's conduct (Cass. com., 29 June 2010, No. 09-11.841). Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts for clients and for service providers alike. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
An IT project going off track, disputed acceptance testing, an invoice refused?
Understanding your situation
IT litigation in Paris, explained
A party whose contract has been poorly performed can choose between several remedies (Article 1217 of the French Civil Code). What to do at the first signs of trouble, what the provider and the client each owe, the remedies and their limits, how the lawsuit and the expert assessment unfold, and how each party defends itself.
Key points
The project goes off track: six steps before any decision
The first few weeks determine the evidence, and therefore often the outcome.
Gather the documents while they still exist: the contract and its schedules, commercial proposals, specifications and their versions, steering committee minutes, tickets, emails, technical logs. Between traders, commercial transactions can be proved by any means (Article L. 110-3 of the French Commercial Code).
Do not sign any acceptance certificate (procès-verbal de recette) without written, precise and dated reservations listing the blocking defects.
Reread the clauses on acceptance, penalties, termination, limitation of liability, prior conciliation and jurisdiction before writing to the other party.
Send a formal notice (mise en demeure) that targets each failure and sets a deadline: specific performance, replacement and price reduction all require a prior formal notice (Articles 1221, 1222 and 1223 of the French Civil Code), and a termination clause requires a formal notice that has gone unheeded and expressly refers to the clause, unless it was agreed that termination would follow from the mere fact of non-performance (Article 1225).
Do not suspend payments by reflex: the defence of non-performance (exception d'inexécution) requires a sufficiently serious non-performance by the other party (Article 1219); otherwise, the suspension itself becomes the main complaint against you.
Freeze the state of the system before any migration or uninstallation, through a report by a judicial officer (commissaire de justice) or an expert assessment, and keep a complete copy of the data and access rights.
An acceptance certificate is not an automatic bar to a claim. In an ERP integration dispute, the Paris Court of Appeal ruled as follows: “Because of the reservations it contains, this certificate, despite its title, cannot however be regarded as a final acceptance of the IT solution” (our translation). Such a document records a factual situation “only until proven otherwise, which may be done by any means” (our translation). The burden of proof was thus reversed: “It is therefore for Prodware to show that it remedied all the defects identified” (our translation). The integrator was ordered to pay €121,761.57 to the client, and its claim for payment of invoices was dismissed (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 March 2024, No. 21/16505).
The same decision shows the value of a judicial officer's report: the judicial officer had noted that the solution was still in the client's system, and nothing suggested that the client had modified it. Without written reservations and without a record of the state of the system, each party is left with its own assertions, whereas each party must prove the facts needed for its claim to succeed (Article 9 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
Obligations
The provider's duty to advise, the client's cooperation, the solution's conformity
Most disputes turn on these three obligations, and on how they are proved.
Inform: a party who knows information of decisive importance for the other party's consent must disclose it, if the other party is legitimately unaware of it or relies on its contracting partner; the parties can neither limit nor exclude this duty (Article 1112-1 of the French Civil Code).
Advise: the provider finds out about the client's needs before proposing a solution, and warns the client when the standard solution will not meet its expectations. Contracts also bind the parties to all the consequences that fairness, custom or the law attach to them (Article 1194).
Cooperate: the client expresses its needs, appoints available contacts, provides the data and takes part in analyses and tests. Contracts must be performed in good faith (Article 1104).
Deliver in conformity: the solution must work according to the agreed specifications, within the agreed timeframe. Bespoke development or customisation may fall under a contract for work and services (louage d'ouvrage), whereby one party undertakes to do something for the other in return for a price (Articles 1710 and 1787), rather than a contract of sale.
The duty to advise falls first on the professional. According to the Lyon Court of Appeal, “an IT service provider owes a duty to inform and advise a client who has no expertise whatsoever in the field” (our translation); “It must first find out about its client's needs in order to offer it a product suited to them” (our translation). The software publisher could not rely on a risk accepted by the client, because “it was for the publisher to check that its product matched the client's needs before the contract was signed, and not once the software package had been installed” (our translation). The resulting error as to the essential qualities of the service (Article 1132) led to the contract being annulled, which “entails mutual restitution” (our translation) (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 28 May 2025, No. 21/08394).
A non-specialist client is not, however, fully protected. In an ERP project without a specification document, the Paris Court of Appeal examined “whether the IT service provider had properly assisted its non-specialist client in defining its needs so as to meet them appropriately” (our translation). It found that the client had “deliberately chosen, in order to meet its deadline of 1 October 2018, to ignore the repeated advice” (our translation) of the integrator, and terminated the contract on the client's sole fault, ordering it to pay €66,626.44 incl. VAT to the provider (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604). The provider's written warnings, in minutes and emails, decided the outcome.
The client's own expertise also matters: a company specialising in digital data was held to be “informed enough to understand and assess the purpose and scope of the contract” (our translation), which defeated the complaint of failure to advise (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675). Conversely, the Lyon Court of Appeal found the software publisher and integrator in default “even though the cooperation of Seripanneaux is established” (our translation) by its tender file and its correspondence (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 30 January 2025, No. 21/00620). Drafting the contract upstream is covered on our page IT contracts lawyer.
Remedies
Withhold, enforce, reduce, terminate, obtain compensation
The choice depends on the goal: obtaining the system, getting out of it, or being compensated.
Defence of non-performance
A party may refuse to perform its obligation, even if it is due, if the other party fails to perform its own and that non-performance is sufficiently serious (Article 1219 of the French Civil Code). It may also suspend performance in advance where it is clear that the other party will not perform when due and the consequences of that non-performance are sufficiently serious for it, provided that it gives notice as soon as possible (Article 1220).
Performance or replacement
After a formal notice, the creditor may seek specific performance, unless performance is impossible or there is a manifest disproportion between its cost to a debtor acting in good faith and its value to the creditor (Article 1221). It may also, within a reasonable time and at a reasonable cost, have the obligation performed itself and claim reimbursement from the debtor, or ask the court to order the debtor to advance the necessary sums (Article 1222).
Price reduction
In the event of imperfect performance, a creditor who has not yet paid all or part of the service may, after a formal notice, give notice of its decision to reduce the price proportionately; if it has already paid, it asks the court to do so failing agreement (Article 1223).
Termination
Termination results from a termination clause or, in the event of sufficiently serious non-performance, from a notice served by the creditor or from a court decision (Article 1224). Termination by notice is at the creditor's own risk, after a formal notice that has gone unheeded (save in an emergency), and the creditor must prove the seriousness of the non-performance if the debtor disputes it (Article 1226).
Restitution
Where the services exchanged could only be of use through full performance of the contract, the parties return everything they have obtained from each other; where they were of use as reciprocal performance went along, there is no restitution for the period before the last service that did not receive its counterpart, and the termination is treated as a termination for the future (résiliation) (Article 1229). Restitution of a service takes place by value (Article 1352-8).
Damages
The debtor compensates for non-performance or delay, save in cases of force majeure (Article 1231-1), to the extent of the loss suffered and the gain forgone (Article 1231-2), but only for the damage that was foreseen or foreseeable when the contract was made, unless there was gross negligence or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3).
Termination with full restitution is possible where the solution has been of no use. The Paris Court of Appeal upheld termination for the fault of an integrator which “therefore failed to fulfil its obligation of result to deliver conforming software” (our translation), noting that “the installation of a new tool is currently of no use to Acta, which would have been better off keeping its old software” (our translation); even without an identified cause, the malfunctions, by “their mere existence, not attributable to Acta, and insofar as they are sufficiently serious, justify the termination of the contract” (our translation). The client recovered €109,995.94 incl. VAT and returned the software (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 3 June 2022, No. 20/09351). For a contract signed in 2012, governed by the law in force before the 2016 reform, the Lyon Court of Appeal ordered termination under former Article 1184 and the repayment of €227,914.91 for services (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 30 January 2025, No. 21/00620).
Unilateral termination remains a gamble. Under the law in force before 2016, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) put it this way: “The seriousness of the conduct of a party to a contract not governed by the provisions of the Order of 10 February 2016 may justify the other party terminating it unilaterally at its own risk” (our translation). It adds: “In the event of a dispute, it is for the party that terminated the contract to prove such conduct” (our translation) (Cass. com., 22 November 2023, No. 22-16.514). For contracts concluded since then, Article 1226 lays down the same requirement. A client that terminated too early may be held responsible for the breakdown, as in the ERP case decided by the Paris Court of Appeal in 2024 (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604).
A limitation of liability clause usually holds. Any clause that deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten (Article 1170). Before the 2016 reform, the Court of Cassation already held that “only a clause limiting compensation that contradicts the scope of the essential obligation undertaken by the debtor is deemed unwritten” (our translation), and that “gross negligence cannot result from the mere breach of a contractual obligation, even an essential one, but must be inferred from the seriousness of the debtor's conduct” (our translation). In that software package case, the client lost: the negotiated compensation was not derisory (Cass. com., 29 June 2010, No. 09-11.841). For a hosting provider, the Versailles Court of Appeal applied the cap of three months' invoicing, which “does not contradict its essential obligation” (our translation) (CA Versailles, 12e ch., 19 May 2022, No. 20/05106). See our article on the validity of limitation of liability clauses.
The lawsuit
Urgent applications, court-appointed experts, time limits and jurisdiction
In IT disputes, the expert assessment usually shapes the court's decision.
Expert assessment before proceedings
If there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish, before any proceedings, evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend, legally admissible investigative measures may be ordered on an ex parte application (requête) or in summary proceedings (référé). The court with territorial jurisdiction is, at the applicant's choice, the court that may hear the case on the merits or, where appropriate, the court in whose district the measure is to be carried out (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
Urgent application
The president of the commercial court or of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) may, even where there is a serious dispute, order the protective or restorative measures needed to prevent imminent damage or to stop a manifestly unlawful disturbance, and award an interim payment where the obligation is not seriously disputable (Articles 873 and 835).
How it unfolds
The court appoints a technical expert on a question of fact (Article 232); an expert assessment is ordered only where findings or a consultation would not suffice (Article 263). The expert takes into account the parties' observations, known as dires, and states what action was taken on them (Article 276).
Limitation period
Five years for obligations arising between traders or between traders and non-traders (Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code), five years for personal actions from the date the facts became known (Article 2224 of the French Civil Code), two years from discovery of the defect for the warranty against hidden defects specific to sales (Article 1648).
Suspension and interruption
The limitation period is suspended when the court grants an application for an investigative measure made before any proceedings, and starts running again for at least six months after the measure has been carried out (Article 2239). A claim brought before a court, even in summary proceedings, interrupts the limitation period (Article 2241).
Jurisdiction
Commercial courts (tribunaux de commerce) hear disputes between traders and disputes relating to commercial companies, unless there is an arbitration clause (Article L. 721-3 of the French Commercial Code). In Paris, Nanterre and Versailles, these commercial courts have been designated economic activities courts (tribunaux des activités économiques), on an experimental basis for four years from 1 January 2025 (Order of 5 July 2024, Articles 1 and 2, issued under Article 26 of Law No. 2023-1059 of 20 November 2023). Copyright actions, including those concerning software, fall within the jurisdiction of designated judicial courts (Article L. 331-1 of the French Intellectual Property Code).
A legitimate reason is shown by facts. The urgent applications judge of the Paris judicial court put it as follows: “While the dispute on the merits may be merely potential, the measure sought must nevertheless rest on precise, objective and verifiable facts that make this future dispute plausible and credible” (our translation); on the other hand, “urgency, the existence of a manifestly excessive disturbance or of imminent danger and the absence of serious dispute are not required for an expert assessment to be ordered under Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure” (our translation). The judge ordered an expert assessment of the IT problems suffered by a company, with terms of reference that the judge set personally, since “the urgent applications judge may freely choose the terms of reference given to the expert and is not bound by the parties' proposals” (our translation) (TJ Paris, réf., 6 May 2025, No. 25/51066).
An expert assessment suspends the limitation period for the action on the merits that pursues the same aim. In a dispute over delivered equipment, the Court of Cassation laid down the following rule: “Although, in principle, neither the suspension nor the interruption of the limitation period can extend from one action to another, it is otherwise where both actions pursue the same aim, so that the second is virtually included in the first” (our translation); the request for an expert assessment of the causes of the incidents thus pursued “the same aim as the action for breach of the obligation to deliver in conformity” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 2 March 2023, No. 21-18.771).
The expert assessment must remain adversarial. The court must ensure in all circumstances that the adversarial principle is respected (Article 16 of the French Code of Civil Procedure), and the nullity of acts relating to investigative measures follows the rules on the nullity of procedural acts (Article 175). The Paris Court of Appeal annulled an IT expert report because the expert had not examined the source code provided by the service provider: “this necessarily results in prejudice and a breach of the adversarial principle justifying the annulment of the expert report” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675). The firm drafts the written observations to the expert, works with your technical team and makes sure the terms of reference cover conformity, delays, attribution of fault and the cost of remedial work. See our article on how to obtain a court-appointed expert assessment.
Both sides
You are the client, or you are the service provider
The same documents serve both sides; everything depends on what they show.
You are the client
- Prove the defects, their seriousness and who is responsible for them: acceptance reservations, tickets, judicial officer's report, expert assessment.
- Establish the failure to advise: needs expressed, a standard answer offered without reservation, no warning given.
- Choose the useful remedy: completion by a third party, price reduction, termination and restitution, quantified damages.
You are the service provider
- Produce your warnings, meeting minutes and proposals for further analysis, as well as the client's change requests.
- Raise the client's lack of cooperation, scope changes made without an amendment, the acceptance that was signed off and the use made of the solution.
- Recover unpaid invoices, with late payment penalties and the fixed compensation for recovery costs.
On the provider's side, the invoice is also protected by statute: late payment penalties are due on the day after the payment date shown on the invoice, without any reminder being needed, at a rate that cannot be lower than three times the statutory interest rate, and any business that pays late automatically owes a fixed compensation for recovery costs set by decree (Article L. 441-10 of the French Commercial Code). The termination of a maintenance contract or of an ongoing relationship may also be challenged under Article L. 442-1, II, of the French Commercial Code: abruptly terminating, even partially, an established commercial relationship without sufficient written notice makes the party responsible liable, and a notice period of eighteen months rules out any complaint that the notice was too short. These disputes are heard by courts designated by decree (Article L. 442-4, III).
The burden of proving a partial termination lies with the party alleging it. An IT service provider that blamed its client, after a sixteen-year relationship, for ceasing to order development work while keeping the maintenance contract, lost its case: “It is therefore for it to establish that the halt in these orders entailed a substantial change in the terms of the commercial relationship imposed by Protexsur” (our translation), and its tables “are not based on any probative evidence, mere invoices being insufficient to make up for the lack of accounting records” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 13 September 2024, No. 22/04675). Since 20 August 2026, the provision has also stated that a substantial reduction in order volumes, even a temporary one, in the context of negotiating a contract, may make the party responsible liable if, by its scale, its unusual nature or the circumstances in which it occurs, it is likely to undermine the balance of the established commercial relationship. See our article on sufficient notice when ending an established commercial relationship.
The arguments the firm examines in every case:
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen detailed answers, based on the legislation in force and on verified court decisions.
What does an IT litigation lawyer do in France?
The lawyer turns a technical project into a body of evidence, then chooses the procedure. IT disputes most often arise from an integration, licence, development, hosting or maintenance contract that has been poorly performed: delay, non-conforming solution, blocking defects, failure to meet needs, disputed invoice. A party whose contract has been poorly performed has several remedies, which can be combined unless they are incompatible, and to which damages can always be added (Article 1217 of the French Civil Code).
The work starts with a timeline of the project, built from the documents: contract and schedules, specifications, committee minutes, tickets, acceptance certificates, emails. Between traders, all of these are admissible, since evidence is unrestricted (Article L. 110-3 of the French Commercial Code). Next comes the legal characterisation of the failures, such as breach of the duty to advise, lack of cooperation or non-conformity, followed by the quantification of the loss.
The procedure is chosen next: formal notice and negotiation, a court-appointed expert assessment before proceedings where there is a legitimate reason for it (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure), an action on the merits, a settlement. The firm acts for client companies as well as for software publishers, integrators and IT services companies, and coordinates its work with your technical team or a private expert. For digital law as a whole, see our page digital law lawyer.
The software does not work: can we stop paying?
Only if the provider's failure is sufficiently serious. A party may refuse to perform its obligation, even though it is due, if the other party fails to perform its own and that non-performance is sufficiently serious (Article 1219 of the French Civil Code). It may also suspend its performance in advance where it is clear that the other party will not perform when due and the consequences are sufficiently serious for it, provided that it gives notice as soon as possible (Article 1220).
The risk is real. A client that suspends roll-out and payments without giving the provider time to fix the problems may be held responsible for the breakdown. The Paris Court of Appeal thus found, regarding a client that had halted an ERP project, that “AD does not demonstrate the existence of a serious breach by LSE of its obligations justifying the termination of the contract” (our translation), and ordered the client to pay the provider (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604).
The prudent course is to send a formal notice listing the defects, document why they are blocking, and then decide. A price reduction is another option: in the event of imperfect performance, a client that has not yet paid all or part of the service may, after a formal notice, give notice of its decision to reduce the price proportionately (Article 1223). The firm assesses the seriousness of the defects with you before any suspension.
Did the IT provider breach its duty to advise?
It all depends on what the provider knew about your needs and what it told you. The pre-contractual duty to inform is laid down by statute: a party who knows information that is decisive for the other party's consent must disclose it; the party claiming that information was owed to it must prove this, and the other party must then prove that it provided it; and the parties can neither limit nor exclude this duty (Article 1112-1 of the French Civil Code).
In IT matters, the courts derive from this a duty to advise tailored to the client. The Lyon Court of Appeal holds that “an IT service provider owes a duty to inform and advise a client who has no expertise whatsoever in the field” (our translation) and that “It must first find out about its client's needs in order to offer it a product suited to them” (our translation); it upheld the annulment of the software package contract for error as to the essential qualities of the service (Article 1132), with restitution (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 28 May 2025, No. 21/08394).
The duty to advise has its limits. It is assessed in light of the client's own expertise: a specialist company was held to be “informed enough to understand and assess the purpose and scope of the contract” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675). It also falls away where the client ignored repeated written warnings (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604). The firm reconstructs what was said, written and proposed before signature, and then during the project.
We signed the acceptance certificate: can we still take action?
Yes, in many cases, and especially if the certificate contains reservations. A party claiming performance of an obligation must prove it, and a party claiming to be released must prove the fact that extinguished its obligation (Article 1353 of the French Civil Code). Acceptance is a fact that can be disputed, not an automatic waiver.
The Paris Court of Appeal so held in an ERP integration dispute: “Because of the reservations it contains, this certificate, despite its title, cannot however be regarded as a final acceptance of the IT solution” (our translation). It added that such a document records a factual situation “only until proven otherwise, which may be done by any means” (our translation), so that it was for the integrator to show that it had remedied the defects. The integrator was ordered to compensate the client (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 March 2024, No. 21/16505).
Acceptance signed without reservation, followed by lengthy use of the solution, makes the case harder to prove: the provider will treat it as acceptance. You then need to establish defects that were not apparent during testing, through a judicial officer's report or an expert assessment, and check what the contract attaches to acceptance. The firm analyses the certificate, the acceptance procedure provided for in the contract and the defects that arose afterwards.
How do you obtain a court-appointed IT expert assessment in France?
By asking the court for one, before any proceedings, under Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: if there is a legitimate reason to preserve or establish evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend, legally admissible investigative measures may be ordered at the request of any interested party, on an ex parte application or in summary proceedings. Since the version in force on 1 September 2025, the court with territorial jurisdiction is, at the applicant's choice, the court that may hear the case on the merits or, where appropriate, the court in whose district the measure is to be carried out.
The legitimate reason must be proved. The Paris urgent applications judge requires the measure to rest “on precise, objective and verifiable facts that make this future dispute plausible and credible” (our translation), without requiring urgency or the absence of a serious dispute (TJ Paris, réf., 6 May 2025, No. 25/51066). An expert assessment is ordered only where findings or a consultation would not suffice (Article 263), and, in the Paris case, the advance on the expert's fees was charged to the company that had requested the measure.
The terms of reference are negotiated at the hearing: description of the defects, conformity with the specifications, causes of the delays, attribution of fault, cost of remedial work, elements for assessing the loss. During the expert's work, the expert must take into account the parties' written observations, known as dires (Article 276), and the adversarial principle applies (Article 16). A report drawn up in breach of this principle may be annulled (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675). See our article on court-appointed expert assessments.
Can we terminate the IT contract and recover the sums paid?
Yes, if the non-performance is sufficiently serious. Termination results from a termination clause, a notice served by the creditor or a court decision (Article 1224 of the French Civil Code), and it can always be sought in court (Article 1227). The court may also order performance while granting additional time, or award damages only (Article 1228).
Restitution depends on whether the services were of any use. Where the services exchanged could only be of use through full performance of the contract, the parties return everything they have obtained from each other; where they were of use as performance went along, there is no restitution for the period before the last service that did not receive its counterpart, and the termination is treated as a termination for the future (Article 1229). The Paris Court of Appeal ordered the return of €109,995.94 incl. VAT, noting that “the installation of a new tool is currently of no use to Acta, which would have been better off keeping its old software” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 3 June 2022, No. 20/09351). For a contract signed in 2012, governed by the law in force before the reform, the Lyon Court of Appeal held that termination, under former Article 1184, wiped out the contract, and ordered the repayment of €227,914.91 for services (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 30 January 2025, No. 21/00620).
If the hardware or the solution is financed through a finance lease, the end of the services contract may bring the lease down with it. According to the Court of Cassation, “Since concurrent or successive contracts forming part of a transaction that includes a finance lease are interdependent” (our translation), the disappearance of one makes the others lapse if the other contracting party knew of the overall transaction, and “clauses irreconcilable with this interdependence are deemed unwritten” (our translation) (Cass. com., 10 January 2024, No. 22-20.466). The reference provision is Article 1186 of the French Civil Code.
Can we have the project completed by another IT provider?
Yes, under specific conditions. After a formal notice, the creditor may, within a reasonable time and at a reasonable cost, have the obligation performed itself, then claim reimbursement of the sums spent for that purpose from the debtor; it may also ask the court to order the debtor to advance the sums needed for that performance (Article 1222 of the French Civil Code). Specific performance remains possible, unless it is impossible or there is a manifest disproportion between its cost to a debtor acting in good faith and its value to the creditor (Article 1221).
Replacement carries an evidential risk. Once the system has been taken over, migrated or uninstalled, the expert has nothing left to examine, and the defaulting provider will argue that the problems came from the takeover. Before any migration, you therefore need to have the state of the system formally recorded, keep a complete copy of the data and of the versions delivered and, where the stakes justify it, obtain an expert assessment before proceedings (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
The cost of the takeover must also remain linked to the failure. The Court of Cassation overturned an award that included advisory and replacement costs “without establishing how the services performed by Sinparde were the direct and immediate consequence of the contractual non-performance attributed to Cegid” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 March 2023, No. 21-21.432). The firm prepares the formal notice, the judicial officer's report and the quantification before the switch to the new provider.
What losses can we claim, including our staff's time?
Damages cover the loss suffered and the gain forgone (Article 1231-2 of the French Civil Code), limited to the damage that was foreseen or foreseeable when the contract was concluded, unless there was gross negligence or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3). The usual heads of loss are the sums paid for an unusable solution, the extra cost of remedial work, keeping the old system running, contractual penalties, operating losses and the time of staff assigned to the project.
Internal staff time is open to debate. The Court of Cassation holds that “the court cannot refuse to compensate a loss whose existence it acknowledges in principle on the ground that the evidence provided by the parties is insufficient” (our translation), and that it was for the court of appeal to assess the cost of the staff assigned to the ERP project to no avail, “if necessary by ordering a further investigative measure” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 March 2023, No. 21-21.432, judgment delivered by a restricted panel (formation restreinte)). Conversely, the Lyon Court of Appeal refused this head of loss, holding that “the involvement of its staff in this project falls within the normal demands placed on these employees in their usual roles” (our translation) (CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 30 January 2025, No. 21/00620).
The difference lies in the evidence: timesheets, assignments, dedicated recruits or temporary staff, time spent fixing rather than operating. If the contract contains a penalty clause, the court may reduce or increase it if it is manifestly excessive or derisory (Article 1231-5). The firm builds the quantification head by head, each linked to a specific failure.
Does the IT provider's limitation of liability clause apply?
In principle, yes. It is set aside mainly in two cases. First, where it deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance: it is then deemed unwritten (Article 1170 of the French Civil Code). Second, in the event of gross negligence, which the courts accept only if it can be inferred from the seriousness of the debtor's conduct; gross negligence or wilful misconduct also removes the statutory limit to foreseeable damage (Article 1231-3).
These exceptions are applied strictly. In the case of a software package that was never delivered, decided in 2010 under the law in force before the 2016 reform, the Court of Cassation held that “only a clause limiting compensation that contradicts the scope of the essential obligation undertaken by the debtor is deemed unwritten” (our translation), and approved the application of a clause whose negotiated compensation was not derisory. It added that “gross negligence cannot result from the mere breach of a contractual obligation, even an essential one, but must be inferred from the seriousness of the debtor's conduct” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 June 2010, No. 09-11.841). The client lost on this point.
The clause must also be enforceable against the client: general terms and conditions take effect against the other party only if they were brought to its attention and it accepted them (Article 1119). For a hosting provider whose client had signed only the special terms, the Versailles Court of Appeal held that the express reference to the general terms “in the contract it signed, combined with the fact that Apogea was aware of them, is sufficient to establish tacit acceptance of these terms” (our translation), and then applied the cap (CA Versailles, 12e ch., 19 May 2022, No. 20/05106). Between businesses, subjecting or attempting to subject the other party to obligations that create a significant imbalance also makes the party responsible liable (Article L. 442-1, I, 2° of the French Commercial Code).
The useful argument therefore concerns the amount of the cap in relation to what is at stake, and the seriousness of the provider's conduct.
What is the time limit for suing an IT service provider in France?
Five years, in most cases. Obligations arising in the course of business between traders or between traders and non-traders are time-barred after five years, unless a shorter special limitation period applies (Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code). Personal actions are time-barred after five years from the day on which the right-holder knew or should have known the facts enabling it to bring the action (Article 2224 of the French Civil Code).
The legal characterisation of the contract may shorten this period. If the contract is treated as a sale and the action is based on the warranty against hidden defects (Article 1641), it must be brought within two years of discovery of the defect (Article 1648). Bespoke development, on the other hand, may fall under a contract for work and services (Article 1710): the Paris Court of Appeal thus upheld the characterisation as a contract for services (contrat d'entreprise) for a package combining a licence and customisation services (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675). The choice of legal basis is therefore made at the outset of the case.
Two mechanisms protect the claimant. A claim brought before a court, even in summary proceedings, interrupts the limitation period (Article 2241). And when the court orders an investigative measure before any proceedings, the limitation period is suspended, then starts running again for at least six months from the date the measure was carried out (Article 2239). This suspension benefits the action on the merits that pursues the same aim as the expert assessment: the Court of Cassation so held for an expert assessment that pursued “the same aim as the action for breach of the obligation to deliver in conformity” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 2 March 2023, No. 21-18.771). The firm calculates the applicable time limit at the very first review.
Which court has jurisdiction over an IT dispute in France?
Between commercial companies, the commercial courts: commercial courts hear disputes relating to commitments between traders, to commercial companies and to commercial transactions between any persons, and the parties may agree, when they enter into the contract, to submit these disputes to arbitration (Article L. 721-3 of the French Commercial Code). In Paris, Nanterre and Versailles, these commercial courts have been designated, since 1 January 2025 and on an experimental basis for four years, as economic activities courts (Order of 5 July 2024, Articles 1 and 2, issued under Article 26 of Law No. 2023-1059 of 20 November 2023). The contract often contains a jurisdiction clause or a prior conciliation clause, which must be read before issuing proceedings.
Certain matters have their own courts. Software is a work protected by copyright (Article L. 112-2 of the French Intellectual Property Code), and civil actions relating to literary and artistic property fall exclusively within the jurisdiction of judicial courts designated by regulation (Article L. 331-1). Reproducing or modifying software without authorisation falls within the author's exploitation right (Article L. 122-6) and may constitute the offence of infringement (contrefaçon) (Article L. 335-3); a descriptive seizure may take the form of a copy of the allegedly infringing software (Article L. 332-4). Disputes over the abrupt termination of an established relationship are assigned to courts designated by decree (Article L. 442-4, III, of the French Commercial Code).
In summary proceedings, the president of the commercial court or of the judicial court may order urgent measures or award an interim payment where the obligation is not seriously disputable (Articles 872, 873, 834 and 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). For criminal software infringement, see our page on counterfeiting and infringement.
We are the IT provider: the client refuses to pay, what should we do?
Claim payment while preparing your answer to the non-conformity the client will raise. An unpaid invoice has statutory effects: late payment penalties are due on the day after the payment date shown on the invoice, without any reminder being needed, at a rate that cannot be lower than three times the statutory interest rate, and a business that pays late automatically owes a fixed compensation for recovery costs (Article L. 441-10 of the French Commercial Code). Where the obligation is not seriously disputable, the urgent applications judge may award an interim payment (Article 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
The defence rests on the project documents: validated specifications, change requests, warnings sent, analysis days offered and refused, acceptance signed off, use of the solution. In the case decided by the Paris Court of Appeal in 2024, these documents established that the client had chosen to ignore the integrator's warnings, and it was the client that was ordered to pay the provider €66,626.44 incl. VAT (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604). Against a knowledgeable client, the complaint of failure to advise is easier to defeat (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675).
If the client ends a long-standing relationship, the provider may rely on the abrupt termination of an established commercial relationship (Article L. 442-1, II, of the French Commercial Code), but it must prove this with accounting evidence: one provider lost because it failed to show the share of development work in its turnover, “mere invoices being insufficient to make up for the lack of accounting records” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 13 September 2024, No. 22/04675). For a SaaS publisher, see our article on the client who stops paying its subscription.
What are the fees of an IT litigation lawyer in Paris?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies the amount of the fees, or how they are determined, for the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements.
The firm favours a fixed fee for each stage: case analysis and project timeline, formal notice or reply, application for an expert assessment in summary proceedings, follow-up of the expert's work and drafting of written observations, proceedings on the merits, appeal, negotiation of a settlement agreement. Court expert fees and, where applicable, a private expert's fees are added to the lawyer's fees. The fixed fee for each stage is set after reviewing the documents, according to the complexity of the case and the foreseeable work. Any new assignment is covered by an amendment, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, via the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 1104, 1112-1, 1119, 1132 and 1194 of the French Civil Code: good faith, duty to inform, general terms and conditions, error, consequences of the contract
- Articles 1170, 1231-3 and 1231-5 of the French Civil Code: essential obligation, foreseeable damage and gross negligence, penalty clause
- Articles 1217, 1219, 1220, 1221, 1222 and 1223 of the French Civil Code: remedies for non-performance, defence of non-performance, specific performance, replacement, price reduction
- Articles 1224, 1225, 1226, 1227, 1228 and 1229 of the French Civil Code: termination, termination clause, notice, powers of the court, effects
- Articles 1352, 1352-8 and 1186 of the French Civil Code: restitution, lapse of interdependent contracts
- Articles 1231-1, 1231-2, 1344 and 1353 of the French Civil Code: damages, formal notice, evidence
- Articles 1603, 1604, 1641, 1648, 1710 and 1787 of the French Civil Code: sale and hidden defects, contract for work and services
- Articles 2224, 2239, 2241, 2044 and 2052 of the French Civil Code: limitation period, suspension and interruption, settlement
- Articles 9, 16, 145, 175, 232, 263 and 276 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: evidence, adversarial principle, investigative measures and expert assessment
- Articles 834, 835, 872 and 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: summary proceedings before the judicial court and the commercial court
- Articles L. 110-3, L. 110-4 and L. 721-3 of the French Commercial Code: evidence, limitation period, commercial jurisdiction
- Articles L. 441-10, L. 442-1 and L. 442-4 of the French Commercial Code: late payment penalties, abrupt termination, specialised courts
- Articles L. 112-2, L. 122-6, L. 331-1, L. 332-4 and L. 335-3 of the French Intellectual Property Code: software, author's rights, courts, infringement seizure, offence
- Article 1 and Article 2 of the Order of 5 July 2024: experimental economic activities court
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. com., 29 June 2010, No. 09-11.841: limitation clause and gross negligence
- Cass. com., 29 March 2023, No. 21-21.432: wasted staff time, causation
- Cass. com., 22 November 2023, No. 22-16.514: unilateral termination at one's own risk
- Cass. com., 10 January 2024, No. 22-20.466: finance lease and interdependent contracts
- Cass. 2e civ., 2 March 2023, No. 21-18.771: expert assessment and suspension of the limitation period
- CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 28 May 2025, No. 21/08394: duty to advise, annulment of a software package contract
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 November 2024, No. 21/08604: warnings ignored by the client, termination at its fault
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 22 March 2024, No. 21/16505: acceptance with reservations, burden of proof
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 3 June 2022, No. 20/09351: termination and full restitution
- CA Lyon, 3e ch. A, 30 January 2025, No. 21/00620: cooperation established, termination, internal time refused
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 2 May 2025, No. 22/19675: knowledgeable client, annulment of the expert report
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 13 September 2024, No. 22/04675: partial termination not proved by the provider
- CA Versailles, 12e ch., 19 May 2022, No. 20/05106: liability cap of a hosting provider
- TJ Paris, réf., 6 May 2025, No. 25/51066: IT expert assessment ordered in summary proceedings
Further reading
A failed IT project, disputed acceptance testing, an invoice refused?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the contract and its schedules, the specifications, the meeting minutes, the acceptance certificates, the correspondence exchanged and the invoices: Hassan Kohen, avocat at the Paris Bar, reviews the failures, the evidence and the time limits, then tells you which route suits your case: formal notice, expert assessment in summary proceedings, termination, action for payment or defence before the competent court.