Kohen Avocats — Real estate law
Social housing lawyer in Paris, France: defending HLM tenants
Eviction for rent arrears, transfer of the lease after a death, alleged subletting, substandard housing: the firm defends tenants of social housing landlords in France, in Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France).
Received a writ of summons or a formal demand to pay? Send it to us with the hearing date: the defence is prepared without delay, and some extensions of time can still be requested after the judgment.
Social housing · Paris
Prepare your defence
Send the lease, the writ of summons or the landlord's letters to our real estate law firm in Paris for a first analysis.
HLM
eviction, death,
subletting
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
Your social housing dispute
Social housing · Paris 16th
Defending the tenant against the social housing landlord
- Paris Bar
- Real estate law
- Paris and the Paris region
- HLM tenants and families
A social housing lease is governed by the Law of 6 July 1989 and by rules specific to HLM bodies (organismes d'HLM), set out in the French Construction and Housing Code (code de la construction et de l'habitation). These rules change the answer to several common questions: who takes over the lease when the tenant dies, what a tenant who houses someone or sublets is exposed to, and how an eviction for arrears unfolds. Lease disputes fall within the jurisdiction of the litigation protection judge (juge des contentieux de la protection) of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire); after the order to vacate the premises (commandement de quitter les lieux), requests for time to leave are brought before the enforcement judge (juge de l'exécution).
The firm assists tenants, members of their family and occupants in their disputes with social housing landlords in Paris and the Paris region. The review starts with the lease, the landlord's letters, and the writ of summons or judgment received. Call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45 or send these documents through the form for a first written analysis.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Avoiding eviction
Checking the landlord's procedure, requesting time to pay and the suspension of the termination clause (clause résolutoire).
Keeping a relative's home
Examining the conditions for transferring the lease on the tenant's death and challenging a refusal.
Defending against an allegation
Subletting, failure to occupy, disturbances: challenging the evidence produced by the landlord.
Rent arrears and eviction
Eviction for arrears is not automatic
A social housing landlord, as a legal entity, may only serve a writ of summons once two months have passed since the referral to the committee for coordinating action to prevent rental evictions (CCAPEX), failing which the claim is inadmissible; this referral is deemed to have been made where arrears already reported to the bodies paying housing benefit persist (Article 24, II of the Law of 6 July 1989). The writ of summons is notified to the prefect at least six weeks before the hearing.
6 weeks
in principle, after the formal demand to pay
3 years
at most of time to pay
2 months
after the order to vacate the premises
Formal demand to pay
The termination clause only takes effect six weeks after a formal demand to pay that has gone unanswered. The demand must state, among other things, this time limit, the monthly rent, the statement of the debt and the possibility of applying to the housing solidarity fund (fonds de solidarité pour le logement) (Article 24, I of the Law of 6 July 1989). Some older leases remain subject to the contractual two-month period (Cass., avis, 13 June 2024, No. 24-70.002): the date of the lease must be checked.
Referral to the CCAPEX
For a landlord that is a legal entity, the writ of summons may only be served two months after the referral to the committee, including where that referral is deemed made through a report to the bodies paying housing benefit.
Writ of summons and assessment
The writ of summons is notified to the prefect six weeks before the hearing. A social and financial assessment (diagnostic social et financier) is sent to the judge.
Hearing
The judge may grant time to pay of up to three years if the tenant is able to pay off the debt and has resumed paying the full current rent before the hearing (Article 24, V of the Law of 6 July 1989).
After the judgment
In principle, eviction from inhabited premises may only take place once two months have passed after the order to vacate the premises; the judge may reduce or remove this period in the cases provided for, and it does not apply where bad faith is established (Article L. 412-1 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures (CPCE)). Subject to the statutory exclusions, the judge may grant periods of one month to one year (Article L. 412-4 of the CPCE).
Winter truce
Any eviction not yet carried out is stayed from 1 November to 31 March, unless rehousing is ensured in adequate conditions, or where the occupants entered another person's home without right or title through deception, threats, assault or coercion; the judge may also reduce or remove this stay in other cases of entry by such means (Article L. 412-6 of the CPCE).
Suspension
Treating the clause as if it had never applied
Where the tenant has resumed paying the full current rent before the hearing, the judge, on an application to that effect by the tenant or the landlord, may suspend the effects of the termination clause during the periods granted. If the debt is cleared within the time and in the manner set, together with payment of the current rent and service charges, the clause is deemed never to have applied; at the first missed payment, it takes full effect again (Article 24, VII of the Law of 6 July 1989).
Over-indebtedness
A procedure that changes the hearing
If an over-indebtedness procedure (surendettement) has been opened and the tenant has resumed paying the rent and service charges by the day of the hearing, the judge adapts the periods to the stage of the procedure and to the decisions made (Article 24, VI of the Law of 6 July 1989); personal recovery (rétablissement personnel) follows its own rules. The decisions received must be produced, not merely proof of filing.
Procedural checks are not a mere formality: no referral to the CCAPEX, late notification to the prefect, an incomplete formal demand. In a case involving Paris Habitat, the Paris judge first checked that the writ of summons had been notified to the prefect more than six weeks before the hearing and that the committee had been referred to beforehand, before examining the debt (TJ Paris, 4 April 2025, No. 24/09560).
Death or departure of the tenant
Taking over the lease of a relative
On the tenant's death, subject to the rights of a spouse or partner who is joint holder of the lease, the lease is transferred to the surviving spouse, to the civil partner (PACS) and, if they had been living with the tenant for at least one year, to descendants, ascendants, an established cohabiting partner (concubin notoire) or dependants; where there are several applications, the judge decides according to the interests involved (Article 14 of the Law of 6 July 1989). In an HLM dwelling, two further conditions apply.
Additional conditions
Income and household size
Article 40 of the Law of 6 July 1989
The person to whom the lease is transferred must meet the eligibility conditions for social housing, and the dwelling must be suited to the size of their household (Article 40). Descendants are the most affected: a child left alone in a large dwelling may be refused the transfer.
Exempted persons
Income and size are not required
Article 40, I and III
Among the beneficiaries under Article 14, the spouse, the civil partner (PACS) and the established cohabiting partner are exempt from the income and dwelling-size conditions, although the cohabiting partner is not exempt from the one year of living together. Also exempt, if they had actually been living with the tenant for more than one year, are ascendants, persons with disabilities and persons over sixty-five. For dwellings covered by Article 40, I, the landlord may offer a descendant who meets the income condition a smaller dwelling, for which they have priority.
“Article L. 442-3-1 of the Construction and Housing Code only applies to relations between the HLM body and the tenant” (our translation)
Cass. 3e civ., 20 December 2018, No. 18-10.124
In that case, the descendant who lived alone in an unsuitable dwelling could not obtain the transfer, and the landlord was not required to offer rehousing on grounds of under-occupation, since the descendant was not a tenant. The notion of household, by contrast, means the economic and family unit: siblings can form one (Cass. 3e civ., 25 March 2015, No. 14-11.043).
Evidence
Proving you lived together before the death
Actually living together for the required period before the death can be proven by any documents: tax returns, letters sent to the address, certificates from the family allowance fund (CAF), invoices. The Paris judge checks in turn the conditions of Article 14, then those of Article 40, which are cumulative (TJ Paris, 14 January 2025, No. 24/05695).
Refusal
What happens if the transfer is refused
Where there is no beneficiary, the lease is terminated automatically by the death (Article 14 of the Law of 6 July 1989). An occupant who stays in the premises faces eviction proceedings and an occupancy indemnity (indemnité d'occupation). They may request time if their rehousing cannot take place in normal conditions (Article L. 412-3 of the CPCE).
Occupation, subletting and disturbances
The landlord's allegations and how they are proven
Social housing must be occupied for at least eight months a year by the tenant, their spouse or a dependant, except for work obligations, health reasons or force majeure. The tenant may not sublet it, furnished or unfurnished, assign the lease or exchange it outside the cases provided for. In the event of a breach, the landlord may apply for termination of the lease (Article L. 442-3-5 of the Construction and Housing Code (CCH)).
Subletting
A prohibition in principle
Subletting is only allowed under a statutory exception: in particular the cases in Article L. 442-8-1 of the CCH, including housing a person over sixty or an adult with a disability under a family placement contract, with a regulated charge for the rooms, and intergenerational solidarity cohabitation (Article L. 631-17 of the CCH). Repeated letting through an online platform exposes the tenant to termination and to repayment of the sums received.
Burden of proof
It is for the landlord to prove it
The Paris court restates the rule: “It is for the landlord who alleges that the tenant does not personally occupy the premises as a main residence, or that the lease has been assigned or sublet, to prove it” (our translation) (TJ Paris, 17 February 2026, No. 25/05548). Absences linked to health or work are justified with documents.
“rent is a civil fruit of ownership and the tenant, who carried out the prohibited subletting, could not be a possessor in good faith” (our translation)
Cass. 3e civ., 22 June 2022, No. 21-18.612, § 14
In the same judgment, concerning a subsidised (conventionné) dwelling in Paris partly let through an online platform, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) faulted the lower court for failing to assess the seriousness of the breach in light of the statutory prohibition on subletting. The sub-rents go to the landlord, and the judge cannot deduct from them the rent the landlord has received.
Disturbances
Peaceful enjoyment and neighbours
The obligation to use the premises peacefully applies to the tenant of an HLM dwelling; serious and repeated disturbances may justify termination of the lease, depending on the evidence gathered by the landlord (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 3, 11 May 2023, No. 21/03409). The defence challenges whether the facts are real, who was responsible and how serious they were.
Housing someone
Taking in a relative without subletting
Housing a family member without charge is not, in principle, subletting, since no rent is paid. The risk arises when the tenant no longer lives in the dwelling or receives something in return. The firm reviews the situation before the landlord serves a formal notice.
Condition of the dwelling and the right to housing
Obtaining decent, suitable housing
The landlord, whether social or private, must provide decent housing, with no obvious risk to safety or health and with no pest infestation, and must maintain it (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989). Decency also includes a minimum level of energy performance. The defects, their cause and the obligation breached must be established before asking for works or compensation.
Proving the defect
Establish the facts before acting
Written reports to the landlord, dated photos, a report from the public health service, an official report by a commissaire de justice: the file is built before the hearing. Where the dwelling is not decent, the judge may order it to be brought up to standard, reduce the rent or suspend its payment until the works are done (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989); damages require proof of loss.
The DALO
Applying to the mediation committee
Subject to the conditions for access to social housing, a person acting in good faith who is threatened with eviction without rehousing, or housed in unsanitary or dangerous premises, may apply to the mediation committee (commission de médiation) without waiting for the ordinary time limit; the same applies to housing that is not decent if the applicant has a minor child, has a disability or has a dependant with a disability (Article L. 441-2-3 of the CCH). If the committee recognises the applicant as a priority case and an eviction decision exists, it may refer the matter to the judge to grant time; the application does not, by itself, stay the eviction.
Under-occupation
Rehousing offered by the landlord
In the event of under-occupation, the landlord offers a new dwelling matching the tenant's needs. In the areas covered by the law, refusing three compliant offers causes the loss of the right to remain in the premises, six months after notification of the third offer. Protected are tenants over sixty-five, tenants with a disability or loss of autonomy, or who have such a person as a dependant, as well as dwellings located in a priority neighbourhood, or that were when the tenant moved in (Article L. 442-3-1 of the CCH).
Documents to send to the firm
- Lease and amendments, latest rent notice.
- Formal demand to pay, writ of summons, judgment or order to vacate the premises received.
- Statement of the debt and proof of payments, housing benefit.
- In the event of a death: death certificate, proof of living together before the death, tax notices.
- Letters from the landlord alleging subletting or failure to occupy.
- Photos, reports and inspections on the condition of the dwelling.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions about social housing in France
Can a social housing landlord in France evict its tenant?
Yes, but only after a court decision and following a regulated procedure. For rent arrears, a landlord that is a legal entity must refer the matter to the CCAPEX two months before serving a writ of summons and notify the writ to the prefect six weeks before the hearing (Article 24 of the Law of 6 July 1989). The lease may also be terminated for subletting or failure to occupy (Article L. 442-3-5 of the CCH), or for disturbances that are serious enough in light of the obligation of peaceful enjoyment.
Once eviction has been ordered, it may in principle only take place after a period of two months following the order to vacate the premises (Article L. 412-1 of the CPCE), and not during the winter truce from 1 November to 31 March, subject to the statutory exceptions (Article L. 412-6 of the CPCE). The enforcement judge may grant periods of one month to one year.
Can eviction be avoided after rent arrears in HLM housing?
It is possible if the tenant has resumed paying the full current rent before the hearing and can pay off the debt. The judge may then grant time to pay of up to three years and, if asked, suspend the effects of the termination clause; if the debt is paid within that time, the clause is deemed never to have applied (Article 24, V and VII of the Law of 6 July 1989).
The request is prepared with a realistic budget, proof of income and, where relevant, the over-indebtedness file. Assistance from the housing solidarity fund may be requested. The judge may grant time on their own initiative, but the suspension of the clause must be requested: the defence asks for it with a costed plan.
Who can take over an HLM lease when the tenant dies?
Subject to the rights of a spouse or partner who is joint holder of the lease: the surviving spouse, the civil partner (PACS) and, if they had been living with the tenant for at least one year at the date of death, the established cohabiting partner, descendants, ascendants and dependants (Article 14 of the Law of 6 July 1989). In an HLM dwelling, the beneficiary must also meet the eligibility conditions and the dwelling must be suited to the size of their household (Article 40 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
These two conditions do not apply to the spouse, the partner or the established cohabiting partner, nor, after more than one year of living together, to ascendants, persons with disabilities and people over sixty-five; the other conditions for the transfer remain. A descendant alone in a large dwelling may therefore be refused the transfer (Cass. 3e civ., 20 December 2018, No. 18-10.124).
The landlord refuses to transfer the lease: what can I do?
First identify the ground: length of time living together, income, size of the dwelling. Each one can be challenged with documents. The notion of household means the economic and family unit, and siblings can form one (Cass. 3e civ., 25 March 2015, No. 14-11.043). The refusal can be challenged before the litigation protection judge.
If the refusal is based solely on the size of the dwelling and the income conditions are met, the landlord may, for dwellings covered by Article 40, I, offer the descendant a smaller dwelling for which they have priority (Article 40 of the Law of 6 July 1989); this is not a general obligation to rehouse. Staying in the premises without a right of occupation exposes the occupant to an occupancy indemnity: the strategy must be decided quickly.
Can I sublet my HLM flat in France?
In principle, no. The tenant of social housing may not sublet, furnished or unfurnished, assign the lease or exchange it outside the cases provided for, and must occupy it for at least eight months a year (Article L. 442-3-5 of the CCH). Exceptions exist, in particular housing a person over sixty or an adult with a disability under a family placement contract (Article L. 442-8-1 of the CCH) and intergenerational solidarity cohabitation (Article L. 631-17 of the CCH). Simply informing the landlord is not enough.
Prohibited subletting exposes the tenant to termination of the lease and repayment of the sub-rents. The Court of Cassation holds that a tenant who carried out prohibited subletting cannot keep these sums (Cass. 3e civ., 22 June 2022, No. 21-18.612).
My landlord claims I no longer live in the dwelling: how do I defend myself?
It is for the landlord to prove failure to occupy or subletting (TJ Paris, 17 February 2026, No. 25/05548). Occupation for eight months a year, by the tenant, their spouse or a dependant, is assessed under Article 2 of the 1989 Law, which makes exceptions for work obligations, health reasons and force majeure.
The defence gathers proof of presence: energy and phone bills, bank statements, medical records, statements from neighbours, the children's schooling. A hospital stay or a long stay with a sick relative can be justified. Reply in writing to the formal notice, with these documents, before any writ of summons.
My social housing is unsanitary or damp: what are my options?
The landlord must provide decent housing and maintain it (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989). After reports that have gone unanswered, the tenant may apply to the judge, who may order the dwelling to be brought up to standard, reduce the rent or suspend its payment (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989); damages require proof of loss. The file rests on dated evidence: letters, photos, a report from the public health service, an official report.
If the dwelling is not decent and the applicant has a minor child, has a disability or has a dependant with a disability, the DALO mediation committee may be approached without waiting for the ordinary time limit (Article L. 441-2-3 of the CCH). Do not stop paying based solely on your own view of the condition of the dwelling; check whether a safety order or an order dealing with unsanitary conditions legally stops the rent from being due (Article L. 521-2 of the CCH).
What is the DALO mediation committee and when should I apply to it?
The departmental mediation committee recognises priority applicants who must be allocated housing urgently. Subject to the conditions for access to social housing, it may be approached without waiting for the ordinary time limit, in particular by a person acting in good faith who is threatened with eviction without rehousing, or housed in unsanitary or dangerous premises (Article L. 441-2-3 of the CCH).
When it recognises as a priority case an applicant subject to an eviction decision, it may refer the matter to the judge to grant time; the application does not, by itself, stay the eviction. The eviction judge also takes into account applications made under this scheme when setting the periods (Article L. 412-4 of the CPCE).
Can the landlord force me to move to a smaller dwelling?
In the event of under-occupation, the landlord must offer a new dwelling matching the tenant's needs, with a lower basic rent (Article L. 442-3-1 of the CCH). In the areas covered by the law, a tenant who refuses three compliant offers loses the right to remain in the premises and loses any right of occupation six months after notification of the third offer.
This sanction does not apply to tenants over sixty-five, tenants with a disability or loss of autonomy, or who have such a person as a dependant, nor to dwellings located in a priority urban policy neighbourhood (quartier prioritaire de la politique de la ville), or that were when the tenant moved in. Each offer is checked against these conditions before any refusal.
How much does a lawyer cost for a dispute with a social housing landlord?
Fees are set by a written agreement, except in the cases provided for by law, in particular full legal aid (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971). They depend on the procedure: defence against an eviction claim, a request for time, challenging a refusal to transfer the lease, a claim concerning substandard housing.
The firm offers a first written analysis for €80 incl. VAT, based on the documents sent through the form. It sets out the time limits, the defence arguments and the possible next steps. No court outcome can be guaranteed.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Main texts cited, checked in their version in force on 21 October 2026: Law No. 89-462 of 6 July 1989, the Construction and Housing Code and the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures.
Further reading
Page updated on 21 October 2026. The applicable rules must be checked again at the date of your situation.
A dispute with your social housing landlord?
Contact the firm. Send the lease, the landlord's letters and, where relevant, the writ of summons with the hearing date.