KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Parent Left a Handwritten Will for Their French House: Is It Valid in France, How the Notaire Probates It, and What the IRS Still Taxes

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Parent Left a Handwritten Will for Their French House: Is It Valid in France, How the Notaire Probates It, and What the IRS Still Taxes

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your father lived twenty years in the Dordogne, in a stone house he bought after retiring from Ohio. After the funeral in France, you find in his desk drawer a will written entirely by his own hand, in English, on three pages of a yellow legal pad. It leaves the French house to you, gives the bank accounts to your brother, and asks that everything be handled quickly. You fly home to Chicago wondering whether that piece of paper is worth anything at all in France, whether a French notaire — the public officer who settles every French succession — will even read an English handwritten document, and whether the Internal Revenue Service will tax you again on a house France has already taxed. This article answers those three questions in order: first, the strict French validity test for a handwritten will, called a testament olographe; second, the exact probate path from the drawer to the French land registry, with its deadlines; and third, what the will can legally give you when French forced heirship applies, plus how France and the United States divide the tax bill. Keep the original paper exactly as you found it, and read on before you sign or promise anything to anyone.

I. Is My Parent’s Handwritten Will Valid in France, and Will the Notaire Accept It?

French law starts from a simple definition. Under Article 895 of the Civil Code, a will — le testament — is “un acte par lequel le testateur dispose, pour le temps où il n’existera plus, de tout ou partie de ses biens ou de ses droits et qu’il peut révoquer”, meaning a document by which a person disposes of all or part of their property and rights for the time when they will no longer exist, and which they may revoke at any time. That last word matters enormously for American families: until death, your parent could tear the will up, write a new one, or simply change their mind, and no promise made during their lifetime binds the succession. French law then offers exactly three permitted forms. Under Article 969 of the Civil Code, “Un testament pourra être olographe ou fait par acte public ou dans la forme mystique”, meaning a will may be handwritten, or received as a formal notarial act, or made in the sealed mystic form. The handwritten form is by far the most common for a private individual, it costs nothing to write, and it is also the form American parents reach for spontaneously. Everything below therefore concerns that handwritten form first, with the notarial form as the safer comparison point.

A. The Three Handwritten Conditions That Decide Everything

The entire validity of your parent’s will hangs on one short sentence. Under Article 970 of the Civil Code, “Le testament olographe ne sera point valable s’il n’est écrit en entier, daté et signé de la main du testateur : il n’est assujetti à aucune autre forme”, meaning a handwritten will is not valid unless it is written out in full, dated, and signed by the hand of the testator, and it is subject to no other formal requirement. Three conditions, no witness, no notary, no seal — but each of the three is interpreted with genuine strictness by French courts, and American habits collide with every one of them.

First, the will must be entirely handwritten by the testator. A will typed on a computer and merely signed at the bottom is void as a testament olographe, even if the signature is authentic and even if two friends witnessed the signing. This shocks many Americans, because a typed will with witnesses is perfectly valid in most US states. In France it is worthless in this form. The same fate awaits a fill-in-the-blank form from a stationery store or a document drafted by a well-meaning child and signed by the parent. If your parent’s English text is genuinely in their own handwriting from the first word to the last, this condition is satisfied; if any passage was typed, printed, or written by someone else, the document fails as a handwritten will. The notarial alternative exists precisely for people who cannot or will not handwrite: under Article 971 of the Civil Code, “Le testament par acte public est reçu par deux notaires ou par un notaire assisté de deux témoins”, meaning the public will is received by two notaries, or by one notary assisted by two witnesses. That dictated, read-back, and archived procedure is the gold standard, and if your parent is still alive and their handwritten will looks fragile, having a notary draw up a public will alongside it is the single most effective protection you can buy.

Second, spouses cannot make one will together. Many American couples write a single joint document leaving everything to the survivor and then to the children. French law forbids this outright. Under Article 968 of the Civil Code, “Un testament ne pourra être fait dans le même acte par deux ou plusieurs personnes soit au profit d’un tiers, soit à titre de disposition réciproque ou mutuelle”, meaning one document may not serve as the will of two or more persons, whether in favor of a third party or as reciprocal gifts between them. If your mother and father signed the same sheet of paper, each disposition must be judged separately, and the shared form itself is a ground for nullity. Each parent needs their own separate handwritten will, each fully handwritten, dated, and signed by its own author. When you find a single document signed by both parents, treat it as an emergency and consult counsel before the succession advances, because the surviving parent should urgently make a fresh individual will while the deceased parent’s document goes through validity analysis.

Third, the signature must come last, and nothing given away may sit below it. This is the trap the Cour de cassation restated with unusual firmness on March 26, 2025. In Cass. 1st civil chamber, March 26, 2025, No. 23-14.430, heirs challenged a handwritten will dated April 27, 2016, and the Court held that “Pour être la marque de l’approbation personnelle et définitive du contenu de l’acte, la signature doit nécessairement être apposée à sa suite”, meaning that to mark the personal and definitive approval of the contents, the signature must necessarily be placed after the text. A bequest written underneath the signature and date — in that case a legacy added below — is not covered by the signature and fails. The Court therefore quashed the appeal judgment that had validated the whole will including the below-signature legacy. Read your parent’s pages with a ruler in mind: if the signature closes the text and nothing dispositive follows, you are safe; if a paragraph, a postscript, or an extra gift was squeezed in after the signature, that addition is exposed to annulment even if the rest of the will survives. A codicil must itself be a complete mini-will — handwritten, dated, signed — never a scribble in the margin beneath the original signature.

The same 2025 decision settled a second practical point that matters whenever siblings fight over a will. When handwriting is denied, the court must verify it against the original document, not a photocopy. The Court held, as seen in Cass. 1st civil chamber, March 26, 2025, No. 23-14.430 approving the visa of Articles 287 and 288 of the Code of Civil Procedure, that “la vérification d’écriture doit être effectuée au vu de l’original de l’écrit contesté”, meaning handwriting verification must be performed on the original of the contested writing. An appeal court that compared only a readable copy, however legible, violated those texts. The lesson for you is physical: keep the original paper untouched, unfolded as found, unlaminated, stored dry and flat. Do not circulate the original among family members, do not mail it, and give the notaire and the court only copies until the original is formally required. If a sibling announces they will contest the handwriting, the original in your safekeeping is your case.

What about the missing date, the most common defect in American handwritten wills? Here the courts show a narrow path to survival, but you should never walk it voluntarily. In Cass. 1st civil chamber, November 22, 2023, No. 21-17.524, a woman died leaving a handwritten will written on the back of a bank statement, signed but bearing no handwritten date. The Court preserved the will, holding that “En dépit de son absence de date, un testament olographe n’encourt pas la nullité dès lors que des éléments intrinsèques à l’acte, éventuellement corroborés par des éléments extrinsèques, établissent qu’il a été rédigé au cours d’une période déterminée”, meaning that despite the missing date, a handwritten will is not void where elements intrinsic to the document, possibly corroborated by extrinsic evidence, establish that it was written during a determinable period. It added that “Une date pré-imprimée sur le support utilisé par le testateur pour rédiger son testament olographe peut constituer un élément intrinsèque à celui-ci”, meaning a pre-printed date on the paper used for the will can count as such an intrinsic element. In that case the statement valued savings at March 31, 2014, the address matched, and hospitalization from May 2014 framed the window, with no incapacity shown — so the will survived. Treat this as a rescue doctrine, not a planning tool: if your parent’s will is undated, gather every intrinsic clue at once — the paper, printed dates, addresses, references to events — plus extrinsic proof of capacity and of the absence of any later revoking will, because challengers will attack exactly there. And if your parent is alive, the fix costs nothing: add the full date in their hand and have them re-sign, or better, rewrite the will cleanly with an explicit date.

Two final practical points close this validity review. A will written in English is not automatically void — French law requires the testator’s hand, not the French language — but an English-only will slows everything down: the notaire will require a certified French translation, witnesses to capacity may need to confirm your parent understood what they wrote, and any ambiguity will be construed under French succession concepts, not American ones. If your parent is still alive, a French text, or a bilingual text in their hand, removes a whole layer of dispute. And capacity is judged at the date of writing: a will written during a lucid interval stands, but hospitalization, dementia diagnoses, and guardianship measures invite challenges, which is why dating the will precisely and keeping medical context documented protects it. Our companion guide on choosing American law for your French succession explains how a valid will interacts with the cross-border choice of law, and it is the natural next read once validity is confirmed: My US Will and My French House: Choosing American Law for Your French Succession.

B. From the Kitchen Drawer to the Land Registry: Deposit, Searches, and Deadlines

A valid will does nothing by itself; it must travel a formal French path before anyone owns the house. The first step is finding every will, not just the one in the drawer. Ask the French notaire to query the central wills registry, the fichier central des dispositions de dernières volontés (FCDDV), which records wills deposited with notaries. The official guidance on wills explains that you may deposit your handwritten will with a notaire for safekeeping and have it registered with the FCDDV so its existence is revealed at death: service-public.fr, drafting your will, and the registry’s role is detailed at service-public.fr, the central registry of last wishes. This search is essential because a later will revokes an earlier one to the extent they conflict, and the paper you found may not be the last word. If your parent deposited a notarial will years later, the drawer document may be partially revoked without anyone in the family knowing. Never distribute property or pay out legacies before the FCDDV search comes back.

Once the will is identified, the law imposes a deposit ritual. Under Article 1007 of the Civil Code, “Tout testament olographe ou mystique sera, avant d’être mis à exécution, déposé entre les mains d’un notaire”, meaning every handwritten or mystic will must, before execution, be deposited with a notaire. The notaire opens it if sealed, draws up immediately a written record of the opening and of the will’s condition specifying the circumstances of deposit, keeps both with their official records, and within a month sends a copy to the clerk of the judicial court of the place where the succession opened. Interested parties then have a short window to object to a universal legatee taking possession, and if anyone objects, that legatee must seek a court order of possession. In plain terms: bring the original to the notaire promptly, expect a formal written record, and understand that a sibling who objects can force the beneficiary into court before they touch anything. This is also why our step-by-step probate guide for American families pairs naturally with this article — it lists the papers, the land-registry deed, and the traps on deadlines: My American Parent Died Owning a House in France: the Notaire Probate, Your Papers, and the Deadlines.

The house itself changes hands on paper through a specific notarial deed, the attestation de propriété immobilière, which the notaire publishes at the land-registry service (the service de publicité foncière). Until that publication, heirs cannot sell or mortgage the property with clean title, and buyers’ notaires will demand it. Assemble the file the notaire will ask for: the original will and its translation, the American death certificate with apostille and certified translation, the French death certificate if death occurred in France, family record documents proving heirship, marriage contracts or divorce decrees, property title deeds, recent property-tax notices, bank statements, and any trust or company documents if the house sits in a structure. American documents need an apostille under the Hague Convention plus a translation by a certified translator (traducteur assermenté); start that process from the United States immediately, because it routinely takes weeks and the French clock is already running.

That clock is strict and it runs from death, not from the day you found the will. Under Article 641 of the General Tax Code, the time allowed to file the succession declaration is “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas”, meaning six months from death when the deceased died in metropolitan France, and one year in all other cases. An American parent who died in Ohio or Florida therefore generally gives you twelve months, while a parent who died at home in the Dordogne gives you six. These are tax-filing deadlines for the declaration (déclaration de succession), and Article 800 of the General Tax Code requires heirs, legatees, and donees to file that detailed declaration, with only narrow exemptions for very small estates — direct-line heirs are excused only where gross estate assets fall below 50,000 euros and no prior unregistered gift was received. Missing the deadline triggers late interest and penalties on the tax due, and the notaire cannot finalize the file without the declaration, so calendar the deadline on the day of death and work backward: translations, FCDDV search, deposit record, valuation of the house, then filing. If the deadline is about to expire, a protective filing with estimated values beats a late complete filing, and your notaire knows how to do it.

II. What the Will Can Give Your Family, and What France and the United States Each Tax

Many American parents write their French-house will as if French law worked like Ohio or Florida law: everything to the surviving spouse, or everything to one child who will “take care of” the others, or a favorite charity for the whole estate. French law can frustrate each of those plans through forced heirship, and the tax analysis then runs on two tracks at once. This part explains the limit, the one powerful choice that softens it, and the double tax return every American heir must get right.

A. Your Children Cannot Be Disinherited: the Forced Share, the American-Law Choice, and the 2021 Safety Net

France reserves part of every estate for certain heirs, and no will can take it from them. Under Article 912 of the Civil Code, “La réserve héréditaire est la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires”, meaning the forced share (réserve héréditaire) is the portion of the estate the law guarantees, free of charges, to certain heirs called forced heirs, while the remainder — the disposable portion (quotité disponible) — is what the deceased could freely give away. The forced heirs are, in practice, the children; the surviving spouse is protected differently and is not a forced heir when children survive. The fractions are fixed by Article 913 of the Civil Code: gifts by lifetime transfer or by will “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant, s’il ne laisse à son décès qu’un enfant ; le tiers, s’il laisse deux enfants ; le quart, s’il en laisse trois ou un plus grand nombre”, meaning they may not exceed one-half of the property with one child, one-third with two children, and one-quarter with three or more children. With two American children, for example, each child is guaranteed one-third and your parent could freely dispose of only one-third — the house cannot go entirely to one child, entirely to a new spouse, or entirely to charity if the numbers do not fit. A will that exceeds the disposable portion is not thrown out wholesale; it is reduced (réduction) down to the legal limit at the request of the shortchanged forced heir, which is why a disinherited child sues for reduction rather than for nullity.

For American families, one clause can change the applicable law — but it cannot erase the forced share by itself. The European Succession Regulation No. 650/2012, which governs cross-border successions in France, provides in its Article 22(1) that “Une personne peut choisir comme loi régissant l’ensemble de sa succession la loi de l’État dont elle possède la nationalité au moment où elle fait ce choix ou au moment de son décès”, meaning a person may choose, to govern their whole succession, the law of the State whose nationality they hold when making the choice or at death: Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, official text. An American parent may therefore validly elect US law — typically the law of their US state — inside the will itself, and our companion guide walks through exactly how to draft that election so a French notaire accepts it: choosing American law for your French succession. But the Regulation’s own design warns against using that choice to defeat children’s expectations: its recitals state that the choice is limited to the law of a State of nationality precisely to prevent a law from being chosen in order to defeat the legitimate expectations of forced-share beneficiaries. In practice, French notaires and courts scrutinize American-law elections that disinherit children, and since 2021 France added a compensatory backstop. The second paragraph of Article 913, introduced in 2021, provides that where the deceased or at least one child is, at death, a national of or habitually resident in an EU Member State, and the applicable foreign law offers children no forced-share protection, each child may levy a compensatory taking (prélèvement compensatoire) on French-situated assets existing at death, restoring their French forced-share rights within those limits. Concretely: if your father’s will elects Florida law and leaves the Dordogne house entirely to his second wife, and you are his daughter living in Lyon or holding French nationality, you can claim your forced share directly against the French house despite the Florida election. If none of the family has any EU nationality or habitual residence, the backstop does not trigger — which is exactly the configuration where careful lifetime planning, gifts within the disposable portion, and proper elections matter most. Our case study on a disinherited American child shows how these claims are actually filed and argued: claiming your forced share and compensatory levy on a French house.

What should you do with this knowledge, depending on which side of the will you stand? If you are the heir your parent favored, do not celebrate early: have the notaire compute the disposable portion before you spend a euro, because a reduction action by a sibling can claw back the excess with interest years later. If you are the child the will shortchanges, act within your rights but watch limitation periods — reduction claims expire, and sitting on your rights while the favored heir sells the house to a good-faith buyer complicates everything. If your parent is alive, the honest solution is a will that respects the forced shares while using the disposable portion strategically: give the house to the child who will keep it, compensate the other within the disposable share, add an American-law election for coherence with US assets, and document the arithmetic in a side memorandum for the notaire. A will that picks a fight with the forced share is a will that funds litigation; a will that prices it in is a will that settles successions.

B. French Inheritance Tax on the House and the American Paperwork That Follows

France taxes the transfer, and its tax net catches the French house almost regardless of where anyone lives. Under Article 750 ter of the General Tax Code, France taxes worldwide assets where the deceased was fiscally domiciled in France, French-situated assets where the deceased was not domiciled in France, and — the trap for American families — worldwide assets received by an heir domiciled in France who was domiciled there at least six of the last ten years. So the Dordogne house is taxable in France whether your father died domiciled in France or in Florida, and if you, the heir, have lived in France for years, even the Ohio bank accounts flowing to you can enter the French base. Each child’s share then benefits from a personal allowance: under Article 779 of the General Tax Code, “il est effectué un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation”, meaning a 100,000-euro allowance applies to each living or represented child’s share. Above that allowance, the progressive rate scale of Article 777 of the General Tax Code runs from 5 percent on the first 8,072 euros up to 45 percent beyond 1,805,677 euros, with intermediate brackets at 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 percent. On a 600,000-euro house passing to a single child, the rough math after the allowance lands deep in five figures of French tax — which is why valuations, deductible debts and charges, and the allowance arithmetic deserve professional attention rather than back-of-the-envelope treatment. Siblings inheriting together each get their own allowance against their own share, and our detailed walkthrough of heir-level computation is here: French inheritance tax for the American heir of a French house.

The 1978 Franco-American estate and gift tax convention then prevents the same house from being fully taxed twice. Its consolidated text, as amended by the 2004 protocol, is published by the French tax administration: consolidated France–United States convention of November 24, 1978 (impots.gouv.fr, PDF). Its scope clause covers both sides of the ocean, covering estates of persons domiciled in France at death as well as estates of persons subject to United States tax at death by reason of domicile there or American citizenship. In practice, France taxes the French house first under its domestic rules, and the United States then grants relief — typically a credit against US estate tax for the French tax paid on the same property, within the convention’s limits and the Internal Revenue Code’s own limits. Because the US taxes its citizens on worldwide transfers while France taxes the French-situs asset, the credit mechanics, the different exemptions, and the different valuation dates can leave residual double cost if the file is handled in the wrong order. File the French declaration correctly first, keep every French tax receipt, and hand the whole package to a US CPA experienced in cross-border estates before any US estate or gift tax return is signed.

Finally, do not confuse the French declaration with your American reporting duties, which continue in parallel. US citizens and residents report worldwide inheritances under US rules even when France already taxed them; large bequests from foreign persons can trigger dedicated information returns, and ongoing ownership of the French house brings its own yearly US reporting if accounts or entities are involved. Ask your CPA specifically about foreign-bequest information reporting, about the yearly foreign-account and foreign-asset forms if the succession leaves you French accounts, and about the income-tax basis you take in the house for a future sale, because the French and American basis rules do not match. The notaire settles the French succession; only coordinated Franco-American advice settles your total bill. Keep a single binder — will, deposit record, FCDDV result, land-registry deed, French declaration with receipts, translations, CPA correspondence — and every professional you consult will bless you.

Conclusion

A handwritten English will can absolutely govern your parent’s French house, but only if it passes France’s three-word test — entirely handwritten, dated, signed — with the signature closing the text and nothing dispositive beneath it, as the Cour de cassation restated in 2025. An undated will may still be rescued by the intrinsic-clue doctrine the Court confirmed in 2023, yet rescue litigation costs a multiple of a clean rewrite, so verify the date today and rewrite while there is still time. Then move the paper through the mandatory French channel: central-registry search, deposit with the notaire and its written record, land-registry publication of the transfer deed, and the succession declaration within six months of a death in France or twelve months otherwise. Measure every gift against the children’s forced shares — one-half, one-third, or one-quarter freely disposable depending on the number of children — use an American-law election knowingly rather than as a disinheritance trick, and remember the 2021 compensatory levy that protects EU-connected children against foreign laws with no forced share. Pay the French tax on the house with its 100,000-euro allowance per child and progressive rates, invoke the 1978 convention’s credit machinery on the American side, and keep your CPA in the loop from day one. Handled in that order, the yellow legal pad in the drawer becomes what your parent intended: a fast, lawful, once-taxed transfer of the family house, not a lawsuit.

📄 Official circular