Kohen Avocats — Welfare benefit fraud
CAF fraud lawyer in Paris: audit, overpayment, complaint, prosecution
An audit by the French family benefits fund (CAF), a demand for repayment, a financial penalty or a criminal summons: our CAF fraud lawyer in Paris examines the facts, the benefits concerned and the appeals to be prepared.
Received a summons or a decision you want to challenge? Send the complete document and the date you received it, so that the steps to take and the time limits can be checked.
CAF fraud · Paris
Have your case reviewed
State the benefit concerned, the periods audited and the decisions received. The firm distinguishes between repayment, the penalty and the criminal proceedings.
CAF
Audits, appeals
and criminal defence
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16th
Your defence against an accusation of CAF fraud

Welfare benefit fraud · Paris 16th
Your CAF fraud lawyer in Paris
- Paris Bar
- Welfare benefit fraud
- Audits and appeals
- Criminal defence
A notice from the CAF may demand repayment, announce a penalty or mention a criminal complaint. Each of these calls for a different response. An overpayment (indu) of family benefits is governed in particular by Article L553-2 of the French Social Security Code (Code de la sécurité sociale), the penalty by Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code and the criminal offence of making a false declaration by Article 441-6 of the French Criminal Code (Code pénal). The firm reviews the letters, declarations and supporting documents to identify the benefit, the period and the precise facts alleged.
Hassan Kohen works with you on the response to the audit, the challenge to the overpayment or the penalty and, if an investigation is opened, your criminal defence. The work covers the chronology, the sums actually paid, the legal classification adopted and the available evidence. Send the notice and proof of the date you received it, together with any summons. You can reach the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45 to explain your situation.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Understanding the debt
Reconstructing entitlements, declarations, payments and the CAF's calculation.
Choosing the appeal
Identifying the decision being challenged, who it is addressed to and the deadline to be met.
Preparing the defence
Testing the alleged facts against the documents before the interview and preparing the relevant observations.
Overpayment, declaration and intent
A CAF debt alone does not establish an offence
The recovery of an overpayment, the administrative penalty and a criminal conviction are each subject to different conditions (Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code, Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code, Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code).
The benefit
Was it due?
Check the calculation
For family benefits, an overpayment can be recovered even if no criminal offence is established. A write-off on grounds of financial hardship remains subject to the conditions of Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code.
The conduct
What act is alleged?
Check the legal classification
The false or incomplete declaration must have been made knowingly in order to obtain, or attempt to obtain, an undue advantage. The provision also covers anyone who seeks to obtain such an advantage for someone else (Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code).
False declaration
Find the form and its date
A declaration actually made must be identified, together with its content, the fact that it was false or incomplete, and the aim pursued. The mere failure to report a later change of circumstances is not enough to constitute this criminal false declaration. It may nevertheless amount to the administrative breach provided for by Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code, except in cases of good faith under points 1° and 2°.
Fraud (escroquerie)
Check each element
Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code requires a false name, a false capacity, the abuse of a genuine capacity or fraudulent manoeuvres (manœuvres frauduleuses); a deception that brings about a handover; and a loss to the person deceived or to a third party. Intent must also be established (Article 121-3 of the Criminal Code). The defence examines separately the method used, the payments, their link with the deception and the loss.
Forgery and attestations
Identify the document concerned
Forgery requires a fraudulent alteration of the truth, capable of causing harm, in a document or medium that has evidential value (Article 441-1 of the Criminal Code). A materially inaccurate attestation may fall under the specific provision of Article 441-7 of the Criminal Code. Not every attestation given as a favour (attestation de complaisance) should therefore be classified, without distinction, under Article 441-1.
“it wrongly held that each defendant's failure to report a change in their living circumstances amounted to the false or incomplete declaration required by Article 441-6, paragraph 2, cited above.” (our translation)
Cass. crim., 26 November 2024, No. 23-81.498
Here the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) quashes the appeal ruling for equating the omission with a false declaration. This decision does not wipe out every debt linked to an undeclared family situation.
The CAF's documents and your response
Responding to a CAF audit, challenging its findings
Sworn and approved inspectors (agents de contrôle) carry out the administrative checks. Their findings stand unless proven otherwise (Article L114-10 of the Social Security Code). This evidential weight does not remove the need to examine the legal classification adopted.
Request for supporting documents
Keep a dated response
File the request, the documents sent and the proof of sending. Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code allows certain acts or omissions intended to obstruct the audit to be penalised: refusing access to information formally requested, failing to reply, or giving a false, incomplete or unreasonably late reply. The request must be necessary for the audit; any difficulty in producing a document is therefore not, in itself, an established obstruction.
Information from third parties
Ask for the documents used
When it uses its right to obtain information from third parties (droit de communication), the CAF must state the content and source of the third-party information on which it bases a recovery or the withdrawal of a benefit. On request, it provides a copy before taking that measure (Article L114-21 of the Social Security Code). This safeguard covers the documents obtained in this way; it is not the same as automatic and full access to the criminal case file.
Proposed penalty
Submit observations
The notice must specify the facts and the proposed sanction. You have one month from receipt to ask to be heard or to submit written observations (Article R114-11 of the Social Security Code). The procedure may be dropped, or end in a warning or a reasoned penalty. A committee's opinion is not always required: Article L114-17-2 of the Social Security Code provides, among other things, for an exemption where the loss does not exceed eight times the monthly social security ceiling (plafond mensuel de la sécurité sociale).
An appeal on the merits is no substitute for scrutinising the procedure. The Court of Cassation points out: “It is for the social security court to rule on a ground raised before it alleging an irregularity in the procedure followed for the application of the penalties provided for by that provision.” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-21.495). The judgment concerns the former wording of L. 114-17; the current steps are checked against L. 114-17-2 and R. 114-11.
Identify the benefit and the decision
Challenging the overpayment or the penalty: separate appeals
A CAF letterhead alone does not tell you which court has jurisdiction. A single letter may concern several benefits and several decisions.
2 months
to refer a family benefits overpayment to the CRA (amicable appeals board)
2 months
for the prior administrative appeal on RSA (minimum income benefit)
1 month
for observations on a proposed penalty
Time limits laid down by Article R142-1 of the Social Security Code, Article R262-88 of the Social Action and Families Code (Code de l'action sociale et des familles) and Article R114-11 of the Social Security Code, running from the corresponding notifications.
Family benefits
Amicable appeals board, then the social security court
The overpayment is first challenged before the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable), within two months of notification (Article L142-4 of the Social Security Code, Article R142-1 of the Social Security Code). Litigation then falls to the specially designated judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) (Article L142-1 of the Social Security Code, Article R142-1-A of the Social Security Code). Check, on each decision, the available means of appeal and when the time limit starts to run.
L. 114-17 penalty
Direct appeal to the judicial court
The penalty decision can be challenged before the specially designated judicial court (Article L114-17-2 of the Social Security Code). It is expressly excluded from the mandatory prior appeal by Article L142-4 of the Social Security Code. The ordinary time limit for bringing proceedings is two months, subject to the notification conditions of Article R142-1-A of the Social Security Code. Do not confuse the challenge to this penalty with the challenge to the overpayment.
RSA
President of the departmental council
The reasoned prior appeal is sent to the president of the departmental council (président du conseil départemental) within two months (Article L262-47 of the Social Action and Families Code, Article R262-88 of the Social Action and Families Code). Objections to recovery, requests for a write-off and the related appeals have suspensive effect under Article L262-46 of the Social Action and Families Code. The RSA administrative fine follows the specific regime of Article L262-52 of the Social Action and Families Code.
Activity bonus and housing
Do not apply the family benefits appeals procedure
For the activity bonus (prime d'activité): a prior appeal to the CRA, then the administrative courts (Article L845-2 of the Social Security Code); the suspensive effect of challenges to an overpayment is provided for by Article L845-3 of the Social Security Code. For personal housing benefits (aides personnelles au logement): a prior administrative appeal to the paying body, then the administrative courts, subject to the jurisdiction of the judicial courts over fraud penalties (Article L825-2 of the Construction and Housing Code (Code de la construction et de l'habitation), Article L825-1 of the Construction and Housing Code).
Debt write-off
A request distinct from challenging the calculation
For family benefits, financial hardship (précarité) may justify a write-off, except in cases of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations (Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code). This provision applies to the recovery of personal housing benefits through a cross-reference in Article L823-9 of the Construction and Housing Code. The RSA and the activity bonus have their own write-off provisions (Article L262-46 of the Social Action and Families Code, Article L845-3 of the Social Security Code). Ruling out fraud is not enough to establish all the conditions for a write-off.
“it is for the court to assess whether the debtor's situation justifies a full or partial write-off of the debt in question or whether fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations rule it out” (our translation)
Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-11.044 — family benefits
Statutory maximum penalties, depending on the facts
What you risk for benefit fraud, depending on the classification
The applicable sentence depends on the provision relied on and on the date of the acts. A harsher criminal law does not apply to acts committed before it came into force (Article 112-1 of the Criminal Code). Sentences are individualised under Article 132-1 of the Criminal Code.
2 years
and €30,000: knowingly false or incomplete declaration
3 years
and €45,000: forgery and use of forged documents under Article 441-1
7 years
and €750,000: aggravated benefit fraud (escroquerie)
Maximum penalties under Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code, Article 441-1 of the Criminal Code and Article 313-2 of the Criminal Code; each offence requires its own constituent elements.
Fraud (escroquerie)
An aggravating circumstance linked to the undue benefit
Simple fraud (escroquerie) is punishable by five years' imprisonment and a €375,000 fine (Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code). Point 5° of Article 313-2 of the Criminal Code raises the maximum penalties to seven years and €750,000 where the fraud targets a public body, a social protection body or a body entrusted with a public service mission, in order to obtain an undue allowance, benefit, payment or advantage.
Organised gang
Classification as a serious crime under point 5°
Since 27 June 2026, fraud under point 5° committed by an organised gang (bande organisée) has been punishable by fifteen years' criminal imprisonment (réclusion criminelle) and a fine of one million euros (Article 313-2 of the Criminal Code). An organised gang is a group or an agreement formed to prepare offences, the preparation being shown by material acts (Article 132-71 of the Criminal Code). The involvement of several people is not enough to dispense with this proof. This form of fraud is a serious crime and does not follow the procedure described here for offences (délits).
Inaccurate attestation
The specific provision must also be examined
Article 441-7 of the Criminal Code provides for one year and €15,000 for materially inaccurate attestations or certificates, their falsification or their use. The maximum penalties are three years and €45,000, in particular where the acts are intended to harm the Public Treasury or another person's assets. The nature of the document and the circumstances must be identified.
Administrative penalty
Seriousness, good faith, fraud and repeat breaches
Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code sets an ordinary cap of four times the monthly social security ceiling, tripled for a repeat breach (récidive) within the period set by regulation. If intent to defraud is established, the minimum is one thirtieth of the ceiling and the maximum eight times the ceiling; for an organised gang, the cap rises to sixteen times the ceiling. Inaccurate declarations or undeclared changes under points 1° and 2° escape the penalty where the person acted in good faith.
Overpayment and handling costs
Distinguishing repayment from sanction
A handling-costs charge (indemnité de frais de gestion) of 10% of the benefits wrongly paid is provided for where the overpayment results from fraud, for family benefits, the RSA and the activity bonus (Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code, Article L262-46 of the Social Action and Families Code, Article L845-3 of the Social Security Code). It must not be confused with the administrative penalty or with the late-payment surcharge on that penalty.
For penalties, the court's review covers in particular whether the facts occurred, their classification, their seriousness and the proportionality of the amount (Cass. 2e civ., 15 February 2018, No. 17-12.966). The judgment concerned an agricultural social insurance fund (caisse de mutualité sociale agricole) and does not allow intent to defraud to be required for every administrative breach.
Procedure and useful documents
Preparing a welfare fraud defence, step by step
The firm checks the declarations against the supporting documents and distinguishes between challenging the debt, challenging the sanction and the criminal defence.
The notice
Identify the benefit, the reason, the period, the amount and the date of receipt. Appeals against the overpayment and against the penalty are separate (Article L142-4 of the Social Security Code).
The response
Gather the declarations and supporting documents. Ask for the third-party documents used by the CAF under the conditions of Article L114-21 of the Social Security Code. Prepare observations on the penalty (Article R114-11 of the Social Security Code).
A possible criminal complaint
Above the threshold set by regulation, the CAF must file a criminal complaint, unless the official report (procès-verbal) is sent directly to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République) (Article L114-9 of the Social Security Code). The prosecutor decides what follows: prosecution, an alternative to prosecution or dropping the case (classement sans suite) (Article 40-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure (Code de procédure pénale)).
The interview
In a voluntary interview (audition libre), the suspect has in particular the right to remain silent and, for a serious crime or an offence punishable by imprisonment, the right to be assisted by a lawyer (Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In police custody (garde à vue), see Article 63-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Article 63-3-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. An interview does not necessarily mean that a trial will follow.
The judgment and the appeal
For a judgment of the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel) given after adversarial proceedings, the time limit for appeal is in principle ten days from the delivery of the judgment, with the exceptions set out in Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Where only the defendant appeals, their position cannot be made worse (Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
- Overpayment notice, penalty decision and proof of receipt.
- Audit report, if available, and third-party documents disclosed.
- History of declarations and acknowledgements of submission to the CAF.
- Benefit statements and records of deductions already made.
- Proof of income, housing and family situation for each period.
- Summons, judgment and service document (acte de signification), if you have received them.
Limitation periods
Two calculations not to be confused
For family benefits, Article L553-1 of the Social Security Code provides for two years, or five years in the event of fraudulent manoeuvres or a false declaration, with its own rules on interruption. For offences (délits), Article 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure sets a six-year period, which may be interrupted under Article 9-2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The deferred starting point provided for by Article 9-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires an inherently hidden or deliberately concealed offence (infraction occulte ou dissimulée) that meets its definition, not merely the late discovery of an overpayment. The serious-crime form of benefit fraud is subject to the limitation period for serious crimes in Article 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, not to the period for lesser offences.
Your questions
CAF fraud: frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a CAF overpayment and fraud?
An overpayment (trop-perçu) is a benefit paid without entitlement; recovering it does not necessarily imply a criminal offence. For family benefits, Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code governs repayment and allows a write-off on grounds of financial hardship, except in cases of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations. Good faith alone is therefore not enough to cancel a debt that has been correctly calculated.
The criminal offence of false declaration, by contrast, requires a declaration made knowingly in order to obtain an undue advantage, for oneself or for someone else (Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code). For the administrative penalty, Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code distinguishes between types of breach and rules out the penalty for inaccurate declarations or undeclared changes under points 1° and 2° where the person acted in good faith. The firm checks separately the entitlement to the benefit, the content of the declarations and the evidence relied on to allege fraud.
How does a CAF audit work and how should you respond?
The checks are carried out by sworn and approved inspectors; their findings stand unless proven otherwise (Article L114-10 of the Social Security Code). Gather the supporting documents requested, explain precisely why any document is missing and keep a copy of your response. Certain acts or omissions intended to obstruct an audit can be penalised, if the request was necessary for the audit (Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code).
When the CAF uses information obtained from third parties through its right to obtain information (droit de communication), it must state the content and source of that information. You can ask for a copy of the documents used before the benefit is recovered or withdrawn (Article L114-21 of the Social Security Code). The firm compares these documents with your declarations and the periods audited. A response to an administrative audit is prepared separately from a police interview.
What criminal penalties can you face for CAF fraud?
The maximum penalties depend on the offence: two years' imprisonment and €30,000 for a knowingly false or incomplete declaration made to obtain an undue advantage (Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code); three years and €45,000 for forgery and use of forged documents meeting the conditions of Article 441-1 of the Criminal Code; seven years and €750,000 for aggravated benefit fraud (escroquerie) under point 5° of Article 313-2 of the Criminal Code.
Since 27 June 2026, this last form of fraud, when committed by an organised gang, has been punishable by fifteen years' criminal imprisonment (réclusion criminelle) and a fine of one million euros. This aggravation requires an organised gang and does not apply retroactively to earlier acts (Article 112-1 of the Criminal Code). These are statutory maximums: the court individualises the sentence according to the facts and the offender's personality and situation (Article 132-1 of the Criminal Code).
Is not declaring that you live as a couple considered fraud?
Failing to declare a change of circumstances may give rise to the administrative penalty provided for by Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code, except in the case of good faith under point 2°. The conditions for the benefit and the actual effect of the family situation on the sums paid must still be checked.
Under criminal law, Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code requires a false or incomplete declaration made knowingly. The Court of Cassation quashed an appeal ruling that equated a mere failure to report a change in living circumstances with such a declaration (Cass. crim., 26 November 2024, No. 23-81.498). This does not mean that an undeclared couple relationship never has consequences: declarations that were actually completed may also be in the file. The defence goes back over the forms, their dates, the answers given and the benefits concerned, without confusing a later omission with a declaration that was false from the outset.
Can the CAF file a criminal complaint against me?
Yes. Article L114-9 of the Social Security Code even requires these bodies to file a criminal complaint when a fraud exceeds the threshold set by regulation. They are released from this obligation if an official report (procès-verbal) recording the fraud has been sent directly to the public prosecutor; they then join the proceedings as a civil party (partie civile). The provision also exempts them from paying a deposit (consignation) in the cases it specifies.
Filing a complaint does not automatically lead to a conviction or to a hearing. The public prosecutor decides what follows: prosecution, an alternative to prosecution or dropping the case, under the conditions of Article 40-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Have ready the declarations sent to the CAF, the audit letters and the supporting documents for the period. If a summons arrives, send it to the firm with the CAF's decisions so that the administrative and criminal aspects can be examined together.
I have been summoned to the police station for CAF fraud: what should I do?
Send the summons and state whether it mentions a voluntary interview (audition libre). In that setting, the suspect is informed in particular of the legal classification and the presumed date and place of the offence, of the right to leave the premises and of the right to answer questions or to remain silent. For a serious crime or an offence punishable by imprisonment, the suspect is entitled to the assistance of a lawyer (Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Prepare a chronology based on the forms actually sent, the CAF's requests and the supporting documents from the time. Avoid reconstructing from memory amounts or dates that the documents can verify. In police custody (garde à vue), the right to silence and the assistance of a lawyer are governed by Article 63-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Article 63-3-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The person informed of the custody may appoint a lawyer, but the appointment must be confirmed by the person in custody.
False declaration or fraud (escroquerie): what is the difference?
The false declaration offence under Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code requires a knowingly false or incomplete declaration made to obtain, or attempt to obtain, an undue advantage. Fraud (escroquerie) requires one of the methods listed in Article 313-1 of the Criminal Code, a deception that brings about the handover of funds, and a loss. Intent is also governed by Article 121-3 of the Criminal Code.
In an investment case unrelated to CAF benefits, the Court of Cassation quashed a conviction that gave insufficient reasons on the manoeuvres: “without further establishing fraudulent manoeuvres, prior to the handover of the funds, capable of lending weight and credibility to the defendants' lies” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 16 September 2026, No. 25-83.924). This judgment sheds light on that general requirement; it does not automatically classify a CAF form. The method relied on, its role in the payments and the evidence establishing it must be identified.
Can a CAF penalty be combined with a criminal conviction?
Combining them is not ruled out in principle. In a decision declining to refer a question for a priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality (QPC) to the Constitutional Council, the Court of Cassation accepted that the acts sanctioned by Article L114-17 of the Social Security Code and Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code may give rise to sanctions of a different nature. It recalled that the overall amount of the sanctions is subject to review and must not exceed the highest amount provided for by these provisions (Cass. 2e civ., 18 January 2024, No. 23-12.483). This decision concerns the versions in force at the time; it does not remove the need to examine the provisions and caps applicable to the facts.
The RSA has its own specific system: Article L262-52 of the Social Action and Families Code rules out the administrative fine after a final criminal conviction for the same acts and provides for the administrative fine to be deducted from any subsequent criminal fine. This provision also rules out combining it with the L. 114-17 penalty for the same acts.
How do you challenge a CAF financial penalty?
First check whether it is a proposed penalty or the final decision. At the preliminary stage, Article R114-11 of the Social Security Code allows one month to ask for a hearing or to submit observations. Once the penalty has been notified, the appeal is brought directly before the specially designated judicial court (Article L114-17-2 of the Social Security Code); the mandatory amicable appeal under Article L142-4 of the Social Security Code is expressly excluded for this decision. The time limit for bringing proceedings is in principle two months, subject to the notification conditions of Article R142-1-A of the Social Security Code.
The challenge may concern the facts, the classification, good faith where the provision allows for it, the amount and the procedure. The Court of Cassation requires the court to review whether the facts occurred, how serious they are and whether the penalty is appropriate (Cass. 2e civ., 15 February 2018, No. 17-12.966). Keep the decision and proof of when you received it.
Can a CAF debt be written off in a fraud case?
For family benefits, Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code allows a write-off in cases of financial hardship, but rules it out in cases of fraudulent manoeuvres or false declarations. This provision applies to the recovery of personal housing benefits through a cross-reference in Article L823-9 of the Construction and Housing Code. For the RSA and the activity bonus, the provisions allow a write-off for good faith or financial hardship, with their own exclusion in cases of fraud or false declarations (Article L262-46 of the Social Action and Families Code, Article L845-3 of the Social Security Code).
Challenging the fraud classification therefore does not automatically give a right to a write-off. The conditions of the applicable provision must still be established. For family benefits, the Court of Cassation recognises that the court hearing a challenge to a refusal has the power to assess the debtor's situation and the exclusion linked to fraud (Cass. 2e civ., 24 June 2021, No. 20-11.044). A write-off is distinct from challenging the existence or the calculation of the debt.
How long do the CAF and the prosecutor have to take action?
For family benefits, Article L553-1 of the Social Security Code allows two years to recover an overpayment, or five years in the event of fraudulent manoeuvres or a false declaration. This rule must not be extended to other benefits without examination. The RSA administrative fine cannot cover acts dating back more than two years (Article L262-52 of the Social Action and Families Code).
Under criminal law, the ordinary limitation period for offences (délits) is six years (Article 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The deferred starting point for an inherently hidden or deliberately concealed offence requires the conditions of Article 9-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and is capped by a long-stop of twelve years from the acts for offences, without prejudice to the rules on interruption. In a false invoices case unrelated to the CAF, the Court of Cassation accepted that “fraud may be classified as concealed within the meaning of Article 9-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, if the conditions are met” (our translation) (Cass. crim., 25 March 2026, No. 24-80.607). The serious-crime form falls under Article 7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The calculation requires the dates and the procedural steps.
I have been convicted of CAF fraud: how do I appeal?
For a criminal court judgment given after adversarial proceedings, Article 498 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in principle sets the time limit for appeal at ten days from the delivery of the judgment. The provision sets out cases in which the time limit runs from formal service (signification), depending in particular on whether the defendant was present or represented and was informed of the delivery date. Send the judgment and any service document immediately: knowing only the date on which you found out about the decision is not enough to calculate the time limit.
Where only the defendant appeals, the court of appeal cannot make their position worse. An appeal by the prosecution (ministère public), on the other hand, allows the court to rule either in the defendant's favour or against them (Article 515 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The firm examines the classification, the evidence, the amount found and the sentence. Assistance by the defence lawyer of one's choice is provided for by Article 417 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This guidance concerns appeals against judgments of the criminal court for offences, not convictions for a serious crime.
Does a criminal acquittal cancel the debt to the CAF?
The debt, the sanction and the exact grounds of the judgment must be distinguished. Recovery of an overpayment of family benefits rests on the absence of entitlement to the sum paid (Article L553-2 of the Social Security Code). An acquittal (relaxe) on a false declaration charge therefore does not, in itself, show that all the benefits were due. In particular, an omission may not amount to the declaration required by Article 441-6 of the Criminal Code, while still calling for a separate administrative examination (Cass. crim., 26 November 2024, No. 23-81.498).
For the RSA administrative fine, Article L262-52 of the Social Action and Families Code expressly governs the effect of a final dismissal (non-lieu) or acquittal declaring that the offence is not established or cannot be attributed to the person: the fine is barred or must be reviewed as of right. This rule concerns the fine, not the automatic cancellation of the overpayment. Send the full judgment and the CAF's notices so that the facts and the legal grounds relied on can be compared.
What are the fees for a CAF fraud defence?
Fees are agreed with the client according to the assignment and the work planned. Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971 requires a written fee agreement, subject to the exceptions it sets out, in particular for urgency, force majeure and certain work carried out under legal aid. The agreement specifies the amount of the fees or how they are calculated, as well as the expected costs and disbursements.
To define the assignment, the firm needs to know whether you want a response to the audit, an appeal against the overpayment, a challenge to a penalty or a criminal defence. These steps may be separate and may require different documents. Send the letters you have received and state any deadlines you know of. The firm can specify the scope of its work before you commit; this page sets no rates and does not prejudge the outcome of the case.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Texts checked in the version applicable on 13 October 2026, with their applicability verified on 15 October 2026. For older facts, the applicable version must be determined separately.
The decisions cited can be accessed through their links in the text. Judgments concerning an earlier version of a provision or a related area are presented with that clarification.
Further reading
Page updated on 15 October 2026.
Facing a CAF audit or an accusation of CAF fraud?
Send the notice, the declarations and the supporting documents you have. The firm examines the classification, the calculation of the sums claimed and the procedure to follow.