Kohen Avocats — Real estate law
Indecent housing lawyer in Paris: repairs, rent, compensation
Damp, mould, faulty heating, insufficient floor area, a home rated G: as an indecent housing lawyer in Paris, the firm acts for tenants and landlords in housing decency disputes (logement indécent) in Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France).
Defects in your home? Report them in writing and keep evidence of when they appeared and how long they have lasted: compensation can cover the loss established before the report.
Indecent housing · Paris
Prove and obtain
Send the lease, the check-in inventory (état des lieux) and the evidence of the defects to our real estate law firm in Paris for a first analysis.
9 m²
and 2.20 m, or 20 m³
for a main room
Kohen Avocats, Paris 16
Your indecent housing case
Indecent housing · Paris 16th
Obtain repairs and compensation
- Paris Bar
- Real estate law
- Paris and Île-de-France
- Tenants and landlords
The landlord must provide decent housing that shows no obvious risk to safety or health, has no pest infestation, meeting a minimum level of energy performance and fitted with what makes it suitable for residential use (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989). Damp and mould, faulty heating, a room that is too small, a home rated G: each defect is linked to a specific criterion.
The firm assists tenants seeking compliance works, a rent reduction or compensation, and landlords disputing the alleged indecency or the withholding of housing benefit. The review starts with the lease, the check-in inventory, the reports made and the technical reports. Call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45 or send these documents through the form for a first written analysis.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB)Office at 10 avenue du Colonel Bonnet, 75016 Paris
Establish the defects
Link each defect to a decency criterion and prove it: reports, photographs, bailiff's report, public health services.
Obtain compliance works
Ask the landlord for the works, then the judge, with a reduction or suspension of the rent.
Obtain compensation
Quantify the proven loss of enjoyment, including the period before the first report, within the limitation period.
The decency criteria
What makes a home indecent
The characteristics of decent housing are set by the Decree of 30 January 2002. They cover safety and health, equipment and floor area, to which the law adds energy performance (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
9 m² and 2.20 m
or 20 m³ for a main room, under the decree
9 m²
minimum for a single room let separately in Paris
Class F
the lowest rating allowed for the leases concerned since 2025
Safety and health
Weathertight, roofed, ventilated
The home is weathertight and roofed (clos et couvert), protected against water and air infiltration, its materials present no obvious risk, its electricity and gas networks and connections and its heating and hot water equipment meet safety standards and are in good working order, and it allows adequate ventilation and the removal of damp (Article 2 of the Decree of 30 January 2002).
Equipment
Heating, water, kitchen, sanitary facilities
It must include, in particular, a heating installation for normal heating, drinking water, a kitchen or kitchen area with a sink supplied with hot and cold water, in principle an indoor sanitary installation with a WC and a shower or bath, and an adequate electrical network. A one-room home may have only an outside WC, located in the same building and easily accessible (Article 3 of the Decree of 30 January 2002).
Floor area
A minimum main room
Under the decree, at least one main room must offer either 9 m² of living space with a ceiling height of 2.20 m, or 20 m³ of living volume (Article 4 of the Decree of 30 January 2002). In Paris, the public health regulations (règlement sanitaire) also require a one-room home or a single room let separately to measure at least 9 m², with a ceiling height of 2.20 m (Article 40 of the Paris public health regulations). In a flatshare under multiple leases, the private rooms must reach both 9 m² and 20 m³ (Article 8-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989), without adding a share of the common areas (Cass. 3e civ., 1 October 2026, No. 25-15.395).
Energy
Energy performance classes
Since 1 January 2025, a decent home must be rated between A and F; from 2028, between A and E; and from 2034, between A and D (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989). For a current lease, check the date it was signed, renewed or tacitly extended, and obtain a valid energy performance certificate (DPE), where applicable with the certificate updating its rating. This timetable applies to mainland France.
The tenant's remedies
Compliance works, rent and compensation
The tenant may ask the owner to bring the home into compliance, without calling the lease into question. If there is no agreement or no reply within two months, the departmental conciliation committee (commission départementale de conciliation) may be referred to, although this is not a mandatory step before going to court (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
Reporting the defects
The tenant reports the defects to the landlord in writing, with photographs and dates. The city's public health services can also record the condition of the home. The report serves as evidence; it does not, on its own, set the starting point of compensation.
The request for compliance works
A registered letter asks for the works, citing the decency criteria that are not met; keep the proof of receipt. Notice sent to the landlord by the CAF (family benefits office) counts as this request. The two-month period opens the way to the committee; it does not prevent going to court.
Conciliation
The departmental conciliation committee may issue an opinion. Referral to it remains optional; other requirements to attempt an amicable settlement may apply depending on the nature and amount of the claim.
The judge
The judge determines the nature of the works and the time allowed for them. The judge may reduce the rent or suspend, with or without payment into a deposit account, its payment and the term of the lease until the works are completed (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
“ An owner who fails in the obligations to provide decent housing and to maintain it may be ordered to pay the tenants damages to compensate their loss of enjoyment ” (our translation)
TJ Paris, JCP, 19 May 2026, No. 25/02036
In that case, an expert report established damp and mould in every room, caused by inoperative ventilation and poor insulation. The court found the home indecent and awarded €17,278.80 for loss of enjoyment, set off against the rent arrears. This amount reflects the claims and the period accepted in that case; it is not a scale. The evidence had been built up document by document, from the first report to the expert report.
Rent, benefits and sanctions
Should you keep paying the rent?
In principle, yes. Alleged indecency does not, on its own, allow the tenant to stop paying: the tenant risks debt proceedings and termination of the lease. A rent reduction or suspension must be requested from the judge (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989), unless a specific statutory regime applies. Withholding performance (exception d'inexécution) remains exceptional and is exercised at the tenant's own risk, subject to review by the judge.
“ The lessee may raise the defence of non-performance against a formal demand to pay the rent only where it is totally impossible to use the premises, because they are uninhabitable or unfit for their purpose ” (our translation)
CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 3, 5 December 2024, No. 22/16878
Housing benefit
Withheld by the CAF
When the paying body finds that the home is not decent, it withholds the housing benefit (family or social housing allowance) for up to eighteen months, subject to six-month extensions provided for by the texts (Article R. 843-2 of the French Construction and Housing Code (Code de la construction et de l'habitation)); the tenant pays the rent and charges minus the benefit, and this reduction cannot ground a claim for termination of the lease (Article L. 843-1 of the Construction and Housing Code). The landlord may only demand this reduced amount from the tenant (Cass. 3e civ., 14 December 2023, No. 22-23.267; Cass. 3e civ., 16 April 2026, No. 25-10.188). The withheld benefit is paid to the landlord only once the body has recorded that the home has been brought into compliance (Article R. 843-4 of the Construction and Housing Code); the landlord cannot pass the sums lost on to the tenant. A challenge to the withholding decision follows a separate administrative route, after an appeal to the paying body.
Unfit housing
An order that suspends the rent
When the home is subject to a safety order or an order to remedy unfit conditions (arrêté de mise en sécurité ou de traitement de l'insalubrité), the basic rent, or the occupancy charge, ceases to be due from the first day of the month following the sending of notice of the order or its posting at the town hall and on the façade, until the first day of the month following the sending of notice or the posting of the order lifting it, save for the exceptions provided for by the text (Article L. 521-2 of the Construction and Housing Code). Service charges are checked separately. Sums unduly received are refunded or deducted from the rent that becomes due again. The order does not, on its own, terminate the lease.
The landlord
Disputing the alleged indecency
The landlord may show a cause attributable to the tenant, argue that the defects fall within the tenant's routine maintenance and dispute the reality of the loss. A mere allegation of inadequate ventilation is not enough: the working of the ventilation systems and the technical causes must be checked. In the case decided in December 2024 by the Paris Court of Appeal, the older documents did not prove indecency before the termination of the lease.
Documents to send to the firm
- Lease, check-in inventory, valid energy performance certificate (DPE) and, where applicable, the certificate updating its rating.
- Letters and emails reporting the defects to the landlord, with their dates.
- Dated photographs, contractor or expert reports.
- Public health services report, municipal or prefectoral order, with its notice or proof of its posting.
- Letters from the CAF on the withholding of the benefit.
- Evidence of the costs and losses incurred: health, rehousing, damaged belongings.
Frequently asked questions
Your questions on indecent housing
What is indecent housing in France?
A home that does not meet the characteristics set by the law and the Decree of 30 January 2002: an obvious risk to safety or health, pest infestation, lack of essential equipment, no main room offering 9 m² with a ceiling height of 2.20 m or 20 m³, or insufficient energy performance (Article 6 of the Law of 6 July 1989; Articles 2 to 4 of the Decree of 30 January 2002).
In mainland France, a home rated G is no longer decent for leases signed, renewed or tacitly extended since 1 January 2025; from 2028, class F will be excluded in turn. The rating is checked on a valid energy performance certificate (DPE).
What should I do if my rented home is indecent?
Report the defects to the landlord in writing, then ask them to bring the home into compliance. Keep the proof of receipt. If there is no agreement or no reply within two months, the departmental conciliation committee may be referred to; its opinion is not a prerequisite for going to court (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989). An urgent situation or a claim for compensation is assessed separately.
The judge sets the works and the time allowed for them, and may reduce the rent or suspend its payment until the works are done. Build your evidence file without delay: dated photographs, reports, public health services. Report the defects in writing and keep evidence of when they appeared and how long they have lasted.
Can I stop paying rent for an indecent home in France?
Alleged indecency is not enough, on its own, to stop paying. The Paris Court of Appeal points out that the defence of non-performance can only be raised where it is totally impossible to use the premises, because they are uninhabitable or unfit for their purpose (CA Paris, 5 December 2024, No. 22/16878). This defence remains exceptional and is exercised subject to review by the judge; otherwise, the tenant risks proceedings for unpaid rent.
A suspension or reduction of the rent must be requested from the judge (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989). By contrast, a safety order or an order to remedy unfit conditions stops the basic rent automatically, from the first day of the month following the sending of its notice or its posting, under the rules of Article L. 521-2 of the Construction and Housing Code.
What compensation can I get for indecent housing?
A landlord who fails in the obligation to provide and maintain decent housing may be ordered to compensate the loss of enjoyment (TJ Paris, 19 May 2026, No. 25/02036). In that case of widespread damp, the court awarded €17,278.80.
The amount depends on the defects, their proven duration and the losses established: health, damaged belongings, costs. Compensation can cover the loss suffered before the first report; the period that can be compensated is checked against the three-year limitation period for actions arising from the lease (Article 7-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989). There is no scale: each item must be substantiated.
Can the CAF withhold housing benefit because the home is not decent?
This mechanism concerns the family or social housing allowance (allocation de logement familiale ou sociale), which is distinct from the APL. When it finds that the home is not decent, the CAF withholds the allowance for up to eighteen months, subject to six-month extensions provided for by the texts (Article R. 843-2 of the Construction and Housing Code); the tenant pays the rent and charges minus the allowance, with no risk of termination on that ground (Article L. 843-1 of the Construction and Housing Code).
The Cour de cassation (French supreme court) holds that the landlord may then only demand from the tenant the rent minus the allowance (Cass. 3e civ., 14 December 2023, No. 22-23.267). The withheld allowance is paid to the landlord only once the body has recorded that the home has been brought into compliance (Article R. 843-4 of the Construction and Housing Code); failing that, the landlord cannot pass the lost sums on to the tenant. A challenge to the CAF's decision follows a separate administrative route, with a prior appeal to the paying body.
Is a room under 9 m² indecent housing?
Under the decree, at least one main room must offer either 9 m² of living space with a ceiling height of 2.20 m, or 20 m³ of living volume (Article 4 of the Decree of 30 January 2002). In Paris, a single room let separately must also comply with the public health regulations, which require at least 9 m² and a ceiling height of 2.20 m (Article 40 of the Paris public health regulations): a volume of 20 m³ is not enough, on its own, to set these requirements aside.
In a flatshare under multiple leases, the private rooms must reach at least 9 m² and 20 m³ (Article 8-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989), without adding a share of the common areas (Cass. 3e civ., 1 October 2026, No. 25-15.395). Indecency does not automatically lead to termination of the lease: the same decision points out that the seriousness of the breach is assessed case by case.
Can the landlord dispute the indecency?
Yes. The landlord may show a cause attributable to the tenant, argue that the defects fall within the tenant's routine maintenance or that the findings are insufficient; a mere allegation of inadequate ventilation is not enough. In a case decided by the Paris Court of Appeal, the older documents were not enough to establish indecency before the termination of the lease, as the serious defects recorded later were not proven for the earlier period (CA Paris, 5 December 2024, No. 22/16878).
For energy works, the judge cannot order them if the co-owner shows the steps taken to have the common works considered and the completion of suitable private works without being able to reach the required level, or if architectural or heritage constraints prevent it despite compatible works (Article 20-1 of the Law of 6 July 1989). The other measures, in particular on the rent, remain available.
How much does an indecent housing lawyer cost in France?
Fees are set by a written agreement, save for the exceptions provided for by law, in particular full legal aid (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971). They depend on the procedure: formal notice, referral to the judge, expert assessment, defence of the landlord.
The firm offers a first written analysis for €80 incl. VAT based on the documents sent through the form. It sets out the criteria at stake, the remedies and the possible next steps. No court outcome can be guaranteed.
Sources and related pages
Official texts and related pages
Main texts cited, checked in their version in force on 21 October 2026: Law of 6 July 1989, Decree No. 2002-120 of 30 January 2002 and the Construction and Housing Code.
Further reading
Page updated on 21 October 2026. The applicable rules should be checked again as at the date of your situation.
An indecent home?
Contact the firm. Send the lease, the check-in inventory, the reports made and any reports on the condition of the home.