KOHEN AVOCATS FIRM · PARIS 16
My American Mother Died Owning a House in France: French Succession Tax, the 1978 Estate Tax Treaty Credit, and the Notaire Paper Trail

Hassan KOHEN acts in urgent matters, from the police station to the assize court. Initial strategic analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation – Judilibre and Légifrance open data

Paris Bar Police custody, investigation, assize court CNB listing avocat.fr
Maître Hassan KOHEN, avocat au Barreau de Paris
Hassan KOHEN
Attorney at the Paris Bar

My American Mother Died Owning a House in France: French Succession Tax, the 1978 Estate Tax Treaty Credit, and the Notaire Paper Trail

Speak to a lawyer 06 89 11 34 45

Your mother lived in Ohio all her life, filed her taxes in Cleveland every April, and voted in every presidential election. Twenty years ago she bought a small stone house near Sarlat, in the Dordogne, where she spent every summer and where your family scattered half its memories. Now she has died, and two countries want a share of that house. The French notaire — the public officer who alone can transfer French real estate after a death — tells you a French estate return must be filed and French succession tax may be due. Your American accountant tells you the house must also be listed on the United States estate tax return. Both are right, and neither bill cancels the other automatically. The good news is that a bilateral treaty signed in Washington nearly fifty years ago was written for exactly this situation: France taxes the French house first, and the Internal Revenue Service then gives you a dollar-for-dollar credit for the French tax so the same value is not taxed twice. The bad news is that the credit is not automatic, the deadlines on the two sides of the Atlantic do not match, and the person who inherits under your mother’s Ohio will is not necessarily the person French law designates. This article walks through the whole path in order: what France taxes and how much, which law decides who gets the house, how the 1978 estate tax treaty credit works in practice, and the exact paper trail — with both deadlines — that closes the file in both countries.

I. What France taxes when a United States resident dies owning French real estate

A. French succession tax reaches the French house even if everyone lives in America

The first surprise for most American families is that French succession tax (droits de succession) does not care where the deceased lived, where the heirs live, or where the will was signed. It cares where the property sits. Article 750 ter of the French General Tax Code (Code général des impôts) provides that, where the deceased was not domiciled in France for tax purposes, the tax still catches “Les biens meubles et immeubles, que ces derniers soient possédés directement ou indirectement, situés en France” — movable and immovable property, held directly or indirectly, located in France — “lorsque le donateur ou le défunt n’a pas son domicile fiscal en France”. A house in the Dordogne owned outright by an Ohio resident therefore falls squarely inside the French tax net, even if every heir is American and the probate runs in Ohio. Note the words “directly or indirectly”: if your mother held the house through a French property company (société civile immobilière, or SCI), the shares are treated as French real estate all the same, and the same article extends the net to bank accounts, securities, and receivables located in France. Only the treaty, examined in Part II, can soften this territorial claim — it never removes it.

The second surprise is the rate scale, because France taxes each heir separately on his or her net share, and the scale climbs fast. Article 777 of the same Code sets the direct-line scale (parents to children) from 5 percent on the slice below 8,072 euros up to 20 percent on the slice between 15,932 and 552,324 euros, then 30, 40, and 45 percent above. Between siblings the scale is 35 percent below 24,430 euros and 45 percent above; between distant relatives it is 55 percent, and between non-relatives 60 percent. Before applying those rates, each heir deducts a personal allowance (abattement): article 779 grants “un abattement de 100 000 € sur la part de chacun des ascendants et sur la part de chacun des enfants vivants ou représentés par suite de prédécès ou de renonciation” — 100,000 euros off the share of each living or represented child. Take a concrete example. Your mother leaves a house worth 450,000 euros to her two children in equal shares. Each share is 225,000 euros; minus the 100,000-euro allowance, each taxable share is 125,000 euros. The tax per child is roughly 404 euros on the first slice, 404 on the second, 573 on the third, and 21,814 euros at 20 percent on the remainder — about 23,195 euros each, or 46,390 euros for the estate. That is the normal, no-drama case: two children, one house, no prior gifts. Change one fact — a stepchild treated as a non-relative at 60 percent, a sibling heir at 45 percent — and the bill changes completely.

A third trap concerns gifts your mother made during her lifetime. Article 784 requires the parties to disclose in every estate return any prior gifts from the deceased to the heirs, because “La perception est effectuée en ajoutant à la valeur des biens compris dans la donation ou la déclaration de succession celle des biens qui ont fait l’objet de donations antérieures, à l’exception de celles passées depuis plus de quinze ans” — gifts made within the last fifteen years are added back to the estate to compute the tax, a mechanism lawyers call the rappel fiscal. If your mother gave you 80,000 euros five years ago toward a down payment and you now inherit her share of the house, that 80,000 euros comes back into the calculation and can push your share into a higher bracket. Gifts older than fifteen years are ignored. American families often discover this rule with dismay because nothing equivalent exists in the United States federal system, where lifetime gifts and the estate share a single lifetime exemption instead. Tell the notaire about every gift, with dates and amounts: the fifteen-year lookback is one of the first things the tax office checks, and an omission found later carries penalties and interest.

B. Which law decides who inherits the house, and why a United States will may not be enough

Before any tax is computed, someone must establish who owns the house now. That question belongs to succession law, not tax law, and for real estate in France the answer starts in Europe. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, which governs cross-border successions for France, lays down one general rule in Article 21(1): unless the regulation provides otherwise, the whole succession is governed by the law of the country where the deceased was habitually resident at the time of death. Your mother was habitually resident in Ohio, so in principle Ohio law governs her worldwide succession — including the Dordogne house. The regulation also lets a person choose in advance the law of any country of his or her nationality to govern the whole estate (professio juris), which is precisely what a well-drafted American will with a French property clause does; the mechanics of that choice, and the notaire formalities that make it effective, are explained in our succession pillar article, How your American will can elect United States law for your French house. If your mother signed such a clause, the notaire applies the designated American law to the house. If she did not, the notaire determines her habitual residence from the facts — years of life in Ohio, family center, tax residence — and normally lands on Ohio law anyway.

But “Ohio law applies” is not the end of the story, because French law protects children in a way American law does not, and that protection follows French real estate with remarkable stubbornness. The réserve héréditaire — the forced share — is defined by Article 912 of the Civil Code as “la part des biens et droits successoraux dont la loi assure la dévolution libre de charges à certains héritiers dits réservataires, s’ils sont appelés à la succession et s’ils l’acceptent”: the portion of the estate the law guarantees to certain heirs, free of charges, if they accept the succession. Article 913 fixes the fractions: where the deceased leaves one child, lifetime gifts and legacies “ne pourront excéder la moitié des biens du disposant”; with two children they cannot exceed one-third; with three or more, one-quarter. In plain terms, one child is guaranteed half the estate, two children two-thirds, three or more three-quarters. An Ohio will that leaves everything to a second spouse, or that disinherits a child from a first marriage, collides head-on with these fractions when French real estate is involved.

The Cour de cassation has given that collision a clear answer, and American families should read it carefully. In a decision of 4 July 2018 (First Civil Chamber, case numbers 17-16.515 and 17-16.522, published in the Bulletin), the Court approved an appellate ruling holding that the transfer of French immovable property had to respect the forced share, “laquelle, d’ordre public interne, ne pouvait être écartée par des dispositions testamentaires établies selon la loi du domicile du défunt et régissant son statut personnel” — a rule of domestic public policy that could not be set aside by testamentary dispositions made under the law of the deceased’s domicile. Since 2021, Parliament has added a statutory safety net for exactly this situation: where the applicable foreign law gives a child nothing, the child can levy a compensatory claim (prélèvement compensatoire) against French assets. The full mechanics of that claim are set out in our article My American father cut me out of his French house. The practical lesson is simple: if your mother’s will gives the Dordogne house to someone other than her children, or unequally among them, expect the notaire to raise the forced share before any deed is signed — and expect the timetable to stretch while shares are recalculated. A will that looked perfectly valid in Ohio can thus produce a very different division in Sarlat, and the tax computation in Section I.A must then be rerun on the corrected shares.

II. How to pay once instead of twice and close the file on both sides of the Atlantic

A. The 1978 treaty credit: France taxes first, the Internal Revenue Service gives you a credit

The instrument that prevents double taxation is the convention signed in Washington on 24 November 1978 between France and the United States, devoted entirely to estate and gift taxes. The French tax administration’s official commentary presents it as the treaty against double taxation and tax evasion for estate and gift taxes, ratified in France by the statute of 25 June 1980 (Law No. 80-452) and published by Decree No. 80-771 of 24 September 1980, then updated by an amendment signed on 8 December 2004. The heart of the treaty for your case is its Article 12, titled “Exemptions and credits”: each country keeps the right to tax the property situated on its territory, but must grant a credit for the tax the other country has levied on the same property. The administration’s commentary confirms that the amended paragraphs of Article 11 (community property and marital deduction) and Article 12 (exemptions and credits) of the treaty, as amended by the agreement signed on 8 December 2004, apply to estates opened since 10 November 1988. In practice the order of operations is fixed: the French succession tax on the Dordogne house is assessed and paid first, and the United States then credits that French tax against the federal estate tax attributable to the same house.

On the American side, the credit is claimed under Section 2014 of the Internal Revenue Code, which credits the federal estate tax with foreign estate, inheritance, legacy, or succession taxes actually paid on property that is both situated in the foreign country and included in the United States gross estate. Three conditions hide in that one sentence. First, the French tax must have been “actually paid” — a French assessment alone, or a payment plan still running, does not qualify; the notaire’s proof of payment and the French tax receipt are therefore exhibits to the American return, not mere background. Second, the property must be both situated in France and included in the United States gross estate, which is why the Dordogne house must appear on Form 706 even though it sits abroad: property omitted from the gross estate cannot generate a credit. Third, the credit is capped by two proportional limitations — it cannot exceed the share of the French tax attributable to the French property, nor the share of the United States tax attributable to that same property — so where French rates exceed American rates on the same value, the excess French tax is simply lost; no refund comes back from either treasury. And there is a strict clock: under the same section, the credit is allowed only for French taxes actually paid and claimed within four years after the filing of the required estate tax return, with the taxpayer bearing the burden of proof to the satisfaction of the Secretary. Miss that four-year window while the French file drags on, and the credit evaporates.

One honest qualification matters enormously for middle-class families: the credit only helps if there is an American tax to credit against. The federal estate tax applies only above a lifetime exemption measured in millions of dollars (the figure is indexed every year — verify the current IRS amount for the year of death), so an estate consisting of a 450,000-euro house and ordinary savings usually owes zero federal estate tax, and a credit against zero is worth zero. In that common case there is no double taxation to relieve, because only France actually taxes anything — but the house must still be reported correctly, and the French return must still be filed on time. The treaty becomes decisive for larger estates, typically where a Paris apartment, a portfolio, and American assets combine above the exemption, or where the decedent made large taxable lifetime gifts that consumed the exemption early. Two further caveats: several American states impose their own estate or inheritance tax with thresholds far below the federal exemption, and the federal-state interaction follows different rules — check the decedent’s state of domicile separately. And American citizens remain subject to United States estate tax on their worldwide assets wherever they live, which is exactly why the treaty credit, rather than any exemption, is the mechanism that matters. Families sometimes ask whether French succession tax can instead be deducted as an expense: for estate tax purposes the answer is the credit or nothing, so the strategy is to pay France cleanly, document everything, and claim the credit within its window.

B. The notaire paper trail and the two deadlines that control everything

Everything described so far converges on one person: the French notaire. In France, real estate cannot change hands after a death by private agreement or by an American probate order alone; only a notarial deed, published at the land registry (service de la publicité foncière), transfers title. The notaire therefore runs the French side of the file from start to finish. The first deed is the acte de notoriété, which identifies the heirs, states the applicable succession law, records any will or choice-of-law clause, and lists the forced-share calculations from Part I. To draw it up, the notaire will ask for the death certificate with apostille and sworn translation, the will and any codicils, family record documents proving kinship, marriage contracts or divorce decrees, the property title deed (titre de propriété), the last French property tax bills, bank statements, and proof of any lifetime gifts within fifteen years. American families consistently underestimate this gathering phase: order the apostilled documents from the United States before you fly over, because a missing apostille is the single most common cause of delay, and the deadlines below do not wait for paperwork.

The French deadline is set by Article 641 of the General Tax Code: “De six mois, à compter du jour du décès, lorsque celui dont on recueille la succession est décédé en France métropolitaine; D’une année, dans tous les autres cas.” Your mother died in Ohio, so the estate has one year from the date of death to file the French estate return and pay the tax. The public service portal confirms the twelve-month rule for deaths abroad and adds the essential routing instruction — the return goes to the nonresident tax office (service des impôts des particuliers non résidents) — whose valuation guidance is detailed on the companion pages for assessing the estate and computing the tax and for paying succession tax. Late filing triggers interest from the first day and a penalty that grows with the delay, and the notaire cannot publish the transfer deed until the tax office issues its clearance — so a late return freezes the house itself: no sale, no mortgage, no clean rental. If cash is short because the estate is essentially the house, ask early about payment facilities or a staggered schedule rather than letting the deadline pass in silence.

The American deadline is shorter and runs in parallel. The estate tax return, Form 706, is due nine months after the date of death, with an automatic six-month filing extension available by filing Form 4768, as the IRS estate-tax guidance explains. Note the mismatch: the French return may lawfully be filed up to twelve months after death, while the American return is due at nine months — yet the Section 2014 credit requires French tax “actually paid.” The standard solution is to file Form 706 on time, compute the credit on the best available estimate of the French tax, and perfect the claim once the French assessment and payment proof arrive, always inside the four-year credit window. Where the decedent’s executor was appointed by an American court, French banks and the notaire will also want proof of that authority — translated, apostilled, and sometimes backed by a French certificate — and the coordination between the American executor and the French notaire over who signs what, who sells, and who pays which tax is a file in itself, described in our article The American executor, the French notaire, and the taxes on the house. Expect the French bank to freeze your mother’s accounts on notification of death; the release procedure, heirship certificates, and the tax clearance needed to unfreeze funds are covered in My American father died and his French bank froze the account. And if the family decides to sell the Dordogne house rather than keep it, the capital-gains computation, the treaty credit on the gain, and the closing mechanics are a separate chapter: Selling the French house from America.

Conclusion

A French house in an American estate is not a tragedy and not a windfall for either treasury — it is a procedure with a fixed order. French tax law claims the house because it sits in France, whatever passports the family holds; European conflicts rules and the forced share decide who actually receives it, and an Ohio will covers the house only if it was drafted with France in mind; the 1978 treaty then ensures the same value is not taxed twice by crediting the French tax against the American estate tax; and the notaire’s paper trail, filed within one year in France and nine months in America, is what turns those principles into a transfer deed and two closed files. Start with the documents, respect the shorter American deadline first, pay France cleanly, and claim the credit with proof in hand. Handled in that order, your mother’s summer house becomes what she intended it to be: a family asset with a clear title, not a two-country dispute.

📄 Official circular