
Your obligation alimentaire lawyer in Paris: elderly parents and EHPAD
Parent in an EHPAD Département questionnaire Release for serious failings Split between children
First written analysis80 € incl. VAT
Describe your situation and attach your documents.Your written analysis within 24 working hours.
Or call the firm on +33 6 89 11 34 45
Kohen Avocats, family law
A parent moves into a care home (EHPAD) and the département (the local authority) sends a questionnaire to each of their children; an elderly father claims maintenance from children he did not bring up; a sister has been paying alone for years. The duty to support a parent or other ascendant (obligation alimentaire) depends on the needs of the person claiming support and the means of the person liable, and the family court judge (JAF) decides when there is no agreement. These are the situations an obligation alimentaire lawyer in Paris handles.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar — family law.
Official listing in the national directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (over 250 reviews)
Page updated on 10 October 2026.
Need comes first
Maintenance is granted only in proportion to the need of the person claiming it and the wealth of the person who owes it (Article 208 of the French Civil Code).
A release is possible
Where the parent has seriously failed in their obligations towards the child, the judge may release the child from all or part of the debt (Article 207).
Each according to their means
For a parent receiving assistance from the département, failing agreement, each liable person's share is set by the judge for the parent's place of residence (Article R. 132-9 of the French Social Action and Families Code, CASF).
Quick answer
An obligation alimentaire lawyer steps in when a parent, parent-in-law or grandparent is in need and the family, the département or the care home asks for a contribution. Children owe maintenance to their father and mother and other ascendants in need (Article 205 of the Civil Code), sons-in-law and daughters-in-law to their parents-in-law (Article 206), in proportion to need and resources (Article 208). The family court judge sets each person's share, may release a child from supporting a parent who seriously failed in their obligations (Article 207) and may reduce or end the maintenance if circumstances change (Article 209). Kohen Avocats advises and defends parents, children and in-laws in Paris and the Paris region (Île-de-France). In confidence, on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Understanding your situation
The obligation alimentaire towards parents, explained
The duty of support between ascendants, descendants and in-laws (obligation alimentaire), France's counterpart to filial responsibility laws, is governed by Articles 205 et seq. of the Civil Code: it requires need on the part of the person claiming and resources on the part of the person who owes, and it gives way to the claimant's serious failings. Everything you need to understand.
The framework
The obligation alimentaire towards parents and in-laws
What Articles 205 to 211 of the Civil Code provide.
Children owe maintenance to their father and mother or other ascendants who are in need, and the obligation is reciprocal.
Sons-in-law and daughters-in-law owe it to their father-in-law and mother-in-law, until the death of the spouse through whom the relationship by marriage arose and of the children of that union.
The amount is set in proportion to the creditor's need and the debtor's wealth; the judge may attach an indexation clause to it.
Release or reduction may be sought when one can no longer pay or the other no longer needs all or part of the maintenance.
If the debtor shows that they cannot pay maintenance, the family court judge may order them to take in, feed and support in their home the parent to whom they owe maintenance (Article 210 of the Civil Code). A person adopted by simple adoption owes maintenance to the adopter in need (Article 364). The contribution to a child's upkeep follows different rules, set out on our page on child maintenance (pension alimentaire).
What to watch
What the judge examines
The need, the resources, and the parent's past conduct.
On the side of the parent claiming maintenance
- The actual cost of accommodation or upkeep.
- Their income and assets, which measure the need.
- The steps taken to claim maintenance, on which any arrears depend.
On the side of the child who owes maintenance
- Their income and the actual outgoings of their household.
- The parent's serious failings towards them.
- The exemptions provided for by the Social Action and Families Code.
The firm's advice: answer the département's questionnaire with complete, up-to-date documents, and raise the parent's serious failings or a statutory exemption at that stage. The administrative decision can be revised on production of a court decision limiting the maintenance obligation to a lower amount (Article L. 132-6 of the CASF).
The points to establish before any hearing:
How we support you
How the firm supports you
From the département's questionnaire to the judgment.
Review of your documents
Letter from the département or the care home, invoices, income, family history: a written note before you commit.
Written position
Reasoned reply to the département or the care home, proposed split between brothers and sisters.
Hearing before the judge
Writ of summons or application, acting for the maintenance creditor or debtor, request for release where the facts justify it.
Enforcement and review
Monitoring of payments, application for review when resources or needs change.
The firm offers a first analysis appointment at the price of a consultation, followed by a written fixed-fee quote; the strategy is provided before you commit, with no promise of outcome.
Timeline
From the social assistance application to the judge's decision
The most common path, when a parent moves into a care home.
Social assistance application
The parent provides a list, by name, of the family members liable for maintenance.
Questionnaire to those liable
Each states the help they can give, or proves that they cannot cover the costs.
Département's decision
Notified to the parent and to those liable, who are jointly responsible for the balance not covered.
Referral to the judge
Failing agreement, the judge for the parent's place of residence sets each person's share.
Judgment
Amount, start date, possible release of one of those liable.
Review
A new application if either side's situation changes.
Preparing the file
Documents to gather
A complete file speeds everything up.
Family record book (livret de famille) or civil status certificates proving the relationship with the parent.
Letters, questionnaire and decision from the département.
The care home's residence contract and invoices.
Tax notices, payslips or pension statements for the household.
Outgoings: rent or mortgage, dependent children, health costs.
Witness statements, court decisions or written material on the parent's past conduct.
Send what you have, even if incomplete: the firm sorts it by priority and fills the gaps with you on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
12 detailed answers, sourced from statutes and case law.
Who has a legal duty to support their parents in France (obligation alimentaire)?
Under Article 205 of the Civil Code, children owe maintenance to their father and mother or other ascendants who are in need: in principle, the debt therefore also concerns grandchildren towards their grandparents. Article 206 adds sons-in-law and daughters-in-law towards their father-in-law and mother-in-law, an obligation that ends when the spouse through whom the relationship by marriage arose and the children of their union with the other spouse have died. A person adopted by simple adoption also owes maintenance to the adopter in need. The obligation is reciprocal: conversely, a parent may owe maintenance to an adult child in need. The firm first identifies exactly who is liable, because that list determines how the cost is shared and which exemptions may apply.
How does the judge calculate the amount each child must pay?
Article 208 of the Civil Code sets the rule: maintenance is granted only in proportion to the need of the person claiming it and the wealth of the person who owes it. The judge therefore compares the actual cost of the parent's upkeep or accommodation with the parent's own resources, then examines the income and outgoings of each person liable. The amount claimed by a care home is not enough to fix the debt: the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) partly quashed a court of appeal judgment made by reference to the EHPAD's claim
(our translation), and not in the light of the resident's needs and her son's resources (Cass. 1re civ., 21 November 2018, No. 17-27.071). The same article allows the judge to attach an indexation clause to the maintenance.
Can I refuse to support a parent who never took care of me?
Yes, subject to conditions. Article 207 of the Civil Code allows the judge to release the debtor from all or part of the debt where the creditor has personally failed seriously in their obligations towards the debtor. The Court of Cassation confirmed that this article allows a child to be released from the obligation if they establish their parent's seriously wrongful conduct towards them
(our translation), and it accepted that a father who never tried to contact his son or let him know how he was, took no interest in him and made no contribution to his upkeep or education
(our translation) had behaved in that way (Cass. 1re civ., 31 March 2021, No. 20-14.107, published in the Bulletin). The burden of proof lies with the child, and the seriousness of the failings is for the trial and appeal courts to assess.
How can I prove a parent's serious failings?
Proof may be given by any means: statements from family and friends, court decisions, letters, official reports (constats), school or social services records. The Court of Cassation upheld a full release based on humiliating and insulting telephone messages, noting that the court of appeal found, in the exercise of its discretion, that the father had seriously failed in his obligations towards the maintenance debtors
(Cass. 1re civ., 21 November 2012, No. 11-20.140, our translation). A court of appeal has held that a finding of serious failing may be made on the basis of consistent witness statements, without any need to require documentary proof of each fact alleged
(CA Lyon, 30 June 2026, No. 25/04180, our translation). Finally, where the parent has been convicted of a serious crime (crime) against the child or one of the relatives listed in Article 207, the release applies as of right, unless the judge decides otherwise.
Can the département make children contribute to a parent's care home (EHPAD) fees?
When a parent applies for social assistance with accommodation costs (aide sociale à l'hébergement), the family members liable for maintenance are asked to state the help they can give and, where appropriate, to prove that they cannot cover the costs (Article L. 132-6 of the CASF). The decision is notified to those liable, who are jointly responsible for the balance not covered; failing agreement, the amount of their respective obligations is set by the court for the place where the beneficiary lives (Article R. 132-9). If the parent fails to act, the département can itself refer the matter to the judge (Article L. 132-7). The département's scale is not binding on the judge: it is merely an assessment tool whose relevance it is for the judge to review in the light of the specific situation of the person liable for maintenance
(CA Lyon, 30 June 2026, No. 24/07074, our translation).
Do grandchildren have to pay for their grandparents' care home (EHPAD)?
Since 10 April 2024, Article L. 132-6 of the CASF has exempted grandchildren from providing support when an application for social assistance with accommodation costs is made on behalf of one of their grandparents. The same article exempts children removed from their family by court order for at least thirty-six months in total during the first eighteen years of their life, and children whose father or mother has been convicted of a serious crime (crime) or a sexual assault against the other parent, the exemption then relating to support for the convicted parent; in both cases, the family court judge may decide otherwise. These exemptions extend to the descendants of the persons concerned. Outside social assistance with accommodation costs, Article 205 of the Civil Code still refers to “other ascendants”: the position of grandchildren is therefore assessed case by case.
How is the debt split between brothers and sisters?
The law does not impose an equal split. Each person liable contributes according to their own wealth, in line with Article 208 of the Civil Code, so a brother on a high income may bear a heavier share than a sister of modest means. A child who has paid alone is not without remedy: a court of appeal points out that the person bound by the maintenance obligation has a claim against their co-debtors for the sums they have paid in excess of their contributory share, taking into account the respective means of the debtors
(CA Grenoble, 24 March 2026, No. 22/03377, our translation). The firm reconstructs everyone's resources over the period in question, proposes a written split and, failing agreement, applies to the judge to set each person's share.
Can the care home or hospital take action directly against the children?
Yes. Social and medico-social establishments, which include EHPAD care homes, can bring their claim against residents, their debtors and the persons designated by Articles 205, 206, 207 and 212 of the Civil Code, before the family court judge (Article L. 314-12-1 of the CASF). Public hospitals (établissements publics de santé) have the same remedy (Article L. 6145-11 of the Public Health Code). This remedy does not, by itself, entitle the establishment to recover the whole bill: the Court of Cassation holds that it is commensurate with what these debtors owe
(our translation) and restates that, as a rule, maintenance cannot be claimed retrospectively
(Cass. 1re civ., 14 January 2003, No. 00-20.267, our translation). A child who is sued can therefore dispute the parent's need and their own resources and, where relevant, rely on the parent's serious failings.
Can a care home or hospital claim arrears for the past?
In principle, maintenance cannot be claimed retrospectively (les aliments ne s'arréragent pas): a parent who has claimed nothing is presumed not to have been in need or to have chosen not to bring a claim. A public hospital's claim against the maintenance debtors can only be exercised within the limits of their maintenance obligation
(Cass. 1re civ., 28 January 2003, No. 00-20.979, our translation). The Court of Cassation specifies that this rule must be assessed solely by reference to the maintenance creditor
(our translation): the establishment can obtain maintenance for a period before its court claim if it proves that the parent did not remain inactive or was unable to act, for example because of their state of health (Cass. 1re civ., 1 July 2026, No. 25-13.153). The start date of the contribution must therefore be examined in the light of the supporting documents.
Which judge hears the case, and do I need a lawyer?
The family court judge of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) hears actions relating to the setting of the maintenance obligation (Article L. 213-3 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). When the parent receives social assistance, the amount is set by the court for the place where the parent lives; in other cases, Article 1070 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) in principle designates the judge for the place where the party who did not start the proceedings lives. The case is brought before the judge by writ of summons or by application (Article 1137 of the CPC). The parties conduct their own case and may choose to be assisted or represented by a lawyer (Article 1139). A lawyer checks the figures, prepares the evidence of serious failings and argues how the cost should be shared.
Can the amount set by the judge be reviewed?
Yes. Article 209 of the Civil Code allows release or reduction to be sought when the person providing maintenance can no longer do so, or the person receiving it no longer needs all or part of it. Conversely, a parent whose needs increase, for example on moving into a care home, can make a new application, the amount remaining proportionate to their need and to the resources of those liable (Article 208). On the social assistance side, the département's decision can be revised on production of a court decision rejecting the maintenance claim or limiting the obligation to a lower amount than the one envisaged (Article L. 132-6 of the CASF). The firm advises applying to the judge as soon as the situation changes, with recent supporting documents.
I supported my parent on my own for years: can I be compensated?
Help that goes beyond the maintenance obligation can give rise to compensation on the basis of unjust enrichment. The Court of Cassation holds that the help and assistance given by a child to their parents may give rise to payment of compensation insofar as, exceeding the requirements of filial piety, the services voluntarily provided resulted both in a loss for the child and a corresponding enrichment of the parents
(our translation). It adds that this claim, immediately due from those who benefited from the assistance, is subject to the ordinary limitation period of five years from the date on which the person asserting it knew the facts enabling them to bring the action
(Cass. 1re civ., 30 April 2025, No. 23-15.838, published in the Bulletin, our translation). Waiting until the parent dies can therefore mean losing part of the sums.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Civil Code, Article 205
- Civil Code, Article 206
- Civil Code, Article 207
- Civil Code, Article 208
- Civil Code, Article 209
- Civil Code, Article 210
- Social Action and Families Code, Article L. 132-6
- Social Action and Families Code, Article L. 132-7
- Social Action and Families Code, Article R. 132-9
- Social Action and Families Code, Article L. 314-12-1
- Public Health Code, Article L. 6145-11
- Code of Judicial Organisation, Article L. 213-3
- Code of Civil Procedure, Article 1070
- Code of Civil Procedure, Article 1137
- Code of Civil Procedure, Article 1139
Practical summary
Steps, documents and time limits: at a glance.
For each step: the document produced, the time limit where a statute sets one, and the point to watch.
| Step | Document produced | Time limit | Point to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Application for social assistance with accommodation costs | File with the list, by name, of the family members liable for maintenance | No statutory time limit | Each person liable is then invited to set their possible contribution (Article R. 132-9 of the CASF). |
| 2. Reply from those liable to the département | Questionnaire, proof of income and outgoings | Variable | Prove, where relevant, inability to cover the costs and rely on the exemptions in Article L. 132-6. |
| 3. Département's decision | Decision notified to the parent and to those liable | Variable | Those liable are jointly responsible for the balance not covered by social assistance and by the parent. |
| 4. Referral to the judge by writ of summons | Writ of summons for a hearing date | Filed with the court registry no later than the day before the hearing | If it is not filed in time, the court records that the summons has lapsed (Article 1137 of the CPC). |
| 5. Referral to the judge by application | Application filed with or sent to the court registry | Respondent summoned within fifteen days of the application | The notice to appear must mention Articles 1139 to 1141 of the CPC, failing which it is liable to be declared void (Article 1138). |
| 6. Hearing and judgment | Judgment setting each person's share | Variable | Start date of the contribution: arrears for the period before the claim are subject to strict rules. |
| 7. Review | New application to the judge | No statutory time limit | Prove the change in resources or needs (Article 209 of the Civil Code). |
Case law
Decided cases, with commentary.
The reasoning in three decisions: release, calculation of the contribution, arrears.
Forty years without contact: full release
The département had required a daughter to contribute to her father's care home (EHPAD) fees, calculated under its social assistance regulations. She relied on violence and economic exploitation during her childhood, her expulsion from the family home at nineteen and more than forty-three years without contact. The first-instance judge had found the witness statements insufficient, for lack of any medical evidence.
The court of appeal reversed the judgment and released the daughter from any maintenance obligation, holding that a finding of serious failing may be made on the basis of consistent witness statements, without any need to require documentary proof of each fact alleged
(our translation; read the decision).
Lyon Court of Appeal, social chamber D, 30 June 2026, No. 25/04180.
EHPAD: the contribution follows the need, not the bill
A care home (EHPAD) sued a resident's maintenance debtors, her son and her grandson, for the monthly balance of the accommodation fees. The court of first instance had ordered the son to pay €1,000; the court of appeal reduced his share to €84, starting from the residual cost of accommodation after the département's assistance. These facts predate the 10 April 2024 reform of Article L. 132-6.
The Court of Cassation partly quashed the judgment: the court of appeal had ruled by reference to the EHPAD's claim
(our translation), and not in the light of the resident's needs and her son's resources, in breach of Article 208 of the Civil Code (read the decision).
Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, 21 November 2018, No. 17-27.071, published in the Bulletin.
Arrears: the parent's state of health counts
A public establishment had been accommodating a mother since February 2022. On 5 February 2024 it sued her three children for their contribution from 1 November 2022. The court of appeal set their shares at €500, €300 and €200 a month, but only from the date of the summons, even though it found that the mother's state of health prevented her from acting.
The Court of Cassation quashed the ruling: a public hospital may claim from maintenance debtors payment of maintenance for a period prior to the court claim if it proves that the creditor did not remain inactive or was unable to act
(our translation; read the decision).
Court of Cassation, First Civil Chamber, 1 July 2026, No. 25-13.153.
Need to set or challenge an obligation alimentaire?
Contact the firm with the letter from the département or the care home and proof of your income. We check the need, each person's share and the grounds for release, then defend you before the family court judge.