In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, MDPH decision disputes in Paris
MDPH Lawyer in Paris: Challenging a CDAPH Decision
Adult disability allowance (AAH) refused, incapacity rate underestimated, disability compensation benefit (PCH) or education allowance for a disabled child (AEEH) rejected, mobility inclusion card, placement, school support or recognition as a disabled worker: as an MDPH lawyer in Paris, the firm assists disabled people and their families before the departmental centre for disabled people (MDPH), from conciliation and the mandatory prior appeal through to the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court or the administrative court.
The firm can be reached 24/7. A decision of the Commission for the Rights and Autonomy of Disabled People (CDAPH) is first challenged through a mandatory prior appeal, within two months of its notification (Article R. 142-1-A of the Social Security Code (Code de la sécurité sociale) for decisions heard by the social division, Articles R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice (Code de justice administrative) and L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration (CRPA) for the others); starting a conciliation interrupts this time limit (Article L. 146-10 of the Social Action and Families Code (Code de l'action sociale et des familles)).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received first-rate support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
An excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case that my ex had requested abusively
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has a perfect command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation fully. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar, social security and social assistance litigation, appeals against MDPH decisions before the social division and the administrative courts.
Official listing in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The Commission for the Rights and Autonomy of Disabled People (CDAPH), within the MDPH, decides on placement and guidance, the adult disability allowance (AAH), the education allowance for a disabled child (AEEH), the disability compensation benefit (PCH), the mobility inclusion card (carte mobilité inclusion, CMI) and recognition as a disabled worker (RQTH) (Article L. 241-6 of the Social Action and Families Code). Its silence for more than four months amounts to a rejection (Article R. 241-33). Any court action must be preceded by a mandatory prior appeal (recours administratif préalable obligatoire, RAPO) sent to the MDPH (Articles L. 142-4 of the Social Security Code and R. 241-36), within two months of notification. Before the social division, this time limit can only be relied on against you if it appears in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A); before the administrative courts, if that information is missing, the appeal must still be brought within a reasonable time, in principle one year (Council of State, 10 February 2020, No. 429343). The social division (pôle social) of the judicial court decides AAH, AEEH, PCH, the placement of children and the "invalidity" and "priority" endorsements of the card (Articles L. 241-9 and L. 241-3); the administrative court decides recognition as a disabled worker, the vocational guidance of adults and the "parking" endorsement. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts for the disabled person, their parents or their legal representative. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Received an MDPH decision, an AAH refusal, a prior appeal to lodge?
Understanding your situation
MDPH appeals in Paris, explained
The decisions of the CDAPH must in all cases state their reasons (Article L. 241-6 of the Social Action and Families Code). What it decides, how to challenge it, before which court, and what the judge examines for the adult disability allowance, children's rights, disability compensation and the mobility inclusion card.
Key points
What the CDAPH decides
A single commission, within the MDPH, for very different rights, which do not all come under the same court.
The placement and guidance of the disabled person and the measures needed to ensure their educational or vocational and social integration, as well as the designation of the establishments, services or schemes that meet their needs (Article L. 241-6, I, 1° and 2°, of the Social Action and Families Code).
The assessment of the condition or incapacity rate that justifies the education allowance for a disabled child and its supplement, the adult disability allowance and the mobility inclusion card, and of the compensation needs that justify the disability compensation benefit (Article L. 241-6, I, 3°).
Recognition as a disabled worker for people who meet the conditions of Article L. 5213-1 of the Labour Code (Code du travail) (Article L. 241-6, I, 4°), and the support of disabled people over sixty living in facilities for adults (5°).
Reasoned and reviewed decisions: "The decisions of the commission shall in all cases state their reasons and be subject to periodic review." (our translation) (Article L. 241-6, II). They are taken in the name of the MDPH for a period of at least one year and at most ten years, unless a text provides otherwise (Article R. 241-31).
The commission rules on the basis of the assessment carried out by a multidisciplinary team, which hears the disabled person, their parents where the person is a minor, or the person responsible for their legal protection, either on its own initiative or at their request, and visits the place where they live, on its own initiative or at the disabled person's request (Article L. 146-8). The application is admissible when it is accompanied by a medical certificate less than one year old and the documents set by ministerial order (Article R. 146-26). The time limit for a decision runs from that date: silence kept by the commission for more than four months amounts to a rejection (Article R. 241-33).
The person is informed at least two weeks in advance of the date and place of the session at which their application will be examined, and of the possibility of being assisted or represented by a person of their choice (Article R. 241-30). This session needs preparing: it is often the last opportunity to put forward a medical or educational point before the decision. Lastly, the notification must state the time limits and means of appeal, the obligation to lodge a prior appeal and the authority to which it must be addressed (Article R. 241-32).
For the adult disability allowance, the commission assesses the disability and grants the allowance for one to ten years, or without time limit where the rate reaches 80% and the activity limitations are not likely to improve; the allowance granted on the basis of a rate of 50 to 79% is granted for one to two years, five at most (Article R. 821-5 of the Social Security Code). A dispute over payment, an overpayment or the calculation of resources is then dealt with the paying body: see our page on our CAF benefits lawyers and our article on AAH granted by the MDPH but not paid. For the application itself, see our article on a missing or out-of-date medical certificate.
The procedure
Conciliation, mandatory prior appeal (RAPO), time limits
Before any court, a mandatory administrative step, and a time limit that cannot always be relied on.
Notification
It states the time limits and means of appeal, the obligation to lodge a prior appeal and to whom it is addressed, and reminds you of the right to request, before that appeal, the intervention of a qualified person tasked with proposing conciliation measures (Article R. 241-32 of the Social Action and Families Code).
Conciliation
A person who considers that a decision disregards their rights may ask for a qualified person from the MDPH's list. "Starting a conciliation procedure interrupts the time limits for appeal." (our translation) (Article L. 146-10, in the version in force since 28 May 2026). The decree still refers to a suspension during the two months of the mission, which ends when the report is notified (Article R. 146-35). The request is addressed to the director of the MDPH (Article R. 146-34); the conciliation mission is provided at no cost (Article R. 146-33).
Prior appeal
It is mandatory before going to court (Article L. 142-4 of the Social Security Code, Article R. 241-35 for decisions that come under the administrative courts). It is sent to the MDPH by any means that gives it a certain date, with a covering letter addressed to the commission and a copy of the contested decision (Article R. 241-36).
Mobility inclusion card
The prior appeal against a decision on the card is lodged with the president of the departmental council, by any means that gives it a certain date; their silence for more than two months amounts to a rejection (Article R. 241-17-1).
Time limits
Before the social division, two months for the prior appeal, then two months to bring the case before the court, which can only be relied on if they appear, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III, of the Social Security Code). Before the administrative courts, also two months (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), a prior appeal lodged within that period interrupting it (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration); these time limits cannot be relied on without that information (Article R. 421-5), but the appeal must then still be brought within a reasonable time, in principle one year.
Suspensive effect
The prior appeal has no suspensive effect, except where it is lodged by the disabled person or their representative against a decision designating an establishment or a service (Article R. 241-37).
The covering letter is not an empty formality. The text provides that it "may set out the grounds for the challenge and the elements that were insufficiently or incorrectly taken into account" (our translation) (Article R. 241-36): this is the moment to produce the certificates, assessments and reports the commission did not have, and to link each of them to a legal criterion. The firm drafts this appeal as a first pleading, because the file it builds will be the one the judge reads.
Going straight to court is penalised. For the social division of the Versailles judicial court, the prior appeal "is mandatory and constitutes a substantial formality of public policy, so that it cannot be regularised in the course of proceedings before a court." (our translation) (TJ Versailles, pôle social, 13 March 2026, No. 25/01556). The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation), on the other hand, pays close attention to the sequence of events: a prior appeal lodged before the implicit rejection arose does not make the court action inadmissible, provided that an implicit rejection decision then occurred on expiry of the four-month period (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-21.454, delivered under former Articles L. 142-5 and L. 142-2 of the Social Security Code, now taken over by Article L. 142-4, and under Article R. 241-33 as currently worded).
Before the social division, the time limit does not run without proper notification. The Court of Cassation so held, in a case on the permanent incapacity rate set after an occupational disease, for the two-month time limit of Article R. 142-1-A, III, which is common to all social security litigation: "It follows that, in the absence of proper notification of the means of and time limits for appeal, the two-month time limit for appeal, initially provided for by Article R. 143-7 of the Social Security Code and now by Article R. 142-1-A, III, of the same code, for challenging the decision of a social security body on the permanent incapacity rate in the event of an accident at work or an occupational disease, does not run" (our translation); it adds that the claimant "is not required to bring the matter before the civil court within the time limit defined by the decision of the Council of State" (our translation) which confines such an appeal to a reasonable time (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881). Before the administrative courts, which have jurisdiction over recognition as a disabled worker, the vocational guidance of adults and the "parking" endorsement, the rule is stricter: the recipient of a decision notified without the means of and time limits for appeal "cannot bring a court action beyond a reasonable time" (our translation), which as a general rule may not "exceed one year" (our translation) (CE, 10 February 2020, No. 429343). See our article on the mandatory prior appeal when AAH is refused.
The right court
Social division of the judicial court or administrative court
The law divides the decisions of the same commission between two court systems; going to the wrong one costs months.
Social division of the judicial court
- Adult disability allowance, education allowance for a disabled child and its supplement, disability compensation benefit, incapacity rate (Article L. 241-9 and Article L. 241-6, I, 3°).
- Placement and educational inclusion measures for a child or adolescent, designation of establishments and services, support for people over sixty.
- "Invalidity" and "priority" endorsements of the mobility inclusion card (Article L. 241-3, V bis, and Article L. 142-1, 9°, of the Social Security Code).
Administrative court
- Recognition as a disabled worker (Article L. 241-6, I, 4°, and Article L. 241-9).
- Guidance and designation of an establishment for an adult in the field of vocational rehabilitation, adapted or sheltered work.
- "Parking for disabled people" endorsement of the mobility inclusion card (Article L. 241-3, V bis).
The division follows the wording of Article L. 241-9 of the Social Action and Families Code: decisions under its first paragraph go to the specially designated judicial courts (Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation (Code de l'organisation judiciaire)), which make up social security litigation (Article L. 142-1, 8° and 9°, of the Social Security Code); vocational decisions taken for an adult go to the administrative courts. The Council of State (Conseil d'État) restated this in the case of an adult in Paris whose placement in a medico-social establishment had been refused by the commission: "It follows from the provisions cited above that it is for the judicial courts to hear such an appeal." (our translation) (CE, 6 November 2019, No. 427614). This appeal before the judicial court itself has no suspensive effect, except where the person or their representative challenges a decision designating an establishment or a service (Article L. 241-9).
Before the social division, the court with territorial jurisdiction is that of the place where the claimant lives; for a person living abroad, that of the seat of the MDPH that took the decision (Article R. 142-10 of the Social Security Code). The case is brought by an application handed in or sent to the court registry by recorded delivery letter with acknowledgement of receipt, with a brief statement of the grounds, the documents listed in a schedule and a copy of the contested decision and of the prior appeal (Article R. 142-10-1). The procedure is oral (Article R. 142-10-4). Before the administrative courts, the application must be lodged within two months of notification of the decision (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), or of the date an implicit rejection arose (Article R. 421-2), and an administrative appeal lodged within that period interrupts it (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration).
What the firm checks before any application:
A single notification may group several decisions, for example a refusal of the allowance and recognition as a disabled worker: each then follows its own path. See our pages on the social division of the judicial court and on social security law, and our article on MDPH decision disputes before the Court of Cassation.
The merits
Adult disability allowance (AAH), incapacity rate and access to employment
Two routes to the allowance, two thresholds, and an employment criterion that judges examine in concrete terms.
A permanent incapacity rate of at least 80% gives entitlement to the allowance (Articles L. 821-1 and D. 821-1 of the Social Security Code).
A rate of at least 50% and below 80% also gives entitlement, if the commission recognises, in view of the disability, a substantial and lasting restriction on access to employment (Articles L. 821-2 and D. 821-1).
The rate is assessed according to the scale-guide for the assessment of impairments and incapacities set out in Annex 2-4 of the Social Action and Families Code (Article D. 821-1).
The restriction is substantial where the claimant, because of the disability itself, faces significant difficulties in accessing employment compared with a person without a disability, and these cannot be overcome through compensation, adaptation of the workstation or their own capacity to adapt (Article D. 821-1-2).
It is lasting if its foreseeable duration is at least one year from the filing of the application, even if the medical situation has not stabilised; it is recognised for one to five years (Article D. 821-1-2, 3°).
It remains compatible with work in a sheltered environment, activity in an ordinary work environment of less than half-time where that limitation results exclusively from the disability, and attending a training course (Article D. 821-1-2, 5°).
The courts of appeal examine each criterion on the evidence. The Pau Court of Appeal overturned a refusal and recognised the restriction, after finding that the claimant's conditions "result in a definite disability with significant activity limitations making compensation measures or workstation adjustments impossible" (our translation); it concluded that "The restriction on access to employment is therefore indeed substantial and is set to last at least two years, having regard in particular to the date on which treatment of the anxiety-depressive syndrome began." (our translation) (CA Pau, ch. sociale, 22 January 2026, No. 25/01744). Conversely, the Grenoble Court of Appeal upheld the refusal against an employee who was working more than half-time on the date of her application: "Her ability to carry on a professional activity at least half-time is established, regardless of the subsequent voluntary reduction of her working hours in an attempt to meet the criteria for granting the allowance." (our translation) (CA Grenoble, ch. sécurité sociale, 20 May 2025, No. 24/02269).
The same court points out that the situation examined by the judge "is necessarily the one at the time the application was filed" (our translation), and that "Any subsequent deterioration is, where appropriate, a matter for a new application after notification of the rejection of the previous one, once the mandatory prior amicable appeal procedure has been completed." (our translation) (CA Grenoble, ch. sécurité sociale, 20 May 2025, No. 24/02269). The file is therefore built with documents dating from the time of the application. The judge may order a clinical or documentary medical consultation carried out at the hearing (Article R. 142-16), the cost of which is borne by the national body referred to in Article L. 221-1 of the same code (Article L. 142-11); confidential information on which the decision on the prior appeal was based is passed to the expert or consulting doctor appointed by the court (Article L. 142-10).
The allowance granted on the basis of a rate of 50 to 79% has an end date: its payment "ends at the age at which the recipient is deemed unfit for work" (our translation) (Article L. 821-2 of the Social Security Code), that is, for recipients of the allowance, the age provided for in Article L. 351-1-5 (Article L. 821-1). The Court of Cassation applied this rule under an earlier wording of Articles L. 821-1 and L. 821-2, which then referred to the fifth paragraph of the former (Cass. 2e civ., 24 January 2019, No. 18-10.804): it dismissed the claim of a recipient who sought to keep the allowance until her pension was actually paid. See our articles on AAH refused to a person working less than half-time and on the end of AAH at retirement age.
Other rights
Children, disability compensation benefit (PCH) and mobility inclusion card
Each right has its own criterion; a challenge is won by holding the commission to its exact wording.
AEEH and supplement
The education allowance for a disabled child requires a permanent incapacity at least equal to a set rate; a supplement is granted where the disability entails particularly costly expenses or frequent recourse to a third person (Article L. 541-1 of the Social Security Code). The commission places the child in one of the six categories of the supplement (Article R. 541-2).
Schooling
The commission determines whether schooling requires individual support, for which it sets the number of hours, or shared support, for which it specifies the main activities (Article L. 351-3 of the Education Code (Code de l'éducation)).
Placement
The commission offers a choice between several suitable solutions; it must include the establishment or service the family prefers, if it falls within the category chosen and can take the person, and its decision is binding on the establishment within the limits of its specialisation (Article L. 241-6, III, of the Social Action and Families Code).
Compensation
The disability compensation benefit is due to a person who has an absolute difficulty in carrying out one activity, or a serious difficulty in carrying out at least two, according to the reference framework in Annex 2-5, for a permanent or foreseeable period of at least one year (Articles L. 245-1 and D. 245-4).
Mobility inclusion card
"Invalidity" endorsement for an incapacity rate of at least 80% or classification in the third invalidity category, "priority" endorsement for a lower incapacity that makes standing difficult, "parking" endorsement for a disability that significantly and lastingly reduces the ability and autonomy to move about on foot, or that requires the person to be accompanied by a third person when getting around (Article L. 241-3).
For the sixth-category AEEH supplement, the Court of Cassation overturned a court of appeal that required permanent medical care: "the condition of permanent supervision and care constraints for entitlement to the 6th-category supplement to the education allowance for a disabled child is not limited to medical care" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-17.006). For school support, the judge rules on the needs that are established: the Paris social division refused full-time individual support to a pupil enrolled in a ULIS inclusive education unit, since the information in the reports produced could not "on its own justify the allocation of a full-time individual AESH (school support assistant)" (our translation) (TJ Paris, pôle social, 29 January 2026, No. 25/04912).
For the disability compensation benefit, the Court of Cassation distinguishes two reviews: "entitlement to the compensation benefit is subject, on the one hand, to medical conditions relating to the existence of a disability and to the recognition of a need for compensation examined by the CDAPH, which decides on the award of the benefit, and, on the other hand, to administrative conditions, the review of which falls within the competence of the department, which pays it" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 22-22.855); the department's refusal to fund a family employment arrangement that had not been court-approved was upheld. The medical certificate attached to the application carries great weight: the Toulouse Court of Appeal refused human assistance, since four hours a month of household help could not "suffice to establish a need to make up for serious difficulties in the activities of daily living" (our translation) (CA Toulouse, 4e ch. sect. 3, 29 January 2026, No. 24/01028).
For the card, the Lyon social division raised the rate to 80% and granted the "invalidity" endorsement for ten years, relying on the observations of the consulting doctor at the hearing (TJ Lyon, pôle social, 15 December 2025, No. 24/02392). For the "parking" endorsement, the Council of State requires the person to meet one of the criteria of the ministerial order of 3 January 2017, in particular a limited walking range of less than 200 metres; an administrative court that had disregarded them made an error of law (CE, 29 December 2023, No. 473559). See our articles on a refused mobility inclusion card, on an underestimated AEEH supplement and on a placement notified without an available place.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
Why hire a lawyer to challenge an MDPH decision?
Because the appeal is won on procedure as much as on the medical file. The law does not require it: before the social division, "The parties may defend themselves." (our translation) (Article L. 142-9 of the Social Security Code), and may also be assisted or represented by a relative, a delegate of certain associations or a lawyer. But each step has its own rules: the mandatory prior appeal and to whom it is addressed, the two-month time limit and the conditions for relying on it, judicial or administrative court depending on the decision.
The lawyer first works on classification: a single notification may contain several decisions that do not come under the same court (Article L. 241-9 of the Social Action and Families Code). The lawyer then links each document to the legal criterion: the rate under the scale-guide, the restriction on access to employment, absolute or serious difficulties for the disability compensation benefit, the categories of the AEEH supplement. Finally, the lawyer prepares the hearing, where a consulting doctor may examine the person or their file (Article R. 142-16 of the Social Security Code).
The firm drafts the prior appeal, the application and the written submissions, assists the person at the hearing and follows the case on appeal. It acts for the disabled person, their parents or their legal representative.
What is the time limit to challenge an MDPH decision?
Two months from notification to lodge the prior appeal, then two months to bring the case before the judicial court after the decision on that appeal: "Unless otherwise provided, the time limit for the prior appeal and the time limit for the court action are two months from notification of the contested decision." (our translation) (Article R. 142-1-A, III, of the Social Security Code).
The same text adds a decisive safeguard: "These time limits can only be relied on if they, together with the means of appeal, were stated in the notification of the contested decision" (our translation). The commission's notification must state the time limits, the obligation to lodge a prior appeal and the authority with which it is lodged (Article R. 241-32 of the Social Action and Families Code). The Court of Cassation holds that, in the absence of proper notification, the two-month time limit of Article R. 142-1-A, III, does not run, and that the reasonable-time rule of the administrative courts cannot be relied on before the civil court (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881, in a case on the permanent incapacity rate set after an occupational disease).
Two qualifications. Starting a conciliation interrupts the time limits for appeal (Article L. 146-10 of the Social Action and Families Code). And before the administrative courts, which have jurisdiction over recognition as a disabled worker, the vocational guidance of adults and the "parking" endorsement, the two-month time limit derives from Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice; it can only be relied on if it appears in the notification (Article R. 421-5), but the appeal must then be lodged within a reasonable time, in principle one year (CE, 10 February 2020, No. 429343).
Keep the envelope or the acknowledgement of receipt of the notification: the date of receipt governs the whole timetable. See our article on an AAH refusal notified without the means of and time limits for appeal.
What is the MDPH RAPO and how do you write it?
The mandatory prior administrative appeal (recours administratif préalable obligatoire, RAPO) is the complaint that must precede any court action against a decision of the CDAPH (Article L. 142-4 of the Social Security Code; Article R. 241-35 of the Social Action and Families Code for decisions that come under the administrative courts). It is sent to the MDPH by any means that gives it a certain date, in practice by recorded delivery letter with acknowledgement of receipt or by hand delivery against a receipt (Article R. 241-36).
The text sets its minimum content: a covering letter addressed to the commission that took the decision, and a copy of that decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, of the acknowledgement of receipt of the application. The letter "may set out the grounds for the challenge and the elements that were insufficiently or incorrectly taken into account." (our translation) An effective appeal therefore does not merely express disagreement: it identifies the decision, takes up the legal criterion at issue, and answers it with dated medical, educational or employment documents.
Do not neglect it: without it, the judge declares the action inadmissible, and the Versailles judicial court held that it "cannot be regularised in the course of proceedings before a court." (our translation) (TJ Versailles, pôle social, 13 March 2026, No. 25/01556). For the mobility inclusion card, the prior appeal is lodged with the president of the departmental council (Article R. 241-17-1).
The firm does not supply a template letter: it drafts the appeal from the decision and the documents, because this document fixes the file the judge will examine.
Does conciliation with the MDPH suspend the time limit for appeal?
The law now says that it interrupts it. Where the disabled person, their parents if the person is a minor, or their legal representative consider that a decision of the commission disregards their rights, they may request the intervention of a qualified person tasked with proposing conciliation measures, and "Starting a conciliation procedure interrupts the time limits for appeal." (our translation) (Article L. 146-10 of the Social Action and Families Code, in the version in force since 28 May 2026).
The request is addressed to the director of the MDPH, who appoints the qualified person (Article R. 146-34). That person may consult the file held by the MDPH, excluding medical documents (Article R. 146-35); the role is performed at no cost to the applicant (Article R. 146-33).
The implementing decree has not been brought into line with the law. Article R. 146-35 still provides that the qualified person "has two months to carry out the conciliation mission, during which the time limit for court action is suspended" (our translation), and that notification of the mission report "ends the suspension of the time limits for appeal" (our translation). The law, being higher in rank, prevails, but the time limit only starts again, at the earliest, on notification of that report. As a precaution, the firm counts as if the time limit had only been suspended, and lodges the prior appeal as soon as that notification is received, within the time that remained.
Conciliation does not replace the mandatory prior appeal. The notification presents it as a right to be exercised "before lodging a prior appeal" (our translation) (Article R. 241-32), so the prior appeal remains necessary if conciliation fails. The firm assesses, case by case, whether it is better to start conciliation or to lodge the prior appeal directly, and dates each step to keep proof of the timetable.
The MDPH has not replied: what can you do?
Two kinds of silence must be distinguished. On the initial application, "Silence kept for more than four months by the Commission for the Rights and Autonomy of Disabled People" (our translation) from the date on which the application is admissible amounts to a rejection decision (Article R. 241-33 of the Social Action and Families Code). This implicit rejection is challenged like an express decision, through the prior appeal, with a copy of the acknowledgement of receipt of the application (Article R. 241-36).
On the prior appeal itself, the rules of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration apply (Article R. 142-1-A, I, of the Social Security Code): silence kept for two months on an administrative appeal amounts to a rejection (Article L. 231-4, 2°, of that code). For the mobility inclusion card, silence from the president of the departmental council for more than two months also amounts to a rejection (Article R. 241-17-1).
The sequence of events must not trap the claimant. The Court of Cassation held that a prior appeal lodged before the implicit decision arose does not make the court action inadmissible, and that "Notification of an express rejection decision after the date on which the implicit rejection decision occurred has no bearing on the admissibility of the court action." (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-21.454). Before the court, a person who challenged an implicit rejection cannot be time-barred solely because they did not challenge the express rejection issued during the proceedings (Article R. 142-10-1).
Which court should hear a challenge to an MDPH decision?
It depends on the decision. The specially designated judicial courts, that is, the social division, hear decisions on the placement and educational inclusion of a child or adolescent, the designation of establishments and services, the adult disability allowance, the education allowance for a disabled child, the disability compensation benefit and support for people over sixty (Article L. 241-9 of the Social Action and Families Code; Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). The administrative courts hear decisions taken for an adult in the field of vocational rehabilitation, adapted or sheltered work, and recognition as a disabled worker.
The mobility inclusion card follows its endorsement: judicial court for the "invalidity" and "priority" endorsements, administrative court for the "parking" endorsement (Article L. 241-3, V bis; Article L. 142-1, 9°, of the Social Security Code). For the placement of an adult in a medico-social establishment, outside the employment field, the Council of State confirmed the jurisdiction of the judicial courts: "It follows from the provisions cited above that it is for the judicial courts to hear such an appeal." (our translation) (CE, 6 November 2019, No. 427614).
The judicial court with territorial jurisdiction is the one for the area where the claimant lives; if the claimant lives abroad, that of the seat of the MDPH that took the decision (Article R. 142-10 of the Social Security Code). For a person living in Paris, it is therefore the social division of the Paris judicial court, which hears this litigation, for example on human assistance for schooling (TJ Paris, pôle social, 29 January 2026, No. 25/04912). See our page on the social division of the judicial court.
How does the hearing before the social division work?
The case is brought before the court by an application handed in or sent to the court registry by recorded delivery letter with acknowledgement of receipt. The application contains a brief statement of the grounds and is accompanied by the documents, listed in a schedule, together with a copy of the contested decision or, in the case of an implicit decision, of the initial decision and the prior appeal; where applicable, it names the doctor appointed to receive the medical documents (Article R. 142-10-1 of the Social Security Code).
"The procedure is oral." (our translation) (Article R. 142-10-4); its general course is described on our page on the social division of the judicial court. What is specific to MDPH litigation is the medical evidence. The court may order a clinical or documentary consultation carried out at the hearing by a consultant (Article R. 142-16); for the commission's decisions and the "invalidity" and "priority" endorsements, confidential information on which the decision on the prior appeal was based is passed to the expert or consulting doctor appointed by the court (Article L. 142-10), and the costs of these consultations and expert assessments are borne by the national body referred to in Article L. 221-1 (Article L. 142-11).
The consultation can change the outcome: the Lyon social division, "referring to the hearing, the supporting documents produced and the observations of the consulting doctor at the hearing" (our translation), set the rate at 80% and granted the mobility inclusion card with the "invalidity" endorsement (TJ Lyon, pôle social, 15 December 2025, No. 24/02392). The firm prepares the examination with the person, gathers the medical documents dating from the time of the application and submits observations on the consultant's opinion.
AAH refused with an incapacity rate between 50 and 79%: what arguments?
Below the 80% threshold, the allowance is due to a person whose incapacity reaches at least 50% and to whom the commission recognises a substantial and lasting restriction on access to employment (Article L. 821-2 of the Social Security Code; Article D. 821-1). The dispute almost always concerns this restriction, the criteria for which are set out in Article D. 821-1-2: it is substantial "where the claimant, because of the disability itself, faces significant difficulties in accessing employment" (our translation), having regard to the impairments, activity limitations, constraints of treatment and aggravating disorders, and it is no longer substantial if it can be overcome through compensation, workstation adjustments or the person's capacity to adapt. It is lasting if it is expected to last at least one year.
Working does not rule everything out: activity in a sheltered environment, activity in an ordinary work environment of less than half-time where that limitation results exclusively from the disability, and training all remain compatible (Article D. 821-1-2, 5°). The Pau Court of Appeal granted the allowance for two years to a claimant whose conditions made compensation or adjustment measures impossible: "The restriction on access to employment is therefore indeed substantial and is set to last at least two years, having regard in particular to the date on which treatment of the anxiety-depressive syndrome began." (our translation) (CA Pau, ch. sociale, 22 January 2026, No. 25/01744). The Grenoble Court of Appeal refused it to an employee working more than half-time on the date of her application (CA Grenoble, ch. sécurité sociale, 20 May 2025, No. 24/02269).
Useful documents describe the effects of the disability on employment: detailed certificates, opinions of the occupational doctor, attempts at returning to work, adjustments tried. See our article on proving a substantial and lasting restriction.
My condition has worsened since the application: does the judge take this into account?
In principle no, at least for the pending application. The courts of appeal assess rights at the date of the application. For the Grenoble Court of Appeal, the situation examined "is necessarily the one at the time the application was filed" (our translation), and "Any subsequent deterioration is, where appropriate, a matter for a new application after notification of the rejection of the previous one, once the mandatory prior amicable appeal procedure has been completed." (our translation) (CA Grenoble, ch. sécurité sociale, 20 May 2025, No. 24/02269).
Later documents are not useless for all that: they can shed light on a condition that already existed on the date of the application. The Pau Court of Appeal held that conditions described in later documents pre-dated the application (CA Pau, ch. sociale, 22 January 2026, No. 25/01744). Conversely, the Toulouse Court of Appeal set aside a certificate drawn up "at a date very far removed from the filing of the application in dispute and without sufficient clinical detail to characterise those complaints at the reference date for assessing the claims" (our translation) (CA Toulouse, 4e ch. sect. 3, 29 January 2026, No. 24/01028).
The strategy is therefore decided case by case: pursue the appeal on the initial application where the documents from that time are sufficient, and file a new application in parallel where the deterioration is recent. For the adult disability allowance, rights may also be reviewed before the end of the award period, at the request of the person concerned, if their incapacity changes (Article R. 821-5 of the Social Security Code). See our article on a renewal refused despite a deterioration.
AEEH or supplement refused: how do you challenge it?
Through the prior appeal sent to the MDPH, then before the social division of the judicial court, since the decision falls within the commission's assessment under Article L. 241-6, I, 3°, of the Social Action and Families Code (Article L. 241-9). Any person who has the care of a disabled child is entitled to the education allowance if the child's permanent incapacity reaches a set rate, and a supplement is granted where the disability entails particularly costly expenses or frequent recourse to a third person (Article L. 541-1 of the Social Security Code).
The amount of the supplement depends on the category, from the first to the sixth, in which the commission places the child using an assessment guide, taking into account, on the basis of supporting documents, a parent's reduction or cessation of work and the length of time a paid third person is needed (Article R. 541-2). The supporting documents therefore decide the outcome: employer certificates, contracts and invoices, care schedules, unreimbursed expenses.
The Court of Cassation makes sure that judges do not add conditions to the text: for the sixth category, "the condition of permanent supervision and care constraints for entitlement to the 6th-category supplement to the education allowance for a disabled child is not limited to medical care" (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-17.006); on that point it overturned a judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal. See our article on AEEH and its supplements before the social division.
PCH refused or insufficient: what can be challenged?
First, access to the benefit. Any disabled person residing stably and lawfully in metropolitan France or in the territories covered by the text, whose age and disability meet the regulatory criteria, is entitled to a disability compensation benefit (Article L. 245-1 of the Social Action and Families Code). Entitlement arises for a person who has an absolute difficulty in carrying out one activity or a serious difficulty in carrying out at least two activities defined by the reference framework in Annex 2-5, these difficulties having to be permanent or of a foreseeable duration of at least one year (Article D. 245-4).
Proof is made activity by activity. The Toulouse Court of Appeal overturned a judgment that had granted human assistance, since the medical questionnaire attached to the application described tasks performed with difficulty but without help, and four hours a month of household help could not "suffice to establish a need to make up for serious difficulties in the activities of daily living" (our translation) (CA Toulouse, 4e ch. sect. 3, 29 January 2026, No. 24/01028). The medical certificate filed with the application must therefore describe precisely what the person cannot do alone.
Next, payment. The commission decides on the award, but the department reviews the administrative conditions and pays: the Court of Cassation upheld the department's refusal to pay the benefit for the direct employment of a guardian, in the absence of a court-approved employment contract (Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 22-22.855). A challenge concerning the payment or use of the sums is therefore not directed at the same authority as a challenge to the compensation plan. See our article on benefit overpayments claimed from heirs.
Mobility inclusion card refused: what appeal?
The card is issued by the president of the departmental council on the basis of the commission's assessment (Article L. 241-3 of the Social Action and Families Code). The prior appeal is therefore lodged with the president, by any means that gives it a certain date, with a covering letter and a copy of the decision; this appeal is examined in the same way as the initial application, and silence kept for more than two months amounts to a rejection (Article R. 241-17-1).
The competent court then depends on the endorsement. The "invalidity" endorsement requires an incapacity rate of at least 80% or classification in the third category of invalidity pension; the "priority" endorsement, an incapacity below 80% that makes standing difficult. These two endorsements are challenged before the judicial court, the "parking" endorsement before the administrative court (Article L. 241-3, V bis). The "invalidity" endorsement is granted without time limit to a person whose rate reaches 80% and whose limitations are not likely to improve (Article R. 241-15).
Judges accept well-documented files: the Lyon social division granted the "invalidity" endorsement "for a period of 10 years in view of the condition, which is not likely to improve in the current state of knowledge" (our translation) (TJ Lyon, pôle social, 15 December 2025, No. 24/02392); those ten years were the outcome of that particular case, as the text provides, in that situation, for an award without time limit. For the "parking" endorsement, the Council of State keeps to the criteria of the ministerial order of 3 January 2017, such as a limited walking range of less than 200 metres (CE, 29 December 2023, No. 473559). See our article on the mobility inclusion card before the courts.
RQTH refused or vocational guidance: which court?
The administrative court, after a prior appeal. Decisions taken for an adult in the field of vocational rehabilitation, adapted or sheltered work, and recognition as a disabled worker (reconnaissance de la qualité de travailleur handicapé, RQTH), may be appealed to the administrative courts (Article L. 241-9 of the Social Action and Families Code), preceded by a prior appeal (Article R. 241-35) sent to the MDPH (Article R. 241-36).
The definition is set by law: "A disabled worker is any person whose possibilities of obtaining or keeping employment are effectively reduced as a result of the impairment of one or more physical, sensory, mental or psychological functions." (our translation) (Article L. 5213-1 of the Labour Code). The status is recognised by the commission (Article L. 5213-2), and without time limit in the case of a permanent impairment (Article R. 241-31 of the Social Action and Families Code).
In 2026, the Council of State specified that the disability does not have to be permanent: "while recognition as a disabled worker is not conditional on the persons concerned having a disability of a permanent nature, that status may lawfully be recognised only for persons who, on the date on which the commission rules, have a disability likely to reduce their possibilities of obtaining or keeping employment on a lasting basis" (our translation) (CE, 20 May 2026, No. 502159); it set aside the judgment that had required permanent after-effects. The application to the administrative court must be lodged within two months (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice); if the notification omits the means of and time limits for appeal, this time limit cannot be relied on, but the appeal must be lodged within a reasonable time, in principle one year (CE, 10 February 2020, No. 429343). For the consequences at work, see our article on disability discrimination at work.
What are a lawyer's fees for an MDPH appeal?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing yourself, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or method of calculating the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The same text prohibits fees set solely according to the outcome of the case: "Any setting of fees solely according to the judicial outcome is prohibited" (our translation) (Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971).
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: request for conciliation, mandatory prior appeal, application and hearing before the social division of the judicial court or the administrative court, appeal. The amount reflects what is at stake and the volume of medical, educational or employment documents to be examined. Any new work is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For an initial opinion on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a first written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 146-8 of the Social Action and Families Code, L. 146-9, L. 241-6 and R. 146-26: assessment, Commission for the Rights and Autonomy of Disabled People, decisions and review, admissibility of the application
- Articles R. 241-30, R. 241-31, R. 241-32 and R. 241-33: session, duration of decisions, notification, implicit rejection
- Articles L. 146-10, R. 146-33, R. 146-34 and R. 146-35: conciliation by a qualified person, interruption of time limits
- Articles L. 241-9, R. 241-35, R. 241-36 and R. 241-37: competent courts, mandatory prior appeal, suspensive effect
- Articles L. 241-3, R. 241-15 and R. 241-17-1: mobility inclusion card, duration, prior appeal and courts
- Articles L. 245-1 and D. 245-4: disability compensation benefit
- Articles L. 142-1 of the Social Security Code, L. 142-4, L. 142-9 and R. 142-1-A: social security litigation, prior appeal, representation, time limits and when they can be relied on
- Articles R. 142-10, R. 142-10-1, R. 142-10-4, R. 142-16, L. 142-10 and L. 142-11: competent court, application, oral procedure, medical consultation and costs
- Articles L. 821-1, L. 821-2, D. 821-1, D. 821-1-2, R. 821-5 and L. 351-1-5: adult disability allowance, rate, restriction on access to employment, duration, age at which payment ends
- Articles L. 541-1 and R. 541-2: education allowance for a disabled child and categories of the supplement
- Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation: specially designated judicial courts
- Articles L. 5213-1 and L. 5213-2 of the Labour Code: disabled worker status
- Article L. 351-3 of the Education Code: individual or shared human support for schooling
- Articles L. 231-4 and L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration: silence amounting to rejection, administrative appeal
- Articles R. 421-1, R. 421-2 and R. 421-5 of the Code of Administrative Justice: time limit for appeal before the administrative courts and when it can be relied on
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-21.454: prior appeal and implicit rejection by the CDAPH
- Cass. 2e civ., 27 June 2024, No. 22-17.881: time limit cannot be relied on without proper notification, before the social division
- Cass. 2e civ., 24 January 2019, No. 18-10.804: end of AAH at retirement age (rate of 50 to 79%)
- Cass. 2e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-17.006: 6th-category AEEH supplement
- Cass. 2e civ., 14 November 2024, No. 22-22.855: PCH, roles of the CDAPH and of the department
- CA Pau, ch. sociale, 22 January 2026, No. 25/01744: substantial and lasting restriction recognised
- CA Grenoble, ch. sécurité sociale, 20 May 2025, No. 24/02269: situation assessed on the date of the application
- CA Toulouse, 4e ch. sect. 3, 29 January 2026, No. 24/01028: PCH human assistance refused
- TJ Lyon, pôle social, 15 December 2025, No. 24/02392: mobility inclusion card with "invalidity" endorsement granted
- TJ Versailles, pôle social, 13 March 2026, No. 25/01556: inadmissibility for lack of a prior appeal
- TJ Paris, pôle social, 29 January 2026, No. 25/04912: individual school support refused
- CE, 10 February 2020, No. 429343: reasonable time of one year before the administrative courts where the means of and time limits for appeal are not stated
- CE, 6 November 2019, No. 427614: jurisdiction of the judicial courts for medico-social placement
- CE, 20 May 2026, No. 502159: RQTH without requiring a permanent disability
- CE, 29 December 2023, No. 473559: "parking" endorsement and the criteria of the ministerial order
Further reading
An MDPH decision to challenge, a prior appeal to lodge?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send us the notification and its envelope or acknowledgement of receipt, your application, any prior appeal you have lodged and the medical, educational or employment documents you have: Hassan Kohen checks the time limits, the nature of each decision and the competent court, then tells you the appropriate route, whether conciliation, the mandatory prior appeal, or an application to the social division of the judicial court or to the administrative court.