In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, contract law firm in Paris
Contract lawyer in Paris: negotiate, draft, enforce
Negotiations and breaking off talks, the duty to inform and defects of consent, drafting and auditing clauses, unfair terms between businesses, hardship (imprévision), non-performance, termination, penalty clauses: as a contract lawyer in Paris, the firm advises and represents businesses and individuals alike, on the creditor's side as well as the debtor's. A badly drafted formal notice or a termination notified too hastily is often enough to turn a case around.
The firm can be reached 24/7. Termination by notification is at the creditor's own risk: except in an emergency, the creditor must first serve formal notice on the debtor to perform within a reasonable time (Article 1226 of the French Civil Code, Code civil); a formal notice invoking a termination clause only takes effect if it expressly mentions the clause (Article 1225); an action for payment is in principle time-barred after five years (Articles 2224 of the Civil Code and L. 110-4 of the Commercial Code), and after only two years for an action brought by a business against a consumer (Article L. 218-2 of the Consumer Code).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice tailored to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) that my ex had applied for abusively
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He listens very well, shows great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar: contract law, commercial contracts and terms and conditions, non-performance and termination, contract litigation.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
A contract is an agreement between two or more parties intended to create, modify, transfer or extinguish obligations (Article 1101 of the French Civil Code, Code civil). It must be negotiated, formed and performed in good faith, a rule of public policy (Article 1104), and it has the force of law between those who made it (Article 1103). Since the reform that came into force on 1 October 2016, the Civil Code governs negotiations and breaking them off (Article 1112), the duty to inform (Article 1112-1), defects of consent (Articles 1130 to 1144), unfair terms in standard-form contracts (Article 1171), hardship (Article 1195) and the remedies for non-performance (Article 1217). Contracts concluded before that date remain governed by the former law, and Articles 1110, 1137, 1171 and 1223, amended by the Act of 20 April 2018, apply in their current wording only to contracts concluded since 1 October 2018. Between businesses, Article L. 442-1 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce) penalises significant imbalance and the abrupt termination of an established commercial relationship. Kohen Avocats, a contract law firm in Paris 16th, acts for all parties at the negotiation, drafting, performance and litigation stages. Call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A contract to negotiate, a clause to check, a breach of contract to remedy?
Understanding your situation
French contract law in Paris, explained
“Contracts lawfully formed have the force of law for those who made them” (Article 1103 of the Civil Code, our translation). How a contract is formed, which clauses stand up in court, what can be done about non-performance or a radical change in circumstances, and how the same rule reads depending on whether you are claiming or defending.
Formation
Negotiating, informing, consenting: the conditions of a sound contract
Most disputes are set up before signature, during the negotiations.
Negotiating in good faith: “Pre-contractual negotiations may be freely initiated, conducted and broken off”, but they “must imperatively meet the requirements of good faith” (Article 1112 of the Civil Code, our translation). Fault committed during negotiations gives rise to compensation for the loss, but not for the loss of the benefits expected from the contract that was not concluded, nor for the loss of a chance of obtaining them.
Informing: a party who knows information of decisive importance for the other's consent must disclose it, where the other party is legitimately unaware of it or relies on its contracting partner. This duty does not extend to the estimated value of the performance, and “The parties may neither limit nor exclude this duty” (Article 1112-1, our translation).
Keeping secrets: a party who uses or discloses without authorisation confidential information obtained during the negotiations incurs liability (Article 1112-2). A non-disclosure agreement signed before any data is shared specifies what is protected and for how long.
Consenting freely: consent, capacity and lawful and certain content are necessary for a contract to be valid (Article 1128). Mistake, fraud (dol) and duress (violence) vitiate consent where, without them, one of the parties “would not have contracted or would have contracted on substantially different terms” (Article 1130, our translation).
Setting lawful and determined content: a contract cannot derogate from public policy (Article 1162), the performance must be possible and determined or determinable (Article 1163), and a contract for consideration is void where the agreed counter-performance is illusory or derisory at the time it is formed (Article 1169).
Negotiations may be freely broken off; it is the manner of doing so that is judged. On Réunion Island, a company had ended, after six months of discussions, well-advanced negotiations for the sale of its business (fonds de commerce), citing a formal notice from the prefecture unrelated to the transaction. The court of appeal held that it “had thus put an end to the negotiations on an illegitimate ground, since it had no bearing whatsoever on the planned sale of the business, the progress of the negotiations having legitimately led the company Greko to believe it would go ahead” (our translation). It awarded the prospective buyer its audit and legal fees, “overall expenses incurred to no avail” (our translation), and rejected the claim for the time spent by its managers, because the amounts were not substantiated and because that time was inherent in the project “of which the negotiations were only the first stage” (our translation) (CA Saint-Denis de la Réunion, ch. com., 19 March 2025, No. 23/01653).
The expected gain, on the other hand, is never compensated. The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) restates that compensation “may not be intended to make up for either the loss of the benefits expected from the contract not concluded or the loss of a chance of obtaining those benefits” (our translation), and it quashed the judgment that had awarded 90,000 euros for the loss of a chance of acquiring a business in a sought-after neighbourhood: the court of appeal had compensated “a loss of a chance of obtaining benefits expected from the contract not concluded” (our translation) (Cass. com., 5 June 2024, No. 23-14.904). During negotiations, each party should therefore keep a record of its expenses and set out in a letter of intent what has been agreed and what has not. See our article on wrongful termination of negotiations and compensation.
The duty to inform has precise limits. The Court of Cassation holds that it “only covers information that has a direct and necessary link with the content of the contract or the status of the parties, and whose importance is decisive for the other party's consent” (our translation). The buyer of shares in a fast-food company, who accused the seller of hiding the fact that the leased premises did not allow frying, lost, because “it was not established that the possibility of frying was a decisive condition for the consent of Mr [T]” (our translation) (Cass. com., 14 May 2025, No. 23-17.948). A party who attaches importance to a particular quality of the performance must therefore write it into the contract.
Fraud requires more: “Fraud is the act of a contracting party obtaining the other's consent by schemes or lies” (our translation), and the intentional concealment of information known to be decisive also amounts to fraud (Article 1137). The Poitiers court of appeal upheld the annulment of a promise to sell in which the promising company had concealed that the negotiator was one of its partners: this situation “constituted, for them, information decisive for their consent, which had been intentionally concealed from them” (our translation), and the beneficiaries recovered the 67,000 euros they had paid (CA Poitiers, 1re ch., 18 November 2025, No. 24/00153). Lastly, economic duress requires a genuine abuse of a state of dependence (Article 1143): the Court of Cassation rejected it in favour of a buyer whose sellers, assisted by their lawyer and their chartered accountant, “had retained the ability not to comply with the demands of the company Equip'jardin” (our translation) (Cass. com., 10 July 2024, No. 22-21.947).
The time limit for an action for annulment only runs, in the case of mistake or fraud, from the day they were discovered and, in the case of duress, from the day it ceased (Article 1144 of the Civil Code); the nullity is relative (Article 1131) and may only be claimed by the party the law protects (Article 1181), and the annulled contract “is deemed never to have existed” (our translation), with restitution of what was performed (Article 1178). See our article on fraud and excessive price in business and share sales.
Clauses
The clauses that decide a dispute, and those the court sets aside
Clauses deemed unwritten, significant imbalance, terms and conditions, interpretation.
“Any clause which deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten” (Article 1170 of the Civil Code, our translation). Only a clause that empties the essential obligation of its substance is targeted.
In a standard-form contract (contrat d'adhésion), any non-negotiable clause, determined in advance by one of the parties, which creates a significant imbalance is deemed unwritten (Article 1171); the assessment covers neither the main subject matter of the contract nor the adequacy of the price to the performance. A standard-form contract is one that contains a set of non-negotiable clauses determined in advance by one of the parties (Article 1110).
Between businesses engaged in production, distribution or services, liability is incurred by the act of “subjecting or attempting to subject the other party to obligations creating a significant imbalance in the rights and obligations of the parties” (Article L. 442-1, I, 2° of the Commercial Code, our translation).
Where a consumer is involved, clauses that create a significant imbalance to the consumer's detriment are unfair (Article L. 212-1 of the Consumer Code, Code de la consommation).
General terms and conditions only take effect against the other party if they were brought to its attention and it accepted them; where two sets of general terms conflict, the incompatible clauses have no effect, and special terms prevail over general terms (Article 1119 of the Civil Code).
“In case of doubt, a negotiated contract is interpreted against the creditor and in favour of the debtor, and a standard-form contract against the party who proposed it” (Article 1190, our translation), after seeking the common intention of the parties (Article 1188).
The applicable text depends on who the parties are, and the question has just been settled. For the Court of Cassation, Article 1171 of the Civil Code, “interpreted in the light of this legislative history, therefore does not apply to contracts concluded by a person engaged in production, distribution or services, unless the application of Article L. 442-1 of the Commercial Code to those contracts is excluded by another provision” (our translation). The subcontracted carrier who accused its principal of imposing an unbalanced standard-form contract on it lost: “It follows that Article 1171 of the Civil Code does not apply to the dispute” (our translation) (Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137). Where the contract is concluded by a person engaged in production, distribution or services, the dispute is therefore fought on the ground of the Commercial Code.
Article 1171 still has real scope. The Court of Cassation applies it to contracts that fall outside the Commercial Code, “even when concluded between producers, traders, manufacturers or persons registered in the trades register, where they do not fall within Article L. 442-6, I, 2° of the Commercial Code” (our translation), in its wording prior to the Order of 24 April 2019, such as a financial lease granted by a credit institution. It sets a limit that is useful to the drafter: a termination clause available only to the lessor is not unbalanced where “the lack of reciprocity of the automatic termination clause for non-performance of the contract provided for in Article 12, a) of the general terms and conditions is justified by the nature of the obligations by which the parties are respectively bound” (our translation) (Cass. com., 26 January 2022, No. 20-16.782). The appeal judgment that had deemed this clause unwritten was quashed.
Drafting or challenging a clause therefore requires, first and foremost, classifying the contract: negotiated or standard-form, between businesses engaged in production, distribution or services or not, with a consumer or not. The firm audits terms and conditions, model contracts and clauses on liability, termination, penalties and price, and identifies those a court could deem unwritten. See our articles on significant imbalance in commercial contracts, on limitation of liability clauses and gross negligence, on the enforceability of unsigned terms and conditions and on abuse of economic dependence.
A business's general terms and conditions of sale include in particular the payment terms and the factors used to determine the price, and they must be provided to any business buyer who asks for them (Article L. 441-1 of the Commercial Code). They form the sole basis of commercial negotiation.
Non-performance
From formal notice to termination: remedies for breach of contract
Article 1217 of the Civil Code opens five courses of action, which can be combined and each have their own procedure.
Formal notice
The debtor is put on formal notice (mise en demeure) by a summons or a document containing a sufficient demand, or by the mere fact that the obligation has fallen due if the contract so provides (Article 1344). Unless the non-performance is definitive, damages are only due after formal notice to perform within a reasonable time (Article 1231).
Suspending
A party may refuse to perform its obligation if the other party does not perform its own and if that non-performance is sufficiently serious (Article 1219). It may also suspend performance in anticipation where it is clear that the other party will not perform, but “This suspension must be notified as soon as possible” (Article 1220, our translation).
Specific performance
After formal notice, the creditor may seek performance in kind, unless it is impossible or there is a manifest disproportion between its cost to the debtor in good faith and its benefit to the creditor (Article 1221); the creditor may also have the obligation performed itself within a reasonable time and at a reasonable cost, and then claim reimbursement (Article 1222).
Price reduction
Where performance is imperfect, a creditor who has not yet paid may, after formal notice, notify its decision to reduce the price proportionately; if it has already paid, it asks the court for the reduction in the absence of agreement (Article 1223).
Termination
It results from a termination clause, from a notification by the creditor in the event of sufficiently serious non-performance, or from a court decision (Article 1224). The clause specifies the commitments concerned and the formal notice must expressly mention it (Article 1225); notification requires prior formal notice, except in an emergency (Article 1226).
Damages
They cover the loss suffered and the gain forgone (Article 1231-2), within the limit of what was foreseeable when the contract was concluded, except in the case of gross or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3). They can be added to the other compatible remedies (Article 1217).
The defence of non-performance (exception d'inexécution) is the quickest weapon, and the riskiest. The Rennes court of appeal allowed it for a customer who refused to pay for an air extraction system less powerful than the one in the quote: the service provider's non-performance “is sufficiently serious to justify the non-performance of its own obligation by Le 19 de Paul Bert since, by installing equipment different from that covered by the quote signed by both parties and without having first informed its contracting partner or obtained its agreement” (our translation), the provider had undermined the substance of its obligation, and “The reciprocal non-performance of its obligation by the company Le 19 de Paul Bert is proportionate to that of Air+Net Ouest” (our translation) (CA Rennes, 3e ch. com., 20 January 2026, No. 24/06727). The provider's claim for payment was dismissed. Seriousness and proportionality must be demonstrated with supporting documents before suspending performance.
Termination by notification is made “at the creditor's own risk”, and the creditor “must then prove the seriousness of the non-performance” (our translation) if the debtor brings the matter before the court (Article 1226). The Court of Cassation overturned a court of appeal which, having found that there was no serious non-performance at all, had only taken into account the abruptness of the termination and limited the compensation to 5,000 euros: it followed “that the termination was unjustified and not merely abrupt” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 January 2025, No. 23-17.795). A party who terminates without justification therefore cannot confine the debate to the abruptness of the termination: it is the non-performance of its own obligations that is at stake. See our articles on unilateral termination for serious breach and on termination clauses in commercial contracts.
Performance in kind, by contrast, is made easier. For the Court of Cassation, “It is for the debtor who relies on such a disproportion to prove it” (our translation), and the creditor may ask the court to order performance “without being required to assess the cost of that performance or to make a separate claim for damages” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-21.151). The project owner who sought, subject to a daily penalty (astreinte), works on a roof structure and roofing obtained the quashing of the judgment that had dismissed the claim for lack of a corresponding claim for damages. As for the foreseeability limit, it falls away in the case of gross negligence (faute lourde), defined as “conduct of extreme seriousness showing the inability of the obligor to perform the contractual task it had accepted” (our translation), even without bad faith (Cass. com., 9 September 2026, No. 25-19.382).
A penalty clause (clause pénale) sets in advance the compensation due in the event of non-performance. The court may, even of its own motion, reduce or increase it if it is manifestly excessive or derisory, and, unless the non-performance is definitive, “the penalty is only incurred once the debtor has been put on formal notice” (Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code, our translation). The Douai court of appeal upheld the halving of a 14,000-euro penalty after comparing its amount with the loss proven (CA Douai, ch. 1, sect. 3, 26 March 2026, No. 23/01146). See our article on the reduction of penalty clauses by the courts.
Circumstances
Hardship, force majeure, lapse: when circumstances upset the contract
Three distinct mechanisms, with strict conditions, which the contract can adjust.
Hardship (imprévision): a change in circumstances that was unforeseeable when the contract was concluded, and which makes performance excessively onerous for a party that had not agreed to bear the risk, allows that party to request a renegotiation (Article 1195 of the Civil Code). “It continues to perform its obligations during the renegotiation” (our translation).
Failed renegotiation: the parties may agree to terminate the contract or jointly ask the court to adapt it; failing agreement within a reasonable time, the court may, at the request of one party, revise the contract or end it, on the date and on the terms it sets (Article 1195).
Force majeure: an event beyond the debtor's control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures, prevents performance. A temporary impediment suspends the obligation; a definitive impediment terminates the contract automatically (Article 1218).
Lapse (caducité): a validly formed contract lapses if one of its essential elements disappears; the disappearance of one contract causes the lapse of the contracts in the same transaction whose performance becomes impossible or for which it was a decisive condition of consent, provided the contracting partner knew of the overall transaction (Article 1186).
Hardship is proven with accounts, not market prices. The Paris court of appeal accepted that the surge in the price of urea, driven by that of gas and then by the war in Ukraine, was an unforeseeable change for an AdBlue supplier. It nevertheless dismissed its claim, because excessive onerousness “cannot be inferred either from the mere variation in the price of the urea supplied and invoiced by the companies Duslo and GreenChem Holding” (our translation), or from wholesale prices, and the supplier failed to produce “accounting and financial evidence capable of establishing this condition for terminating the contract on the ground of hardship” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 25 November 2022, No. 22/00326). A party relying on Article 1195 should therefore prepare an accounting file, and keep performing during the renegotiation.
Force majeure only benefits the debtor who is prevented from performing. The Court of Cassation so held in the case of a couple who had paid for a stay at an establishment and had been unable to enjoy it, one of the spouses having suffered a health problem: “the creditor who was unable to enjoy the performance to which it was entitled cannot obtain termination of the contract by relying on force majeure” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 25 November 2020, No. 19-21.060). The judgment that had ordered the termination was quashed. A customer prevented from enjoying a service it has paid for must look for another route, contractual or statutory, and should first read the contract's cancellation terms.
The contract can allocate these risks. Article 1195 only applies to a party that had not agreed to bear the risk, and freedom of contract allows, within the limits of public policy (Article 1102), an indexation, price review or renegotiation clause to be included, or the events and the notification procedure in the event of force majeure to be specified. The firm drafts these clauses according to the real risks of the business and advises, when the event occurs, on the notice to be sent and the timetable to follow. See our articles on hardship in business contracts and on renegotiation and termination for hardship.
Lapse applies to transactions that rest on several contracts, for example a financing arrangement and a service: the disappearance of one can cause the others to lapse, under the strict conditions of Article 1186. Before any termination, the firm checks which contracts are linked and what each provides if the others disappear.
The parties
Creditor, debtor, drafter, adhering party: four positions, and the evidence
The same rule reads differently depending on whether you are claiming, defending or drafting.
You are seeking performance
- Gather the contract, the purchase orders, the correspondence and proof of what was delivered or performed.
- Serve formal notice by a document containing a sufficient demand, citing the termination clause if there is one.
- Choose the remedy: specific performance, price reduction, termination, damages, or an order for payment (injonction de payer).
Performance is being claimed from you
- Check the date of the contract, the applicable law and whether the claim is time-barred.
- Look for the claimant's own failures to perform, the defence of non-performance, force majeure or hardship.
- Challenge the clauses relied on, a manifestly excessive penalty and the loss actually proven.
You are drafting the contract or the terms and conditions
- Classify the contract: negotiated or standard-form, between businesses or with a consumer.
- Draft liability, termination and penalty clauses that stand up in court.
- Allocate risk: price review, force majeure, confidentiality, dispute resolution.
You have signed an unbalanced contract
- Identify the non-negotiable clauses and the applicable text, Article 1171 or Article L. 442-1.
- Look for a defect of consent, and date its discovery for the purpose of the time limit for bringing an action.
- Weigh the cost of each option before breaking off: an unjustified termination backfires on the party who makes it.
Evidence is prepared from the moment of signature. “A party who claims performance of an obligation must prove it” (our translation), and a party who claims to be released must prove payment (Article 1353 of the Civil Code). A legal act concerning a sum above the threshold set by decree, 1,500 euros, must be proven in writing (Article 1359 and Article 1 of Decree No. 80-533 of 15 July 1980); against a trader, on the other hand, a commercial act may be proven by any means (Article L. 110-3 of the Commercial Code). An electronic document has the same evidential value as a paper document if its author can be identified and its integrity is guaranteed (Article 1366). A contract signed in as many originals as there are parties with a separate interest, or concluded electronically in accordance with these requirements, avoids the debate (Article 1375).
Time limits frame everything else. Personal actions are time-barred after five years from the day the holder of the right knew or should have known the facts (Article 2224), and obligations arising in the course of trade between traders or between traders and non-traders are time-barred after five years, unless a shorter special limitation period applies (Article L. 110-4 of the Commercial Code); an action by a business for goods or services it supplies to a consumer is time-barred after two years (Article L. 218-2 of the Consumer Code). The date of the contract matters just as much: under Article 9 of Order No. 2016-131 of 10 February 2016, “Contracts concluded before that date remain governed by the former law, including as regards their statutory effects and public policy provisions” (our translation). A contract concluded in 2015 falls under neither Article 1195 nor Article 1226. Likewise, Articles 1110, 1137, 1171 and 1223, as worded by the Act of 20 April 2018, only apply to contracts concluded since 1 October 2018 (Article 16 of Act No. 2018-287 of 20 April 2018): for a contract concluded between 1 October 2016 and 30 September 2018, Article 1171 is read in its 2016 wording.
Between businesses, the end of a long-standing relationship is also governed by Article L. 442-1, II of the Commercial Code, which penalises the act of “abruptly terminating, even partially, an established commercial relationship, in the absence of written notice” (our translation) that takes into account, in particular, the length of the relationship; liability for insufficient notice cannot be incurred “once eighteen months' notice has been given” (our translation). This type of litigation is covered on our page on commercial disputes. Specific contracts have their own pages: service agreements, partnership agreements, IT contracts, franchising and commercial agents.
The points the firm examines in every case:
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does a contract lawyer in France do?
A contract lawyer acts at every stage in the life of a contract. Before signature, the lawyer conducts or oversees the negotiation, drafts the letter of intent, the non-disclosure agreement and the contract itself, and reviews the other party's terms and conditions. During performance, the lawyer interprets the clauses, drafts formal notices and advises on suspension, renegotiation or termination. In a dispute, the lawyer represents the claiming party as well as the defending party, before the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) or the commercial court (tribunal de commerce), or in mediation.
The framework is the Civil Code as reformed in 2016. “Everyone has the freedom to contract or not to contract” (our translation), to choose the other party and to set the content and form of the contract within the limits of the law, but “Freedom of contract does not allow derogation from rules of public policy” (Article 1102 of the Civil Code, our translation). Good faith governs negotiation, formation and performance, and this rule is a matter of public policy (Article 1104). Special texts are added to it: the Commercial Code between businesses, the Consumer Code where a consumer is involved.
The value of advice is measured at the moment of termination. The Court of Cassation held that the termination of a services contract notified without any serious breach was unjustified, and not merely abrupt: the award limited to 5,000 euros by the lower courts was quashed (Cass. com., 29 January 2025, No. 23-17.795). The firm acts for businesses, company directors and individuals, in Paris and throughout France.
Can you break off contract negotiations in France without being liable?
Yes, because negotiations may be freely broken off, but this must be done fairly. Article 1112 of the Civil Code provides that negotiations may be freely initiated, conducted and broken off, and that they “must imperatively meet the requirements of good faith” (our translation). Fault arises from the circumstances: very advanced negotiations, the other party's legitimate belief that the contract would be concluded, a misleading reason, a sudden breaking off after commitments in principle.
The Saint-Denis de La Réunion court of appeal thus ordered a company to pay damages after it had broken off, after six months, negotiations for the sale of its business on a ground unrelated to the transaction: an “illegitimate ground, since it had no bearing whatsoever on the planned sale” (our translation). The prospective buyer recovered the cost of its audits and its legal fees, “overall expenses incurred to no avail” (our translation), but not the time spent by its managers (CA Saint-Denis de la Réunion, ch. com., 19 March 2025, No. 23/01653).
The recoverable loss is limited by law. Compensation can make up neither for the loss of the benefits expected from the contract not concluded, nor for the loss of a chance of obtaining those benefits (Article 1112). The Court of Cassation quashed a judgment that had awarded 90,000 euros for the loss of a chance of acquiring a business (Cass. com., 5 June 2024, No. 23-14.904). A party breaking off should therefore give reasons for its decision and do so early; a party suffering the breaking off should keep evidence of how far the negotiations had progressed and of its expenses. See our article on wrongful termination of negotiations.
The other party hid information from me: can I have the contract annulled?
Yes, if the information was decisive: on the ground of fraud where the concealment was intentional or, without intent, on the ground of mistake where it concerns the essential qualities of the performance or of the other party (Article 1132). Two legal bases must be distinguished. The duty to inform under Article 1112-1 of the Civil Code requires a party who knows decisive information to pass it on to the other party, who is legitimately unaware of it; it does not extend to the estimated value of the performance, and a breach of it renders its author liable and may lead to annulment. Fraud under Article 1137 covers schemes, lies and the intentional concealment of information known to be decisive; “A mistake resulting from fraud is always excusable” (Article 1139, our translation).
The burden of proof is demanding. The Court of Cassation restates that the duty to inform only covers information that has a direct and necessary link with the content of the contract or the status of the parties, and whose importance is decisive for consent; the buyer of company shares who did not establish that the possibility of frying in the premises was decisive lost (Cass. com., 14 May 2025, No. 23-17.948). Conversely, the Poitiers court of appeal upheld the annulment of a promise to sell in which the promisor had concealed that the negotiator was its partner, the beneficiaries being “entitled to argue that they would not have contracted, or not on those terms, had they been properly informed” (our translation) (CA Poitiers, 1re ch., 18 November 2025, No. 24/00153).
The time limit for an action for annulment, five years for personal actions (Article 2224), only runs, in the case of fraud, from the day it was discovered (Article 1144). The firm reconstructs what each party knew, and when.
Is a contract signed under economic pressure valid in France?
It can be annulled for duress, under strict conditions. Under Article 1143 of the Civil Code, “There is also duress where a party, abusing the state of dependence in which its contracting partner finds itself in relation to it, obtains from it a commitment that it would not have entered into in the absence of such constraint and derives a manifestly excessive advantage from it” (our translation). Four elements are therefore required: a state of dependence on the other party, an abuse of that dependence, a commitment that would not have been made without that constraint, and a manifestly excessive advantage. Like other defects of consent, duress leads to relative nullity (Article 1131), and the time limit for bringing an action only runs from the day it ceased (Article 1144).
Dependence alone is not enough. The Court of Cassation approved a court of appeal that had rejected the duress claimed by the sellers of a business, even though they were acknowledged to be in a state of dependence on the buyer: assisted by their lawyer and their chartered accountant, they had negotiated on the very day of signature, which showed that they “had retained the ability not to comply with the demands of the company Equip'jardin” (our translation). It adds that the court may rely “on elements contemporaneous with or subsequent to the date on which the contract was formed in order to assess whether the alleged defect of consent was real” (our translation) (Cass. com., 10 July 2024, No. 22-21.947). The sellers' appeal was dismissed.
A party signing under pressure should therefore keep a written record of its objection, of the lack of any alternative and of the advantage obtained by the other party. Between businesses, Article L. 442-1 of the Commercial Code also provides an action for damages against an advantage obtained without consideration. See our article on abuse of economic dependence.
Can an unfair clause between businesses be set aside in France?
Yes, but the legal basis depends on the parties' activity. Article 1171 of the Civil Code deems unwritten, in a standard-form contract, a non-negotiable clause that creates a significant imbalance, without review of the main subject matter or the price. Article L. 442-1, I, 2° of the Commercial Code renders liable a business that subjects or attempts to subject its partner to obligations creating a significant imbalance.
These texts cannot be combined. The Court of Cassation holds that Article 1171 “therefore does not apply to contracts concluded by a person engaged in production, distribution or services, unless the application of Article L. 442-1 of the Commercial Code to those contracts is excluded by another provision” (our translation); the subcontracted carrier who relied on it had its appeal dismissed (Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137). Article 1171 remains applicable to contracts that fall outside the Commercial Code, such as a financial lease granted by a credit institution; in that case, however, the Court held that a termination clause available only to the lessor was justified by the nature of the parties' obligations (Cass. com., 26 January 2022, No. 20-16.782).
The sanction also differs. Article 1171 deems the clause unwritten; Article L. 442-1 opens an action for compensation of the loss caused. Where a consumer is involved, Article L. 212-1 of the Consumer Code applies. The firm first classifies the contract and the parties, then chooses the legal basis and the court. See our article on significant imbalance in commercial contracts.
Is a limitation of liability clause always valid under French law?
It is valid in principle, subject to a limit linked to the essential obligation: “Any clause which deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten” (Article 1170 of the Civil Code, our translation). The clause is therefore judged by its effect: only a clause that empties the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten. In a standard-form contract that falls outside the Commercial Code, the clause may also be challenged on the ground of significant imbalance (Article 1171).
The seriousness of the fault also matters, at least for the statutory limit on damages: gross or wilful misconduct already removes the foreseeable-damage limit, since the debtor is only liable for damages that were foreseen or foreseeable when the contract was concluded, “except where the non-performance is due to gross or wilful misconduct” (Article 1231-3, our translation). The Court of Cassation defines gross negligence as “conduct of extreme seriousness showing the inability of the obligor to perform the contractual task it had accepted” (our translation), and it quashed the judgment that had dismissed a bank customer's claim without examining whether the bank's error amounted, “quite apart from any bad faith” (our translation), to gross negligence capable of removing the foreseeable-damage limit (Cass. com., 9 September 2026, No. 25-19.382).
The drafter should therefore define the essential obligation and set a cap consistent with the price and the risks. The party subject to the clause examines, with supporting documents, whether it empties the essential obligation of its substance and whether the breach reveals gross negligence, which removes the foreseeable-damage limit. See our article on limitation of liability clauses and gross negligence.
My suppliers' prices have soared: can I renegotiate the contract under French law?
Yes, on the ground of hardship, if its conditions are met and the contract has not excluded it. Article 1195 of the Civil Code allows a party for whom a change in circumstances that was unforeseeable when the contract was concluded makes performance excessively onerous, and who had not agreed to bear that risk, to ask the other party to renegotiate. It continues to perform its obligations during the renegotiation. If the other party refuses or the renegotiation fails, the parties may agree to terminate the contract or jointly ask the court to adapt it; failing agreement within a reasonable time, the court may, at the request of one party, revise the contract or end it.
Proof of excessive onerousness is decisive. The Paris court of appeal accepted that the surge in the price of urea was an unforeseeable change for an AdBlue supplier, but it upheld the dismissal of its claim for lack of accounting evidence: excessive onerousness “cannot be inferred either from the mere variation in the price of the urea supplied and invoiced by the companies Duslo and GreenChem Holding” (our translation), or from wholesale market prices (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 25 November 2022, No. 22/00326). The supplier was ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings.
The request should therefore be prepared with the chartered accountant: margins before and after the change, actual cost of inputs, share of the contract in the business. The contract must also be reread, as it may provide for indexation, a price review or a waiver of hardship, and its date of conclusion checked, since Article 1195 only applies to contracts concluded since 1 October 2016. See our article on hardship in business contracts.
My client is not paying: how do I recover an unpaid debt in France?
Step by step, while preserving the evidence. The first step is formal notice: the debtor is put on notice to pay “either by a summons or a document containing a sufficient demand or, if the contract so provides, by the mere fact that the obligation has fallen due” (Article 1344 of the Civil Code, our translation). For a sum of money, it causes interest to run at the statutory rate (Article 1231-6); more broadly, damages are only due, unless the non-performance is definitive, after formal notice (Article 1231), and formal notice triggers the penalty provided for by a penalty clause (Article 1231-5). The registered letter must be precise: amount, invoices, deadline, consequences.
The second step is judicial. A party who claims performance of an obligation must prove it (Article 1353): contract, purchase orders, proof of delivery or completion, correspondence. Depending on the amount and how seriously the claim is disputed, the firm chooses between the order for payment procedure (injonction de payer) and a writ of summons on the merits. If the client relies on breaches, the debate then turns on their seriousness and on the defence of non-performance.
Where the obligation is not a sum of money, performance in kind may be sought. The Court of Cassation held that “It is for the debtor who relies on such a disproportion to prove it” (our translation), and that the creditor may obtain performance without putting a figure on its cost or making a separate claim for damages (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-21.151). The time limit for bringing an action is in principle five years (Articles 2224 of the Civil Code and L. 110-4 of the Commercial Code), but only two years for an action by a business against a consumer (Article L. 218-2 of the Consumer Code). See also our page on commercial disputes.
Can I stop performing a contract because the other party is not performing theirs?
Yes, through the defence of non-performance, if the other party's breach is sufficiently serious. Under Article 1219 of the Civil Code, “A party may refuse to perform its obligation, even where it is due, if the other party does not perform its own and if that non-performance is sufficiently serious” (our translation). Article 1220 also allows performance to be suspended in anticipation, where it is clear that the other party will not perform when due and the consequences are sufficiently serious, provided that the suspension is notified as soon as possible.
Seriousness and proportionality are the whole debate. The Rennes court of appeal allowed the defence raised by a customer against a provider that had installed an extraction unit less powerful than the one in the quote, without informing the customer or obtaining its agreement: the non-performance was “sufficiently serious to justify the non-performance of its own obligation” (our translation), and the refusal to pay was proportionate, since the remedial work would cost the equivalent of the invoice (CA Rennes, 3e ch. com., 20 January 2026, No. 24/06727). The provider's claim for payment was dismissed.
An unfounded defence backfires on the party who raises it: it becomes a defaulting debtor itself, exposed to penalties, interest and termination. Before suspending, the firm has the breach recorded (bailiff's report, out-of-court expert assessment, written exchanges), sends a reasoned formal notice and limits the suspension to what the non-performance justifies. A partial, proportionate and notified suspension stands up better in court than a total and silent stoppage.
Can a contract be terminated in France without going to court?
Yes, in two ways, each with its own procedure. A termination clause specifies the commitments whose non-performance will lead to termination; termination is subject to an unsuccessful formal notice, unless otherwise agreed, and “The formal notice only takes effect if it expressly mentions the termination clause” (Article 1225 of the Civil Code, our translation). Without a clause, the creditor may terminate by notification in the event of sufficiently serious non-performance (Article 1224): “The creditor may, at its own risk, terminate the contract by notification” (our translation), after a formal notice announcing the termination, except in an emergency, and then by a reasoned notification (Article 1226).
Review comes afterwards. The debtor may bring the matter before the court at any time, and the creditor must then prove the seriousness of the non-performance. The Court of Cassation overturned the judgment which, without any finding of serious non-performance, had only penalised the abruptness of the termination: it followed “that the termination was unjustified and not merely abrupt” (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 January 2025, No. 23-17.795). Lastly, termination may always be sought in court (Article 1227), and the court may order it, order performance while granting additional time, or award damages only (Article 1228).
Termination ends the contract, and restitution depends on its economics: where the performances were useful as they were carried out, it is classified as cancellation for the future (résiliation), with no restitution for the period before the last performance that received no counter-performance (Article 1229). The firm drafts the formal notice and the notification, and builds the evidence of seriousness before acting. See our article on the unilateral termination of a commercial contract.
Can a French court reduce a penalty clause?
Yes, and it may even do so of its own motion. Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code provides that, where the contract stipulates that the party who fails to perform will pay a certain sum as damages, neither a greater nor a lesser sum may be awarded. “Nevertheless, the court may, even of its own motion, reduce or increase the penalty so agreed if it is manifestly excessive or derisory” (our translation). In the case of partial performance, the penalty may be reduced in proportion to the benefit that performance gave the creditor. Any stipulation to the contrary is deemed unwritten, and, unless the non-performance is definitive, the penalty is only incurred after formal notice.
The review is objective. The Douai court of appeal holds that “Where the court decides to revise the amount of the penalty clause, it must examine and state in what way the amount was excessive or derisory in relation to the loss actually suffered by the creditor” (our translation), and that “the debtor's situation or good faith are not to be taken into account” (our translation). It upheld the reduction to 7,000 euros of a 14,000-euro penalty stipulated in a promise to sell, and refused any additional compensation, the application of the penalty clause excluding, according to the court, any further compensation “unless there is proof of a loss not compensated by the application of the penalty clause” (our translation) (CA Douai, ch. 1, sect. 3, 26 March 2026, No. 23/01146).
The creditor should therefore document its actual loss to defend the amount; the debtor compares the penalty with that loss. The firm also drafts proportionate penalty clauses, less exposed to reduction. See our article on penalty clauses and the court's power to reduce them.
Does force majeure allow you to get out of a contract in France?
It releases the debtor who is prevented from performing, subject to cumulative conditions. Under Article 1218 of the Civil Code, there is force majeure where “an event beyond the debtor's control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures, prevents the debtor from performing its obligation” (our translation). If the impediment is temporary, performance is suspended, unless the delay justifies termination; if it is definitive, the contract is terminated automatically and the parties are released. The debtor prevented from performing is then not ordered to pay damages (Article 1231-1).
It does not benefit the creditor who was unable to enjoy the performance. The Court of Cassation quashed the judgment that had ordered the termination of an accommodation contract in favour of customers who had paid for their stay but had been unable to enjoy it, one of them having fallen ill: “the creditor who was unable to enjoy the performance to which it was entitled cannot obtain termination of the contract by relying on force majeure” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 25 November 2020, No. 19-21.060). The customer had performed its obligation, which was to pay.
Within the limits of freedom of contract (Article 1102), the contract may specify the events covered, the notification procedure and the period of suspension after which either party may terminate. Where the event makes performance more costly without preventing it, it is hardship under Article 1195 that may apply, not force majeure. The firm analyses the contract and the event before any notification, because force majeure wrongly invoked exposes the party to the remedies for non-performance.
What are the fees of a contract lawyer in Paris?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Act of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or method of calculating the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The same text prohibits fees set solely according to the outcome of the case: “Any setting of fees based solely on the judicial outcome is prohibited” (our translation).
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: drafting or auditing a contract or terms and conditions, negotiation, letter of intent and non-disclosure agreement, formal notice or reply, notice of suspension or termination, request for renegotiation on the ground of hardship, payment proceedings, action for annulment or damages, defence, appeal. Court costs, bailiff (commissaire de justice) fees and expert fees are added to the fees. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a first opinion on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, results in a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles 1101 of the Civil Code, 1102, 1103 and 1104: definition of the contract, freedom of contract, binding force, good faith
- Articles 1110, 1112, 1112-1 and 1112-2: standard-form contract, negotiations, duty to inform, confidentiality
- Articles 1113 and 1119: offer and acceptance, general terms and conditions
- Articles 1128, 1130, 1131 and 1132: validity, defects of consent, mistake
- Articles 1137, 1138, 1139, 1143 and 1144: fraud, duress through abuse of dependence, time limit for the action
- Articles 1162, 1163, 1166, 1169, 1170 and 1171: content of the contract, clauses deemed unwritten
- Articles 1178, 1181 and 1186: nullity, who may claim relative nullity, lapse
- Articles 1188 and 1190: interpretation
- Article 1195: hardship
- Articles 1217, 1218, 1219 and 1220: remedies for non-performance, force majeure, defence of non-performance
- Articles 1221, 1222 and 1223: specific performance, price reduction
- Articles 1224, 1225, 1226, 1227, 1228 and 1229: termination
- Articles 1231, 1231-1, 1231-2, 1231-3, 1231-5 and 1231-6: damages, penalty clause, late-payment interest
- Articles 1344, 1353, 1359, 1366 and 1375: formal notice, evidence
- Article 2224: general limitation period
- Articles L. 110-4 of the Commercial Code, L. 110-3, L. 441-1 and L. 442-1: commercial limitation period, evidence between traders, general terms and conditions of sale, restrictive practices
- Articles L. 212-1 of the Consumer Code and L. 218-2: unfair terms, two-year limitation period
- Article 9 of Order No. 2016-131 of 10 February 2016: entry into force of the reform, earlier contracts
- Article 1 of Decree No. 80-533 of 15 July 1980: threshold for proof in writing
- Article 16 of Act No. 2018-287 of 20 April 2018: application in time of the articles amended in 2018
- Article 10 of Act No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. com., 5 June 2024, No. 23-14.904: breaking off negotiations, loss of a chance not recoverable
- CA Saint-Denis de la Réunion, ch. com., 19 March 2025, No. 23/01653: wrongful breaking off of negotiations, wasted expenses
- Cass. com., 14 May 2025, No. 23-17.948: scope of the duty to inform
- CA Poitiers, 1re ch., 18 November 2025, No. 24/00153: fraud by concealment, annulment of the promise
- Cass. com., 10 July 2024, No. 22-21.947: duress through abuse of dependence rejected
- Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137: Article 1171 excluded between businesses
- Cass. com., 26 January 2022, No. 20-16.782: Article 1171 and financial leasing
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 11, 25 November 2022, No. 22/00326: hardship, proof of excessive onerousness
- CA Rennes, 3e ch. com., 20 January 2026, No. 24/06727: defence of non-performance upheld
- Cass. com., 29 January 2025, No. 23-17.795: unjustified termination by notification
- Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-21.151: specific performance, proof of disproportion
- CA Douai, ch. 1, sect. 3, 26 March 2026, No. 23/01146: reduction of a penalty clause
- Cass. com., 9 September 2026, No. 25-19.382: gross negligence and unforeseeable damage
- Cass. 1re civ., 25 November 2020, No. 19-21.060: force majeure relied on by the creditor
Further reading
A contract to sign, a clause to check, a breach of contract to remedy?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the contract and its schedules, the terms and conditions, the negotiation correspondence, any formal notices received or sent and the documents relating to performance: Hassan Kohen examines the date and classification of the contract, the clauses at issue, the seriousness of the breaches and the time limits, then tells you the appropriate course of action: drafting, renegotiation, formal notice, suspension, termination, action for payment or defence.