Kohen Avocats, executive compensation and director remuneration in Paris
Executive compensation lawyer in Paris: salary, dividends, approval
Manager (gérant) of a SARL, president of a SAS or director of an SA: as an executive compensation lawyer in Paris, we know that pay is decided by the body that the law or the articles of association designate, is proved by properly drawn-up minutes, and is then split between salary and dividends according to the resulting social security status and tax treatment. The firm secures the decision, clarifies the choice and handles disputes, for the director as well as for the company or the shareholder who challenges the pay.
The firm can be reached 24/7. Pay that a manager has awarded himself without a decision in the articles of association or by the shareholders gives rise to an obligation to compensate the company that the Cour de cassation holds is not seriously disputable, and which can therefore be claimed as an interim payment in summary proceedings (Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 24-15.111). Regularisation is best prepared before the dispute breaks out.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) case that my ex had requested abusively
Very satisfied with the outcome of my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar: company law, executive compensation, shareholder disputes and directors' liability.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The pay of the manager (gérant) of a private limited company (SARL) is determined either by the articles of association (statuts) or by a decision of the shareholders acting collectively, and it can only be proved by minutes that comply with Article R. 223-24 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce) (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466). In a public limited company (société anonyme, SA), the board of directors determines the pay of the chairman, the chief executive officer and the deputy chief executive officers (Articles L. 225-47 and L. 225-53); in a simplified joint-stock company (SAS), the articles of association set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5). Social security status follows the legal form: the president of a SAS and a minority manager of a SARL fall under the general scheme (régime général), a majority manager under the self-employed scheme (Article L. 311-3 of the French Social Security Code). Salary is deductible if it pays for actual work and is not excessive (Article 39 of the French General Tax Code); dividends bear 12.8% income tax and 18.6% social levies; for a self-employed director, the portion above 10% of the capital bears his social security contributions and levies instead (Articles L. 136-3 and L. 136-7 of the French Social Security Code). Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts for the director as well as for the company or the shareholder. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Pay to set, a salary or dividends decision, a disputed resolution?
Understanding your situation
Executive compensation in Paris, explained
A director's pay is never a decision he takes alone: the board of directors determines the pay of the chairman of an SA, the shareholders or the articles of association that of a SARL manager, and the body designated by the articles that of a SAS president. Who decides, how to prove it, which social security status and which tax treatment apply, and how to challenge or defend it.
Key points
Who sets director remuneration: the answer depends on the legal form
The law or the articles of association designate the competent body; a director never sets his own pay alone.
SARL: the manager's pay is determined by the articles of association or by a decision of the shareholders acting collectively, taken at a meeting or, if the articles so provide, by written consultation, both recorded in minutes, or by the consent of all the shareholders expressed in a deed, which then serves as its record (Articles L. 223-18, L. 223-27 and R. 223-24 of the French Commercial Code).
Single-member SARL (EURL): the sole shareholder decides in place of the meeting, his decisions are entered in a register, and decisions taken in breach of these rules may be annulled at the request of any interested party (Article L. 223-31).
SA: the board of directors determines the pay of the chairman, the chief executive officer and the deputy chief executive officers (Articles L. 225-47 and L. 225-53); in an SA with a management board (directoire), the instrument of appointment sets the method and amount of each management board member's pay (Article L. 225-63).
SAS: “The articles of association set the conditions under which the company is managed” (Article L. 227-5, our translation); they designate the body that sets the pay of the president and the other directors, for example the shareholders acting collectively or, in a single-shareholder SAS (SASU), the sole shareholder.
The Cour de cassation restated this twice in 2026 for the SARL: “the pay of the manager of a private limited company is determined either by the articles of association or by a decision of the shareholders acting collectively” (our translation) (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466). In the SA, the rule is just as clear: “the board of directors of a public limited company has exclusive power to determine the pay of the chairman” (our translation), and “the supervisory board has exclusive power to determine the pay of the members of the management board” (our translation). In that case, the variable pay promised in a letter of engagement could not be awarded on the sole basis of that letter, since the judges had not found any decision of the boards; the order to pay it was quashed and the case referred back to the Paris Court of Appeal (Cass. com., 4 January 2023, No. 20-17.658).
In a SAS, everything goes through the articles of association. A shareholders' agreement or a letter may supplement them but not contradict them: “While extra-statutory instruments may supplement these articles, they cannot derogate from them” (our translation) (Cass. com., 12 October 2022, No. 21-15.382, concerning a dismissal indemnity that the articles excluded). Where the articles entrust the president's pay to a collective decision of the shareholders, the Besançon Court of Appeal upheld the interim payment awarded to the company against its former president, since no decision authorised the sum received (CA Besançon, 1re ch., 2 September 2025, No. 25/00013).
The firm always starts by reading the articles of association and the register of decisions: they show who could decide, in what form and by what majority. For dismissal and the related indemnities, see our page on director dismissal lawyers.
The decision
Corporate decision, minutes and related-party agreements
Lawful pay is decided before it is paid, recorded in writing and is not the same thing as an agreement.
Decide
The competent body sets the amount and its components: fixed pay, variable pay, bonuses, benefits in kind, payment of contributions. Each new increase or bonus requires a new decision.
Record
In a SARL, the minutes state, among other things, the date and place of the meeting, the shareholders present or represented, the documents submitted, the text of the resolutions and the result of the votes; they are drawn up and signed by the managers (Article R. 223-24).
Vote
A manager's exceptional bonus is a component of his pay, not an agreement: a manager who is also a shareholder may take part in the vote (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.057).
Agreements
Agreements concluded between the company and its director, directly or through an intermediary, are subject to the related-party agreements procedure (conventions réglementées) (Articles L. 223-19, L. 225-38 and L. 227-10): this is the case of a services contract invoiced by the director's own company.
Approving the accounts
Booking the pay in the accounts or having the accounts approved does not replace the decision that sets it; for the SARL, the Cour de cassation requires compliant minutes.
Ratify
In an SA, the board cannot approve after the event an increase that the chairman granted himself without a prior decision (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.045).
Proof is now strictly regulated in the SARL: “proof of the authorisation by the shareholders acting collectively concerning the pay granted to the manager of a private limited company can only be provided by producing minutes that meet the conditions laid down by the last of these provisions” (our translation), that is Article R. 223-24. The court of appeal had accepted a year-end bonus on the basis of minutes bearing a single crossed-out signature, its entry in the accounts and the fact that the company's legal adviser had prepared it; the Cour de cassation quashed that ruling and ordered the manager to repay the bonus (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466).
The director's vote follows its own logic. According to the Cour de cassation, “the allocation of an exceptional bonus to the manager is not to be analysed as an agreement between him and the company but as the setting of a component of his pay, so that he may take part in the vote” (our translation) (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.057). In a SAS, where the articles of association entrust the president's pay to a collective decision, “this pay is not subject to the control provided for by the above-mentioned provisions” (our translation), namely those on related-party agreements (CA Besançon, 1re ch., 2 September 2025, No. 25/00013). In an SA, by contrast, “the board of directors of a public limited company does not have the power to ratify the decision of the chairman who, without first obtaining a decision of the board, granted himself an increase in his pay” (our translation); the statutory auditor who failed to point this out incurred liability (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.045).
Pay channelled through an intermediary company, in the form of management fees, is subject to two checks: the related-party agreements procedure, and the URSSAF (social security contributions agency) when it disguises a salary. See our article on management fees reclassified as salary by the URSSAF.
Social security status
Employee-equivalent or self-employed: what the legal form decides
A director does not choose his social protection scheme: it follows from the legal form of the company and from how the capital is held.
General scheme (employee-equivalent, assimilé salarié)
- Presidents and directors of SAS and SELAS companies (Article L. 311-3, 23°, of the French Social Security Code).
- Chairman of the board of directors, chief executive officer and deputy chief executive officers of an SA (Article L. 311-3, 12°).
- Managers of SARL and SELARL companies who do not together hold more than half of the capital, including shares held by a spouse, a civil partner (PACS) and unemancipated minor children (Article L. 311-3, 11°).
Self-employed
- Majority manager of a SARL, or member of a board of managers that holds more than half of the capital.
- Contributions based on the sums received for performing the role, and on the portion of dividends above 10% of the capital, share premiums and current accounts (Articles L. 131-6 and L. 136-3, II).
- A 26% allowance on that base, within a floor and a ceiling set by decree (Article L. 136-3, III).
The majority is assessed across the whole management: “the members of a board of managers of a private limited company and of a professional private limited company are not compulsorily affiliated to the general scheme under this provision where they together hold more than half of the share capital, even if some of them hold no shares” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 31 May 2018, No. 17-17.518). Nor is the title enough: members of the supervisory board of a SAS do not, in principle, fall under the general scheme, “unless it is shown that they in fact perform a management function” (our translation); for a chairman of the supervisory board who bound the company and chose its investments, the URSSAF reassessment was upheld (Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 23-13.887).
Dividends do not always shield from contributions. For the majority manager, the rule lies in the 10% threshold of Article L. 136-3, II, 2°, to which Article L. 131-6 refers. Liberal professions practising through a professional practice company (société d'exercice libéral) are subject to a specific solution, given under the former wording of Article L. 131-6: “the profits of the professional practice company within which the self-employed worker carries on his activity constitute the proceeds of his professional activity and must be included in the base for the social security contributions he owes, including where those profits are distributed to the financial holding company of the liberal profession that holds the capital of the professional practice company” (our translation). For a dental surgeon who was the only practising professional shareholder of his SELARL, the Cour de cassation dismissed the appeal brought against the contributions demanded by his pension fund, without dwelling on the 10% threshold: the court of appeal's calculation of it on the holding company's capital was a ground that was “erroneous but superfluous” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 21-20.366). The decision went against the practitioner.
On reassessments targeting majority managers, see our page on URSSAF defence for majority managers and our article on dividends paid up through a holding company and Article L. 131-6.
What the firm checks before reaching a view on status:
The choice
Salary or dividends: the tax and social security rules to know
Rates are those of the texts in force on 31 October 2026; the right mix depends on status, cash flow and the level of protection sought.
Salary is an expense of the company, deductible if it corresponds to actual work and is not excessive in relation to the service rendered, including benefits in kind and expense reimbursements (Article 39, 1, 1°, of the French General Tax Code).
The non-deductible portion of excessive pay is reclassified as distributed income (Article 111, d); the pay of the majority manager of a SARL subject to corporation tax is taxed under the rules for wages and salaries (Article 62).
Dividends are paid out of profit after corporation tax. They bear the 12.8% flat-rate tax or, on an express and global election, the progressive income tax scale (Article 200 A); with the election, a 40% allowance applies to distributions that have been properly decided (Article 158, 3, 2°).
On payment, a 12.8% levy is withheld as an advance payment, with a possible exemption below a reference taxable income of €50,000 for a single person or €75,000 for a couple taxed jointly (Article 117 quater).
Social levies on dividends: CSG of 10.6% (Articles L. 136-7 and L. 136-8 of the French Social Security Code, rate in force since 31 December 2025, 9.2% before), CRDS of 0.5% (Articles 16 and 19 of Ordinance No. 96-50 of 24 January 1996) and solidarity levy of 7.5% (Article 235 ter of the General Tax Code), i.e. 18.6% in total.
For a self-employed director, the portion of dividends above 10% of the capital, share premiums and current accounts is included in the base for his contributions (Article L. 136-3, II, 2°); it is then not subject to the CSG on investment income (Article L. 136-7, I, 1°).
The 40% allowance also depends on corporate regularity: it covers distributed income “resulting from a regular decision of the competent bodies” (Article 158, 3, 2°, of the French General Tax Code, our translation). The meeting that approves the accounts and decides the distribution therefore determines the tax advantage, just as it determines the validity of the pay. See our articles on the 40% dividend allowance and on interim dividends and the 12.8% levy.
On the pay side, the Council of State (Conseil d'État) holds that “reimbursements of travel expenses received by a majority manager of a private limited company constitute, in principle, even in the absence of supporting documents, a component of his taxable pay” (our translation) under Article 62, unless the tax authorities establish a lack of explicit entry in the accounts or an excessive total pay; it set aside the judgment that had treated them as hidden benefits (CE, 9e ch., 7 November 2023, No. 471338).
No ratio suits everyone: salary gives rise to social security rights and reduces corporation tax, while dividends depend on profit, reserves and the shareholders' decision. The firm works with the chartered accountant on the company's real figures, then drafts the decisions that implement the option chosen. For the director's own tax position, see also our tax lawyers in Paris.
Disputes
Challenging or defending a director's pay
The same rules read differently depending on whether you are the company, the minority shareholder or the director under challenge.
You are the company or a shareholder
- Gather the articles of association, the register and the minutes, then quantify what was paid without a decision.
- Claim repayment, if necessary as an interim payment in summary proceedings, or bring the company's action (action sociale) against the manager (Article L. 223-22 of the French Commercial Code).
- Challenge a resolution that increases the majority shareholder's pay to the detriment of the minority.
You are the director under challenge
- Look for any regular decision, even partial, and the applicable clause in the articles of association.
- Establish the work done, the proportionality of the pay and the absence of fraud.
- Dispute the amount claimed, period by period, and regularise for the future.
A shareholder acting on behalf of the company has a quick lever: “where the manager has paid himself pay that was determined neither by the articles of association nor by a decision of the shareholders acting collectively, the resulting obligation to compensate the loss suffered by the company cannot be regarded as seriously disputable” (our translation). The Cour de cassation rejects the argument that the manager keeps the company going through his work, and adds that “the mere finding that there is a serious dispute on the merits is insufficient to justify refusing to order the measures provided for by Article 873, paragraph 1, of the Code of Civil Procedure” (our translation), such as a ban on paying the pay before authorisation (Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 24-15.111).
Against pay that has been voted, abuse of majority remains the main route. The Bordeaux Court of Appeal upheld the annulment, ordered by the Bordeaux commercial court, of the resolution that quadrupled a majority manager's pay and created a new expense almost equal to the company's average profit: “He does not justify an increase of this size by the company's interest” (our translation), and the decision, “which was taken for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholder to the detriment of the minority shareholder, constitutes an abuse of majority and is therefore liable to be annulled” (our translation) (CA Bordeaux, 4e ch. civ., 5 January 2026, No. 24/00405). The limit is real for the minority shareholder: a resolution granting exceptional bonuses to the director “can only be annulled for breach of the mandatory provisions of Book II of that code or of the laws governing contracts, and not solely on the ground that it is contrary to the company's interest, save for fraud or abuse of rights committed by one or more shareholders” (our translation) (Cass. com., 13 January 2021, No. 18-21.860, under former Article L. 235-1 of the French Commercial Code, repealed on 1 October 2025).
Since 1 October 2025, corporate decisions can only be declared null for breach of a mandatory provision of company law, other than a mere failure to take social and environmental issues into consideration (last paragraph of Article 1833), or for a ground of nullity of contracts (Article 1844-10 of the French Civil Code), and nullity requires prejudice, an influence of the irregularity on the outcome of the decision and consequences that are not excessive for the company's interest (Article 1844-12-1). On the criminal side, pay that a director awards himself in bad faith, against the company's interest and for personal ends, may amount to misuse of company assets (abus de biens sociaux) (Articles L. 241-3, 4°, L. 242-6, 3°, and L. 244-1 of the French Commercial Code): see our page on misuse of company assets, penalties and defence. For lasting deadlock between shareholders, see our shareholder dispute lawyers.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
Who sets the pay of a SARL manager in France?
The articles of association or the shareholders acting collectively, and no one else. The Cour de cassation derives this from Article L. 223-18 of the French Commercial Code: “the pay of the manager of a private limited company is determined either by the articles of association or by a decision of the shareholders acting collectively” (our translation) (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466). In practice, the articles almost always refer to an ordinary decision of the shareholders, which avoids amending them every time the amount changes.
The decision is taken at a meeting or, if the articles so provide, by written consultation (Article L. 223-27), and every resolution is recorded in minutes that state, among other things, the shareholders present or represented, the text of the resolutions and the result of the votes (Article R. 223-24). In a single-member SARL (EURL), the sole shareholder decides alone, but his decisions must be entered in a register (Article L. 223-31).
The decision specifies the components: fixed pay, variable pay and its criteria, bonuses, benefits in kind, payment of contributions, reimbursement of expenses. Each change requires a new decision. A manager who pays himself a sum that neither the articles nor the shareholders have set may have to repay it: the Versailles Court of Appeal held it irrelevant that the shareholders knew of this pay or that it had been deducted in the accounts (CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 16 September 2025, No. 25/01147). The firm drafts the clause in the articles and the minutes, and audits past decisions.
How is the pay of a SAS president set in France?
By the body designated in the articles of association. Article L. 227-5 of the French Commercial Code provides that “The articles of association set the conditions under which the company is managed” (our translation): they may entrust the president's pay to the shareholders acting collectively or, in a SASU, to the sole shareholder. A silent or ambiguous clause should be corrected before any payment.
Compliance with the clause is strictly reviewed. The Besançon Court of Appeal upheld the interim payment awarded to a SAS against its former president, as the articles entrusted the president's pay to a collective decision of the shareholders and no decision had authorised the sum received; it held that “the fact that the sums paid were recorded in the company accounts, whether approved or not, has no bearing on the lack of authorisation of this pay” (our translation) (CA Besançon, 1re ch., 2 September 2025, No. 25/00013).
A shareholders' agreement or an engagement letter does not replace the decision provided for in the articles: “While extra-statutory instruments may supplement these articles, they cannot derogate from them” (our translation) (Cass. com., 12 October 2022, No. 21-15.382). The president of a SAS falls under the general social security scheme (Article L. 311-3, 23°, of the French Social Security Code), as do its other directors. See also our page on shareholders' agreement lawyers.
In a French public limited company (SA), who decides directors' pay?
The board of directors, exclusively. Article L. 225-47 of the French Commercial Code states of the chairman of the board: “It determines his pay” (our translation), and Article L. 225-53 extends the rule to the chief executive officer and the deputy chief executive officers. In an SA with a management board, “The instrument of appointment sets the method and amount of the pay of each member of the management board” (Article L. 225-63, our translation).
The Cour de cassation draws concrete consequences from this. The board “has exclusive power to determine the pay of the chairman” (our translation): variable pay promised in a letter of engagement cannot be awarded on the sole basis of that letter, without a finding of a decision of the board of directors or of the supervisory board determining it. The order against the company to pay it was quashed and the case referred back to the Paris Court of Appeal. In the same case, the order for the director to return 254,093 euros of pay received without a board decision was upheld (Cass. com., 4 January 2023, No. 20-17.658).
Regularisation after the event is not possible: the board of directors “does not have the power to ratify the decision of the chairman who, without first obtaining a decision of the board, granted himself an increase in his pay” (our translation), and the statutory auditor who failed to point this out was found at fault (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.045). The firm checks the board's resolutions before any increase, bonus or indemnity, and prepares the missing ones for the future.
Can a manager who is a shareholder vote on his own pay?
Yes, where the decision sets his pay. Article L. 223-19 of the French Commercial Code deprives the interested shareholder of the right to vote on agreements concluded between the company and one of its managers or shareholders; but setting pay is not an agreement. According to the Cour de cassation, “the allocation of an exceptional bonus to the manager is not to be analysed as an agreement between him and the company but as the setting of a component of his pay, so that he may take part in the vote” (our translation) (Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.057).
A majority manager can therefore have the resolution adopted on his own. This power is not unlimited: an increase contrary to the company's interest, decided for the sole purpose of favouring the majority to the detriment of the minority, constitutes an abuse of majority. On that ground, the Bordeaux Court of Appeal upheld the annulment of the resolution that quadrupled a manager's pay, noting that the new annual expense was very close to the average profit of the three previous years (CA Bordeaux, 4e ch. civ., 5 January 2026, No. 24/00405).
It is different when the pay passes through another entity. A services or management contract concluded with a company run by the manager falls within the scope of related-party agreements (last paragraph of Article L. 223-19): a report to the meeting, a vote without the interested manager, and his personal liability for the harmful consequences of an agreement that has not been approved.
Does approval of the accounts validate a director's pay?
No, and the rule has become stricter. The Cour de cassation holds, on the basis of Articles L. 223-18, L. 223-27 and R. 223-24 of the French Commercial Code, that “proof of the authorisation by the shareholders acting collectively concerning the pay granted to the manager of a private limited company can only be provided by producing minutes that meet the conditions laid down by the last of these provisions” (our translation). The entry of the bonus in the annual accounts, established by an expert, and minutes with a crossed-out signature were not enough: the manager was ordered to repay (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466).
Lower courts reason in the same way for the SAS: recording the sums in the company accounts, “whether approved or not” (our translation), has no bearing on the lack of authorisation (CA Besançon, 1re ch., 2 September 2025, No. 25/00013). The Versailles Court of Appeal held irrelevant the shareholders' knowledge of the pay, its payment by a shareholder and its deduction in the accounts. It nevertheless found that a vote to maintain the pay had “implicitly but necessarily decided to set his pay at that amount for the past” (our translation), reducing the sum to be returned to 290,195.04 euros (CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 16 September 2025, No. 25/01147); this ruling predates that of 14 October 2026.
Prudence calls for a separate, express resolution stating the figures, adopted before payment and recorded in complete minutes.
Pay was made without a decision: what does the director risk?
Repayment of the sums, sometimes quickly. Managers are liable to the company for breaches of the articles of association and for mismanagement, and shareholders may bring the company's action to obtain compensation for the company's entire loss (Article L. 223-22 of the French Commercial Code). The Cour de cassation holds that, where the manager has paid himself pay that was determined neither by the articles nor by a decision of the shareholders, the obligation to compensate “cannot be regarded as seriously disputable” (our translation): an interim payment may be granted in summary proceedings (Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 24-15.111).
The argument based on the work done is not enough. In that case, the court of appeal had refused the interim payment on the ground that the manager kept the company going through his work; its ruling was overturned. The SA is subject to the same rigour: the director had to return the 2012 pay received without a decision of the board of directors (Cass. com., 4 January 2023, No. 20-17.658).
The director is not defenceless, however. He can look for a regular decision covering all or part of the period, dispute the amount claimed, and argue, as the Versailles Court of Appeal accepted, that a shareholders' vote set the pay for the past (CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 16 September 2025, No. 25/01147), provided that this vote appears in minutes that comply with Article R. 223-24, a requirement laid down by the Cour de cassation on 14 October 2026 (Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466). Regularising for the future, through a compliant decision, stops the risk from growing. See also our article on the derivative action (ut singuli) against a director.
Salary or dividends: how should a director in France choose?
By comparing mechanisms of a different nature, not isolated rates. Salary is an expense deductible from the company's taxable profit, provided that it corresponds to actual work and is not excessive in relation to the service rendered (Article 39, 1, 1°, of the French General Tax Code). It bears the social security contributions of the director's status and gives rise to rights, in particular to a pension.
A dividend is not an expense: it is paid out of profit that has already borne corporation tax, requires a decision of the shareholders, and bears the 12.8% flat-rate tax (Article 200 A) as well as 18.6% social levies, namely CSG of 10.6% (Articles L. 136-7 and L. 136-8 of the French Social Security Code), CRDS of 0.5% (Articles 16 and 19 of Ordinance No. 96-50 of 24 January 1996) and the solidarity levy of 7.5% (Article 235 ter of the French General Tax Code). On a global election for the progressive scale, a 40% allowance applies (Article 158, 3, 2°).
For the majority manager of a SARL and other self-employed directors, the portion of dividends above 10% of the capital, share premiums and current accounts is subject to their contributions, like pay (Article L. 136-3, II, 2°, of the French Social Security Code). For a practitioner working through a professional practice company, the Cour de cassation goes further, under the former wording of Article L. 131-6: the profits of the practice company are included in his base, even when distributed to his holding company (Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 21-20.366). The president of a SAS, treated as an employee, is not subject to this rule. The right balance depends on profit, reserves, social protection needs and plans to sell. The firm models the scenarios with the chartered accountant, on the real accounts.
How are a director's dividends taxed in France in 2026?
By default, income tax is charged at the 12.8% flat rate on the gross amount of the dividends (Article 200 A of the French General Tax Code). On an express and global election, made when filing the return, all the income concerned is subject to the progressive scale; dividends then benefit from a 40% allowance where they come from a company subject to corporation tax and result “from a regular decision of the competent bodies” (Article 158, 3, 2°, our translation).
On payment, the company withholds a 12.8% levy as an advance payment. A household whose reference taxable income for the year before last is below €50,000 for a single person, or €75,000 for a couple taxed jointly, may ask to be exempted (Article 117 quater). On the reporting obligations of the distributing company, see our article on form 2777 for SARL dividends.
Social levies are added: CSG at the 10.6% rate set by Article L. 136-8 of the French Social Security Code in its version in force since 31 December 2025 (9.2% before), CRDS of 0.5% and the solidarity levy of 7.5%, i.e. 18.6% in total. The portion of dividends already subject to the self-employed worker's contributions under Article L. 136-3 is excluded from the CSG on investment income (Article L. 136-7, I, 1°). Rates should be checked every year, as finance acts and social security financing acts regularly change them.
Does a majority SARL manager pay social security contributions on dividends?
Yes, on the portion above 10%. For activities subject to corporation tax, the contribution of self-employed workers is based on the sums received for performing their role and on the portion of dividends received by them, their spouse, their civil partner (PACS) or their unemancipated minor children that exceeds 10% of a reference amount made up of the share capital, including share premiums, and the sums held in shareholders' current accounts (Article L. 136-3, II, of the French Social Security Code). Article L. 131-6 refers to this base for social security contributions.
For an intermediary holding company, the known solution concerns professional practice companies. Under the former wording of Article L. 131-6, the Cour de cassation holds that the profits of the professional practice company “constitute the proceeds of his professional activity and must be included in the base for the social security contributions he owes” (our translation), even when distributed to the financial holding company of the liberal profession that holds its capital. It thus approved, for a dental surgeon who was the only practising professional shareholder, the inclusion of these dividends in his base, without dwelling on the 10% threshold, the court of appeal's calculation of which was described as a ground that was “erroneous but superfluous” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 21-20.366). The decision went against the practitioner; for the majority manager of a commercial SARL, the firm starts from the text of the 10% threshold, which covers dividends received by the self-employed worker, his spouse, his civil partner or his unemancipated minor children. See our article on dividends paid up through a holding company.
Two practical consequences follow. Low share capital and small current accounts lower the 10% threshold; and the portion thus subject to contributions is no longer subject to the CSG on investment income (Article L. 136-7, I, 1°). The firm analyses the structure of the capital and current accounts before any distribution, and defends the director in the event of a reassessment.
Employee-equivalent or self-employed: what determines a director's status in France?
The legal form of the company and, in a SARL, how the capital is split between the managers. The following are affiliated to the general scheme: presidents and directors of SAS companies (Article L. 311-3, 23°, of the French Social Security Code), the chairman of the board of directors, the chief executive officer and the deputy chief executive officers of an SA (12°), and SARL managers provided that they do not together hold more than half of the capital, shares held by a spouse, a civil partner (PACS) and unemancipated minor children being counted as their own (11°).
The majority is assessed across the whole board of managers. The Cour de cassation quashed the judgment that affiliated a co-manager to the general scheme without examining whether she belonged to a majority management: members of a board of managers who together hold more than half of the capital do not fall under the general scheme, “even if some of them hold no shares” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 31 May 2018, No. 17-17.518). A non-shareholder manager in a majority management is therefore self-employed.
The functions actually performed also count: the chairman of the supervisory board of a SAS who in fact performs a management function falls under the general scheme, and the URSSAF obtained confirmation of its reassessment (Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 23-13.887). Status determines the cost of each euro paid and the protection obtained; changing it means changing the legal form or the breakdown of the capital, with their tax and corporate consequences.
Can a minority shareholder challenge a director's pay?
Yes, by two separate routes. If the pay was not decided by the competent body, he can act on behalf of the company for repayment, through the company's action (Article L. 223-22 of the French Commercial Code for the SARL), and obtain an interim payment in summary proceedings: the Cour de cassation overturned the judgment that had refused it to a shareholder (Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 24-15.111).
If the pay was properly voted by the majority, an abuse of majority must be shown: a decision contrary to the company's interest, taken for the sole purpose of favouring the majority to his detriment. The Bordeaux Court of Appeal found one for quadrupled pay, a new expense almost equal to the average profit, which reduced the minority shareholder's dividend prospects accordingly, noting that the manager “does not justify an increase of this size by the company's interest” (our translation) (CA Bordeaux, 4e ch. civ., 5 January 2026, No. 24/00405). The level of pay of comparable directors, produced by the minority shareholder, weighed in the analysis.
Being contrary to the company's interest is not enough on its own. The Cour de cassation quashed a judgment that annulled bonuses representing thirteen times the annual profit, since it had not established a breach of the law, fraud or abuse (Cass. com., 13 January 2021, No. 18-21.860). The annulment had been sought by the purchaser of the shares who had become director, together with the company, and not by a minority shareholder; the decision went against them, and the rule it lays down, given under former Article L. 235-1, also limits the minority shareholder's action. Since 1 October 2025, the nullity of corporate decisions is governed by Articles 1844-10 and 1844-12-1 of the French Civil Code, which require, among other things, prejudice and an influence of the irregularity on the outcome of the decision. See also our article on abuse of majority in a SAS.
When does a director's pay become excessive for the French tax authorities?
When it does not correspond to actual work or is excessive in relation to the service rendered. In that case, the company cannot deduct it from its profit, and the rule applies to all direct or indirect pay, including indemnities, allowances, benefits in kind and expense reimbursements (Article 39, 1, 1°, of the French General Tax Code). The non-deductible portion is treated as income distributed to the director (Article 111, d).
The classification changes the taxation. The majority manager of a SARL is taxed on his pay under the rules for wages and salaries (Article 62); the reclassified portion follows the regime for investment income. The Council of State holds that a majority manager's travel expense reimbursements remain in principle a component of his taxable pay, even without supporting documents, unless the tax authorities establish a lack of explicit entry in the accounts or that their amount, added to the other components of pay, brings it to an excessive level; it overturned the judgment that had treated them as hidden benefits (CE, 9e ch., 7 November 2023, No. 471338).
The defence is prepared in advance: functions performed, time devoted, responsibilities, comparison with similar businesses, consistency with results. The firm documents the pay when it is set and assists the company and the director in the event of a proposed tax reassessment. See our page on tax audit lawyers in Paris.
Is a dismissed director entitled to an indemnity or to his pay?
Only if the corporate rules properly provide for it. What remains due after the director leaves office depends on what the articles of association or the competent body have decided. In an SA, the board of directors may dismiss the chairman at any time, and any provision to the contrary is deemed unwritten (Article L. 225-47 of the French Commercial Code). It is also the board that determines the chairman's pay (same article): the firm therefore checks which body decided the promised indemnity, in what form and on what date.
In a SAS, the articles of association prevail. The Cour de cassation refused a chief executive officer the indemnity provided for in a letter agreement, as the articles excluded any indemnity on termination of office: “While extra-statutory instruments may supplement these articles, they cannot derogate from them” (our translation) (Cass. com., 12 October 2022, No. 21-15.382). The decision went against the director; it shows that a promised indemnity must be written into the articles or into a decision of the body they designate.
Dismissal itself, its grounds, whether it was abusive or humiliating and the damages that may result are dealt with on our page on director dismissal lawyers. The firm also negotiates the financial terms of departure, together with the sale of the shares: see our shareholder exit lawyers.
What are a lawyer's fees for an executive compensation matter in France?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Act of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: audit of the articles of association and past decisions, drafting of the clause in the articles and of the minutes, review of the salary versus dividends choice with the chartered accountant, formal notice or reply, summary proceedings, action on the merits or defence, appeal. Any new engagement gives rise to an amendment, with no unexpected billing. Where the question is also a tax or social security matter, the agreement specifies what falls to the lawyer and what falls to the company's chartered accountant; in a dispute, it distinguishes the out-of-court phase, summary proceedings and proceedings on the merits.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 223-18, L. 223-27, R. 223-24 and L. 223-31 of the French Commercial Code: SARL manager, form of decisions, minutes, decisions of the sole shareholder
- Articles L. 223-19 and L. 223-22: related-party agreements in a SARL, managers' liability and the company's action
- Articles L. 225-38, L. 225-47, L. 225-53 and L. 225-63: SA: related-party agreements, pay of the chairman, the chief executive officer and the management board
- Articles L. 227-1, L. 227-5 and L. 227-10: SAS: application of SA rules, management set by the articles of association, agreements
- Articles L. 241-3, L. 242-6 and L. 244-1: misuse of company assets in a SARL, an SA and a SAS
- Articles 1833, 1844-10 and 1844-12-1 of the French Civil Code: company's interest, nullity of corporate decisions since 1 October 2025
- Article L. 311-3 of the French Social Security Code: affiliation of directors to the general scheme (11°, 12°, 23°)
- Articles L. 131-6 and L. 136-3: contributions of self-employed workers, dividends above 10%
- Articles L. 136-7 and L. 136-8: CSG on investment income, 10.6% rate
- Articles 39, 62, 111, 117 quater, 158, 200 A and 235 ter of the French General Tax Code: deduction of pay, majority manager, distributed income, withholding levy, allowance, flat rate, solidarity levy
- Articles 16 and 19 of Ordinance No. 96-50 of 24 January 1996: CRDS on investment income, 0.5% rate
- Article 10 of Act No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. com., 14 October 2026, No. 25-12.466: proof of the decision by compliant minutes
- Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 24-15.111: interim payment in summary proceedings against the manager
- Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.057: exceptional bonus and the manager's vote
- Cass. com., 31 March 2021, No. 19-12.045: no ratification by the board in an SA
- Cass. com., 4 January 2023, No. 20-17.658: exclusive power of the board in an SA
- Cass. com., 13 January 2021, No. 18-21.860: limit on annulment for being contrary to the company's interest
- Cass. com., 12 October 2022, No. 21-15.382: SAS articles of association and extra-statutory instruments
- Cass. 2e civ., 19 October 2023, No. 21-20.366: profits of a professional practice company (SEL) distributed to the holding company and the practitioner's contributions
- Cass. 2e civ., 31 May 2018, No. 17-17.518: majority board of managers
- Cass. 2e civ., 5 June 2025, No. 23-13.887: de facto director and the general scheme
- CA Bordeaux, 4e ch. civ., 5 January 2026, No. 24/00405: abuse of majority, quadrupled pay
- CA Besançon, 1re ch., 2 September 2025, No. 25/00013: SAS president paid without a decision
- CA Versailles, ch. com. 3-2, 16 September 2025, No. 25/01147: shareholders' knowledge and implied decision
- CE, 9e ch., 7 November 2023, No. 471338: majority manager's expenses and taxable pay
Further reading
Pay to set, to decide on or to challenge?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the articles of association, the register or the minutes, the payslips or statements of the sums paid and the latest accounts: Hassan Kohen checks the competent body, the proof of the decision, the social security status and the tax risks, then tells you the appropriate route, whether a regularising decision, a choice between salary and dividends, a formal notice, summary proceedings, or an action or defence before the court.